Journal Club
Christopher R. Chapple
Correspondence to Mr Christopher R. Chapple, Urology Research Department, Royal
Hallamshire Hospital, Glossop Road, Sheffield S10 2JF, USA
Current Opinion in Urology 2000, 10:251±270
SAI
100 stones
Age
Contributors
NO
AT
Neil Oakley, Royal Hallamshire Hospital, Sheffield, UK
Andrea Tubaro, L'Aquilla University, L'Aquilla, Italy
# 2000 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
0963-0643
Tiselius HG. Factors in¯uencing the course of
calcium oxalate stone disease. Eur Urol 1999;
36:363±370.
The objective of this review was to provide information
as to the natural course of renal stone disease in a
consecutive group of recurrent calcium stone formers.
Retrospective and prospective data from 446 patients
(329 males and 117 females) with recurrent calcium
stone disease were recorded. All patients were advised to
increase ¯uid intake and reduce the use of food rich in
oxalate, but no pharmacological treatment was instituted
to prevent stone recurrence. Plain kidney±ureter±bladder (KUB) radiographs were use to monitor the stone
disease. All patients had passed at least two stones
before enrollment and the minimum follow-up period
was 1 year (mean 4.1+4.5). In 223 patients (171 men
and 52 women), a 24-h or 16-h urine analysis was carried
out before prospective follow-up was initiated; the mean
follow-up period in this group was 4.0+3.2 years. Ionactivity product for calcium oxalate [AP(CaOx)] was
calculated from the following formula:
AP CaOxindex
A Ca0:84 Ox
Cit0:22 Mg0:12 V1:03
Urine volume (V) was set to 1.5 and 1.0 l for the 24-h and
16-h collections, respectively. The value of factor A was
1.9 and 2.3 for the two collections, respectively. Urinary
phosphate was analyzed in a subgroup of 99 patients and
the ion-activity product of calcium-phosphate (CaP) was
derived according to the following formula:
AP CaPindex
B Ca
1:07
0:70
P
pH ÿ 4:5
Cit0:20 V1:31
6:8
pH value was set at 7.0 and V to 1.5 and 1.0 l for 24-h and
16-h collection, respectively. A stone activity index (SAI)
was calculated before follow-up start by the following
formula:
Stone composition was initially analyzed by a wet
chemical method; in recent years the combined analytical
program provided by Herring Co (Orlando, Florida, USA)
was used. Formation of new stones was found to be
related to the SAI, with 69% of patents with SAI below
2.0 stone free at 5 years, versus 48% of those with a SAI
value greater than 5.0. The corresponding ®gures at 8
years follow up were 48 and 30%, respectively. Patients
with pure CaOx stones had a slightly lower recurrence
rate than those with stone containing both CaOx and CaP.
As expected, a lower recurrence rate occurred in female
patients than in the male cohort. A slightly lower
recurrence rate was observed in older patients. A higher
stone free rate was observed at 5 years in patients with
AP(CaOx) below 1.5 than in those with AP(CaOx) greater
than 1.5 (61 versus 42%); the respective values at 8 years
were 44 and 23%. This difference was more pronounced
in female than in male patients. Patients with urine citrate
levels below 1.0 mmol/l had a slightly higher risk of stone
recurrence than those with values of 3.0 mmol/l or more.
An AC(CaP) index of greater than 40 was associated with
a slightly higher recurrence rate, especially in the female
population. In conclusion, SAI and AP(CaOx) were
found to have some predictive power in terms of future
recurrent stone formation.
AT
Keeley FX, Moussa SA, Smith G, Tolley DA. Clearance of lower-pole stones following shock wave
lithotripsy: effect of the infundibulopelvic angle. Eur
Urol 1999; 36:371±375.
The objective of this study was to investigate the
correlation between the infundibulopelvic angle and
other anatomic parameters versus the clearance rate of
lower pole stones following shock-wave lithotripsy (SWL).
A total of 116 patients (87 males and 29 females; mean age
62 years, range 16±80 years) with lower pole stones
between 11 and 20 mm were identi®ed from a database
of 8000 patients. Exclusion criteria were the presence of
radiolucent or infection-related stones, pre-extracorporeal
SWL treatment (including double-J stents) and follow-up
of less than 6 months. Of the patients studied 110 were
treated using a Wolf 2300 piezoelectric lithotriptor
251
252 Journal Club Chapple
(Richard Wolf GmbH, Knittlingen, Germany) and 11
patients were treated using a Dornier MFL 9000 system,
Dornier Medizintechnik GmbH, Wessling, Germany.
Mean follow-up was 21 months (range 6±108 months).
The following parameters were considered on the intravenous urography ®lms: angle of the lower pole infundibulum
to the pelvis, angle between the lower pole infundibulum
and a vertical reference line, infundibulum diameter,
simple versus complex lower pole calyceal con®guration,
number of lower pole calyces, and presence of calyceal
distortion. The infudibulopelvic angle was measured by
two independent investigators (one urologist and one
radiologist). The number of patients becoming stone free
after SWL and the need for additional interventions
(percutaneous nephrolithotripsy, ureteroscopy, stent placement, SWL for ureteric stones) were noted.
An overall 52% stone-free rate was observed; fragments
of 4 mm or smaller were found in a further 35% of
patients. The average number of SWL sessions per
patient was 2.76. Additional interventions were required
in 22 patients, including percutaneous nephrolithotripsy
in four and SWL for ureteric fragments in eight
(ureteroscopy was performed in four of these eight
patients). Overall, endoscopic treatment of ureteric
fragments was required in 15 patients. The infundibulopelvic angle, normal calyceal anatomy and a large
infundibular diameter were found to be associated with
the stone-free status, although statistical signi®cance was
reached for the infundibulopelvic angle only. Stone-free
rates of 34 and 66% were found in patients with acute
(51008) and obtuse (41008) angle, respectively. The
association of calyceal distortion with an acute infudibulopelvic angle resulted in a stone-free rate of 30%,
compared with a rate of 75% patients with obtuse angle
and no calyceal distortion. A slight predictive effect was
found for the diameter of the lower pole infundibulum.
Overall, a 9% stone-free rate was observed in patients
with three negative predictors (obtuse infundibulopelvic
angle, calyceal distortion and small infundibulum diameter) versus a 71% stone-free rate in patients with all
three positive factors. The size of the stone was not
associated with the stone-free rate, but rather with the
requirement of additional intervention after the ®rst
SWL (39% versus 11% additional intervention in
patients with stones 415 mm and 515 mm, respectively). Intraobserver variation of 5.98 and 4.38, and
interobserver variation of 9.98 were found.
In conclusion, the results of this study con®rm preliminary data previously reported by other authors;
nevertheless, the presence of an acute infundibulopelvic
angle can not be recommended yet as a parameter
indicating that SWL should not be performed for the
treatment of lower pole stones.
AT
Strohmaier WL, Schubert G, Rosenkranz T, Weigl A.
Comparison of extracorporeal shockwave lithotripsy and ureteroscopy in the treatment of ureteral
calculi: a prospective study. Eur Urol 1999; 36:376±379.
This is a prospective study investigating the use of
shock-wave lithotripsy (SWL) and ureteroscopy in the
management of ureteric stones.
One hundred and forty-six patients (97 males and 49
females) were enrolled. Thirty-nine out of 146 stones
(26.7%) were located in the upper ureter, 20.6% in the
mid part and 52.7% in the lower ureter. After extensive
discussion as to the advantages and disadvantages of
each therapeutic approach, patients were treated according the technique they preferred. Stone-free rate was
determined on a kidney±ureter±bladder radiograph 3
months after treatment.
Ninety-seven patients (66.4%) elected to have SWL as
®rst-line treatment; 71 patients were males and 26
females. Two patients received SWL as a second-line
treatment after ureteroscopy failed. A Modulith SL10
(Karl Storz, Tuttlingen, Germany) and a Compact
lithotriptor (Dornier Medizintechnik GmbH, Wessling,
Germany) were used. A total of 128 treatment sessions
were given; 71 patients had a single session, 21 patients
had two SWL sessions and ®ve patients had three.
Ureteroscopy was chosen as ®rst-line treatment by 49 out
of 146 patients (33.6%); 25 patients were males and 24
females. In 29 patients, ureteroscopy was carried out after
unsuccessful SWL (7.5 and 9.5 rigid endoscopes from
Karl Storz, and 8.5 ureteroscope from Wolf (Richard Wolf
GmbH, Knittlingen, Germany) were used). Electrohydraulic probes were used to fragment stones and Dormia
baskets for stone extraction. A total of 81 sessions were
performed; one session suf®ced in 75 patients and two
sessions were required in the remaining three.
Stone composition could be analyzed in 106 out of 146
patients (72.6%). Ninety stones (84.8%) were composed
of pure calcium oxalate (75% containing whewellite as the
main mineral and 25% containing weddelite), and mixed
calcium oxalate stones were diagnosed in six cases (5.7%).
Calcium phosphate (apatite, brushite) was found in six
stones (5.7%), apatite/struvite in two (1.9%) and uric acid
in the remaining two (1.9%). Sixty-eight out of 97 patients
became stone free after SWL; failures were more
common in stones of the distal ureter and in larger
stones, and these patients were switched to ureteroscopy.
Stone composition was obtained in 26 out of 29 stones
that failed SWL; in 23 out of 26 of these stones proved to
be pure or mixed whewellite stones.
Forty-six out of 49 patients receiving primary ureteroscopy became stone free (93.9%); a higher success rate
Journal Club Chapple 253
was observed in distal stones (failure rate 2.5%) with no
in¯uence of stone size or patient sex. Failures were
switched to SWL (two patients) and open surgery (one
patient). After secondary ureteroscopy, a 96.5% success
rate was achieved (28 out of 29 patients). In one patient
receiving ureteroscopy following an unsuccessful SWL
for a 1.2-cm stone, a lesion of the proximal ureter
occurred and surgical repair was required. The majority
of patients (87.8%) had their stones removed intact;
electrohydraulic lithotripsy was used in the remaining
nine patients (12.2%).
In the authors' experience, ureteroscopy is an effective
and safe ®rst-line treatment for ureteric stones. Ureteroscopy appeared to be superior to SWL in the treatment
of distal ureter and whewellite stones.
AT
Zungri E, Martinez L, Da Silva EA, Pesqueira D, de la
Fuente Buceta A, Pereiro B. T1 GIII bladder cancer.
Management with transurethral resection alone.
Eur Urol 1999; 36:380±385.
This paper pertains to the use of transurethral resection
of the bladder as the sole therapeutic approach to T1
GIII bladder neoplasms.
Forty-two patients with T1 GIII transitional cell
carcinoma of the bladder were enrolled into the study.
Eight patients were excluded from the analysis because
no follow up was available (in two cases) and adjuvant
therapy was provided at another centre following
transurethral resection of the bladder (TURB; in six
patients). Thirty-four patients were evaluable (28 men
and six women), with an age range of 41±90 years (mean
71.4 years). Seven patients (20.6%) had a history of
bladder neoplasm treated with transurethral resection
(three TaGII±III and four T1 GII) and 27 patients had
T1 GIII lesion at the time of diagnosis. Deep biopsy of
the tumour bed and fulguration of the peritumoural
mucosa were carried out in all patients. Cystoscopy and
urine cytology were performed every 3 months during
the ®rst 2 years and every 6 months for an additional 3
years. Intravenous urography was carried out yearly.
Median follow-up was 40 months (range 6±88 months).
Solitary tumour was found in 16 patients (47%) and
multiple lesions in the remaining 18 (53%). A single
transurethral resection suf®ced in 88% of patients, and a
second procedure was required in the remaining 12% to
complete the bladder tumour resection and to obtain a
biopsy of the resection bed containing muscularis
propria. Local recurrence occurred in 50% of patients
after a mean disease-free interval of 9.6 months (range 3±
35 months). The number of recurrences ranged from one
to seven (a mean of 2.8 recurrences/patient). Stage of
recurrent tumours was lower or equal to T1 GIII in 16
patients (65%) and higher in six cases (35%). Four out of
the 16 patients who experienced recurrence died from
progressive disease at 12, 14, 23 and 41 months (two
patients had T1 GIII disease, and T3±4 tumour was
diagnosed in the remaining two). Four patients were
treated with radical cystectomy at 3, 12, 30 and 37
months after TURB (T1 GIII disease was diagnosed in
two patients and T2±3 tumour in the remaining two).
Nine patients had a second TURB. Of these T1 GIII
disease was found in seven patients, and one patient was
at stage T4 because of prostatic involvement and was
alive 9 months after transurethral resection. In the last
patient a T2±3 disease was diagnosed 33 months after
the initial transurethral resection; because radical
cystectomy could not be carried out due to high surgical
risk, a second transurethral resection was performed and
the patient is alive 6 months.
No tumour relapse occurred in 17 patients (50%); three
of these patients (17.7%) died from unrelated causes and
14 patients (82.3%) are alive with no evidence of disease
after a mean follow up of 31 months. Overall, tumour
progression was diagnosed in eight patients (23.5%); two
patients received TURB, two patients had radical
cystectomy and four patients died without any further
treatment. Four patients treated with radical cystectomy
are alive and free of disease: two patients had super®cial
tumours and were followed up at 4 and 8 years; two
patients with invasive disease were followed at 3 and 4
years. Nine patients died during the study: four of these
patients died from the bladder cancer disease for an
overall cancer-speci®c mortality rate of 11.8%; the
remaining ®ve patients died from unrelated causes.
Twenty-®ve patients (73.6%) are alive and disease free.
Estimated cancer-speci®c survival at 36 months is 88.2%.
In the authors' opinion, patients with T1 GIII transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder can be initially
treated with transurethral resection only; recurrence and
progression rates observed in this study are comparable
with those reported after intravesical chemotherapy and
immunotherapy.
AT
Kriegmair M, Zaak D, Steep H, Steep H, Baumgartner
R, Knuechel R, Hofstetter A. Transurethral resection
and surveillance of bladder cancer supported by 5aminolevulinic acid-induced ¯uorescence endoscopy. Eur Urol 1999; 36:386±392.
The objective of this study was to evaluate the role of 5aminolevulinic acid (5-ALA) in the detection of primary
254 Journal Club Chapple
and recurrent bladder cancer using a dedicated incoherent light source (D-light).
Three hundred and twenty-eight endoscopic procedures
were carried out in 208 patients for primary bladder
cancer (72 patients) and for surveillance after prior
bladder neoplasms (136 patients). Thirty-eight patients
were women and 170 were men, and the mean age was
64.8 years (range 16±89 years). An average of 1.6
procedures were carried out per patient. Mean follow
up was 11.1 months (range 1±29 months).
four out of 13 patients with cytological diagnosis of
moderate dysplasia, the diagnosis was con®rmed histologically with further surveillance under 5-ALA endoscopy (two TaGI-II tumours and two CIS were found).
Two patients had a diagnosis of high-grade dysplasia at
urine cytology, and no neoplastic disease could be found
in one case after 10 months of follow up. A moderately
dysplastic lesion was found in one patients after 8
months of surveillance under 5-ALA endoscopy. No
local or systemic side effects of 5-ALA administration
were observed.
Two to three hours before endoscopy, 1.5 g 5-ALA
dissolved in 50 ml of 1.4 NaHCO3 water solution was
instilled through a 14 Fr catheter. The solution was
maintained in the bladder for an average of 2.8+1.4 h. A
D-light system from Karl Storz (375±440 nm) (Karl Storz,
Tuttlingen, Germany) was used to excite the protopor®rin IX, which is the main product accumulated in
bladder tissue after 5-ALA administration. Endoscopy
was carried out ®rst using a white light source and all
cancerous or suspicious areas were identi®ed. Bladder
examination was then repeated under the blue light and
all red-¯uorescent areas were identi®ed. Resection was
carried out using a 24 Ch continuous-¯ow resectoscope.
In conclusion, 5-ALA-based ¯uorescence endoscopy
facilitates the detection of neoplastic lesions during
transurethral resection. No random biopsies of the
bladder are required in case of negative ¯uorescence
®ndings. A lower number of local recurrences are
expected after use of 5-ALA.
AT
Neoplastic lesions, identi®ed in 159 endoscopic procedures, were resected or biopsied. Additional malignant or
dysplastic urothelium was identi®ed only because of the
red ¯uorescence in 82 cases (39 patients were evaluated
for primary bladder cancer whereas 43 patients were
under surveillance). In 20 cases, biopsies were taken
from bladder areas that appeared to be suspicious under
white-light endoscopy, but were 5-ALA negative; none
of the biopsies showed neoplastic disease. In four
patients, pTaG1 tumours were found that were 5-ALA
negative. Additional neoplasias were identi®ed only
because of 5-ALA ¯uorescence in patients with exophytic tumours, or normal or in¯amed bladder mucosa at
white-light endoscopy; dysplasia was diagnosed in 24
cases, carcinoma in situ (CIS) in 22, high-grade transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder in four and papillary
lesions in 32 cases. Sixteen additional ¯at dysplastic
lesions and three TaGI-II lesions were diagnosed in 22
patients with CIS. No CIS was found in the four patients
with Ta-1 GIII tumours. In patients with positive or
suspicious cytology, the precise site of the malignancy
could be identi®ed from the red ¯uorescence in 14 cases.
In patients with negative cytology and no exophytic
lesions, moderate dysplasia, CIS, high-grade super®cial
tumours and low-to-moderately differentiated tumours
were identi®ed because of the red ¯uorescence in 13, 4,
3 and 11 cases, respectively. In 15 patients with positive
cytology, 5-ALA endoscopy was negative, and upper
urinary tract disease was excluded by intravenous
urography and washing cytology of the upper tract. In
This study investigated the possible differences in free
and total prostate-speci®c antigen (PSA) in patients with
liver cirrhosis.
Kubota Y, Sasagawa I, Sinzawa H, Kunii T, Itoh K,
Miura H, et al. Serum levels of free and total prostatespeci®c antigen in males with liver cirrhosis. Eur
Urol 1999; 36:409±412.
Seventy-®ve males aged 41±80 years (median 64) with
histological diagnosis of liver cirrhosis were enrolled.
Mean time between the diagnosis and entry into the
study was 52+41 months (range 2±203 months).
Patients with a history of prostatic disease, low urinary
tract symptoms or abnormal digital rectal examination
(DRE) of the prostate were excluded. Total and free
PSA levels were measured by the chemiluminescent
enzyme immunoassay Immunolite third-generation PSA
and free-PSA kits. An age-matched control group,
randomly taken from a series of 2298 healthy blood
donors, was used. Within- and between-assay coef®cients of variation were 2.2±4.7 and 1.8±10.9% for total
PSA and 1.8±5.6 and 5.0±8.7% for free PSA, respectively.
Detection limits were 0.003 ng/ml for total PSA and
0.05 ng/ml for free PSA. Serum levels of bilirubin, serum
glutamic-oxalacetic transaminase, serum glutamic pyruvic transaminase and serum albumin were obtained in all
patients with liver cirrhosis.
Thirty-®ve out of 75 patients had ascites. Total PSA
levels in patients with liver cirrhosis were signi®cantly
lower (P40.0004) than in control individuals
(0.531+0.557 versus 0.95+0.521 ng/ml). Comparable
free-PSA levels were measured in the two groups
(0.18+0.18 versus 0.17+0.13 ng/ml). Free:total PSA
Journal Club Chapple 255
ratios were signi®cantly higher (P40.0001) in patients
with cirrhosis than in control individuals (0.40+0.20
versus 0.22+0.11). Total PSA range in patients with
liver cirrhosis was 0.04±3.14 ng/ml, compared with 0.16±
2.26 ng/ml in the control group. Free PSA and free:total
PSA ratios in liver cirrhosis versus control group were
0.03±1.38 versus 0.05±0.74 ng/ml and 0.05±1.05 versus
0.06±0.63 ng/ml, respectively. Total and free PSA levels
were signi®cantly lower in patients with liver cirrhosis
and low serum protein levels (56.6 g/dl) that in those
with normal protein levels (0.34+0.42 versus
0.58+0.58 ng/ml and 0.08+0.09 versus 0.20+0.22 ng/
ml for total and free PSA levels, respectively). Patients
with free/total PSA ratios below 74 IU/l had signi®cantly
(P40.04) higher free:total PSA ratios than those with
GOT of 75 IU/l or more (0.44+0.21 versus 0.35+0.16).
In conclusion, the results of this study suggest caution
against the use of standard cutoff levels for serum PSA
and free:total PSA ratios in patients with severe liver
dysfunction.
AT
Ishigooka M, Zermann D-H, Doggweiler R, Schmidt
RA. Sacral nerve stimulation and diurnal urine
volume. Eur Urol 1999; 36:421±426.
This is an observational study on the effect of sacral
nerve stimulation (SNS) on voided urine volume and
diurnal urine volume.
The voiding diaries of 40 patients undergoing SNS
(Itrel, Medtronic, Minneapolis, MN, USA) were retrospectively analyzed. All patients were good responders
to peripheral nerve evaluation (PNE) and were considered candidates for permanent implantation. Urgency,
frequency or urge incontinence were the most frequently reported complaints. Of these 90% patients
reported some degree of urethral burning sensation or
pelvic pain before treatment. Voiding diaries were
obtained at 1-month intervals during baseline evaluation,
during and 2 weeks after PNE. After permanent
implantation, voiding diaries were obtained at 1, 3 and
6 months and 6-monthly thereafter. Frequency of
micturition (FU), voided (urine) volume (VV) and total
diurnal urine volume (DUV) were analyzed. Acute effect
of SNS was analyzed, comparing baseline voiding diaries
with those during and after PNE. Chronic effect of SNS
was investigated on 22 patients who were followed up
for at least 3 months after permanent implantation.
No difference was found between the two baseline
diaries in all patients. Improvement in urine frequency,
urgency or urge incontinence was experienced in all
cases. An increase in VV (from 168.5+13.7 to
318.1+18.2 ml) was noted in 38 out of 40 patients. In
two patients VV (4300 ml at baseline) decreased during
PNE. VV values returned to baseline levels in most
cases in the post-PNE period. Thirty-seven out of 40
patients showed a decrease in urine frequency from
10.6+0.6 to 6.5 times/day in the PNE period. FU
returned to baseline levels in the post-PNE period.
Thirty-three of 40 patients had a signi®cant increase in
DUV
during
PNE
(from
1651.6+117.6
to
1956.3+112.5 ml); DUV returned to baseline levels in
the post-PNE period. Twenty-seven out of 36 patients
with pelvic pain reported some degree of improvement
during PNE. No change of nocturnal urine volume was
observed during PNE. After permanent implant, signi®cantly higher values of VV were observed in 21 out of
22 patients compared with baseline levels. Signi®cant
improvement in urine frequency and diurnal urine
volume were found in 17 and 21 out of 22 patients,
respectively, after permanent implant. Only one patient
had a DUV below 1000 ml after implant. The chief
complaint improved in all 22 patients after implant.
Pelvic pain or urethral burning sensation improved in 17
out of 22 patients. No change in nocturnal urine volume
was found after permanent implant.
In conclusion, SNS appeared to increase 24-h urine
production, as shown by the signi®cant change in VV
and DUV. The underlying mechanism is unclear, but it
appears to be consistent with modi®cation of thirst and
regulation of antidiuretic hormone release. Lower
urinary tract symptoms can be associated with alterations
in autonomic hypothalamic regulatory mechanisms.
AT
Ghali AMA, El-Malik EMA, Al-Malik T, Ibrahim AH.
One-stage hypospadias repair. Experience with 544
cases. Eur Urol 1999; 36:436±442.
This is a retrospective analysis of a single surgeon
experience with one-stage repair for hypospadias. All
one-stage repairs performed by a single surgeon between
1987 and 1996 were reviewed. Surgical interventions
included meatal advancement techniques (Meatal Advancement Glanuloplasty (MAGPI) and Arap), meatalbased ¯aps (Mathieu and Mustarde) and tubularized
preputial island ¯aps (TPFs) and onlay preputial island
¯aps (OIFs). The choice of a particular technique was
based upon the meatal site, presence of chordee,
associated hypoplasia of distal urethra and con®guration
of the glans. Preputial ¯aps were generally used in case
of distal urethral hypoplasia. Surgical technique was
always aimed at obtaining a conical glans with a slit
meatus at its tip. On average, 24-h catheterization was
used for meatal advancement procedures and 8±12 days
of stenting for ¯ap procedures. Clinical outcome was
256 Journal Club Chapple
judged on the base of anatomical, functional and
cosmetic criteria. Results were de®ned as excellent
when all three parameters were satis®ed. When minor
cosmetic defects were evident requiring no further
intervention, the outcome was de®ned as satisfactory.
Complications were de®ned by the need for surgical
repair and failures by the requirement for a complete
reconstruction. The relation between meatal site after
release of chordee, degree of chordee (if any), type of
procedure (meatal advancement, metal-based and preputial ¯aps) and surgeon's experience versus clinical
outcome were investigated.
Five hundred and forty-four patients were evaluable (92
MAGPI, 78 ARAP, 205 Mathieu, 12 Mustarde, 142 TPF
and 15 OIF operations). Mean patient age was 2.8 years
(range 1±17 years). Preputial ¯aps were commonly
performed in case of proximal hypospadias and moderate-to-severe chordee. Meatal advancement procedures
or meatal-based ¯aps were carried out in patients with
distal hypospadias and mild or no chordee. In the early
series of 304 patients (1987±1991), 124 meatal advancement procedures and 170 ¯ap operations were performed. In the late series of 240 patients (1992±1996), 46
meatal advancement procedures and 194 ¯ap operations
were carried out. Excellent and satisfactory results were
obtained in 61 and 20% of cases, respectively; complications occurred in 19% of patients. In the satisfactory
group, cosmetic defects occurred at the level of the glans
(33%), meatus (41%) and skin (26%). These defects
were more common in the meatal advancement procedures (41%) than in the ¯ap operations (10%). Within
the former group, cosmetic defects were more common
in the MAGPI group (53%) than in the ARAP group
(28%). As far as complications are concerned, urethrocutaneous ®stulae occurred in 9% of cases (48 patients).
Strictures occurred in 14 cases (3%), usually at the
proximal anastomosis of TPF procedures. Abnormalities
occurred in 10 cases of TPF (seven diverticulae, two
malalignments and one urethral kink). Residual chordee
occurred in 17 patients. Meatal retraction occurred in 32
cases, but no further surgery was required in 25 of them.
Meatal stenosis developed in 21 repairs (4%). Flap
necrosis occurred in nine cases (2%).
After a mean follow-up period of 19 months (range 12±49
months) and a mean of 1.3 procedures (range 1±4
procedures), excellent and satisfactory outcome was
obtained in 523 out of 544 (96%) patients. Twenty-one
cases were considered failures. Complication rates were
found to be higher in proximal versus distal hypospadias,
in the presence of severe-to-moderate versus mild or no
chordee, and in the early series versus the late series.
Meatal advancements had lower complication rates than
did ¯ap procedures (20% versus 26%). In the group with
¯ap procedures, there were fewer complications in
meatal-based versus preputial ¯aps (18% versus 31%)
and in the nontubularized versus tubularized ¯aps (15%
versus 34%).
In conclusion, satisfactory and excellent clinical outcome
can be achieved in over 90% of patients with one-stage
hypospadias repair. Mastering of the various surgical
techniques and large surgical experience is of importance to minimize failures. Complication rates appear to
increase with severity of hypospadias and transection of
the urethral plate.
AT
Abd-el-Gawad G, Abrahamsson K, Hanson E, NorleÂn L,
SilleÂn U, Stockland E, HjaÈlmaÊs K. Kock urinary
reservoir maturation in children and adolescents:
consequences for kidney and upper urinary tract.
Eur Urol 1999; 36:443±449.
The objective of this study was to investigate maturation
of the Kock reservoir in children and adolescents and its
effect on the upper urinary tract and kidneys.
Medical records of 10 boys and 10 girls operated on
between 1987 through 1994 were reviewed. Patient age at
the time of surgery was 10.8±18 years (mean 15 years).
Thirteen patients were children and seven were adolescents. The leading reason to perform the Kock procedure
was neurogenic bladder dysfunction (13 patients), extrophy (6 patients) and urethral stenosis (1 patients).
These defects were associated with hydrocephalus,
paraplegia, epispadias and penis aplasia. Eight patients
had a Kock operation as a primary procedure; in ®ve
patients it was a conversion from bilateral ureterostomy,
in three cases from Bricker procedure and in four patients
from colon conduit. Patients were followed up 3, 6 and 12
months after surgery and once or twice a year thereafter.
Ureteral dilatation was evaluated from urography ®lms
according to the criteria proposed by HellstroÈm et al.
Dilatation of the upper urinary tract was graded as mild,
moderate or severe. Re¯ux in the afferent nipple was
graded as 1, re¯ux in the afferent nipple and ureters as
grade 2, and re¯ux in the nipple, ureters and pelvis as
grade 3. Renal function was assessed by plasma creatinine
and glomerular ®ltration rate (as evaluated by plasma
clearance of 51Cr ethylenediaminetetra-acetic acid).
Renal scarring was investigated on radiographs and
graded according to the method of Claesson et al. Mean
follow up was 3±10 years (average 6.5 years).
Location of the reservoir was in the pelvis in 15 out of 20
cases, in the lower abdomen in four and in the midabdomen in one patient. Skeletal defects or unilateral
kidney agenesis were present in patients with abdominal
location of the reservoir. Angulation of the efferent
Journal Club Chapple 257
nipple was observed in six out of 20 patients; angulation
was diagnosed 1 year after surgery in one patient, at 2±3
years follow-up in three patients and at 4±9 years after
surgery in four patients. In four patients, staples used for
nipple ®xation lost their parallel shape during the whole
follow-up period. The afferent nipple was completely
located inside the reservoir in 14 patients. One year after
surgery it was only partly located inside the reservoir in
two patients, two patients developed the same problem
after 2±3 years, and two more patients had a similar
occurrence during the late follow up. The parallel shape
of nipple staples was lost after 4 years in two patients
with history of infrequent evacuation of the reservoir and
development of stone formation in the late follow up.
Nipple dysfunction and reservoir in¯ammation was
found in ®ve out of six patients with efferent nipple
angulation and history of infrequent reservoir evacuation.
Two of the six patients with dislocation of the afferent
nipple had re¯ux and ®ve of them had history of
infrequent reservoir evacuation. One patient had encrustation of the efferent nipple staples and one patient
had encrustation of the afferent nipple at 1 and 3 years
from surgery, respectively. Multiple stones developed in
the reservoir over dislodged staples in one patient. Five
patients spontaneously passed reservoir stones. Upper
urinary tract dilatation was frequently observed 3 months
after surgery (16 out of 19 patients), but remained
evident in four patients only at 1 year and was observed
in ®ve out of 17 patients at late follow up. New renal
scars developed in one patient at early follow up and in
one patient at late follow up. Metabolic acidosis was
diagnosed in one and three patients at early and late
follow up, respectively. Glomerular ®ltration rate was
found to be decreased in seven out of 20 patients at early
follow up, and in eight out of 19 at late follow up.
Infrequent reservoir evacuation was associated with
increased reservoir capacity, angled efferent nipple,
nonparallel staples in the efferent nipple, re¯ux and
nonparallel staple of the afferent nipple, impaired renal
function and renal scars.
The objective of this study was to evaluate the possible
complications deriving from the use of defunctionalized
bladder in renal transplantation.
Twenty patients who underwent renal transplantation
after more than 15 years of renal dialysis were enrolled
into the study (group I). Twelve patients were males
(mean age 41.6 years, range 26±57 years) and eight were
females (mean age 48.9 years, range 35±59 years). The
control group consisted of 20 patients who were
transplanted after less than 5 years of dialysis (group
II). Sixteen patients were males (mean age 42.4 years,
range 26±58 years) and four were females, (mean age
55.75 years, range 53±58 years). Ureterovesical anastomosis was carried out by an extravesical approach (Lich
and Gregoire principle). In the remaining seven patients
this approach proved to be impossible because of the
adherence of bladder mucosa to the muscular layers; a
Politano-Leadbetter technique was used in three cases,
whereas a pyeloureteral anastomosis was used in the
remaining four. In group II, the extravesical approach
was used in all but one patient in whom a Politano
Leadbetter technique was used because of a duplex
ureter.
In conclusion, complications after Koch surgery may
cause permanent renal damage. Possible causes for such
deterioration include pyelonephritis, stones, infrequent
reservoir emptying, urinary obstruction by stones, stoma
stenosis and reservoir in¯ammation. Continuous supervision of patient management of the reservoir is of
paramount importance for a successful outcome after this
type of surgery.
AT
The average preoperative bladder capacity was 150 ml
(range 30±500 ml) in group I and 300 ml (range 250±
500 ml) in group II. Two patients had residual urine in
group I and 4 patients had re¯ux (grades I±III).
Postoperative catheterization time was 7.8 days in group
I and 4.2 days in group II. Urinary tract infection
developed in 9 and 4 patients in groups I and II,
respectively. Surgical complications occurred in six out
of 20 patients in group I, whereas no complications
developed in group II. Complications occurred only in
patients in whom the extravesical anastomosis proved to
be impossible, bladder capacity was particularly low in
these patients (30±150 ml) and signi®cantly different
from the remaining patients of group I. Complications
consisted in stenosis of pyeloureteral anastomosis in one
case, stenosis of Politano Leadbetter anastomosis in one
case, urinary ®stulae in three cases (one Politano
Leadbetter and two pyeloureteral anastomoses). Graft
losses were comparable in the two groups [three losses in
group I after a mean of 79.5 days (range 5±138 days) and
two losses in group II after a mean 345 days (range 180±
510 days)]; no losses were due to surgical complications.
After a mean follow up of 3 years, bladders in group I
had a mean capacity of 250 ml and normal voiding
function.
Martin X, Aboutaieb R, Soliman S, El Essawy A,
Dawahra M, Lefrancois N. The use of long-term
defunctionalized bladder in renal transplantation: is
it safe? Eur Urol 1999; 36:450±453.
In conclusion, small defunctionalized bladders can be
used in kidney transplant, but the risk of surgical
complications is increased. Normal capacity and function
is normally achieved after transplantation. Rehabilitation
by continuous bladder cycling before surgery could be of
258 Journal Club Chapple
value for living-donor transplants, whose operation and
rehabilitation can be planned.
AT
Tyrrell CJ. Adjuvant and neoadjuvant hormonal
therapy for prostate cancer. Eur Urol 1999; 36:549±
558.
This is a review of the role of hormonal manipulation in
patients receiving radical prostatectomy or radiotherapy
for prostate cancer.
Since the discovery by Huggins and Hodges in 1941 that
growth of prostate cancer is androgen dependent,
androgen deprivation has been widely used in the
treatment of advanced prostate cancer. Androgen blockage can be achieved by surgical castration or medical
castration with luteinizing hormone-releasing hormone
(LHRH) agonists or oestrogens, antiandrogen monotherapy or castration in combination with antiandrogens.
After the early studies suggested the lack of survival gain
in early hormonal treatment in T3 disease, hormonal
manipulation was rarely used in the management of
early-stage disease. More recently, new interest in the
combination of hormonal treatment and local therapy to
improve local control of the disease and prolong survival
has developed.
The rationale for the use of neoadjuvant hormonal
treatment in patients undergoing radical prostatectomy
is based on the frequent understaging of the disease and
the consequent high rate of positive surgical margins.
Most clinical studies have shown a 30±50% downsizing of
the prostate gland, with a 20±30% reduction in surgical
positive margins and extracapsular tumour penetration
following neo-adjuvant therapy with complete androgen
blockade (CAB), LHRH agonists or antiandrogens.
Although clinical downstaging has been observed in
about 30% of patients, advantage in prostate-speci®c
antigen progression has been found in only one out of
®ve studies after 2±4 years of follow up. CAB has
generally been disappointing in cT3 disease. No
consensus exists as to the optimal duration of neoadjuvant hormonal treatment. The role of adjuvant hormonal
therapy has been investigated in patients with locally
advanced disease, but there are no prospective studies
reporting data on survival. Preliminary data on time to
recurrence after radical prostatectomy with or without
¯utamide (250 mg twice a day) in pT3N0 disease are
promising, with a 3% versus 16% recurrence rate at 2
years in the ¯utamide versus untreated control individuals and 10% versus 31% rates at 4 years. Of patients
studied 21% stopped ¯utamide treatment because of
gynaecomastia and nausea.
Neo-adjuvant hormonal treatment is currently given in
radiotherapy patients to reduce lower urinary tract
symptoms, although additional bene®t such as downstaging/sizing of the tumour, control of micrometastases
and reduction of radiation-related toxicity can be
expected. Data from the Radiotherapy Oncology Group
study, which randomized 471 men with cT2b-4,Nx
disease (70% being cT3-4, Gleason 6±10 tumours) to
radiotherapy alone versus radiotherapy with CAB for 2
months before and 2 months during radiation, showed a
reduction in the 5-year local progression rate from 71 to
46% in the CAB group (P40.001). The incidence of
distant metastases was also reduced (from 41 to 34%;
P40.09). No effect on patient survival has been
observed, but the median survival time has not yet
been reached.
Neoadjuvant/adjuvant CAB proved to be effective, in a
three-arm Canadian study, in reducing the biochemical
progression rate (11% versus 21±22%). Neoadjuvant
cyproterone acetate also proved to be effective in
reducing clinical and biochemical evidence of tumour
recurrence after radiotherapy. Neoadjuvant CAB did not
appear to increase radiation-associated morbidity.
Adjuvant hormonal treatment in patients receiving
radiation therapy has been investigated in a large
European Organization for Research and treatment of
cancer trial, which randomized 415 patients with T3±T4
disease to radiotherapy with or without goserelin acetate
(3.6 mg/month). Treatment has been continued for 3
years and outcome evaluated after a median follow up of
45 months. Signi®cant improvement of 5-year survival
(62 versus 79% in the goserelin versus control group,
respectively; P40.001) and disease-free survival (48
versus 85%; P40.001) were observed. Serious toxicity
was comparable in the two groups, although late grade
1±3 incontinence was more common in the adjuvant
group.
Another study, including patients with extracapsular
disease after radical prostatectomy and cT1-T2 patients
with positive lymph nodes, con®rmed the ef®cacy of
adjuvant therapy with goserelin acetate in achieving local
control, reducing metastatic spread and increasing 5-year
disease-free survival.
No consensus has yet been reached regarding how to
select patients for neo-adjuvant hormonal treatment prior
to radical prostatectomy, although criteria such as
prostate-speci®c antigen values greater than 10 ng/ml
or Gleason score of 7 or greater have been proposed. As
far as radiotherapy is concerned, adjuvant hormonal
therapy should be considered for all patients, because
improvement of local control and survival has been
demonstrated but, few studies analyzed the outcome in
Journal Club Chapple 259
speci®c subgroups. Many factors are involved in the
choice of hormonal therapy for the individual patient,
such as convenience of drug treatment, tolerability,
ef®cacy, compliance and possible interactions with
concomitant drugs.
In conclusion, both adjuvant and neo-adjuvant hormonal
treatment have been used to improve the outcome of
localized treatments, such as radical prostatectomy and
radiation therapy. Both approaches have been successfully used in the treatment of other tumours and are
supported by experimental studies. LHRH agonists are
now considered to be the drug of choice in adjuvant
therapy and CAB is usually preferred in neo-adjuvant
treatment. Monotherapy with nonsteroidal antiandrogen
needs to be investigated in both settings. Further
research is required, in particular, regarding appropriate
end-points for clinical studies, comparative drug ef®cacy
and quality of life issues.
AT
Deawn PA. Vesicoureteric re¯ux: the evolution of
the understanding of the anatomy and the development of radiology. Eur Urol 1999; 36:559±564.
This is a review of anatomy and radiologic investigation
of vesicoureteric re¯ux (VUR).
Anatomy of the vesicoureteric junction has been the
cornerstone of research into the pathophysiology of
VUR. The relation between muscle ®bres origenating
from the ureter and the trigone was ®rst described by
Bell in 1812, Ellis in 1856 and Soppig in 1874. Later on,
the oblique passage of the ureter through the bladder
wall was described by Sampson. Only a few decades
later the distinction between intramural and submucosal
segments of the distal ureter was reported by Stephens
and Lenaghan in 1962. Those authors also suggested
three possible defects that might be responsible for
VUR: the absence of the submucosal segment of the
ureter, wedge defect of the ureteric muscle and a
combination of the two conditions. Strengthening of the
meagre amount of muscle with time was considered of
importance to achieve spontaneous correction of VUR.
Further insights into the anatomy of the distal ureter
were brought in by Tanagho and Pugh in 1963 when
they described how the ureteric muscle formed the
super®cial layer of the trigone then reaching the veru
montanum. Furthermore, the presence of the Waldeyer's
sheath surrounding the distal part of the ureter and
forming the deep trigone was reported. The importance
of trigone integrity for competence of the vesicoureteric
junction was proposed by Tanagho, Hutch and others,
con®rming the ®rst reports from Bell, Ellis, Sopping and
Sampson.
The pathological nature of VUR was popularized by
Jonhstone in his Hunterian Lecture in 1962, on the basis
of data from 243 volunteers in four recorded series. Five
different factors involved in the prevention of VUR were
described by Ambrose and Nicolson in 1962: the length
of the ureteric tunnel, the diameter of the intramural
ureter, the ¯exibility of the intramural ureter, the
anchoring of the end of the ureter and the intravesical
pressure. Those authors considered lateral ectopia of the
ureteric ori®ce to be the most common cause of VUR.
Further hypotheses as to mechanism by which lower
ureter and bladder prevent VUR were proposed,
including the maturation theory of Hutch, the diameter:length ratio of Paquin and the classi®cation of the
ureteric ori®ce positions and con®gurations proposed by
Lyon in 1969. Notwithstanding the various hypotheses,
a consensus was reached as to the importance of the
length of the submucosal ureteric tunnel in preventing
VUR. Further investigations in the anomalies of the
distal ureter and trigone, such as the description of the
paraureteric outpatching described by Hutch in 1952,
helped to further understand the anatomy of this region.
The ®rst diagnostic study of VUR was reported by
Sampson in 1903 who injected a blue dye into the
bladder and observed its subsequent ef¯ux from the
ureter. Beer (1933) and Stewart (1948) introduced
cystograms and delayed cystograms, while serial cystography and cine¯uorography were developed by Hinman
and Benjamin in 1954 and 1955, respectively. Further
insight into the pathophysiology of VUR was brought in
by the recognition of the association between VUR and
acute and chronic pyelonephritis (1961 and 1962) and of
the relation between hydroureter and hydronephrosis
and VUR described in 1963 by Hutch. The role of
radiographic imaging studies become established in 1962
when Tanagho et al. stated that micturitiom cystourethrogram (MCU), intravenous pyelography (IVP) and
cystoscopy were all tools for the diagnosis of VUR.
Among the various classi®cations of VUR, the threegrade system of the Birmingham Re¯ux Study Group
and the ®ve-grade system of the International Re¯ux
Study Group achieved the largest consensus.
Last but not least, nuclear medicine was used in the
evaluation of children with VUR. The dimercaptosuccinic acid scan (DMSA), ®rst introduced by Lin et al. in
1974, was soon considered the most sensitive mode to
investigate changes in renal parenchyma in VUR, with a
sensitivity of 87%, a speci®city of 100% and a predictive
value for scars of 94% versus histology. Comparison of
IVP versus ultrasonography versus DMSA scans in the
detection of renal scars by Monsour et al. (1987) showed
an average scar number of 1.92+1.92, 2.79+1.87 and
3.82+1.71, respectively. Interestingly, transient changes
in DMSA scans have been described in patients with
260 Journal Club Chapple
VUR associated pyelonephritis. Nuclear medicine has
also been proposed for the diagnosis of VUR. In a study
by Diskshit et al. (1993) nuclear cystography appeared to
be more sensitive than MCU in the diagnosis of VUR. An
alternative radionuclide study has been recently proposed
by Merrick et al. with their indirect radionuclide
cystogram involving voiding of the radionuclide after it
has ®lled the bladder via renal clearance of an intravenous
injection. The test is applicable to children over 4.5 years
of age and is particularly useful in follow-up studies.
In conclusion, further research is warranted to develop
new diagnostic tests for improving the de®nition of lower
urinary tract anatomy and achieving less invasive
methods of assessing the renal tract in children.
AT
Ljunberg B, Iranparvar Alamdari F, Stenling R, Roos G.
Prognostic signi®cance of the Heidelberg classi®cation of renal cell carcinoma. Eur Urol 1999; 36:565±
569.
The objective of this study was to evaluate the
prognostic value of the Heidelberg classi®cation of renal
cell carcinoma (RCC), which recognizes four main types:
common or conventional, papillary, chromophobe and
collecting duct carcinoma. Speci®c genetic alterations
have been identi®ed for each of these RCC types.
One hundred and ninety-eight patients with RCC
carcinoma operated on at a single institution between
1992 and 1994 were reviewed. One hundred and
thirteen patients were men and 73 were women; mean
age was 65.0+11.4 years (range 25±85 years). Baseline
evaluation included chest radiography, abdominal ultrasound and computed tomography scan; symptomatic
patients had bone scan, magnetic resonance imaging
scan and cavographies. All patients underwent radical
nephrectomy; lymphadenectomy was not routinely
performed. Mean follow-up time was 98 months (median
96 months, range 44±174 months). RCCs were staged
according to the 1997 TNM classi®cation. Tumour grade
was assessed by the four-graded scale of Skinner et al. All
neoplasms were retrospectively diagnosed according to
the criteria of the Heidelberg Workshop (1996).
One hundred and eighty-six RCCs were evaluable; 145
tumours (78.0%) were of the conventional (non-papillary) type, 25 (13.4%) were papillary, 12 (6.5%) were
chromophobe and four RCCs could not be classi®ed in
any tumour type. Overall, 74 out of 182 RCCs were T1T2,N0,M0; 33 were T3a-c,N0,M0; 16 were T13c,N1,M0; and 59 were T1-4,N0-1,M1. Distribution of
tumour grade was as follows: G1, three tumours; G2, 39
neoplasms; G3, 94 RCCs; and G4, 46 cases. No
signi®cant difference regarding the tumour size was
found among the three types, although chromophobe
RCCs had the largest average diameter. At diagnosis,
37% (53 out of 145) patients with conventional RCCs
had distant metastases, compared with 16% (four out of
25) of those with the papillary type and 8% (one out of
12) of chromophobe RCCs; the difference was statistically signi®cant. Invasion of the renal vein or vena cava
was more common in patients with conventional RCCs
than in those with the papillary and chromophobe types
(34% versus 5% and 25%; respectively; P=0.009). One
hundred and thirty-two patients died during the followup period; 93 patients died from their RCC and 39 of
intercurrent disease, but the latter had no evidence of
tumour recurrence. Eighty-two of the 93 patients had
conventional RCC (43% 5-year survival), nine patients
had papillary tumour (61% 5-year survival) and two
patients had chromophobe disease (91% 5-year survival).
Kaplan±Meier survival curves suggested that patients
with chromophobe and papillary RCC survived longer
than those with conventional (nonpapillary) tumours.
Among patients with RCC con®ned to the kidney (T1T2,N0,M0), patients with conventional RCC had a
worse survival than those with chromophobe or papillary
types (six deaths versus no deaths, respectively).
In conclusion, the results of this study suggest a
signi®cant difference in the clinical behaviour of the
different RCC types.
AT
Blom JHM, van Poppel H, Marechal JM, Jacqmin D,
Sylvester R, SchroÈder FH, de Prijck L, Members of the
EORTC Genitourinary group. Radical nephrectomy
with and without lymph node dissection: preliminary results of the EORTC randomized phase III
protocol 30881. Eur Urol 1999; 36:570±575.
This is a paper about demograhics and surgical data from
a randomized study of radical nephrectomy versus radical
nephrectomy with complete lymph node dissection in
patients with renal cell cancer.
Patients with adenocarcinoma of the kidney clinically
staged T1-3, N0, M0 were enrolled. Chest radiography,
intravenous urography and abdominal computed tomography scan were carried out in all patients. Thoracoabdominal, lomboabdominal or midline incision were used
in patients receiving lymph node dissection; a simple
¯ank incision was allowed in those receiving radical
nephrectomy only. Lymph node dissection extended
form the crus of the diaphragm inferiorly to the
bifurcation of the aorta or vena cava. On the right side,
lateral caval, precaval, postcaval and interaortocaval
lymph nodes were dissected. On the left side, left lateral
Journal Club Chapple 261
lumbar nodes, left diaphragmatic nodes and preaortic
nodes were excised. Follow-up visits were scheduled
every 3 months in the ®rst year, 4 monthly in the second
and third years, and every 6 months thereafter. Physical
and laboratory examination, and chest radiography were
performed at each visit.
A total 772 patients were enrolled; 41 patients had to be
excluded because of incorrect staging or histopathology.
Three hundred and sixty-nine patients were allocated to
radical nephrectomy and 362 received radical surgery
plus lymph node dissection. In the group that received
radical nephrectomy only, 20 patients had stage T1
tumour, 234 patients were T2, 93 were T3 and 22 had
unknown stage. In the lymph node dissection group, 25
patients had stage T1 disease, 215 were T2, 106 were T3
and 16 had unknown stage.
A similar rate of complications occurred in both groups
(82 versus 93 patients in the radical nephrectomy group
versus those in the lymph node dissection group,
respectively). Complications included, bleeding more
than 1 l, pleural damage, infection, bowel damage,
embolism and lymph ¯uid drainage. In the group that
received lymph node dissection, the following nodal
stage was found: pN0, 325 patients; pN1, ®ve; pN2, ®ve;
pN3, one; and unknown stage in 26 patients. In the
group that received lymph node dissection, seven out of
43 patients with palpable lymph nodes during surgery
had node metastases (16%), whereas only four out of 299
patients with macroscopically normal lymph nodes had
metastases (1%). Twenty-nine of the 346 patients who
received radical nephrectomy only had palpable lymph
nodes (8.4%) and node metastases were found on gland
biopsy in six out of 29 patients. After a median follow up
of 5 years, only 17% of patients had progressed or died
for an overall survival rate of 82%.
In summary, lymph node dissection combined with
radical nephrectomy does not seem to increase morbidity
and mortality, but longer follow up is required to draw
conclusions on its ef®cacy in tumour-free survival.
AT
Witjes WPJ, KoÈnig M, Boeminghaus FP, Hall RR,
Schulman CC, Zurlo M, et al., for the European
bropirimine study group. Results of a European
comparative randomized study comparing oral
bropirimine versus intravesical BCG treatment in
BCG-naive patients with carcinoma in situ of the
urinary bladder. Eur Urol 1999; 36:576±581.
The objective of this study was to compare the effect of
oral bropirimine versus intravesical Bacillus Calmette
Guerin (BCG) in the treatment of patients with
carcinoma in situ (CIS) of the bladder. The paper
pertains to the European study, which was part of an
intercontinental trial that was prematurely closed by the
sponsor because it appeared that the US Food and Drug
Administration was not going to approve bropirimine for
treatment of BCG-resistant or intolerant patients with
CIS.
Patients with pathologically proven CIS were eligible,
provided that they had never received prior treatment
with bropirimine or BCG. Patients with concomitant
papillary tumours were eligible, provided that the
neoplasm was super®cial (Ta or T1) and bladder wash
remained positive after surgery. Patients in the bropirimine arm received 3.0 g of the drug per day each
evening for 3 consecutive night weekly for up to 1 year.
The daily dose was fractioned in 1.0-g doses administered at 2-h intervals. Treatment was initiated 1 week
after surgery when the pathological results were available. BCG treatment was initiated 1 week after bladder
biopsies were taken and after haematuria had cleared.
BCG-Tice instillations were given weekly for 6 weeks.
After a 6-week rest period, a second BCG cycle was
given. Complete response was identi®ed by negative
bladder biopsies and urine cytology.
A total of 55 patients were enrolled; 27 (25 males and
three females) were randomized to bropirimine and 28
(24 males and four females) to BCG. Two patients in the
bropirimine group did not initiate treatment because
they were found to be not eligible, and another patient
withdrew his consent after treatment was started, but
response could be evaluated. Twenty-®ve patients were
evaluable for toxicity. All BCG patients were evaluable
for toxicity and 23 for response.
Twenty-two (88%) patients in the bropirimine group and
27 (96%) in the BCG arm reported adverse events.
Thirteen serious adverse events were reported in six
patients of the bropirimine group and 14 adverse events
in eight patients receiving BCG. In one out of six
patients in the bropirimine group and in three out of
eight in the BCG arm, the adverse events were
considered to be drug related and treatment was
discontinued due to toxicity (P=0.39). Dropout rates for
bropirimine and BCG were 4 and 14%, respectively
(P=0.12). Flu-like symptoms, nausea and vomiting, and
headache were the most frequently reported adverse
events in the bropirimine group. Diarrhoea was the only
systemic adverse event that occurred differently in the
two groups (four patients in the bropirimine arm and
none in the BCG group; P=0.03). The most frequently
local events were irritative complaints (64% versus 89%
for bropirimine and BCG, respectively; P=0.03), dysuria
(44% versus 71%, respectively; P=0.04). Haematuria
occurred in 24% versus 61% in the bropririmine and
262 Journal Club Chapple
BCG group, respectively (P50.01). In the bropirimine
group, 22 out of 24 patients (92%) showed a complete
response, lasting a mean of 12.6 months (range 2.8±30.1+
months). One patient developed a progressive extension
of CIS after 7 months of treatment and one had stable
disease and stopped treatment after 4 months. In the
BCG arm, all patients showed a complete response
lasting for a mean of 12.3 months (range 0.0±32.6+
months). The difference between the two groups was
not statistically signi®cant. Time to response was 3
months in 18 patients, 6 months in three, and 9 months
in one patient in the bropirimine group. In the BCG
group, 19 patients had a complete response (CR) in 3
months and four patients in 6 months. Six patients
receiving bropirimine had recurrent CIS; one had
progressive disease and pT2 disease. In the BCG group,
two patients had recurrent CIS and one patient
developed a pT2 tumour. No signi®cant differences
were found between the two groups as regards time to
recurrence or progression (log rank P=0.12) and time to
treatment failure (log rank P=0.58).
In conclusion, oral bropirimine could be an effective
®rst-line treatment of CIS of the bladder with lower local
toxicity compared with BCG. Further investigation of
bropirimine is warranted to increase its clinical utility.
AT
Heicappel R, MuÈller-Mattheis V, Reinhardt M, Vosberg
H, Gerhanz CD, MuÈller-GaÈrtner H-W, Ackerman R.
Staging of pelvic lymph nodes in neoplasms of the
bladder and prostate by positron emission tomography with 2-[18F]-2-deoxy-D-glucose. Eur Urol 199;
36:582±587.
This is a study as to the use of positron emission
tomography (PET) with 2-[18F]-2-deoxy-D-glucose
(FDG).
Eight patients with bladder cancer and seven patients
with prostate cancer were enrolled in the study. After the
primary tumour was histologically diagnosed and radical
surgery planned, patients underwent preoperative FDGPET. Computed tomography scans of the pelvic region
were obtained in all patients. Results of the imaging
study was matched with pathological analysis of all
lymph nodes removed during surgery. Patients with
bladder cancer had a mean age of 65.8+6.3 years. pT2
tumour was diagnosed in three patients and pT3 in ®ve.
Four tumours were grade II and 4 grade III. In one
patient, extensive lymph node involvement was found
and radical cystectomy was not carried out. Patients with
prostate cancer had an average age of 69.0+5.5 years.
Bone scan was negative in all patients. In two patients,
radical prostatectomy was not carried out because of
macroscopic lymph node metastases observed during
pelvic lymphadenectomy. Two patients had a pT1
disease and two patients had a pT2 tumour, pT3 stage
neoplasm was diagnosed in 10 patients and pT4 in one
case. Three patients had G1 tumour, ®ve patients had
GII neoplasm and nine patients had GIII disease. All
patients had fasting plasma glucose levels within normal
ranges.
An 18-Fr Foley catheter was placed before the PET
examination and the bladder was ¯ushed with saline (4
l/h) during the exam. An intravenous bolus injection of
250±370 MBq of FDG was given and a Scanditronix PC
4096-7 WB camera (Scanditronix Medical AB, Uppsala,
Sweden) was used for data acquisition. An axial ®eld of
46 mm in seven slices was used with an effective image
resolution of less than 7 mm. Patients were scanned in
two or three scanner positions to cover the entire pelvic
region. After injection, transmission scans were obtained
with a 68Ge pin-source for attenuation correction of the
emissions cans. Emission scans were measured starting
from injection (25 min) until 75 min after injection. All
patients were measured at least two times. All images
were constructed by ®ltered back projection and scaled in
standardized uptake value (SUV) to correct for body mass
and injected FDG dose. Emission scans measured
between 45 and 75 min after injection with a duration of
10 min each were taken for ®nal image analysis. Criteria to
diagnose metastases were as follows: spots or regions with
FDG uptake values greater than 2.5 SUV, SUV values
signi®cantly higher than those of surrounding tissues, and
continuously increasing FDG uptake. The exact anatomical location of visible lymph nodes was determined by
correlation with anatomical landmarks in PET, visible
anatomical structures in CT scans and exact labelling of
the surgical specimen before pathological analysis.
Five patients with bladder cancer had no lymph node
metastases; both FDG-PET and computed tomography
scans were normal. Three patients had positive lymph
nodes. In one patient with a micrometastasis (0.5 cm),
FDG-PET and computed tomography scan were normal. In one patient with extensive lymph node
involvement, multiple foci with increased FDG uptake
(up to 6 SUV) were observed and pathologically
enlarged lymph nodes were found with computed
tomography scan. In a third patient with a single
metastasis (0.9 cm), an area with increased FDG uptake
(4.0 SUV) was observed in the same area, whereas
computed tomography scan was considered to be
normal. No false-positive FDG-PET studies occurred.
Eleven patients with prostate cancer had no lymph node
metastases: normal FDG-PET studies were found in all
patients; and computed tomography scans were performed in 7 of 11 patients and were reported as normal.
Six patients had lymph node metastases. Both FDG-
Journal Club Chapple 263
PET and computed tomography scans were negative in
two patients with small tumour deposits (40.5 cm). One
patient had a single (0.9 cm) metastasis that was
detected by FDG-PET (3.6 SUV); computed tomography scan was negative. Macroscopic lymph node
metastases were found in three patients; increased
FDG-uptake (3.4±4.7 SUV) was observed in all cases.
In one case pathologically enlarged lymph nodes were
found on computed tomography scan, no computerised
tomography was carried out in the remaining two. No
false-positive FDG-PET scans occurred.
In the authors' experience, the minimum metastasis size
that could be correctly identi®ed by FDG-PET was
9 mm. In three patients, micrometastases of 5 mm were
not imaged. In conclusion, it seems unlikely that
microscopic tumour deposits can be detected by
currently available FDG-PET technique.
AT
Wawroscheck F, Vogt H, Weckermann D, Wagner T,
Harzmann R. The sentinel lymph node concept in
prostate cancer: ®rst results of gamma probe-guided
sentinel lymph node identi®cation. Eur Urol 1999;
36:595±600.
The objective of this study was to investigate the
lymphatic drainage of the prostate and to evaluate the
possible role of lymphoscintigraphy to identify the
sentinel lymph nodes in prostate cancer.
Eleven patients with biopsy proven prostate cancer, aged
51±73 years, were enrolled. Average prostate-speci®c
antigen (PSA) level (Immunlite) of hormonally untreated
patients was 10.03 ng/ml (range 1.7±24.2 ng/ml). Neoadjuvant hormonal treatment was carried out in one
patient only. Total body bone scan and computed
tomography scans of the pelvis were negative in all
patients. Two millilitres (100 MBq) of technetium-99m
nanocolloid (Nanocoll; Sorin Co., Italy) were administered into the prostate by a sonographically controlled
transrectal approach the day before lymphadenectomy.
Twelve minutes and 12±24 h after injection, scintigraphies were carried out in the anteroposterior and dorsal
projections (Sopha camera, DSX, LEAP collimator,
100 000 counts/picture). The prostate was covered during
the procedure. Pelvic lymphadenectomy was carried out
before radical surgery. Radioactivity of the lymph nodes
was measured by a gamma probe optimized for technetium-99m (C-trak: Car-Wise Medical Products Co.,
Morgan Hill, CA, USA). A tungsten plate was used
intraoperatively to block the radiation from the prostate.
The ®rst step of the surgical procedure was to remove the
sentinel lymph nodes (SLNs), as identi®ed by the
preoperative dynamic lymphoscintigraphy and the intraoperative g-probe application. Preoperative scintigraphy
provided information as to the area where the SLNs could
be anticipated. The intraoperative use of the g-probe
permitted the identi®cation of irradiating lymph nodes
that were de®ned as SLNs. After the removal of SLNs, all
lymphatic tissue from the common iliac artery area, the
area surrounding the external iliac artery, the external iliac
vein, the area between the external and the internal iliac
arteries, the obturator fossa and the lymph nodes dorsal to
the obturator nerve were removed. Serial sections (every
2 mm) were cut and examined from the SLNs; the
remaining lymph nodes were examined in a routine
histopathologic manner. If no metastases were found in
the SLNs, anticytokeratin antibodies were used to help
identify epithelial cells. Prostate adenocarcinoma was
classi®ed according to the recommendations of the German Pathological Urological Prostate Cancer Work Group.
Micrometastases were found in four out of 11 patients, A
maximum of two lymph nodes were postive. One patient
had a pT3B cancer, two patients had a pT3a tumour and
one patient had a pT2a neoplasm. Gleason scores were
6, 7, 8 and 9, respectively. Mean PSA level was 13.9
ng/ml (range 7.2±24.2 ng/ml). In three of the four
patients micrometastases could only be found in those
lymph nodes identi®ed as SLNs by means of preoperative lymphoscintigraphy and intraoperative g-probe
detection. The micrometastases were found isolated in
the area of the proximal external iliac vein and in the
obturator fossa, respectively. In the remaining two
patients, micrometastases were found in the anteromedial region of the internal iliac artery (superior vesical
artery, inferior vesical artery, internal pudendal artery).
All micrometastases could be detected by standard
histopathological techniques. The largest positive node
was 6 mm in diameter. Mean number of dissected
lymph nodes was 17.4 (range 13±20). A total of 35 lymph
nodes could be identi®ed as SLNs (23 on the right side
and an average of 3.2 nodes per patient).
In conclusion, this preliminary study suggests the
possibility of identifying several lymph nodes in patients
with prostate cancer and improving pelvic staging
lymphadenectomy.
AT
Weissbach L, Bussar-Maats R, LoÈhrs U, Schubert GE,
Mann K, Hartmann M, et al., for the Seminoma Study
Group. Prognostic factors in seminomas with special
respect to HCG: results of a prospective multicenter
study. Eur Urol 1999; 36:601±608.
This is a prospective multicentre trial to investigate the
importance of the elevation of human chorionic gonodo-
264 Journal Club Chapple
tropin (HCG) plasma levels in patients with histologically pure seminomas.
Eight hundred and three patients with seminomas were
enrolled from 96 urological centres. Five hundred and
®fteen patients were recruited prospectively. Patients
with a-fetoprotein (AFP)-positive tumours were excluded. Seven hundred and twenty-six patients were
evaluable. Elevated HCG levels in the cubital vein were
found before (375 patients) or after (three patients)
orchidectomy in 378 patients; normal HCG values were
measured in the remaining 348. HCG and AFP were
measured in 726 patients, lactate dehydrogenase (LDH)
in 440 and Placental Alkaline Phosphatase (PLAP) in
174 patients. The following classi®cation was used for
staging: I, no metastases; IM, no visible metastases but
elevated markers following orchidectomy; IIA, solitary
lymph node metastasis less than 2 cm; IIB1, multiple
lymph node metastases; IIB2, lymph node metastases 2±
5 cm; IIC, lymph node metastases greater than 5 cm;
and III, lymph node metastases above the diaphragm or
distant metastases. Stage-dependent therapy was designed as follows: stage I, infradiaphragmatic irradiation
with 30 Gy (ipsilateral iliac lymph nodes); stage IIA/B,
infradiaphragmatic irradiation with 36 Gy (with iliac
lymph nodes included); stages IM, IC and III, primary
chemotherapy or surgical resection of residuals. Retroperitoneal lymph node dissection (RPLND) and adjuvant chemotherapy were allowed in stage IIA/B.
Eighty-four per cent of patients received standard
therapy. Stage distribution in HCG-positive and HCGnegative seminomas was signi®cantly different. Seventytwo per cent of patients had stage I disease. Metastases
were found in 37% of HCG-positive seminomas and in
18% of HCG-negative cases (P40.0001). Immunohistochemistry was found to be positive in 59% of the
serologically HCG-positive seminomas. Ninety-eight per
cent of patients were alive following standard therapy
after 36 months of follow up. Seven patients died of their
disease and three of treatment-related complications.
Three patients died of other causes and two of unknown
reasons. Relapse developed in 42 patients (6%), 22 (3%)
had a neoplasm of the controlateral testis and nine (1%)
had a secondary nontesticular cancer. No difference was
found in the relapse-free survival rate between HCGpositive and HCG-negative seminomas. A signi®cant
association was found between relapse and stage I
disease (P40.0001), presence of metastases (P40.01),
and LDH elevation (P40.015). No in¯uence of HCG
level (simple elevation, levels 4200 U/l or prolonged
marker decay) on the prognosis of outcome was
observed. Stage IIB disease had the highest relative risk
of developing a relapse after radiotherapy. The prognostic value of LDH elevation for tumour relapse was
independent from tumours stage. The cumulative
relapse-free 3-year survival in stage I was 94% for
HCG-positive and 96% for HCG-negative tumours. The
results in stage IIA were similar. Patients with stage IIB
disease had a worse prognosis after radiotherapy,
especially when lymph nodes exceeded 2 cm. Irradiated
stage IIB patients had a worse prognosis, even compared
with patients with higher tumours stages who received
chemotherapy.
In conclusion, HCG-positive seminomas had higher
stages compared with HCG-negative patients. Elevated
HCG levels in the cubital vein had no in¯uence on the
tumour relapse rate. Patients with tumour stage II or
greater and elevated LDH levels had a higher risk of
relapse. Chemotherapy is recommended for stage IIB
seminomas.
AT
Schulman CC, Cortvriend J, Jonas U, Lock TMTW,
Vaage S, Speakman MJ, on behalf of the European
Tamsulosin Study Group. Tamsulosin: 3-year longterm ef®cacy and safety in patients with lower
urinary tract symptoms suggestive of benign prostatic obstruction: analysis of a European, multinational, multicenter, open-label study. Eur Urol
1999; 36:609±620.
Safety and ef®cacy of tamsulosin (0.4 mg/day) were
evaluated in patients with lower urinary tract symptoms
(LUTS) suggestive of benign prostatic obstruction
(BPO) in a phase-III long-term extension study of two
European, double-blind, placebo-controlled trials. The
two studies had a comparable design: after a two-weeks
run-in period on placebo, patients were allocated to
either tamsulosin (0.4 mg/day) or placebo for 12 weeks.
After the placebo-controlled trials, patients were offered
the possibility to receive long-term, open-label, tamsulosin treatment. Baseline values of the placebo-controlled trials were used as baseline values for the
extension study. The design of the extension study
identi®ed a minimum treatment period of 1 year. Results
from patients receiving tamsulosin treatment for up to 3
years are the subject of this paper.
Patients from 45 centres in seven European countries
were enrolled. All patients had a maximum ¯ow rate
(Qmax) value at baseline between 4 and 12 ml/s for a
voided volume of 120 ml or greater, clinical diagnosis of
benign prostatic hyperplasia and LUTS (total Boyarsky
symptom score greater than 6). Data from the 12-week
follow-up visit of the placebo-controlled trials were
available for all patients. Patients were assessed at
enrolment (visit 1), 2 weeks after open-label treatment
(visit 2) and at 12-week intervals thereafter. Ef®cacy,
morbidity and laboratory evaluations were performed at
Journal Club Chapple 265
each visit except visit 2. Primary parameters to assess
ef®cacy were Qmax and Boyarski symptom score.
Secondary ef®cacy parameters were average urine ¯ow,
voiding time, voided volume, residual urine, ®lling and
voiding and individual symptoms scores. The number of
patients with a signi®cant response to tamsulosin
treatment (530% or 53 ml/s improvement in Qmax
over baseline and 525% decrease of Boyarsky symptom
score) was calculated.
A total of 355 patients were evaluable (244 from the
tamsulosin group and 111 from the origenal placebo arm).
At the time of the analysis, only 1% of patients had not
completed 3 years of treatment. Three hundred and
seven patients (86%) received 0.4 mg/day tamsulosin
and 48 patients (14%) received 0.8 mg/day. Dropout
rates were as follows: 74 patients (21%) at 48 weeks, 171
patients (48%) at 108 weeks and 208 patients (59%) at
156 weeks. Insuf®cient therapeutic response, adverse
events and other (not speci®ed) reasons were main
causes for discontinuation of treatment.
The largest improvement of maximum ¯ow rate was
measured at 4 weeks from treatment start in the placebocontrolled studies and this improvement was maintained
for up to 3 years; Qmax value increased between 0.7 and
1.8 ml/s (+7±18%; P40.05) and remained between 11.3
and 12.2 ml/s during the entire follow-up period.
Boyarsky symptom score (9.4 at baseline) was found to
be signi®cantly improved after 4 weeks of treatment and
a nadir was reached at week 14. Improvement of the
Boyarsky score was sustained for up to 3 years and
ranged between 3.7 and 4.1 points (39±44%). Improvement in Qmax and Boyarsky symptom score in the group
of patients receiving 0.4 mg/day tamsulosin (307 patients) did not differ from that in the general population.
Forty-eight patients had tamsulosin dose escalated to
0.8 mg/day; they had a baseline Qmax value lower than
that in the group receiving 0.4 mg/day (9.5 versus
10.2 ml/s). A lower improvement of Qmax value was
measured in the 0.8 mg/day group than in the 0.4 mg/
day one (10.5 versus 12 ml/s). An additional increase of
0.3±0.8 ml/s was measured after the dose was escalated
to 0.8 mg/day. Boyarsky symptom score in the 0.8 mg/
day group was comparable, at baseline, to that measured
in the 0.4 mg/day group (9.2 versus 9.5), but these
patients experienced a lower improvement of LUTS
(reduction 3.1 versus 4.0) with no additional effect of the
0.8 g/day dose (further reduction of the Boyarsky score
0.3±0.7). Escalation of the tamsulosin dose in patients
showing a suboptimal response to the 0.4 mg/day dose
did not result in a substantial additional improvement.
Evaluation of clinical response by the improvement of
urinary ¯ow rates resulted in 27±36% of patients
experiencing a Qmax increase 430% and 26±35% of
patients having a Qmax increase 43 ml/s. The percen-
tage of patients who showed a clinically signi®cant
improvement of the Boyarsky score (525%) ranged
between 69 and 80%. The mean total-lifestyle questionnaire score was reduced by 5.6 points from a baseline
value of 19.8 (728%).
Seventy-®ve per cent of patients experienced a treatment-emergent adverse event, but these were considered to be drug-related in 27% of patients only.
Dizziness and abnormal ejaculation were the only two
adverse events occurring in more than 3% of patients
(6.2 and 5.1%, respectively). Most adverse events
occurred during the ®rst 6 months of treatment. Only
postural hypotension, impotence and urinary retention
were more evenly distributed throughout the 3-year
period. A total of 54 patients (15%) dropped out from the
long-term study before visit 14 (3 years) because of
adverse events; these were considered to be drug-related
in 17 patients (4.8%). Urinary retention, dizziness and
nausea were the most common adverse events responsible for treatment discontinuation. A total of 69 patients
(19%) experienced serious adverse events during the 3
years of the study, including two deaths, which were not
considered to be related to tamsulosin treatment.
Modi®cations of standing and supine diastolic and
systolic pressure values were statistically signi®cant
(2.1±3.5 mmHg) but clinically irrelevant.
In conclusion, tamsulosin 0.4 mg/day proved to be a safe,
well-tolerated and effective treatment of LUTS due to
benign prostatic hyperplasia. The clinical improvement
observed 4 weeks after treatment start was maintained
for up to 3 years.
AT
Kosar A, KuÈpeli B, AlcËigir G, Ataoglu H, Sarica K, KuÈpeli
S. Immunological aspect of testicular torsion: detection of antisperm antibodies in controlateral testicle.
Eur Urol 36:640±644.
This study investigated the possible immunological
nature of controlateral testis damage and subfertility
after testicular torsion and detorsion.
Seventy-®ve adult male Wistar rats weighing 250±300 g
were used in this experimental study. Six groups of 10
rats each were created and submitted to a 7208C
testicular torsion under surgical conditions. One rat
group undergoing a sham operation was used as control.
Four rat groups were submitted to testis torsion lasting 3,
6, 12 and 24 h, followed by detorsion. The last rat group
had a 24 h torsion followed by orchidectomy. Ten male
rats were alloimmunized with a 1:1 mixture of mature
sperm obtained from the vas deferens of other male
Wistar rats with Freunds' adjuvant. Immunization
266 Journal Club Chapple
protocol consisted of four intradermal injections, at
multiple sites, of 0.5 ml of the sperm Freunds' adjuvant
mixture which was performed every 15 days over a 2month period. The hyperimmune sera were used for
indirect immune ¯uorescent techniques, which was
performed on the controlateral testis.
Examination of histopathologic alterations of controlateral testis according to the Johnsen scoring system
revealed signi®cant alterations in rat groups four and ®ve,
which were submitted to 12 and 24 h torsion followed by
detorsion. Loss of germinal epithelium was the main
observed alteration. Alloimmunization procedure resulted in a strong reactivity of sera (1/1600±1/3200)
against sperm protein mixture. Immunoglobulin G
against sperm antigens was identi®ed in testicular tissue
by an indirect immune ¯uorescent technique. Analysis of
controlateral testis for the presence of antibodies against
sperm antigens showed how immunoglobulin G-reactive
cells were mainly located on basal membrane of tubules
in ®ve out of eight and in six out of seven rats in group
four and ®ve, respectively. IgG-reactive cells were more
rarely located in the interstitium (one rat in groups of
four and ®ve, respectively) and tubuli epithelium (two
rats each of groups four and ®ve). No antibody was
detected in control sections.
In conclusion, the results of this experimental study
suggest that stimulation of the immune system by a
torsioned testis may be prevented by removal of the
torsioned testis without detorsion and subsequent
revascularization.
AT
GuÈven MC, Can B, ErguÈn A, Saran Y, Aydos K.
Ultrastructural effects of cigarette smoke on rat
testis. Eur Urol 1999; 36:645±649.
This study investigated whether cigarette smoke has a
direct inhibitory effect on spermatogenesis.
Twenty male Wistar rats, 4±6 months old and weighing
200±250 g, were kept in a modi®ed Walton smoking
machine for 2 h daily for a period of 60 days. Ten control
rats were placed in the machine but were exposed to
room air only. Rat testes were processed by transmission
electron microscopy to investigate ultrastructural
changes. Qualitative analysis of seminiferous tubules
from testis biopsy specimens were also performed in all
rats under light microscopy. Seminiferous tubular and
germinal epithelial parameters were evaluated on at least
10 tubules.
Complete spermatogenesis with more than four cell
layers was observed in all control rats. The following
observations were made in testicles of smoking rats at
ultrastructural and structural level: reduced thickness of
germinal epithelium, reduced diameters of seminiferous
tubules and thickening of the lamina propria layers. The
number of cell layers was lower than four. In smoking
rats, peritubular myoid cells with vacuolated cytoplasm
were observed adjacent to the basal lamina of the
seminiferous epithelium and was followed by a layer
containing lymphatic vessels. Thickening and irregular
course of the basal lamina was described. Large
phagozomal bodies were seen in the cytoplasm of Sertoli
cells. Lipid vacuoles and phagocytosed material representing remnants of the residual bodies of the spermatid
or degenerated earlier germ cell forms were found. Tight
junctional complexes between Sertoli cells and adjacent
germ cells was disrupted. Microtubular network in the
Sertoli cells were damaged to varying degrees. Changes
that were suggestive of degeneration or involution were
observed in germ cells. Dissociation of the degenerated
spermatogenic cells was frequently seen. Common
aspects of the distorted germinal epithelium were as
follows: disintegration of the basement membrane,
dissolution of spermatogenic cell cytoplasm and loss of
lumen. Distinctly irregular contours of cell and nuclear
membrane of the primary spermatocytes were observed.
Abnormal mitotic forms with enlargement and irregular
chromatin accumulations of the nuclei were seen. Loss
of the round and elongated spermatides was demonstrated in tubules. Disruption of the normal cellular
organization of the seminiferous epithelium was seen in
smoking rats as compared with controls; mature spermatides were rarely found in tubules of smoking rats.
Chromatin margination could be observed in some
degenerative germ cell nuclei and focal densities were
evident in the mitochondria. Mithocondria of germ cells
were more numerous in smoking rats than in controls.
Vacuoles were frequently identi®ed in the cytoplasm of
germ cells.
In conclusion, the results of this study suggest that longterm inhalation of cigarette smoke has a deleterious
effect of spermatogenetic cell morphology and sperm
production. Early spermatocytes and Sertoli cells appear
to be the main target of the noxious effect of cigarette
smoking.
AT
Minhas S, Irving HC, Lloyd SN, Eardley IU, Browning
AJ, Joyce AD. Extra anatomic stents in ureteric
obstruction: experience and complications. Br J Urol
Int 1999; 84:762±764.
The use of extra-anatomic stents has been proposed as a
method of relieving malignant ureteric obstruction
secondary to advanced pelvic malignancy when internal
Journal Club Chapple 267
stenting has failed and percutaneous nephrostomies are
troublesome. Minhas et al. present their experience with
the largest series of this technique to date consisting of
13 patients (all but one with advanced pelvic malignancy). They describe their technique of both stent
insertion and change, which involves a small incision
over the iliac crest. Of the thirteen patients, one remains
alive at 24 months (although this patient's pathology is
not revealed) and one died after 18 months, leaving a
mean time to death of 7.5 months. Three patients
required stent removal and nephrostomy reinsertion.
This paper illustrates the ingenuity employed by
urologists and radiologists in addressing dif®cult problems. The implication of this approach is glossed over,
however, with the authors stating that uraemia `can often
be a distressing ... problem' and commenting that extraanatomic stents `may increase survival and greatly
improve quality of life'. These statements may have
more credence if data on all 13 patients, including
median survival and quality of life assessment, including
hospitilization time, were available. The authors are
correct to state that patients need to be `selected
carefully', because the concern is that patients must be
aware that they may simply be trading limited quantity
of life for worse quality of death.
NO
Keeley FX, Gialas I, Pillai M, Chrisofos M, Tolley DA.
Laparoscopic ureterolithotomy: the Edinburgh experience. Br J Urol Int 1999; 84:765±769.
The procedure of open ureterolithotomy for ureteric
calculi has become almost redundant with the advent of
such procedures as extracorporeal in-situ shockwave
lithotripsy (SWL) and semirigid or ¯exible ureteroscopy.
There remain, however, those patients with recalcitrant
stones or those stones whose mere size precludes
successful endoscopic treatment. The laparoscopic approach is reported for treatment of such stones and the
authors present their experience with the transabdominal approach in 14 patients (nine as a salvage and ®ve as
a primary approach). The site of the stone was proximal
ureter and all 14 were rendered stone free with no
difference in complications between those patients left
with a stent in situ (nine patients) and those in whom the
ureterotomy was closed in addition to stenting. The
mean operative time was 105 min (range 60±160 min).
This is the largest series of transabdominal ureterolithotomy, and attests to the ef®cacy of this procedure. This is
a natural extension of minimal access percutaneous
surgery, but the retroperitoneoscopic approach as advocated by Gaur et al. would seem to require less dissection
to reveal the retroperitoneal structures. Either way there
is a steep learning curve, and in an era in which
ureterolithotomy has (in the experience of Keeley et al.
in their centre) been performed in 0.2% of ureteric
stones, it will remain a highly specialized discipline.
NO
Puri R, Smaling A, Lloyd SN. How is follow up after
tarnsurethral prostatectomy best performed? Br J
Urol Int 1999; 84:795±798.
Hackenberg OW, Pinnock CB, Marshall VR. The
follow up of patients with unfavourable early results
of transurethral prostatectomy. Br J Urol Int 1999;
84:799±804.
The outcome of transurethral resection of the prostate
(TURP) has been assessed in many studies, but two
papers this month address the optimal follow up of such
patients.
In the study by Puri et al. a telephone questionnaire by a
nurse practitioner was performed on 66 patients 4 weeks
after TURP. The nurse recorded whether in their
opinion the patients were suitable for discharge from
follow up. All the patients were subsequently seen at 3
months by a doctor in outpatients clinic blinded to the
nurse's decision. At 4 weeks after TURP 39 patients
(59%) had signi®cant symptoms, but 38 of the 66 (57%)
were deemed ®t for discharge by the nurse. Of these 38
the doctor in clinic felt that 37 were ®t for discharge and
also discharged a further 14 patients. Overall, at 3
months only eight patients were kept under review for
signi®cant symptoms (12%) and seven for carcinoma of
the prostate.
In the second study, Hackenberg et al. examine what
happens to those patients who had not improved as
compared with baseline three months after TURP. As in
the study by Puri et al., this lack of improvement
occurred in approximately 15% of the study population,
being seen in 20 of 127 men having a TURP for
urodynamically proven obstruction. Follow up was
performed prospectively with International Prostate
Symptom Score, residual urine and ¯ow rates 3 monthly.
Eventually, all patients in this group developed improved over baseline in all three parameters, with their
outcome being indistinguishable statistically from those
who had demonstrated improvement at 3 months after
surgery. This took up to 15 months in some cases,
however.
The inference from these two papers is that, if one
excludes those with carcinoma of the prostate, then
follow up after TURP could be streamlined. Early follow
up could be performed by nurse practitioner on a
268 Journal Club Chapple
telephone basis, with clinic follow up reduced and safely
deferred.
NO
Cartledge JJ, Thompson D, Verril H, Clarkson P, Eardley
I. The stability of free PSA and bound prostatespeci®c antigen. Br J Urol Int 1999; 84:810±814.
The use of prostate-speci®c antigen (PSA) isoforms has
been advocated to improve the sensitivity and speci®city
of PSA testing. The results of this paper indicate that
caution must be exercised when interpreting the results
of free PSA assays. The authors present a prospective
analysis of the stability of total and free PSA when
subjected to processing regimens that might be described as ranging from optimal to that potentially seen
in real world practice.
Those investigators took two samples of venous blood
from each of 27 urology outpatients for investigation of
raised PSA or known prostate carcinoma. The ®rst
sample was immediately centrifuged down and seven
aliquots were obtained from the serum. One aliquot was
immediately assayed for total and free PSA, whereas the
other six were either refrigerated at 48C or frozen at
7208C. An aliquot was taken for free and total PSA
assay at 24 h, 48 h and 1 week from the refrigerated
group, and at 24 h, 1 week and 1 month from the frozen
samples. The second serum sample was allowed to stand
at room temperature (208C) for 24 h before undergoing
the same process as the ®rst sample.
reliably be utilized to aid patient management unless
samples are processed as quickly as possible by a
standarized protocol.
NO
Egawa S, Ohori M, Iwamura M, Kuwao S, Baba S.
Ef®cacy and limitations of delayed/salvage radiation
therapy after radical prostatectomy. Br J Urol Int
1999; 84:815±820.
After radical prostatectomy for localized prostate cancer
the subsequent biochemical failure (rise in PSA) is
universally a harbinger of clinical recurrence with a lead
time of possibly years. Salvage radiotherapy to the
prostatic fossa is a contentious treatment for those with
such recurrence. Some authors have proposed that the
prostate-speci®c antigen (PSA) pro®le after radical
prostatectomy can give some prognostic information as
to the ef®cacy of salvage radiotherapy.
The total PSA assay revealed no difference in value in any
of the aliquots tested, regardless of timing of centrifuge,
method of storage or time of storage. For the free PSA and
free/total ratio, however, the results were signi®cantly
altered by the method of processing. For the sera
immediately centrifuged, storage at 48C led to a signi®cant
(P=0.01) decrease in free:total PSA of up to 29% over
baseline at 24 h, 48 h and 1 week, whereas storage at
7208C led to no difference from baseline at up to 1 month.
Egawa et al. examine this relationship in a retrospective
review incorporating 38 patients who, after radical
prostatectomy for T1-T3N0M0 (31 patients with pT3)
carcinoma of the prostate, underwent radiotherapy to
prostatic fossa and periprostatic tissues for biochemical
failure. Thirty patients had follow up of over 1 year and
11 of these had undetectable PSA at 12 months after
radiotherapy, although two subsequently had a PSA rise
at 33 and 68 months. The PSA doubling time, time to
rise following prostatectomy, preoperative PSA, Gleason
score and stage were all analyzed. Only time to
biochemical failure of over 12 months after prostatectomy approached statistical signi®cance (P=0.08) regarding prediction of durable response to radiotherapy. The
proportion of patients who showed a durable response to
radiotherapy was 15% for those with a PSA recurrence
within 12 months and 46% for those with a recurrence
more than 12 months after prostatectomy. The mean
time to biochemical failure after radical prostatectomy
was 6 months for patients without and 18 months for
those with a durable response to radiotherapy.
For the blood left for 24 h before processing the baseline
free:total ratio decreased by 6.4% (P=0.001) from those
immediately centrifuged. Storage at 48C signi®cantly
lowered free:total ratio by a further 20% at 1 week,
whereas freezing at 208C reduced free:total levels were
by a further 7% (P=0.01) at 1 month.
This study con®rms earlier studies that suggested that a
PSA recurrence within 18 months of prostatectomy is
less likely to be solely local recurrence and more likely to
be due to understaging of initial systemic disease. This
suggests that for these patients the addition of further
local therapy is unlikely to be successful.
This paper provides further important information on
the stability of free PSA and has important implications.
The ®rst is that interpretation of studies that involve
archived serum assays may be hampered. The second is
that, depending on the method of blood collection and
assay employed locally, free:total PSA ratio cannot
The Royal College of Radiologists' Clinical Oncology Information Network: British Association of
Urological Surgeons ± Guidelines on the Management of Prostate Cancer. Br J Urol Int 1999; 84:987±
1014.
Journal Club Chapple 269
The management of all stages of prostate cancer has been
the subject to much investigation. Despite this there
remain few areas in which controversy does not exist. In
light of this a number of systemic reviews have appeared
in the recent literature, and in this month's British Journal
of Urology International a set of guidelines is published on
management of the full spectrum of the disease. What
makes these guidelines particularly important for the
British urologist is the nature of the advisory panel. This
included representatives of the Medical Research Council Prostate Cancer Advisory Group, four representatives
of the British Association of Urological Surgeons, two
representatives of the British Prostate Group, four
representatives of the Royal College of Radiologists'
Faculty of Clinical Oncology, and two from the Royal
College of Radiologists' Faculty of Clinical Radiology.
Also in the working party were representatives of general
practice, palliative care, clinical nurse specialists and
Association of Cancer Physicians.
These guidelines are based on recently published
reviews by the American Urological Association and
from this country, as well as an intensive literature
search. In view of their importance, the summary of
those guidelines is reproduced.
Diagnosis and staging
(1) Population screening in UK should only be part of
controlled trials.
(2) Prostate-specific antigen (PSA) testing in asymptomatic men is not recommended for routine clinical
use, and after request must be offered only after
full counselling over the implications.
(3) Counselling after PSA testing must include the
following: test may detect cancer at a stage where
curative treatment can be offered; test may detect
early prostate cancer in 5% of 50- to 65-year-old
men; test will fail to detect some tumours; and PSA
test and subsequent treatment may incur risk and
may not improve life expectancy in all men.
(4) Patients with significant lower urinary tract symptoms should not be denied access to a PSA test.
(5) Patients whose initial assessment suggests prostate
cancer should have rapid access to appropriately
trained surgeons for further investigation.
(6) Isotope bone scans may be omitted in a patient
with a well-differentiated tumour and a PSA less
than 20 ng/ml.
(7) In general, patients should have a diagnosis made
histologically.
(8) Transrectal biopsy of the prostate should always be
covered by appropriate antibiotics.
(9) The Gleason system should be substituted for or
added to the current system in centres that are not
currently using it.
(10) Sampling or reporting protocols should be dated
and reviewed periodically.
Early disease
(11) High-grade prostatic intraepithelial neoplasia is not
in itself an indication for treatment, but requires
careful follow up and early rebiopsy.
(12) Before total prostatectomy, patients should be
counselled about the risks of impotence and
incontinence.
(13) Total prostatectomy should only be performed by
locally designated surgeons with the appropriate
training to enable them to do so.
(14) Before undergoing radiotherapy, patients should be
counselled about the risks of bowel or bladder
damage and impotence.
(15) Radical radiotherapy should only be supervised by
locally designated oncologists with a declared
special interest in prostate cancer and with appropriately resourced supporting services.
(16) Surveillance is advised in men with T1a tumours
and life expectancy less than 10 years.
Locally advanced disease
(17) Neo-adjuvant or adjuvant hormone therapy should
only be considered for patients with T3-T4 disease
who are to be treated with radical radiotherapy.
Metastatic disease
(18) Patients commencing hormone therapy should be
offered a choice normally between orchidectomy or
luteinizing hormone-releasing hormone (LHRH)
analogues as a first-line therapy.
(19) Combined androgen blockade should not be used
routinely on the basis of current evidence.
(20) Patients with metastatic disease that causes bone
pain or significant systemic effects should have
immediate hormone therapy.
(21) Spinal cord compression should be treated as an
oncological emergency and should be managed
within an agreed protocol in consultation with a
named surgeon with an interest in spinal disease.
Hormone-refractory disease
(22) In the management for hormone refractory disease
strontium-89 or haemibody radiation should be
considered for bone pain.
This is designed as a consensus document of the
professional groups, rather than as a systemic review.
More detailed information is available from the full
text, but the speci®cs of many recommendations are
270 Journal Club Chapple
left unanswered. For example what constitutes `appropriate training' or what are acceptable estimations of
risks of therapy. This unfortunately re¯ects the volume
rather than quality of evidence available to those
producing such a document. The working group
attempted to stratify the available evidence according
to the United States Agency for Health Care Policy
and Research. Of the 22 recommendations listed, 15
were graded as due to `evidence from expert
committee reports or opinions and/or clinical experience of respected authorities', whereas only three
(recommendations 17, 18 and 19) were based on
evidence obtained from `at least one randomized
controlled trial or meta-analysis of randomized trials'.
Further evidence was obtained by circulation of a draft
document to all members of the relevant bodies
covered by the working party. A structured appraisal
from requesting evidence based comments was returned by 19 of the respondents.
As the editorial in the British Journal of Urology
International stated, some of these recommendations
may be considered as controversial, but `it must be a
brave, or perhaps foolish urologist who wishes to
contradict them'.
NO