Histone-induced damage of a mammalian epithelium:
the role of protein and membrane structure
TERI J. KLEINE,1 PETER N. LEWIS,2 AND SIMON A. LEWIS1
of Physiology and Biophysics, University of Texas Medical Branch, Galveston, Texas
77555; and 2Department of Biochemistry, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada M5S 1A8
1Department
Kleine, Teri J., Peter N. Lewis, and Simon A. Lewis.
Histone-induced damage of a mammalian epithelium: the
role of protein and membrane structure. Am. J. Physiol. 273
(Cell Physiol. 42): C1925–C1936, 1997.—In a previous report
[T. J. Kleine, A. Gladfelter, P. N. Lewis, and S. A. Lewis. Am.
J. Physiol. 268 (Cell Physiol. 37): C1114–C1125, 1995], we
found that the cationic DNA-binding proteins histones H4,
H1, and H5 caused a voltage-dependent increase in the
transepithelial conductance in rabbit urinary bladder epithelium. In this study, results from lipid bilayer experiments
suggest that histones H5-H1 and H4 form variably sized
conductive units. Purified fragments of histones H4 and H5
were used to determine the role of histone tertiary structure
in inducing conductance. Isolated COOH- and NH2-terminal
tails of histone H4, which are random coils, were inactive,
whereas the central a-helical domain induced a conductance
increase. Although the activities of the central fragment and
intact histone H4 were in many ways similar, the doseresponse relationships suggest that the isolated central domain was much less potent than intact histone H4. This
suggests than the NH2- and COOH-terminal tails are also
important for histone H4 activity. For histone H5, the isolated
globular central domain was inactive. Thus the random-coil
NH2- and COOH-terminal tails are important for H5 activity
as well. These results indicate that histone molecules interact
directly with membrane phospholipids to form a channel and
that protein tertiary structure and the degree of positive
charge play an important role in this activity.
tight epithelium; mammalian bladder; toxicity; ion permeability
CATIONIC PROTEINS (proteins with a net positive charge)
are known to be cytotoxic to eukaryotic cells as well as
to possess antimicrobial properties. Examples of such
cationic proteins are numerous and include protamine
sulfate, histones, major basic protein (MBP), and eosinophil peroxidase (EPO) (6, 7, 13, 19). Although histones
are normally contained within the nucleus of the cell,
conditions such as cell death and lysis cause the release
of histones from the cell. Purified histones have been
found to increase cell membrane permeability to small
monovalent cations and anions, and it has been proposed that this increase in membrane permeability
leads to cell swelling and ultimately cell lysis (7). Thus
the release of histones may be pathologically important
in conditions of significant cell death, such as that
which occurs during the breakdown of sperm. In this
regard, Mendizabal and Naftalin (12) demonstrated
that human semen was toxic to rat colonic mucosa,
resulting in a focal loss of epithelial cells (i.e., a loss of
the local barrier function of the colon). In addition,
some patients with diabetes mellitus suffer from retrograde ejaculation (a painful disorder), which results in
the delivery of semen into the lumen of the bladder.
Given the cytotoxic nature of histones on the bladder
epithelium, the pain resulting from retrograde ejaculation might be caused by the loss of bladder barrier
function, allowing ready access of urine to underlying
sensory neurons.
The membrane conductances induced by histone
share a number of properties with protamine, MBP
(unpublished observations), and EPO (unpublished observations), including voltage dependence and reversal
by calcium, suggesting a common mechanism among
these proteins. Thus the effects of histone on membrane
permeability are of interest not only because of a
potential pathological role of histones on disruption of
the barrier function of colonic and bladder epithelia but
also as a model for the mechanism of action of other
cationic proteins.
In a previous report (7), it was demonstrated that
histones H1, H4, and H5 increase apical membrane
permeability in rabbit urinary bladder epithelium,
which ultimately led to cytotoxicity. The permeabilities
were characterized in terms of the dose-response relationship, voltage dependence, ion selectivity, and reversibility. However, it was unclear whether histone was
forming a channel in the cell membrane or was instead
increasing activity of a native membrane channel.
Other questions posed by this earlier study involve
defining the structures of the histone molecule that
participate in activity. Histones H4 and H5 are two
similar yet structurally distinct cationic DNA-binding
proteins (Table 1). Both have two random-coil tails that
flank a central domain. This central domain of H4
contains an a-helical region that spans amino acids
55–67 (3). A second span from 70–90 has been demonstrated to be a-helical when histone H4 is associated
with the nucleosome but not when purified histone H4
polymerizes in solution (8). In contrast, the central
domain of histone H5 is globular (2). Another structural
difference between histones H4 and H5 is that the
COOH-terminal tails of histone H4 can associate into
b-sheets to form high-molecular-weight aggregates (8).
Although both histone H5 and the isolated globular
domain have been shown to self-associate under certain
conditions (11), significant aggregation of intact H5 in
solution does not occur.
In this report, the following questions are addressed.
1) Do histones induce the formation of a channel? and
2) What are the active domain(s) of the histone molecule? The data presented in this study suggest that
histones interact with phospholipids to induce the
formation of a channel. In addition, the central fragment of histone H4 (amino acids 25–67) is important
for channel formation, whereas the random-coil tails
are important in potentiating the activity of the channel-
0363-6143/97 $5.00 Copyright r 1997 the American Physiological Society
Downloaded from journals.physiology.org/journal/ajpcell (052.090.062.141) on January 12, 2022.
C1925
C1926
HISTONE DAMAGES A MAMMALIAN EPITHELIUM
Table 1. Characteristics of histones H4
and H5 and their fragments
Protein
Amino
Acids
Basic
Amino
Acids
Positive
Charge, %
Acidic
Amino
Acids
Mol
Wt
Histone H4
NH2-tail
a-Helix
COOH-tail 1
COOH-tail 2
Histone H5
Globular H5
1–102
1–23
25–67
69–102
86–102
1–190
22–102
23
8
10
6
3
66
16
22.5
33.3
23.3
17.6
17.6
34.6
19.7
7
0
3
2
0
5
4
11,300
2,366
4,696
4,003
1,886
20,900
8,900
No. of positive charges includes all arginine and unmethylated
lysine residues. Negatively charged amino acids include glutamic
acid and aspartic acid. Data on histone H4 fragments are from a
previously published report by Lewis et al. (8).
with nitrogen gas, and the lipids were resuspended in decane.
Bilayer formation has been described previously (5). The
lipids were painted across a 100–200 µM aperture of a Delrin
cup until a bilayer with a capacitance of 200–500 pF was
formed. Experiments were performed in symmetric 150 mM
KCl in twice-distilled water at room temperature. Histone
was added to the solution in the cis-chamber, and the
trans-chamber was defined as a ground. The solutions in both
chambers were stirred with magnetic stirring bars.
Voltage was passed, and the resulting current (I) was
measured via Ag-AgCl electrodes connected to a bilayer
voltage clamp (5). These were continuously monitored on an
oscilloscope as well as passed through a pulse-code modulator
(Sony) and recorded on videotape. The data were subsequently digitized and analyzed using pClamp 6.0 (Axon
Instruments).
Transepithelial Voltage Clamping Experiments
forming domains. For histone H5, the isolated central
globular domain was inactive, demonstrating the importance of the random-coil tails for the conductive activity
of histone H5.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Purification of Histones and Histone Fragments
Purification of histones H4 (mol wt 11,294) and H5 (mol wt
20,900) has been described previously (8, 9). In brief, histones
were separated from chicken erythrocytes by gel filtration
using a Bio-Gel P-10 column (150 3 2.7 cm) eluted with 0.02
M HCl. Fractions contained purified H4 and an H5-H1 (4:1)
mixture. H5 was separated from H1 by ion-exchange chromatography. Histones were recovered from concentrated column
fractions by precipitation with acidified acetone (0.1% HCl)
and then washed with acetone and dried under a vacuum.
Production of histone H4 fragments has been described
previously (8). Intact H4 was cleaved at three aspartic acid
residues (amino acids 24, 68, and 85) as follows. Briefly, H4
was dissolved in 0.25 M acetic acid and heated for 6 h at
105°C. The mixture was then fractionated on a Sephadex
G-50 column (150 3 2.7 cm) and eluted with 0.02 M HCl.
Eluted fractions were monitored at 200 nm and were appropriately pooled. The pooled fractions were then dialyzed against
absolute ethanol, and 10 volumes of acidified acetone (0.1%
HCl) were then added to precipitate the peptides. The peptides were washed with dry acetone and dried under a
vacuum. Fragments 1–23 and 69–102 were separated by
preparative electrophoresis (20) using a Sephadex G-10 column (50 3 1.1 cm) with 0.05 M acetic acid buffer at 500 V (1.4
mA) for 3.5 h.
Purification of the globular domain of H5 has been previously described (2). First, histone H5 (20 mg/ml) was dissolved in 0.2 M K2SO4 and 50 mM tris(hydroxymethyl)aminomethane · HCl buffer, at pH 8. Next, trypsin was added
at an enzyme-to-substrate ratio of 1:1,000 at 20°C for 2 h. The
digestion was then quenched using 0.02% 1-chloro-3-tosylamido-7-amino-heptanone, and the globular H5 was isolated
using a Sephadex G-50 F column. The sample was then
dialyzed against 20 mM HCl and recovered by acetone
precipitation. All histones were dissolved in distilled, deionized water to make concentrated stock solutions, which were
stored at 0°C.
Bilayer Experiments
All phospholipids were purchased in chloroform from Avanti
Polar Lipids (Alabaster, AL). The chloroform was evaporated
Tissue preparation. Urinary bladders were excised from
3-kg male New Zealand White rabbits and were washed in
NaCl Ringer (see Solutions below). The smooth muscle was
dissected away, and the epithelium was mounted on a ring of
2 cm2 exposed area. The ring was transferred to a temperaturecontrolled, modified Ussing chamber (10) where the serosal
side of the epithelium was held against a nylon mesh by a
slight excess of solution in the mucosal chamber. Both the
mucosal and serosal chambers initially held a bathing solution of NaCl Ringer and were aerated with 95% O2-5% CO2
while integral water jackets maintained the temperature of
the bathing solution at 37°C. The mucosal chamber was
modified to reduce the volume to 4.5 ml (the serosal chamber
volume was 15 ml). This was done to minimize the amount of
protein used in the experiments. The serosal chamber was
stirred by a magnetic spin bar at the bottom of the chamber
while the mucosal chamber was stirred by adding the 95%
O2-5% CO2 at the bottom of the chamber and allowing it to
bubble upward.
Solutions. NaCl Ringer contains (in mM) 111.2 NaCl, 25
NaHCO3, 10 glucose, 5.8 KCl, 2.0 CaCl2, 1.2 KH2PO4, and 1.2
MgSO4. In KCl Ringer, all Na1 salts were substituted with
the appropriate K1 salts. Unless otherwise noted, all experiments with histones and histone fragments were performed
using KCl Ringer as the mucosal bathing solution. Histones,
histone fragments, and amino acid heteropolymers were
suspended in distilled H2O as a stock solution that was added
in microliter quantities to the mucosal solution. Poly(Lys-Ala)
1:1 and poly(D-Glu-D-Lys) 6:4 were purchased from Sigma (St.
Louis, MO).
Transepithelial Electrophysiological Methods
Electrical measurements. All electrical measurements were
made under voltage clamp conditions unless otherwise noted.
The transepithelial voltage (Vt ) was measured with Ag-AgCl
wires placed adjacent to either side of the epithelium (serosal
solution ground) while I was passed from Ag-AgCl electrodes
placed in the rear of each hemichamber. Both sets of electrodes were connected to an automatic voltage clamp (Warner
Instruments). Transepithelial resistance and its inverse,
transepithelial conductance (Gt ), were calculated using Ohm’s
law from I required to clamp the epithelium 10 mV from the
holding voltage under voltage clamp conditions.
Data acquisition. I and voltage outputs of the voltage
clamp were connected to an analog-to-digital converter (Axon
Instruments) interfaced with a computer that calculated
values for resistance and short-circuit current (Isc ). Vt and I
were continuously monitored on an oscilloscope. All data were
Downloaded from journals.physiology.org/journal/ajpcell (052.090.062.141) on January 12, 2022.
HISTONE DAMAGES A MAMMALIAN EPITHELIUM
C1927
This plot is linear if the added protein changes only the cell
resistance when Vt is clamped to 0 mV. The y-intercept of the
line will be equal to the junctional conductance (Gj ), and the
slope will be the inverse of the cellular electromotive force
(Ec ), which is the sum of the apical and basolateral membrane
equivalent batteries.
Current-voltage relationship. The steady-state difference
current-voltage (I-V) relationship of the protein-induced conductance was calculated using the method of Tzan et al. (19).
This method involves measuring the transepithelial I-V relationships in both the absence and the presence of added
protein; the difference between these two relationships is the
voltage dependence of I flowing through the protein-induced
conductance. First, the tissue was voltage clamped to Vt 5 0
mV, and the transepithelial I responses to computergenerated voltage pulses 30 ms long and of increasing magnitude and alternating polarity were measured. Next, the
transepithelial potential was voltage clamped to 270 mV,
protein was added to the mucosal solution and equilibrated
for 3 min, and then the transepithelial potential was clamped
to 0 mV. The conductance was allowed to reach a steady state
before the I-V relationship was again measured. The difference between the I-V relationships in the presence and
absence of added protein was then fit by the constant-field
equation to determine the relative ionic permeabilities of the
protein-induced conductance.
Data analysis and statistics. Curve fitting was done on an
IBM-AT using NFIT (Island Products, Galveston, TX). Statistics were calculated using INSTAT (GraphPAD Software, San
Diego, CA). Data are shown as means 6 SE.
of phospholipid bilayers composed of a 5:3:2 ratio of
phosphatidylserine (PS), phosphatidylethanolamine
(PE), and phosphatidylcholine (PC) (wt/wt/wt). Voltage
was first held at 0 mV (trans-side ground) during an
equilibration period of several minutes and then was
clamped to either 2100 mV or 100 mV. At either
voltage, channels of variable sizes appeared (Fig. 1A).
When the voltage polarity was reversed, channels were
still evident. The all points histogram of the I tracing
demonstrates the variability in the magnitude of the
channels (Fig. 1B). In eight bilayers, the channel
conductances ranged in size from 4 to 20 pS. H5-H1
(185 nM) was also tested on bilayers composed of only
PE. Channel activity was observed at both 1100 mV
and 2100 mV (data not shown). However, in contrast to
the PS:PE:PC bilayers, only single-channel events with
a low probability of opening (0.036 6 0.005, n 5 4) were
observed in PE bilayers. This suggests that histones
have a stronger affinity for negatively-charged phospholipids, which results in increased channel activity.
Histone H4 (89 nM) was also added to bilayers
composed of a 5:3:2 ratio of PS:PE:PC. Channels of
variable sizes appeared at both 100 mV and 2100 mV
(Fig. 2A). In addition to distinct channel openings and
closings, there were sporadic increases in noise that
could have been the result of channels flickering open
and closed. Because of this noisy channel activity, the
peaks in the all points histograms were broad and not
well resolved (Fig. 2B). Therefore, I amplitudes were
determined by measuring each distinct individual opening. The distinct channels were variable in size, ranging from 2 to 15 pS (53 distinct openings, n 5 2). In
another bilayer, after histone addition, several large
spikes (100–160 pS) appeared followed by breakdown
of the bilayer (not shown). These results suggest that
histone H4, like histone H5-H1, is capable of forming
channels of variable sizes in phospholipid bilayers.
RESULTS
Activity of the Histone Fragments
printed out with the time of data acquisition and were
additionally stored on hard disk.
Equivalent circuit analysis. The method of Yonath and
Civan (21) was used to differentiate between an increase in
the conductance of the cell membrane or tight junctions. Gt
(µS/cm2 ) was plotted as a function of Isc (in µA/cm2 ) when Vt 5
0 mV in the presence of added protein. This plot was then fit
by the equation
Gt 5 (Isc /Ec) 1 Gj
(1)
In this section, we first report the effects of purified
histones on phospholipid bilayers. Then the fragments
of histones H4 and H5 and their ability to induce an
increase in Gt in rabbit urinary bladder epithelium are
compared. Finally, the synthetic proteins poly(Lys-Ala)
and poly(Glu-Lys) are tested to determine the role of
negatively-charged amino acids.
Histones Induce a Conductance in Bilayers
In previous reports of the conductive effect of histones on rabbit urinary bladder epithelium, it was
unclear whether histones were directly inducing channel formation or whether they were indirectly affecting
epithelial conductance, for example, by activating a
native membrane channel or a second messenger system which would in turn cause an increase in conductance (7). Therefore, purified histones were tested on
phospholipid bilayers.
First, a 4:1 mixture of histones H5 and H1 (H5-H1)
was tested on phospholipid bilayers. Histone H5-H1
(185 nM) was added to the solution bathing the cis-side
The activity of whole histones has previously been
described in rabbit urinary bladder epithelium (7). In
this report, the effects of the histone fragments are
tested to identify the active domains. The activity of the
fragments is characterized in terms of time course, dose
response, voltage sensitivity, ion selectivity, and site of
action. Differences between the activity of the histone
fragments and the intact histones are also described.
Unless otherwise noted, the mucosal solution was a
KCl Ringer in all histone and histone fragment experiments.
The effect of histone fragments on Gt of rabbit urinary
bladder epithelium. A previous report suggested that
histones induce a voltage-sensitive conductance in the
apical membrane of rabbit urinary bladder (7). In
urinary bladder epithelium, the apical membrane has a
high resistance to ion flux, whereas the basolateral
membrane is quite permeable to K1 and Cl2. Therefore,
the voltage across the apical membrane can be controlled by the transepithelial potential. The apical
membrane voltage (Va ) is calculated as the difference
between Vt and the basolateral membrane voltage (Vb ),
Downloaded from journals.physiology.org/journal/ajpcell (052.090.062.141) on January 12, 2022.
C1928
HISTONE DAMAGES A MAMMALIAN EPITHELIUM
Fig. 1. Histone-induced variably sized channels in
phospholipid bilayers. A: current (I) trace demonstrating channel activity of histone H5-H1 in phospholipid bilayer. Bilayer was composed of 5:3:2 ratio
of phosphatidylserine (PS), phosphatidylethanolamine (PE), and phosphatidylcholine (PC). Histone
H5-H1 (186 nM) was added to cis-chamber, with
bilayer voltage clamped to 0 mV (trans-side ground),
and then solution was stirred (not shown). Next
voltage was clamped to 100 mV. Solution was symmetric 150 mM KCl. Data were filtered at 30 Hz,
amplified by a factor of 10, and sampled at 120 Hz.
Solid horizontal line indicates I at 0 mV. B: all points
histogram for I trace. Data have been corrected for
baseline I. Tallest peak corresponds to baseline.
Histogram is shown fitted using Marquardt’s least
squares fitting algorithm. Best fit peaks were at DI of
0, 0.4, 0.6, and 1.0 pA.
which is relatively constant at 255 mV [as previously
determined using microelectrodes (10)]. For example,
when Vt is clamped at 270 mV (serosa ground), Vb is
255 mV, and therefore Va is 115 mV relative to the
mucosal solution. If Vt is clamped to 0 mV, the apical
membrane cell potential is 255 mV. Under normal
conditions, Gt of the rabbit urinary bladder epithelium
displayed little or no voltage sensitivity. However,
when either histone H1, H4, or H5 was added to the
mucosal solution, there was a rapid, voltage-sensitive
increase in Gt when Vt was clamped from 270 mV to 0
mV (7). All three of the histones induced an increase in
Gt only when the voltage gradient across the apical
membrane was cell interior negative.
To identify the histone domains responsible for inducing this voltage-sensitive increase in Gt, five fragments
of histones H4 and H5 were tested. The four histone H4
fragments were as follows: a portion of the NH2terminal tail (amino acids 1–23), the remainder of the
NH2-terminal tail connected with an a-helical portion
of the central domain (25–67), and two fragments from
the COOH-terminal tail (69–102 and 86–102). The
fifth fragment that was tested was the central globular
domain of histone H5-(22–102). A number of the physical characteristics of these fragments is summarized in
Table 1. These fragments were tested in the following
manner: first, protein was added to the mucosal bathing solution while Vt was clamped at 270 mV, allowed
to equilibrate for 3 min, and then clamped to 0 mV. The
isolated NH2- and COOH-terminal tails of H4 (fragments 1–23, 69–102, and 86–102) and the globular
domain of H5 (fragment 22–102) failed to induce a
conductance over a wide range of concentrations when
Vt was clamped to 0 mV (time course data not shown;
see Dose-response relationship). In contrast, the H4
a-helix fragment (25–67) induced an increase in Gt at
Vt 5 0 mV or when the apical membrane potential was
cell interior negative. The time course of the response
for the 850 nM histone fragment H4-(25–67) is shown
in Fig. 3. Data are shown fitted by the equation
DGt(t) 5 Gh(1 2 e2k h t)
(2)
where DGt(t) is the change in the transepithelial conductance as a function of time, normalized to the concentration of histone (µS · cm22 · µM21 ); Gh is the maximal
histone-induced conductance, normalized for concentration; and kh (unit of inverse seconds) is the rate
constant of the conductance change. This equation has
been previously demonstrated to describe the time
Downloaded from journals.physiology.org/journal/ajpcell (052.090.062.141) on January 12, 2022.
C1929
HISTONE DAMAGES A MAMMALIAN EPITHELIUM
Fig. 3. Time course of conductance change in rabbit urinary bladder
epithelium induced by H4 fragment 25–67. Histone H4 fragment
25–67 (850 nM) was added to mucosal solution at transepithelial
voltage (Vt ) of 270 mV and equilibrated for 3 min. Voltage was
clamped to 0 mV at time 0. Smooth curve is best fit of Eq. 2 to data.
Best fit value for fragment-induced conductance (Gh ) was 66
µS · cm22 · µM21 and rate constant (k) was 0.09 s21. Mucosal solution
was KCl Ringer, and serosal solution was NaCl Ringer. Gt, transepithelial conductance.
Fig. 2. Histone H4-induced channels in bilayers. A: histone H4 (89
nM) was added to cis-chamber while voltage was held at 0 mV
(trans-side ground), solution was stirred, and then voltage was
clamped to indicated voltages. At both 100 mV and 2100 mV, 2
different activities were evident. One was a sporadic increase in
noise, which may be a channel flickering open and closed. Also
evident were longer openings of various magnitudes. Data were
filtered at 100 Hz, amplified by a factor of 10, and sampled at 500 Hz.
I at 0 mV is indicated by solid horizontal line. Bilayer was 5:3:2 ratio
of PS, PE, and PC. Solution was symmetric 150 mM KCl. B: all points
histogram of H4-induced channel activity at 100 mV. Data have been
corrected for baseline I. Histogram was generated from I trace at 100
mV using Fetchan (pClamp 6.0).
course of the conductance change induced by intact
histones H1, H4, and H5 (7). Thus the H4-(25–67)
fragment induces a voltage-sensitive increase in Gt
that follows a time course similar to intact histone H4.
To determine if loss of the NH2- and COOH-terminal
tails resulted in a change in either the potency or the
speed of the conductance increase, the magnitude (Gh )
and the rate constant (k) of the induced conductances
for H4-(25–67) and intact histone H4 were compared.
As shown in Table 2, the H4-(25–67)-induced conductance was significantly smaller than that of intact H4
on a micromolar basis. The rate constant was also
markedly slower for H4-(25–67). Thus the loss of the
NH2- and COOH-terminal tails resulted in a reduction
of histone H4 activity.
Dose-response relationship. The dose-response relationship also indicated that the histone fragment H4(25–67) was much less potent than intact H4. The
magnitude of the induced conductance was determined
as a function of concentration for both the fragments
and intact histone H4 (Fig. 4). The H4 fragments
(1–23), (69–102), and (86–102) did not alter Gt at any of
the tested concentrations. The globular domain of H5
also did not elicit a response for concentrations ranging
from 102 to 3,700 nM (3 tissues, data not shown). In
contrast, the magnitude of the conductance increased
as a function of protein concentration for both H4-(25–
67) and intact histone H4. The shape of the doseresponse relationship for the H4-(25–67) fragment is
sigmoidal. Such a sigmoidal relationship possibly suggests that several molecules of the fragment combine to
induce a conductance. This is in contrast to the dose
response of intact histone H4, which is hyperbolic.
The dose-response relationships were normalized to
minimize tissue variability. For the fragment, conductance was normalized to the conductance induced by
426 nM fragment (21 6 5 µS/cm2, n 5 9). For H4,
conductance was first normalized to the conductance
Table 2. Comparison of histone H4
and H4(25–67)-induced conductance
Protein
n
kh , s21
Gh , µS · cm22 · µM21
H4-(25–67)
Histone H4
7
31
0.03 6 0.007
0.21 6 0.03
71 6 20
1,270 6 150
Values are means 6 SE; n 5 no. of experiments. Comparison of rate
constant (kh ) and magnitude (Gh ) of conductance induced by intact
histone H4 and H4 fragment (25–67). Both kh and the Gh induced by
H4-(25–67) are significantly different from that of intact H4
(P , 0.0001, Welch’s t-test). Values were calculated by fitting time
courses of conductance induced by 89 nM intact histone H4 or 426 nM
H4-(25–67) by Eq. 2.
Downloaded from journals.physiology.org/journal/ajpcell (052.090.062.141) on January 12, 2022.
C1930
HISTONE DAMAGES A MAMMALIAN EPITHELIUM
voltage than intact histone H4. After protein addition
and equilibration, the tissue was clamped to various Vt
and the magnitude and rate constant were measured at
each voltage. As shown in Fig. 5, A and B, both the
magnitude and the rate constant were exponential
functions of the transepithelial (and apical) membrane
voltage. Values were normalized to the conductance
change or rate constant measured at 0 mV to correct for
tissue variability.
To determine the steepness of the voltage sensitivity
for both the magnitude and the rate constant, the data
were fit by the following equation
Fig. 4. Dose-response relationships for histone H4 fragments and
intact histone H4. Varying amounts of protein were added to mucosal
solution at Vt 5 270 mV and equilibrated, and then Vt was clamped
to 0 mV. Time courses of conductance responses were then fitted by
Eq. 2 to determine values for Gh. There was no change of conductance
for fragments H4-(1–23) (3 tissues, s), H4-(69–102) (4 tissues, k), or
H4-(86–102) (1 tissue, q). For fragment H4-(25–67) (n) and intact
histone H4 (r), magnitude of conductance change increased as
function of protein concentration, although fragment was much less
potent than intact histone H4. For fragment, data from 7 tissues were
normalized to magnitude of conductance change elicited by 426 nM
H4-(25–67) (21 6 5 µS/cm2, n 5 9). For intact histone H4, data from
14 tissues were normalized to change at 89 nM H4 (96 6 9 µS/cm2,
n 5 32) and then again normalized to ratio of maximum increase in
transepithelial conductance (Gmax ) for intact histone H4 to Gmax for
fragment. When fit by Hill equation, best fit values for H4-(25–67)
were: Gmax, 3.47 times conductance change at 426 nM, or 73 µS/cm2;
Km, 567 nM; and Hill coefficient (nH ), 2.73 (n 5 9). For intact histone
H4, Gmax was 3.9 times the conductance induced by 89 nM H4, or 374
µS/cm2, and Km was 348 nM (n 5 32).
induced by 89 nM H4 (96 6 9 µS/cm2, n 5 32) to
minimize tissue variability. The conductances for H4
were then normalized to the ratio of the best fit values
for maximum conductance change (Gmax ) for intact H4
and H4-(25–67) so that the conductances induced by
these proteins could be compared. When fit by the Hill
equation, the Gmax for the fragment was 73 µS/cm2 (or
3.47 times greater than the conductance change induced by 426 nM of the fragment), the Michaelis
constant (Km ) was 567 nM, and the Hill coefficient (nH )
was 2.73, suggesting that three fragments are necessary to form a conductive unit (n 5 9). For intact H4,
Gmax was 374 µS/cm2 (or 3.9 times the conductance
induced by 89 nM H4), Km was 348 nM (n 5 32), and nH
was 1. The large decrease in both Gmax and Km for the
fragment in comparison with intact H4 suggests a
decrease in the number of binding sites and in the
binding affinity of the fragment.
The rate constant of the fragment-induced conductance change was independent of the bath concentration of the fragment. When the fragment concentration
was doubled from 426 nM to 852 nM, there was no
significant change in the rate constant (P 5 0.9, n 5 4,
data not shown). In contrast, for intact histone H4, it
has been shown that the rate constant was weakly
dependent on histone concentration (7).
Voltage sensitivity. Both the magnitude and the rate
constant of the H4-(25–67)-induced conductance increased as a function of the applied voltage. In addition,
the H4 fragment was more sensitive to the applied
Gt(V) 5 G(0)eeNVt /kT
(3)
where G(0) is the conductance change (µS/cm2 ) at 0 mV
(or alternatively, the rate constant at 0 mV), Gt(V)
(µS/cm2 ) is the total conductance change (or rate constant) at a particular voltage, N is an empirical constant that indicates the degree of voltage sensitivity, Vt
is the transepithelial voltage (mV), e is the electron
charge (1.602 3 10219 C), k is the Boltzmann constant
(1.38 3 10223 J/K), and T is temperature (310 K). For
the magnitude of the conductance change, N was 1.5 for
the histone fragment and 0.99 for intact histone H4.
This suggests that the magnitude of the conductance
induced by the H4-(25–67) fragment was more steeply
a function of membrane voltage than that induced by
the intact H4 molecule.
The rate constant for H4-(25–67) was also voltage
sensitive, although it was not as strongly affected by
voltage as the magnitude of the conductance change.
The best-fit value for N for H4-(25–67) was 0.85 (n 5 7,
4 tissues). This is in contrast to intact histone H4, for
which the rate constant was shown to be independent of
voltage (7).
Site of action. Previously, it has been shown that
intact histone H4 predominantly affects the apical,
rather than junctional or basolateral, membrane permeability. To determine if the central helical domain has
the same site of action, the method of Yonath and Civan
(21) was used (see MATERIALS AND METHODS ). While Vt
was clamped to 0 mV, the changes in conductance (Gt )
and Isc were monitored. Changes in Gt can occur at
three sites: the apical membrane, basolateral membrane, or tight junctions. If the protein-induced conductance increases as a linear function of Isc (see Eq. 1),
this suggests that only the cellular conductance (apical
and/or basolateral membrane conductance) was increased by histones. The best fit values to Eq. 1 for the
fragment are Ec 5 260 6 3 mV and Gj5 28 6 6 µS/cm2
(n 5 6). As shown in Fig. 6, the relationship between
the change in Gt and the change in Isc was linear for the
a-helical fragment, with a slope similar to that of intact
histone H4. This suggests that the fragment acts on the
apical membrane and that removal of the tails does not
alter the specificity of the site of action.
Ion selectivity. The H4-(25–67)-induced conductance
was nonselective for K1 and Cl2. The ion selectivity was
determined from the steady-state difference I-V relationship (see MATERIALS AND METHODS ). An example of this
Downloaded from journals.physiology.org/journal/ajpcell (052.090.062.141) on January 12, 2022.
HISTONE DAMAGES A MAMMALIAN EPITHELIUM
C1931
Fig. 6. Histone H4 and isolated central domain have same site of
action. This was determined from a plot of Gt vs. short-circuit current
(Isc ). Linear relationships suggest an increase in conductance of cell
membrane rather than tight junction. Data are shown fitted by Eq. 1.
Best fit values for intact histone H4 (r): junctional conductance (Gj ),
25 µS/cm2; cellular electromotive force (Ec ), 265 mV. Best fit values
for H4-(25–67) fragment (n): Gj, 61 µS/cm2; Ec, 256 mV.
relationship, which was linear, is shown in Fig. 7. The
data were fit by the constant-field equation to determine the K1 and Cl2 permeabilities. For 426 nM
H4-(25–67), the best fit value for the K1 permeability
was 3.6 6 1.2 3 1028 cm/s (n 5 4), and the ratio of Cl2 to
K1 permeability (PCl/PK ) was 0.8 6 0.2 (n 5 4), indicating that the fragment-induced conductance was nonselective for these two ions. This is in agreement with the
I-V relationship for intact histone H4 and suggests that
the ion specificity of the induced conductance is conferred by the central helical domain.
Fig. 5. Voltage sensitivity of H4-(25–67) fragment. Protein was
added to mucosal solution at Vt 5 270 mV and allowed to equilibrate,
and then Vt was clamped to more positive potentials. Gh and k were
then determined using Eq. 2. Data were normalized to Gh and k at 0
mV. A: magnitude of H4-(25–67)-induced conductance was more
voltage sensitive than that of intact histone H4. Data from 4 tissues
for the fragment (n) and 13 tissues for H4 (r) were fitted by Eq. 3.
Best fit values for empirical constant indicating degree of voltage
sensitivity (N) for fragment and H4 were 1.5 and 0.99, respectively,
indicating that fragment has a steeper voltage dependence. Conductance change at 0 mV was 58 6 15 µS · cm22 · µM21 (n 5 11) for 426 nM
fragment and 1,210 6 153 µS · cm22 · µM21 (n 5 21) for 89 nM histone
H4. B: rate constant was voltage sensitive for H4-(25–67). Data from
4 tissues are shown fitted by Eq. 3; best fit value for N was 0.85. Rate
constant at 0 mV was 0.03 6 0.007 (n 5 7).
Fig. 7. Current-voltage (I-V) relationship of H4-(25–67) fragment.
This I-V relationship was generated by subtracting control I-V
relationship at 0 mV from I-V curve measured for steady-state
conductance induced by 640 nM histone fragment at 0 mV in KCl
Ringer. Data were then fitted by constant-field equation to determine
K1 and Cl2 permeabilities (see MATERIALS AND METHODS ).
Downloaded from journals.physiology.org/journal/ajpcell (052.090.062.141) on January 12, 2022.
C1932
HISTONE DAMAGES A MAMMALIAN EPITHELIUM
the time for the induced conductance to reverse 90%
was measured. For the fragment, the average reversal
time was 147 6 14 s (n 5 10). This value is very similar
to the 90% reversal time of intact H4, which was
reported to be 145 s (7). Thus loss of the tails did not
affect the rate of reversal of the induced conductance at
270 mV.
Role of Acidic Amino Acids
Fig. 8. Voltage-induced reversal of H4-(25–67) conductance. After
fragment-induced increase in Gt had reached a plateau at Vt 5 0 mV,
voltage was reversed to 270 mV (time 0). This resulted in a large,
rapid increase in Gt followed by a biphasic decrease. Smooth curve
through data is best fitted by a double exponential equation modeling
reversal as 2 conductances in parallel. Best fit values: Gr, 18 µS/cm2;
kr, 0.08 s21; Gs, 34 µS/cm2; ks, 0.01 s21 where subscripts r and s are
rapid and slow, respectively.
Reversibility of the induced conductance. Previously,
it has been demonstrated that the intact histone H4induced conductance can be reversed be changing Vt
from 0 mV back to 270 mV (7). To determine if the loss
of the NH2- and COOH-terminal tails affected voltagedependent reversal, Vt was clamped back to 270 mV
after the fragment-induced conductance reached a plateau at 0 mV. The time course of the conductance
reversal is shown in Fig. 8. Note that the conductance
increased first before decreasing. This response was
observed in all of the voltage reversal experiments (n 5
20). The average increase was 31 6 3 µS/cm2. In
contrast, only 44% of the intact histone H4 voltage
reversals were reported to show this response (7). This
initial jump was hypothesized to result from the intact
histone H4 partitioning through the cell membrane
into the cytoplasm, where it would induce a conductance when the voltage gradient across the apical
membrane was cell interior positive. This was further
supported by the serosal addition of histone resulting
in an increase in apical membrane conductance, with
the opposite voltage polarity as mucosal histone, suggesting that histone entered the cell through the basolateral membrane rather than by crossing the tight
junctions and entering into the mucosal solution (7).
Because the initial jump was more frequent with the
H4-(25–67) than with intact histone H4, this suggests
that the fragment may partition through the membrane at Vt 5 0 mV more easily than intact histone H4.
After the initial jump, when clamping from 0 mV to
270 mV, the reversal of the H4-(25–67)-induced conductance followed the form of a double exponential, consistent with intact histone H4.
To determine if the loss of the COOH- and NH2terminal tails affected the rate of reversal at 270 mV,
As the fragment experiments demonstrate, the tertiary structure of histones is important for their conductive activity. It has been demonstrated that positively
charged amino acids located within the protein molecule are important as well (18). However, the role of
negatively charged amino acids within the protein
molecule has not been characterized. To determine the
role of acidic amino acids within the protein, two
synthetic molecules were tested: poly(Lys-Ala) 1:1 and
poly(D-Glu-D-Lys) 5.7:4.3. Both of these proteins had a
molecular weight that ranged from 20,000 to 50,000;
the average molecular weight was 41,600 for poly(LysAla) and 23,000 for poly(Glu-Lys), as determined by
viscosity measurements (Sigma). These proteins are
similar in that approximately one-half of each protein
is composed of cationic amino acids. However, they
differ in their net charge density. The charge density is
defined as the percentage of the total protein molecule
that is composed of similarly charged amino acids (18).
The net charge density is the difference between the
positive and negative charge densities of the protein.
Poly(Lys-Ala) had a net charge density of 50% positive
charge, whereas poly(Glu-Lys) had a net 14% negative
charge density.
The effect of poly(Lys-Ala) and poly(Glu-Lys) on Gt.
Each synthetic protein was tested on the urinary
bladder epithelium in the same manner as the histone
fragments; protein was added to the mucosal solution
while Vt was clamped at 270 mV and equilibrated for 3
min. Then Vt was clamped to 0 mV. Typical time courses
for each protein are shown in Fig. 9. Note that the
concentration of poly(Glu-Lys) was 24-fold higher than
poly(Lys-Ala).
The time course data for poly(Lys-Ala) were fitted by
a double exponential equation that assumes two conductive states in parallel
DGt(t) 5 Gp1(1 2 e2k1t) 1 Gp2(1 2 e2k2t)
(4)
where DGt(t) is the time-dependent change in the
transepithelial conductance, normalized to the concentration of added protein (µS · cm22 · µM21 ); Gp1 and Gp2
are the two protein-induced conductances, normalized
for concentration (µS · cm22 · µM21 ); t is time; and k1 and
k2 are the rate constants (inverse seconds) for entering
the respective conductance states. Best-fit values for 72
nM poly(Lys-Ala) are Gp1 5 700 6 180 µS · cm22 · µM21,
k1 5 1.0 6 0.2 s21, Gp2 5 4,100 6 750 µS · cm22 · µM21,
and k2 5 0.02 6 0.005 s21 (n 5 4).
In contrast, the time course for poly(Glu-Lys) was fit
by Eq. 2, which is a single exponential equation.
Downloaded from journals.physiology.org/journal/ajpcell (052.090.062.141) on January 12, 2022.
HISTONE DAMAGES A MAMMALIAN EPITHELIUM
C1933
phospholipid bilayers. The results suggest that histone
is capable of inducing channel formation and that this
activity is enhanced by the presence of anionic phospholipids in the membrane. The importance of histone
tertiary structure and the effect of negatively charged
amino acids within the protein molecule were explored
in an effort to elucidate the structural features of the
protein that contribute to activity.
Histone Channels and Membrane-Binding Sites
Fig. 9. Time course of effects of poly(Lys-Ala) (s) and poly(Glu-Lys)
(r) on Gt. Poly(Lys-Ala) (72 nM) or poly(Glu-Lys) (1,740 nM) was
added to mucosal solution at Vt 5 270 mV and allowed to equilibrate,
and at time 0, Vt was clamped to 0 mV. Smooth curves are best fits of
data by Eq. 2 for poly(Glu-Lys) and Eq. 4 for poly(Lys-Ala). Best fit
values for poly(Glu-Lys): Gh, 16 µS · cm22 · µM21; k, 0.15 s21. Best fit
values for poly(Lys-Ala): Gp1, 820 µS · cm22 · µM21; k1, 1.1 s21; Gp2,
4,900 µS · cm22 · µM21; k2, 0.01 s21; where Gp1 and Gp2 and k1 and k2
are protein-induced conductances and rate constants, respectively,
for 2 conductance states in parallel. Data were normalized for protein
concentration. Mucosal solution was KCl Ringer, and serosal solution
was NaCl Ringer.
The results of the phospholipid bilayer experiments
are important from two perspectives: first, because
channel activity occurred in the presence of histone,
this indicates that histone is capable of forming channels; second, the channel activity was increased in
anionic phospholipid-containing bilayers compared with
bilayers composed only of neutral phospholipids. This
suggests that anionic membrane-binding sites, although not required for histone activity, enhance channel formation. This is perhaps a result of the electrostatic interaction between histones and the anionic
phospholipid, resulting in an increased amount of
histone binding or greater stability of the histonephospholipid interaction. Histones have been reported
to preferentially bind to anionic phospholipids (16).
Purified histones were demonstrated to bind to the
anionic phospholipids cardiolipin and PS with high
avidity but not to the zwitterionic phospholipid PC.
Histone Fragments
Best-fit values for 1,740 nM poly(Glu-Lys) are Gh 5
18 6 6 µS · cm22 · µM21 and k 5 0.17 6 0.03 s21 (n 5 5).
The dose-response relationships. Poly(Lys-Ala) was
much more potent than poly(Glu-Lys), as indicated by
the dose-response relationship. The relationship between the magnitude of the conductance change and
the concentration of added protein was determined in
the same manner as described for the histone fragment
(see above). For poly(Lys-Ala), the time courses were fit
by Eq. 4, and Gp1 and Gp2 were added to determine the
total conductance change. As shown in Fig. 10, the
magnitude of the conductance induced by either protein increased as a function of protein concentration,
but poly(Lys-Ala) was much more potent than poly(GluLys). There are several possibilities to explain the
reduced activity by poly(Glu-Lys). One possibility is
that the net negative charge repels poly(Glu-Lys) from
an anionic binding site for cationic proteins. Another
explanation is that, by interacting electrostatically, the
acidic residue glutamic acid neutralizes the basic amino
acid lysine, which could result in loss of the voltage
sensitivity of the peptide. An alternative explanation is
that the poly(Glu-Lys) molecules electrostatically interact to form aggregates that are inactive.
The 25–67 fragment of histone H4 was capable of
increasing Gt in a manner similar to intact histone H4.
Both the fragment and H4 conductances displayed
comparable time courses, sites of action, voltage dependence, and ion selectivity. Because of the limited quantity of fragment available, the long-term toxicity was
DISCUSSION
In this paper, the components of both the cellular
membrane and the protein that are important for
conductive activity were examined. First, the identity
of the membrane-binding site and the ability of histone
to induce ion channel formation were explored using
Fig. 10. Dose-response relationships for both poly(Lys-Ala) and
poly(Glu-Lys). Magnitudes of conductance induced by proteins was
determined for a wide range of protein concentrations. For both
proteins, magnitude of conductance increased as a function of protein
concentration. Poly(Lys-Ala) (s) is much more potent than poly(GluLys) (r).
Downloaded from journals.physiology.org/journal/ajpcell (052.090.062.141) on January 12, 2022.
C1934
HISTONE DAMAGES A MAMMALIAN EPITHELIUM
not determined. Therefore, it is yet to be determined if
the fragment is able to induce the same degree of
toxicity as intact histone H4.
The conductive activity of the H4-(25–67) fragment
suggests that this fragment is important for channel
formation and may contain the channel-forming domain. Both the structure of this fragment and of intact
histone H4 has been described in detail (3, 8). Comparison of the structures may help explain the similarities
and differences in the activities of these two proteins.
With the use of fragments of histone H4, it has been
determined that the stretch of amino acids from 50 to
67 is critically involved in the formation of both the
a-helix and multimeric aggregates. The a-helix is composed of two sections, residues 55–67 and 70–90. The
helical wheel diagram of the helical portions of histone
H4 suggests that the stretch of amino acids involved in
helix formation and aggregation (amino acids 50–67) is
somewhat amphipathic in character (Fig. 11). The
hydrophilic amino acids are located on one side of the
helix, opposite to the majority of the hydrophobic amino
acids, making one side of the helix much more polar
than the rest of the helix. This suggests that histone H4
[and the H4-(25–67) fragment] may belong to a family
of amphipathic a-helical proteins that increase membrane permeability (4, 14, 15, 22). These proteins are
believed to aggregate into barrel-like structures, with
their outward-facing hydrophobic sides interacting with
the phospholipid bilayer, while the hydrophilic faces
line the channel. Further investigation is necessary to
determine if histone H4 behaves similarly.
When the H4-(25–67) fragment aggregates in solution, the portion of the H4-(25–67) fragment that is not
helical (residues 25–54) is incorporated into the aggregates rather than being free in solution. In contrast,
histone H4 has an additional stretch of NH2-terminal
tail (residues 1–24) that is highly cationic and is a
random coil in solution. The carboxyl tail of histone H4
is also a random coil but is not quite as cationic as the
amino tail; the COOH-terminal tail is important for the
formation of high-molecular weight aggregates by histone H4 (23).
Both histone H4 and the 25–67 fragment are each
long enough to span the cell membrane (.20 amino
acids); therefore, individual protein molecules may
form the conductive unit. In addition, both of these
proteins aggregate, and therefore channels might also
be formed by the polymerized proteins. Previous reports by Lewis et al. (8) indicate that these two proteins
aggregate differently. Both intact histone H4 and H4(25–67) rapidly aggregate along the a-helical residues
in a parallel fashion. Intact histone H4 then forms
high-molecular weight aggregates by slowly forming
b-sheets along the COOH-terminal tails. Fragment
H4-(25–67), in contrast, quickly forms b-sheets at the
NH2-terminal of the fragment (amino acids 25–34). The
fragment, however, is not able to form high-molecular
weight aggregates, because the COOH-terminal is required for this process (23).
There are a number of possible explanations for the
lower potency of the H4-(25–67) fragment. 1) The
Fig. 11. Helical wheel diagrams of a-helical portions of histone H4.
Hydrophobic residues are underlined. Charged residues are indicated in bold and marked with appropriate charge.
a-helical region from amino acids 70–90, which is
found in intact histone H4 but not in the fragment, may
contribute to the formation of a more stable membrane
channel. Studies suggest that increasing the length of
an amphipathic a-helix increases both channel formation in bilayers and toxicity in bacteria (1). 2) The NH2and/or the COOH-terminal tails of histone H4 are
important for membrane binding or for stabilizing the
conductance in the membrane. Loss of the tails would
then either make it more difficult for the fragment to
associate with the membrane or result in the fragment
dissociating from the membrane more easily. 3) The
b-structure of the fragment aggregates may impede
their ability to form a conductance. 4) The aggregation
of the COOH-terminal tails of intact histone H4 into
high-molecular-weight aggregates could lead to the
formation of larger channels than H4-(25–67), which
does not form high-molecular weight aggregates. 5) The
Downloaded from journals.physiology.org/journal/ajpcell (052.090.062.141) on January 12, 2022.
HISTONE DAMAGES A MAMMALIAN EPITHELIUM
fragment has a weaker voltage sensitivity than intact
H4. Preliminary analysis of washout experiments suggests that the rate constants at which both histone H4
and the fragment become nonconductive at 0 mV are
similar, whereas the rate constant of formation of the
conductance is much slower for the fragment compared
with intact H4. This suggests that the difference in the
dose-response relationships (i.e., the maximum conductance and binding affinity) is because of the fragment’s
slower rate constant for the formation of a conductance
than H4.
Interestingly, the central domain of histone H5 did
not induce a conductance. One possible explanation is
that the positively charged amino acids within this
central domain are not accessible to the membrane
surface and thus cannot associate with the cell membrane binding site. The three-dimensional structures of
both histone H5 and the isolated globular domain have
been described previously (2, 17). The central domain is
compact and is composed of three a-helical regions and
an anti-parallel b-sheet. This complex structure may
not be able to interact with the cell membrane because
of steric hindrance. The COOH-terminal of histone H5
is a long and highly charged random-coil tail. This tail
is composed of amino acids 103–190 and is 50% cationic. In contrast, the NH2-tail is small; it spans
residues 1–21 and is 29% cationic. These random-coil
tails, which have been removed from the purified
globular domain, may be necessary for membrane
binding of histone H5. Both histone H5 and its globular
domain have been reported to form high-molecular
weight aggregates (11). For globular H5, multimers
ranged from 2 to 14 monomers. It is as yet unclear
whether individual protein molecules or aggregates are
responsible for the conductive activity of histone H5.
It has been reported that histone H1 also increases
membrane permeability in rabbit urinary bladder epithelium (7). Histone H1 is structurally very similar to
histone H5, and histone H5 is regarded as an ‘‘extreme
variant’’ of histone H1 (17). They have similar molecular weights (21,000 for H5, 24,000 for H1) and similar
structures. Both have a central globular domain flanked
by random-coil tails (2). The major structural differences between these two proteins are that histone H5
contains more arginine and serine than histone H1 and
that histone H5 has a shorter NH2-terminal tail (21
amino acids compared with 35 amino acids for H1).
Histones H1 and H5 display another interesting difference; the globular domain of histone H1 does not form
aggregates as readily as the globular domain of histone
H5 (11). One might predict that, because of the structural similarities between H1 and H5, the isolated
central domain of histone H1 would be inactive.
Predicted Activity of the Histone Fragments
Based on Positive Charge
The model developed by Tzan et al. (18) is useful in
predicting the relationship between cationic charge
and induced conductance. The conductance induced by
cationic proteins increased as the square of both the
total number of cationic residues and the density of the
C1935
cationic charge within the protein molecule. This model
was developed using synthetic proteins that are composed of cationic and neutral amino acids and are
random coils in solution. With the use of this model and
histone H1 as a reference molecule, the magnitude of
the conductance change that would be induced solely on
the basis of positive charge can be predicted for the
histone fragments. The calculated values for the fragments indicate that they would be predicted to induce
an appreciable change in conductance at the concentrations used in the experiments. There are a number of
possible explanations for the lack of activity that was
demonstrated by these molecules. Some of the fragments may be too small to be active. For example, the
smallest fragment was 86–102, which is only 16 amino
acids long and therefore is not long enough to span the
cell membrane. The fragment 1–23 is predicted to be
the most active of the fragments based on charge but is
barely long enough to span the membrane and may not
be able to form a stable conductance.
Acidic Amino Acids
Addition of negatively charged molecules such as
DNA or pentosan polysulfate has been demonstrated to
decrease the conductive effect of histone (7), most likely
by an electrostatic interaction that neutralizes the
cationic charge of the histone. These data suggest that
negative charges within the protein molecule also are
inhibitory, although the mechanism of inhibition is
unclear.
The differences in the magnitude of the conductance
changes induced by poly(Lys-Ala) and poly(Glu-Lys)
are not a result of the difference in positive charge
between the two molecules. The model developed by
Tzan et al. (18) was also used to predict the magnitude
of the conductance change that would be induced by
both poly(Lys-Ala) and poly(Glu-Lys). Poly(Lys-Ala) is
about as active as predicted, whereas poly(Glu-Lys) is
much less active than predicted on the basis of its
positive charge. This deviation by poly(Glu-Lys) suggests that the negative charge is reducing the ability to
induce a conductance. However, the ability to induce a
conductance was not entirely abolished by the net
negative charge of the molecule. One possible explanation is that because the synthetic proteins are made by
a random distribution of amino acids, they are therefore a heterogeneous mixture of proteins with an
average ratio of 6:4 glutamic acid to lysine. A certain
percentage of the poly(Glu-Lys) will have a higher
concentration of positive charge (and an equivalent
amount will have a lower proportion of positive charge).
The portion with the higher degree of cationic charge
might have a sufficient amount of positive charge so
that the net charge on the protein molecule is positive.
A net positive charge might then result in the protein
being able to induce a conductance.
Summary
These results indicate that histone is capable of
forming a conductive unit and identify the central
Downloaded from journals.physiology.org/journal/ajpcell (052.090.062.141) on January 12, 2022.
C1936
HISTONE DAMAGES A MAMMALIAN EPITHELIUM
portion of histone H4 as the domain that is responsible
for many of the conductive properties of this molecule.
The fragment of histone H4 that spans amino acids
25–67 forms a voltage-dependent, non-ion-selective
conductance in the apical membrane of rabbit urinary
bladder epithelium. This region is predominantly ahelical in structure. This suggests that histone H4
behaves similarly to a number of channel-forming,
amphipathic, a-helical proteins. Further studies are
needed to more definitively describe the mechanism by
which these proteins increase membrane permeability.
This work was supported by National Institute of Diabetes and
Digestive and Kidney Diseases Grant DK-51382 to S. A. Lewis,
Medical Research Council of Canada Grant MT-5453 to P. N. Lewis,
and James W. McLaughlin Fellowship Fund to T. J. Kleine.
Address for reprint requests: S. A. Lewis, Dept. of Physiology and
Biophysics, Univ. of Texas Medical Branch, 301 Univ. Blvd., Galveston, TX, 77555-0641.
Received 20 June 1997; accepted in final form 19 August 1997.
REFERENCES
1. Agawa, Y., S. Lee, S. Ono, H. Aoyagi, M. Ohno, T. Taniguchi,
K. Anzai, and Y. Kirino. Interaction with phospholipid bilayers,
ion channel formation, and antimicrobial activity of basic amphipathic a-helical model peptides of various chain lengths. J. Biol.
Chem. 266: 20218–20222, 1991.
2. Aviles, F. J., G. E. Chapman, G. G. Kneale, C. CraneRobinson, and E. M. Bradbury. The conformation of histone
H5: isolation and characterisation of the globular segment.
Eur. J. Biochem. 88: 363–371, 1978.
3. Crane-Robinson, C., H. Hayashi, P. D. Cary, G. Briand, P.
Sautiere, D. Krieger, G. Vidali, P. N. Lewis, and J. TomKun. The location of secondary structure in histone H4. Eur. J.
Biochem. 79: 535–548, 1977.
4. Cruciani, R. A., J. L. Barker, S. R. Durell, G. Raghunathan,
H. R. Guy, M. Zasloff, and E. F. Stanley. Magainin 2, a natural
antibiotic from frog skin, forms ion channels in lipid bilayer
membranes. Eur. J. Pharmacol. 226: 287–296, 1992.
5. Hamilton, S. L., L. Mejia-Alvarez, M. Fill, M. J. Hawkes,
K. L. Brush, W. P. Schilling, and E. Stefani. [3H]-PN200–110
and [3H]-ryanodine binding and reconstitution of ion channel
activity with skeletal muscle membranes. Anal. Biochem. 183:
31–41, 1989.
6. Hirsch, J. G. Bactericidal action of histone. J. Exp. Med. 108:
925–944, 1958.
7. Kleine, T. J., A. Gladfelter, P. N. Lewis, and S. A. Lewis.
Histone-induced damage of a mammalian epithelium. Am. J.
Physiol. 268 (Cell Physiol. 37): C1114–C1125, 1995.
8. Lewis, P. N., E. M. Bradbury, and C. Crane-Robinson. Ionic
strength induced structure in histone H4 and its fragments.
Biochemistry 14: 3391–3400, 1975.
9. Lewis, P. N., J. G. Guillemette, and S. Chan. Histone
accessibility determined by lysine-specific acetylation on chicken
erythrocyte nuclei. Eur. J. Biochem. 172: 135–145, 1988.
10. Lewis, S. A., D. C. Eaton, C. Clausen, and J. M. Diamond.
Nystatin as a probe for investigating the electrical properties of a
tight epithelium. J. Gen. Physiol. 70: 427–440, 1977.
11. Maman, J. D., T. D. Yager, and J. Allan. Self-association of the
globular domain of histone H5. Biochemistry 33: 1300–1310,
1994.
12. Mendizabal, M. V., and R. J. Naftalin. In vivo exposure of rat
colonic mucosa to human semen induces mucosal cytolysis,
abolishes fluid absorption and raises paracellular permeability
(Abstract). J. Physiol. (Lond.) 446: 411P, 1992.
13. Motojima, S., E. Frigas, D. A. Loegering, and G. J. Gleich.
Toxicity of eosinophil cationic proteins for guinea pig tracheal
epithelium in vitro. Am. Rev. Respir. Dis. 139: 801–805, 1989.
14. Oka, T., Y. Murata, T. Nakanishi, H. Yoshizumi, H. Hayashida, Y. Ohtsuki, K. Toyoshima, and A. Hakura. Similarity, in molecular structure and function, between the plant toxin
purothionin and the mammalian pore-forming proteins. Mol.
Biol. Evol. 9: 707–715, 1992.
15. Peitsch, M. C., and J. Tschopp. Assembly of macromolecular
pores by immune defense systems. Curr. Opin. Cell Biol. 3:
710–716, 1991.
16. Periera, L. F., F. M. Marco, R. Boimorto, A. Caturla, A.
Bustos, E. G. de la Concha, and J. L. Subiza. Histones
interact with anionic phospholipids with high avidity; its relevance for the binding of histone-antihistone immune complexes.
Clin. Exp. Immunol. 97: 175–180, 1994.
17. Ramakrishnan, V., J. T. Finch, V. Graziano, P. L. Lee, and
R. M. Sweet. Crystal structure of globular domain of histone H5
and its implications for nucleosome binding. Nature 362: 219–
223, 1993.
18. Tzan, C. J., J. R. Berg, and S. A. Lewis. Modification of
epithelial permeability by cationic polypeptides. Am. J. Physiol.
265 (Cell Physiol. 34): C1637–C1647, 1993.
19. Tzan, C., J. Berg, and S. A. Lewis. Effect of protamine sulfate
on the permeability properties of the mammalian urinary bladder. J. Membr. Biol. 133: 227–242, 1993.
20. Whitehead, J. S., E. Kay, J. Y. Lew, and L. M. Shannon. A
preparative column electrophoresis apparatus using Sephadex
G-25. Anal. Biochem. 40: 287–291, 1971.
21. Yonath, J., and M. M. Civan. Determination of the driving
force of the Na1 pump in toad bladder by means of vasopressin. J.
Membr. Biol. 5: 366–385, 1971.
22. Young, J. D., and C. C. Liu. Multiple mechanisms of lymphocytemediated killing. Immunol. Today 9: 140–144, 1988.
23. Ziccardi, R., and V. Schumaker. Interaction of histone f2al
with T7 deoxyribonucleic acid. Cooperativity of histone binding.
Biochemistry 12: 3231–3235, 1973.
Downloaded from journals.physiology.org/journal/ajpcell (052.090.062.141) on January 12, 2022.