The Ancient Urban Maya: Neighborhoods, Inequality and Built Form
2016, University Press of Florida
Scott R. Hutson
Precis
We often think that the ancient Maya were exceptional. Though we now know that the ancient
Maya were just as violent as other societies and that their remarkable writing system does not encode
esoteric prophecies, we still overlook some of the ways that they resemble other societies—both
ancient and modern. For example, from as far back as the nineteenth century writers have told us that
the ancient Maya had cities, but we don’t usually think about those cities the way we think about
ancient Rome or modern Tokyo. Though they were home to tens of thousands of people, Maya cities
were not nearly as crowded as Babylon (28,000 people per km2), Timbuktu (20,000 people per km2), or
most other Old World cities from Athens to Zaria. In the most cited archaeological work of all time,
Gordon Childe purposefully omitted the Maya when writing about ancient urbanism in 1950.
Yet several Maya cities were more crowded than we realize. And some of the same troubles that
haunted other pre-industrial cities—disease, sewage, inequality, alienation—also beset Maya cities. But
archaeology often shows how resourceful people can be. Though they were constrained by deeply
embedded customs and assumptions about what is proper and what is not, people in the past as in the
present responded to challenges in creative ways, making life livable. The ancient Maya made city life
look appealing to those who lived outside city limits.
Figure 1: Part of the skyline of Uxmal. Mexico
My new book The Ancient Urban Maya explores how ancient Maya cities attracted people. Much of the
population of the Maya lowlands lived in rural villages, and though life in the countryside was less
romantic than sometimes assumed, it was entirely viable. Maya political leaders benefited from getting
people to cluster together, so they had to woo people from the countryside. They did so by hosting
markets and building monuments. Markets and market exchange are turning up with greater frequency
in Maya ruins as archaeologists rethink the nature of ancient economies and use new methods for
finding and interpreting evidence of trade. Psychological research on how people respond to
monuments and cityscapes of different kinds shows that the big temples and plazas that draw tourists to
places like Tikal and Chichén Itzá today would have been attractive to people in the past as well (Figures
1 and 2). And while Maya kings worked hard to attract followers to their cities, those same followers
made cities attractive in their own ways. Specifically, they organized themselves into neighborhoods.
Neighborhoods provide a sense of familiarity and distinction amidst a sea of anonymous faces. They
foster networks of trust and social control, giving an urban twist to the phrase it takes a illage. People
who share neighborhoods often form communities that are larger than the household but smaller than
the city as a whole. Social units of this intermediate size play an extremely important role in city politics
and economics, but they have been difficult to identify in the ruins of Maya cities.
The Ancient Urban Maya uncovers new data in a city that is ideally suited to a study of neighborhoods:
Chunchucmil in Yucatan, Mexico. At Chunchucmil, dozens of kilometers of stone fences separated
walkways throughout the city. These walkways generally extended from the site core out to the edges,
in the same way that spokes on a bicycle extend from the hub to the tire. People interacted quite a bit
with others living on the same spoke, but much less so with people from other spokes. To get from one
spoke to another, you ould first ha e to alk to the site ore. “in e ea h of these spoke
neigh orhoods had its own temple complex, they were also politico-religious organizations that had a
powerful voice in the affairs of the city.
Figure 2: A portion of the cityscape of Oxkintok, Mexico—some of it excavated, some not.
My book also explores the community attractions that arose in Maya cities as an unintended
consequence of lots of people settling together in close quarters. Maya cities brimmed with priests,
peddlers, potters, farmers, fishers, featherworkers and people from many other walks of life
who came into contact in impressive public spaces. Bazaars, plazas, and other busy places are not
just good for people-watching. They present the possibility of chance encounters that may lead to
unexpected opportunities, resources, and social networks. The human resources found in
cities—an abundance of individuals with diverse skills, backgrounds, and interests—drive social,
economic, and technological developments, and have done so for millennia.
Maya cities had many draws: markets, opulent and carefully-choreographed ceremonies, an
enchanting mix of different and unequal people, and well-integrated neighborhoods. Ancient
Urban Maya discusses how both leaders and less powerful people shaped cities and benefitted
from the experiences they afforded.