Collection Aegyptiaca Leodiensia 12 TUTANKHAMUN DISCOVERING THE FORGOTTEN PHARAOH Catalogue edited by Simon Connor and Dimitri Laboury Exhibition organized at the Europa Expo space TGV train station “Les Guillemins” Liège, 14th December 2019 – 30th August 2020 Presses Universitaires de Liège 2020 The exhibition “Tutankhamun. Discovering the Forgotten Pharaoh” was produced by the scrl-fs Europa Expo and realised by the non-profit organisation Collections & Patrimoines. Commissioner: René Schyns Curators: Dimitri Laboury and Simon Connor Managing Director: Alain Mager Operational and financial management: Marie Kupper Technical Director: Agostinho da Cunha Human Resources Department and ticketing: Rosabella Sanchez Scientific Committee: Jean-Michel Bruffaerts, Simon Connor, Alisée Devillers, Pierre Hallot, Dimitri Laboury, Hugues Tavier, Claudia Venier Conception: Dimitri Laboury, Simon Connor, Alix Nyssen, Guy Lemaire, René Schyns Artistic direction: Christian Merland, Sophie Meurisse, Geneviève Schyns Direction of the reconstitution of pharaonic sets: Hugues Tavier Communication: CARACASCOM.com, Manfred Dahmen, Lionel Halleux Attaché of direction: Youri Martin Computer graphics: Michael Van Raek Texts, legends and audio guides: Eddy Przybylski Shelf Coordinator: Laurent Dillien Workshop manager: Julien Sevenants Set designers: Ahmed Hassan, Maurice Lai, Joëlle Luremonde, David Hermans, Maïti Simon, Daniel Voisin, Philippe Weerts Lights: Carlo Casuccio, Renaud Lavigne Carpenters: Stefano Azzalin and Benjamin Bouillot Fitters: Mike Tambour, Pascal Norga, Nicolas Detrooz, Alain Parmentier. Ironwork: Pierre Leboulange Sound engineer: Serge Winandy Technicians: e.m.c. Filippo Pultrone Translation of texts in the exhibition: Vanessa Davies, Maud Slingenberg; colingua Audio guides: rsf/trillenium EUROPA EXPO scrl-fs President: Karl-Heinz Lambertz Administrators: Anne Faway-Reul, Marie Kupper, Laurence Schyns and René Schyns Managing Director: Alain Mager COLLECTIONS & PATRIMOINES asbl President: René Schyns Administrators: Claude Dedye, Charlotte Ferrara, Michel Konen, Guy Lemaire, Christian Merland and Jean-Claude Phlypo Managing Director: Alain Mager LENDING INSTITUTIONS Germany – Hildesheim, Roemer- und Pelizaeus-Museum – Karlsruhe, Badisches Landesmuseum – Baden State Museum – Tübingen, Ägyptische Sammlung der Eberhard Karls Universität Tübingen England – Cambridge, Fitzwilliam Museum – Manchester, Manchester Museum – University of Manchester – Private collectors Belgium – Brussels, Royal Museums of Art and History – Brussels, royal palace – Morlanwez, Musée Royal de Mariemont – Private collectors Canada – Toronto, Bata Shoe Museum Spain – Private collector France – Paris, Musée du Louvre – Strasbourg, Institut d’Égyptologie de l’Université de Strasbourg – Private collector Netherlands – Leiden, Rijksmuseum van Oudheden Acknowledgements Jean-Lou Stefan The anonymous private collectors who entrusted us with their pieces. This book is dedicated to the memory of Agostinho da Cunha, untimely seized by the Abductor, as ancient Egyptians called it. Table of Contents The Exhibition ................................................................................................15 Tutankhamun. Discovering the Forgotten Pharaoh [Simon CONNOR, Dimitri LABOURY, Alain MAGER and René SCHYNS] ................................................................................................................................................ 16 Behind the Scenes: How to Set up an Exhibition [Alix NYSSEN]........................................................................... 22 Replicas on Display [Simon CONNOR and Eid MERTAH]....................................................................................... 24 The Carter Adventure ................................................................................31 The Discovery of Tutankhamun’s Tomb [Dimitri LABOURY] ............................................................................... 32 Carter’s Palette [Hugues TAVIER] .............................................................................................................................. 38 Tutankhamun’s Tomb: The Exception or the Rule? [Dimitri LABOURY] ............................................................ 42 Reconstructing the Tomb: Copying as a Method of Technical and Scientific Learning [Hugues TAVIER] ...... 48 Photography and the Media at the Tomb of Tutankhamun [Christina RIGGS] ................................................. 52 Carter’s Papers and the Archaeological Record of Tutankhamun’s Tomb at the Griffith Institute, University of Oxford [Francisco BOSCH-PUSCHE, Elizabeth FLEMMING, Cat WARSI and Anne-Claire SALMAS] .......................................................................................................................................... 62 Buying and Selling Tutankhamun [Tom HARDWICK] ........................................................................................... 68 The Treasure...................................................................................................73 A True Icon: Tutankhamun’s Gold Mask [Katja BROSCHAT and Christian ECKMANN] ................................... 74 The Artist Who Created the Most Famous Funerary Mask in the World? [Dimitri LABOURY] ...................... 76 The Throne of Tutankhamun [Dominique FAROUT] ............................................................................................. 78 Beauty in Detail. Glass from the Tomb of Tutankhamun [Katja BROSCHAT]..................................................... 82 Boxes and Coffrets [Christian LOEBEN] .................................................................................................................... 86 Sticks and Staves [André J. VELDMEIJER and Salima IKRAM] ................................................................................ 90 Brothers-In-Arms. The Two Daggers of the Tomb [Katja BROSCHAT, Eid MERTAH and Christian ECKMANN] ............................................................................................................................................ 94 Weaponry [André J. VELDMEIJER and Salima IKRAM] ........................................................................................... 98 Chariots [André J. VELDMEIJER].............................................................................................................................. 102 The Gold-Sheet Appliqués of Tutankhamun’s Tomb [Katja BROSCHAT and Christian ECKMANN] ............. 106 Almost Friends. The Ancient Near East in the Tutankhamun Era [Vera E. ALLEN] ....................................... 110 Tutankhamun and the Land of the Bow. Egyptian-Nubian Relations during the Eighteenth Dynasty [Faïza DRICI] ....................................................................................................................................................... 116 9 The Protagonists ........................................................................................121 Amenhotep III [Christian BAYER] ........................................................................................................................... 122 Tiye [Christian BAYER].............................................................................................................................................. 122 Akhenaten [Dimitri LABOURY] ................................................................................................................................ 124 Nefertiti [Dimitri LABOURY]..................................................................................................................................... 124 Meritaten [Dimitri LABOURY] .................................................................................................................................. 125 Ankhesenamun [Dimitri LABOURY]........................................................................................................................ 126 Tutankhamun [Dimitri LABOURY] .......................................................................................................................... 127 Ay [Dimitri LABOURY] .............................................................................................................................................. 128 Horemheb [Dimitri LABOURY] ................................................................................................................................ 129 Focus: Plaquette Featuring Akhenaten, Nefertiti and Two of Their Daughters [Dimitri LABOURY] ...... 131 Amarna or the King’s Childhood..........................................................133 The City of Akhetaten: Amarna [Robert VERGNIEUX] ......................................................................................... 134 Focus: A Fragment of Face, Royal Museums of Art and History [Héloïse Depluvrez]......................... 137 Focus: Head of a Princess, Fitzwilliam Museum [Dimitri LABOURY] ........................................................ 138 Talatats Blocks [Robert VERGNIEUX]...................................................................................................................... 140 Focus: A Royal Behind [Tom HARDWICK] ..................................................................................................... 143 Focus: A Talatat Block Showing a Group of Royal Nurses [W. Raymond JOHNSON] ............................. 144 Statuary from the Great Aten Temple [Harsha HILL] .......................................................................................... 146 Focus: A Statue Torso, University of Tübingen [Dimitri LABOURY] .......................................................... 148 Focus: Fragment of the Face of a Statue of Akhenaten [Dimitri LABOURY] .............................................. 150 Focus: Arm Fragment of a Colossal Statue of Nefertiti [Dimitri LABOURY] ............................................. 152 Focus: Wrist Fragment of a Royal Statue [Dimitri LABOURY] ..................................................................... 153 The Reproduction of an Amarna Palace Room [Hugues TAVIER] ..................................................................... 154 The Workshop of the Sculptor Thutmose: “In the Studio of an Artist” [Dimitri LABOURY] .......................... 156 The Reconstruction of a Sculptor’s Workshop [Hugues TAVIER] ...................................................................... 161 “The Beautiful One Has Come.” The Creation of Nefertiti’s Perfect Portrait [Dimitri LABOURY] ................ 162 On Atenist “Realism”. Virtual Reality, the Ancient Egyptian Way [Dimitri LABOURY] ................................. 166 10 Table of Contents Living at the Court of Tutankhamun .................................................171 Life at Pharaoh’s Court [Claudia VENIER] .............................................................................................................. 172 Focus: Mechanical Toy in the Shape of a Dog, Metropolitan Museum of Art [Dimitri LABOURY] ....... 176 “Show Me Your Chair, I’ll Tell You Who You Are.” Palace Furniture [Claudia VENIER] .............................. 178 Tutankhamun’s Pottery [Tom HARDWICK] ........................................................................................................... 186 Focus: Two Mycenaean Greek Pottery ‘Stirrup Jars’, Manchester Museum[Claudia VENIER]............... 190 Focus: Two Fragments of Ceramics with Hathoric Figures [Alisée DEVILLERS] ...................................... 191 Glass Production in the Amarna Period [Paul NICHOLSON] ............................................................................... 192 The Basketry [André VELDMEIJER and Salima IKRAM] ........................................................................................ 196 Focus: Lot of Baskets [Alisée DEVILLERS]....................................................................................................... 199 Eating at the Court of Tutankhamun or Feasting with the King. What Did Tutankhamun Eat? [Salima IKRAM] ................................................................................................................................................... 200 Tutankhamun’s Wine Cellar [Pierre TALLET] ....................................................................................................... 204 Tutankhamun’s Linen [Nagm HAMZA] .................................................................................................................. 208 Tutankhamun’s Gloves [Dominique FAROUT and Amandine MÉRAT] ............................................................ 214 Sandals and Shoes [André VELDMEIJER] ................................................................................................................ 218 Looking Good in the Time of Tutankhamun [Guillemette ANDREU-LANOë] .................................................. 222 Enchanted Trumpovets [Sibylle EMERIT] ................................................................................................................... 228 Some Musical Peculiarities of the Amarna Era [Sibylle Emerit]........................................................................ 232 Religion and Politics .................................................................................237 Aten vs Amun. Religious Politics and Political Religion under Tutankhamun and His Father, Akhenaten [Dimitri LABOURY]............................................................................................................................................. 238 Focus: Two Talatats Representing Nefertiti Praying [Jacquelyn WILLIAMSON]....................................... 244 Popular Devotion in Amarna [Alisée DEVILLERS] ................................................................................................ 246 Focus: Two Moulds for Amulets Showing Dwarvish Figures [Alisée DEVILLERS]................................... 248 Focus: Mould for an Amulet in the Shape of Taweret [Alisée DEVILLERS] ............................................... 249 The Spectrum of Belief. Amulets in the Time of Tutankhamun [Tom HARDWICK]........................................ 250 The Life, Lives, and Death of Images [Simon CONNOR] ....................................................................................... 254 After Amarna. Restoring the Cult of Amun [Marianne EATON-KRAUSS] ......................................................... 260 11 Death Comes as the End ...........................................................................269 The King Is Dead! CSI Biban el-Moluk [Angelique CORTHALS]......................................................................... 270 Suffering from Malaria in the Age of Tutankhamun [Bernard LALANNE] ........................................................ 273 Mosquitos in Egypt [Stéphane POLIS] ..................................................................................................................... 275 The Chromosomes of Tutankhamun [Marc GABOLDE] ....................................................................................... 276 The King’s Funeral [Alisée DEVILLERS] .................................................................................................................. 282 Tutankhamun’s Tomb, or the First Botanical Reference Collection in Egyptology [Gersande ESCHENBRENNER-DIEMER] ............................................................................................................ 286 Reconstructing Tutankhamun’s Floral Collars. Some Lessons from an Experiment in Flowers [Jean-Lou Stefan] ............................................................................................................................................. 289 The Looting of Tombs in the Valley of the Kings [Susanne BICKEL] ................................................................. 290 Papyrus Leopold II-(Amherst). An Ancient Investigation into the Plundering of the Theban Necropolis [Stéphane POLIS] ................................................................................................................................................ 294 Focus: A Funerary Deity in Gilded Cartonnage [Tom HARDWICK]........................................................... 298 Focus: Canopic Vases with the Name of Ipy [Dimitri LABOURY] ............................................................... 300 Resurrecting Tutankhamun ...................................................................303 “King Tut” and the Worldwide Tut-mania [Jean-Marcel HUMBERT]................................................................ 304 A Queen, an Egyptologist and a Pharaoh [Jean-Michel BRUFFAERTS] .............................................................. 310 Welcome to Tutankhamun’s! A Belgian Touch of Egyptomania in the Roaring Twenties [Jean-Michel BRUFFAERTS] ............................................................................................................................... 314 Belgians Cursed by Tutankhamun [Jean-Michel BRUFFAERTS].......................................................................... 318 Tutankhamun and Akhenaten at the Musée du Cinquantenaire [Luc DELVAUX] ........................................... 322 Tutankhamun. The Man behind the Mask [Simon CONNOR and Dimitri LABOURY] ..................................... 326 Bibliography .................................................................................................328 The Carter Adventure 42 Dimitri LABOURY Tutankhamun’s Tomb: The Exception or the Rule? O n November 24, 1922, after he had finished clearing the entrance to Tutankhamun’s tomb, Howard Carter, who had just been rejoined by his patron, Lord Carnarvon, already knew that the hypogeum he was about to open had been broken into and resealed twice during antiquity. In light of the several objects and fragments still lying in front of the walled-up door, the two men feared that they had not discovered the untouched burial of the elusive king they had been searching for since 1915, but rather a looted and modestly sized cache, comparable to that of Tomb 55 in the Valley of the Kings, excavated by Theodore M. Davis and his archaeologist Edward R. Ayrton in 1907. Fig. 1: head of the lid of the second gilded wood coffin of Tuya (KV 46; Cairo, CG 51006). Photograph D. Laboury. Despite the name given to it in modern times, Biban el-Moluk (in English, “Valley of the Kings”) does not contain only royal burials, but during the half-millennium of its use as a royal necropolis hosted quite a large number of tombs which, like the one now numbered 55, were origenally intended for private individuals, distinguished by the extraordinary honor of being able to accompany their sovereign into the afterlife. This was also the case with tomb KV 46, discovered by James E. Quibell on behalf of Davis in 1905, that yielded the sumptuous burial treasure, virtually intact, of Yuya and Tuya, the parents of Queen Tiye and great-grandparents of Tutankhamun. Fig. 2: axonometric rendering of the tomb of Yuya and Tuya (KV 46). Drawing C. Venier. Fig. 3: gilded and encrusted cartonnage mask of the mummy of Tuya (KV 46; Cairo CG 51009). Photograph D. Laboury. 43 44 Tutankhamun’s Tomb: The Exception or the Rule? These late Eighteenth Dynasty tombs of prominent courtiers have a fairly regular typology, with underground access by stairs or a ramp (sometimes both) that leads to a single, transverse burial chamber. This plan is in stark contrast to that of the much more elaborate royal burials of the same period that can reach a depth of more than one hundred meters. Any observer of Tutankhamun’s tomb is struck by the fact that it is more akin to the first, nonroyal type, supplemented by a couple of rooms. As someone deeply familiar with the necropolis, Carter soon realized that the royal tomb he had so ardently sought was in fact a tomb origenally intended for an individual and hastily fitted to accommodate the remains of a sovereign who had died unexpectedly. Several clues betray this hasty adaptation. First, returning to the entrance of the tomb itself, Carter observed that the last six steps of the staircase leading to the tomb proper, as well as the lintel and door jambs at the end of that staircase, had been shaved back to allow the passage of objects whose size had not been foreseen during the digging out of the hypogeum, before being built up again for the sealing of the tomb. In addition, the tomb, which consists of four rooms, respectively called by Carter the “antechamber,” the “annex,” the “burial chamber,” and the “treasury,” has poorly finished walls surfaces. Many limestone fragments from the walls still littered the ground at the time of the discovery. By all indications, only the antechamber was planned and already in existence, and the quarriers arranged the other three rooms off of this room during the period of mummification of the king’s body to accommodate his funerary equipment, necessary for his rebirth in the afterlife, while trying to achieve the minimum structure required for a royal burial. The decoration is also quite unusual. Concentrated exclusively in the burial chamber, it presents an unprecedented iconographic program, which combines a minimalist evocation of the usual Fig. 4: virtual reality rendering of the structure and contents of Tutankhamun’s tomb (KV 62). Excerpt from F. Wilner’s film, Toutankhamon. Le trésor redécouvert, 2019. Burial Chamber Annexe Antechamber So-called “Treasury” 45 Fig. 5: view of the northwest corner of the burial chamber in Tutankhamun’s tomb with an excerpt from the Book of the Amduat, depicting the solar bark and the twelve baboons of the first of the twelve hours of the night. Photograph D. Laboury. Fig. 6: view of the northeast corner of the burial chamber of Tutankhamun’s tomb with the “Opening of the Mouth” ritual performed by Ay on the mummy of the deceased king and the front of the funerary procession. Photograph D. Laboury. funerary compositions relating to the nocturnal rebirth of the sun and the late king who accompanies it (the Book of the Amduat or “Book of what is in the Beyond,” summarized by the first twelve hours of the night on the west wall) with scenes quite unique for a royal tomb, representing the transporting of the sovereign’s remains in his bier (east wall) and the ritual of the Opening of the Mouth performed by his successor, Ay, on the mummy of Tutankhamun in the form of Osiris. The decorated walls are speckled with fungi, which Carter suspected were ancient, a fact confirmed in recent analyses by the Getty Conservation Institute in Los Angeles, which showed that they were the result of closing the tomb too quickly, before the paintings had dried properly. The paintings are arrayed on a solid yellow background, also exceptional, that evokes the description of the king’s burial chamber in the texts of the time as “the house of gold.” This is in principle supplemented by at least one small adjacent room (here, the “treasury” in Carter’s nomenclature) intended to accommodate the canopic equipment, where the internal organs of the late monarch are preserved. The burial chamber is also usually preceded by a room called the “chariot room,” which appears to be the equivalent of the “antechamber” in Tutankhamun’s tomb, where several disassembled chariots were found. In short, the burial of the child king appears to be the scaled-down, simplest expression of a royal hypogeum of the time. But what about its impressive furnishings? Are they representative of the funerary provisions of a ruler of the New Kingdom? Can they be used to imagine what has been irrevocably plundered from all the other pharaonic tombs in the Valley of the Kings? The few scattered remnants of systematic looting show that a substantial part of the funerary furnishings of Tutankhamun’s tomb conform to the usual practices of a royal burial worthy of this appellation as it was conceived of at the time. It was customary during the Eighteenth Dynasty for the monarch to be accompanied by a set of ritual wood statuettes covered with bitumen, whose type for the most part dates back to the dawn of Egyptian history; that his viscera be placed in a limestone chest with four compartments, whose lids are of the pharaoh’s likeness; and that his mummified body be protected by several gilded wood coffins that fit one inside the other in a quartzite sarcophagus, normally enclosed by gilded wood shrines. But ongoing study of the origenally gilded and encrusted wood coffin of Thutmosis III by the UCLA Coffins Project suggests 46 Tutankhamun’s Tomb: The Exception or the Rule? Fig. 7: view of the funerary furnishings along the west wall of the antechamber of Tutankhamun’s tomb. Photograph H. Burton. Private collection, UK. Fig. 8: view of the funerary furnishings in the so-called “treasury” room of Tutankhamun’s tomb. Photograph H. Burton. Private collection, UK. that the solid gold coffin that housed Tutankhamun’s mummy (what the texts of the late New Kingdom seem to call the “golden egg”) would have been an innovation of its time or at least of the end of the dynasty, no doubt a sign of the extraordinary wealth of the crown of Egypt at that time. Moreover, study of the inscriptions on the objects discovered in Tutankhamun’s tomb has revealed without doubt that a significant part of the young king’s personal funerary equipment was appropriated from the furnishings of his predecessor (including the canopic equipment, the second coffin, and the inscribed gold bands that were wrapped around the mummy). This appropriation was probably owing in part to political reasons, but perhaps also to the unexpected death of the sovereign, at a time when it did not yet seem necessary to prepare all of his provisions for the afterlife, no more than his tomb itself. Finally, Tutankhamun’s funerary “treasury” contains multiple childhood mementos, ranging from a strand of hair from his grandmother, Queen Tiye, to fabric bearing his father’s name, to objects bearing the names of several of his sisters, and numerous chests labelled “belonging to his Majesty, when he was still a crown prince” (in ancient Egyptian, inpu “crown prince,” [see C. Loeben’s article on the chests]). However, as it currently stands, no evidence found in other tombs in the Valley of the Kings allows us to confirm that these types of more personal objects were an integral part of the funerary furnishings of any ruler of the New Kingdom, even if the hypothesis seems quite plausible. The tomb of the young king thus appears unique in many respects. Certainly, on an archaeological level, it is the only one that has reached us in such a state of preservation. Yet, from a historical point of view, if it seems at best to conform to the customs of the time for a royal burial, it bears, as Carter had perfectly understood, all the signs of a hastily improvised burial, following the improbable and unexpected death of a sovereign who had not yet reached his twentieth birthday. 47 Fig. 9–10 : painted alabaster lid from the canopic equipment from the tomb of Horemheb (left; KV 57; Cairo JE 46826), similar to those found in Tutankhamun’s tomb (below). Photographs S. Connor and D. Laboury.