Content deleted Content added
Reply |
→Vote: B |
||
Line 54:
*<s>'''Option A''' - To pass [[WP:NFCC]], use this one.[[User:TheGreatestLuvofAll|TheGreatestLuvofAll]] ([[User talk:TheGreatestLuvofAll|talk]]) 02:08, 16 February 2024 (UTC)</s>
*'''Option B''' - This is missing the context of the fact that the main single cover art (Option A) is also being used by Ariana Grande as the main album cover and therefore is used in the album page. To pass [[WP:NFCC]], this image must be only used once on one of the two pages. I understand the frustration with the most recognized single cover art not being used on the single's page, and I agree that the primary cover art should be preferred when possible. However, '''the same image must not be used on two pages by [[WP:NFCC]]'''. Unless the album infobox cover is left empty, the same image cannot be used on the single's page. As a result, there are really only two options here: Option B (only using the cover art for the album page, and instead using an alternate cover for the single, which is the solution currently employed), or Option E (only using the cover art for the album page, and having no cover art for the single page). This situation has happened numerous times where a pre-release single uses the same artwork as the main album, and so an alternate cover is used. Examples include "[[Look What You Made Me Do]]" ([https://web.archive.org/web/20170825062007/https://itunes.apple.com/us/album/look-what-you-made-me-do-single/id1275004355]) and "[[...Ready for It?]]" ([https://web.archive.org/web/20171127190007/https://itunes.apple.com/us/album/ready-for-it-single/id1278522951]), which shared the same cover art as ''[[Reputation (album)|Reputation]]'', "[[Flowers (Miley Cyrus song)|Flowers]]", which shared the same cover art as ''[[Endless Summer Vacation]]'', and "[[Green Light (Lorde song)|Green Light]]" ([https://web.archive.org/web/20170312082001/https://itunes.apple.com/us/album/green-light/id1211010237?i=1211010244]), which shared the same cover art as ''[[Melodrama (Lorde album)|Melodrama]]''; note that "Green Light" is a good article. Linking [[Wikipedia:Files for discussion/2024 February 3#File:Ariana Grande - Yes, And? (edit).png]] for the initial discussion of this point. [[User:Flabshoe1|Flabshoe1]] ([[User talk:Flabshoe1|talk]]) 03:53, 16 February 2024 (UTC)
*'''Option B'''. Per [[MOS:LEADIMAGE]], "It is common for an article's lead or infobox to carry a representative image—such as of a person or place, a book or album cover—to give readers visual confirmation that they've arrived at the right page." Using same image for single and album article might confuse readers per [[WP:ASTONISH]]. As the maxi single is the fullest form of the single (it also includes the original version of the song; it's not a remix EP), I believe the cover for it should be used as it encompasses the most versions of this song, which would be the most "representative" form of identification. It's not like the other versions don't matter—they contributed a lot to its commercial success, so I think its use is justified. [[User:Heartfox|Heartfox]] ([[User talk:Heartfox|talk]]) 20:28, 16 February 2024 (UTC)
===Additional discussion===
| |||