Fun Home (Resumen No Oficial)
Fun Home (Resumen No Oficial)
Fun Home (Resumen No Oficial)
Fun Home fue la primera historieta finalista del Premio del Crculo de Crticos
Nacional del Libro.5 Adems, recibi el premio Eisner como mejor trabajo
basado en hechos reales,6 el Stonewall Book Award, el Premio Literario
Lambda, el Publishing Triangle-Judy Grahn Nonfiction Award y un GLAAD
Media Awards.7 8 La revista Time incluy a la historieta en el primer puesto
de su ranking de los diez mejores libros del ao 2006.9
Argumento
La historieta narra la historia de la relacin de la autora con su padre, un
profesor de ingls y director de la funeraria familiar, que fallece cuatro
meses despus de que Alison le revelara que era lesbiana.12 La historieta
no sigue una lnea temporal, sino que se alternan fragmentos de la infancia,
adolescencia y juventud de Alison sin seguir un orden establecido.13
Trama
In un continuo sussesseguirsi di analessi e prolessi, Alison Bechdel ripercorre
la sua vita soffermandosi soprattutto sulla propria omosessualit e sul
rapporto complicato con il padre (anch'egli omosessuale). Bruce Bechdel era
un professore di inglese al liceo cittadino e anche il proprietario di
un'impresa di pompe funebri, che mor in circostanza sospsette (molto
probabilmente suicida) quando la figlia era al college. Nel romanzo grafico,
Alison traccia parallelismi tra la figura del padre e quelle del mito greco o di
Fun Home has been both a popular and critical success, and spent two
weeks on the New York Times Best Seller list.[5][6] In The New York Times
Sunday Book Review, Sean Wilsey called it "a pioneering work, pushing two
genres (comics and memoir) in multiple new directions."[7] Several
publications named Fun Home as one of the best books of 2006; it was also
included in several lists of the best books of the 2000s.[8] It was nominated
for several awards, including the National Book Critics Circle Award and
three Eisner Awards (one of which it won).[8][9] A French translation of Fun
Home was serialized in the newspaper Libration; the book was an official
selection of the Angoulme International Comics Festival and has been the
subject of an academic conference in France.[10][11][12] Fun Home has
been the subject of numerous academic publications in areas such as
biography studies and cultural studies, as part of a larger turn towards
serious academic investment in the study of comics/sequential art.[13]
In the beginning of the book, the memoir exhibits Bruce Bechdel's obsession
with restoring the family's Victorian home.[31] His obsessive need to restore
the house is connected to his emotional distance from his family, which he
expressed in coldness and occasional bouts of abusive rage.[31][32] This
emotional distance, in turn, is connected with his being a closeted
homosexual.[33] Bruce Bechdel had homosexual relationships in the military
and with his high school students; some of those students were also family
friends and babysitters.[34] At the age of 44, two weeks after his wife
requested a divorce, he stepped into the path of an oncoming Sunbeam
Bread truck and was killed.[35] Although the evidence is equivocal, Alison
Bechdel concludes that her father committed suicide.[31][36][37]
The story also deals with Alison Bechdel's own struggle with her sexual
identity, reaching a catharsis in the realization that she is a lesbian and her
coming out to her parents.[31][38] The memoir frankly examines her sexual
development, including transcripts from her childhood diary, anecdotes
about masturbation, and tales of her first sexual experiences with her
girlfriend, Joan.[39] In addition to their common homosexuality, Alison and
Bruce Bechdel share obsessive-compulsive tendencies and artistic leanings,
albeit with opposing aesthetic senses: "I was Spartan to my father's
Athenian. Modern to his Victorian. Butch to his nelly. Utilitarian to his
aesthete."[40] This opposition was a source of tension in their relationship,
as both tried to express their dissatisfaction with their given gender roles:
"Not only were we inverts, we were inversions of each other. While I was
trying to compensate for something unmanly in him, he was attempting to
express something feminine through me. It was a war of cross-purposes,
and so doomed to perpetual escalation."[41] However, shortly before Bruce
Bechdel's death, he and his daughter have a conversation in which Bruce
confesses some of his sexual history; this is presented as a partial resolution
to the conflict between father and daughter.[42]
Themes[edit]
Fun Home has several themes recurring throughout the book. The biggest
theme, arguably, is sexual orientation. Bechdel tells the readers of her
journey of discovering her own sexuality through books. "My realization at
nineteen that I was a lesbian came about in a manner consistent with my
bookish upbringing."[44] Her exposure (from reading literal definitions in
dictionaries, reading interviews of others like her, etc.) helped her come to
terms with her sexuality, but in truth, the hints of it plagued her childhood:
her desire "for the right to exchange [her] tank suit for a pair of shorts" in
Cannes"[45] or her desire for her brothers to call her Albert instead of Alison
on one camping trip.[46] However, Bechdel also reveals that she wasn't
alone in her choice of partners; her father also exhibited some homosexual
behaviors, but in a different way than Alison. "I'd been upstaged, demoted
from protagonist in my own drama to comic relief in my parents' tragedy"
quoted on page 58 when her mother reveals Bechdel's father's secret.
Though both, father and daughter, had similar situations (Bechdel was a
lesbian while her father was gay or bisexual), the two handled their issues
differently. Bechdel chose to accept the fact and not hide from the issue,
taking a female partner and going to "gay union" meetings when she was a
student at Oberlin College . Bechdel was open about her sexuality before
she'd even been in a same-sex relationship (of any sort). Her father, on the
other hand, had had countless affairs with men but wasn't open about it ".
[47] This may be due to homophobia (his and/or others'), or because he was
married with a family. In any case, it is clear that he is afraid of coming out,
as illustrated by "the fear in his eyes" when the conversation topic is
dangerously close to homosexuality.[48]
The third, underlying theme of death is also portrayed. Unlike most young
people, the Bechdel children have a tangible relationship with death
because of the family mortuary business. Alison ponders whether Bechdel's
father's death was an accident or suicide, and finds it more likely that he
killed himself purposefully.[50] Whether this was because of his own
sexuality, Alison's sexuality, or some other cause remains unclear.
Allusions[edit]
The allusive literary references used in Fun Home are not merely structural
or stylistic: Bechdel writes, "I employ these allusions ... not only as
descriptive devices, but because my parents are most real to me in fictional
terms. And perhaps my cool aesthetic distance itself does more to convey
the Arctic climate of our family than any particular literary comparison."[51]
Bechdel, as the narrator, considers her relationship to her father through the
myth of Daedalus and Icarus.[52] As a child, she confused her family and
their Gothic Revival home with the Addams Family seen in the cartoons of
Charles Addams.[53] Bruce Bechdel's suicide is discussed with reference to
Albert Camus' novel A Happy Death and essay The Myth of Sisyphus.[54] His
careful construction of an aesthetic and intellectual world is compared to
The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald, and the narrator suggests that
Bruce Bechdel modeled elements of his life after Fitzgerald's, as portrayed
in the biography The Far Side of Paradise.[55] His wife Helen is compared
with the protagonists of the Henry James novels Washington Square and The
Portrait of a Lady.[56] Helen Bechdel was an amateur actress, and plays in
which she acted are also used to illuminate aspects of her marriage. She
met Bruce Bechdel when the two were appearing in a college production of
The Taming of the Shrew, and Alison Bechdel intimates that this was "a
harbinger of my parents' later marriage".[57] Helen Bechdel's role as Lady
Bracknell in a local production of The Importance of Being Earnest is shown
in some detail; Bruce Bechdel is compared with Oscar Wilde.[58] His
homosexuality is also examined with allusion to Marcel Proust's In Search of
Lost Time.[59] The father and daughter's artistic and obsessive-compulsive
tendencies are discussed with reference to E. H. Shepard's illustrations for
The Wind in the Willows.[60] Bruce and Alison Bechdel exchange hints about
their sexualities by exchanging memoirs: the father gives the daughter
The chapter headings, too, are all literary allusions.[63] The first chapter,
"Old Father, Old Artificer," refers to line in Joyce's A Portrait of the Artist as a
Young Man, and the second, "A Happy Death," invokes the Camus novel.
"That Old Catastrophe" is a line from Wallace Stevens's "Sunday Morning,"
and "In the Shadow of the Young Girls in Flower" is the literal translation of
the title of one of the volumes of Marcel Proust's In Search of Lost Time,
which is usually given in English as Within a Budding Grove.
Artwork[edit]
Fun Home is drawn in black line art with a gray-green ink wash.[2] Sean
Wilsey wrote that Fun Home's panels "combine the detail and technical
proficiency of R. Crumb with a seriousness, emotional complexity and
innovation completely its own."[7] Writing in the Gay & Lesbian Review
Worldwide, Diane Ellen Hamer contrasted "Bechdel's habit of drawing her
characters very simply and yet distinctly" with "the attention to detail that
she devotes to the background, those TV shows and posters on the wall, not
to mention the intricacies of the funeral home as a recurring backdrop."[33]
Bechdel told an interviewer for The Comics Journal that the richness of each
panel of Fun Home was very deliberate:
It's very important for me that people be able to read the images in the
same kind of gradually unfolding way as they're reading the text. I don't like
pictures that don't have information in them. I want pictures that you have
to read, that you have to decode, that take time, that you can get lost in.
Otherwise what's the point?[65]
annoyance, frustration, pity and loveusually all at the same time and
never without a pervasive, deeply literary irony about the near-impossible
task of staying true to yourself, and to the people who made you who you
are."[98] Entertainment Weekly called it the best nonfiction book of the
year, and Time named Fun Home the best book of 2006, describing it as
"the unlikeliest literary success of 2006" and "a masterpiece about two
people who live in the same house but different worlds, and their mysterious
debts to each other."[99][100]
Fun Home was a finalist for the 2006 National Book Critics Circle Award, in
the memoir/autobiography category.[101][102] In 2007, Fun Home won the
GLAAD Media Award for Outstanding Comic Book, the Stonewall Book Award
for non-fiction, the Publishing Triangle-Judy Grahn Nonfiction Award, and the
Lambda Literary Award in the "Lesbian Memoir and Biography" category.
[103][104][105][106] Fun Home was nominated for the 2007 Eisner Awards
in two categories, Best Reality-Based Work and Best Graphic Album, and
Bechdel was nominated as Best Writer/Artist.[107] Fun Home won the Eisner
for Best Reality-Based Work.[9] In 2008, Entertainment Weekly placed Fun
Home at #68 in its list of "New Classics" (defined as "the 100 best books
from 1983 to 2008").[108] The Guardian included Fun Home in its series
"1000 novels everyone must read", noting its "beautifully rendered" details.
[109]
In 2009, Fun Home was listed as one of the best books of the previous
decade by The Times of London, Entertainment Weekly and Salon.com, and
as one of the best comic books of the decade by The Onion's A.V. Club.[8]
[110]
In 2010, the Los Angeles Times literary blog "Jacket Copy" named Fun Home
as one of "20 classic works of gay literature".[111]
Marshall Public Library Board of Trustees voted to return both Fun Home and
Blankets to the library's shelves.[15] Bechdel described the attempted
banning as "a great honor", and described the incident as "part of the whole
evolution of the graphic-novel form."[118]
Free Expression, the Comic Book Legal Defense Fund, the Association of
American Publishers, the National Council of Teachers of English and the
American Library Association.[132][133] After a nearly week-long debate in
which Fun Home and Bechdel were compared to slavery, Charles Manson
and Adolf Hitler, the state Senate voted to restore the funding, but redirect
the funds towards study of the United States Constitution and The Federalist
Papers; the university was also required to provide alternate books to
students who object to an assignment due to a "religious, moral or cultural
belief".[134][135][136] Governor Nikki Haley approved the budget measure
penalizing the university.[137]
In 2015, the book was assigned as summer reading for the incoming class of
2019 at Duke University. Several students objected to the book on moral
and/or religious grounds.[138]
Musical adaptation[edit]
Main article: Fun Home (musical)
Fun Home has been adapted into a stage musical, with book by Lisa Kron
and music by Jeanine Tesori. The play was first developed in a 2009
workshop at the Ojai Playwrights Conference, and subsequently
workshopped in 2012 at the Sundance Theatre Lab and The Public Theater's
Public Lab.[139][140][141]