Heather Kullorn in an undated photo; her fifth-grade school picture; age-progressed to age 19
As previously reported at Netscape, the Major Case Squad of Greater St. Louis will soon reopen the cold case of Heather Kullorn. According to Bill Baker, who leads the squad, the police have a longtime suspect. Yet no one has ever been charged in since Heather disappeared from a Richmond Heights, Missouri apartment on July 15, 1999.
At the time she vanished, the 12-year-old was babysitting the infant daughter of family friends Christopher Herbert and Dana Madden. Police believe she was abducted sometime during the night or early morning hours. There was no forced entry and Heather's blood was found on the couch in the apartment. The only witness was a neighbor --who was legally blind without his glasses--who saw a child being carried out of the apartment in the early morning hours.
Police detectives will go back and interview everyone who was originally questioned. Meanwhile, the lack of an arrest has given those close to the case plenty of time to ruminate on what might have happened to Heather.
"I have had years to think about this," says Mike Mason. Back in July 1999, he was living across the street from the apartment complex from which Heather disappeared. Today, he sits in federal prison in Marion, Illinois, serving a six-year sentence on federal drug charges.
In an interview at the prison, Mason recounts being awakened by a knock at the door the morning after Heather was discovered missing. When he answered, he found Christopher Herbert, accompanied by a police officer. "Is she in there?" the police officer asked, before searching Mason's apartment.
According to Mason, he was one of the few people in the building who knew Heather. In his view, that explains the visit and the search. Mason adds that he was given a lie detector test soon afterwards, and that he passed it. (Police refuse to comment on the results of any lie detector tests.)
Still, the police had another reason to be interested in Mason: his drug dealings with Herbert. At the time, both men were doing heavy amounts of methamphetamine. Police also found drug paraphernalia in a garage shared by the two men.
Heather, who was close with Dana Madden, frequently hung around Herbert's apartment. She was quite aware of the drug use going on, says Mason. "That girl had seen a lifetime of stuff," he notes.
For his part, Mason believes that Heather knew her abductor. Major Case Squad Commander Baker agrees that the culprit probably wasn't a stranger. This judgment is partly based on the proximity of the apartments in the complex. "Usually when you have a stranger abduction," says Baker, "you would have someone hearing screams." No such noise was reported.
Shortly after Heather's disappearance, Mason discovered that his tow chains were missing. Today, he still think it's possible someone used the chains to weigh down Heather's body and throw her in the Mississippi River.
"I Want Her To Come Back Home" What happened to Heather also weighs on the mind of Dana Madden, 31, who shared the apartment with Herbert. She and Heather were buddies, she says. One of their favorite things to do was to go to the Dollar Store together. Now living in Illinois, Madden says she scans the Internet once a month, looking for news stories about Kullorn.
"I am scared for Heather and I want to know where she is at," says Madden in a phone interview. "I want her to come home."
Madden was also friendly with the girl's mother, Christine Kullorn, but today the two no longer talk. In 2000, Kullorn was arrested for trying to attack Madden with a baseball bat. To this day, Kullorn believes her former friend knows something about what happened to her daughter. Madden denies the charge.
What does she think happened that night? "I can only account for myself," says Madden, who was working the overnight shift at a convenience store when Heather disappeared. After the police searched Mason's apartment, they sent him to pick up Madden at work and bring her home.
Madden says it wasn't common for a friend or acquaintance to randomly drop by her apartment. She is at least willing to consider the possibility of a stranger abduction. Heather used to play at a nearby park, she recalls. Perhaps somebody followed her back to the apartment complex.
"You Don't Think About Things" In the weeks and months that followed Heather's disappearance, the group continued their heavy substance abuse, even as the police kept a close eye on the apartment. Both Mason and Madden agree that the drugs affected their reaction to the girl's disappearance.
"When you are high, you don't think about things," says Madden. "And you wake up in the morning, and you think, 'I am going to have to deal with this stuff.' So then you get more high.'"
And what about Christopher Herbert, who will be released from federal prison later this year? He had actually dated Christine Kullorn on and off before he met Madden. Some people close to the case recall that he treated Heather like an uncle. (Others recall no particular warmth to the relationship.)
The night of the disappearance, he told police he was out with friends. Later, he admitted that he was trying to manufacture meth with a friend along a bank of the Mississippi River. That area of the river would eventually be dragged by police, as would a lake on a nearby property frequented by Herbert. Their search yielded nothing.
Herbert, who has repeatedly told police he doesn't know what happened to Heather, declined Netscape's request for an in-person interview. But in a letter to this reporter, he writes that he has "nothing to hide." "I don't think I can tell you any more than you already know," he adds.
"Maybe Someone Will Come Forward" The original investigators interviewed some additional parties. These included Herbert's companion at the river that night and a couple from Sikeston, Missouri, who stopped by Herbert's apartment earlier that same afternoon to recover some meth-manufacturing equipment (which police say was stolen by Herbert in the first place).
Now the Cold Case Sqaud will take a second shot at the whole process. Commander Baker is hopeful about the new interviews. "Maybe this will trigger something for someone," says Baker. "Maybe someone will come forward."
For Christine Kullorn, who is currently trying to raise funds to start a foundation in her daughter's name, the reopening of the case is bittersweet. "I just wish they'd done this a long time ago," she says, speaking by phone from her Saint Clair, Missouri apartment.
As for Mike Mason, he's eager to see the case move forward. "I would love to see this go to trial," he says. "I would love to be able to talk to someone about this."
Previously on Netscape:
Heather Kullorn Case UpdateThe Disappearance of Heather Kullorn