UNLIMITED

New Zealand Listener

Not like the old days

Nostalgia may be psychologically beneficial but it can also be harmful (“Bringing on back the good times”, June 22). One form of harmful nostalgia is exemplified by the Trumpist slogan “Make America great again” and the Brexit slogan “Take back control”.

This “good old days” nostalgia is harmful and, I believe, pernicious, because its proponents forget, or fail to recognise, that their “good old days” were probably bad old days for many, if not most, other people. In addition, it is pointless because conditions in the “good old days” were so different from present-day conditions that it would be impossible, or indeed dangerous and undesirable, to attempt to reinstate these conditions.

Another form of harmful nostalgia is suffered by those whose reflections on their past life are dominated by regret, remorse or anger about

previous actions which they or another person did or did not do. According to some definitions of nostalgia, such persons are not nostalgic, because they do not have “a fond remembrance of an earlier time in their life”. But they do have a desire to return to that earlier time, albeit one that is no less pointless or pernicious than that other

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from New Zealand Listener

New Zealand Listener1 min read
10 Quick Questions
❑ Arsenal ❑ Newcastle United ❑ Wolverhampton Wanderers ❑ Manchester City ❑ Documents ❑ Seeds ❑ DNA ❑ Fossils ❑ Issey Miyake ❑ Burberry ❑ Balenciaga ❑ Prada ❑ True ❑ False ❑ Pacific Ocean ❑ Atlantic Ocean ❑ Indian Ocean ❑ Arctic Ocean
New Zealand Listener3 min read
Turning Points
It was a lot like the fall of the Berlin Wall. Euphoria at the end of a repressive, authoritarian regime. No need to be careful about what you said to your mum on the phone any more in case someone was listening. But at the same time, there was anoth
New Zealand Listener5 min read
Winners (& Losers) On The Day
1. Which country won the most gold medals per capita at the Paris Olympics? A. Australia B. Dominica C. Grenada D. New Zealand E. San Marino F. St Lucia 2. Which cricket commentator said the following: “153 for 4, 153 all out. If someon

Related Books & Audiobooks

pFad - Phonifier reborn

Pfad - The Proxy pFad of © 2024 Garber Painting. All rights reserved.

Note: This service is not intended for secure transactions such as banking, social media, email, or purchasing. Use at your own risk. We assume no liability whatsoever for broken pages.


Alternative Proxies:

Alternative Proxy

pFad Proxy

pFad v3 Proxy

pFad v4 Proxy