Molly must deal with a broken heart on Halloween and seeks comfort from her family, who rather go all out for the holiday instead.

Molly finds a mix CD labeled "Songs About Her." She vows to find the boy who created the CD because she is convinced that he is her soulmate.

Molly and Grant clean out the attic during a day off from school and accidentally spill paint on their mother's wedding dress; Rick baby-sits the twins in their room, where they force their brother to participate in a humiliating tea party.