Primer 2 Nded
Primer 2 Nded
Primer 2 Nded
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER 1:
Goals for the Clerkship
CHAPTER 7:
Professionalism
CHAPTER 2:
How to Learn Most Effectively on the Internal Medicine Clerkship
CHAPTER 8:
Conclusion
CHAPTER 3:
Clinical Reasoning, Learning Theory, and the Core Competencies
APPENDIX 1:
If You Are Thinking About Internal Medicine
CHAPTER 4:
Suggestions for Sucess in the Inpatient Setting
APPENDIX 2:
Basic Clinical Denitions
APPENDIX 3:
The People With Whom You Will Work, Interact, and Learn During Your Internal Medicine Clerkship
CHAPTER 5:
How to Present a Patient
CHAPTER 6:
Suggestions for Success in the Ambulatory Setting
CO-AUTHORS:
University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey-Robert Wood Johnson Medical School
Anna Headly, MD
Patrick Nichols
Andrew R. Hoellein, MD
Suma Pokala, MD
Lucy Goddard
Cynthia H. Ledford, MD
3. 4.
5.
6. 7.
8. 9.
10. Always be enthusiastic. Be caring and conscientious and strive to deliver outstanding quality to your patients as you learn as much as you can from every experience.
INTRODUCTION Welcome to your internal medicine clerkship. We are genuinely delighted that you have joined us for this short period. During the clerkship, you will likely get only a small glimpse into the world of internal medicine. Nevertheless, through this experience, we expect that you will acquire fundamental skills, reinforce and expand your knowledge, and develop personally and professionally. We hope that this experience inspires you to learn and experience more of what internal medicine has to offer. Regardless of your future career path, we wish you the most exciting, stimulating, rewarding, and transforming experience possible over the coming weeks. The information in this booklet has been produced through the collaboration and consensus of internal medicine clerkship directors across the country, most of whom have spent many years teaching, evaluating, and advising students. Additionally, a substantial component of this book has come from the insights of students who recently completed their clerkship. We try to provide the most generic, reliable, tried and true approaches to the clerkship. We hope that this guide will provide you with knowledge and perspective that will last well beyond your internal medicine clerkship. It is important to note that information provided by your clerkship director should take precedence over these suggestions. ACKNOWLEDGMENT The purpose of this second edition is more to update than improve upon the initial primer. The original version was such an important addition to the tools available to help enhance the internal medicine clerkship that we were quite inspired and left much of it unchanged. The current editor and co-authors are deeply indebted to the original group of authors and, of course, Eric J. Alper, MD, the editor and mastermind behind the first edition, for providing us this wonderful template.
Disclaimer Any reference to a product in this book does not imply any endorsement of the product by CDIM or the editor and authors. Product references are only included to provide examples of resources and are not meant to be exhaustive lists of available material.
of that experience. Your clerkship director will provide a more specific guide to the duties and expectations of the site where you will be performing your rotation. The following expectations are common to all sites: Attend all clerkship activities on time. If you must be absent, get permission in advance. Dress professionally. The way you dress makes a statement about your school, hospital, and the medical profession; it will influence the way you are perceived by your patients and your colleagues. If you have any question about what constitutes professional dress, consult your clerkship director. Treat every member of the health care team, your colleagues on the clerkship team, and every patient with respect. Always introduce yourself, correctly identifying your role on the team as a medical student. Student doctor is a particularly useful description. Answer your pager and email in a reasonable time frame. Make sure your handwriting is legible and ensure every note includes your name, role, and pager number. Preserve confidentialitydo not discuss patients in public places and destroy all papers with patient-specific information that are not part of the medical record. Do not look in the chart (paper or electronic) of any patient for whom you are not caring.
Try to acquire all of the best lessons from your teachers. Much as they strive for perfection in every behavior and decision, your role models may not always be able to manage every situation in the best manner every time. Try to model their best skills and behaviors, while learning from their mistakes as well as your own.
It is important to gain broad knowledge about the spectrum of medical illnesses as it will be impossible for you to see patients with all conditions about which you need to learn during your clerkship. Follow a structured reading program. It is helpful to have an overview or concise textbook of medicine, which you can read from cover to cover, during the course of the clerkship such as the ACP-CDIM Internal Medicine Essentials for Clerkship Students, Cecil Essentials of Medicine, Paauws Internal Medicine Clerkship Guide, and the First Exposure to Internal Medicine books among others. A reference textbook of medicine, such as Harrisons Principles of Internal Medicine, Cecil Textbook of Medicine, or ACP Medicine, is recommended for most patient-related reading. Information about reading resources is available online at the AAIM may (www.im.org) and ACP (www.acponline.org) websites. Your clerkship director can provide specific recommendations about which books and resources are preferred locally. Students also need additional resources to read in greater depth; review articles from the literature or electronic resources are good resources to access. You may want access to pocket manuals for rapid reference (on bedside rounds or in the emergency department, for example). The Washington Manual of Medical Therapeutics is invaluable for formulating treatment plans and writing orders. Ferris Care of the Medical Patient and The 5-Minute Clinical Consult are also commonly used. These abbreviated resources can be purchased for electronic devices for slightly more than their print counterparts (www.skyscape.com has many titles). When it comes time to prepare for the clerkship final examination, many students use MKSAP for Students, an excellent resource produced by CDIM and ACP that contains questions with detailed explanations organized around the core CDIM training problems. ACPs Physician Information and Education Resource (PIER) is an electronic resource that provides evidence-based guidance for managing clinical problems. Access to PIER is free for ACP members; membership is free for students. UpToDate is another excellent electronic resource for investigating specific clinical questions. However, these resources will be less valuable for overview reading of larger clinical topics (an overview of congestive heart failure, for instance). Additionally, the Internet provides access to an enormous library of medical information as a rapid reference. It is always a good idea to start at your schools library website. Students should be self-directed learners and share what they have learned with their colleagues. This practice of continuous, ongoing learning will be necessary throughout your career. When you read, consider preparing a one-page summary; be prepared to present this synopsis to your team. If your attending or resident does not assign you a topic, pick a clinical subject that interests you and is relevant to at least one of the patients on your current team. If you are having trouble choosing a topic, ask for help from your attending or resident. If you have been given a specific topic to research, do not be afraid to ask for guidance. A concise, summative handout that you share with your team is a nice touch.
2. Systems Approach (also known as Universal Differential Diagnosis). Lists are generated based on pathophysiology or underlying mechanisms of disease processes. The categories/systems are:
Autoimmune Allergic/Immunologic Degenerative Drugs Endocrinologic Genetic/Congenital Iatrogenic Idiopathic Infectious Inflammatory Metabolic Neoplastic Nutritional Psychiatric Toxic Trauma/Mechanical Vascular
When using a mnemonic device to recall common lists in medicine, remember such lists are not all-inclusive. VINDICATE Vascular Infection/inflammatory Neoplasm Degenerative Iatrogenic Congenital/hereditary Autoimmune Toxic/metabolic Endocrine 3. Other sources of lists. With electronic access to information, it is easy to find sources of lists such as The 5Minute Clinical Consult, Ferris Instant Diagnosis, and UpToDate.
Forward Thinking Forward thinking refers to a problem-solving strategy that progressively adds more detail about the clinical problem to narrow the differential of diagnoses. It can often be illustrated as an algorithm. Example: Hyponatremia
Hyponatremia (Low Na)
Urine Na >20mEq/L
Urine Na >20mEq/L
Renal failure
The differential is based on adding characteristics of the syndrome to narrow the list of potential diagnoses, e.g., hyponatremia (as above), anemia (macrocytic, normocytic, or microcytic?) or gastrointestinal bleeding (upper or lower?). There are many common algorithms in clinical medicine. Experienced physicians group related diagnoses to develop their own algorithms that use branching logic to help solve clinical problems. Expert diagnosticians use branch points to guide clarifying questions while obtaining the history. Look for different forward thinking algorithms in basic medical textbooks and pocket manuals for the wards. Pattern Recognition Physicians often instantaneously recognize the patterns of diseases with which their patients present. Pattern recognition is a common strategy used in everyday life. When a nephew recognizes his great-aunt, it is instantaneous. He thinks, Great Aunt Minnie! He did not try a forward thinking approach Here is a little old lady with blue hair, orthopedic shoes, and an outrageous orange handbag. I know who this must be, my Great Aunt Minnie! He did not consider hypothesis testing: This is a little old lady. Could it be the Queen of England? Could it be my grandmother? When pattern recognition is used in medicine, the trigger for the
diagnosis is the disease, not the syndrome and not the symptom. The physician arrives at the diagnosis by instantaneously processing and synthesizing the patients clinical information to recognize that the patients presentation exactly matches the diseases illness script. To use this method of reasoning, the physician must have clinical experience; have an excellent knowledge base of classic disease illness scripts; be adept at processing, prioritizing, and synthesizing clinical information into the patients illness script; and use a compare and contrast mentality. Until a physician has a great deal of clinical experience, diagnostic errors can be made if pattern recognition is attempted prematurely. With this method, knowledge has become organized into complex networks, in which the multiple branching algorithms are interlinked. PUTTING IT ALL TOGETHER Students more efficiently arrive at an accurate differential and develop the knowledge organization to support more advanced problem-solving skills when they use a systematic approach to managing clinical information. The most common approach is to develop a problem list, synthesize a one-sentence summary, and then create a differential of potential diagnoses. The assessment and differential guides the plan to diagnose and treat the patient. While this approach is used by nearly all physicians, it is not necessarily communicated explicitly to students who are learning these skills. The following is a stepwise approach to solving clinical problems from problem list to a synthesized summary of the patients presentation. The Problem List Identify all problems or key features from the history and examination. Process the list into accurate and precise medical terminology o Process descriptively, e.g. dizziness like spinning becomes the more precise vertigo. o Process summatively, e.g. features such as chest pain, hypotension, S3 gallop, pulmonary edema, and poor perfusion combine to become chest pain with cardiogenic shock. Reduce the list o Remove redundancies. o Eliminate due to, e.g. eliminate the dyspnea due to the more specific problem of pleural effusion. o Drop nonspecific abnormalities, e.g. malaise in the patient with pneumonia. Prioritize the problems and identify how they relate, including key markers of severity or complications, e.g. mitral regurgitation complicating acute coronary syndrome. Identify which problems are unrelated to the primary presenting syndrome and separate these as problems of secondary importance. The One-Sentence Summary (Synthesis of Patients Presentation) Every attending physician will ask a student to give a short summary of the case either after a full presentation or in place of one. The student must interpret and synthesize many data points to arrive at this summary. The best one-sentence summary of a patients clinical situation concisely highlights the most pertinent features without omitting any significant points. The sentence should contain the following three key components: the patients epidemiology, the
temporal pattern, and a syndrome statement. When using this format, the summary models an illness script, the basic construct that physicians use to recall and recognize a disease. The classic disease illness script emphasizes (1) who gets it, (2) how does it present with respect to time, and (3) what key features are expected at presentation. Example: Summary of the Patients Presentation: Epidemiology: Who is this patient? o Include only the patient demographics, past medical history, and social and family history that make him/her at risk for diseases that present in this manner. o Omit demographics, past medical history, and social and family history that are unrelated to the current clinical situation. Temporal pattern: How did the symptoms and signs presenting with respect to time? o Describe the chronology of the presentation: Is it acute or chronic? Constant or intermittent? Is it worsening or improving? Syndrome statement: What are the key clinical features of the presentation? o Construct this phrase by combining, prioritizing, and relating the identified problems.
Common student mistakes are to include too much and irrelevant patient epidemiology, forget or fail to emphasize the temporal pattern, or accidentally omit or incorrectly state important parts of the syndrome. Model summary statement: Mrs. M. is an elderly woman with atrial fibrillation and heart failure, who presents with sudden onset right hemiparesis and dysarthria. The Differential Diagnosis A differential of diagnoses that commits to what is most likely and what is unlikely is developed by comparing the patients symptoms and findings to particular disease entities. To accurately match the patients presentation to the known patterns of diseases, physicians store and retrieve knowledge about how diseases present. The basic construct that physicians use to recall and recognize diseases in patients is the illness script. Classic Disease Illness Scripts: Epidemiology (who gets it) Temporal pattern (how it presents with respect to time) Syndrome statement (key clinical features present at the time of initial diagnosis) Other information about pathophysiology, therapies, late onset complications, and atypical presentations are anchored to uniform memory framework, while these three basic components remain at the core. How likely a disease is in a specific patient can be estimated by comparing the classic disease illness scripts to the individual patients presentation. The better the fit, the more likely the diagnosis under consideration is present. Prioritize the differential based on fit.
o Very likely diagnoses fit the epidemiology, temporal pattern, and syndrome. o Less likely diagnoses fit some, but not all key features of the patient; or the patient has only some of the key features of the disease. o Diagnoses relegated to unlikely match only one or a few symptoms or findings. Also, consider how common the disease is.
Always consider prevalence: a common disease is always more likely than a rare condition. In general, a patient is more likely to have a condition that is a common presentation of a common condition before an atypical presentation of a common disease or a typical presentation of a rare disease. An atypical presentation of a rare disease is much less likely. Internists love to consider rare diseases; after all, thinking of the disease is the first step to making the diagnosis. It is good to recognize and consider a rare disease, but put the disease likelihood into perspective by remembering the overall prevalence of the disease. In general:
Typical presentation of a common disease Atypical presentation of a common disease Typical presentation of a rare disease Atypical presentation of a rare disease
>
>
>
Physicians use the prioritized differential to guide the plan for the patient. A physician will test and/or treat for diagnoses that are most likely before those diagnoses that are unlikely. The only exception to this rule is for diagnoses that are potential emergencies, i.e., those that might kill a patient if missed in the first 24 hours. Myocardial infarction, pulmonary embolus, bacterial meningitis fit this definition. Therefore, physicians have a lowered threshold to test and treat for these diseases. SUMMARY Problem List (processing) Summary of (matching to diagnoses) Differential Patients Presentation
PERFORMING INPATIENT HISTORY AND PHYSICALS When new patients are assigned to your team, your initial responsibility will generally consist of performing a complete history and physical examination (H&P). The data you collect on your patient will likely be more detailed than that obtained by other team members. It is not at all unusual for the medical student to be the one who obtains a crucial piece of information that substantively changes the management of the patient. Although your initial workup should be thorough, it, does not automatically imply that it be long. Being concise without sacrificing thoroughness is an important skill that you will develop over time. Perform as many H&Ps on your own as possible. Whenever feasible, get to the patient before others do their evaluation. The H&P should be thorough, yet focused. The differential diagnosis for the patients problems should inform the questions you ask and the physical exam maneuvers you perform. Begin with open-ended questions and then narrow down to more specific questions as necessary. Gather a complete social history and review of systems.
While examining your patient, strive to proceed in a logical sequence that maximizes efficiency and minimizes patient discomfort. The old-fashioned head-to-toe method still works well for the large majority of patients. The inpatient admission examination should be complete and never confined to a single system. For example, in addition to examining the lungs and heart of a patient with shortness of breath, you should examine the neck for jugular venous distention; the extremities for edema, tenderness (DVT?) and clubbing; and the abdomen for splinting or masses. Perform examinations such as funduscopic exams, rectal examinations, and male and female genitourinary examinations (chaperoned) whenever possible.
THE WRITTEN HISTORY AND PHYSICAL EXAMINATION One of the major goals of the internal medicine clerkship is to learn how to communicate medical information and assessment via thorough, well-developed medical documentation. Writing H&Ps is an important skill and learning tool. Think of writing your H&P as a means to integrate all of the information you gather with what you know and what you read to form a coherent, informed argument of what you think is happening with the patient, why it is happening, and what diagnostic and therapeutic actions you want to take. There are many different ways of preparing an H&P and you should be open to suggestions. Be sure to carefully review any specific guidelines for written H&P provided by the clerkship. Eventually, you will develop your own style, but for now, stick to the stated expectations. Use a clear and concise writing style. Words that are not completely necessary are often left out. Just include the facts. Write your history of present illness (HPI) in a way that tells the patients chronology with all relevant details. When reading your HPI, others should be able to determine the diagnostic possibilities that you are considering and what is most likely. Write systematically, which will identify information you might have forgotten to gather. Document a thorough past medical history and complete medication list. This step is essential to providing safe, high quality care. Document general appearance and vital signs. Use only standard and widely accepted abbreviations; creative abbreviations confuse and slow the reader.
Never use dangerous abbreviations in the medication section (e.g., never qd, always daily; never g, always mcg; never U always units,). A complete list of abbreviations prohibited by the hospital at which you rotate should be available to you. Include laboratory data and results of diagnostic studies after recording your history and exam findings. Interpret the admitting ECG and document-specific findings (or lack thereof) from radiologic studies (e.g., CXR-no infiltrate or edema is better than CXR negative.) Write neatly. If no one can read what you have written, what good is it? Be sure to label, date, and sign each chart entry.
The assessment and plan (A/P) is always the most challenging and important section. You may want to discuss your thoughts with your resident before beginning. It is important to develop a complete, well-considered problem list for your patient. List all active problems in order of descending importance. Each problem should be considered as you write your assessment and plan. For each problem, your assessment should include a differential diagnosis (when appropriate), a statement demonstrating understanding of underlying pathophysiology, and a diagnostic and management plan. Do not use systems (e.g., respiratory, cardiac) as the headers for discussion in your A/P, regardless of what your resident may tell you. The risks of using this approach are that one problem may involve multiple systems (e.g., chest pain), and patients may have multiple problems within a single system (e.g., COPD, pneumonia, lung nodule). Except in critical care settings, a problem-based approach is much more effective and appropriate. For example, the headers for your discussion in the A/P would be:
Correct Chest pain Pneumonia Lung Nodule Incorrect Cardiac Infectious Diseases Oncologic
In some cases, the problem will be a symptom (abdominal pain); in other cases, when established by the data you have already collected, it will be a diagnosis (pancreatitis). As your understanding of the problem gets more refined, it should be renamed in the most accurate language possible. In your discussion, a list of differential diagnostic possibilities is not sufficient. Do not simply quote a textbook. You must articulate why you think that patient has specific diagnoses, citing data from the history, exam, and studies that support your thought process. ADDITIONAL SUGGESTIONS
Communicate Effectively with Patients and Their Families. You have the ability to make an important impact on the care and experience of your patient. You will likely spend more time with your patients than other members of the team. Your patients may see you as their primary provider, in effect, as their doctor. Spend additional time learning about who your patient is; understand his/her social, economic, and personal background and values. After diagnostic and therapeutic plans have been formulated, return to the bedside and discuss them with your patients. Do this initially with the assistance of your resident and attending. Feel free to have discussions with your patients. You will have the ability to comfort your patients during times of anxiety and fear. You will likely benefit from these discussions as much as your patients. Some sensitive discussions, such as disclosing very bad news, should be conducted by more senior members of the team, but you can still be available to provide additional information and support to the patient and family once this information has been presented. Discuss your role with your team and attending.
Show Competency with Patient Care Responsibilities. Be fully prepared and on time for work rounds every day and have all pertinent data available. Have a daily plan for each of your patients. Try to be the first one to get the important pieces of information about your patients and stay up-to-date on things that happen outside your purview. Have all notes and orders promptly co-signed. You may want to carry order sheets with you on rounds or text page the co-signing resident if using electronic order entry. Discuss the strategy with your team. With the guidance of your resident, contact and communicate with consultants as much as is possible and appropriate. Participate (including just watching) in as many procedures as possible, even if you are not following the patient. Try to accompany your patient to any diagnostic evaluations that occur during the hospital stay. Write admission orders on all patients that you admit. (Even if the intern has already completed this task, it is very instructive to write your own.) Learn about the other patients on your team. You should have at least a basic understanding of what is going on with all the patients on the team.
Integrate Fully into the Team. Clarify your role on the team. Ask what is expected of you and deliver it. Show your interest. Offer to help other members of your team with their patient care if you fulfill your other responsibilities. This cooperation will allow you to make a greater contribution to patient
care and give the team more time for teaching. Offer to research topics and contribute educational presentations in teaching conferences. Ask for guidance in your reading. Bring what you have learned back to the team. Ask questions when you cannot find the answers yourself. Ask for feedback. Respond to the feedback you receive.
o PE should contain report and describe information you gather by looking at, listening to, or touching the patient. o Do not put your conclusions or interpretation in the primary data section. Keep your presentation five to 10 minutes long (when given without interruptions). Do not interrupt your presentation to apologize for deficiencies in your information, ask questions of the attending, or make editorial asides about the patients story. It is best to keep it formal.
SPECIFIC COMPONENTS The History of Present Illness Generally, the HPI makes up 30-50% of the total presentation and is chronological, attentive to detail, and inclusive of pertinent positives and negatives. It should flow like a story and be free of tangents or editorial comments. Make sure to begin with an orienting statement that informs your audience of major demographics. For example, an 82-year-old nursing home resident differs greatly from a previously healthy 23-year-old college student or a 45-year-old liver transplant recipient. However, avoid the temptation to include a lengthy past history at this point. If there is information in the PMH, family history, social history, or review of systems that is vital to the case, it should be mentioned in the HPI. At this point, you will need to make hard decisions about pertinence. There are no rules for what should be mentioned and what should be left out. If a young person is presenting with chest pain, family history is pertinent; if a 90-yearold is presenting with pneumonia, it is not. Presenting the Rest of the Past Medical History, Family History, and Social History How much to include from the rest of the history depends on the time available to present the case and the purpose or teaching focus of the rounds. The managing team usually prefers to hear a concise listing of all medical conditions, medications, and allergies. Some attendings prefer to hear the social context that gives a picture of who the patient is as person. Consider the time available and audience to determine how much of these sections to include. Never present the review of systems in its entirety, which is better left to the written database. Presenting the Physical Exam The PE should be presented in an orderly manner, presenting enough information so that the listener knows your exam was thorough. A few things should always be included: General appearance (describe the patient vividly; paint a picture for the audience) Vital signs (never just stable) All abnormal findings Normal findings if they pertain to the patients major problems
Presenting Test Results Include only data that was available when the patient was admitted or when you formulated your assessment. If you like, you can give a follow-up at the end of the presentation. Include only the most important pieces of data, which may include normal studies. Never read through the whole list of results. Presenting the Summary Statement and the Assessment and Plan The summary statement is one or two sentences summing up the important aspects of the history, PE, and data findings. Translate the case into terms that characterize illnesses as much as possible at this point. Episodic severe unilateral throbbing headaches with a preceding aura goes a long way toward suggesting a specific diagnosis to anyone familiar with migraine. Each problem should then be addressed with its own assessment and plan. Your assessment should include a brief discussion of the major problem under diagnostic consideration, its differential diagnosis, and which diagnosis is most likely and why (using only the data you have just presented). For chronic medical conditions, assess the condition as specifically as possible, e.g. uncontrolled type 2 diabetes complicated by stage 3 diabetic nephropathy, retinopathy, and gastroparesis. Your plan should include the initial diagnostic and/or therapeutic strategies. The rationale for each element of the plan should have appeared in the preceding assessment. Be Prepared for the Discussion that Follows You should make sure that you are very knowledgeable about the differential and about the pathophysiology of the patients most likely diagnoses. If there is time, you may be asked to educate the audience about the patients problems.
How are test results communicated to the patient? How should you follow-up on test results?
In the outpatient setting, timing and efficiency are especially important. Because patients are scheduled for specific times, there is less flexibility than in the inpatient setting. When a patient requires, for example, 20 minutes more than allotted, that means the preceptor is 20 minutes behind for all patients that follow, unless time is made up with other patients. Some preceptors have a greater propensity and a greater tolerance for running behind, and this issue may vary with the day (e.g., if your preceptor needs to attend a meeting or pick up a child at daycare). Office-based preceptors generally recognize that having a student in the office usually adds some time to their day. Nevertheless, students should be sensitive to their preceptors efficiency and time demands, so that you will be able to help your preceptor meet personal and professional obligations as you meet yours. Further, if time permits, a way to give back may be to assist in coordinating services or counseling patients in preventive health matters such as diet, exercise, and smoking cessation. SUGGESTIONS FOR THE OUTPATIENT VISIT New Patients/Annual Check-Ups The structure of the new patient visit will vary in general and subspecialty clinics. Overall, you should collect a history of present illness if the patient has a chief complaint. If not, collect a past medical, surgical, gynecological, and psychiatric history as appropriate; inquire about medications, drug allergies, family history, and preventive health. The latter is of particular importance in the primary care clinic. You should ask about vaccination status, screening, vitamins, and alternative therapies. Follow-Up Clinic Visits Outpatients frequently do not have a chief complaint; they frequently have multiple complaints and conditions. As follow-up clinic visits are generally brief, you may not be able to cover all of the patients concerns in one visit. A physician must set an agenda with the patient that covers his or her most significant concerns as well as the physicians. Suggested Structure for the Outpatient Interview Prepare. Find out what the patients medical problems are by briefly reviewing the chart or discussing the history with your preceptor. Focus on highlights such as the problem list, flow sheets, and the most recent progress notes since you cannot read the entire chart in the time available. Negotiate an agenda: o Ask the patient what his or her concerns are. o Prioritize concerns by the problems that are most concerning to you and to the patient. o Tell the patient your agenda; most frequently, this prioritization will involve establishing the status of chronic medical problems. Dr. Smith tells me you have high blood pressure and diabetes. How are doing with your blood pressure and blood sugar? o When the patient has more concerns than can be covered, let the patient know that you would like to hear more about those concerns later. Lets talk some more about your chest pain and hypertension. Id like to hear more about your concerns about menopause but since we have a brief visit scheduled today, can we cover that in more detail at another time?
Gather the data: o Conduct a focused history with targeted review of systems. For example, in a patient with diabetes, you may want to ask about polyuria and polydipsia. o Perform a targeted yet appropriately thorough physical exam. Collect your thoughts: o What are the major issues? o What are the most likely differential diagnoses? o Do you have time to quickly read up on your patients complaint? o What is your assessment and plan? Present the case: o Identify the patient: Mr. Smith is a 50-year-old man with hypertension and diabetes who presents for a routine three-month follow-up. o Review the agenda: In addition to reviewing his chronic medical problems, the patient also wanted to discuss left knee pain. o Present the problem list: Knee pain: The patient has had knee pain for six months. It is worsened by Diabetes: home blood sugars (average, lowest reading, highest reading), last eye exam, foot care, etc. Hypertension Health maintenance o Present the physical examination. o Present your assessment: Overall, Mr. Smith is doing well. His diabetes and hypertension are adequately controlled. The differential diagnosis for his knee pain is osteoarthritis, gout, and pseudogout. I think it is most likely o Present your plan: For his knee pain, x-rays will help to confirm the diagnosis of OA. He can try Tylenol for the pain. We should avoid NSAIDS in diabetic patients, if possible. For his diabetes, check hemoglobin A1C, etc. For his hypertension For his health maintenance o Discuss follow-up appointments and referrals. Follow through: check test results and communicate them to the patient as arranged with your preceptor.
A learner-centered approach to the presentation that can be useful is the SNAPPS model: Summarize briefly the history and findings. Narrow the differential to two or three relevant possibilities. Analyze the differential by comparing and contrasting the possibilities. Probe the preceptor with questions about uncertainties, difficulties, or alternative approaches. Plan management for the patients medical issues. Select a case-related issue for self-directed learning.
CHAPTER 7: PROFESSIONALISM
The development of professionalism is an explicit and important goal of your clerkship. In 2002, the American Board of Internal Medicine Foundation, American College of Physicians Foundation, and the European Federation for Internal Medicine wrote a charter on professionalism that has gained widespread support (see the charter at www.abimfoundation.org). It starts by stating that professionalism is the basis of medicines contract with society. Society gives the profession of medicine the responsibility of selfregulation to maintain our high standards. If we are not good stewards of this responsibility, society may take the privilege of self-regulation away. The fundamental principles of professionalism are primacy of patient welfare, patient autonomy, and social justice. The charters set of professional responsibilities are a commitment to: Professional competence. Honesty with patients. Patient confidentiality. Maintaining appropriate relations with patients. Improving quality of care. Improving access to care. A just distribution of finite resources. Scientific knowledge. Maintaining trust by managing conflicts of interest. In daily professional life, some of these principles are occasionally at odds with one another; in these situations, a physician must recognize and effectively negotiate conflicts between competing professional values. To face these professionalism dilemmas most effectively, a physician must understand his or her personal limitations, including what triggers high stress or high emotions. Recognizing when you are under stress or not at your best is the first step toward maintaining resiliency in professionalism. The language and conduct of residents and other physicians that you observe convey powerful messages about the culture of hospital wards and clinics. Often referred to as the informal or hidden curriculum, its impact should not be underestimated. Be aware that you will likely be influenced greatly by this aspect of clinical training often not in the best of ways. Since you are so new to this culture, it is particularly easy for you to assimilate these norms. Through a mindful and self-reflective approach, you can better manage that impact and keep more to the values and ideals that you brought with you to medical school. There are a number of ways to grow your level of professionalism over the course of the clerkship. Do your best to get to know your patients well. Understand who they are. Treat every patient as you would hope your family member would be treated. As you invest in your patient, they will invest in you, which will allow you to experience something that you
may not have beforea true therapeutic relationship. Follow your patients over time; find out how they are doing after they left the hospital service.
Be an advocate for your patient whenever necessary. Discover for yourself what Francis W. Peabody, MD, articulated: the secret of the care of the patient is in caring for the patient. Reflect actively on your actions and experiences on a regular basis. After each interaction, especially when you find you are have strong emotions, spend some time considering and analyzing what you have experienced. Write it down. Discuss your thoughts with your peers and advisors. Have empathy for others- your patients, your colleagues, and everyone who is part of the health care team. Always ask: Why might a reasonable person do this? Be honest with yourself and others. It is honorable to say, I dont know, but I will find out. Work to improve the quality of the system in which you work. Every medical system has weaknesses, gaps, inefficiencies, and processes that allow errors to occur. Every individual will be faced with stressful situations in which he may not be at his best. Be a part of the solution. Consider ways that the system might be improved and pass them along. Learn from mistakesyours and others. You will make mistakes, in medical decisions and in professional behaviors. As a learner, you do not yet have all the knowledge and skills to practice independently or to be professionally resilient. Strive to never make the same mistake twice. Share your experiences with your colleagues, so they can share in your learning.
If any problems occur during your clerkship, let your clerkship director know as early as possible. The clerkship director is your advocate and your coach through a tough situation.
CHAPTER 8: CONCLUSION
The internal medicine clerkship is one of the most important experiences of medical school. Regardless of what specialty training you ultimately pursue, you will unquestionably advance your knowledge and skills during this clerkship. Ultimately, we will view this as a successful clerkship experience if it makes you a better caregiver, improves your skills, helps you become more professional, improves your confidence, and guides you in career choices. You will be one step further to what you ultimately become a skilled, caring, knowledgeable physician in the area of your choice. You will only have one opportunity to learn from this internal medicine clerkship. As much as we may try to make experiences consistent, no two medicine clerkships are ever the samefrom school to school or from student to student. You, your patients, your team, your preceptors and attendings, and your hospital and clinics will ultimately determine the outcome of the experience. The clerkship will shape you, even if in small ways. We encourage you to do everything that you can to make the very most of this experience. We hope that this handbook has served as a guide of how to do exactly that. While you will likely face frustrations in dealing with uncertainty and emotional challenges when your patients health fails, we wish you the very best experience possible. If you do not find the clerkship exhilarating and fun most of the time, then something is not right. Let your clerkship director know so that changes can be made to get things back on track. We genuinely feel privileged to accompany and guide you on this important professional journey.
recognize the desire to build a family and to preserve personal time. Many people within internal medicine achieve the desired level of balance between professional and personal life. HOW WELL ARE INTERNISTS AND SUBSPECIALISTS OF INTERNAL MEDICINE REIMBURSED? We ultimately hope that our future physicians will choose a career based on the enjoyment and satisfaction that the field produces, as this will likely produce long-term fulfillment. However, compensation is an important variable most students consider. Data on compensation of various specialties are widely available; we have not included them here due to space limitations. A review of these data demonstrate that internists earn compensation to support a very comfortable lifestyle; some subspecialties earn more than others, particularly in the private sector; and compensation for internal medicine and its subspecialties is on par with other major specialties. WHAT DOES AN INTERNAL MEDICINE RESIDENCY CONSIST OF? Internal medicine is a three-year residency program. There are two main types of internal medicine residencies: categorical (or traditional) and primary care. You may find additional tracks of residencies (e.g., womens health and hospital medicine), but these are the most common. Generally, categorical residencies are more heavily hospital-based. Residents spend most of their time on hospital medical wards, in intensive care units, in subspecialty services, in the outpatient setting, and in the emergency department. All internal medicine residents have a continuity clinic in which they follow their own patients (with supervision) over time. Continuity clinics are required to occur at least one session (approximately four hours) per week, regardless of the residents monthly rotation assignment. In primary care tracks, medical residents spend a higher percentage of their time in the outpatient setting, especially after their internship year. Regardless of the track, residents can still choose a variety of career options at the end of training, including an outpatient or hospitalist practice or further training in a subspecialty. In the majority of internal medicine programs, the internship year is the most intense year of training with the most months of direct patient care and fewest electives. During direct patient care months, there is virtually always in-house backup from an upper-level resident. Call schedules vary from program to program, but they tend to range from every fourth to sixth day on call. In the second and third years of an internal medicine residency, residents have progressively more independence and more time for elective rotations, during which residents have more flexibility in their schedules. Some residents choose to do research, some choose clinical electives on site, and some travel elsewhere. There tends to be a fair amount of flexibility to the training as a whole. HOW DIFFICULT IS IT TO GET INTO AN INTERNAL MEDICINE RESIDENCY PROGRAM? Top internal medicine programs remain extremely competitive. Students who match at top internal medicine programs often have sustained superior clinical performance on their
clerkships and fourth-year rotations, obtained Alpha Omega Alpha (AOA) Honor Medical Society status, scored well on the United States Medical Licensing Examination Step I and Step II, and secured strong letters of recommendation. However, for the majority of applicants and the majority of programs, it remains a buyers market with students who perform well typically entering a program of their choice. Because there are more internal medicine positions than any other positions, the current supply of internal medicine positions is greater than the demand from applicants. Therefore, overall it is not difficult to find a very good position in internal medicine. Internal medicine residencies typically offer a comprehensive teaching program and extensive supervision by skilled physicians; therefore, you do not need to attend the very top competitive programs to become very well prepared in internal medicine. WHAT COMBINED INTERNAL MEDICINE PROGRAMS ARE THERE? It is possible to complete a combined residency with internal medicine and other areas such as pediatrics, emergency medicine, family practice, preventative medicine, and psychiatry. These combined programs offer dual board certification eligibility with fewer years of residency than internal medicine (three years) and the corresponding specialty put together (e.g., pediatrics is three years; however, most medicine-pediatrics residency programs last four years). There are some benefits and some disadvantages of pursuing a combined program. Some physicians feel students should pick one specialty and focus on it. Others support building careers by taking advantage of the overlap between the combined specialties. For example, some residents in medicine-pediatrics are interested in pursuing a career in adolescent medicine, while others plan to subspecialize and see patients of all ages in that subspecialty. For instance, a medicine-pediatrics specialist could further subspecialize in cardiology and focus on congenital heart disease. Some medicine-emergency medicine residents choose this route because they are interested in having an ambulatory practice in addition to working shifts in an emergency department. Some internal medicine-psychiatry residents select this training to prepare them to care for mental illness in medically complicated patients. Some residents in combined programs choose the longer training period to maintain options for career flexibility. IM INTERESTED! WHAT SHOULD I DO? Keep your mind open during all your clerkships. Actively consider what it is that you enjoy and that you can envision doing for the rest of your professional career. Work hard. Express enthusiasm for your work. Read actively and frequently. Embrace opportunities for patient care, learning, and presenting. Learn more about internal medicine. ACP has prepared a number of resources for students who are considering entering internal medicine. (www.acponline.org)
Finally, identify an internal medicine advisor who can give you guidance about how to proceed as you plan your fourth-year courses, complete your residency applications, and conduct successful residency interviews.
If you remain unsure at the end of your clerkship, as many people do, do not get anxious. Your fourth year should allow you substantial opportunities to experience different aspects of internal medicine and other fields, and for most students, these additional rotations are helpful in determining career choice. Use an advisor who knows you well to help you find direction.
Program Director: A physician who assumes ultimate responsibility for the residency program. Responsibilities include program credentials, training certification of graduating residents, annual schedules, and the residents emotional/behavioral well-being. Residents/Trainees/Housestaff: Residents have completed their medical school training, have their doctoral (MD or DO) degree, but are not yet eligible for autonomous practice. All postgraduate students must complete a residency in the area of their choice; residency in internal medicine is traditionally three years in duration. Residents are typically described by the year of their training. For example, a junior resident is a resident in their second postgraduate year (PGY-2). A senior resident is typically PGY-3. Rounds: There are several different types of rounds. Rounds most typically refers to morning walk rounds or work rounds, during which the team will see all the patients on the service. Rounds typically include briefly reviewing the patients history, the status of active problems, the medications that the patient is taking, and the vital signs or intake/output for the previous 24 hours. These reviews are followed by patient interviews and examinations. Ideally, the plan for the day will be determined. Pre-rounds is typically an individual activity in which the student will see all of his or her patients and gather information prior to the entire team visit. Attending rounds is commonly the term for a teaching session in which the team will discuss cases and learn from their patients with the teams attending. Sub-intern or acting intern: A fourth-year medical student preparing for residency, working as independently as possible but with resident supervision to provide direct patient care. Subspecialists: Internists who practice a specialty other than general internal medicine. A number of subspecialties exist within internal medicine, including: Allergy and Immunology Geriatric Medicine Cardiology Nephrology Endocrinology Oncology Infectious Diseases Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine Hematology Rheumatology Many of these subspecialties have additional paths of specialization, for example, invasive cardiology or hepatology.
APPENDIX 3: THE PEOPLE YOU WILL WORK WITH, INTERACT WITH, AND LEARN FROM DURING YOUR INTERNAL MEDICINE CLERKSHIP
In addition to the resident and faculty physicians, you will work with many other people during your internal medicine clerkship. All of these people are part of a large multidisciplinary team that participates in the care of patients. There is an interdependency of all members to do their jobs well to take the most effective care of patients; therefore, it is important to be able to work well with all of these extended team members. Ancillary staff includes the many additional non-physician providers who may interact with your patients: IV therapists place saline locks and more durable longer lines.
Occupational therapists evaluate patients fine motor and cognitive skills to determine their abilities to effectively care for themselves. PharmDs reconcile drug lists, provide patient education regarding new medications, and help monitor certain drugs (heparin drips, peak/trough antibiotic levels). Phlebotomists draw blood. Physical therapists prescribe exercises and evaluate strength and balance to determine if patients can safely return home. Speech therapists evaluate patients abilities to swallow in the event of neurologic injury or muscular weakness of the oropharynx.
Case managers are typically nurses or social workers whose primary responsibility is to assist the provider team with achieving timely and appropriate discharge of patients. They are invaluable in securing outside services, coordinating follow-up, and getting patients screened for placement in rehabilitation facilities or nursing homes. Nurses are responsible for safely and promptly executing the plan of care and are the first line in addressing patients emotional needs while hospitalized. They administer almost all medications, coordinate transportation, educate, and discharge. If something needs to get done rapidly for the patient, it is best to discuss it directly with the patients nurse. Nurses aides, or patient care aides, are assistants to nurses. Nurses aids may have a variety of responsibilitieslifting or moving patients, measuring and recording vital signs or blood sugars, drawing blood, bathing, toileting, ambulating, and feeding patients. Unit secretaries are stationed at the front of the ward. They are responsible for answering phones, responding to patient calls, and perhaps most importantly, transcribing orders. In most hospitals (those that do not have computerized provider order entry), the secretary will transcribe orders into a computer system or onto paper medication administration records. The unit
secretaries will likely know if blood has been drawn, if a patient has left the floor, or if a test has been ordered. It is very important to understand the role of each member of the team and effectively communicate with all of them so that patients receive the most effective care. Finally, you will be working with patients. While autonomy and confidentiality are principles that must always be honored, realize that often patients invite family members or others very close to them to play a central role in their health care. These individuals also need and deserve your care and attention. It bears noting that your patients will come from all walks of life and may have very different abilities or styles of communication. Some will not speak the same language. Since the stresses of illness can bring out the worst in people, some may be angry or offensive while others may be entitled and demanding. Some may be severely disabled or unable to communicate at all. At times, it may be tempting to pass judgment on those we treat. Strive at all times to follow Maimonides recommendation: May I never see in the patient anything but a fellow creature in pain.
2501 M Street, NW Suite 550 Washington, DC 20037 T: (202) 861-9351 F: (202) 861-9731 E: Publications@im.org W: www.im.org/AAIM/Pubs
CDIM is a member of the Alliance for Academic Internal Medicine. 2008 Clerkship Directors in Internal Medicine