Eli 08167 B
Eli 08167 B
Eli 08167 B
Digital Storytelling
Tips and Resources
Table of Contents
I. Digital Storytelling: An Overview .......................................................................2 What is Digital Storytelling? ....................................................................................2 How is Digital Storytelling Relevant to Teaching & Learning? ........................................2 II. Digital Storytelling Assignments: Tips and Suggestions ....................................4 Resources for Assignment Development and Assessment ............................................6 Story-Making Tools and Tool Reviews .......................................................................8 Open Sources for Music and Images ......................................................................8 III. Sample Lesson Sequence and Collateral Materials ...........................................9 Sample Rubric..................................................................................................... 11 Sample Peer/Faculty Feedback Form ...................................................................... 13 Sample Storyboards............................................................................................. 14 Storyboard Form ................................................................................................. 15 IV. A Webography of Digital Storytelling.............................................................. 16 Portals and Centers.............................................................................................. 16 Story as a Tool for Social Justice and Change .......................................................... 17 Family and Community......................................................................................... 17 Language and Literature ....................................................................................... 19 Story and Ethnicity .............................................................................................. 20 Story and History ................................................................................................ 21
Digital Storytelling and Science Education: While digital storytelling is most often associated with the arts and humanities, it can also be an effective strategy for learning in the sciences. For example, as part of their Masters in Science Education program through Lesley University, program participants are asked to share and compare personal experience narratives about motion in the first week of a fully-online Physics course. As participants learn more about the physics of motion in subsequent weeks, they are asked to reflect back on their motion stories using physics to explain forces and identify recurring motion signatures. Later in the course, they translate motion narratives (some written and others presented as digital movies) into acceleration graphs. Digital Storytelling in the Arts, Humanities, and Social Sciences: Digital storytelling provides rich opportunities for self-reflection. For example, students in an education course may be asked to write narratives about a memorable learning experience, and then analyze the stories to identify common criteria in positive (or discouraging) learning experiences. Digital storytelling is also a powerful tool intercultural learning. Students can compare their stories with those authored by people from other culture and other life experiences. In so doing, fundamental assumptions can be challenged, questioned, or even reconsidered. People with diverse life experiences can also collaborate across great geographical distances to co-author digital stories that reflect multiple cultural perspectives. The links in this booklet provide a range of high-quality digital storytelling sites. Browse the lists to see the range of things that can be done with the medium. In addition, you may want to integrate a few relevant sites into your coursework students can begin the assignment by reading the stories of others, then compose their own on a related topic (or develop a story about their reactions to stories of others). NOTE: If you are interested in incorporating digital storytelling into courses you teach, Instructional Designers are available at PTRC for consultation on how to best implement your ideas. In addition, the PTRC offers training workshops on software that is useful for creating digital stories: iMovie, Photoshop, Flash, and Dreamweaver.
The Assignment
The more planning you encourage students to do up front, the better and more time efficient the story development will be. This is because it takes only minutes to rearrange words and images on index cards or paper, but it can be very time consuming to rearrange and edit clips in iMovie. Because this is a new experience for most people, its helpful to provide students with a rubric up front so that they know the criteria for success. In addition to the rubric included in this booklet, the Georgetown Universitys Crossroads project also provides sample rubrics (http://crossroads.georgetown.edu/vkp/newsletter/0902/resources.htm#gr). Its important to build periodic progress reviews into the assignment timeline. This will allow you to intervene if a project is off-track or floundering, or to offer feedback that will help students create a story that is both intellectually and visually engaging. We recommend that you divide the assignment into the following phases: Brainstorming: Students share their ideas with others in the class (sometimes called a story circle). Peers and instructor ask questions and help each other refine their ideas. Scripting: Students author a 200-300 word script that will become the audio for their stories. Peers and instructor can ask questions and provide feedback on the script as well. Storyboarding: Using a comic strip format, students show how the words in their scripts will synch up with the images they plan to use in their stories. Time permitting, this is another opportunity for feedback. Recording and Editing: This is where the piece comes together Fine Tuning and Titling: Students add transitions, titles, and credits. Its important for this to come last, as transitions can change the timing of a piece. Burning: Students export their projects and burn them to CD or DVD at least one copy for the student and another for the teacher.
Digital Storytelling Tips and Resources, Page 5
Sharing: Its important to schedule a final screening so that students can present and discuss their work. This is where some of the most important reflective learning takes place!
We also recommend that you create a space within Simmons eLearning for student work, such as a learning module or a folder. The space can include the assignment timeline, rubric, information about fair use, links to Creative Commons-licensed images and audio, links to iMove tutorials, as well as links to exemplary stories. If you include an assignment drop-box or discussion board, students can upload storyboards, script drafts, and proposed images for faculty and/or peer feedback. This will also help ensure that students show up at the media lab with the materials they need to produce their stories.
Middlebury Community Digital Storytelling Collaborative https://segue.middlebury.edu/index.php?action=site&site=collaborative Ohler, Jason Digital Storytelling Overview http://www.jasonohler.com/storytelling Handouts http://www.jasonohler.com/resources/handouts.cfm Widson Lists http://www.jasonohler.com/resources/educwisdom.cfm Photobus: Digital Storytelling Tutorial http://www.photobus.co.uk/dstory_pages/find.html Shewbridge, Bill Intergenerational Storytelling as Process and Product http://www.nercomp.org/data/media/NERCOMP%202007.ppt Spinning Yarns Around the Digital Fire http://www.firstmonday.org/issues/issue9_1/huffaker Rubistar http://rubistar.4teachers.org Tip: In the "Find a Rubric" section, enter the keywords "digital storytelling," search type "match all of your words" Thinking Spaces: Handouts (Templates, Revision Strategies, Elements of Narrative) http://www.thinkingspaces.org/resources_handouts.html Visible Knowledge Project: Learning Technology Inquiry http://crossroads.georgetown.edu/vkp/newsletter/0902/resources.htm Visible Knowledge Project: Three Types of Grading Rubrics for Digital Stories http://crossroads.georgetown.edu/vkp/newsletter/0902/resources.htm#gr
Week V: In class, students do a "walk about" during which teams present their PowerPoint storyboards to one another. During each presentation, peers fill out a storyboard feedback form to provide each other with written feedback. Students use the feedback to revise and resubmit their storyboards/scripts. By the end of the week, students have shown their script/storyboard to people at the service learning placement to make sure they're okay with the plan. Students submit the revised version of their storyboard and their script. Week VI until the Final Week: Students record audio, scan/process images, and use iMovie to produce their story. Work sessions (out of class) are scheduled in the P113 computer lab with the PTRC trainer on hand to assist with story production. Last Session of Class: Celebrate in class, homegrown film festival, including popcorn. Students burn their stories onto DVDs. Videos are also uploaded to the web so that future classes can benefit from viewing their work. After Class: Students screen their digital stories at their Service Learning placements and each placement receives a copy.
Sample Rubric
Because this is a new type of assignment, you may wonder how its quality will be assessed. A "rubric" is a set of criteria for assessing quality and targeting areas for improvement. The digital case rubric below is the framework within which your final assignment will be judged. You may want to refer to it often as you develop your script and storyboard -- it will help you stay on track and come up with ideas for improvements.
CATEGORY1 Excellent Point of View
- Purpose Establishes a purpose early on and maintains a clear focus throughout. It is clear that the authors care about their video and feel that they have something important to communicate. Strong awareness of audience/viewer in the design. Students can clearly explain why they felt the vocabulary, audio and graphics chosen fit the target audience. Content is engaging -- viewer is left with thought-provoking ideas and/or the story develops in a way that's different from initial expectations. Useful for prompting discussion and dialogue. Establishes a purpose early on and maintains focus for most of the presentation. There are a few lapses in focus, but the purpose is fairly clear. It is difficult to figure out the purpose of the presentation.
Good
Satisfactory
Needs Improvement
- Audience
Some awareness of audience in the design. Students can partially explain why they felt the vocabulary, audio and graphics chosen fit the target audience. Content is interesting -viewer is left with thought-provoking ideas and/or the story develops in a way that's different from initial expectations.
Some awareness of audience in the design. Students find it difficult to explain how the vocabulary, audio and graphics chosen fit the target audience. Some surprises and/or insights, but realization barely differs from the expectation.
Dramatic Question
Predictable and not very interesting. Realization and expectation do not differ.
Script/Voice
- Script Compelling and well written -concise use of words to make important points. Deftly integrates course themes into the video (e.g., cultural diversity, multiple perspectives on a topic, integrative thinking across disciplines). Integrates at least one quote from course readings -- not tacked on, but integral to the meaning of the piece. Voice quality is clear and consistently audible throughout the presentation. If music is used, it enhances the piece and matches the story line. Well written -- makes important points. Speaks to some of the course themes (e.g., cultural diversity, multiple perspectives on a topic, integrative thinking across disciplines). Integrates at least one quote from course readings. Voice quality is clear and consistently audible throughout the majority (85-95%) of the presentation. If music is used, it matches the story line. Occasionally speaks too fast or too slowly for the story line. The pacing (rhythm and voice punctuation) is relatively engaging for the audience. Adequately written, but sometimes meanders or is confusing. Addresses at least one course theme (e.g., cultural diversity, multiple perspectives on a topic, integrative thinking across disciplines). Uses at least one quote from course readings. Difficult to understand the point. Doesn't address course themes. Doesn't reference course readings.
- Audio
Voice quality is clear and consistently audible through some (70-84%) of the presentation. If music is used, it is not distracting -but it also does not add much to the story. Tries to use pacing (rhythm and voice punctuation), but it is often noticeable that the pacing does not fit the story line. Audience is not consistently engaged.
Voice quality needs more attention. If music is used, it is distracting, too loud, and/or inappropriate to the story line. No attempt to match the pace of the storytelling to the story line or the audience.
- Pacing
The pace (rhythm and voice punctuation) fits the story line and helps the audience really "get into" the story.
Emotion
Emotional dimension of the piece Emotional dimension of matches the story line well. the piece somewhat Viewers are encouraged to care matches the story line. about the topic, person, organization, etc. Illuminating: Images create a distinct atmosphere or tone that matches different parts of the story. The images may communicate symbolism and/or metaphors. The meaning of the story is transformed by the use of images. Interpretive: Images create an atmosphere or tone that matches some parts of the story. The images may communicate symbolism and/or metaphors. The story relies on images to convey meaning. The story composition is typically good, though it seems to drag somewhat OR need slightly more detail in one or two sections.
Emotional dimension of the piece is distracting (over the top) and/or does not add much to the story. Illustrative: An attempt was made to use images to create an atmosphere/tone but it needed more work. Image choice is logical. Images are decorative -- the story is not altered by the use of images.
Emotional dimension of the piece is inappropriate OR absent. Inappropriate: Little or no attempt to use images to create an appropriate atmosphere/tone. Images interfere or are at crosspurposes with the story's meaning. The story needs extensive editing. It is too long or too short to be interesting. People, organizations, quotes, and contributors are not comprehensively credited.
Images
Economy
The story is told with exactly the right amount of detail throughout. It does not seem too short nor does it seem too long.
The story seems to need more editing. It is noticeably too long or too short in more than one section.
Credit
All people, organizations, quotes, There is no in between ideas, music, and contributors are appropriately credited. Permission has been obtained (or Creative Commons license information provided) for images and audio not created by the author.
Rubric categories adapted from the Center for Digital Storytelling's "Seven Elements of Digital Storytelling" as outlined in the Digital Storytelling Cookbook.
Criteria
Has A Point (of View)
- purpose - stance
Assessment/Feedback
Outstanding Satisfactory Poor Why? (Include Suggestions for Improvement)
Engaging
- interesting - surprising - thought-provoking
Quality Script/Voice
- well spoken - good pacing - music, if any, furthers message
Use of Images/Video
- combined w. voice, adds new insight - visual flow
Sample Storyboards
Storyboarding and script-writing are the steps that students most frequently give short shrift, or even skip altogether. But be forewarned that, without advance thought and planning, the amount of time students will need for production increases exponentially. In addition, stories created without planning, feedback, and revision, are usually of lesser quality both in terms of production value and substance. Storyboards can be presented in a range of formats: rough sketches, 3x5 cards, presentation slides (e.g., Keynote or PowerPoint), or word-processed (e.g., Word or Rich Text Format). Below are links to examples. The next page provides a basic storyboard. Examples: Arrive Alive Advertisement Campaign http://www.savemolives.com/southeast/documents/BOTBStoryboardSample07.doc Knight Digital Media Center (Berkeley) http://multimedia.journalism.berkeley.edu/tutorials/reporting/starttofinish/storyboarding Ohio State Women and Technology Program http://accad.osu.edu/womenandtech/Storyboard%20Resource Studio 1151, Maricopa Community Colleges http://www.mcli.dist.maricopa.edu/authoring/studio/guidebook/storyboard_example.html World Affairs, Beyond Islam Curriculum www.world-affairs.org/globalclassroom/curriculum/BeyondIslam/Unit1_Pakistan/O_Storyboard.doc
Storyboard Form
Story Title:______________________________________________ Page #:____ Author/Group: _____________________________________________________
Beyond Words http://www.digitales.us/gallery/gallery_beyond_words.php Fray http://www.fray.com Founded by Derek Powazek, The Fray is a blog-like online publication devoted to the art of the personal story real people telling true stories in real time. A new feature story is posted approximately once a month, and each one ends with a posting area where you can respond to the piece with your story. KQED Digital Storytelling Initiative http://dsi.kqed.org/index.php/projects Sound Portraits http://soundportraits.org Site is dedicated to telling stories that bring neglected American voices to a national audience. StoryCorps http://storycorps.net A collection of stories recorded in Story Booths, at first in New York Citys Grand Central Station and subsequently in booths located in mobile units at sites across the nation. As opposed to professional interviews, StoryCorps stories are usually excerpts from interviews between family members or close friends, lending a warmth and intimacy to the narratives.
Bubbes Back Porch http://www.bubbe.com Web site by Abbe Don that is a collection of stories about grandmothers. California Stories (CA Council for the Humanities) http://www.calhum.org Projects for this storytelling initiative include: "Living on the Dime" (Inland Mexican Heritage) http://www.mexicanheritage.org/dime.htm Stories associated with life along highway I-10 From Generation to Generation: Making a Life in South Los Angeles, 1940-2005 http://www.socallib.org/generations Community Arts Network: Connecting Californians http://www.communityarts.net/concal/concal.php Connecting Californians is the report of a research project exploring story as a powerful means of building community. The report was developed out of a tenmonth public conversation at the intersection of the arts, the humanities, grassroots narrative and community organizing. This report presents the findings of that inquiry, some questions for the future and a potential program design. NOTE: Community Arts Network sponsors a range of other projects related to storytelling. Indivisible: Stories of American Community http://www.indivisible.org Through photographs and recorded voices, Indivisible focuses on the real-life stories of struggle and change in twelve communitiesfrom Delray Beach, Florida, to Ithaca, New York; from the North Pacific Coast of Alaska to Chicagos Southwest side; from the Rio Grande Valley in Texas to the Yaak Valley, Montana. Montana Heritage Project http://www.edheritage.org MHP is dedicated to teaching young people to think clearly and deeply about the world they face. Students are asked to explore their community its place in national and world events, its relationship to the natural environment, and its cultural heritage as expressed in traditions and celebrations, literature and arts, economic practices, responses to crises, and everyday life. The Telling Takes Us Home: A Celebration of American Family Stories http://americanfamilystories.org/stories Joe and Paula McHugh have been doing work with stories and identity especially connected with social issues. The site includes a range of audio recordings of stories about critical life experiences: becoming a mail order bride, surviving the holocaust, caring for sick and dying relatives, etc. Swapping Stories http://www.arlington.k12.va.us/instruct/swapping_stories
This site outlines a process by which intergenerational gatherings of people pair off, discuss, then come back to the group and tell each others stories. For example, an older Jewish man may tell the story of a Salvadoran youth, and then the Salvadoran youth tells the story of the Jewish man's experience as a child in a concentration camp. Wisconsin Weather Stories http://cimss.ssec.wisc.edu/wi_weather_stories The site includes MP3s and transcripts of people telling stories about their severe weather experiences in snowstorms, flooding, and storms on the Great Lakes. Most of these were recorded by 7th and 8th graders who live in towns on the southern shore of Lake Superior. As they continue to pull the site together, more about regional identities reflected through weather stories will emerge.
In the spirit of Brazilian cordel (string) poets who hold forth in marketplaces with their poetry chapbooks strung across stalls, the Peoples Poetry Gathering stretches a clothesline of poems from around the world across the streets of Lower Manhattan. Includes a virtual gathering of storytellers Points of Entry: Crosscurrents in Storytelling Journal http://www.pointsofentry.org This journal encourages narrative writing in journalism by exploring crosscurrents in storytelling in reporting, fiction, and oral tradition.
A portal site for Cambodian people who immigrated elsewhere (often as refugees) includes online discussions, interviews, and stories written by Cambodian immigrants. Masters of Ceremony http://www.ohs.org/exhibitions/moc/shell.htm Stories about rites of passage among people from Oregon (represents a range of cultures, including: Latina, Native American, and Palestinian) Swapping Stories: Folktales from Louisiana http://www.lpb.org/programs/swappingstories/stories.html Includes transcripts, translations from Creole to English, and clips from recorded storytelling sessions with people from Louisiana.
This site includes guidelines for assessing and evaluating oral history narratives including online sites. Private Art http://www.private-art.com This site is a collection of letters to and from Private Arthur Pranger during WWII the letters are juxtaposed with historic memorabilia to tell the soldiers story. September 11th Digital Archive: Stories Section (Library of Congress) http://911digitalarchive.org/lc/911-browse-story/0/6 The Veterans Oral History Project (Library of Congress) http://www.loc.gov/folklife/vets/sights.html Within these Walls http://americanhistory.si.edu/house/default.asp This Smithsonian exhibit site tells the stories of five families who lived (sequentially) in a house over 200 years What did you do in the war, Grandma? http://www.stg.brown.edu/projects/WWII_Women/tocCS.html An oral history of Rhode Island Women during World War II Without Sanctuary: Photographs and Postcards of Lynching in America http://www.musarium.com/withoutsanctuary What was Told http://www-cds.aas.duke.edu/hine/what_was_told Photos and interviews with people living on the Cape Flats in South Africa