English 30-1

Name: __________

Isherwood

Bethune By Rod Langely

Guided Analysis
Team Name:_____________

Group Members: ___________________________________________________

Pre-reading
Part 1: Dr. Norman Bethune Biography
Dr. Norman Bethune is best known as a hero in the People's Republic of China and for his
impact on Sino-Canadian relations. But he also gained a reputation in his native Canada as a
gifted surgeon, an inventor, a political activist and an early proponent of a universal health care
system.
Norman Bethune was born in 1890 in Gravenhurst, Ontario, north of Toronto. He was the son of
a clergyman but chose to follow in his grandfather's footsteps and become a surgeon. He studied
at the University of Toronto's Faculty of Medicine but, in 1911, he interrupted his studies to
work for a year as a labourer-teacher with Frontier College.
Wartime service
At the outbreak of the First World War, Bethune joined the N0.2
Field Ambulance Medical Corps and sailed for France in
February 1915. He was working as a stretcher-bearer in Ypres,
Belgium, when a shrapnel shell exploded close to him and pieces
of it pierced his leg. He was sent by ship to England where he
spent three months recovering in hospital.
When Bethune returned to Canada, he resumed his medical
studies and completed his Bachelor of Medicine in December
1916. One of his classmates was Frederick Banting, who would
later achieve fame as the co-discoverer of insulin.
With the war still raging, Dr. Bethune felt compelled to return to
service, so he joined the Royal Navy as a lieutenant-surgeon. At war's end, he took on a sixmonth internship at the prestigious Hospital for Sick Children in London, England.
Back in Canada, Dr. Bethune worked in private practice in Stratford and Ingersoll, Ontario. But
he was a restless man, so he traveled back to Britain to train as a surgeon at the University of
Edinburgh. On February 3, 1922, he was elected a Fellow of the Royal College of Surgeons.
Personal crises

Adapted from Edgington

English 30-1

Isherwood

While he was in Scotland, Norman Bethune married a Scottish girl, Frances Campbell Penney,
and they moved to Detroit, Michigan, where he set up another private practice. But he was facing
a period of crises in his personal life. In 1926, he contracted pulmonary tuberculosis. About the
same time, his marriage failed, largely due to his lavish spending and flamboyant lifestyle.
Turning point
Dr. Bethune's stay in a New York sanitarium was a turning point. Here, he saw first-hand how
little could be done for many victims of tuberculosis. In September 1928 he returned to the Royal
Victoria Hospital in Montral and worked for eight years, devoting himself to helping other
tuberculosis victims and to studying thoracic surgery.
It was a productive time for Dr. Bethune. He invented or re-designed 12 medical and surgical
instruments, some of which are still used today. He also wrote a large body of work describing
his innovations in thoracic technique. These books provided essential reference material for
surgeons.
But slowly, Dr. Bethune became disillusioned with surgical treatment and more concerned with
the socio-economic aspects of disease. He was constantly challenging his profession and
proposing reforms of medical care, including socialized medicine. As an example to others, he
opened a free clinic where he treated women, children and unemployed men.
First brush with communism
In 1935, Dr. Bethune attended a conference in the Soviet Union and returned to Montral with
high praise for their medical system. Still convinced of the benefits of socialized medicine, he
helped organize the Montreal Group for the Security of the People's Health, an organization
dedicated to establishing socialized medicine in Canada. The Group's recommendations were
met with complete indifference. Dr. Bethune became bitter and disillusioned.
Off to Spain
Dr. Bethune formally joined the Communist Party in the winter of 1935. He felt that his own
goals were perfectly reflected in those of the Party: to change the world for the better. When he
saw that he could not accomplish his objectives in Canada, he decided to travel to Spain, which,
in 1936, was on the verge of civil war.
A chance to make a difference
Norman Bethune was a man of action and here was his chance to act. No sooner had he arrived
in Spain than he traveled to the front lines and jumped into action. His experience as a stretcherbearer during the First World War taught him the importance of helping the wounded quickly. So
he set up a blood bank close to the front lines and organized a mobile blood-transfusion service,
the first of its kind. By the next spring, Dr. Bethune and his small medical team were giving up
to 100 blood transfusions a day.

Adapted from Edgington

English 30-1

Isherwood

Dr. Bethune returned to Canada in 1937 to a hero's welcome. Still firmly committed to the war in
Spain, he criss-crossed the country, trying to raise money for the anti-fascist cause. But there was
little interest in that distant war, and Bethune became bitterly disappointed.
A new cause to embrace
Once again, Dr. Bethune was growing restless, just as another war was escalating in the East. In
1937, the Japanese invaded China and Chinese Chairman Mao Zedong and his communist
soldiers were trying to resist the Japanese invaders. Bethune saw this as another battle against
fascism and he was determined to help.
He gathered together a medical team and on January 8, 1938, the Canadian-American Mobile
Medical Unit left Canada to join the 8th Route Army in the Shanxi-Hobei border region of
China. Once in China, Dr. Bethune immediately adopted the cause and the people as his own. He
worked long hard days under the most rudimentary conditions and quickly became known as a
skilled surgeon and a dedicated teacher.
In October 1939, the Japanese launched another attack. Dr. Bethune and his team rushed to the
front where the worst fighting was unfolding and worked long hours caring for the wounded.
While he was operating on a soldier, Bethune cut his finger. Probably due to his weakened state,
he contracted septicaemia (blood poisoning) and died of his wounds on November 12, 1939.
A nation mourns
Dr. Bethune's death shocked the Chinese nation. Chinese Chairman Mao Zedong wrote a tribute
titled "In Memory of Norman Bethune," in which he praised the doctor for his selflessness and
dedication to the Chinese people.
In 1952, Norman Bethune's body was moved to a memorial park built to commemorate those
who died in the war. Across the road from Bethune's tomb and statue lies the most fitting tribute
of all: the Norman Bethune International Peace Hospital.
Canada too marked Norman Bethune's passing by naming his birthplace in Gravenhurst, Ontario,
a national historic site and unveiling a bronze statue of him in downtown Gravenhurst.

Source: http://www.collectionscanada.gc.ca/physicians/030002-2100-e.html

Adapted from Edgington

English 30-1

Isherwood

Part 2: In Memory of Norman Bethune

By Chairman Mao Zedong
(December 21, 1939)
Comrade Norman Bethune, a member of the Communist Party of Canada, was around fifty when
he was sent by the Communist Parties of Canada and the United States to China; he made light
of travelling thousands of miles to help us in our War of Resistance Against Japan. He arrived in
Yenan in the spring of last year, went to work in the Wutai Mountains, and to our great sorrow
died a martyr at his post. What kind of spirit is this that makes a foreigner selflessly adopt the
cause of the Chinese people's liberation as his own? It is the spirit of internationalism, the spirit
of communism, from which every Chinese Communist must learn. Leninism teaches that the
world revolution can only succeed if the proletariat of the capitalist countries supports the
struggle for liberation of the colonial and semi-colonial peoples and if the proletariat of the
colonies and semi-colonies supports that of the proletariat of the capitalist countries. Comrade
Bethune put this Leninist line into practice. We Chinese Communists must also follow this line
in our practice. We must unite with the proletariat of all the capitalist countries, with the
proletariat of Japan, Britain, the United States, Germany, Italy and all other capitalist countries,
for this is the only way to overthrow imperialism, to liberate our nation and people and to
liberate the other nations and peoples of the world. This is our internationalism, the
internationalism with which we oppose both narrow nationalism and narrow patriotism.
Comrade Bethune's spirit, his utter devotion to others without any thought of self, was shown in
his great sense of responsibility in his work and his great warm-heartedness towards all comrades
and the people. Every Communist must learn from him. There are not a few people who are
irresponsible in their work, preferring the light and shirking the heavy, passing the burdensome
tasks on to others and choosing the easy ones for themselves. At every turn they think of
themselves before others. When they make some small contribution, they swell with pride and
brag about it for fear that others will not know. They feel no warmth towards comrades and the
people but are cold, indifferent and apathetic. In truth such people are not Communists, or at
least cannot be counted as devoted Communists. No one who returned from the front failed to
express admiration for Bethune whenever his name was mentioned, and none remained unmoved
by his spirit. In the Shansi-Chahar-Hopei border area, no soldier or civilian was unmoved who
had been treated by Dr. Bethune or had seen how he worked. Every Communist must learn this
true communist spirit from Comrade Bethune.
Comrade Bethune was a doctor, the art of healing was his profession and he was constantly
perfecting his skill, which stood very high in the Eighth Route Army's medical service. His
example is an excellent lesson for those people who wish to change their work the moment they
see something different and for those who despise technical work as of no consequence or as
promising no future.
Comrade Bethune and I met only once. Afterwards he wrote me many letters. But I was busy,
and I wrote him only one letter and do not even know if he ever received it. I am deeply grieved
over his death. Now we are all commemorating him, which shows how profoundly his spirit
inspires everyone. We must all learn the spirit of absolute selflessness from him. With this spirit
Adapted from Edgington

English 30-1

Isherwood

everyone can be very useful to the people. A man's ability may be great or small, but if he has
this spirit, he is already noble-minded and pure, a man of moral integrity and above vulgar
interests, a man who is of value to the people.
NOTES
(1). The distinguished surgeon Norman Bethune was a member of the Canadian Communist
Party. In 1936 when the German and Italian fascist bandits invaded Spain, he went to the front
and worked for the anti-fascist Spanish people. In order to help the Chinese people in their War
of Resistance Against Japan, he came to China at the head of a medical team and arrived in
Yenan in the spring of 1938. Soon after he went to the Shansi-Chahar-Hopei border area. Imbued
with ardent internationalism and the great communist spirit, he served the army and the people of
the Liberated Areas for nearly two years. He contracted blood poisoning while operating on
wounded soldiers and died in Tanghsien, Hopei, on November 12, 1939
(2). See J. V. Stalin, "The Foundations of Leninism", Problems of Leninism, Eng. ed., FLPH,
Moscow, 1954, pp. 70-79.

Source: http://chairmanmaozedong.org/article/57.html

Reading & Guided Analysis

__________________________________________________________________
Instructions:
You will be assigned to a team that you will meet with each day. Together, you
will read the play aloud and complete the guided analysis for each Act. You need
to have finished reading and analyzing each Act by that Challenge date indicated.
Do not fall behind.
On Challenge Days, your team will be given a task to complete together. You
must use your group work skills to successfully complete the task in 65 minutes.
Complete all three challenges successfully to un-lock a special English 30-1 bonus
prize!

Adapted from Edgington

English 30-1

Isherwood

Bethune Rod Langley

Act I: pages 11-43

Challenge Date: Friday February 20

Character - Bethune

Questions about Act

What your group discusses

Quotes from Text

Significance what is revealed about

character(s)

Track the character development of Bethune

himself

Adapted from Edgington

English 30-1

Isherwood

Track how Bethune affects other characters in the

play

Adapted from Edgington

English 30-1

Isherwood

Personal Response to Act Focus on the key events of the act and respond this may be through making
connections or commenting on a characters actions, ex whether you agree or disagree etc.

Adapted from Edgington

English 30-1

Isherwood

Bethune Rod Langley

Act II: pages 45-81

Challenge Date: Wednesday February 25

Questions about Act

What your group discusses

Character - Bethune
Quotes from Text

Significance what is revealed about

character(s)

Track the character development of Bethune

himself

Adapted from Edgington

English 30-1

Isherwood

Track how Bethune affects other characters in the

play

Adapted from Edgington

10

English 30-1

Isherwood

Personal Response to Act Focus on the key events of the act and respond this may be through making
connections or commenting on a characters actions, ex whether you agree or disagree etc.

Adapted from Edgington

11

English 30-1

Isherwood

Bethune Rod Langley

Act III: pages 83-117

Meeting Date: Monday March 2

Questions about Act

What your group discusses

Character - Bethune
Quotes from Text

Significance what is revealed about

character(s)

Track the character development of Bethune

himself

Adapted from Edgington

12

English 30-1

Isherwood

Track how Bethune affects other characters in the

play

Adapted from Edgington

13

English 30-1

Isherwood

Personal Response to Act Focus on the key events of the act and respond this may be through making
connections or commenting on a characters actions, ex whether you agree or disagree etc.

Adapted from Edgington

14

English 30-1

Isherwood

Post-reading Response to Literature Assignment

Due: Tuesday March 3
Write a response to literature exploring the character of Bethune, as well as your personal
observations and thoughts on the character. I expect this to be a polished piece of writing
that discusses your ideas in detail and provides specific examples and/or quotations from
the text to support these ideas. Organize your response in a structured and sensible way.
Please comment on the following in your response:

what you feel are his key character traits/personality

how these traits affect how others view/respond to him
how these traits lead to difficulties in his life, but also success

if you agree or disagree with him receiving the Order of Canada

why was it such a controversial decision?
At least one text-to-text connection, one text-to-self connection,
and one text-to-world connection you made while reading the play
Read the speech written about him by Mao and use it as a
reference/source in your response

See the attached Response to Literature rubric for information on how your writing will
be assessed.
As always, if you need help, please ask!
Good luck
Adapted from Edgington

15

English 30-1

Isherwood

Response to Literature Rubric

Thought and Understanding

Support

Insightful ideas
Evident understanding of
subtleties of text and topic
Perceptive and illuminating
interpretations

thoughtful ideas
well considered
comprehension of text and
topic
revealing and convincing
interpretations

relevant and straightforward

ideas
generalized comprehension of
text and topic
plausible interpretations

superficial ideas
weak comprehension of text
and topic
incomplete or literal
interpretations

Writing Skills

explicit, precise
and deliberately
chosen examples
strong connection
to ideas maintained

relevant, accurate
and occasionally
deliberately chosen
examples
clear connection to
ideas maintained

adequate and
general examples
straightforward
connection to ideas
maintained

examples are often

inappropriate, a
restatement of
literature, or
repetitive,
contradictory or
over simplified
vague and/or
redundant
connection to ideas

irrelevant,
overgeneralized or
lacking examples
examples are
largely unrelated to
discussion

selection and use of words and

structures are effective
writing demonstrates confident control
of correct sentence construction, usage,
grammar and mechanics

absent or irrelevant ideas

ideas do not develop the topic
little comprehension of text or
topic

1
Total: ____/15

selection and use of words and structure

are frequently effective
writing demonstrates competent control
of correct sentence construction, usage,
grammar and mechanics

selection and use of words and

structures are occasionally effective
writing demonstrates basic control of
correct sentence construction, usage,
grammar and mechanics

selection and use of words and

structures are frequently ineffective
writing demonstrates faltering control
of correct sentence construction, usage,
grammar and mechanics

selection and use of words and

structures are ineffective
writing demonstrates lack of control of
correct sentence construction, usage,
grammar and mechanics

Percentage: ______%

Adapted from Edgington

16