Lions led by donkeys

A German army commander once described the British army as lions led by
donkeys. He admired the courage of ordinary British soldiers, but felt that
many lives could have been saved had their generals performed their jobs
more effectively. Field Marshall Sir Douglas Haig, was the most senior officer
in the army. He was the Commander in Chief from 1915 to 1918. He, too, has
been criticised for the way he managed the war and has been nicknamed, the
butcher of the Somme after the disastrous battle of the Somme in 1916 when
tens of thousands of troops died. Is this criticism fair? Were the soldiers of the
British army really lions led by donkeys?
Biography of Haig
Douglas Haig was born in Edinburgh 1861, the son of
John Haig, who owned the famous whisky distillery.
He went to Oxford in 1880, and then the prestigious
Royal Military College at Sandhurst in 1883.

Haig

Haig was sent to India with his regiment in 1886 and

while there worked his way through the ranks. He
experienced active service in the several conflicts
around the world in India, South Africa and the Middle
East. He served under Lord Kitchener (the officer who
appears on the famous British Army recruitment
poster). When Haig became major-general he was the
youngest officer of that rank in the British Army.

Haig had a distinguished career in the early stages of the First World War and
his courage and leadership skills were admired by fellow soldiers during the
Battles of Mons and Ypres in 1914. Haig was promoted to full general and
was given command of the British Expeditionary Forces in France and
Belgium. Haig was severely criticised for his conduct of the Battle of the
Somme in 1916 by people (including the Prime Minister at the time Lloyd
George) who claimed his military tactics misjudged.
After the war Haig became commander in chief of home forces until his
retirement in 1921. Haig was given 100,000 by the British government and
spent the rest of his life helping ex-servicemen through the Royal British
Legion (who organize the Poppy Day Appeal every year). He was made Earl
Haig in 1919 and died in 1928.
Source 1
The nation must be taught to bear losses. No amount of skill on the part of the
commentators, no training, however good, no superiority of arms and
ammunition, however great, will enable victories to be won without the
sacrifice of men. The nation must be prepared to see heavy casualty lists
three years of war and the loss of one-tenth of Britains men is not too great a
price to pay.
Haig wrote this just before the battle of the Somme in 1916. Haig believed ina
war of attrition which means wearing down the enemy

Source 2
You will be able to go over the top with a walking stick, you will not need rifles
you will find the Germans all dead, not even a rat will have survived.
Before the battle of the Somme, the general assured their troops that the
shells would destroy the enemy before they arrived.
Source 3
On that first day of the Battle of the Somme, 20,000 British soldiers were killed
and 35,000 wounded, but this did not make General Haig want to change his
methods. He ordered more attacks but the same tragic story was repeated
each time. Against the advice of experts who said he did not have enough, he
sent fifty tanks into battle in September. Twenty-nine broke down before they
even reached the battlefield and the rest soon got stuck in the mud. By the
end of the battle, the British and French had lost 620,000 men and the
Germans 450,000. The allies had advanced 15 kilometres at the furthest
point.
From Broomans, The Great War, 1991. The number of dead soldiers
appears in the Guinness Book of Records as the greatest number of
casualties in one battle!
Source 4
One regiment, the First Newfoundlanders, left the trenches with 752 men on
the first day of the Battle of the Somme. 684 (91%) were killed or wounded in
half an hour. No Germans were killed.
Modern history textbook
Source 5
In another six weeks the enemy will find it hard to get enough men
Haig believed in wearing the enemy down. He said the above after 2 weeks of
the battle.
Source 6
We had heavy losses in men and material. As a result of the Somme we were
completely exhausted on the Western Front.
Quote taken from the autobiography of General Ludendorff, one of the most
senior officers in the German army.

Source 7
What the hell does that matter? There are plenty more men in Britain.
A quote from one of Haigs generals in 1915, when told Britain had lost 60,000
soldiers at the Battle of Loos
Source 8
In the Somme fighting of 1916, we lost our best men. The men who joined
afterwards did not have the temper, the hardness or the spirit of the men who
had fallen.
Official German Army record.
Source 9
My God, did we really send men to fight in that?
One of Haigs generals said this about the area where the Battle of
Passchendaele (3rd Battle of Ypres, 1917) was fought. In it Britain lost 400,
000 men many had drowned in a sea of stinking, liquid mud. As the dead
bodies rotted, the generals in their headquarters could smell the decaying
from 6 miles away!
Source 10
The horse is the future. Aeroplanes and tanks only aid the man and his horse
and I feel sure that as time goes on you will find just as much use for the
horse the well-bred horse as you have ever done in the past.
Even writing in 1926, Haig believed the horse would still be important in
warfare. He was often criticised for not accepting new ideas. During WWI he
felt that machine guns were hardly needed. The Prime Minister had to order
him to send more to the front lines.
Sources taken from A. Wilkes, Technology, War & Identities

Your tasks
1. Read the biography of Haig and highlight in blue all the events in his life
which suggest he had all the qualities necessary to be a good leader or
organiser.
Are there any events or characteristics that suggest that he was ill-suited to
the task of leading the British army in the First World War? List them below.
2. Study source 1. What impression does this give of Haigs character? List
some adjectives to describe him below.

3. Study source 3. Does this source provide a different view of Haigs

character or confirm your original suspicions? Explain your answer.
4. Study sources 2,3,4,5 & 6. Write down 5 facts from the sources about the
Battle of the Somme. Is there any evidence to suggest the Somme was
successful?
5. Recently there has been a campaign to have the statue of Field Marshall
Haig in London removed and replaced by a statue of an ordinary soldier. Write
a letter to the Mayor of London explaining what you think should be done.
Include the following points:
A brief description of who Haig was
Explain the key events of the most famous / infamous battle associated with
him the Somme
Use quotes from historians or contemporaries where appropriate
Explain what should be done with the monument to Haig and why

Haig

Extension task

Work in pairs. A radio journalist is interviewing Douglas Haig in 1927. Write a transcript
of the interview, with one of you as the reporter and one of you as Haig. Consider the
following.

his background

education early career in the army the highs & lows of his
military career the last years of his life