Urban Mindfulness
Urban Mindfulness
Urban Mindfulness
|
and maintaining a meditation practice was very difficult. Vacations,
yoga, and spa visits helped, but their therapeutic effects were short
lived. Retreats for meditation and community provided a welcome
respite, but eventually my clients had to face returning to real life
in the city.
Besides complaining about daily hassles, my clients spoke of
more significant difficulties. They talked about feeling lonely and
isolated, despite being surrounded by people day and night. They
described feeling burned out from the competitiveness they per-
ceived at work, while dating, or even standing in line at the movies.
Some spoke of the financial strain of living in one of the most
expensive cities in the world and how they had to work so hard
to stay afloat. Despite earning a decent salary, they saw their pay-
checks seemingly evaporate after covering household expenses. Even
people who had significant financial resources werent immune to
city stress. They resented having to be available by phone, e-mail,
and text message 24/7, while feeling unable to enjoy their earnings.
After dealing with these stresses over time, many started to feel
anxious, depressed, irritable, and completely overwhelmed, which
was often when they arrived at my office door.
As any well-trained psychologist would do, I resumed reading
books and studies on stress management, especially those focused
on mindfulness. If youre unfamiliar with mindfulness, you can
consider it to be a special way of paying attention. Disengaging
from automatic pilot, we consciously turn our focus to whats
happening right now, in the present. For example, in this immedi-
ate moment, youre breathing while holding this book and reading
this sentence, even though you may have groceries to buy, bills
to pay, calls to make, and so on. Though mindfulness is often
equated with meditation or a focus on breathing, it involves more
than these practices. It helps you cultivate the ability to experience
life as it unfolds through the practice of noticing your thoughts,
|
feelings, sensations, and perceptions unencumbered by thinking,
evaluating, rejecting, or clinging. Mindfulness also engenders a
gentle curiosity about such experiences, which necessarily requires
openness and acceptance. Instead of getting wrapped up in what
should or shouldnt be, for example, mindfulness encourages us
to become aware of the way things are, including the degree to
which we might be judgingor even ignoringour experiences.
Put simply, mindfulness is:
Noticing your thoughts, feelings, and actions without
judgment or criticism
Observing whats happening around you
Being fully aware of your senses moment to moment
Living in the here and now without resorting to old
patterns and automatic reactions
Exercising acceptance of your own experience, whether
good, bad, or neutral
Mindfulness is often misidentified as exclusively a Buddhist
concept, but more correctly, its part of all spiritual traditions.
Within Christianity, for example, the centering prayer aims to
cultivate an inner stillness, better enabling communion with God.
In Judaism, Shabbat, the holiest day of the week, sanctifies the
practice of merely being rather than working or creating anything.
Further, psychology has adopted mindfulness in a secular fashion
over the past few decades. Various scientific studies have identi-
fied the benefits of mindfulness and meditation in treating chronic
pain, alcohol abuse, anxiety, and relapse in chronic depression
(Kabat-Zinn 1990; Marlatt and Gordon 1985; Orsillo and Roemer
2005; Segal, Williams, and Teasdale 2002).
Given these benefits and the fact that not only my clients
but I, too, suffered from the stresses of city living, it made sense
for me to rededicate myself to mindfulness practice. I pored over
scientific articles and books by many experts on mindfulness. In
Buddhist texts, I found tales of sitting in the forest, riding horses,
and practicing falconry, which werent particularly relevant to
urban experiences of eating on the go or driving in traffic. Many
mindfulness-based therapies also seemed impractical. They empha-
sized spending up to an hour daily in meditation, which, although
an incredibly helpful practice, proved to be too much of a hurdle
to those of us struggling with limited time and energy. So, while
there were some helpful insights, I found that none of the resources
quite adequately addressed the unique experiences, opportunities,
and challenges of urban life. This discrepancy isnt that surprising,
given that many of the authors (monks, mindfulness experts, and
the like) lived in rural or monastic communities, removed from the
busyness and chaos of modern city life. So where does this leave
the rest of us? How can we nurture our own practice of mindful-
ness while continuing to live and work in the city? Are there ways
for us to become aware and present withoutor despitefeeling
overwhelmed? Can we find ways to practice mindfulness other
than sitting on a meditation cushion or a therapists couch?
Asking questions like these, I realized we needed to find better
ways to practice mindfulness in the city. Drawing on its princi-
pal foundations, I knew we could develop ways to become more
mindfuland even to meditatein the context of our everyday
experiences. Instead of just talking about loving thy neighbor
in church or practicing loving-kindness in the sangha (meditation
community), we could be compassionate toward our fellow subway
riders and the homeless people we see each day. We could meditate
while strolling through the park, running to catch the bus, or even
;
experiences and settings were likely to have on the job, whether we
work in an office, restaurant, or retail store, or even outdoors. In
most of these settings, we want to have friendly relationships with
coworkers and practice mindfulness in ways that dont interfere
with what were hired to do. Out and About provides guidelines
for practice as we move around the cityfor example, meditating
on the subway or mindfully walking down a busy, crowded street.
We can approach many common urban experiences, like encoun-
tering homeless people or street musicians, in ways that embody
our dedication to mindfulness. And finally, Anytime, Anywhere
includes exercises to do and reflections to consider regardless of
where we are and what we might be doing in the city. Because
they dont require us to be in any particular place, these exercises
invite you to practice mindfulness in ways consistent with almost
any situation, such as when you text a friend or hear a siren. The
fifty chapters arent meant to be read sequentially but, rather, to be
considered individually so you can focus on whichever parts seem
most relevant to you at a particular time. So if you dont have small
children, you might skip the chapter Toddler Time and go to
Mindful Messaging to learn how to mindfully send text messages.
Later in your life, if and when you have children, you might decide
to revisit this book and read that chapter you missed.
I wish I could say that these exercises fixed everything for
my clients, readers of the Urban Mindfulness blog, and me, that
we never feel stressed, lonely, or overwhelmed, but thats not the
case. There continue to be days in which my blog readers want
more green space. My clients still talk of feeling lonely sometimes.
And every so often, I find myself longing for a little peace and
quiet. However, weve found some relief by becoming more mindful,
accepting, compassionate, and grateful while remaining grounded
during our experiences. Reacting with more equanimity and realiz-
ing important personal goals in the now provide a new perspective
8
and help us have more mindful moments. In particular, the realiza-
tion has come about that every day in the city is a new opportunity
for practice as we travel down the same noisy, busy, crowded streets
together. Through this books advice and support, combined with
your intention and commitment to practice mindfulness, youll be
well on your way to cultivating peace, presence, and purpose while
living in the middle of it all.
1o
\.dit.tio: .t lo:.: \ li.!ou.
L.t..: i::.: .:d ut.: :...s
Scene: In a city apartment, someone prepares to meditate. Sunlight
spills through the window as the day dawns: 7:32 a.m.
INSIDE. Time for practice. Just need to take my seat and
settle down now. Oops, two minutes late!
OUTSIDE. [Crack!]
INSIDE. Ouch! What was that? My knee? Oh, no, not
again! I hope its notoh, whew! It doesnt really
hurt. Okay, so where was I? Ah, yes, sitting. Sit
up straight, review my intentionI intend to rest
my attention on my breathingand breathe.
When thoughts arise, Ill let them go and return
to my breath.
11
OUTSIDE. [Woo-woo-woo!]
INSIDE. A fire engine? Wow, thats really loud! Itll be
gone in a minute. Ill just wait. Going, going,
gone. Now, back to the breath.
OUTSIDE. [Rumble; ee-ur, ee-ur, ee-ur, woop-woop-
woop!]
INSIDE. Stupid car alarm! That thing always goes off
whenever I try to concentrate. I wish itd just get
stolen, already.
OUTSIDE. Hey, whatcha doing?
INSIDE. Oh, look who wandered in! What does it look
like Im doing? Huh? Maybe if I breathe really
loudly, youll get the hint.
OUTSIDE. Oh, meditating, huh? Okay, let me just get
something for a second [bang].
INSIDE. Go away, already. I cant concentrate. This has
got to be the worst meditation ever. Wait a sec
didnt I say that last time?
Recognizing the physical, emotional, mental, and spiritual
importance of meditation, many of us try to meditate at home.
However, when you live in the city, creating the ideal atmosphere
at home can be frustrating, if not impossible. We have to deal with
excessive noise, little space, and the potential for unending distrac-
tions. Its bad enough when we have only our thoughts to distract
us, but worse when the outside world also seems to conspire to
undermine our practice. Regardless of the source, its important
1.
to recognize that getting distracted is normal. In fact, its the raw
material of meditation: we focus our awareness on some aspect of
the present moment and return our attention to it whenever the
mind wanders. Its a relatively simple process, but not easy. If it
were, thered be no need to meditate!
To address these challenges, here are a few tips to help you
structure your home meditation experience a little better:
Create a pleasant, uncluttered space. Depending on
the size of your home, maybe youre limited to claim-
ing a small corner of the bedroom or, if youre lucky,
you have a whole room to yourself. Either way, size
doesnt matter. Its mainly important that your space
be relatively clean and tidy. You dont want to medi-
tate while staring at a pile of dirty laundry. You also
dont need to be too concerned with decorating your
space. Flowers, candles, or images can be inviting and
supportive, but theyre not required. In formal zazen
meditation, people meditate while staring at a blank
wallnot too inspiring, but it works.
Establish a consistent time, ritual, or both for your
home meditation. To best support your practice, it
helps to meditate routinely at a particular time of day.
Most people choose the morning, because its gener-
ally quieter and our minds havent quite gotten going
yet. However, you can choose to meditate whenever
is most convenient for you. Additionally, establish a
small ritual to help you transition into the meditative
state. Perhaps ring a bell, recite your reasons for medi-
tating, or brew a cup of tea that steeps while you sit.
1|
Keep your meditation cushion, mat, or other supplies
clean and protected. You dont want to leave your
meditation cushion on the sofa, where something
might get spilled on it. Try putting your meditation
supplies in a special corner or in the closet. Keeping
them covered and protected from dirt and dust also
helps.
Minimize external distractions. You cant control some
things, like oversensitive car alarms, but you can limit
some distractions and lessen the impact of others. For
example, if your pet is too curious about your medita-
tion, offer a few treats in another room just before you
begin. If other people in your house are disruptive,
talk to them beforehand, or arrange to meditate while
theyre gone. Also consider wearing earplugs or ear-
phones if the noise around you is too distracting.
Roll with disruptions. In any meditation session, youre
bound to get distracted by stuff around you, bodily
sensations, or thoughts going through your mind. So
when you find that your mind has wandered, just
return your attention to the subject of the medita-
tion. Notice whats happening and your reaction to
it. Accept that its your reality right now, and keep
returning your awareness to the meditation.
1|
\i:i \i:du!:.ss
\.st.:s .t lo:.
Often, our search for inner peace and tranquility involves leaving
home. We seek support from others by attending talks, meditat-
ing in groups, or retreating to the country. Alternatively, we might
visit a website or bookstore in search of guidance in blogs, books,
or magazines. However, we need not always pursue (and pay for)
mindfulness experts in these settings. Sometimes, we can find
the best mindfulness teachers in our own homes, literally under-
foot. Pets and children have an uncanny ability to live fully in the
present moment, thus they can serve as mini mindfulness masters
to guide our practice. Cats, dogs, and babies each contribute their
own unique teachings.
When you see a cat basking in the sunshine, its easy to appre-
ciate such mindfulness-related qualities as acceptance and sensual
fulfillment. Reveling in the present moment, cats find content-
ment in the experience of napping in a warm, dry place. Rather
1
than insistently dragging a well-loved toy nearby or striving for the
perfect angle at which to sleep, the cat simply settles into the space.
And when the sun passes, cats almost always continue napping in
the shade, rather than chase the sun to another well-lit spot. Cats
stretch to relish the warmth of the sunny day as it unfolds, without
worrying about the chance of rain, or regretting bygone sunbeams.
Dogs are also wonderful teachers of mindfulness practice.
They can demonstrate an enviable level of concentration and
focus on the present moment. Dont believe me? Have you ever
tried to eat lunch in front of a hungry dog? Salivating unabashedly,
dogs focus visually on every bite of food as it travels from plate to
mouth. Paying such exquisite attention to the process of eating is
an integral part of several mindfulness-based psychotherapies (for
example, Kristeller and Hallett 1999). Dogs loyalty is a wonder-
ful example of a relationship without criticism or condemnation. It
doesnt matter what kind of day youve had, what you look like, or
how your breath smells; you can be confident that your dog loves
you unconditionally. Dogs dont pass judgment on you or set limits
on when and how they express their affection for you.
With reactions unmitigated by expectations, babies, too, fully
engage with the present moment. Given their nascent cognitive
development, babies dont yet have memories to guide their interac-
tions with the environment. If a baby is hungry, wet, sick, or tired,
crying ensues. If a baby is well fed, warm, healthy, and well rested,
youll likely see big smiles and hear soft cooing. In this respect,
babies expressions reflect their immediate experience, unmediated
by thinking or judging. From a babys perspective, what happened
in the past is over. A hungry baby is hungry even if he just ate. A
tired baby is tired even if she slept through the night. And babies
have little appreciation of the future. For example, as every parent
knows, a plaintive Wait a minute! does little to soothe a crying
baby whos sitting in a cold, wet diaper.
1
Given these mini mindfulness masters apparent sagacity, here
are a few tips on how to apply their teachings. They have much to
teach us, even if they cant talk.
Be with your pet or child. Spend some time follow-
ing your mini mindfulness masters lead. This might
simply mean lying next to your cat, nuzzling your
dog, or gazing at your infant. See if you can get in
touch with some of the sensual aspects of the present
moment your pet or baby might be experiencing (for
example, temperature, sound, lightness or darkness,
and so on).
Watch how your mini mindfulness master interacts
with the present moment. Does your pet or baby seem
to be experiencing something pleasant, unpleasant, or
neutral? What behaviors or expressions do you notice
that lead you to this conclusion? What is your own
experience of this moment? Are you having a similar
reaction or a completely different one? To what degree
does whats going through your mind influence your
experience, as opposed to whats actually happening
in the world around you?
Ask yourself, What would Winston [or whatever your
mini mindfulness master is called] do? How would
your pet or infant respond to this situation? You might
anticipate reactions like purring, barking, crying, or
tail wagging. Alternatively, you might expect a cocked
ear or nonplussed acknowledgment. The idea isnt
to embody or mimic this reaction (can you imagine
growling in a crowded restaurant?) but simply to con-
sider a different response from your usual automatic
1;
programming. If the image of your pet or babys reac-
tion merely brings a smile to your face, all the better.
Notice how your mini mindfulness masters actions
push your buttons. While pets and babies might be
free from judging and striving, were not. So the cat
that decides to vomit while youre running late will
likely spark feelings of anger and contempt rather
than compassion. Try to bring awareness to how and
when your emotions get triggered when your pet or
infant behaves in ways you dislike. Some Zen para-
bles recount how disciples became enlightened after
being hit on the head or slapped in the face by the
top priest. So maybe youre just one spit-up encounter
away from achieving nirvana yourself!
18
|.:. You: L:.i:,
|.:. You: Roo::.t.
Living in the city usually means living in smaller spaces. Given
the expense of real estate relative to suburban and rural areas, we
simply get less bang for the buck when it comes to square footage.
To reduce expensesor to share a life with someone we lovewe
end up living with others, typically roommates or a romantic
partner. As a result, were often in fairly cramped quarters as we
struggle to carve out some personal space and share household
responsibilities.
This kind of crowded living isnt easy. In fact, its inherently
stressful. Research shows that animals like rats and monkeys turn
against each other when given too little space to live in (Calhoun
1962). Fortunately, it doesnt get to the point where were gnawing
on our roommates or hurling feces, but we do get stressed and irri-
table, and tend to act out in more humanlike ways. We forget
to take out the trash or decide to wash only our own dishes. We
1
ruminate about the ways our roommates or partners arent doing
their fair share to maintain the household. I walk the dog, pay the
bills, and go grocery shopping, while he cant even put away his coat,
we think.
As we get progressively more bitter and resentful, were more
likely to act out in unhealthy ways, perhaps by becoming argumen-
tative and making snarky, passive-aggressive comments. We decide
unilaterally to change our household responsibilities and just focus
on doing things for ourselves. For example, we might decide to buy
only the food we like.
In such circumstances, we clearly feel miserable. With our neg-
ative thoughts and retaliatory actions, we ruin the present moment.
That glass a roommate abandoned on the kitchen table, complete
with sour, stale milk, isnt as noxious as we make it out to be.
We can promptly dispose of smelly milk. Its the perceived disre-
spect and lack of consideration that are more troubling. Through
our judgments, we perpetuate our own dissatisfactionits our
own fault we feel bad! Sure, the glass might be a catalyst, but the
recrimination and perceived insult is what actually makes us feel
angry and disappointed.
If youve had these kinds of experiences with your room-
mate or partner, you clearly need to approach the situation a little
differently:
Become aware of whats going through your mind.
What are you telling yourself about whats happening
right now?
Consider whether or not a problem exists in this
present moment. What, if anything, is wrong right
now? Does the dog need to be walked? Do the dishes
need to be washed? Do you need to eat dinner?
.o
Accept that the situation is as it is. Telling yourself it
should or shouldnt be this way makes it difficult
to reach any constructive solution.
Objectively consider the problem in terms of spe-
cific behaviors. What action can you takeor try to
get your roommate or partner to taketo solve the
problem? Be aware of when you use judgmental lan-
guage. Wanting your partner or roommate to be more
respectful is a nice goal, but its also too ambiguous.
What do you mean by more respectful or whatever
judgmental language youre using? See if you can artic-
ulate in behavioral terms what you would like.
If none of these strategies works, you might simply need some
time alone. Research shows that we find overcrowding stressful
because of a lack of desired privacy (Ramsden 2009). So maybe
the dissatisfaction you feel while talking with your roommate or
partner comes from doing so at a time when you would rather be
alone. In such circumstances, discuss your need for more solitude
and see what arrangements you can make. Though initiating this
conversation might be awkward at first, it prevents future argu-
ments and helps you feel more relaxed at home.
.1
!.!|i:' !:.s|
Given the density of urban areas, its not surprising that cities gen-
erate a lot of trash. According to information available at their
respective sanitation departments, the cities of New York, Los
Angeles, and Chicago (the three most populous U.S. cities) gener-
ate over twenty-one thousand tons of garbage daily. Thats a lot
of waste! Yet somehow, we dont find ourselves overwhelmed with
filth. The reason, of course, is that thousands of people are respon-
sible for removing and disposing of our garbage. Whether we bid
good-bye to our trash at the wastebasket, garbage chute, or curb,
many other people take it from there.
When the citys sanitation department is working well, it lulls
us into a mindless complacency. We throw something away, and it
soon disappears. We dont have to concern ourselves with person-
ally taking trash to the nearest landfill. But when the system breaks
down and our garbage starts piling up too close to home (or work),
were suddenly aware of trash in a way we werent before. Were
quick to get upset or angry, even though we likely werent particu-
..
larly grateful when things worked smoothly. Based on his personal
experience, the Zen monk Thich Nhat Hanh (1991) once remarked
that a non-toothache is a pleasant experience. Similarly, we all
can probably agree that having no problem with garbage collection
is also a nice experience.
In this spirit, if trash pickup is important to you and your daily
life, consider trying one of the following practices:
Express your appreciation or gratitude for the people
who remove the trash. Perhaps extend a blessing to
the sanitation workers as they come down the block,
or say thanks to your building superintendent. At the
very least, maybe you can refrain from honking your
horn when the garbage truck temporarily blocks your
car.
Recognize that someone else will literally be left
holding the bag when you discard something. To
reduce this persons risk of getting either injured or
too messy, try to wrap broken glass securely and pour
liquids down the drain before tossing the container.
Consider how you would want others to dispose of
garbage if you were responsible for carrying it away.
Bring awareness to the process of discarding things
by slowly placing trash in the garbage can rather than
tossing it in. Notice what youre throwing away. If it
seems appropriate, consider other uses for this item or
other ways to dispose of it.
Ask yourself, Do I want to reduce the amount of
garbage I generate? If so, how important is this goal
to you, and how much time and energy can you devote
.|
to it? Having many pressures, we need to thoughtfully
consider our priorities. What you do to reduce, reuse,
and recycle likely isnt what your neighbor does. But
the question isnt about your neighbors actions but,
rather, the degree to which your own actions fit your
values.
Think about the various ways to reduce your trash.
Donate or sell items, such as appliances, clothing, and fur-
niture, through www.craigslist.org, www.freecycle.org,
or a local LISTSERV. Also, many cities have a thriving
leave and take system where people leave unwanted
items on their stoops or curbs for passersby to take
freely! Personally, Im convinced that some enterprising
people could furnish a whole apartment this way.
As to recycling, leave yourself reminders to
recycle, buy special recycling bins, and carry used
bottles until you find a recycling bin (rather than
throw them in a garbage can).
Encourage others to recycle properly. Ask your favorite
restaurants and take-out joints what happens to cus-
tomers bottles and cans. If they already recycle these
items properly, thank them for their efforts. If not,
encourage them to do so. Such a conversation need
not be hostile or confrontational; a simple request or
expression of the personal importance you place on
recycling can suffice.
Consider composting. Much of the food waste we gen-
erate can be composted into fertilizer. Even if you dont
have access to a yard where you can have a compost
bin, you have several other options. Often, you can
.|
bring vegetable scraps, coffee grounds, and other com-
postable products to your local farmers market, com-
munity garden, or food co-op. In between visits, you
can keep these items in a compost pail or bag stored
in the freezer. If you want to do the composting your-
self, you can investigate vermicomposting, composting
with worms. The worms live happily in your closet or
under your desk, and subsist entirely on whatever fruit
and vegetable scraps you would normally throw away.
Notice the proliferation of flyers, newspapers, restau-
rant menus, and the like around your home or work-
place. We often get bombarded by leaflets left on the
doorstep or wedged into some space near the entry-
way. Be cognizant of what happens to these materi-
als. Are they thrown into the trash? Does someone
take and read them? Are they left outside, only to
get blown into the street? If you dont want to receive
such materials, consider putting up a sign or register-
ing a complaint with the city. You can find other sug-
gestions online about getting fewer of such unwanted
advertisements.
All of these options involve becoming more aware of what you
discard and the attitude you bring to the process. Changing your
perspective and your waste-making behavior might introduce a
better spirit and environment to your city.
.
\.:t:.:t l:
For better or worse, we often compare ourselves to others, and
become dissatisfied if we dont quite measure up. So-and-so has a
better job, car, partner, or whatever. Researchers suggest that our
tendency to make social comparisons serves an evolutionary func-
tion and that we are particularly sensitive to instances where we
seem disadvantaged (Hill and Buss 2008).
In the city, a special kind of envy develops: apartment envy.
Maybe youve found yourself coveting your friends walk-in closet,
dishwasher, parking spot, or incredibly low rent (or mortgage).
Whatever the specifics, were never quite satisfied with where we
live, and theres ample opportunity to want what someone else has.
Our reasons for envying others homes are related to the inter-
section of three factors: First, the density of urban areas ensures
that were regularly reminded of people who live better than we do.
These reminders come in the form of billboards, real estate ads in
the newspaper, and ornate buildings. This direct experience is more
.
unsettling for us than indirect comparisons based on, say, watching
a TV show about someones home (Alicke and Zell 2008). Second,
the citys high cost of living necessarily requires us to make trade-
offs in terms of location, size, and amenities. We are also limited
in our ability to modify our homes; we cant just add another room
if we live in an apartment, for example. Finally, there are few ways
of assessing social standing in the city, compared to the suburbs
or rural areas. We dont all have cars, boats, lawns, and so on, but
most of us have a place to live. So our abodes take on particular
significance for us.
Youre likely familiar with how and when we tend to make
these comparisons. At parties, for example, its almost de rigueur to
discuss each others living spaces. We complain about noisy neigh-
bors, lack of space, parking difficulties, insufficient interior light,
unreasonable condo boards, long commutes, nonexistent outdoor
space, or poor school districts. Whenever we visit friends who
have just moved into a new space, we unconsciously compare their
spaces to our own, noting the ways they have it better than us,
or finding ways to disparage their places, thus preserving our own
apartmental self-esteem.
You might even know peoplenot you, of coursewho make
a hobby of looking for a new and better apartment. Poring through
the real estate section of the newspaper or Craigslist (www.craigs
list.org), they spend much of their free time seeking the perfect
place to live. However, as we all know, no place is ever perfect.
Theres always something less than ideal. And as our circumstances
change over time, what was once perfect can become less so very
quickly. All it takes is a yappy puppy next door to disrupt your
personal Eden.
The problem in these circumstances isnt what you might nor-
mally think. Most likely, its not that your place is too small, noisy,
far, or whatever you think is wrong with it. Thus, your solution
.;
moving to a new apartmentis doomed to fail. The real problem
is your comparative mind-set. You seeor imagineanother
apartment that you decide is better than yours in significant ways.
The comparison not only leads to feelings of envy and dissatisfac-
tion, but also potentially prevents you from investing the time and
energy in making your place as nice as it can be. If youre busy
meeting with real estate brokers, youre not finding ways to improve
your current home.
But what if I really do need to move? you might ask. Great
question. You might indeed need to move to a different place. But
the answer lies in looking objectively at your own needs and circum-
stances, not in comparing your apartment to someone elses.
To overcome apartment envy (or decide whether or not to
move), look for ways to accept where you areliterally; that is,
accept that you currently live in this particular apartment and
neighborhood. It might not be perfect (indeed, no moment ever
is), but its what you have. Paradoxically, by bringing your attention
back to your own living space and accepting it, you might discover
changes you can and do wish to make. Like mindfully changing
your meditation posture when you become uncomfortable, such
an attitude helps you make judicious choices in nonreactive ways.
Imagining yourself having to live in this apartment foreveras
opposed to imagining a much better placehelps you take better
ownership of the space (and maybe even improve it). Often the first
step to acceptance is imagining or realizing that your situation may
never change. After the anger and disappointment subside, youll
be better able to actually live where you are. Alternatively, you
might realize you do indeed need to move, but now your decision
comes from a place of objectivity rather than emotional reactivity.
Practice-wise, if youre still stuck envying someone elses home,
here are some ways to mindfully experience what you have:
.8
Choose a part of your home that you particularly
dislike, and sit there in silence for ten minutes. Find
something there you can appreciate, and sit with that
sense of appreciation for a moment. How do you feel
when you are in this place? Notice your emotions,
thoughts, and sensations as you sit there, but dont get
hooked by them. Just notice them and let them drift
away.
Find a dissatisfying area of your home, one that isnt
quite what it could or should be. Taking a step back,
ask yourself, Whats wrong with this? Notice what
judgments come to mind, especially ones that compare
this space to others. Consider this area of your home
on its own merits. How could you describe it objec-
tively? For example, you might describe a closet thats
too small or useless as being three feet wide, two
feet deep, and seven-and-a-half feet high. Given this
objective description, can you see a way to compen-
sate for whatever you think is wrong?
.
:ot !..:i:
Typically, we do our best to keep our living spaces clean and neat.
We attend to housekeeping chores regularly or find someone else
(such as a roommate, partner, or cleaning service) to do it for us.
Because our living spaces can be relatively small, we often cant
neglect something dirty or untidy for very long. For example, living
in a studio apartment means your kitchen, living room, dining
room, and bedroom are all the same room. So a sink full of dirty
dishes can create a nasty odor that disturbs your guests or your
sleep. In these smaller spaces, we cant easily avoid encountering a
mess, or relegate it to a particular area of our homes.
Given our limited living spaces, we need to be a little more
attentive to basic issues of cleanliness and tidiness. Of course, house-
keeping isnt something we typically relish. Its a chore we try to get
over with as quickly as possible. However, through mindfulness,
we can approach this experience differently. Jon Kabat-Zinn has
noted, for example, that moving our hands rhythmically in warm
water can be a pleasant sensory experience for us, once we stop
|o
negatively associating this act with doing the dishes (Kabat-Zinn
1994). Indeed, we can better enjoy many of the actions involved in
cleaning by becoming aware of what were actually doing and expe-
riencing. While cleaning the bathtub or toilet, notice how the color
changes from a mildew-tinged gray or brown to something shinier
and more representative of the underlying tile or porcelain. While
vacuuming, feel the handles subtle vibration and hear the crinkly
slurp of dirt getting sucked into the bag. While dusting, turn your
attention to the feel of the cloth in your hand or the texture of the
surface youre cleaning. When we focus on our immediate sensory
experience, these activities arent unpleasant. Its the dread and
reluctance we bring to these tasks that make them undesirable and
off-putting. So the next time you prepare to clean your home, try
some of these approaches:
Select one area to clean thoroughly and slowly.
Perhaps focus on your bedroom, bathroom, or living
room. Looking at this room, how would you objec-
tively describe whatever seems dirty or messy? If you
had to give someone very specific instructions on what
needs to be done, what would you say? Simply telling
yourself (or someone else) Clean up this mess leaves
room for confusion about priorities and even where
to begin. You could spend considerable time dusting,
for example, while the clothes remain strewn all over
the floor.
Break down an overwhelming task into smaller steps.
If something is really dirty or cluttered, our minds tell
us its too much to do, which leads us to feel over-
whelmed and to avoid cleaning at all. Notice whether
you feel intimidated while approaching a particular
|1
chore. Maybe you think it will require a lot of time or
energy, for example. Cognizant of your reactions and
resistance, decide to do just a small part of whatevers
necessary. If you have a sink full of dishes, try washing
only one or two of them. If the bathtub needs scrub-
bing, do just one side.
Slow down your cleaning, and practice mindfulness.
As suggested earlier, sometimes you can find quite
pleasant ways to connect with the sensory experience
of cleaning. Also, try using this time as an opportu-
nity to check in with your body. Notice your move-
ments and bodily sensations as you clean. Try observ-
ing your posture as you stand there doing dishes,
or feel your arms extension and contraction as you
vacuum. Further, if you use your nondominant hand,
youll naturally focus more on your bodily feelings due
to the inherent awkwardness.
Though doing household chores mindfully wont make them
exciting, you can discover some enjoyable momentsor at least,
ones you dont resentwhile cleaning. You also might be surprised
to discover that youre less likely to put off what needs to be done.
Of course, once youre finished, be sure to take a few moments to
focus on your breathing and revel in the fresh scent of your clean
home.
|.
!|.:|s o: t|. :ois., :.i||o::
Because of the density of urban areas, many of us live in close prox-
imity to others. Houses are spaced closely together, or even touching
each other, as in the case of row houses and brownstones. In apart-
ment buildings, people literally live on top of each other. Ceilings,
walls, and floors delineate your personal space, which makes it harder
to perceive just how closeliterallyyou are to your neighbors. In
fact, if youre both leaning against the same wall (albeit on opposite
sides, obviously), youre probably less than six inches apart!
Because of this proximity, what happens in our neighbors
apartments more easily affects us. If our neighbors burn a cake, we
smell it. If they get into a loud argument, we hear it. If they throw
a raucous party, we feel their music shake our floors, windows, and
walls. More catastrophic events adversely affect us too. A fire or
vermin in the house next door can damage or infest our homes.
Similarly, burst pipes and an overflowing toilet in the upstairs
apartment can make it rain in your living room. Not surprisingly,
its easy to get annoyed, angry, and even vengeful at such times.
||
Compassion, kindness, gratitude? All the states of being we strive
to cultivate in our lives can go out the window.
Often, we get stuck in blaming our neighbors for disturbing our
peace and harmony. We consider their actions to be inconsiderate
or even purposefully harmful. While confrontations can escalate
to the point where neighbors are consciously feuding with each
other, its usually something more benign at the beginning. The
toddler running around upstairs is playing aroundnot trying to
disrupt our work or meditation practice. And the childs caregivers
are not encouraging or condoning the behavior simply to upset us.
Maintaining such negative judgments merely perpetuates destruc-
tive emotions (such as anger or hatred), making it more difficult to
negotiate a successful resolution.
So what do we do? When were angry and disturbed by our
neighbors, how can we reconnect with the positive emotions toward
others that we strive to elicit in more peaceful moments? And how
do we get along better with our neighbors, especially when theyre
disturbing us?
Dont assume your neighbors know what you can hear
in your house or apartment. Often, our negative reac-
tions are based on the assumption that they are doing
something wrong to us. But almost always, our neigh-
bors actions result from whats going on in their own
homes, not ours. This perspective suggests it might be
beneficial to let the neighbors know what were expe-
riencing in our homes and allow them to make some
adjustments in their behavior.
Similarly, dont assume you know whats happening in
your neighbors homes. A visiting house sitter or a lost
or malfunctioning remote could be causing the very
||
loud TV. Or your neighbors might have turned up the
volume to drown out a loud argument, compensate
for hearing impairment, or try out some new stereo
speakers. As you can see, none of these explanations
has anything to do with you or your home, so dont
take their actions personally.
Politely and respectfully discuss the disturbance with
your neighbors. Explain objectively how their actions,
noise, and so on affect the environment in your own
home. Invite them to provide feedback about you
as a neighbor. Living close to each other necessarily
requires us to exercise mutual respect and consider-
ation. We cant just ask for concessions and accommo-
dations; we have to be willing to make similar adjust-
ments in our own lives in the interest of preserving
and improving our relationships with others.
Invite yourself to be the neighbor you would love to
have. Who would be your ideal neighbor? Would you
like someone whos friendly, generous, and consider-
ate or someone whos aloof, possessive, and critical?
Ultimately, you cant control your neighbors actions,
but you can control your own behavior. Instead of
getting caught up in feeling disrespected, why not
consider how you can change to become more consid-
erate, accepting, and compassionate toward your noisy
neighbor? Though it might take a while to improve
an already strained relationship, exploring these issues
might help you feel a little better now. And with
repeated practice, your neighbor might eventually
come around too.
|
|.i::.: \.o is :ot
We love our pets. We lavish them with attention and treats as they
provide us with unconditional love and support. They become vital
family members, and the next thing you know, were discussing
them at dinner parties as if they were our children. If were not
careful, though, we can forget how much they mean to us. We
get caught up in the excitement and hassle of city life by going
out more often or working later, and dont value our pets as much
as we did initially. We might even start focusing on the negative
aspects of having them around, like having to pay expensive veteri-
nary bills, walk them outside in freezing weather, and clean up hair
balls. Even nice quality time snuggling on the couch can quickly
degenerate into something less enjoyable as we push them away,
recalling something horrible they did earlier in the day, like peeing
on the floor. If we start feeling less connected to our pets, the solu-
tion isnt to spend even less time with them. Buying more hours of
doggy day care or a new scratching post wont make us enjoy being
with our pets again. It might assuage our guilt temporarily or help
|
us compensate for being unavailable for a little while, but its not a
long-term solution.
Given these considerations, why not spend some time with
your furry (scaly, feathery, or whatever) loved one? Research
focused on our interactions with cats and dogs shows that having
pets improves our own physical and mental health (Giaquinto and
Valentini 2009). For example, petting a dog can actually lower your
blood pressure (Vormbrock and Grossberg 1988). So, even for your
own health, it helps to reconnect with your beloved pet. If you
dont have one, consider spending time with someone elses pet,
like a friends or neighbors, or even loitering at one of those seem-
ingly ubiquitous animal-adoption stations.
Without doing anything else, spend ten minutes simply petting,
rubbing, and scratching your pet. Does this sound too easy? Well,
be sure to totally focus on your pet without talking on the phone,
watching TV, texting, or engaging in any other activity. Also,
dont get wrapped up in looking for lumps, untangling knots, or
grooming your pet in any way. The primary purpose is simply to
connect with the unfolding experience through visual observation
and touch. Consider what happens from two perspectives, yours
and your pets:
What does your pet seem to like and dislike? Does
your pet seem to prefer being scratched, rubbed, or
petted on certain areas of the body? And does your pet
prefer one kind of touch over another in these areas?
What about the speed or vigorousness of the petting?
Does your pet like a slow, light stroking or a rough,
belly-shaking rubdown? How can you tell? What do
you notice that encourages you to keep doing what-
ever youre doing or signals you to stop? Does your
|;
pet purr, bark, pant, whimper, coo, growl, hiss, moan,
squawk, sing, bite, scratch, or walk away?
From your own perspective, how does it feel to touch
your pets fur, coat, skin, or feathers? What do you
notice as you concentrate your attention on your fin-
gertips? Does your pet feel fluffy, wiry, scratchy, scaly,
fleshy, bony, warm, or cool to your touch? How would
you describe the feel of your pet to a stranger?
|8
l. o :i!.:..
One of the more powerful life experiences is to go on a silent medi-
tation retreat. It allows you to become more aware of the sounds
aroundand voices withinyou. Without the usual chatter,
a retreat also helps you focus on your immediate experience.
Typically, we seek more natural, isolated settings for this practice.
Indeed, wonderful places exist all over the world where you can be
with silence.
You can also create a day of silence for yourself without leaving
the city. Though perhaps not as romantic as meditating by a pris-
tine lake or desert cliff, it can be just as profound, especially since
you literally bring the practice into your own home. Why not spend
a whole day creating a silent retreat for yourself?
To the extent possible, create rules and a daily schedule that
mirror the experience of being away from it all. Here are some of
the more important considerations:
|
Vow not to speak to others during the day, except in
an emergency. You will maintain silence, just as if you
were away on a meditation retreat.
Inform others of your intention. Discourage people
from speaking to you during this time. If you nor-
mally call your mother three times a day, tell her you
wont be available during your retreat. Or perhaps
invite someone to participate in the retreat with you.
Especially powerful for couples living together, this
option supports your mutual dedication to mindful-
ness and forms a special connection, allowing you to
be fully present and attentive to each otheralbeit
wordlesslyin the same space.
Unplug or turn off all noisy electronic distractions in
your home. Dont answer the phone, watch TV, get
on the computer, surf the Internet, play video games,
or listen to music during this time. Obviously, the city
sounds (including neighbors, roommates, pets, chil-
dren, and so on) will continue, but youll reduce the
amount of noise by omitting the usual distractions.
Schedule what you plan to do throughout the day.
Typically, silent retreats have periods set aside for
sitting and walking meditations. Determine the time
and duration of your meditations. Depending on your
familiarity with all-day retreats, perhaps plan several
hour-long meditations where you alternate twenty
minutes sitting with ten minutes walking.
Select some books, chapters, verses, or poems to read.
Retreats typically include periodic meetings or talks
|o
with spiritual leaders. Though you wont have the
advantage of such a guides live presence, you can
find written material that provides opportunities for
reflection.
When not meditating or reading, mindfully experience
whatever you do. If youre sitting on the couch, allow
yourself to feel what its like to sit. If youre walking to
another room, feel how your feet make contact with
the floor. You might also try some of the other mind-
fulness practices outlined in this part of the book, like
attentively petting your dog or cat.
Mindfully prepare and eat your meals. Ideally, try
making each meal from scratch as you slowly attend to
preparing each ingredient (and cooking). Try washing
and drying each lettuce leaf, for example. During
mealtime, focus on the foods taste in your mouth.
Your tongue has different taste receptors for detecting
bitter, salty, sweet, and sour flavors. These receptors
are distributed on different areas of your tongue so
that the same mouthful of food has a different flavor
depending on its physical location. During meals,
move the food around in your mouth and try to dis-
tinguish these different flavors.
Start and end your day of silence whenever you wish.
Maybe decide to practice from sunrise to sundown, or
ten to two. Regardless of your selected times, maintain
the boundaries; resist the urge to end prematurely.
Beginning and ending your silent practice with a set-
tling ritual, like ringing a bell or offering a compassion
or gratitude prayer, also helps.
|1
|ost !o:
Crowds, noise, and congestion contribute significantly to the stress
we urbanites experience. Without these annoyances, cities actually
can be quite peaceful and meditative places. Have you ever walked
through the city late at night or early in the morning, when most
people are asleep? A sense of calm permeates the surrounding air,
despite the fact that hundreds of thousandsor even millionsof
people live around you.
Unless youre an early riser or night owl, youll have few oppor-
tunities to experience the city this way. However, its relatively easy
to imagine. Typically, such relaxation-oriented visualizations invite
you to think of a walk on a beach, a hike through a forest, or a
stroll through a garden. Why not try to introduce the same sense
of stillness and calm by picturing yourself walking through the city
or your own neighborhood? Experiencing the city this wayeven
in your imaginationwill help you feel calmer and increase your
likelihood of bringing this same relaxed attitude along when youre
actually out on a walk.
|.
Practice this meditation whenever you need a little stress relief.
Maybe you are having trouble sleeping, or need to soothe yourself
after a long day at work. Both circumstances are good examples of
appropriate times to try this exercise.
To create a tranquil urban visualization, try to sort out all the
details beforehand. Consider the following questions to get you
started:
Are you by yourself or walking with a friend? Are
people in the distance, or is the area deserted, like a ghost town?
Usually, its easier to imagine that no ones around you, but you
can also imagine others on the street. Ideally, theyll smile happily
while passing by.
Where will you walk? On your street, through
Georgetown, along Rodeo Drive? Determining the location gives
you a better sense of what it looks like. Ideally, to make it easier to
bring to mind, select a place you have previously visited.
Elucidate the information
you receive from your five senses. What do you see? Is it daytime or
nighttime? What buildings and architecture do you notice? What
do you smell? Whats it like temperaturewise? Is it rainy or sunny?
Try to imagine yourself
feeling calm, secure, and peaceful. Theres no point in picturing
yourself scared or stressedthats for sure! In fact, research shows
that visual imagery can reduce or increase anxiety (Holmes and
Matthews 2005). If you imagine something negative, youre more
likely to feel stressed. If you imagine something positive, youre
more likely to feel relaxed. Consequently, therapists often success-
||
fully use this practice to treat phobias and other anxiety disorders
(Leahy 2009).
Is there something you want to see,
like the glowing neon lights of Times Square or the rippling shore
of Lake Michigan? Perhaps you simply want to get a breath of fresh
air? Be sure to include this experience in your visualization.
If you enjoy this meditation, try setting aside time in the
early morning or late evening for an actual walk through the city.
Remaining alert for any safety concerns, try strolling slowly and
mindfully down the sidewalk while basking in the citys twilight
glow. Notice how it feels to be in this space, as well as whatever
judgments come to mind. You might find that the actual experi-
ence is better than you imagined.
|
l.:.isi: \...t.:..
We spend a lot of time exercising or thinking about exercise. Every
day, were bombarded by reminders to work out and take care of
our bodies. Some of us establish exercise regimens, regularly going
to the gym, yoga studio, or martial arts center. Others set particu-
lar goals for athletic achievement, like running a marathon, and
train accordingly. Unable to set aside consistent blocks of time for
exercise, many of us try to incorporate more physical activity into
our daily lives by taking the stairs instead of the elevator, or getting
off the subway or bus a stop early and walking the rest of the way.
Regardless of what we do for exercise, we all have particular
attitudes about it, especially its duration and intensity. But usually
our judgments are pretty negative. When was the last time you
heard a friend or family member complain about doing enough or
even too much exercise? Have you ever heard someone voice these
thoughts? Instead, people are more likely to dwell on what theyre
not doing, or feel bad about how poorly theyre performing. Of
|;
course, its all relative: one person feels guilty about being unable to
make the time to run more than once a week, while another feels
disappointed about being unable to break a six-minute mile.
Our tendency to berate ourselves about exercise has one of
three unfortunate consequences: we lose motivation and stop exer-
cising; we push ourselves too far beyond our capabilities, thus invit-
ing injury; or we continue to do what were doing while feeling
miserable about it. None of these options is particularly appeal-
ing, is it? Fortunately, once we recognize the negative impact of
our attitudes about exercise, we can work on cultivating a different
relationship with what were doing, one thats more grateful and
accepting. Here are four tips on cultivating such acceptance:
Describe what you do for exercise in concrete terms,
without judging or evaluating. If you run twice a week,
youre running twice a week. Its as simple as that. It
doesnt make you a bad or good person; it just is what
it is. If you cant do a headstand in yoga, you cant
do a headstand. If you can, you can. Neither scenario
makes you worthless or marvelous.
Free yourself from comparisons to others. Often, we
devalue our workouts because somebodys always faster,
stronger, or more skillful than we are. Or we compare
ourselves in the now to ourselves in the past, when we
were much more athletic, slim, and fit. Though main-
taining these kinds of comparisons can motivate people
who are fairly competitive, they generally make the rest
of us feel miserable. Doing so also increases your like-
lihood of pushing yourself beyond your limits in ways
that might cause damage or injuries. You might add
|8
too much weight to the bench press or strain yourself
during a yoga pose, just to placate your inner critic.
Appreciate and be grateful for what you can do and have
done. Being able to exercise at all suggests having a body
thats capable of moving and helping us get through our
daily lives. Thinking about exercising without acting on
it also reflects a potentially important value for you
physical healthwhich helps you determine your sched-
ule and priorities. In mindfulness-based stress reduction
(MBSR), a program designed to help people with chronic
pain, one of the more powerful exercises is a body scan
in which participants slowly and systematically observe
whats happening in each part of the body (starting with
the toes) (Kabat-Zinn 1990). Not surprisingly, with this
perspective, people realize that many parts of the body
feel fine and work well. Similarly, for our own exercise
routines, it feels better to acknowledge whats working
than to dwell on whats wrong.
Accept your injuries. When we move, were also more
likely to get injured; its a risk inherent in any activ-
ity. Even when walking down the street (especially
while chewing gum), were at risk of falling or twist-
ing an ankle. And over time, we can accumulate inju-
ries that turn into chronic conditions if we rush the
healing process. As a result, we need to simply accept
our own limitations and pain. It might not be fair or
what you want, but its how things are. Railing against
your injuries or pushing yourself in painful ways simply
aggravates your condition, delays your recovery, and
worsens your pain, thus limiting your activities in the
|
future. Sure, it isnt fair that you have this injury. But
most likely, theres something you can do physically.
Maybe its not specifically what you want, but perhaps
it reflects the value you place on health, which under-
scores your commitment to exercise in the first place.
o
.: You ::.!! !|.t.
Ah, cities! The wonderful sights, sounds, and smells! Smells? Whats
so nice about the smells? Weve got smog, litter, trash, and dog
poop! What smells good about that?
Nothing, really. Cities usually dont smell very nice. Admittedly,
country living is no picnic either; ever driven near a chicken farm?
Yet, like other aspects of urban living, unpleasant smells can be a
wake-up call to mindfulnessa kind of spiritual smelling salts, if
you will.
When we find ourselves smelling something bad or rotten,
we can notice our revulsion and distaste. We can also choose to
remove ourselves from that particular place in hope of finding
something nicer a little farther away. Being mindful and accept-
ing the present moment doesnt mean you need to resign yourself
to putting up with something bad if you can change it. If youre
standing really close to a pile of garbage and it smells bad, move.
No special dignity or award lies in tolerating an unpleasant situa-
tion that you can easily change. The difference is in the attitude
1
you bring to the situation. If you notice a distasteful smell and
simply movewonderful! But its not so helpful to get preoccupied
with the smells source, curse the citys lack of cleanliness, and start
remembering all of the rotten smells youve ever experienced.
Of course, in addition to the citys bad smells, we can easily
find pleasant ones too, like the aroma of baking bread wafting
outside bakeries and bagel shops. Florist shops, fruit stands, farmers
markets, cafs, perfumeries, candle stores, and body-care shops all
provide an opportunity to smell something nice. In New York,
freshly cut flowers typically line the fronts of bodegas. Usually, a
tarp hangs down from the storefront to protect them from direct
sunlight, plus it serves to keep the wonderful scents of the roses,
lilies, and hyacinths concentrated in the small space. Aaah, spend-
ing a few moments immersed in the sweet, honey-like aromas is a
delightful way to recharge before rushing to your next appointment.
.
\ \.!| i: t|. l.:|
For centuries, societies and cultures worldwide have expressed the
need to get away from it all. Whether by going on a religious pil-
grimage or vacationing on Marthas Vineyard, people seek experi-
ences outside their day-to-day environments. For us urbanites, this
usually means some combination of hiking in the country, skiing
in the mountains, camping in the woods, swimming at the beach,
or simply picnicking in the local park. If we have a little money to
spend, this excursion can involve touring wine country, attend-
ing a yoga retreat, or relaxing at a spa. Intuitively, were drawn to
natural settings, and research demonstrates that being in nature
is associated with promoting health and well-being (Hartig et al.
2003). But why?
About twenty years ago, Stephen and Rachel Kaplan (no rela-
tion to the author) proposed a theory of why we benefit more psy-
chologically and physiologically from being in nature than in cities.
Their attention restoration theory suggests that environments requir-
ing directed, sustained attention, like living in chaotic urban areas,
|
eventually drain our mental resources, leaving us feeling tired and
less able to manage surrounding uncertainty and stress (Kaplan
and Kaplan 1989). Natural settings, which require only indirect
attention, thus provide an opportunity to recharge our mental
batteries.
Consider an example comparing hiking in the mountains with
walking down a busy street. Generally, hiking doesnt require a
focused, top-down kind of attention. We get enjoyment from the
rich sensory environment of sounds, smells, and sights, but nothing
demands our attention. We dont focus on a specific tree or bird-
call, but rather attend to the symphony-like integration of sensory
stimuli. In contrast, walking down a busy street requires more of
both our direct and indirect attention. Our indirect attention is
consumed by dramatic stimuli, like sirens, provocative window dis-
plays, and interesting smells. Our direct attention not only tries to
suppress this competing information but also focuses on dodging
oncoming pedestrians and making sure we dont step on anything
too disgusting.
So, attention restoration theory suggests that one reason we
feel better in nature is that it requires less attention (Kaplan 1995).
By not demanding such an intense use of our directed attention,
being in nature allows us to rest and recharge our attentional bat-
teries, if you will. Previous research indeed supports the corre-
sponding hypothesis that our attention and memory improve when
were in nature (Berto 2005). Fortunately for us city dwellers, we
can get similar relief without retreating to the country.
In 2008, a group of University of Michigan researchers tested
attention restoration theory by comparing a walk downtown with a
walk in the park (literally) (Berman, Jonides, and Kaplan 2008). In
a well-designed experiment, they discovered that both conditions
helped improve participants attention and short-term memory.
However, the participants in the group that walked in the park (for
|
about an hour) had a significantly greater improvement in ability to
concentrate. They also felt better moodwise, which was unrelated
to their improved attention.
So if you ever struggle with flagging attention at work or simply
need a break, maybe youll benefit from a little dose of nature.
Check out the many options around you:
Take a stroll in your local park. Be sure to venture
into areas where you are more surrounded by plant
life, rather than merely walk around the periphery or
near a main road. Ideally, try to have as few as pos-
sible of the usual urban distractions.
Explore the unexpected green space around you, like
a rooftop garden, museum spot, florists shop, or natu-
rally scenic area on a local college campus.
Check out your local botanical garden, which provides
a nice opportunity to view a lot of different kinds of
plants within a relatively small space.
Theoretically, looking across an ocean or lake brings
similar relief. So if you live or work near a large body
of water (like in Chicago or San Francisco), spend
some time looking toward the horizon. Admittedly,
this might look a little bizarre to passersby. But if
anyone asks, just say youre waiting for your lover to
return from sea.
In all of these circumstances, try to simply be in the space and
experience it mindfully. Resist the temptation to bring a book or
check your phone messages. Immerse yourself as much as possible
in the nature around you.
l!..|s o :..:
Water cascades down a vertical wall of rock, creating a muffled roar
as it splashes into the pool below. Pink and purple flowers burst like
fireworks. Sunlight peeks through the canopy of trees overhead,
casting shadows that dance across the mottled stones underfoot.
Sounds nice, huh? A bucolic retreat to nature? Not quite. What if
I said you can have this pleasant experience in a small lot between
office buildings in midtown Manhattan? Paley Park, a private park
made available for the public, is located near the intersection of
Fifth Avenue and Fifty-third Street.
Since the creation of cities, weve set aside natural areas for
public use in the form of parks. Typically, these parks required that
a large amount of space be dedicated for this purpose. For example,
the National Mall in Washington, D.C., is over three hundred
acres, San Franciscos Golden Gate Park is over a thousand acres,
and San Diegos Balboa Park is about twelve hundred acres. Over
the past few decades, there has been a growing movement to create
smaller urban spaces dedicated to nature too. Literally sprouting all
over town, these smaller parks are known by many names, includ-
ing microparks, pocket parks, and miniparks. Some of these
parks are professionally developed (for example, Waterfall Garden
in Seattle), while others reflect the actions of neighbors armed with
trowels and seed packets.
Old, abandoned rail lines have also been converted into parks,
providing a strip of nature through crowded urban areas. In New
York, an abandoned elevated train track was reclaimed as an urban
garden and dubbed the High Line. According to Friends of the
High Line (personal communication), in less than six months of
operation, over a million people had visited the park. In Chicago,
people have organized to try to create a park along another ele-
vated rail line, called the Bloomingdale Trail.
Rebar, an interdisciplinary collection of San Francisco artists,
developed another interesting reclamation of space. In 2005, they
created an art installation of a small park located literally within
the confines of a parking space. Since then, Rebars PARK(ing) Day
has been celebrated annually in cities worldwide, as artists, citizens,
organizations, and companies create small oases of green in parking
spots. If you want to learn more, visit the Rebar website (www.
rebargroup.org) or the PARK(ing) Day website (www.parkingday.
org), or even join the community of people dedicated to creating
these spaces (my.parkingday.org).
Whether in the form of a micropark or the temporary greening
of a parking spot, these flecks of green in the city can be hard to
find. They typically have a small footprint, despite their growing
numbers. If youre interested in exploring new locales for contem-
plation, here are a few suggestions:
Conduct an Internet search of your city or neighbor-
hood with the terms micropark, vest park, pocket
park, and minipark. You might be surprised to dis-
;
cover a small park tucked around the corner from
your work or home.
Visit the website of Project for Public Spaces (www.
pps.org), an organization operating for over thirty years
that lists Great Public Spaces in cities worldwide.
Find a satellite image or birds-eye view of the area
around your home and work. From this new perspec-
tive, you might discover an open space thats hidden
from view when youre on the street.
Regularly visit blogs that reflect whats happening
in your neighborhood. Local blogs reflect the word
on your street and thus can reveal interesting green
spaces in planning or development.
Finally, be on the lookout for any vacant, overgrown
lots around you. By conducting a little research on the
address, you might discover some unused public space
that you can convert into a small park or community
garden (with a lot of help from your friends!). The
land for a recently inaugurated community garden in
Brooklyn, for example, was initially discovered while a
local resident was trying to find a vacant lot for parking
his car. The overgrown lot seemed like a perfect
choice, until he discovered that it was owned by the
New York City Department of Parks and Recreation.
A quest for parking unearthed a new space for urban
gardeners! Maybe you can find a similar undiscovered
treasure in your neighborhood.
8
!odd!.: !i:.
Young children are very mindful beings: theyre curious about their
experiences, accepting of their emotions, and exquisitely attuned to
whats happening in the present moment. For example, as a toddler,
my oldest son showed an avid interest in pigeons. He was quick to
spot them and squealed delightedly as he chased after them. After
theyd flown away, he would pick up a forgotten feather, which
became an object of meditation for the whole day. The rest of us
either dont usually notice pigeons or judge them negatively (for
example, rats with wings). Of these perspectives, which do you
think would bring you more happiness?
It seems as if, through our contemplative practice, were often
trying to regain these childlike qualities. Though we might not
want to run through flocks of birds, we certainly envy the excite-
ment, freshness, and lack of self-consciousness of those who do. If
you have children (or see them around), you can learn valuable
lessons from them as they interact with you and the world around
them:
1;8
Allman, L. 1999. The possibilities toolkit: Your guide to better mental
health (unpublished group therapy workbook). Augustus F.
Hawkins Comprehensive Community Mental Health Center, Los
Angeles, CA.
Alicke, M. D., and E. Zell. 2008. Social comparison and envy. In
Envy: Theory and research, ed. R. H. Smith, 7393, New York:
Oxford University Press.
Baron, N. S. 2008. Always On: Language in an Online and Mobile
World. New York: Oxford University Press.
Beck, A. T., G. Emery, and R. L. Greenberg. 1985. Anxiety Disorders
and Phobias: A Cognitive Perspective. New York: Basic Books.
Benson, H., and M. Z. Klipper. 1976. The Relaxation Response. New
York: HarperTorch.
Berman, M. G., J. Jonides, and S. Kaplan. 2008. The cognitive benefits
of interacting with nature. Psychological Science 19 (12):120712.
Berto, R. 2005. Exposure to restorative environments helps restore
attentional capacity. Journal of Environmental Psychology 25
(3):24959.
Boyce, W. T., P. ONeill-Wagner, C. S. Price, M. Haines, and S. J.
Suomi. 1998. Crowding, stress, and violent injuries among
behaviorally inhibited rhesus macaques. Health Psychology 17
(3):28589.
Calhoun, J. B. 1962. Population density and social pathology. Scientific
American 206 (2):13948.
Campbell-Sills, L., D. H. Barlow, T. A. Brown, and S. G. Hofmann.
2006. Acceptability and suppression of negative emotion in
anxiety and mood disorders. Emotion 6 (4):58795.
Chong, H., J. L. Riis, S. M. McGinnis, D. M. Williams, P. J. Holcomb,
and K. R. Daffner. 2008. To ignore or explore: Top-down modu-
lation of novelty processing. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 20
(1):12034.
1;
Crouse, K. 2009. Avoiding the deep end when it comes to jitters. New
York Times, July 26, sports section.
de Lucia, L. Metropolitan diary. 2008. New York Times, November 16,
region section. www.nytimes.com/2008/11/17/nyregion/17diary.ht
ml?partner=permalink&exprod=permalink (accessed December
4, 2009).
Driskell, J. E., C. Copper, and A. Moran. 1994. Does mental prac-
tice improve performance? Journal of Applied Psychology 79
(4):48192.
Immobilization and cold stress affect sympatho-adrenomedul-
lary system and pituitary-adrenocortical axis of rats exposed to
long-term isolation and crowding. Physiology and Behavior 81
(3):40915.
Eriksson, P. S., E. Perfilieva, T. Bjrk-Eriksson, A. M. Alborn, C.
Nordborg, D. A. Peterson, and F. H. Gage. 1998. Neurogenesis in
the adult human hippocampus. Nature Medicine 4 (11):131317.
Giaquinto, S., and F. Valentini. 2009. Is there a scientific basis for pet
therapy? Disability and Rehabilitation 31 (7):59598.
Griskevicius, V., J. M. Tybur, S. W. Gangestad, E. F. Perea, J. R.
Shapiro, and D. T. Kenrick. 2009. Aggress to impress: Hostility
as an evolved context-dependent strategy. Journal of Personality
and Social Psychology 96 (5):98094.
Hartig, T., G. W. Evans, L. D. Jamner, D. S. Davis, and T. Grling.
2003. Tracking restoration in natural and urban field settings.
Journal of Environmental Psychology 23 (2):10923.
Hill, S. E., and D. M. Buss. 2008. The evolutionary psychology of
envy. In Envy: Theory and research, ed. R. H. Smith, 6070. New
York: Oxford University Press.
Holmes, E. A., and A. Matthews. 2005. Mental imagery and emotion:
A special relationship? Emotion 5 (4):48997.
18o
Kabat-Zinn, J. 1990. Full Catastrophe Living: Using the Wisdom of Your
Body and Mind to Face Stress, Pain, and Illness. New York: Delta.
. 1994. Wherever You Go, There You Are: Mindfulness Meditation
in Everyday Life. New York: Hyperion.
Kabat-Zinn, J., and M. Kabat-Zinn. 2009. Mindful parenting:
Cultivating self-awareness, compassion, and understanding.
Presentation at Meditation and Psychotherapy: Cultivating
Compassion and Wisdom conference, Department of Psychiatry,
Cambridge Health Alliance Physicians Organization, at Harvard
Medical School Department of Continuing Education, May 2, in
Boston, MA.
Kaplan, R., and S. Kaplan. 1989. The Experience of Nature: A
Psychological Perspective. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Kaplan, S. 1995. The restorative benefits of nature: Toward an
integrative framework. Journal of Environmental Psychology 15
(3):16982.
Kaplan, S., L. V. Bardwell, and D. B. Slakter. 1993. The museum
as a restorative environment. Environment and Behavior 25
(6):72542.
Kimmelman, M. 2009. At Louvre, many stop to snap, but few stay to
focus. New York Times, August 2, art and design section.
Kleiber, C., and D. C. Harper. 1999. Effects of distraction on childrens
pain and distress during medical procedures: A meta-analysis.
Nursing Research 48 (1):4449.
Kristeller, J. L., and C. B. Hallett. 1999. An exploratory study of a
meditation-based intervention for binge eating disorder. Journal of
Health Psychology 4 (3):35763.
Leahy, R. L. 2005. The Worry Cure: Seven Steps to Stop Worry from
Stopping You. New York: Harmony.
. 2009. Anxiety Free: Unravel Your Fears Before They Unravel
You. New York: Hay House.
181
Lohr, V. I., C. H. Pearson-Mims, and G. K. Goodwin. 1996. Interior
plants may improve worker productivity and reduce stress in a
windowless environment. Journal of Environmental Horticulture 14
(2):97100.
Marlatt, G. A., and J. R. Gordon, ed. 1985. Relapse Prevention:
Maintenance Strategies in the Treatment of Addictive Behaviors. New
York: The Guilford Press.
Mittone, L., and L. Savadori. 2009. The scarcity bias. Applied Psychology
58 (3):45368.
Moore, J. 1999. Population density, social pathology, and behavioral
ecology. Primates 40 (1):122.
National Coffee Association. 2009. National coffee drinking trends
2009. www.ncausa.org/i4a/pages/index.cfm?pageID=647 (accessed
October 6, 2009).
Orsillo, S. M., and L. Roemer, ed. 2005. Acceptance- and Mindfulness-
Based Approaches to Anxiety: Conceptualization and Treatment.
New York: Springer.
Park, S-H., and R. H. Mattson. 2008. Effects of flowering and foliage
plants in hospital rooms on patients recovering from abdominal
surgery. HortTechnology 18 (4):56368.
Post, E. 1922. Etiquette in Society, in Business, in Politics and at Home.
New York: Funk and Wagnalls.
Ramsden, E. 2009. The urban animal: Population density and social
pathology in rodents and humans. Bulletin of the World Health
Organization 87 (2):82.
Segal, Z. V., J. M. G. Williams, and J. D. Teasdale. 2002. Mindfulness-
Based Cognitive Therapy for Depression: A New Approach to
Preventing Relapse. New York: The Guilford Press.
Serrell, B. 1997. Paying attention: The duration and allocation of visi-
tors time in museum exhibitions. Curator 40 (2):10825.
18.
Skinner, B. F. 1953. Science and Human Behavior. New York: The
Macmillan Company.
Slater, A. 2007. Escaping to the gallery: Understanding the motiva-
tions of visitors to galleries. International Journal of Nonprofit and
Voluntary Sector Marketing 12 (2):14962.
Thich Nhat Hanh. 1991. Peace Is Every Step: The Path of Mindfulness
in Everyday Life. New York: Bantam Books.
Ulrich, R. S. 1984. View through a window may influence recovery
from surgery. Science 224 (4647):42021.
Underhill, P. 1999. Why We Buy: The Science of Shopping. New York:
Touchstone.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Noise Abatement
and Control. 1981. Noise Effects Handbook: A Desk Reference
to Health and Welfare Effects of Noise. Revised ed. Fort Walton
Beach, FL: National Association of Noise Control Officials. www
.nonoise.org/library/handbook/handbook.htm (accessed December
11, 2009).
Vormbrock, J. K., and J. M. Grossberg. 1988. Cardiovascular effects
of humanpet dog interactions. Journal of Behavioral Medicine 11
(5):50917.
Weingarten, G. 2007. Pearls before breakfast. Washington Post, April
8.
Wickelgren, W. A. 1977. Speed-accuracy tradeoff and information
processing dynamics. Acta Psychologica 41 (1):6785.
Wu, P-L., and W-B. Chiou. 2009. More options lead to more searching
and worse choices in finding partners for romantic relationships
on-line: An experimental study. CyberPsychology and Behavior 12
(3):31518.
Yerkes, R. M., and J. D. Dodson. 1908. The relation of strength of
stimulus to rapidity of habit formation. Journal of Comparative
Neurology and Psychology 18 (5):45982.
Jonathan S. Kaplan, Ph.D., is a clinical psychologist who special-
izes in the application of mindfulness and meditation to psycho-
therapy. He founded UrbanMindfulness.org in 2008, and maintains
a private practice in New York City where he provides psycho-
therapy, professional training, and clinical supervision. He lives in
Brooklyn with his wife and two children.
5 1 5 9 5
9 781572 247499