Eruption! Discussion Guide
Eruption! Discussion Guide
Eruption! Discussion Guide
Meets Adventure
D i s c u s s i o n a n d a c t i v i t y G u i d e
Eruption! Volcanoes and the Science of Saving Lives is part of the award-winning Sci-
entists in the Field series, which began in 1999. This distinguished and innovative series
examines the work of real-life scientists doing actual research. Young readers discover
what it is like to be a working scientist, investigate an intriguing research project in action,
and gain a wealth of knowledge about fascinating scientific topics. Outstanding writing
and stellar photography are features of every book in the series. Reading levels vary, but
the books will interest a wide range of readers.
Humans have lived next to volcanoes for thousands of years despite the fact
that when volcanoes erupt, humans suffer. Scientists studying volcanoes have
learned a great deal about them, especially the many detectable warning signs
leading up an eruption. A group of scientists banded together to form the
first and only international volcano crises team, the Volcano Disaster Assis-
tance Program or VDAP, hoping to predict eruptions and save lives. Eruption!
chronicles the work of an early member of the VDAP team, Andy Lockhart,
and the efforts of the team to accurately forecast eruptions and the many prob-
lems involved.
Tom Uhlman has taken the photographs for many books, including ones about
the Underground Railroad and our solar system, but he especially loves to pho-
tograph nature. He has worked on two other Scientists in the Field books, The
Bat Scientist and Emi and the Rhino Scientist, both with his wife, the author
Mary Kay Carson. He lives with Mary Kay in Cincinnati with their dog, Ruby.
Pre-Reading Activity
Pass out samples of igneous rocks (granite, quartz, feldspar, mica, obsidian),
sedimentary rocks (shale, sandstone), and metamorphic rocks (marble, quartz-
ite, slate). Review the way these rocks are formed. Pass out cano damage have federal standards in place that determine
some local rocks and try to place them in the correct cat- where buildings should be placed and how they should be
egory. constructed? Is there a limit to how many times our govern-
If you can obtain some pumice stones, have students predict ment should rebuild and repair damage caused by natural
whether or not rocks float or sink (which should have most disasters?
students rolling their eyes at the question—of course they
sink). Fill a container with water. Drop in several of the lo- Why are the volcanoes in some areas more dangerous than
cal rocks and any quartz or granite or sandstone and watch those in other areas?
them sink. Then drop in the pumice stone. Why does the
pumice stone float? Many towns around the world are close to volcanoes. When
a volcano is dormant, it is easy to forget how dangerous it
Take a look at the long-range weather forecasts from is. The city of Armero was forty-five miles from Nevado del
Farmer’s Almanac and other sources. Would anyone use Ruiz and when it erupted in 1985, and the surging volca-
these predictions for planning purposes? Now look at short- nic mudflows killed 23,000 people. Mt. Vesuvius is five km
term weather predictions (forty-eight hours or less). How from the town of Pompeii, and the eruption in 79 AD killed
accurate are these and what value do they have for plan- 16,000 people. Use a local map and locate places that are 50
ning purposes? Discuss how difficult it can be to predict the miles from your school and places that are 3 miles away. If
weather, even if you are a trained meteorologist. Discuss the one of those locations were a volcano, would you be con-
challenges scientists might likewise face in predicting volca- cerned?
nic eruptions.
Pyroclastic flows can travel 100 miles per hour and volcanic
Discussion Questions mudflows or lahars can travel 50 miles per hour. If a volcano
was 5 miles away how quickly would a pyroclastic flow or a
Yogyakarta is a city of up to 500,000 people, which is lahar reach your town following an eruption? How fast can
about the same range of population as Long Beach, Atlanta, a person travel on foot? How much time would it take to get
Miami, or New Orleans. What would be the financial and everyone in your neighborhood and your town to safety?
social ramifications of ordering cities of this size to evacuate?
Keep in mind Andy Lockhart’s quote on page 9: “‘Evacu- Applying and Extending Our Knowledge
ations hold their own dangers,’ Andy explained. ‘Very old
people, very young babies, and very sick people can suffer On page 14 the volcanoes on Hawaii are described as ones
and even die from the stress of an evacuation.’” that would produce “slowly bubbling lava.” Other volca-
noes, however, produce “pyroclastic flows” of incredible
Lockhart’s team also worries about the impact of making a destructive power. While there are many excellent books and
mistake: “Andy and his colleagues knew that most people online resources for understanding the geology behind this
are only willing to be evacuated once. If nothing happens, book, a great source for activities is the book by Matthys
locals might ignore future warnings.” (p. 9) Given tight bud- Levy and Mario Salvadori, Earthquakes, Volcanoes, and
gets and the difficulty of the task, does it make more sense to Tsunamis: Projects and Principles for Beginning Geologists
fund aid after a disaster or fund disaster prevention? Why is (an excellent complement to Eruption!). Many of the activi-
it easier to fund disaster aid than disaster prevention? ties below are also found in Levy and Salvadori’s book.
Satellites provide information about sulfur dioxide emis- • uild a mound of sand to resemble a mountain. Place
B
sions, temperature, location of ash clouds, direction of wind, a film canister inside the mound so that the opening of
the amount of gasses, and more. Communication technol- the container is level with the top of the “mountain,”
ogy allows immediate release of information to concerned forming a “crater.” In the container place about a half-
parties. Have we made enough advances in technology to teaspoon of baking soda, some liquid soap, and (make
change laws concerning hurricane, earthquake, volcano, or sure to add this last) red wine vinegar. Students should
other weather-related evacuation procedures? Should people be able to see “slowly bubbling lava” flow down the side
be legally required to evacuate? Should places prone to vol- of the mountain.
the volcanoes with elevated warning colors. ing on several sources and refocusing the inquiry when appropriate.
• What is the volcano physically doing that causes the
color categories to change? On page 17 in the sidebar, “Sniffing Out the Gas,” we learn
that geologists search for at least three kinds of gases: carbon
Common Core Connection dioxide, hydrogen sulfide, and sulfur dioxide. The more gas,
the larger and more explosive the eruption.
RH.6-8.7. Integrate visual information (e.g., in charts, graphs,
photographs, videos, or maps) with other information in print and • Have students make models of each of the different gas
digital texts.
molecules. Create flash cards for each molecule explaining its
RI.6.7. Integrate information presented in different media or for- composition and its dangers (to people). Describe the gas’s
mats (e.g., visually, quantitatively) as well as in words to develop a reactions to water or air or to other gases.
coherent understanding of a topic or issue.
• esearch how much of these gasses cause scientists to
R
W.6.7. Conduct short research projects to answer a question, draw- elevate the warning system colors.
ing on several sources and refocusing the inquiry when appropriate.
Common Core Connections
GPS devices locate precisely where various features exist on
a volcano, using longitude and latitude lines. These measure- RH.6-8.7. Integrate visual information (e.g., in charts, graphs,
ments function as the guides that allow the USGS scientist photographs, videos, or maps) with other information in print and
Dan Dzurisin to monitor precisely where the ground swell- digital texts.
ings on Mount St. Helens are located.
RI.6.7. Integrate information presented in different media or for-
mats (e.g., visually, quantitatively) as well as in words to develop a
• ind the longitude and latitude of your school to the
F coherent understanding of a topic or issue.
nearest degree.
W.6.7. Conduct short research projects to answer a question, draw-
• sing Google Maps, zoom in to the location of your
U ing on several sources and refocusing the inquiry when appropriate.
school. Print out maps for students and have them insert
and label a grid showing the precise location of the
classroom. Chapter 5 is entitled “Volcano Training Camp.” In this
chapter, the point is made that volcanoes do not operate
• I f your classroom has a document camera, use this tool according to a convenient schedule. It is entirely likely that
to share several of the students’ maps to show that each someday many volcanoes could erupt simultaneously.
student should have the exact same coordinates (and to
explain the factors that cause any errors). • hat makes a good volcanologist in the first place? Go
W
through the book and make a checklist of skills and
• S hare the exact GPS location (which can be found online knowledge one would have to have in order to be on the
through a longitude latitude search: VDAP team.
www.findlatitudeandlongitude.com).
• ndy says that to be effective, knowledge of the local
A
Common Core Connections area and the local people is essential. Discuss why know-
ing the area and the people would make a local volca-
RH.6-8.7. Integrate visual information (e.g., in charts, graphs, nologist more effective than one from another country.
photographs, videos, or maps) with other information in print and
digital texts.
• hat kinds of information, and from what sources (gov-
W
RI.6.7. Integrate information presented in different media or for- ernment officials or scientists, for instance), will people
mats (e.g., visually, quantitatively) as well as in words to develop a rely on when deciding whether or not to evacuate? Make
coherent understanding of a topic or issue. a chart with these pieces of information and sources, list-
W.6.7. Conduct short research projects to answer a question, draw- ing them from most to least reliable.
Further Reading
S.V.
“Volcanoes and Earthquakes.” Encyclopedia Britannica,
2011.
Latta, Sara L. Lava Scientist: Careers on the Edge of
Volcanoes. Enslow, 2009.
Levy, Matthys. Earthquakes, Volcanoes and Tsunamis:
Projects and Principals for Beginning Geologists.
Chicago Review Press, 2009.
Prager, Ellen. Earthquakes and Volcanoes. Chelsea House,
2009.
Spilsbury, Louise and Richard Spilsbury. Violent Volcanoes.
Heineman, 2010.