2010 Metropolitan Water Plan
2010 Metropolitan Water Plan
2010 Metropolitan Water Plan
2010 Metropolitan Water Plan NSW Office of Water August 2010 ISBN 978-1-74263-077-9 (print version) ISBN 978-1-74263-076-2 (web version) The NSW Office of Water is a separate office within the Department of Environment, Climate Change and Water. State of New South Wales through the Department of Environment, Climate Change and Water, 2010. This material may be reproduced in whole or in part for educational and non-commercial use, providing the meaning is unchanged and its source, publisher and authorship are clearly and correctly acknowledged. For enquiries, please contact info@waterforlife.nsw.gov.au Disclaimer While every reasonable effort has been made to ensure that this document is correct at the time of publication, the State of New South Wales, its agents and employees, disclaim any and all liability to any person in respect of anything or the consequences of anything done or omitted to be done in reliance upon the whole or any part of this document. NOW 10_201
Chris Davis (Chair) On behalf of the Panel: Ross Chapman Ronnie Harding John Langford Blair Nancarrow
2010 Metropolitan Water Plan
Contents
Executive summary An adaptive plan Considerations and challenges of the review What has been achieved? Key initiatives and directions of the 2010 Metropolitan Water Plan 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Setting the scene for the Metropolitan Water Plan Sydneys water supply system Sydneys demand for water What is the Metropolitan Water Plan? What area does the plan cover? Strengthening the legislative framework How is the Metropolitan Water Plan managed so it stays current? Reviewing the 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan to keep it current Outcomes of the review of the 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan The review Considerations for the review Community planning principles Our major achievements Whats next Dams continue to provide a vital rain-fed source Contribution of dams to our water supply Transferring water around the system Accessing water deep in the dams Improving reliability of water supplies to the Blue Mountains Our major achievements Whats next Water recycling is reusing water already in the system Water recycling in Sydney Reusing stormwater Residential recycling of greywater Supporting legislative Our major achievements Whats next Desalination is an extra source of water that doesnt rely on rain Sydneys desalination plant When will we use the desalination plant? Our major achievements Whats next Water efficiency is smart use of the water we have Water efficiency We all have a part to play Smart water use becomes our way of life - Water Wise Rules Our major achievements Whats next Water for life equals water for people and the environment Striking a balance Water for people Water for the environment Caring for our catchments and restoring waterways Our major achievements Whats next Being prepared for drought is good planning Drought readiness Drought restrictions How we would respond to rare and extreme drought? Our major achievements Whats next
4 5 5 6 7 8 9 9 11 11 12 13 14 15 15 17 20 21 21 22 23 23 25 25 25 25 26 27 31 31 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 37 38 39 39 43 44 45 46 47 47 49 51 52 53 54 55 55 56 58 58 60
Executive summary
New variable environmental flows from TallowaDam are improving the health of the lower Shoalhaven River.
Greater Sydneys water supply is secure until at least 2025. With everyone continuing to be water wise, plus dams, recycling, desalination and drought readiness strategies, we can withstand future droughts and supply our growing population while continuing to improve river health.
The 2010 Metropolitan Water Plan builds on the significant achievements of past plans by continuing to concentrate efforts on four major areas dams, recycling, desalination and water efficiency to secure greater Sydneys water supply now and in the future. The 2010 Metropolitan Water Plan continues the commitment to recycle 70billion litres of water each year by 2015 and to save 145 billion litres of water each year through water efficiency measures, as established in the 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan and NSW State Plan. Maintaining this commitment is vital because investments in recycling and water efficiency are essential ways to reduce pressure on drinking water supplies and protect the health of our precious riversystems. The 2010 Metropolitan Water Plan will also continue to foster innovation and toinvestigate and monitor developments in climate change research and best practice water management.
An adaptive plan
The Metropolitan Water Plan is designed to be flexible to enable us to adapt to challenges such as our highly variable climate, droughts, climate change and a growing population. A major review of the plan is undertaken every four years. These regular reviews take account of the latest data, techniques and research to keep our water plan current. The review of the 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan found that only minor adjustments to the directions of that plan are needed to ensure greater Sydney has enough water to meet its needs to at least 2025, and to help protect river health through environmental flows.
Executive summary
Targets for water savings through efficiency and recycling are major commitments under the 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan and the NSW State Plan. Reviewing and confirming these targets was an important part of the review. Many of Sydney Waters water efficiency programs, while highly effective, are reaching maturity and will have less impact in reducing water use over time. Our programs need to tackle this challenge with fresh approaches and newtechnologies. While progress has been solid, challenges also exist in recycling. Providing recycled water to businesses and households in the established highly urbanised areas of Sydney can be complex, energy intensive and expensive. Most of Sydneys major recycling opportunities are concentrated in the new growth areas in western Sydney or at large industrial sites. The review also considered how the plan aligns with the Metropolitan Strategy for Sydney, which sets the overall direction for our urban planning, and the water sharing plans that make sure all users who take water directly from rivers or groundwater have equitable access to water. It also ensured the process was consistent with National Water Initiative urban water planning principles.
implemented new infrastructure to allow variable environmental flow releases and fish passage from Sydneys dams and weirs in the Upper Nepean River system delivered Sydneys desalination plant on time and $89 million under budget, which is able to supply up to 90 billion litres of water per year provided almost one million water conservation rebates and offers rolled out education and training programs, and media campaigns to encourage the community to continue to use water wisely, support implementation of Water Wise Rules and build understanding of greater Sydneys changing water supply system undertook extensive work to make groundwater extraction available to supplement Sydneys water supply in severe drought. (Further development of the borefields was shelved in 2008) built new infrastructure to implement variable environmental flow releases and fish passage from Tallowa Dam on the Shoalhaven River to protect river health making more water available for environmental flows and reducing nutrients entering the river system through the Hawkesbury-Nepean River Recovery Program. The program is funded by the Australian Government through its Water for the Future Program, and managed by the NSW Government through the Office of the Hawkesbury-Nepean incorporated community values and attitudes into the plans update under the expert guidance of the Metropolitan Water Independent ReviewPanel established Australias first state-based access and licensing system under the Water Industry Competition Act 2006 to enable the private sector to enter the industry; providing drinking water, recycled water and wastewater services (see page 12).
Water Minister Phil Costa encouraged the community to have their say during the review of the plan.
Recycling
Desalination
Water efficiency
The adoption of the measures in the table above means that, under all modelled rainfall and dam inflow scenarios, the 2010 plan secures greater Sydneys water supplies until at least 2025. A process summary document has been developed which provides more detail on the portfolio approach to water planning and explains how the security of supply has been established. The document can be found at www.waterforlife.nsw.gov.au/review. *Based on a long-term average usage of 600 billion litres per year
Water efficiency continue to offer existing water efficiency programs to the community to save water in homes and businesses. Long-term water savings will be realised through the Building Sustainability Index (BASIX) and national Water Efficiency Labelling and Standards (WELS) scheme. Environmental flows from Warragamba Dam further investigation and research to determine the optimal environmental flow regime and infrastructure requirements will be undertaken to enable a decision on the long-term flow regime from Warragamba Dam to be made in 2014. Drought restrictions new simpler restrictions, based on the Water Wise Rules, will be implemented should Sydney experience another drought. Innovation continued investigation and investment into new techniques and technologies and developing watersources. Rare and extreme drought a number of measures are available to be implemented in extreme drought to slow the depletion of dams. These include: increasing the amount of water transferred from Tallowa Dam in the Shoalhaven by lowering the allowable drawdown, accessing groundwater, implementing voluntary water usage targets, upscaling the
desalination plant, and investigating the optimal rules for reducing environmental flow releases from dams. Pricing is also being examined as a potential tool for managing demand during a drought. Research climate change research will move into its second phase, investigating techniques to improve the way we build extended drought periods into climate modelling. Water for Life communication, education and capacity building will continue to play an important role in implementing the 2010 Metropolitan Water Plan.
Lake Burragorang, formed by Warragamba Dam, during the height of the drought in late 2006.
We know that Sydneys population is growing, that our climate and rainfall are highly variable, and we understand the impacts of prolonged drought. Wealso understand the need to balance the supply of water to people with the supply of water for the environment. Uncertainty exists, however, about the impacts of climate change, the nature of future droughts, and how our rivers will respond to new river health initiatives. While we can plan for what we do know, we must ensure our approach remains innovative, flexible and adaptive in order to manage these uncertainties.
750,000 Estimated water savings and use (millions of litres) 700,000 650,000 600,000
500,000 450,000
2007
2008
2009
Residential Business Leak reduction Regulatory measures Water Wise Rules Recycled water
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Recycled water
2010
Mount Victoria Richmond Rouse Hill St Marys Penrith Orchard Hills Wallacia Warragamba Dam
nR i ve
r
BLUE MOUNTAINS
Quakers Hill
Ha
b u r y R i v er w kes
Prospect Reservoir
SYDNEY
Liverpool
er Cana l
Bondi
Nepea
U pp
La
ke
Bu
rra
go
Kurnell
ran
Woronora Dam
Na tta i
ve Ri
Picton
0
Cordeaux Dam Avon Dam Nepean Dam Bowral
Wing ecarribee River
10
15
20
25
30
Cataract Dam
Wollongong
Pipeline / tunnel / canal Water filtration plant Sewage treatment plant Recycled water treatment plant Desalination plant Groundwater study area
Wingecarribee Reservoir
ILLAWARRA
Kangaloon
SOUTHERN HIGHLANDS
Fitzroy Falls Reservoir Kiama
lh a S h oa
v en
e Riv
Lake Yarrunga
Sydney
SHOALHAVEN
Shoalhaven
Goulburn
Nowra
Canberra
Nowra
Tasman Sea
Cooma
The landscape has now changed. Good rains in mid 2007 and 2008 meant drought restrictions could be lifted in mid 2009 with the introduction of permanent Water Wise Rules. Sydneys desalination plant is on line and through water efficient behaviour Sydney is now using a similar amount of water as in the early 1970s, despite a population increase of about 1.4million people. Our latest review of the Metropolitan Water Plan has shown that greater Sydneys water supply is secure to at least 2025. While we need to maintain our focus on achieving water efficiency and recycling targets, this means there are now further opportunities to ensure that river health is protected. The 2010 Metropolitan Water Plan sets out how the NSW Government will: provide a secure supply of water to meet the medium-term needs of a growing city, while keeping long-term goals in mind (a key concern for thecommunity) help protect the health of our preciousrivers ensure our water supplies are adequate during drought minimise costs to the community. The 2010 plan will continue to focus onfour main areas to secure our water for life: dams recycling desalination water efficiency.
I feel that the maintenance of a healthy environment enables many of the other needs to be enacted and sustained, including that of addressing the needs of the future generations.
Community comment, Consultation workshop 2009
11
The other three schemes all include a recycling component. The first, was to construct, maintain and operate a new recycled water plant at Fairfield. As part of the Rosehill-Camellia Recycled Water Scheme, the plant will initially provide 4.7 billion litres of recycled water a year to industrial and irrigation customers in western Sydney. High-quality recycled water will then be transported to users through a network of retrofitted gaspipes. Further licences have been issued to a company to operate a recycled water treatment plant in the heart of the Sydney CBD, which will supply recycled water for indoor non-drinking uses. Another recent project has been granted licences to undertake sewer mining in a major development at Darling Harbour to provide recycled water for non-drinking purposes. The 2010 Metropolitan Water Plan will continue to encourage the private sector to develop new technology and enter the industry. Work to streamline the approval process between the Water Industry Competition Act 2006 and the Local Government Act 1993 will ensure that private schemes captured by these Acts receive consistent support through government regulation without the burden of overregulation.
Balancing the needs of the environmentand water users For our river and groundwater systems to be healthy and productive in the long term, it is critical to balance the competing needs of the environment and water users. As part of the Metropolitan Water Plan, greater Sydneys dams are now releasing more water for river health through environmental flows that mimic natural inflow patterns. Under the Water Management Act 2000, the government has developed draft water sharing plans for surface and groundwater sources for greater Sydney. These plans will provide the legal framework for the water sharing aspects of the Metropolitan Water Plan, including legal protection for water allocated to the environment. Following a period of public exhibition, the Water Sharing Plan for the Greater Metropolitan Region Unregulated Water Sources and the Water Sharing Plan for the Greater Metropolitan Region Groundwater Sources are expected to come into force in 2010. These measures support the communitys desire to make sure enough water is available to meet both environmental and human needs, with one not more important than the other. They also reflect community concern that water planners should consider all relevant sectors and regions.
Students from Jasper Road Public School testing the water flow from school taps as part of the Every Drop Counts in Schools Program.
12
13
Nepean Dam overflowed following heavy rain in mid 2007. The dam hadnt spilled since 2000.
The 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan sought to secure greater Sydneys water supply to 2015 and beyond. Our review of the plan has revealed that, with only minor adjustments, the measures adopted in the 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan ensure enough water for our growing population and the environment to at least 2025.
The review
The review process The Metropolitan Water Plan is reviewed every four years to factor in changing circumstances. These include advances in technology, updated projections of population growth and associated water demands, climate change research, rainfall/dam inflows, and community views. In this way we ensure the most effective and appropriate solutions are in place for securing the water needs of greater Sydney. The review of the 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan began in late 2008 and was overseen by the Metropolitan Water Independent Review Panel, a panel of independent experts from a wide range of disciplines. One of the Panels primary roles was to oversee community consultation, which is an integral part of the review process. Following a cross-government review of the latest research, a first phase of community consultation was undertaken in May 2009. The aim was to identify values of high priority to the community and stakeholders in planning for Sydneys water future. In parallel, extensive modelling of the suite of available water supply and demand options was undertaken for input into a cost effectiveness analysis. This round of modelling told us how various portfolios performed under different rainfall and inflow scenarios, including modelling a drought more than twice as severe as the recent drought.
15
A range of supply and demand management options was then presented to the community and stakeholders in November and December 2009. The review also included an assessment of the environmental and social impacts of the mix of measures by expert panels. The panels used the findings of the community consultation and existing information and data on environmental and social indicators to assess the impacts of a range of portfolios. The findings of the consultation, along with analyses of social and environmental factors, were then considered in combination with the cost effectiveness analysis, which compared the portfolios based on the cost of providing water security. From this, government determined the mix of measures needed to secure greater Sydneys water supply to 2025 and beyond. Further detail on the review can be found in a separate process summary published concurrently with this plan and available at www.waterforlife.nsw.gov.au/review. The portfolio of agreed measures forms the basis for this 2010 Metropolitan Water Plan.
Existing commitments There is a wide range of measures currently in place to secure greater Sydneys water supply. These measures reflect past commitments and include major assets such as Sydneys dams and the recently constructed desalination plant. In addition, there are other water supply sources that have not been triggered, such as groundwater borefields (which have been shelved), and the substantial water efficiency and recycling programs that will be implemented to meet targets for the future. Existing commitments also include provision for environmental flows to be released from dams, the operational rules for pumping water from the Shoalhaven system and the triggers for drought water restrictions. For the purposes of this review these current assets and commitments were taken as given and formed the basis of the cost effectiveness analysis.
Modelling future water demand and supply options The Sydney Catchment Authority uses a sophisticated computer model to simulate the performance of the water supply system under various conditions. The model, called WATHNET, includes a detailed representation of the dams, pipes, canals and pumping stations that make up the water supply system, including the desalination plant. Generating thousands of potential inflow events, including a drought more than twice as severe as the recent drought, the model is able to simulate the long-term performance of the existing system under various water supply and demand management options, or potential future portfolios. Cost effectiveness analysis A major part of the review was to analyse the cost effectiveness of various portfolios and their ability to ensure greater Sydneys future water needs are met. Achieving an optimal supply and demand mix requires careful consideration of how all the options interact as part of a portfolio of measures. The cost effectiveness analysis incorporated the cost of the whole portfolio of measures, in order to determine how each portfolio performed against a range of potential rainfall and runoff scenarios for the Sydney catchments (using WATHNET).
Updating models Entering updated data to factor in advances in technology and information, updated projections of population growth and rainfall/ dam inflows into forward-planning models Community input Phase 1 Including community values and views onwater security through workshops and public survey Analysis of options Reviewing economic, social and environmental factors to identify the most appropriate and effective options for the 2010 plan Community input Phase 2 Involving community members in discussion around the proposed mix of measures in the 2010 plan Independent Review Panel (a panel of experts from a range of disciplines established to report on the progress of the Metropolitan Water Plan andoversee community consultation)
16
The WATHNET model outputs include time in drought restrictions, minimum dam storage level reached, volumes of water supplied from different sources, environmental releases and spills from dams. Consideration of these factors shows that while some individual options have a higher unit cost than others, when combined within a whole portfolio they may represent value for money. The costs included in this analysis primarily focused on the capital and operational costs of the various measures and on the social and environmental costs for which data were available. Some environmental and social impacts and benefits are difficult to cost. These were estimated in qualitative terms and used in evaluating the best mix of measures to include in this plan.
The population in Sydney Waters area of operation is expected to reach 5.69million by 2036, a 35 percent increase from 4.22million in 2006. This growth in population is likely to increase annual demand for drinking water by around 66 billion litres compared to demand in 2006 (assuming there are no drought restrictions). Other factors such as housing density, availability of recycled water, uptake of water efficient appliances and other water efficient behaviours also affect the total drinking water demand. Climate variability and drought Climate variability relates to the naturally occurring weather events and patterns that have been tracked over time. Balancing greater Sydneys water supply and demand over the long term requires improved understanding of climate cycles and trends and how best to respond. Historical records show that Sydneys climate is highly variable, even without climate change impacts. This is due to a number of climate patterns such as ElNio and La Nia, which are associated with droughts and floods. Circumstances can change quickly and rainfall can vary substantially, as the past decade has shown us. While it is probable there will be severe drought conditions in the future, the exact nature of these droughts timing, duration and severity cannot be known. However, we do have a sound understanding of the effects of drought, and the importance of non-rain dependent supplies such as desalination.
As part of the review process, climate variability, rainfall and dam inflows were extensively modelled. This information was then used in the cost effectiveness analysis to derive the best water supply and demand management approach to secure greater Sydneys water into the future. Climate change and its implications forSydney To better understand the impacts of climate change on Sydneys water supply system and future urban water demand, a collaborative study titled The climate change impacts on water supply and demand in Sydney (Sydney Water Balance Project for short) was undertaken. The Sydney Water Balance Project is the only research to date that has tried to determine the potential impacts of climate change on greater Sydneys water supply and demand. It broke new ground in modelling climate change impacts at the regional level and has helped to identify the next quantum of research needed to improve the confidence of modelling at this scale. The project began in June 2006 and the final report is due for release in 2010. The collaboration involved the NSW Office of Water, the Commonwealth Department of Climate Change and Energy Efficiency, the NSW Department of Environment, Climate Change and Water, Sydney Water, Sydney Catchment Authority, the University of New South Wales and the CSIRO.
Plan for the future because we need to manage the water so that it never reaches critical levels.
Community comment, Consultation workshop 2009
17
The results of the Sydney Water Balance Project provide information on how greater Sydneys water supply may be affected by climate change over time. However, climate change modelling is an evolving science. Uncertainties exist because of the limitations in downscaling global climate models to estimate climate impacts at the regional level and to model future droughts. Further uncertainties exist because we do not know for certain what levels of greenhouse gas concentrations we can expect in the future. In relation to water supply, the results indicate there may be decreases in annual rainfall and runoff in the inland catchments and minor increases in coastal catchments by 2030. Draft findings from the Sydney Water Balance Project also indicate that climatechange: will likely result in an increase in temperature by 2030 may result in an increase in evaporation throughout the catchments, with the most significant increase being recorded in the Goulburn area may result in a very minor increase inwater demand in greater Sydney by2030.
While this research indicates potential changes to supply and demand, the low impact of these changes and lack of certainty in the findings means that for the short term this research has not fundamentally changed our water management planning. The study highlighted the need for more research, particularly in relation to drought persistence under future climate conditions, and regional and local level climate modelling. In recognition of the current lack of certainty around future climate conditions, the 2010 Metropolitan Water Plan maintains a flexible approach to managing greater Sydneys water supply. These draft findings confirm that it is important that the Metropolitan Water Plan maintains the capacity to: manage risk by having an appropriate buffer between supply and demand understand the likely pressure points onthe supply and demand balance in the future respond to changing conditions duetoboth climate change and climatevariability continue to improve our knowledge of climate change impacts on greater Sydneys water supply incorporate this knowledge into futurestrategies.
Given that information about climate change projections and anticipated impacts will improve over time, it is important to maintain our flexible approach to managing greater Sydneys water supply. We will continue to undertake, monitor and review climate change research over time and adapt the Metropolitan Water Plan as required. Further information on climate change and the research government is undertaking that has relevance for the Metropolitan Water Plan, including the NSW Climate Impact Profile, is at www.waterforlife.nsw.gov.au/ climatechange. Providing for environmental flows forthe health of our rivers Protecting the health of our rivers is an important part of the Metropolitan Water Plan. This includes investment in new infrastructure to allow the release of environmental flows from the water supply dams to improve the ecological, recreational and tourism value of ourrivers. Environmental flows can help native fish and other species to breed, reduce the growth of weeds, and improve the suitability of the river for swimming and boating. Accordingly, the new variable environmental flows at Tallowa Dam on the Shoalhaven River have been factored into the water balance, as were new flow releases from the Upper Nepean dams and weirs.
Participants in the community consultation workshops developed the community planning principles used during the review of the plan.
18
Also included for planning purposes were new environmental flow releases from Warragamba Dam, beginning from 2018. The flow regime used in the modelling was that recommended by the Hawkesbury-Nepean River Management Forum in 2004. In the context of the plan, the volume of these releases would be significant and it was important to account for them in the planning for the future. Innovative research, technology and demand management practices The 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan established a strong focus on innovation and research. Through the implementation of the Water Industry Competition Act 2006 the NSW Government is fostering innovation in recycling technology. Our water conservation program is one of the most innovative and comprehensive in the world targeting residential, industrial, commercial, agricultural and government water users. Our research into climate change is the first to provide projections of the potential impact of climate change on the Sydney water system. The review of the 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan took account of: information provided through existing state-of-the-art modelling programs such as WATHNET, which incorporates rainfall and inflow data, and climate projections to simulate a range of potential water balance scenarios
the effectiveness of existing water conservation initiatives, outcomes of pilot programs and investigation into potential new programs advances in leak detection and smart metering technology advances in water supply and recyclingtechnology water quality data available through the extensive research and monitoring program undertaken by the Sydney Catchment Authority findings of the Sydney Water Balance Project (see page 17) which pushed the boundaries of climate science in relation to water supply. Community engagement for thereview Community consultation is a key input into developing the long-term plan for greater Sydneys water future. The Independent Review Panel was tasked with recommending consultation methods and overseeing the consultation process.
First phase of community engagement (Phase 1) The aim of Phase 1 of the consultation was to gauge the publics values and general attitudes towards water. Phase 1 involved 10 workshops across greater Sydney, an online survey, and a review of existing social research on attitudes to water use and management. In May 2009, eight workshops were attended by community and business representatives. Two further workshops were held with key metropolitan and catchment stakeholders, including representatives of local government, catchment management authorities, industry, environment groups, water users and recreational bodies. Three key values emerged from Phase 1: having a safe and affordable water supply for homes considering the needs of future generations in decision-making and water planning ensuring human needs for water are balanced with those of the environment. The complete findings from Phase 1 were condensed into seven key planning principles, which were used in assessing options during Phase 2 of consultation. These community planning principles are outlined over page.
Reverse osmosis technology is used to extract salt from seawater during the desalination process.
2. Reviewing the 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan to keep it current
19
The community planning principles were developed from the findings of the Phase 1 consultation and validated during Phase 2. These principles will continue to underpin the way in which the 2010 plan is delivered. Provide water that is affordable and safe todrink. Ensure enough water to meet both environmental and human needs one not more important than theother. Ensure a dependable long-term water supply for current and future generations. Maximise water efficiency and recycling, especially capturing stormwater and invest inresearch andinnovation. Restore clean healthy waterways and ensure health of catchments by reducing pollution. Ensure government and community take joint responsibility for water management. Share water taking into consideration all relevant sectors andregions.
Community input is an important part of water planning for Sydney. The 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan spelled out the Governments commitment to consult with the community when reviewing that plan and developing this 2010 plan.
20
Second phase of community engagement (Phase 2) The aim of Phase 2 was to involve the community in discussion around the proposed supply and demand management options for the 2010 Metropolitan Water Plan, including evaluation of the options using the community planning principles. Phase 2 involved three one-day workshops in November and December 2009. Two workshops were attended by community representatives and one workshop was held with key stakeholders and opinion leaders. Participants from Phase 1 were invited to participate in Phase 2 70percent attended. The key findings included: endorsement of the seven planning principles developed following feedback in Phase 1 continued agreement that everyone is responsible for saving water (i.e.government, industry, and the community) water efficiency initiatives arecrucial overwhelming support for environmental measures (e.g. environmental flows and river system improvements) reducing environmental flows during droughts was seen as a decision of last resort support for a simplified drought restrictions regime by the majority of participants (two levels of drought restrictions on top of the Water Wise Rules) also strong support for introducing drought restrictions earlier (at higher total dam storage level) and maintaining them for longer supporting the use of the desalination plant as long as the focus remained on water efficiency and recycling initiatives strongly held view that education and empowerment are fundamental to the delivery of water supply and demand measures and that the provision of information must be transparent.
Whats next
Monitor population projections and changes in water demand. Continue annual reporting on progress of the plan and reporting to the Independent Review Panel. Monitor and review future climate change research to better understand the implications for Sydneys watersupplies. Continue interagency discussions to determine the most strategic approach to develop and use climate change information in Sydneys water supply planning, including investigations to improve the way that we model droughts at the local level. Continue investment in innovative research, technology and demand management practices. Continue monitoring existing environmental flow releases and undertake detailed investigations to determine an optimal environmental flow regime for Warragamba Dam. Further investigate long-term water supply and demand options. Finalise and implement water sharing plans for greater Sydney. Undertake community and stakeholder consultation in future reviews of the Metropolitan Water Plan and major initiatives coming from it.
Recycled water is delivered in purple pipes to 19,000 homes in the Rouse Hill area for non-drinking use. Capacity of this network has now increased to serve a potential 36,000 homes.
2. Reviewing the 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan to keep it current
21
Completed work at Tallowa Dam on the Shoalhaven River allows the release of new environmental flows and fish movement up and down stream.
Dams are our major source of drinking water. However, Sydney is no longer totally reliant on rainfall stored in dams because water is now also available through desalination and recycling.
Maintaining and upgrading Sydneysdams Sydney Catchment Authority (SCA) manages the network of dams that supply raw water to greater Sydney. Over the life of the Metropolitan Water Plan, the SCA has continued a comprehensive program of asset maintenance and upgrades. This multimillion dollar program ensures our dams are operated safely and deliver a reliable supply of high quality water. This asset management program is in addition to the specific projects outlined in the Metropolitan Water Plan. Protecting the health of ourcatchments The Sydney Catchment Authority (SCA) is responsible for protecting the health of the drinking water catchments and delivering high quality water from dams to retailers, including Sydney Water, Wingecarribee Shire Council and Shoalhaven City Council. The SCA works in partnership with local councils, landholders, government agencies, industry and other community stakeholders to protect the health of the catchments and provide high quality water. It uses the best available science, water monitoring and modelling, education, regulation and technology to manage the catchments and the water supply network.
Shoalhaven water transfers The Shoalhaven is an integral part of the water supply system. Since the 1970s, in times of drought, Sydney and the Illawarra have relied on water pumped from Tallowa Dam on the Shoalhaven River to boost Sydneys total dam storage level and supplement water supplies. Inthe last drought the system provided around 30 percent of the supply to greater Sydney. Water is transferred using the river system to provide additional water into Warragamba Dam or the Upper Nepean dams.
0%
23
Investigations under the Metropolitan Water Plan have shown more water could be sourced from the Shoalhaven system by transferring when water is readily available rather than accessing low flows during times of drought. In effect, transfers could occur when there will be less impact on the health of the Shoalhaven River. The investigations also looked at ways to provide improved releases of water for the health of the lower Shoalhaven River, and to reduce the impacts of water transfers on rivers in the Southern Highlands. After extensive research, analysis and community consultation important improvements to the Shoalhaven system were announced in March 2007. Theseincluded: new environmental flow rules for the lower Shoalhaven River (see page 50) changed operation of Tallowa Dam: water transfers will begin when Sydneys total dam storage level falls to around 75 percent and continue until total dam storage level rises above 80percent water will not be drawn down further than one metre from Tallowa Dams full storage level this will be increased to three metres in times of severe drought (see page 56) new infrastructure at Tallowa Dam to allow native fish passage and improve the quantity and quality of water releases downstream for the environment (see case study on thispage) upgraded picnic facilities at the damsite. The Shoalhaven and Wingecarribee communities were also invited to comment on six options to upgrade the water supply transfer system. The options looked at ways to transfer more water from Tallowa Dam to Sydney and the Illawarra, if required in the future. Several options had the benefit of protecting the health of the Southern Highlands river system by reducing the use of rivers to transfer water between dams. Based on community feedback, scientific and engineering investigations, and social, economic and cultural heritage assessments, three options were short listed. Further detailed technical investigations of these options have been 24
Upgrades to Tallowa Dam to improve the health of the Shoalhaven River A major project to improve the health of the Shoalhaven River was completed in 2009 with the construction of new environmental flow infrastructure and fishlift at Tallowa Dam in the KangarooValley. The $26 million project allowed variable flows that better mimic natural river conditions to be released downstream for the health of the river, and is allowing for the upstream and downstream migration of native fish.
The Emperor Gudgeon is one of the native fish species benefitting from the new fishlift atTallowa Dam.
A mechanical fishlift, built as part of the project, is the largest fishlift to be fitted to an existing dam anywhere inAustralia. The innovative solution to a technically complex project has been recognised with engineering awards. Since it was built in the 1970s, the dam has been a barrier to the migration of native fish. The new fishlift moves fish up and over the dam restoring full access for 10 native fish species, including the Emperor Gudgeon and the endangered Grayling. A major component of the project was infrastructure works to allow for variable flows to be released from the dam to improve the health of the Shoalhaven River. The temperature of water released from the dam more closely matches the downstream river environment with the construction of a surface level off-take at the dam. The new environmental flows began in mid 2009 following the lifting of drought water restrictions in Sydney. The project was a key initiative of the 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan and meets the community planning principle of ensuring enough water to meet both environmental and human needs. undertaken. The preferred augmentation option is a tunnel from Burrawang to Avon Dam. There are significant costs and lead times for the augmentation and a decision on its timing will depend on factors such as future climate predictions, and population growth and demand. These factors will be reviewed over the next few years with a view to having an upgraded system built and operational by around 2025. Water transfers from the Upper Nepeandams The Upper Canal is integral to Sydneys water supply network. The 130-year-old, 64 kilometre long combination of open channels, tunnels and aqueducts transfers water from the Upper Nepean dams (Cataract, Cordeaux, Avon and Nepean), to Prospect Water Filtration Plant. The catchments of the Upper Nepean and Shoalhaven provide more reliable inflows than Warragamba, and with climate change, may become even more important to Sydneys water supply. The Upper Nepean transfers system can transfer the equivalent of up to 30percent of Sydneys water supply. Thecanal also provides flexibility to change the source or mix of water being supplied to Sydney in response to water quality issues or to planned or emergency systemmaintenance. The Upper Canal, which now passes through urban areas of greater Sydney, has been used for illegal recreation and is subject to vandalism. The open canal can pose a risk to public safety and can also impact reliability, water security and water quality. A range of options for rehabilitation and or replacement have been assessed to identify the best option for renewal of the canal and concept designs drawn up. Work on the canal will continue over the life of the 2010 plan.
Began new variable environmental flow releases into the Hawkesbury-Nepean River system from Cataract, Cordeaux and Nepean dams implemented on 1July 2010 (see page 49). Modified weirs on the Nepean River to allow variable environmental flows and fish passage (see page 49).
Whats next
Review factors relating to the timing of the augmentation of the Shoalhaven water transfers system with a view to having an augmented system operational around 2025. Complete work to improve reliabilityof supply for the upper BlueMountains. Continue work on the rehabilitation and or replacement of the Upper Canal water supply transfer system from the dams in the Upper Nepean Catchment to Sydney. Continue to monitor, assess and report on the effectiveness of the new environmental flow rules for Tallowa Dam in the Shoalhaven, the Upper Nepean dams and the operation of the weirs on the NepeanRiver.
The new deep water pumping station at Warragamba Dam completed in early 2007, which, along with a deep water pumping station at Nepean Dam, provide access to previously inaccessible water, extending supply by around six months during drought.
3. Dams continue to provide a vital rain-fed source
25
The Wollongong recycled water plant provides over seven billion litres of water each year to people and industry in the Illawarra.
Increased water recycling is a key element of the 2010 Metropolitan Water Plan. Recycling initiatives will produce 70 billion litres a year by 2015 equivalent to about 12 percent of greater Sydneys current water needs.
The community has told us that maximising recycling, especially capturing stormwater and investing in research and innovation, must be a key focus in the 2010 Metropolitan Water Plan. The NSW Government supports recycling schemes across greater Sydney and continues to investigate new, innovative and cost effective ways to treat and use recycled water. Recycled water targets In mid 2010, use of recycled water was saving about 33 billion litres of water that might otherwise come from our drinking supplies each year. Implementation ofthe Replacement Flows Project at StMarys from October 2010 will increase recycling by 18 billion litres a year. Increased water recycling is a key element of the 2010 Metropolitan Water Plan and consistent with the 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan and the NSW State Plan, 70billion litres of water will be recycled each year by 2015 (equivalent to about 12percent of Sydneys current water needs). With ongoing efforts beyond 2015, it is projected that up to 100 billion litres of water may be recycled each year by the2030s. In recognition of the importance of maintaining agriculture in the Sydney region, future recycled water schemes developed by Sydney Water will consider irrigators water needs and use patterns. Options considered for meeting these needs will include continuing supply by pipelines and managed sewage treatment plant discharges.
Environmental releases Residential use Industrial/commercial use Irrigation Sewage treatment plant reuse
27
Supporting councils to engage their communities and promote their local recycling, stormwater and water efficiency initiatives The Water for Life Education Program developed a Council Partnership Kit in 2008 to help councils in the Sydney region increase community understanding of the large number of water recycling, stormwater reuse and water efficiency projects managed by councils, and to encourage wise wateruse. The 2008 kit contained funding, case studies and creative templates for councils to advertise and promote their efforts through print advertisements, outdoor advertising (bus interiors, exteriors and shelters), signage (erected at sites of projects or in community centres), workshops and community consultation (prior to and during project development). The 2008 kit was developed through input from a stakeholder survey and a council advisory group. Eighteen councils used the 2008 kit receiving $168,000 in grants. For example, Leichhardt Municipal Council received just over $10,000 to implement the kit. Council used the materials and funding to promote: local residents being the most water efficient users in Sydney (NSW Government report card 200607) and to keep up the good work free sustainability workshops two main recycling initiatives: 450,000 litre rainwater tank installed at Leichhardt Oval to water the sports fields 4 0,000 litre rainwater tank at Leichhardt Park Aquatic Centre to top up pools Results from all participating councils were positive with improved community understanding and recognition of local initiatives measured through increased visits to councils dedicated Water for Life sponsored webpages, increased requests for information on initiatives and attendance at council water events and activities.
Large versus small-scale recyclingprojects The focus in the 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan was on large-scale water recycling projects which would in themselves save billions of litres of water each year, forexample: Wollongong Recycled Water Plant supplying over 7.8 billion litres eachyear Rouse Hill Recycled Water Scheme supplies about 2.2billion litres each year to 19,000 homes for toilet flushing and outdooruses Rosehill-Camellia Recycled Water Scheme will supply 4.7 billion litres of recycled water each year to industry Replacement Flows Project at St Marys will provide 18 billion litres of highly treated recycled water to the Hawkesbury-Nepean River. This will save dam water normally released to help protect the river down stream. Providing recycled water to businesses and households in the established urban areas of Sydney can be costly, disruptive and energy intensive. The building of cost effective large-scale recycling schemes has addressed the major opportunities for financially viable large schemes in the short term. Future large scale recycling opportunities will be recycled water systems supplying large new growth areas in Sydney. Afocus for the 2010 Metropolitan Water Plan is on smaller local-scale projects. These include stormwater projects carried out by councils to irrigate parks and sports fields to the benefit of thecommunity.
Leichhardt Council is installing a 40,000 litre rain water tank and new pool filters to save water at Leichhardt Park Aquatic Centre.
The Council Partnership Kit will be modified in response to feedback from participating councils to include additional templates such as media releases (announcing funding, promoting initiatives, responding to heavy rain), and editorial copy for use in community newsletters. The new kits will be released in 2010 and the Water for Life Education Program will fund and coordinate pre- and postcampaign research to evaluate the success of the campaigns.
All governments at all levels need to work together and be on the same page.
Community comment, Consultation workshop 2009
28
At the end of the first quarter of 2010, there were about 150 smaller local-scale projects operating or under construction, including 70 stormwater projects (outlined on page 31). Smaller scale recycling is generally centred on replacing drinking water and improving recreational amenity with uses such as irrigating parks, sporting fields and golf courses. Some examples include: Liverpool Golf Course recycling 43million litres a year Sports fields at the Hawkesbury Campus of the University of Western Sydney recycling 189 million litres ayear Farm irrigation at the Elizabeth Macarthur Agricultural Institute at Menangle, recycling 550 million litres a year. Recycled water sources In most of the large-scale recycling projects, recycled water is sourced from sewage treatment plants that produce high quality treated effluent. Alternative sources of recycled water, such as sewer mining, stormwater, and greywater are also being used. In working toward the 70billion litres a year target, projects using these sources and new sources such as capturing roof rainwater off commercial buildings, will provide the greatest opportunities.
Industry plays a significant role inwater recycling The Rosehill-Camellia Recycled Water Scheme will provide high quality recycled water to major industrial and commercial customers in western Sydney and reduce the demand on Sydneys drinking water supply. It is the first project to be delivered using the third party access regime under the NSW Water Industry Competition Artists impression of the Fairfield Act 2006. The project is also unique as recycled water plant which will be it serves existing major customers in operational in mid 2011. an established urban area of Sydney. The recycled water is proposed for various end uses including diverse industrial processes, irrigation and fire fighting. The Rosehill-Camellia Recycled Water Scheme is built, owned, operated and maintained by two private operators, AquaNet Sydney Pty Ltd (a Jemena company) and Veolia Water Australia. A 20 million litres a day recycled water treatment facility is being constructed at Fairfield. Pipelines, storage reservoirs, pumping stations and other ancillary work are being built to transport the recycled water to the customers at Smithfield and Camellia. One of the projects innovations is using five kilometres of disused gas mains as part of the 20 kilometres of recycled water pipeline needed. By using existing infrastructure, there will be less disruption to the community and traffic flow, less demand on resources, and cost savings. Construction of the $100 million scheme started in November 2009. In mid 2011 the scheme is expected to start delivering 4.7 billion litres of recycled water per year. Sydney Water will initially be the retailer of the recycled water to seven foundation customers. The project has been set up for AquaNet to develop the market beyond these seven customers and be the retailer for any additional customers. It is one of greater Sydneys largest industrial recycling projects, with a total potential market of 7.3 billion litres of recycled water per year.
One billion litres of recycled water is used to irrigate our parks, playing fields and golf courses saving our precious drinking water.
4. Water recycling is reusing water already in the system
29
Stormwater is not lost with local government playing its part Historically Chatswoods town centre has been subject to major flooding during storms closing businesses, impacting local waterways and creating a potential safety hazard. Willoughby Council, through the development of its regional cultural facility The Concourse in Chatswood CBD, isundertaking a major stormwater reuse project. Originally a measure to prevent stormwater flooding of TheConcourse construction site, the innovative project now extends to ongoing water conservation and reuse. An enormous 5,000m3 tank has been built under the site to capture stormwater runoff. The stormwater will be treated andreused: throughout The Concourse building for toilet flushing, garden watering and air conditioning cooling towers by Chatswood Chase shopping centre cooling towers for Council landscape irrigation, dust suppression and other uses by Councils worksdepartment. The stormwater reuse project will: save 103 million litres of drinking water every year reduce the impacts of heavy stormwater runoff on localwaterways reduce the severity of flooding in theCBD showcase the latest water efficient technologies in a high profile public building demonstrate Councils commitment to water conservation (through the planned sustainability education centre) establish new models for using existing stormwater detentionsystems create a longer-term opportunity to reallocate developer funded onsite detention tanks to other ecologically sustainable development initiatives within the catchment.
The detention tank under The Concourse at Chatswood can capture five million litres of stormwater.
This stormwater reuse project is funded by Willoughby Council, the Federal Governments WaterSmart Australia Program and the NSW Governments Climate Change Fund. The Concourse, which includes a performing arts venue, library and education centre, retail shops, cafes andopen space is expected to open inlate 2011. A video case study of the project is available online at www.waterforlife.nsw.gov.au/recycling/stormwater/videos.
30
Reusing stormwater
Stormwater management helps protect people and property from flooding, improves waterway health and, if stormwater is treated and reused, provides a valuable alternative source for non-drinking water use. The relative costs of large-scale storage and treatment of stormwater can be high. To capture rainfall in the urban environment requires significant water storage, which would need to be built in already established areas of the city. These large detention basins would need to be connected to a recycled water treatment plant in addition to a dedicated distribution system. Moving recycled water around distribution networks usually involves pumping and can be energy intensive. Justification for such cost and disruption can be difficult. The NSW Government is promoting and supporting an integrated approach to stormwater harvesting, focusing on smaller, local schemes which provide an alternative water source but also deliver river health, water quality and flood mitigation benefits. The combined value of the water and environmental improvements makes this approach a better use of funds than supporting schemes that focus only on delivering water. Stormwater reuse projects in Sydney are primarily developed and managed by local councils as Sydney Water directly manages less than five percent of the total stormwater pipes and infrastructure in greater Sydney. There are currently 70 stormwater reuse projects in greater Sydney. These schemes will save over two billion litres of water a year, contributing to the recycling target of supplying 70billion litres a year by 2015.
Interactive map available onWaterforLifewebsite Treated stormwater is being reused all over Sydney to irrigate public parks, golfcourses and sporting fields. It is also reused indoors for cooling towers and flushing toilets. To provide information onstormwater projects that are under wayor planned an innovative and interactive map has been created ontheWater for Life website at www.waterforlife.nsw.gov.au/recycling/ stormwater/stormwatermap. A second map has now been created to include all recycled water projects in greater Sydney. The database that supports these maps is being upgraded to help monitor progress towards our recycling targets and make it easier for people to find out about recycling and stormwater projects in their area.
However, it is important that householders follow some simple rules to ensure the long-term health of their soil. Tocomplement the regulatory framework, guidelines and fact sheets have been developed and are available on the Waterfor Life website. Education and training on residential greywater recycling, and how to install and operate private recycling schemes, was rolled out to over 700 participants from councils and industry following the release of the guidelines.
Supporting legislation
The government is working to streamline the approval process between the Water Industry Competition Act 2006 and the Local Government Act 1993 over the course of the 2010 Metropolitan Water Plan. This will ensure that private recycling schemes captured by these Acts receive consistent support through government regulation without the burden of overregulation. Further opportunities to optimise the regulatory framework relating to recycled water projects will also continue.
Interactive maps on the Water for Life website provide detail on stormwater and recycled water projects under way or planned in greater Sydney.
4. Water recycling is reusing water already in the system
31
Sewer mining as an alternative water source Sewer mining schemes in Sydney are producing over one billion litres of recycled water each year. With four major projects now completed and another eight under way, this alternative water source is helping save precious drinking water supplies. Sewer mining is the process of tapping into a sewer (either before or after the sewage treatment plant) and extracting wastewater, which can be further treated and used as recycled water. Recycled water produced from sewer mining is commonly used to irrigate sports fields, parks and golf courses. It can also be used in some commercial buildings and industrial sites. Pennant Hills Golf Club pioneered the use of sewer mining in the Sydney region. Their Water Reclamation Plant produces up to 100 million litres of recycled water each year to irrigate tees, greens and fairways. Faced with restricted water access during the recent drought, Pennant Hills Golf Club investigated various alternate water supplies to eliminate their reliance on drinking water for irrigation. Increasing use of existing bores and creek water sources was considered unsustainable; sewer mining was the best option as it would provide a reliable source and the technology required to produce quality recycled water was already proven. Working with Sydney Water, the NSW Department of Environment, Climate Change and Water, the NSW Department of Health and Hornsby Council, Pennant Hills Golf Club developed their project in concert with the development of regulatory guidelines that now apply to all sewer mining projects.
Sewer mining scheme at Pennant Hills Golf Club.
Other sewer mining projects already completed include: Sydney Olympic Park Authority over 800 million litres of recycled water through sewer mining replaces 50 percent of the drinking water used to irrigate Sydney Olympic Park and Newington Estate each year Kogarah Council using almost 160 million litres of recycled water to irrigate parks, playing fields and the Beverley Park Golf Course the commercial development Workplace6 in Pyrmont is able to produce up to 16 million litres of recycled water each year for toilet flushing and irrigation of the site.
Implemented many small-scale recycling projects including: Sydney Airport Corporation using 300 million litres of recycled water each year from an on-site wastewater treatment plant Macquarie University treating 21million litres of wastewater a year through an on-site natural reed bed system for sports field irrigation Ensign Services (a commercial laundry) reclaiming, treating and recycling over 50 million litres of water each year. Achieved savings of two billion litres of water through 70 stormwater reuse projects in and around Sydney. Created interactive maps on the Water for Life website providing details on stormwater and recycling projects under way or planned in greater Sydney.
Established Australias first state-based access and licensing system under the Water Industry Competition Act 2006 to enable the private sector to enter the industry; providing drinking water, recycled water and wastewater services (see page 12). Three of the first four schemes licensed under the Water Industry Competition Act 2006 include water recycling initiatives. Developed a Council Partnership Kit to promote water wise use and community recycling projects undertaken by local government (seepage 28). Developed and released user friendly guidelines and fact sheets, and held workshops to support best practice in residential greywater reuse (see page31). Developed and implemented the Sewer Mining Policy in 2008.
2010 Metropolitan Water Plan
Whats next
Complete a number of large-scale recycling schemes: Hoxton Park Recycled Water Scheme will be completed in 2013 supplying about 2.3 billion litres of recycled water to industrial areas and about 13,000 new homes, each year the infrastructure for the Rouse Hill Recycled Water Scheme extension is substantially complete currently supplying about 2.2 billion litres of recycled water each year to 19,000 homes and businesses. This project has now expanded and has the capacity to supply recycled water to 36,000 homes. the private sector Rosehill-Camellia Recycled Water Scheme online in 2011 will supply 4.7 billion litres of recycled water each year.
Continue to support cost-effective smaller local-scale recycling, stormwater and sewer mining projects across Sydney. Continue to provide financial assistance to recycling projects through the NSW Climate ChangeFund. Continue to research and invest in innovative water recycling and stormwater harvesting technology andprocesses. Complete work currently being undertaken to remove duplication between the Water Industry Competition Act 2006 and the LocalGovernment Act 1993 to makeit easier to develop alternative water supplies. Investigate further options for recycling in agriculture.
Examine further opportunities to optimise the regulatory framework relating to recycled water projects. Maintain commitment to funding the Caltex and Continental Carbon project at Kurnell which was delayed due to technical reasons and is now expected to be completed by mid 2012. Enhance the interactive recycling and stormwater maps on the Water for Life website as part the ongoing development of a comprehensive database to monitor progress towards our recycling targets and make it easier for the public to find out about recycling and stormwater projects in their area.
A new water recycling plant at St Marys will use the effluent from the Penrith (pictured), St Marys and Quakers Hill sewage treatment plants to provide 18 billion litres of highly treated recycled water a year to the Hawksbury-Nepean River. This will save dam water normally released to help protect the river down stream.
4. Water recycling is reusing water already in the system
33
The desalination plant at Kurnell can produce 90billion litres of water a year thats 15percent of greater Sydneys current needs.
Desalinated water was added to Sydneys water supplies in January 2010. When operating at full capacity, the desalination plant can provide 15 percent of greater Sydneys water needs, helping to provide water for people and the environment.
The energy requirements of the plant are 100 percent offset by renewable energy produced at the 67-turbine Capital Wind Farm near Bungendore. Water from the desalination plant enters the system at Erskineville and is distributed to approximately 1.5 million people across the Sydney CBD, inner west, eastern suburbs, southern Sydney and parts of the Sutherland shire, and at times as far west as Auburn. The plant has been designed and constructed so that if needed it can be upscaled to produce up to 180 billion litres of water each year. The desalination plant project has won a number of national awards for excellence in government partnership, environmental and project management, as well as the use of innovative technologies andtechniques.
35
During the review of the 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan a number of operating options were modelled. Operating the plant under this regime strikes the right balance between maximising water available for people and the environment, while minimising the potential for the plant to be operating when the dams are full. If it produced water only when dams fell to the very low levels of a deep drought, it may not produce enough water to stop Sydneys total dam storages falling to a critical level and Sydney facing severe water restrictions or other extreme drought measures. This operating regime benefits the community by reducing the likelihood of spending time in drought restrictions, reducing the probability of having to further supplement the water supply system, and providing increased water security, which helps maintain environmental flows for river health.
If necessary, the Government will be able to operate the desalination plant at other times to secure water supplies (for example if availability of water from other parts of the supply system were affected by technical or other problems). The operating regime for the desalination plant meets the community planning principles of ensuring a dependable longterm water supply for current and future generations, and providing water that is affordable and safe to drink. The costs of operating the plant are included in current water prices. They comprise about $35 of the typical annual residential water and wastewater bill which was around $1,045 in 200910.
Using the desalination plant as a buffer system for the water supply of Sydney seems a crucial part of future usage and management.
Community comment, Consultation workshop 2009 The power required to operate the desalination plant is 100 percent offset with renewable energy generated at the Capital Wind Farm near Bungendore.
36
Whats next
Introduce new operating rules for the desalination plant following the two-year proving period: the plant will operate at full production capacity and supply desalinated water to Sydney Waters area of operations when the total dam storage level is below 70 percent and will continue to do so until the total dam storage level reaches 80percent. Should Sydneys total dam storage level drop again under severe drought conditions, the government could take the decision to build the second stage of the desalination plant essentially upscaling the existing plant to supply twice as much water (also see Chapter8). Exact timing of the decision would be influenced by predicted weather patterns, seasonal and projected demand levels.
A jack-up barge, Seafox 6, was used as a drilling platform for the inlet and outlet shafts for the desalination plant. Construction of the plant was completed on time and under budget.
5. Desalination is an extra source of water that doesnt rely on rain
37
It is estimated the Water Efficiency and Labelling Standards (WELS) scheme is saving over seven billion litres each year through certifying and labelling of water efficient appliances.
By using water wisely, whether it comes from rivers and dams, desalination or water recycling initiatives, Sydney will have enough water to meet the needs of its growing population and the environment. Through water efficiency programs we will save 145billion litres of water a year by 2015, or equivalent to 24 percent of Sydneys current water needs*.
Water efficiency
Over the past 20 years, the impact of Sydneys rapid population growth on the water supply system has been managed by reductions in demand per person. These reductions have been achieved through low cost, highly effective water efficiency measures, quarterly meter readings and use based pricing (introduced in 1990), aswell as six years of drought restrictions. As a result, Sydney now uses the same amount of water as it did in the early 1970s, even though the number of people living in the region has increased by 1.4 million. Since 1999 Sydney has reduced its annual demand for drinking water by over 100 billion litres a year through water efficiency. Maximising water efficiency is a key community planning principle and remains a major part of the 2010 Metropolitan Water Plan. Consistent with the 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan and the NSW State Plan, water efficiency programs willsave 145billion litres a year by 2015 thats 24percent of Sydneys current waterneeds*.
*Based on the long-term average water use of 600 billion litres per year
I have been so cautious and efficient for so long its now habit. I value the resource because itsprecious, scarce and finite.
Community comment, Consultation workshop 2009
Residential single dwelling 51% Residential multi-unit 22% Commercial 10% Industrial 9% Government and other (including agriculture) 8%
39
Residential water savings With households using such a large proportion of water in greater Sydney, residential water efficiency programs will continue to play a vital role in saving water inside and outside the home. Current programs are saving almost 20billion litres (or 3.5 percent) of drinking water a year compared to 1999. This is a saving of around 12 litres a day for every person. Current residential water efficiency programs offered by Sydney Water include: WaterFix from only $22 a qualified plumber installs water saving devices in the home Do It Yourself (DIY) Water Saving Kits an alternative to WaterFix providing water saving devices that people can install themselves Toilet Replacement Service replacing single flush toilets with 4 star dual flush models saving customers up to $370 on the cost of the toilet and installation Rebates offering rebates for the purchase of rainwater tanks Outdoor water conservation an ongoing campaign to encourage and educate the community on practical ways they can save water, for example, Water Wise Rules (see page 43). Detail about Sydney Waters rebates can be found at www.sydneywater.com.au/ Water4Life/InYourHome/.
Some of these programs are reaching their full potential in water savings and will begin to be phased out. However, ongoing water savings in residential households will be realised through two main initiatives: the national Water Efficiency and Labelling Standards (WELS) scheme and the Building Sustainability Index (BASIX). The WELS scheme enforces mandatory ratings and labelling for a range of appliances and fittings and develops minimum performance standards for products. As new water efficiency appliances and fittings are released to retailers, customers are encouraged to purchase new and efficient appliances and fittings when their existing inefficient ones break down. It is estimated that WELS saves over seven billion litres of water each year through the rating and labelling of water efficient products. The BASIX program applies to new homes that are built in New South Wales. BASIX is a planning policy that ensures new residential properties are designed to use less drinking water. BASIX also applies for alterations and additions in existing homes. As new homes are built or existing ones are modified, households are required to meet certain requirements to ensure drinking water savings are achieved, for example, installing a rainwater tank. It is estimated that BASIX is saving almost six billion litres each year by increasing the water efficiency of new homes and homes with additions and alterations.
Alternative ways for households to save water will continue to be investigated. Research and development programs that are currently taking place include: monitoring study to measure the longterm water and energy performance of rainwater tanks with the aim of identifying potential improvements trialling the use of smart metering technology which will provide customers with real time information about their water use through an inhome display working with Energy Australia on a Smart Home which showcases both current best practices and the home oftomorrow for water and energy saving technologies collecting data on water end uses in the home (such as toilet flushing, clothes washing and showering) to better forecast demand and target future water efficiency programs investigating the options of setting up a Valuing Water Framework approach that may be used to develop future community education programs and toevaluate and improve existing ones. Some households in greater Sydney also use water drawn direct from rivers, streams and aquifers under domestic and stock rights. Such water use can help in reducing the demand for drinking water. The Government is developing Reasonable Use Guidelines to ensure that the quantity of water used under this right is appropriate. A draft of the guidelines has been completed will be publicly exhibited for comment. Schools water savings Schools account for one percent of water used in greater Sydney (about six billion litres a year). Two programs currently target schools: the Every Drop Counts in Schools program and the Rainwater Tank in Schools Rebate. Over 310 schools have participated in the programs and received rebates, saving over 241 million litres of water each year.
More than 310 schools in greater Sydney are saving over 241 million litres of water each year.
40
Virtual home helps make actual savings in water andmoney Sydney Water has developed an online tool to promote water efficient behaviours in the home, helping householders save water, energy andmoney. As a result of the many water efficiency programs that have already been implemented, residents of greater Sydney are saving over 100 billion litres of drinking water each year through water wise behaviour. Drought restrictions were lifted in 2009, but sensible water use practices adopted during the drought are being maintained under the Water Wise Rules (see page 43) and encouraged in other ways. To help, an online water efficient home is available on Sydney Waters website (www.sydneywater.com.au). The interactive tool takes the viewer through each area in the house and garden providing information on Water Wise Rules and promoting available rebates and appliances that can help save water. For instance, in the garden if the viewer positions their cursor over the car, the Water Wise Rule will appear washing vehicles is allowed, but if possible, park on the lawn.
The tool also calculates how much water and money the viewer can save by being water wise; so if they click on the showerbutton, a box will appear detailing the WaterFix program and how much water and money they could save each year if they take part in the program. A tally of water and money saved and details of the selected programs is provided forthe viewer to download.
Business water savings Business and industry water use accounts for 20 percent of water used in greater Sydney. Business water efficiency programs running since 2001 are saving over 24billion litres of water each year. The business water efficiency programincludes: Every Drop Counts in Business working with businesses in greater Sydney to help them cut water use and business costs. Working one-to-one with large water users (those using more than 80,000 litres each day), and helping smaller businesses through targeted programs
BizFix retrofitting service to install water efficient devices in business, forexample, taps, toilets, and showers Online Monitoring Program online water meter monitoring service for the highest water using businesses. Information about these programs can be found on Sydney Waters website at www.sydneywater.com.au/Water4Life/ InYourBusiness/.
Apart from these projects, we will also work towards setting up benchmarks for water use in businesses and develop best practice guidelines targeting all sectors. To further help businesses save water, the NSW Climate Change Fund provides funding to commercial and industrial businesses for water and energy savingprojects.
Almost 420 large water using businesses have joined the voluntary Every Drop Counts Business Program saving around 17 billion litres of water a year.
6. Water efficiency is smart use of the water we have
41
Minimising water lost throughleaks Like all water pipe networks around the world, Sydneys water distribution system has breaks and leaks. Leaks are caused by deterioration of joints and fittings, and by cracks in the pipes caused by ground movement orpressure changes. Sydney Water is responsible for maintaining the systems that deliver water to the people of greater Sydney. Leak detection and repair is a major priority for Sydney Water, and in 200910 water lost through leakage was impressively low and in the top performance band for leakage according to international standards. Sydney Waters leak reduction programs use the latest methods and technologies to detect and repair hidden leaks and reduce the amount of water lost. With Sydney Water now investing over $100 million each year, water lost through leakage has been reduced by around 30 billion litres each year since the program began (thats enough to supply 150,000 average households). This has been achieved through: actively detecting and repairingleaks reducing pressure in the pipes improving response times tomainbreaks placing meters on the pipe system todetect leaks. For example, in 2009 10 Sydney Water inspected 21,000 km of pipes laid end to end thats the distance from Sydney to Los Angeles and back. During the year, 100 kilometres of water mains were replaced.
The WaterSmart Farms program is helping farmers improve their water efficiency and reduce nutrient run-off.
Government water savings Although only about four percent of greater Sydneys total water use is by government facilities, it is vital that government leads by example. The NSW Government Sustainability Policy sets targets and strategies for government agencies to reduce their water use by 15percent by 2011. Thirty four government agency sites and 44 local councils have completed Water Savings Action Plans to promote and achieve water wise use. These include 19hospitals, five prisons and four education facilities. Cost effective actions identified in the plans will save more than 1.7billion litres of drinking water. Water efficiency on farms Sydney farmers produce a wide range of fresh produce for local consumption. Crops such as field and greenhouse vegetables, dairy products, flowers, turf and fruit trees have an estimated farm gate value of at least $450 million and provide significant employment benefits. The WaterSmart Farms program incorporates education, training and community awareness activities to assist farmers in the lower Hawkesbury-Nepean catchment area to improve their water efficiency and reduce nutrient runoff.
The program is part of the HawkesburyNepean River Recovery Program and receives funding through the Australian Governments Water for the Future program and the NSW Governments Climate Change Fund. By improving water efficiency on farms it is possible to improve river health, save money and help reduce pressure on drinking water supplies.
Sydney Waters leak reduction programs are estimated to be saving 30billion litres each year.
Water use efficiency should be maximised across all sectors irrespective of the level of water storage. This will work to preserve the economic efficiency of supply side investment and will minimise the need for restriction.
Community comment, Consultation workshop 2009
42
Smart water use becomes our way of life Water Wise Rules
In addition to the water efficiency programs described above, Water Wise Rules introduced in June 2009 continue to build on the water saving behaviours the people of greater Sydney adopted during the drought. In 2007, the government announced long-term water saving rules would be introduced once drought restrictions were lifted. Water Wise Rules came into effect once the total dam storage level had remained steady at around 60 percent for12 months and drought restrictions were lifted. Water Wise Rules are simple, common sense actions that apply to everyone using drinking water in greater Sydney including residents, businesses, local councils and government agencies. Theyare: all hoses must now have a triggernozzle to avoid the heat of the day, watering is allowed before 10am and after 4pm no hosing of hard surfaces such as paths and driveways washing vehicles is allowed fire hoses must only be used for fire fighting activities. By improving the efficiency of outdoor water use not just during drought we can make better use of our available water supplies. Drought restrictions will continue to be applied as needed in the future to reduce pressure on supplies during drought periods (see Chapter 8). Water Wise Rules will save an estimated 19 billion litres of drinking water each year. However, current overall water savings since the introduction of Water Wise Rules in mid 2009 are greater than this because people have kept up their water wise behaviours established during the drought.
Keeping our parks, ovals and open spaces green Before 2003, at least 4.3 billion litres of Sydneys drinking water was being used to irrigate parks, ovals and open spaces each year. A number of different water sources are now replacing drinking water for irrigation including recycling, stormwater reuse, greywater recycling, sewer mining and rainwater capture. Now, one billion litres of recycled water a year is being used for urban irrigation, saving our drinking water for drinking. There are also water efficiency programs available to ensure that whatever the source of water being used for irrigation, it is being used as efficiently as possible. The Irrigation and Landscape Efficiency Project run by Sydney Water under the Hawkesbury-Nepean River Recovery Program aims to save 1.06 billion litres a year of drinking water. This will be achieved by using improved technology, land and site management practices. Sydney Water is also working with a panel of experts to develop a set of industry guidelines to promote best practice for irrigating parks, ovals and open spaces. It will be a practical guide to the sustainable management of open space turf areas, which includes everything from Stadium Australia to the local neighbourhood park. The guidelines aim to balance various aspects of open space management to achieve the best turf performance all year round.
Stormwater reuse is just one of the many water sources now replacing drinking water for irrigation, helping keep sporting fields like Lindfield Oval green and safe.
43
The Smart Rinse program has installed over 4,200 smart rinse valves in restaurants and cafes saving over one billion litres of water a year. 162 large water using businesses have connected to Sydney Waters online monitoring system saving 247 million litres of water a year. 106 businesses have taken part in the BizFix amenities retrofit service saving 349million litres of water a year. The NSW Green Business Program has provided funding to seven commercial and industrial water saving projects saving around 100 million litres a year. Water Savings Action Plans have been developed for large water using businesses, 34 government agency sites and 44 local councils, identifying cost effective actions to save water. Over 310 schools have completed the Every Drop Counts in Schools Program and received rainwater tank rebates. WaterSmart Farms program launched in 2009 comprises several projects to help farmers improve water efficiency while maximising their yields. Projects include training events, some with a specific non-English speaking background focus, and water efficiency irrigation, which is a combined training and incentive program.
The Draft Reasonable Use Guidelines for domestic and stock rights water are being finalised and will be publicly exhibited for comment. The NSW Government Sustainability Policy was released in 2008, which includes targets and strategies for the NSW Government to improve its waterefficiency. Sydney Waters leak reduction programs are estimated to be saving around 30billion litres each year through investing $100 million and inspecting more than 20,000 kilometres of pipesannually. Water Wise Rules have saved an estimated 19 billion litres of drinking water since being introduced in June2009.
44
Whats next
Water efficiency programs now in place will achieve savings of 145 billion litres a year by 2015. Beyond this, we will continue to implement programs where there are still savings to be made and investigate new ways to improve water efficiency in households, businesses, government, schools and farms. Continue to improve water efficiency in households using sensible regulatory tools, for example, through proposals to expand the Water Efficiency Labelling and Standards (WELS) scheme. Carry out a study to measure the long-term water and energy performance of rainwater tanks with the aim of identifying potentialimprovements.
Trial the use of smart metering technology which will provide households with real time information about their water use through an inhome display. Work with Energy Australia to develop a Smart Home to showcase best practice and the latest water and energy saving technologies. Collect data on specific water uses in the home (such as toilet flushing, clothes washing and showering) to better forecast demand and target future water efficiency programs. Focus the Every Drop Counts Business Program on targeting small to medium water using businesses. Continue existing programs to save water from outdoor residential use, businesses, schools and councils.
Continue to research and monitor global industry directions to ensure that innovations are trialled and incorporated into water efficiencyprograms. Continue to implement the Water for Life Water Education Plan for greater Sydney 2008 2012. Monitor and analyse the longerterm water savings from the pilot WaterSmart program with a view to expanding the program in the future if initial savings are sustained. Continue to implement the WaterSmart Farms program. Finalise and implement the Reasonable Use Guidelines for domestic and stock basic water rights. Investigate setting up a framework to help develop future community education programs and to evaluate and improve existing ones.
45
Water for life equals water for people and the environment
Local government stormwater management initiatives help protect the health of our local creeks, such as Quarry Creek, West Pymble and other waterways.
The Metropolitan Water Plan recognises the importance of balancing the needs of communities and industry with the need to protect and improve river health.
Striking a balance
The Metropolitan Water Plan is designed to ensure sufficient water for people and the environment with one not more important than the other. Community consultation on the 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan revealed strong support in the community for maintaining this balance. Sharing our water among users (watersharing plans) The government has been developing water sharing plans for the surface water (rivers and streams) and groundwater systems of greater Sydney. These plans protect the basic rights of landholders, enable licensed extraction to be managed under varying climatic conditions, protect water-dependent ecosystems, and enable licence holders to trade their water entitlements on the open market. The water sharing plans do this by establishing the rules for how water is shared. The rules will also give more certainty to licensed water users about the conditions under which they can extract water from rivers and aquifers after ensuring that the environment is protected and about the conditions under which water can be traded. The Water Sharing Plan for the Greater Metropolitan Region Unregulated Water Sources and the Water Sharing Plan for the Greater Metropolitan Region Groundwater Sources, due to commence in late 2010, will ensure that Sydneys drinking water supply and other licensed extractions are balanced and sustainable. Community consultation shows strong support for sharing water taking into consideration all relevant sectors and regions.
The 2009 Day in the Life of a Water Drop multi-media education campaign encouraged ongoing water saving efforts and outlined the range of initiatives being carried out under the plan.
7. Water for life equals water for people and the environment
47
The education program focuses on a number of key areas: Water for Life campaigns and website to reach the wider Sydney community, encouraging ongoing water saving efforts and letting people know about the range of initiatives being carried out under the plan a coordinated capacity building program providing professional learning opportunities, resources and tools, and building a water educators network to support leading practice water education targeted on-the-ground education projects in innovative partnerships to engage different sectors of the community, such as non-English speaking communities, teachers and schools, the property sector, and young adults coordinating water education through interagency partnerships and developing and implementing the Water Education Plan for greater Sydney 20082012.
Water conservation education for non-English speaking communities Research has shown that people from non-English speaking communities are less aware of water saving initiatives and water wise behaviours. To engage people from these communities the Water for Life Education Program has implemented a number of education programs in partnership with the NSW Ethnic Communities Council, Sydney Water and the NSW Department of Environment, Climate Change and Water. One of the initiatives is the Home Water Action Program. Through the program, bilingual educators have been trained to deliver home water action planning workshops and events. This was an intensive one-to-one program that recruited water ambassadors within the Arabic, Cantonese, Greek, Italian, Korean, Mandarin, Macedonian, Spanish and Vietnamese speaking communities and helped over 2,600 people across these communities tosave millions of litres ofwater.
The Water Education Plan for greater Sydney 20082012 helps coordinate andsupport water education across greater Sydney.
The Water for Life Education Program is managed by the NSW Office of Water with strategic direction and coordination provided by the interagency Metropolitan Water Education Group (members include the NSW Office of Water, NSW Department of Environment, Climate Change and Water, Sydney Water, Sydney Catchment Authority and the Office of the Hawkesbury-Nepean). The NSW Government has provided $10.5 million from the Climate Change Fund to fund the program from 2005 to 2010.
Water ambassadors helped deliver the Home Water Action Program to culturally and linguistically diverse communities, saving millions of litres of water.
48
The role of the office is to: provide a one-stop-shop for the community to find out about river health and its management help coordinate and implement river management strategies such as aquatic weed management provide opportunities for community input into the development of river management strategies improve processes for managing in-stream development, for example, jetties and riverbanks works. Water for our rivers The dams for greater Sydney have been built specifically to capture water that can be used for human supply. Recognition of the importance of maintaining some flow down river has resulted in major works to modify dams and weirs to allow for these environmental flow releases.
Environmental flows can help native fish and other species to breed, reduce the growth of weeds, and improve the suitability of the river for swimming and boating. Healthy rivers are also valued and enjoyed for their own sake, and support ecosystems that form a part ofthe natural landscape. Hawkesbury-Nepean environmentalflows There are four dams (Avon, Cataract, Cordeaux and Nepean) and two major water supply weirs (Broughtons Pass and Pheasants Nest) in the Upper Nepean Catchment. In order to release variable environmental flows to protect the downstream health of the HawkesburyNepean River system, works have been completed at the dams and the water supply weirs (see case study this page).
Environmental flow releases for the Upper NepeanRiver As outlined in the 2004 Metropolitan Water Plan, protecting the health of the Hawkesbury-Nepean River system, through the release of water for the environment, was a priority. It was predicted that without environmental flow releases the health of the river would decline in a number of ways, including fewer native fish species, less diversity of invertebrate animals (such as insect larvae and worms) and increasing floating weeds, which can interfere with the use of the river and crowd-out native plant species. To enable environmental flow releases from the Upper Nepean dams and ensure the water passed downstream makes it all the way to the ocean, major upgrades to a number of dams and weirs were required. In 2006, work began on Avon Dam to install new infrastructure to allow the release ofvariable environmental flows. The variable flow releases mimic natural flows because the amount of water released is linked to the amount of water flowing naturally into the dams. A multi-level off-take also permits the release of water of suitable quality and temperature. The new flows began from Avon Dam in March 2008. Similar works at Cataract, Cordeaux and Nepean dams have been completed and new variable flows began on 1 July 2010. Modifications to 10 other weirs on the Upper Nepean River will be completed by the end of 2010. These modifications
allow not only the passage of environmental flows but also free passage by native fish in the river. Thetotal cost of these projects is $39million. An environmental monitoring program is in place to measure changes in the downstream river health to see if these flows are having the desired effect on the river. It is expected that over the next 10years the new environmental flows will result in increases in the length of the river that is swimmable, navigability by boats and able to be fished. It is now critical to the success of this initiativethat provisions in the water sharing plans continue to protect those environmentalreleases.
Water Minister Phil Costa and Member for Mulgoa, DianeBeamer, at the launch of new variable flow releases from Cordeaux Dam.
7. Water for life equals water for people and the environment
49
Environmental flows from TallowaDam In mid 2009, new environmental flow arrangements from Tallowa Dam to the lower Shoalhaven River were introduced. The new rules reflect significant community consultation and scientific analysis undertaken to assess river health, economic, and cultural needs. Specifically, they state that: when there is a small to moderate inflow into the dam, all of that inflow will be passed through the dam to protect the river when there is a high inflow into the dam, for example when there is a heavy rainfall event, 20 percent of the inflow will be passed through the dam to ensure the river still benefits from flow releases that mimic nature, while the remainder is kept in the dam for future use special purpose environmental flow releases may also be made from the dam to manage identified river health issues downstream.
Flows from Warragamba Dam Sydneys largest supply dam In line with adaptive management framework recommended by the Hawkesbury-Nepean River Management Forum (the Forum), the introduction of environmental flows for the Hawkesbury-Nepean river system has been a staged process. This process builds on the knowledge and monitoring of new flows from other dams. With the progressive implementation of flows from the Upper Nepean dams, the next major investment will be in securing long-term environmental flows from Warragamba Dam. The 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan stated that a final regime of environmental flow releases from Warragamba Dam will not be formally set until 2015. Interim flows were to be considered for the period starting 2009 provided sufficient water is available. For planning purposes, the review of the 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan used the variable flow regime recommended by the Forum in 2004 for environmental flows from Warragamba Dam beginning in 2018. However, further detailed analysis is required to identify the actual optimal final regime for releases from Warragamba Dam. This work will be completed in the next four years and included in the 2014 Metropolitan WaterPlan.
Implementing new flows from Warragamba Dam will require a major investment in infrastructure to release the range of flows needed. Due to this, and the potentially large volume of water that may be released under a new regime, the decision process must be robust. The investigative work being undertaken during the life of the 2010 Metropolitan Water Plan to inform the decision is significant. Subject to sufficient water being available, possible increases in the existing interim environmental flows from Warragamba Dam were foreshadowed in the 2006 plan. However, scientific and technical investigations undertaken for the review have revealed that water availability is not the only consideration. Water releases will continue from Warragamba Dam for the health of the Warragamba and Hawkesbury-Nepean rivers. These will in part use water banked when environmental flows were halved during the recent drought. Due to infrastructure limitations and other considerations, these flows cannot be variable, or significantly different in volume to the flows that have been released from Warragamba Dam for a number of years.
Maintaining a healthy environment is the vital and the basic thing. A healthy environment means, and is the result of, good eco balance.
Community comment, Consultation workshop 2009
50
The federally-funded Hawkesbury-Nepean River Recovery Program aims to improve river health by increasing the water available for environmental flows in the river and reducing nutrient loads. The program, which seeks to engage and involve all levels of government with landholders, is being managed by the Office of the Hawkesbury-Nepean, in partnership with NSW agencies. The release of the NSW Governments Lower Hawkesbury-Nepean Nutrient Management Strategy in 2010 brings together the range of projects and programs in a coordinated and targeted manner that are under way to reduce the amount of nutrients entering the river. Many other organisations are involved in catchment protection actions, including the Hawkesbury-Nepean and Southern Rivers catchment management authorities, local councils, landholders and community organisations. As reflected in the community planning principle restore clean healthy waterwaysand ensure health of catchments by reducing pollution, thisissue, and our management of it, isimportant to the community.
Helping fish move up and downrivers Many types of fish need to move between different parts of rivers to complete their life cycles. Dams and weirs form barriers to this natural fish migration. In some cases, managing river flows can provide appropriate water depths and velocities to enable fish to move across natural features and built structures that would otherwise prevent their passage. In other cases, barriers in the river may need to be modified to allow fish to pass. A mechanical fishlift has been built at Tallowa Dam on the Shoalhaven River to enable migrating fish to pass up and over the dam wall. It is expected up to 10native fish species will now re-establish populations in the upper Shoalhaven River (see page 24 for details). The spillway has also been modified to minimise injury to adult fish moving downstream to breed in the estuary. Major modifications to water supply dams and weirs in the Upper Nepean are improving natural fish passage in the Hawkesbury-Nepean River system (see case study page 49).
Monitoring catchment water quality is an important part of the Sydney Catchment Authoritys Healthy Catchments Strategy 20092012.
7. Water for life equals water for people and the environment
51
Working for the environment From mid 2009, began providing variable environmental flows and downstream fish passage, by modifying Tallowa Dam on the Shoalhaven River. Built a mechanical fishlift at Tallowa Dam which is allowing fish to travel up and over the dam wall. Completed major modifications to the dams and water supply weirs on the Upper Nepean River to allow for variable environmental flows. Releases began from Avon Dam in 2008 and from Cataract, Cordeaux and Nepean dams in mid 2010. Modified 10 irrigation weirs on the Nepean River to allow new environmental flows from the dams to make their way downstream, and to improve fish passage. The project will becomplete inlate 2010. Released a number of important strategies and reports: Lower Hawkesbury-Nepean Nutrient Management Strategy in 2010 NSW Diffuse Source Water Pollution Strategy in 2009 SCA Healthy Catchments Strategy 20092012 H awkesbury-Nepean River Environmental Monitoring Program Final Technical Report in 2009.
Established the Office of the Hawkesbury-Nepean in 2009 to coordinate management of the river and provide a one-stop-shop for stakeholders. Achievements include: overseeing the implementation of the Hawkesbury-Nepean River Recovery Program to make more water available for environmental flows and reduce nutrients entering the river running a two-day Working together for a healthy river workshop that sought stakeholder views on priority river issues and possible solutions examining options for improved aquatic weed management established a stakeholder committee to advise the Office on river health and management issues. Sought the publics comments on draft water sharing plans for greater Sydney.
A healthy river system is vitally important for wildlife such as the Eastern Great Egret.
52
Whats next
Commence the Water Sharing Plan for the Greater Metropolitan Region Unregulated Water Sources and the Water Sharing Plan for the Greater Metropolitan Region Groundwater Sources, expected to occur late in2010. Continue to deliver, through the Water for Life Education Program, multi-media communication campaigns, innovative on-the-ground water education projects, training and resources across greater Sydney targeting the community, businesses and local government.
Engaging the community in water management issues through innovative and interactive displays at the new exhibition area of the Warragamba Visitor Centre to be opened in 2010. Continue to monitor, assess and report on the effectiveness of the new environmental flow rules for Tallowa Dam in the Shoalhaven, the Upper Nepean dams, and weirs on the Nepean River. Undertake further work to identify the optimal final environmental flow rules for Warragamba Dam and the Hawkesbury-Nepean River. This work will be completed to enable announcement of the environmental flow rules in the 2014 Metropolitan Water Plan.
Continue to implement the: Lower Hawkesbury-Nepean Nutrient Management Strategy NSW Diffuse Source Water PollutionStrategy S CA Healthy Catchments Strategy 20092012 catchment protection actions. Continue interim environmental flow releases from remaining dams until longer-term releases are decided andimplemented.
Major upgrades to a number of weirs on the Nepean River not only allow passage of new environmental flows but also help native fish move up and down the river.
7. Water for life equals water for people and the environment
53
Being prepared 2 Reviewing the fordrought is 2006 Metropolitan Water goodplanning Plan to keep it current
Drought restrictions will remain an important, effective and relatively low cost tool for responding to future droughts.
As a result of measures already adopted under the Metropolitan Water Plan, the probability of dam storages falling to critical levels during the life of the 2010 plan has been greatly reduced. However, should extended drought conditions occur in the future, we have a number of measures we can implement that will slow the rate of decline of our water supplies.
Drought readiness
Extreme drought conditions are rare but as the past decade shows circumstances can change quickly and rainfall can vary substantially. That is why it is vitally important that the Metropolitan Water Plan remains flexible so it can respond if extreme drought develops. When drought conditions occur in the future, we have a number of options available that can be implemented with relatively short lead times. This will slow the rate at which Sydneys total dam storage level drops. These include: drought restrictions, increasing water transferred from Tallowa Dam by lowering the minimum drawdown, groundwater extraction, voluntary water use targets, upscaling the desalination plant, and decreasing environmental flow releases from dams. Pricing is also being examined as a potential tool for managing demand during a drought. These measures build on other elements of the Metropolitan Water Plan including, dams, recycling, desalination and waterefficiency.
Restricting outdoor water use was a key element in securing greater Sydneys water supply during the recent drought. Overall, the community responded very positively. Between the introduction of Level 1 restrictions in October 2003 and the introduction of Water Wise Rules to replace Level 3 restrictions in June 2009, itis estimated that restrictions achieved total water savings of about 575 billion litres. This is more than the amount of water greater Sydney used in 2009 10. Based on greater Sydneys long-term average water use of 600 billion litres each year it is estimated that reductions in drinking water demand from each of the three levels of restrictions were: Level 1 (from October 2003) 12 percent Level 2 (from June 2004) 16 percent (additional four percentage points on Level1) Level 3 (from June 2005 to June 2009) 17 percent (additional one percentage point on Level 2) Effectively communicating and enforcing drought restrictions was critical to achieving these significant reductions in water use. The community has made it clear that it is prepared to play its part in managing Sydneys water supply in an ongoing way. For example, recent surveys of Sydney Water customers show 85 percent support for the Water Wise Rules.
Drought restrictions
Drought restrictions will remain an important, effective, and relatively low cost tool for responding to futuredroughts. While drought restrictions do impose some costs on the community (for example, inconvenience and adverse impacts on gardens and playing fields) and on some industries, the community consultation phase of the review of the 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan and recent surveys indicate a high level of support for drought restrictions.
55
Revised drought restrictions Mandatory drought restrictions were lifted in mid 2009 and permanent Water Wise Rules introduced when Sydneys total dam storage had been around 60 percent for 12 months. Consistent with the 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan, drought restrictions were then reviewed. The review considered their effectiveness during the recent drought, projected future savings (especially in light of permanent savings through Water Wise Rules) and impacts on the community, industry and the environment. A revised mandatory restrictions regime has been developed, made up of two levels commencing at around 50 percent and 40 percent of Sydneys total dam storage levels. The new restrictions are based on the water saving measures under the Water Wise Rules and allow people and business to continue to use water efficiently, while achieving similarsavings. The exact timing for introducing drought restrictions will be influenced by Sydneys total dam storage level, predicted weather patterns, the season, and demand forecasts. By using drought restrictions as our first response we can slow the rate at which the total dam storage level decreases, increasing the probability that the drought will break before other drought response measures are needed.
Tapping into groundwater supply The 2006 Metropolitan Water Plan identified that if Sydney entered severe drought, several borefields could be built to tap into underground water sources (groundwater). In November 2006, asdrought conditions worsened, the decision was made to further investigate potential borefield sites in Kangaloon in the Southern Highlands, Leonay near EmuPlains and Wallacia near Warragamba. Extensive testing, engineering design, environmental assessment and community consultation was undertaken. However, with Sydneys total dam storage level consistently around 60 percent and construction of the desalination plant under way, further development of the borefields was shelved in 2008. To ensure groundwater extraction can begin as quickly as possible if severe drought conditions return, planning approval is being sought now for the future construction of the borefield at Kangaloon. If needed during severe drought, the borefield could operate for three years then be turned off to allow the aquifers to recharge. The amount of water extracted during a three-year pumping cycle represents about 10percent of the estimated total aquiferstorage. A decision to proceed with construction of the borefield will be made in the event that Sydneys total dam storage falls to a level consistent with severe drought and with regard to seasonal weather outlooks and demand at that time.
Lake Burragorang floor exposed during the recent drought. In early 2007, the lake, formed byWarragamba Dam, dropped to an all-time low of 32.5 percent.
56
Implementing voluntary water usetargets While recent drought restrictions were imposed only on outdoor water use, preliminary analysis has found that about half the total reduction in demand occurred indoors. This suggests people are willing to restrict their water use above and beyond the regulatory measures imposed by drought restrictions. Implementing voluntary water use targets involves setting a daily per-person maximum water use target. For example, in the recent drought in south eastern Australia, Melbourne set a voluntary personal water use target of 155 litres per-day and averaged 149 litres perperson per-day over 2009 10*. Under Level 3 drought restrictions over 2008 09, Sydneys water use averaged 198 litres per-person per-day. The benefit of introducing a voluntary water use target is that it provides people with some choice in how they make savings be that indoor or outdoor. Bythe time voluntary water use targets would be considered, the new Level2 outdoor drought restrictions would already be in place. Recent community engagement on the Metropolitan Water Plan indicated general support for voluntary water use targets during severe drought. While personal use targets have been effective in other areas of Australia, research will be undertaken to confirm the likely water savings, costs, and community attitudes to using voluntary water use targets in greater Sydney.
Could increasing the price for water during drought be a tool for managing demand? The Independent Pricing and Regulatory Tribunal (IPART) is responsible for setting the prices of water and sewerage services in greater Sydney. Water prices are set to recover the costs of providing a secure supply. During past droughts in the Sydney region, drought restrictions have been used successfully to signal water scarcity and reduce demand. However, investigations are under way to examine whether pricing might be an appropriate tool for managing water demand in future drought periods. Scarcity pricing links the price of water to its relative availability. Under this approach, the price of water would be higher when water supplies are low, sending a message about the value of scarce water. Scarcity pricing is being considered through the work of the Council of Australian Governments in urban water reform. In addition to this, the National Water Commission, Productivity Commission, Business Council of Australia and other bodies have recently undertaken research into scarcity pricing principles. IPART has also indicated that it will consider scarcity pricing as part of its next price review for the Sydney Catchment Authority to be completed in 2012. The introduction of usage based pricing in Sydney in 1990 demonstrated that price can be used as a tool to manage water demand. However, water pricing is a complex issue and substantial work is needed before scarcity pricing could be considered for use in the Sydney region. Whether scarcity pricing would have the desired impact and how it would impact on investment in other water sources (such as recycled water) are important considerations. Critically, any approach adopted would make sure that essential water supply is affordable for all households. The outcomes of investigations will be examined, as part of an evaluation of scarcity pricing and other drought response measures, prior to the 2014 review of the Metropolitan Water Plan.
Upscaling the desalination plant Sydneys desalination plant was planned and designed to be readily upscaled should water supplies need a significant boost in the future. In the unlikely event that Sydney experiences a rare and extreme drought, a decision could be made to double the capacity of the desalination plant from 90 billion to 180 billion litres a year (producing up to 30 percent of our current water supply needs). The plant would take about two years to upscale. Over the longer term, the upscale option could be used to bolster supply in response to increasing demand from a growing population, but this would be evaluated along with the range of options available at the time of the decision.
Reducing environmental flows While reducing water allocations for environmental flows would effectively keep as much water as possible in the dams, environmental flows are of great benefit to the health of rivers in low flow periods. As such, reducing environmental flows would only be considered during rare and extreme drought. Community consultation has indicated strong opposition to reducing environmental flows during drought. Thisis captured in the community planning principle: ensure enough water to meet both environmental and human needs one not more important than the other. Monitoring and analysis of existing environmental flows will continue in order to determine what modifications might be appropriate to save water and protect our rivers during severe drought.
*This was achieved when dam levels in Melbourne were extremely low and it was several years until infrastructure options to augment supply would become available.
57
Undertook extensive testing, engineering design, environmental assessment and community consultation to ensure readiness to construct a borefield at Kangaloon in the Southern Highlands in the event of severe drought conditions. Undertook extensive testing and environmental assessment into potential borefield sites at Leonay and Wallacia in Sydneys west. (Further development of the Kangaloon and western Sydney borefields was shelved in 2008.)
Whats next
Continue to investigate new water sources to secure greater Sydneys water needs. Continue to investigate new waystomanage the risks of high impact drought. Ongoing research to confirm the likely savings and costs of setting voluntary water use targets in the event of rare and extreme drought. Ongoing research and analysis to determine potentially appropriate modifications to environmental flow rules during rare and extreme droughtconditions. Continue research into the potential impacts of climate change on greater Sydneys water supply. The outcomes of investigations into scarcity pricing and other drought response measures will be examined prior to the 2014 review of the Metropolitan Water Plan.
A new pumping station at Nepean Dam allows access to deep water and helps secure supplies to the Illawarra during drought.
58
During the height of recent drought dam storage levels dropped to record lows. Being prepared for severe drought in the future is a key element of the 2010 Metropolitan Water Plan.
An adaptive plan Report annually on Metropolitan Water Plan progress Undertake periodic reviews of Metropolitan Water Plan Establish licensing framework to enable the private sector to provide water supply and services Establish third party access regime to enable private sector access to water infrastructureservices Establish Codes of Conduct to support Water Industry Competition Act 2006 (WICA) IPART to conduct information sessions with local government and relevant industry groups on the WICA licensing regime and access regime Undertake a climate change research project on impacts to Sydney's supply and demand Continue research into the potential impacts of climate change on greater Sydney's watersupply Continue to investigate new water sources to secure greater Sydney's water needs Dams Complete the accessing of deep water at Warragamba and Nepean dams Complete work to improve reliability of supply for the upper Blue Mountains Continue work on the rehabilitation and or replacement of the Upper Canal water supply transfer system from the dams in the Upper Nepean Catchment to Sydney Comprehensively investigate Shoalhaven water transfer options Review factors relating to the timing of the augmentation of the Shoalhaven water transfers system with a view to having an augmented system operational around 2025 Recycling Build the new recycled water scheme to supply large industrial users in the Camellia and Smithfield areas Commission Pennant Hills and Kogarah local recycling schemes Increase industrial recycling at Kurnell, Botany and Wollongong Increase recycling to homes in Rouse Hill, Hoxton Park and Ropes Crossing Issue contracts for recycling to industry in Rosehill/Camellia area Provide recycled water to North West and South West growth sectors Increase the volume of recycled water to 70 billion litres a year by 2015 Enhance the interactive recycling map to include all recycled water projects in greater Sydney as part of a comprehensive database to monitor progress towards our recycling targets and educate the public about projects in their area Investigate agricultural recycling opportunities Provide recycled water to irrigators near West Camden
60
Action Completed
Consider the water needs and patterns of irrigators when developing future recycled water schemes by Sydney Water Issue contract for the Replacement Flows Project at St Marys under Urban Sustainability Program Implement a new Sewer Mining Policy to make future sewer mining agreements between Sydney Water and non-government organisations easier Amend planning legislation to simplify approval of small recycling plants Further refine the regulatory framework and guidelines for recycled water, with a specific focus on facilitating stormwater recycling Undertake regulatory reform, supported by training and education programs, to make greywater recycling easier for householders in single dwellings Through the $80 million Urban Sustainability Program, provide grants to councils for stormwater harvesting and other measures designed to save water and protect the environment under the City and Country Environment Restoration Program Finalise NSW Government funding for the Caltex and Continental Carbon project at Kurnell so this project can proceed* Continue to support cost-effective local-scale recycling and stormwater projects across the greater Sydney region Provide financial assistance to recycling projects through the NSW Climate Change Fund Desalination Complete the desalination plant and pipelines Sign contract for 100% renewable energy to offset the power needs ofthe desalinationplant Commission desalination plant and run for a two-year 'defects correction period' which will end in mid June 2012 Develop desalination plant operating regime as part of development ofthe 2010 Metropolitan Water Plan Water efficiency Deliver the WaterSmart Sydney pilot residential program to encourage wise water use. Double the rebate for internally connected residential rainwater tanks Implement water savings programs for gardens Increase the threshold for BASIX for alterations and additions Install water efficient devices in 500,000 homes by 2008 Investigate measures to improve water efficiency of existing homes Investigate ways to roll out individual metering to new multi-residential properties Make an additional 50,000 Department of Housing residential dwellings water efficient Pilot programs for individual metering for apartments Provide rebates for efficient washing machines under the NSW Climate Change Fund Roll out a single flush toilet replacement program Release the NABERS HOME water rating tool by mid 2006 Trial the use of smart metering technology which will provide customers with real time information about their water use through an in-house display Work with Energy Australia on a Smart Home which showcases both current best practices and the home of tomorrow for water and energy saving technologies Collect data on water end uses in the home (such as toilet flushing, clothes washing and showering) to better forecast demand and target future water efficiency programs
61
Action Completed Undertake monitoring and analysis into the longer-term water savings achieved as a result of the pilot WaterSmart program with a view to expanding the program in the future should the initial savings be sustained Continue the new $30 million NSW Climate Change Fund Green Business Program to save water and energy Continue to expand the Every Drop Counts business program Investigate options to ensure water efficient design of new commercial buildings and industrial facilities Pilot DIY programs for small to medium businesses Top water using businesses to develop and implement Water Savings Action Plans Provide rebates for school rainwater tanks Roll out smart monitoring and leakage reduction in schools Audit targeted Government sites Local councils develop and implement Water Savings Action Plans Finalise Government Procurement Guidelines Government agencies develop and implement Water Savings Action Plans Publish policy on sustainable water use by Government Commence long-term Water Wise Rules when drought restrictions arelifted Continue to develop and pilot new programs to improve water efficiency Implement the Water Efficiency Labelling Standards (WELS) scheme and extend to otherappliances Monitoring study to measure the long-term water and energy performance of rainwater tanks with the aim of identifying potential improvements Investigate the options of setting up a Valuing Water Framework approach that may be used to develop future community education programs and to evaluate and improve existing ones Continue active leak detection and pressure management Develop and establish Reasonable Use Guidelines for the take of waterunder domestic and stock rights from surface water and groundwater sources** Deliver a new $3 million farm watering efficiency program Implement a new efficient irrigation scheduling project for farmers Implement metering and water use monitoring of irrigators Educate and train farmers under the WaterSmart Farms project Water for life People (education and empowerment) Deliver progress reports on the Water Education Plan for greater Sydney 20082012 Build on practical education projects tailored to culturally and linguistically diversecommunities Build the knowledge, skills and ability of educators to deliver leading practice watereducation Deliver innovative partnerships to engage priority sectors of the community and continually improve water education Implement programs to engage the community in the review of the Metropolitan Water Plan and build awareness of its initiatives and to encourage wise water use Water for life Environment Commence new environmental flow regime for Avon River Implement monitoring of new flows from Avon Dam Implement improved environmental flow releases at Woronora Dam, including high flow contingent release 62
Status On-track
Ongoing
Delayed
Action Completed
Complete the modifications to Tallowa Dam to allow fish passage and to improve the quality, volume and pattern of water releases Start the new environmental flow releases from Tallowa Dam once all water restrictions in Sydney are lifted and the infrastructure is completed Modify Nepean, Cataract and Cordeaux dams and Pheasants Nest and Broughtons Pass water supply weirs to allow new environmental flows to be released Modify weirs downstream of the Upper Nepean Dams in the Nepean River to allow flow and fish passage Start the new environmental flow releases from Cataract, Cordeaux and Nepean dams, and downstream weirs by 2010 Undertake investigations to enable a decision on a new flow regime for Warragamba to be included in the 2014 Metropolitan Water Plan Continue the interim environmental flow releases from Warragamba Dam until longer term releases are decided and implemented Continue to coordinate the development and implementation of catchment protectionactions Develop and implement Lower Hawkesbury-Nepean Nutrient Management Strategy to manage pollutants entering the waterways Establish the Office of the Hawkesbury-Nepean Improve integration of Hawkesbury-Nepean river health monitoring considering environmental flows, river health and recycling initiatives Publish report on river health monitoring for the Hawkesbury-Nepean Develop water sharing plans for surface and groundwater sources for greater Sydney Drought response Review drought restrictions once lifted and develop a revised mandatory restrictions regime Publish reports on the investigations at all identified groundwater locations and consult the community about potential groundwater use and borefield construction Complete the groundwater investigations at Kangaloon and Leonay Complete the groundwater pilot testing program at Leonay Continue to investigate new ways to manage the risks of high impact drought Research the likely savings and costs of setting voluntary water use targets in the event of rare and extreme drought Research and analysis to determine potentially appropriate modifications to environmental flow rules during rare and extreme drought conditions Investigations into scarcity pricing and other drought response measures to be examined prior to the 2014 review of the Metropolitan Water Plan
* A preferred contractor has been selected and the contract is expected to be signed in late 2010. Work will start in 2010 and is expected to be completed by mid 2012. ** R easonable Use Guidelines developed and will be publicly exhibited.
63
The 2010 Metropolitan Water Plan builds on the significant achievements of past plans to secure greater Sydneys water supply for people and the environment.
Photography credits Cover, 53, 64, back cover: Adam Hollingworth NSW Office of Water 2: Chris Davis 6, 20, 49: NSW Office of Water 4, 8, 14, 22, 25, 51, 58, 59: TVU Sydney Catchment Authority 12, 40, 48: Simon Freeman Sydney Water 18: Simon Freeman NSW Office of Water 19, 34, 42 (lower): Bob Peters Sydney Water 21, 26, 29 (upper), 32, 33, 36, 37, 41, 52: Sydney Water 24: Gunther Schmida Sydney Catchment Authority 29 (lower), 40, 43, 46: Leonie Huxedurp NSW Office of Water 30: Willoughby City Council 38: Department of Environment, Climate Change and Water, Mark Mohell Department of the Environment, Water, Heritage and the Arts 42: Graham Johnson Department of Industry and Investment 54: Kerry Wilson Sydney Water 56: M Mathas Sydney Catchment Authority Printed on Mega Recycled Silk, consisting of 50% post consumer recycled waste and 50%FSCcertified fibre.