Ergonomics Guide For Welders
Ergonomics Guide For Welders
Ergonomics Guide For Welders
ERGONOMICS GUIDE
FOR
WELDERS
24 April 2009
1 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Forward
This guide is for managers and supervisors at activities performing welding tasks. It
provides a brief background on ergonomics and offers suggestions for improving the
workplace to reduce the risk of work-related musculoskeletal injuries.
2 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Table of Contents
Forward ........................................................................................................................... 2
Table of Contents ............................................................................................................ 3
List of Figures.................................................................................................................. 4
Introduction - What is Ergonomics?................................................................................. 6
Work Related Musculoskeletal Disorders........................................................................ 8
The Nature of Welding .................................................................................................. 10
Implementing Solutions ................................................................................................. 16
Types of Ergonomics Improvement............................................................................... 17
Training and Action Plan ............................................................................................... 34
References.................................................................................................................... 36
Resources ..................................................................................................................... 36
Acknowledgements ....................................................................................................... 37
3 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
List of Figures
FIGURE 1: MAN AND WOMAN IN THE KITCHEN......................................................... 6
FIGURE 2: AWKWARD BODY POSTURE ..................................................................... 6
FIGURE 3: SPINAL DISC AND VERTEBRA................................................................... 8
FIGURE 4: WELDING WITH THE HANDS IN FRONT OF THE BODY ........................ 10
FIGURE 5: WELDING AT GROUND LEVEL ................................................................ 11
FIGURE 6: WELDING ABOVE SHOULDER HEIGHT .................................................. 11
FIGURE 7: WELDING IN CONSTRAINED SPACES .................................................... 12
FIGURE 8: WELDING WITH BACK BENT FORWARD ................................................ 13
FIGURE 9: WORKING WITH THE BACK BENT FORWARD ....................................... 14
FIGURE 10: WORKING IN A STOOPED POSTURE.................................................... 15
FIGURE 11: WORKING WITH THE BACK BENT FORWARD ..................................... 15
FIGURE 12: GAS CYLINDER TRANSPORTATION CART (LEFT) .............................. 17
FIGURE 13: GAS SAFETY .......................................................................................... 17
FIGURE 14: GAS CYLINDER TRANSPORTATION CART (LEFT) .............................. 17
FIGURE 15: PANEL CART FOR MOVING SHEET METAL (RIGHT) ........................... 17
FIGURE 17 SHEET METAL STORAGE, SOME OF WHICH WAS OUTDOORS ......... 18
FIGURE 18: VERTICAL SHEET METAL STORAGE SYSTEM .................................... 18
FIGURE 19: VERTICAL SHEET METAL STORAGE SYSTEM .................................... 18
FIGURE 20: BEFORE INDEX UNIT, ROUND STOCK RETRIEVAL............................. 19
FIGURE 21: VERTICAL INDEX UNIT FOR ROUND STOCK ....................................... 19
FIGURE 22: WELDING LEAD ON A PULLEY .............................................................. 20
FIGURE 23: SUCTION MANIPULATOR USED TO MOVE SHEET METAL................. 21
FIGURE 24: SOUTHEAST REGIONAL MAINTENANCE CENTER.............................. 20
FIGURE 25: GRABBING CLAMP.................................................................................. 21
FIGURE 26 MANUAL LIFTING AND CARRYING OF FABRICATED WORK PIECE .. 22
FIGURE 27 OVERHEAD CRANE ELIMINATES HAZARDS......................................... 22
FIGURE 28: MAGNETIC AND VACUUM HANDLES .................................................... 23
FIGURE 29: GRABBING CLAMP USED....................................................................... 23
FIGURE 30: VACUUM LIFTER ATTACHED TO FORK TRUCK .................................. 23
FIGURE 31: BEFORE: ONE WELDER STRUGGLES .................................................. 24
FIGURE 32: AFTER: THE SUPERVISOR FABRICATED A HANDLE .......................... 24
FIGURE 33 WELDING TABLES CAN BE JOINED TOGETHER .................................. 25
FIGURE 34 ROTATING MANIPULATOR ALLOWS PIECES TO BE HELD ................ 25
FIGURE 35 BEFORE: WELDER IS BENT OVER WORK PIECE ................................. 26
FIGURE 36: AFTER: LOW COST WORK TABLE GREATLY IMPROVES POSTURE. 26
FIGURE 37 BEFORE: WELDER'S NECK AND BACK ................................................. 26
FIGURE 38 AFTER: SIMPLE TRAILER JACK LIFTS ................................................... 26
FIGURE 39: SWRMC ACCOMMODATION LADDERS SHOP - ................................... 28
FIGURE 40: ACU FOUR - AWKWARD POSTURES …………………………….……….27
FIGURE 41: ACU FIVE - FIXTURE IS HEIGHT AND ANGLE ADJUSTABLE .............. 27
FIGURE 42: ACU FOUR - PROPELLER FIXTURE ...................................................... 28
FIGURE 43: BEFORE: WELDER IS IN AWKWARD POSTURE .................................. 29
FIGURE 44: AFTER: WELDER IS IN A SUPPORTED POSTER ................................. 29
FIGURE 45: HEIGHT ADJUSTABLE CHAIR ................................................................ 30
4 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
5 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
The practical meaning of Ergonomics is fitting the task and work environment to the
human. Ergonomists try to design tasks and workplaces within the capability of the
human. There are many examples of tasks, work environments, and even products,
which did not take human capabilities into consideration.
For example, in your home, kitchen counter tops are usually about 36 inches in
height. Is this a good height for everyone? No, it is usually too low for males and
may or may not be correct for females (See Figure 1). The height was selected
because it was the average elbow height for females in the 1930s. If counter tops
were designed for the average male the height would be 43 inches. In a perfect
ergonomic world, counter top height would be adjustable or there would be work
surfaces at the proper height for your spouse, your children and yourself in kitchens.
Figure 1: Man and woman in the kitchen Figure 2 : Awkward body posture
In the design of workplaces, human body size and capabilities must be considered.
Injuries are more likely if task demands and the environment exceed the capabilities
of the human. There are times when all ergonomics risk factors cannot be removed
and the worker is exposed. Refer to Figure 2 where the worker is in an awkward
posture while smoothing concrete. The goal is to limit the amount of time the person
is in those less than adequate situations.
Think about how well your workplace accommodates you. Can you reach the items
you use most without straining? Is it comfortable to lift the materials you need to
move around? Are there handles to grasp the items or are they cumbersome and
awkward? Can you change posture when you perform your work or are you in a
static posture all day? These are just a few of the items that may indicate a
mismatch between the workplace and the worker.
6 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Most of the tasks welders perform are dictated by the design of the item being
worked. In many cases, the materials are big, heavy, and might be covered with dirt,
rust, and/or grime. However, there are numerous job aids such as fixtures, jigs, and
part holders available to aid welders in doing their jobs and reduce the risk of injury.
In addition, special chairs and/or creepers are available that provide body support
while performing tasks so that an awkward posture is avoided. These types of
ergonomic solutions will be presented in the following sections.
These causes fall into six major physical workplace risk factors:
When present with sufficient frequency, magnitude, or in combination, these risk factors
may cause Work-related Musculoskeletal Disorders (WMSDs). Musculoskeletal
Disorders (MSDs) are injuries and illnesses that affect muscles, nerves, tendons,
ligaments, joints, spinal discs, skin, subcutaneous tissues, blood vessels, and bones.
WMSDs are:
• MSDs to which the work environment and the performance of work contribute
significantly, or
• MSDs aggravated or prolonged by work conditions.
7 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Back Injuries – From strains and sprains to degradation of the vertebral disks
Bursitis – Inflammation of a saclike bodily cavity, containing a viscous lubricating fluid
located between a tendon and a bone or at points of friction between moving structures
(i.e. inflammation of a bursa)
Carpal Tunnel Syndrome – A complex disorder that starts with the inflammation of the
tendon sheaths in the wrist and progresses into the degradation of median nerve
Tendonitis – Inflammation of the tendons
Tenosynovitis – Inflammation of tendon sheath
Thoracic Outlet Syndrome – A disorder in which blood vessels and nerves in the
upper shoulder region are compressed and cause pain. This condition is sometimes
caused by chronic postures associated with overhead work.
Trigger Finger – Tendons in the fingers “lock down” due to injury to the tendons
If you are experiencing signs / symptoms please contact your physician or occupational
medicine clinic for an evaluation
8 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Welding tasks may expose workers to physical workplace risk factors (or ergonomics
stressors). If tasks are performed repeatedly over long periods of time, they can lead to
fatigue, discomfort and injury. The main physical workplace risk factors (ergonomics
stressors) associated with the development of a work-related musculoskeletal injury in
welding tasks include:
Applying proper ergonomic principles can reduce the potential for these and other
WMSDs.
9 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
The use of proven ergonomic principles can improve the way a particular task is
performed, thereby reducing welder exposure to risk factors. This generally translates
to a healthier workforce, improved morale, greater productivity and increased product
quality. The Navy literally floats on quality welds.
Ergonomics
Stressors:
Compression:
Leaning on a hard
surface
10 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
11 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Compression: Leaning on
a hard surface
12 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Compression:
Leaning on a hard,
sharp surface
13 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Compression:
Kneeling on a hard
surface
14 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Compression: Resting
the arms on a hard
surfaces
15 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Implementing Solutions
The following resources recommend the use of engineering controls as the preferred
method of dealing with ergonomics issues.
The recommended solutions in the following pages are not intended to cover all
ergonomic challenges, nor is it expected that all of these solutions are applicable to
each and every welding environment. It is recognized that implementing engineering
solutions may present certain challenges, which includes work that is performed
outdoors and in cramped spaces.
However, welding personnel are encouraged to use the examples in this document as a
starting point for developing innovative solutions tailored to the specific ergonomic
challenges. The solutions have been categorized according to the equipment type.
Many of the solutions presented were developed and funded by the Mishap Prevention
and Hazard Abatement (MPHA) Program. For more information on the MPHA and no-
cost ergonomics technical support services, go to the Ergonomics Page at
http://www.navfac.navy.mil/safety
16 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Advantage:
• Reduces pushing, pulling, lifting and
carrying forces.
• Safer, saves time
• Carts, trucks, dollies can be
customized
Points to Remember:
• Wheels should be appropriate for
the flooring conditions
• Larger diameter wheels reduces
push forces
Figure 12: Gas cylinder transportation cart (left)
• Wheels should be well maintained Figure 13: Gas safety / guardian transportation cart
• Ensure proper load capacity for developed by the USAF houses cylinders, leads
equipment being moved and hoses (right)
• Pushing is preferred over pulling
17 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
18 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Points to Remember:
Figure 20: Vertical index unit for round stock has a security
access codes for level one stock and incorporates a jib crane at
New London CT
Reduce lifting and carrying forces
Improve raw material quality
Enhance inventory control
Boost security
19 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Hose Reels
Description: Devices that provide a
mechanical advantage in supporting or
cables or long hoses.
Advantage:
• Reduces force needed to roll hoses
• Hose reels can be customized for
special needs
Points to Remember:
• Minimize tangles and pinch points
in the travel path to reduce the
pulling forces Figure 21: Welding lead on a pulley help to reduce
awkward postures
Reduce lifting and pulling forces
Advantage:
• Eliminates heavy lifting and
carrying.
• Allows heavy or awkward materials,
tools or equipment to be moved
without carrying.
• Saves time and effort
Points to Remember:
• Different handling system and
grippers are available for many Figure 23: Southeast Regional Maintenance
situations. Center- portable gantry is used for raw material,
moving dies, and finished products
20 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
21 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Advantage:
• Eliminates heavy
lifting and carrying.
• Allows heavy or
awkward materials
to be moved,
stored and loaded
for distribution
without carrying.
• Saves time and
effort.
Points to Remember: Figure 25 Manual lifting and carrying of fabricated work piece (US Naval
Observatory)
• Different handling
system and
grippers are
available for many
situations.
• Ensure system /
device is rated for
the load weight.
22 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Handling Equipment
Description: Vacuum handling devices and
magnets can be used to reduce heavy lifting
or provide better handling points.
Advantage:
• Eliminates compressive forces on the
hands.
• Grips can be attached to overhead
equipment or fork trucks
• Ensure a safe grasp point that is free
from burrs.
23 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Handling Equipment
Description: A welding unit with an
attached fixture or handle.
Advantages:
• Allows welding unit to be moved
upstairs, safely, with two people
• Allows two-people to share the load
• Reduces muscle fatigue and the
risk of back injury
Points to Remember:
• A small wheeled dolly can be used
to transport welding equipment
without lifting
• Welding handle design available
from the Navy Ergonomics Subject Figure 30: Before: One welder struggles to carry
power con up stairs
Matter Experts (see resources).
24 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Positioning Equipment
Advantage:
• The anvil can be positioned to
reduce awkward postures of the
neck, back, hands and wrists by
positioning the work piece instead
of the worker.
Work surfaces that are easy to raise
or lower allow employees to work in
Figure 32 Welding tables can be joined together for
neutral postures larger parts and include clamping options to
Points to Remember: accommodate many sizes
• An adjustable work table, work chair
or standing platforms may be
necessary to accommodate
different size work pieces.
• Surfaces must be able to support
the weight of the object or material.
• Welding tables come in a variety of
sizes with fixtures for small or large
parts and can be joined together for
larger work pieces
25 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Advantage:
• Reduced awkward neck and
back posture
• Safer
• Low cost
Points to Remember:
• Solutions do not need to be
costly to be effective.
Figure 36 Before: Welder's neck and back are in an
awkward posture while he kneels on a hard surface
26 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
27 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
28 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Advantages:
• Height and or angle
adjustable creepers
and tool stools allow
the welders to get
closer to their work
while supporting some
of the body weight.
Points to Remember:
• Ensure materials used
for these devices are Figure 42: Before: Welder is in awkward posture to reach beneath
flame resistant or work piece
retardant.
• Maintain casters for
ease of movement.
Solution Source:
• Fleet Readiness Center
East
29 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Advantages:
• Height and or angle adjustable
creepers allow the welders to get
closer to their work while supporting
some of the body weight.
• Lean forward type welding stool
relieves some static back loading.
Points to Remember
• Ensure materials used for these
devices are flame resistant or
retardant. Figure 44: Height adjustable chair
30 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Equipment
Advantages:
• Greatly reduces repetitive forward
neck impact to close traditional
helmet
• Lenses are interchangeable
• Models incorporate sensitivity or
delay control
Figure 46: Auto darkening welding lens
Points to Remember
• Insure shade, delay, and sensitivity
features match working
environment and welding type.
31 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Robotic Welders
Description: Remote operation welding.
Advantages:
• Reduced fatigue associated with
welding in awkward or constrained
postures
• More efficiency
• Greater consistency of quality welds
• Increased repeatability
• Reduced production costs
Points to Remember:
• Not applicable for all welding
applications
Advantages:
• Reduces awkward postures and
forceful exertions associated with
manually clamping parts prior to
weld operations
• Can reduce job completion time
Figure 48: Welder using manual clamp method
Points to Remember
• Useful for long seams
32 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
33 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
34 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
o Step 4: Follow-up:
• Has each improvement reduced or eliminated the risk factors, fatigue,
discomfort symptoms or injury reporting?
• Has each improvement been accepted by the workers?
• Have any improvements created new risks or other problems?
• Have any improvements impacted production or quality?
• Are implemented improvements supported by training?
35 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
References
1. OSHA Guidelines for Shipyards; OSHA 3341-03N (2008) Ergonomics for the
prevention of Musculoskeletal Disorders
http://www.osha.gov/dsg/guidance/shipyard-guidelines.html
2. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health: Publication number 2007-
131: Ergonomics Guidelines for Manual Material Handling
http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2007-131/.
Resources
• Naval Facilities Engineering Command Ergonomics Subject Matter Expert site
http://www.navfac.navy.mil/safety (Select Ergonomics) Visit the web site for more
information and your eligibility for no cost ergonomics technical support.
36 ~ 37
ERGONOMICS GUIDE FOR WELDERS
Acknowledgements
For questions/comments contact:
Prepared by:
Navy Occupational Safety and Health Working Group, Ergonomics Task Action Team
with technical support provided by the Certified Professional Ergonomists at General
Dynamics Information Technology (GDIT), San Diego CA.
37 ~ 37