This document describes the Single JET+ jet grouting solution. Single JET+ allows creating jet grouting columns using a patented monitor with optimized flow, requiring less energy than conventional systems. It can replace double jet systems in some conditions. The document provides details on the equipment, installation process, costs, strengths/weaknesses compared to standard single and double jet, and case studies from projects in France, the UK, and France that used the Single JET+ solution.
This document describes the Single JET+ jet grouting solution. Single JET+ allows creating jet grouting columns using a patented monitor with optimized flow, requiring less energy than conventional systems. It can replace double jet systems in some conditions. The document provides details on the equipment, installation process, costs, strengths/weaknesses compared to standard single and double jet, and case studies from projects in France, the UK, and France that used the Single JET+ solution.
This document describes the Single JET+ jet grouting solution. Single JET+ allows creating jet grouting columns using a patented monitor with optimized flow, requiring less energy than conventional systems. It can replace double jet systems in some conditions. The document provides details on the equipment, installation process, costs, strengths/weaknesses compared to standard single and double jet, and case studies from projects in France, the UK, and France that used the Single JET+ solution.
This document describes the Single JET+ jet grouting solution. Single JET+ allows creating jet grouting columns using a patented monitor with optimized flow, requiring less energy than conventional systems. It can replace double jet systems in some conditions. The document provides details on the equipment, installation process, costs, strengths/weaknesses compared to standard single and double jet, and case studies from projects in France, the UK, and France that used the Single JET+ solution.
Marketing & Development page 1 This document and the information contained are confidential and intended solely for the use of the addresses. Dissemination, copying or disclosure of this document, either wholly or partially, is strictly prohibited without express approval.
1. 1.1. Position of the technique JET+ is a system to do jet grouting columns, using a special patented monitor with optimized flow (so with more focused jet). What is JET+ ?
JET+ allows doing the same column with less energy than conventional jetting system. The table bellow gives the dynamic pressure (in bar) at distance varying from 0.5 to 2 m measured in air :
1.2. The single JET+ allows pushing away the limits of the jet single. In some conditions, it can replace the double J et. Scope of application
The scope of soil for JET+ is the same than for standard J et (sand, gravels, marl, peat, clay, silt). The scope of use for JET+ is equivalent to the normal jet (underpinning, break in/ break out, small retaining wall, jetted cut off...). It can be implemented particularly for jetted slab, doing bigger diameter. Single J ET+ Standard single J et Single J ET+ Standard single J et
Si ngl e J ET + Jet grouting solution
Date : 17/ 05/ 13 V1
Page 2 sur 13
Rev E
Marketing & Development page 2 This document and the information contained are confidential and intended solely for the use of the addresses. Dissemination, copying or disclosure of this document, either wholly or partially, is strictly prohibited without express approval.
1.3.
Strength - weakness
Compressive layer Soil improvement Umbrella vault Underpinning Small retaining wall Cut off J et Grouting slab S t a n d a r d
s i n g l e
j e t Strengths - more efficient (less energy for same diameter) even with lower pressure (300 bars). - Less pressure losses in the monitor. - Better productivity (output) - Less cement consumption and less spoil production. Weaknesses - Thicker spoil in clay (lower substitution ratio). - Too efficient for small columns in soft or loose soils. - Expensive monitor difficult to amortize on a small site - Monitor to be cleaned after each column (need of 2 monitors at least). S i n g l e
J E T
+ Strengths - Almost as efficient for small diameter columns either in soft or stiff soils (no real improvement of efficiency with the air) - No use of pressured air (cleaner site, single jet rods, less risk of building or structure heave, less risk of pressured air pocket into the ground). - No spoil "drying effect" due to the air (especially when jetting above the water table). - More fluid spoil (higher substitution ratio). - Higher achievable strength. Weaknesses - Less efficient for big diameter columns =>lower productivity. - No air to ease the spoil return in case of deep columns. - Impossible to perform V-check in single rods (compared to SB double jet rods). - Expensive monitor. - Monitor to be cleaned after each column. S t a n d a r d
d o u b l e
j e t
Si ngl e J ET + Jet grouting solution
Date : 17/ 05/ 13 V1
Page 3 sur 13
Rev E
Marketing & Development page 3 This document and the information contained are confidential and intended solely for the use of the addresses. Dissemination, copying or disclosure of this document, either wholly or partially, is strictly prohibited without express approval. 2. 2.1. Site organization The team is the same than for standard J etting. Team 2.2. The installation for JET + (single / double) is the same than for standard J et (single / double). Installation 2.3.
Equipment single Jet+
Connection at top in 23/8 IF Connection at bottom in 23/8 API REG, possibility of 27/8 or 31/2. Usual nozzles from 4.5 to 6.5 mm (step of 0.5 mm). Maximum pressure : 40 MPa.
monitor body bottom connection top connection nut nozzle monitor counter nut 674 mm dia 88.9 mm 28 kg 300 mm
Si ngl e J ET + Jet grouting solution
Date : 17/ 05/ 13 V1
Page 4 sur 13
Rev E
Marketing & Development page 4 This document and the information contained are confidential and intended solely for the use of the addresses. Dissemination, copying or disclosure of this document, either wholly or partially, is strictly prohibited without express approval. 2.4. 2.4.1 drilling method for JET + : Method statement single JET+
During drilling operation, the drilling fluid comes out through the tool at bottom, and a little through the nozzle. The injection fluid can be water, or bentonite or cement grout. During the jetting operation, the flow increases and closes the pressure valve (see picture) and all the flow comes out through the nozzle.
2.4.2 drilling tools : Drilling tools are the same than conventional drilling (nozzle bit, tricone etc). 2.4.3 controls : Diameter control can be done with CYLJ ET or with coring. 3. All the shift costs, fixed costs and subsidiary costs are the same than for standard jet grouting site. The only monitor is different. Cost elements J et +single monitor with the top and bottom connections #5 600 Nozzle for J et # 150 It is necessary to have 2 monitors on site (1 for work, 1 for cleaning/maintenance). 4. The examples below are done with a maximum of data to help the understanding of the JET + process. References
Marketing & Development page 5 This document and the information contained are confidential and intended solely for the use of the addresses. Dissemination, copying or disclosure of this document, either wholly or partially, is strictly prohibited without express approval. France, Paris Louvre museum, - 2009 Presentation of work 373 columns J ET+single : for retaining wall under piles built on XIX th Drilling 2650 m / J etting 2450 ml c. Diameter 1400 / 1600 mm Average depth 6.55 m Geotechnical data 0 1.50 m : backfills : 1.50 5.60 m : Alluviums Pl #1.2 MPa at top Pl #3.5 MPa at bottom 5.60 6.60 m : gravelly marl Water table is at 4.80 m from plate-form Used technique Equipment : Beretta T46 & SM401 +pump SM7T450 : Method : drilling downward with cement grout and jetting upward C/W Grout : 0.76 (600 kg/m 3 Required strength : 5 MPa, ), J et parameters : J et pressure 31 MPa nozzle 5.5 mm Diameter (mm) 1400 1600 Top alluvium Bottom alluvium Bottom alluvium Flow (l/mn) 300 300 300 Up Speed (cm/mn) 22.5 22.5 13.8 Up step (cm) 3 3 3 Tempo (s) 6 9 13 Rotation speed (rpm) 10 7 9 J et energy (MJ /m) 31 44 67 Obtained data Industrial production : 2.8 m/h or 3.3 columns/8h : Cement consumption : 880 kg / th jetted m 760 kg / column th m 3
Spoils : 162% / th jetted m 3
140% / column th m 3
3
Si ngl e J ET + Jet grouting solution
Date : 17/ 05/ 13 V1
Page 6 sur 13
Rev E
Marketing & Development page 6 This document and the information contained are confidential and intended solely for the use of the addresses. Dissemination, copying or disclosure of this document, either wholly or partially, is strictly prohibited without express approval. UK, Birmingham - 2010 Presentation of work 44 columns single J ET+& 30 columns double J ET+ : (test 1) for a jetted slab inside a shaft global overlapping between columns of 75% treatment between 17.50 m and 12.50 m Geotechnical data 0 17.50 m : silty gravely fine sand : STP : 20 to 30 Water table is at 2 m from plate-form Used technique Equipment :klemm +SM 7T500J : Method : drilling downward with water and jetting upward Required strength : 8 MPa J et parameters : nozzle 5.5 mm Diameter (mm) 1650 2200 2750 J etting system Single Double Double Grout cement content (kg/m 3 800 ) 900 900 Grout C/W 1.08 1.26 1.26 Grout density 1.55 1.61 1.61 Grout flow (l/mn) 300 300 300 Grout pressure (MPa) 342 357 357 Step (cm) 3 3 3 Tempo (s) 28 14 20 Up Speed (mn/m) 15.56 7.78 11.11 Rotation speed (rpm) 9 10 9 J et energy (MJ /m) 160 83 119 Obtained data Industrial production : 3.5 columns / 11 h : (drilling 60 m / 11 h & jetting 20 m / 11 h), Cement consumption : 1260 kg / th jetted m 3 860 kg / column th m , 3 Spoils : 236 % / th jetted m , 3 145 % / column th m , 3 On this site, the monitor has suffered excessive breakdown in J ET+double. .
Si ngl e J ET + Jet grouting solution
Date : 17/ 05/ 13 V1
Page 7 sur 13
Rev E
Marketing & Development page 7 This document and the information contained are confidential and intended solely for the use of the addresses. Dissemination, copying or disclosure of this document, either wholly or partially, is strictly prohibited without express approval.
France, Strasbourg - 2011 Presentation of work 22 columns J ET+single diameter 1200 mm : 79 columns J ET+single diameter 1400 mm for foundation underpinning (existing and new foundations) Drilling up to 7.50 m, jetting on 6.30 m Geotechnical data 0 7.50 m : silty backfills : Pl #0.1 MPa No water table Used technique Equipment : Beretta T46 +SM 7T450 : Method : drilling at down operation with water and jetting at up operation Required strength : 4 MPa J et parameters : nozzle 5.5 mm Diameter (mm) 1200 1400 J etting system Single Single Grout cement content (kg/m 3 550 ) 550 Grout C/W 0.69 0.69 Grout flow (l/mn) 305 305 Grout pressure (MPa) 315 315 Step (cm) 3 3 Tempo (s) 5 8 Up Speed (mn/m) 2.80 4.44 Rotation speed (rpm) 12 15 J et energy (MJ /m) 27 43 Obtained data Industrial production : 3.5 columns / 8 h : Cement consumption : 1550 kg / th jetted m 1360 kg / column th m 3
Spoils : 165 % / th jetted m 3
155 % / column th m 3
3
Si ngl e J ET + Jet grouting solution
Date : 17/ 05/ 13 V1
Page 8 sur 13
Rev E
Marketing & Development page 8 This document and the information contained are confidential and intended solely for the use of the addresses. Dissemination, copying or disclosure of this document, either wholly or partially, is strictly prohibited without express approval.
Viet Nam, Ho Chi Minh M&C - 2010 Presentation of work Diaphragm wall joint treatment with J ET +single columns : Maximum depth 30 m drilling & 10/12 m jetting Geotechnical data 0 30 m : clayey silty sand : SPT 30 to 35 Water table is at 4 m from plate-form Used technique Equipment : local drilling rig +SM 5T302 : Method : drilling downward and jetting upward Required strength : 5 MPa, J et parameters : nozzle 5 mm Diameter (mm) 800 1300 J etting system Single Single Grout cement content (kg/m 3 650 ) 650 Grout C/W 0.84 0.84 Grout flow (l/mn) 235 235 Grout pressure (MPa) 285 285 Step (cm) 4 3 Tempo (s) 4 11 Up Speed (mn/m) 1.70 6 Rotation speed (rpm) 15 11 J et energy (MJ /m) 12 40
Si ngl e J ET + Jet grouting solution
Date : 17/ 05/ 13 V1
Page 9 sur 13
Rev E
Marketing & Development page 9 This document and the information contained are confidential and intended solely for the use of the addresses. Dissemination, copying or disclosure of this document, either wholly or partially, is strictly prohibited without express approval.
France, Le Havre - 2011 Presentation of work 171 half columns J ET+single diameter 1800 mm : for soil improvement near diaphragm wall in harbour Maximum depth 9 m drilling & 8 m jetting Geotechnical data 0 7 m : fine sand (no compact) : 7 9 m : gravels Water table is at 7 m from plate-form Used technique Equipment : PX1200A +SM7T450 : Method : drilling downward and jetting upward Required strength : 1 MPa, J et parameters : nozzle 5.5 mm Diameter (mm) 1800 J etting system Single, alternative Grout cement content (kg/m 3 430 ) Grout C/W 0.5 Grout flow (l/mn) 260 Grout pressure (MPa) 220 Step (cm) 3 Tempo (s) 8 Up Speed (mn/m) 4.44 Rotation speed (rpm) 11 J et energy (MJ /m) 25 Obtained data Industrial production : 5.9 columns / 8 h (7.5 m : 3 Cement consumption : 580 kg / th jetted m jet /h) 260 kg / column th m 3
Spoils : 130 % / th jetted m 3
104 % / column th m 3
3
Si ngl e J ET + Jet grouting solution
Date : 17/ 05/ 13 V1
Page 10 sur 13
Rev E
Marketing & Development page 10 This document and the information contained are confidential and intended solely for the use of the addresses. Dissemination, copying or disclosure of this document, either wholly or partially, is strictly prohibited without express approval. USA, Manhattan 2010 Test 2 Presentation of work 40 columns diameter 1500 in J ET+double : for building underpinning Maximum depth 36 m drilling & 31 m jetting Geotechnical data 0 5 m : backfills, : SPT 3 to 9, Qt 0.8 to 1 MPa 5 8.50 m : organics, SPT 0 to 3, Qt 0.8 to 1 MPa 8.5 18.5 m : silty sand, SPT 6 to 15, Qt 5 to 14 MPa 18.5 36 m : silty clay, SPT 4 to 14, Qt 4 to 10 MPa Used technique Equipment : C14 +metax MP7 : Method : drilling downward and jetting upward Requested strength resistance : 3.5 MPa, J et parameters : nozzle 5.5 mm Soil layers 5 to 8.50 m 8.50 to 18.50 m 18.50 to 36 m Grout cement content (kg/m 3 650 ) 650 650 Grout C/W 0.83 0.83 0.83 Grout flow (l/mn) 210 290 320 Grout pressure (MPa) 160 300 365 Step (cm) 4 4 4 Tempo (s) 41 15 23 Up Speed (mn/m) 17.1 6.25 9.6 Rotation speed (rpm) 1.5 4 J et energy (MJ /m) 56 54 111 Obtained data Industrial production : 1 column / 11 h : On this site, the monitor has suffered excessive breakdown in J ET+double.
Si ngl e J ET + Jet grouting solution
Date : 17/ 05/ 13 V1
Page 11 sur 13
Rev E
Marketing & Development page 11 This document and the information contained are confidential and intended solely for the use of the addresses. Dissemination, copying or disclosure of this document, either wholly or partially, is strictly prohibited without express approval. 5. Following the test on Birmingham and Manathan of double J ET+, with a lot of breakdown of the monitor, a new elbow has been designed and manufactured, with improved sealing (tested at 450 b). This new monitor can be used for single or double J ET+. A single J ET+ monitor can be converted to a double J ET+ monitor. Two new monitors have been successfully tested in the site of Lee tunnel. It seems that the problem is solved. It needs more sites to check with time now. Opportunities A removable rubber plate can be fitted on nozzle (or other system), to avoid plugging the nozzle. 6. General sale approach : Sale arguments Focus the discussion with the customer around his need, argue of our differences and put forward his value creation. Product : J et grouting process. Price : Cheaper than standard jet grouting, on large sites. Position : CAB Characteristic Advantage Benefit (customer) No air use in J ET+single No stress on the soil No risk of building heave Less jetting energy for same diameter Less fuel consumption Less human risk More ecologic Quieter client Bigger diameter with same energy Less columns Faster work Less equipment for same target Less fuel consumption Less human risk Softer site Safety site
Si ngl e J ET + Jet grouting solution
Date : 17/ 05/ 13 V1
Page 12 sur 13
Rev E
Marketing & Development page 12 This document and the information contained are confidential and intended solely for the use of the addresses. Dissemination, copying or disclosure of this document, either wholly or partially, is strictly prohibited without express approval. Environment More ecologic technology of single J et+in front of double J et : :
CO 2 energy , transport, water waste spoil material Promotion : Your large safe J etting solution. People : This product can be built for : Small building promoters, Infrastructure directions, Industries, mines, Dam administrators. In front of a buyer customer typology, refocus all time the discussion on technical matters and ask for a technical person during the meeting. Make the buyer worrying about existing buildings, resident problems, quality of the work. In front of a hitech customer typology, focus on the hitech patented monitor with good environment matters (less energy, less noise etc...), flatter his pride. In front of family customer typology, focus on the safety of the process, his quietness with residents (we will take care of them, less noise, less pollution, less vibration, no risk of uprising), the better quality, the environment. Place : This product can be used for : Underpinning Soil improvement between two strong layers Slope reinforcement Small retaining wall Cut off Umbrella vault This technology is particularly adapted to replace double jet with single J ET+.
SINGLE J ET+ DOUBLE J ET
Si ngl e J ET + Jet grouting solution
Date : 17/ 05/ 13 V1
Page 13 sur 13
Rev E
Marketing & Development page 13 This document and the information contained are confidential and intended solely for the use of the addresses. Dissemination, copying or disclosure of this document, either wholly or partially, is strictly prohibited without express approval. 7. Business development : Bertrand Steff de Verninac To go further bertrand.steffdeverninac @soletanche-bachy.com Methods : Basile Leconte basile.leconte @soletanche-bachy.com, Equipment purchase : DMG, pascal.plique@soletanche-bachy.com Complete documentation : preventive maintenance, corrective maintenance, spare part book. Support for jobsite : according to Groups conditions.