North Jersey Jewish Standard, June 6, 2014
North Jersey Jewish Standard, June 6, 2014
North Jersey Jewish Standard, June 6, 2014
for Israel
Space
pioneer
brings
his lunar
mission to
Paramus
JSTANDARD.COM
2014 83
SENATOR BOOKER AND THE JEWS page 6
WHO ARE THE JEWS IN NORTH JERSEY? page 10
THE VIRAL BEATS OF SIX13 page 14
ERICA BROWNS LEADERSHIP LESSONS page 49
J e w i s h S t a n d a r d
1 0 8 6 T e a n e c k R o a d
T e a n e c k , N J 0 7 6 6 6
C H A N G E S E R V I C E R E Q U E S T E D
page 26
JUNE 6, 2014
VOL. LXXXIII NO. 39 $1.00
NORTH JERSEY
2 JEWISH STANDARD JUNE 6, 2014
JS-2
Page 3
JEWISH STANDARD JUNE 6, 2014 3
JS-3*
PUBLISHERS STATEMENT: (USPS 275-700 ISN 0021-6747) is
published weekly on Fridays with an additional edition every
October, by the New Jersey Jewish Media Group, 1086 Teaneck
Road, Teaneck, NJ 07666. Periodicals postage paid at Hackensack,
NJ and additional offices. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to
New Jersey Jewish Media Group, 1086 Teaneck Road, Teaneck, NJ
07666. Subscription price is $30.00 per year. Out-of-state subscrip-
tions are $45.00, Foreign countries subscriptions are $75.00.
The appearance of an advertisement in The Jewish Standard does
not constitute a kashrut endorsement. The publishing of a paid
political advertisement does not constitute an endorsement of any
candidate political party or political position by the newspaper, the
Federation or any employees.
The Jewish Standard assumes no responsibility to return unsolicit-
ed editorial or graphic materials. All rights in letters and unsolicited
editorial, and graphic material will be treated as unconditionally
assigned for publication and copyright purposes and subject to
JEWISH STANDARDs unrestricted right to edit and to comment
editorially. Nothing may be reprinted in whole or in part without
written permission from the publisher. 2014
NOSHES ...................................................4
OPINION ............................................... 22
COVER STORY .................................... 26
GALLERY .............................................. 42
KEEPING KOSHER .............................44
DEAR RABBI .......................................46
TORAH COMMENTARY ................... 47
CROSSWORD PUZZLE .................... 48
ARTS & CULTURE .............................. 49
CALENDAR ..........................................50
OBITUARIES ........................................ 53
CLASSIFIEDS ...................................... 54
REAL ESTATE ...................................... 56
CONTENTS
Hold on to your hat!
lWell admit to a little sympathy for
advertising copywriters. Its not all the
gin-and-glamour of Mad Men. Cer-
tainly not if youre charged with ad-
vertising a swimming pool in Petach
Tikvah to residents of the next town
over, the charedi city of Bnei Brak.
Sure, you can write The swim-
ming pool of Bnei Brak at the top of
the picture. And you can leave out
pictures of God forbid! women in
bathing suits.
But in the end, nothing says the
swimming pool of Bnei Brak like a
man in a suit and a black hat up to
his shoulders in the water. And only
residents as holy as the inhabitants of
Bnei Brak could merit the miracle of
a happy child diving into a pool, with
his yarmulke not at all askew.
Buyer beware, however: Our infor-
mants tell us that real charedim take
off their hats and jackets and even
most of their clothing before going
for a swim. So much for truth in advertising.
LARRY YUDELSON
Invisible women
lAs they say in Boro Park: Anything
Clint Eastwood can do, a chasidic
rebbe can do ten thousand times
better.
A couple of years back, Mr. East-
wood addressed an empty chair at
the Republican National Convention.
Last week, some of Brooklyns
oldest and presumably most saga-
cious chasidic rabbis called a special
womens-only gathering to condemn
use of the Internet.
The rabbis addressed the woman
through a one-way mirror. All they
saw was their only reflection talking
back at them which may be sadly
appropriate in its own way.
In the interest of modesty, purity,
and chastity, the only photo released
of the audience featured the pre-
speech empty chairs.
Whether women actually attend-
ed the event and whether those
women were visible or, like Sue
Storm of the Fantastic Four, have
been dosed by cosmic rays in order
to be transparent to photos could
not be independently confirmed at
press time.
LARRY YUDELSON
Candlelighting: Friday, June 6, 8:06 p.m.
Shabbat ends: Saturday, June 7, 9:15 p.m.
There goes the bride
lSome religious tradi-
tionalists like to portray
marriage as between a
man and a woman. But
what about those peo-
ple who would rather
not expose themselves
and their children to
pictures of women?
Two possible solu-
tions to this quintes-
sential dilemma of 21st
century Jewish fun-
damentalists recently
have crossed our desk.
In one (right), from
Every Picture Tells a
Story, in which Chaim
Natan Firszt illustrates
the books of Genesis
and Exodus, Moses
mother, Yocheved, is
demurely veiled. (See
also the shocking nu-
dity of our ancestor
Eve, below.)
A second solution
comes in an illustration
of a Jewish wedding from an Israeli
Talmud adaptation for children. Here
(below right) we see the husband
break a glass under the chuppa,
while his wife hey, has anyone see
a runaway bride? LARRY YUDELSON
Noshes
4 JEWISH STANDARD JUNE 6, 2014
JS-4*
To be the president of Israel? Oh, come on. Tats
not for me. I write books. Im not cut out for that.
Elie Wiesel, explaining to an Israeli newspaper, Yediot Achronot, why he turned
down Benjamin Netanyahus request to run for president of Israel.
Want to read more noshes? Visit facebook.com/jewishstandard
for Hannah Senesh, a
1985 one-woman musi-
cal play about the Hun-
garian poet and para-
trooper who was killed
by the Nazis. Its been
performed worldwide,
and Seneshs mother,
who was 90 then, saw a
1986 Israeli production.
Luttwak made me laugh
as he told a San Diego
Jewish website about
his background: I grew
up in a modern kosher
home (we ate lobster in
the backyard).
The Belmont
Stakes, the third
race in the Triple
Crown, will be shown on
NBC on Saturday, June
7, with coverage starting
at 6:30 p.m. California
Chrome, trained by ART
SHERMAN, 77, will try to
be the first horse since
1978 to win all three
Triple Crown races.
Just about every-
body recognizes
STEVEN WEBER,
but most dont remem-
ber his name. Hes the
charming and regular-
guy-handsome fellow
who still probably is best
known for playing one
of the two commuter
airline pilot brothers on
the 90s sitcom Wings.
Now 53, Weber grew-
up in Queens, where his
father scratched out a
lower-middle class in-
come managing Borscht
Belt performers. I long
knew he was Jewish, but
I didnt know his whole
Jewish background until
he wrote a long article
about visiting Israel in
2011 for the Huffington
Post. It is a smart and
moving piece. (Just
google the title to find it:
In a sense, abroad part
trois, Is real, oy!) N.B.
Idina Menzel
THE NOMINEES:
Its Tony time
Stephen Fry
Mare Winningham James Lapine
The Tony awards,
for excellence
in the Broad-
way theater, will be
broadcast live by CBS
on Sunday, June 8, at
8 p.m. Hugh Jackman
hosts. Here are the
Jewish nominees in the
marquee categories:
Lead actress, musical:
IDINA MENZEL, 42, If/
Then; featured actor,
play: STEPHEN FRY,
56, Twelfth Night;
featured actress, play:
MARE WINNINGHAM,
55, Casa Valentina and
SOPHIE OKENEDO, 46,
A Raisin in the Sun;
featured actor, musical:
DANNY BURSTEIN, 49,
Cabaret, and JARROD
SPECTOR, 34, Beau-
tiful: The Carole King
Musical.
Best play author:
JAMES LAPINE, 65,
Act One and HARVEY
FIERSTEIN, 60, Casa
Valentina; best musi-
cal, songwriters: Af-
ter Midnight, a revival
revue, features the work
of four legendary song-
writers. The lineup in-
cludes the music of the
late HAROLD ARLEN
and lyrics by the late
DOROTHY FIELDS. Also
in this category: Alad-
din by ALAN MEN-
KEN, 65, and the late
HOWARD ASHMAN,
and Beautiful (Carole
King), with songs by
KING, 72, and four of her
contemporary (Jewish)
rock songwriters; and
A Gentlemans Guide to
Love and Murder: lyrics
by ROBERT L. FREED-
MAN, 56, and music and
lyrics by STEVEN LUT-
VAK, 56.
The songwriters of
Gentlemans Guide
and Aladdin were
also nominated for best
original score. Also in
this category: JASON
ROBERT BROWN, 43,
The Bridges of Madison
County, and TOM KITT,
40, music for If/Then.
Finally, WOODY AL-
LEN, 79, is nominated
for the book of the mu-
sical version of Bullets
over Broadway. Robert
Freedman of Gentle-
mans Guide was nomi-
nated for a musicals
book as well.
Glatt kosher factoids:
Act One is based on
the autobiography of
the late playwright/pro-
ducer MOSS HART. The
play is told in flashbacks,
with Hart, as an adult,
providing introduc-
tory narration for each
scene. Arab-American
actor Tony Shalhoub is
Tony-nominated (lead
actor, play) for playing
three roles(!): the adult
Hart, Harts father, and
playwright GEORGE S.
KAUFMAN.
Danny Burstein is
nominated for playing
Herr Schultz, an elderly
German Jewish store-
keeper
Jarrod Spector is
nominated for play-
ing songwriter BARRY
MANN, 75. Mann and his
wife, CYNTHIA WEILL,
73, wrote scads of hits,
including, Youve Lost
That Lovin Feeling.
Steven Luttwaks
works include the music
At the movies
Edge of Tomorrow and The Fault in Our Stars
are both set to open today. The former stars Tom Cruise
as a desk-bound army oficer who is thrown into a very
bloody personal battle with a space alien race. Yes, its
familiar material. But this one sounds like it has inter-
esting twists and the director, DOUG LIMAN, 48, has a
strong track record (Bourne ilms, etc.).
Fault is a romantic comedy/drama. It co-stars
Shailene Woodley as a teen with terminal cancer and
ANSEL ELGORT, 20, as a wonderful guy who takes her
to meet her favorite author. NAT WOLFF, 19, has a big
supporting role.
N.B.
California-based Nate Bloom can be reached at
Middleoftheroad1@aol.com
Doug Liman
Audi
Truth in Engineering
powered by
425 Rt 3 East, Secaucus, NJ 07094 Available Now
All-New 2015 A3
audimeadowlands.net
31715 A3_StripAd_Available Now.indd 1 3/31/14 3:44 PM
JS-5
JEWISH STANDARD JUNE 6, 2014 5
Loca
`
646 Cedar Lane Teaneck, NJ 07666
Tel: 201-855-8500 Fax: 201-801-0225
Fresh
Dark Meat
Ground Turkey
Dark Meat
Turkey
5hwarma
lb. lb. lb.
lb. lb.
lb.
lb.
lb. lb.
We reserve the right to limit sales to 1 per family. Prices effective this store only. Not responsible for typographical errors. Some pictures are for design purposes only and do not necessarily represent items on sale.While Supply Lasts. No rain checks.
PRODUCE
MEAT DEPARTMENT
BAKERY
$
11
99
GROCERY DEPARTMENT
Fresh
Whole
Chicken
Fresh
Chicken
Cutlets
American Black Angus Beel
Whole
Brisket
$
5
99
Fresh Homemade
Beel
5liders
Visit Our Website at:
www.thecedarmarket.com
5TORE HOUR5
5UN - TUE: 7AM - 9PM
WED: 7AM - 10PM
THUR5: 7AM - 11PM
FRI: 7AM - 2 HOUR5
BEFORE 5UNDOWN
5ign Up For Your
Loyalty
Card
In 5tore
646 Cedar Lane Teaneck, NJ 07666
201-855-8500 Fax: 201-801-0225
www.thecedarmarket.com
info@thecedarmarket.com
646 Cedar Lane Teaneck, NJ 07666 201-855-8500 Fax: 201-801-0225 www.thecedarmarket.com info@thecedarmarket.com
M A R K E T
M A R K E T
TERMS &CONDITIONS: This card is the property of Cedar Market, Inc. and is intended for exclusive use of the recipient and their household members. Card is not transferable. We reserve the right to change or rescind the terms and conditions of the Cedar Market loyalty programat any time, and without notice. By using this card, the cardholder signifes his/her agreement to the terms & conditions for use. Not to be combined with any other Discount/Store Coupon/Ofer. *Loyalty Card must be presented at time of purchase along with IDfor verifcation. Purchase cannot be reversed once sale is completed.
CEDAR MARKET
Loyalty
Program
CEDAR MARKET
Loyalty
Program
Fine Foods
Great Savings
5ale Ellective
6/8/z - 6/zj/z
U.5.D.A.
Organic
Bananas
9
lb..
U.5.D.A. Organic
Cello
Mushrooms
3/$
5 conts.
zz oz.
z6 oz.
each
Fresh
4/$
5
In Water or Oil
5tarKist
5olid White Tuna
lor
5/$
5
5/$
5
z pint conts.
lb. lb.
Farm Fresh
5trawberries
2/$
3
z lb. conts.
5weet
5outhern
Peaches
99
lb.
3/$
4 lor
Assorted
Hunts
BBQ 5auce
99
z8 oz. btl.
Assorted
Hunts
5nack
Pack
4/$
5
zj oz.
Assorted
Betty
Crocker
5nacks
$
1
79
oz. pkg.
5ave On!
Barilla
5paghetti
or Elbows
$
1
25
z6 oz. box
Post
Grape Nuts or
Raisin Bran
Fresh
Napoleon
Collee
Chillon
5ponge
Chocolate
Flaky
Danish
$
2
99
$
3
99
$
4
99
$
1
25
zo oz. box
Assorted
5kinny
Girl
Water
99
z) oz.
Assorted
Popcorners
Chips
99
oz. bag
5ave On!
Paskesz
Marshmallows
2/$
4
8 oz. pkg.
Assorted
Paskesz
Chocolate
Chips 2/$
5 zo oz. pkg.
5ave On!
Tradition
5oup
Cases
$
49
zz pack
Assorted
Mishpacha
Whole Wheat
Flour
$
2
49
lb. bag Assorted
Applesnax
Pack
99
lor
lor
lor
lor
5ave On!
Paskesz
5andwich
Cookies
Original or
Vanilla
Rice
Dream
2/$
4
$
3
49
z6 oz. pkg.
6 oz. cont.
NEW ITEM!
Gelen
Nice Tea
$
1
79
6 oz. btl.
5ave On!
Hadar
Tirosh
Biscuits
4/$
5
6 oz.
5ave On!
Haddar
Honey Mustard
Pretzels
$
2
49
zo oz.
Assorted
Cheez-It
Crackers
$
2
49
zj.) oz. box
5ave On!
Gelen
Cranberry
5auce
$
1
49
z6 oz. can
Ready to Cook
Honey Garlic
Chicken 5tir Fry
American Black Angus Beel
5houlder
Roast
American Black Angus Beel
Butchers Cut
London Broil
oz. can
9
N
J
M
G
116 MainStreet, Fort Lee
201.947.2500
www.inapoli.com
S
am
m
ys
North Jerseys Premier Italian
Steak, Seafood & Pasta Eatery
JoinUseverytuesday
andthursdayforthe
lobsterspecial, anystyle
Anddontforgetevery
MondayandWednesday
areDelmonicoSteakNights
ComebyMon. throughSat.,
4:00-6:00pmforourawesome
earlybird, completemeal
withdrink
You asked for it for the last 20 years and
nowits here! Chef Sams Basil Vinaigrette
House Dressing is nowbottled to go.
Bring this Ad in
to receive a
Free Bottle
min. $40 purchase
Expires 6/30/13
only
$19.95
only
$19.95
also
$19.95
3493212-01
napoli
5/17/13
subite
canali/singer
carrol/BB
This ad is copyrighted by North
Jersey Media Group and may not
be reproduced in any form, or
replicated in a similar version,
without approval from North
Jersey Media Group.
3
4
9
3
2
1
2
-
0
1
N
J
M
G
Tuesday and Thursday
Our famous seafood special
Call for details
ONLY
$21.95
ONLY
$21.95
ONLY
$21.95
Monday and Wednesday
Steak Night special
Come by Mon. through Sat.,
4:00-6:00pm for our awesome
early bird, complete meal
with drink
Bring this Ad
in to receive a
Free Bottle
min. $40
purchase
Expires 6/25/14
Pinkie Nails
680A River Rd. New Milford, NJ
(Next to Burger King. Parking in Rear)
201-265-7300 OPEN 7 DAYS
READERS
CHOICE
2013
FIRST PLACE
NAIL SALON
JUNE EVENT
NOW OPEN SUNDAY 106
Regular Mani & Pedi
$10
OFF
Exp. 6/30/2014
All New Set
UV French Gel
50%
OFF
Exp. 6/30/2014 Appt. Only
Bring this coupon in. Cannot be combined with any other oer.
The Best Selection of
Talliot and
Kippot anywhere.
Exquisite Styles
for Women, Men,
Bar and Bat Mitzvah
www.thetallislady.com info@thetallislady.com
Lisa Prawer
Convenient Bergen County Location 201-321-4995
Beautifully Beaded, Crystal,
Crocheted, Suede, Lace
Kippot, Tallit Clips
Mention this ad for
10% OFF
We believe we should make an
impact. The kid who constructs
a model in cardboard, his mind is
flying a spaceship to the moon. If
I can impact one kid from every
classroom, Ive made something
amazing for clal Yisrael, the Jew-
ish people.
SpaceILs largest single dona-
tion came from Sheldon Adelson,
whose foundation announced a
$16.4 million donation in April.
But SpaceIL wants widespread
support as well. It is hosting a fun-
draising campaign on IndieGoGo;
it is trying to raise $240,000, one
dollar for every mile to the moon.
Supporters who donate $18 will
be able to send a 140 character
message to the moon on a special
chip within the ship. People who
donate more can get souvenir
shirts, or, for $1,800, a chance to
have a message engraved on the
spaceship itself. For $100,000,
they can get a seat in the SpaceIL
control room on launch day.
The first space race pitted two
large government bureaucracies against each other, as
the Soviet Union competed against NASA. Now, while
China and India are beginning their own governmental
space race, in the West the focus has shifted to private
and flamboyant enterprise. Richard Branson, founder
of Virgin Atlantic airlines, has been taking reservations
for future suborbital trips through his Virgin Galactic
company. Last week, Elon Musk, the billionaire founder
of SpaceX, unveiled the companys Dragon 2 capsule,
designed to ferry up to seven astronauts to the Interna-
tional Space Station and perhaps beyond. (Despite his
Israeli sounding name, Mr. Musk is not Jewish.) And sev-
eral crowd-funded efforts on IndieGoGo and Kickstarter
have offered space enthusiasts the opportunity to sup-
port space flight, control their own orbital experiments,
and even have photographs taken in space.
At this stage, Mr. Bash believes that his team is the
furthest along. And even if it is not, even if someone
else beats us to the moon, it will probably be a private
team in the States, so we will still be the fourth nation
to land gently on it.
SpaceIL has a design for the spaceship, which it has
named Sparrow. It will weigh about 300 pounds at
launch and stand a bit over three feet tall the size of
a small dishwasher.
Construction has begun. In December, SpaceIL signed
a contract with Israel Aircraft Industries for the propul-
sion system. That system, and its fuel, will make up 80
percent of the satellites weight at launch. With the 88
pounds remaining, SpaceIL will squeeze in navigation,
which can control its journey by looking at the stars
and recognizing landmarks on the moon; broadcasting
equipment to beam the message back to earth; and fuel
to make a second 500 meter hop because why would
an Israeli mission send a rover if the ship itself could
make a shortcut?
Now, the organization is focusing on buying a launch
spot. There are a handful of countries and companies
offering launch service.
You cant secure a launch on eBay, said Mr. Bash.
You have to do a lot of email and tours and meetings all
over the world, until you find the right opportunity for
your spacecraft.
No launches from Cape Canaveral are available to be
booked, he said; a launch from the Baikonur Cosmo-
drome in Kazakhstan remains a possibility.
He said he expects the launch to cost $10 million, but
it can change quite a bit. SpaceILs overall budget is $36
million. And if it wins the $20 million Google contest, it
will plow the proceeds back into its educational work.
SpaceIL is not buying a launch from the Israeli Space
Agency; the agencys Shavit rockets are designed for low
earth orbit only. In addition, Israel is unique in launch-
ing its rockets from east to west, rather than the reverse.
This is not because of Hebrew going from right left, jokes
Mr. Bash, but because our neighbors wouldnt appreci-
ate us launching modified ICBMs above them.
Launching against earths rotation makes orbit 30 per-
cent harder to achieve, or requires the satellites to be 30
percent smaller. Out of that came the Israeli know-how
for microsatellites, he said.
Thats particularly important for the lunar lander,
because building a bigger satellite isnt just a matter of
packing more pounds worth of payload on a rocket. A
more powerful moon craft also would bring an added
layer of paperwork, since it would fall under arms trea-
ties regulating intercontinental ballistic missiles.
The direct flight from earth orbit to the lunar orbit
will take three or four days. The whole voyage will be
longer, though. After being launched into earth orbit,
the mission will wait until the moon is in the right align-
ment. And once it is orbiting the moon, there will be a
further delay until it is in the right position to land. Total
expected time: roughly one month.
There will be simulations before the launch. For a
month, the avionics, the computer, and the spacecraft
will be fed data so they believe theyre flying to the
moon. Its a real simulation. Its almost like flying to
the moon, Mr. Bash said.
Still: Theres nothing like going up.
But Mr. Bashs biggest journey may have come about
a year ago, when Volkwagen invited him to talk to the
companys management in Hamburg, Germany. His sec-
ond slide was a picture of his grandfather.
I ended in an optimistic way. Look how far weve
gone in 70 years, he said.
SpaceILs float at Sundays Celebrate Israel Parade in Manhattan
Opinion
JEWISH STANDARD JUNE 6, 2014 29
JS-29*
1415 Queen Anne Road Suite 210
Teaneck, NJ 07666
201-379-9234
www.garbcg.com
Garb Consulting Group LLC
Since 2007
Full Service
I.T. Networking
Lets talk about I.T.
Servers, WiFi,
Anti Virus
Off/On Site
Data Backups,
PC Sales
Garb Consulting Group LLC
Styling Cutting Coloring Highlighting
EXPERT TECNIQUES, STYLES & TRENDS FOR OVER 20 YEARS
Sheitels at Wholesale prices!
Please call Angelica 973-256-2298
MAURO TOLLIS SALON
281 Browertown Road , #103 . Woodland Park, NJ
www.maurotollissalon.com
Tues 11-8, Wed 10-6, Thurs 12-8, Fri 9-6 , Sun & Mon by appointment
HAIR COLOUR GROUP
Specializing in ALL Sheitel Services
D-Day and the
bombing of Auschwitz
S
eventy years ago this week, the Allies staged the
D-Day invasion, landing some 24,000 troops on
the beaches along Frances Normandy Coast in
one of the major turning points of World War II.
What is not widely realized, however, is that the D-Day
assault on June 6, 1944, also had an important link to the
fate of Europes Jewsand in particular to the contro-
versy over the Allies refusal to bomb Auschwitz.
Apologists for the Roosevelt administrations failure to
bomb the death camps often point to the fact that Presi-
dent Roosevelt and the U.S. military were preoccupied
with D-Day. We are talking about the summer of 1944,
Roosevelt Institute president
William vanden Heuvel has
emphasized. [Because of ]
the invasion of Normandy
on June 6th American and
our allies were stretched dan-
gerously across western and
southern Europe.
But that argument mixes
apples and oranges. The
bombers that would have
been used to strike Auschwitz
would have had to come from
the 15th U.S. Air Force, which
was based in Italy. They were the ones closest enough
for such a mission and they had almost nothing to do
with the D-Day preparations.
Moreover, Allied planes were flying over Auschwitz
long before D-Day. Starting in February 1944 four
months before the Normandy landings Allied photo-
recon planes based in southern Italy began carrying out
surveillance missions over Auschwitz.
This Allied surveillance was focused on a cluster of syn-
thetic oil factories that the Germans set up in that area,
some of them within the greater Auschwitz complex and
operating on Jewish slave labor. Several of the plants were
situated less than five miles from the gas chambers and
crematoria. On May 12, British bombers carried out the
first raid in what was to become known as the oil war.
The oil plants represented a high-priority military
target for the Allies because the Germans desperately
needed them to sustain the Axis war effort. It was in part
because of their dwindling oil supplies that the German
air force, the Luftwaffe, was unable to take part in the
defense of the Normandy region when the Allies landed.
During the entire first day of the invasion, enemy
opposition in the air, fighter or bomber, was next to
nil, Gen. Carl Spaatz, the commander of U.S. Army Air
Forces in the theater, noted in a postwar interview. That
was a major reason why the D-Day invasion succeeded,
and why fewer than 4,000 Allied soldiers lost their lives
at Normandy.
Spaatz directed the Allies oil-war offensive. In the
summer of 1944, he clashed with Chief of Staff Gen-
eral Dwight Eisenhower, after Eisenhower repeatedly
diverted bombers from the oil attacks to the Normandy
region to support the Allied advances following D-Day.
Spaatz was furious over the diversions and ultimately
threatened to resign, forcing Eisenhower to relent.
Ironically, at the very same time Eisenhower and
Spaatz were arguing about diverting planes from the oil
war, the diversion argument became the centerpiece in
the controversy over whether or not the United States
should bomb Auschwitz.
American Jewish leaders who urged the Roosevelt
administration to bomb the death camp or the railways
leading to it were told by Assistant Secretary of War John
McCloy that such bombings would be impracticable.
McCloy claimed that the War Department conducted a
study of the feasibility of the proposal and concluded
it would require diversion of U.S. bombers from battle
zones elsewhere in Europe.
In fact, no such study was conducted, and as the War
Department knew, American and British planes were
bombing the Auschwitz area regularly as part of the oil
war. In other words, the bombers were already there
the claim that they would have to be diverted from the
war effort was false, Stuart Erdheim, director of They
Looked Away, a documentary film about the question
of bombing Auschwitz, said. Spaatz himself was fight-
ing with Eisenhower to keep American bombers in the
Auschwitz area to target the oil factories and Spaatz
won that argument.
The irony is painful: while the Roosevelt administra-
tion was claiming it could not divert planes to go to Aus-
chwitz, the only actual diversion was when Eisenhower
diverted American planes away from Auschwitz.
Elie Wiesel, then a 16-year-old slave laborer in Aus-
chwitz, was an eyewitness to the American bombings of
the oil factories next to Auschwitz and wrote about what
he saw in his best-selling book Night.
[I]f a bomb had fallen on the blocks [the prison-
ers barracks], it alone would have claimed hundreds
of victims on the spot. But we were no longer afraid
of death; at any rate, not of that death, Wiesel wrote.
Every bomb that exploded filled us with joy and gave
us new confidence in life. The raid lasted over an hour.
If it could only have lasted ten times ten hours!
JNS.ORG
Dr. Rafael Medoff is the director of the David S. Wyman
Institute for Holocaust Studies, www.WymanInstitute.org.
His most recent book is FDR and the Holocaust: A Breach
of Faith.
Dr. Rafael
Medoff
A U.S. pilot took this aerial surveillance photo-
graph of Auschwitz in 1944.
COURTESY OF DAVID S. WYMAN INSTITUTE FOR HOLOCAUST STUDIES
Jewish World
30 JEWISH STANDARD JUNE 6, 2014
JS-30*
Pick fruit,
its fresher for
Dads and Grads.
*Offer valid at participating locations shown. Containers may vary. Restrictions may apply. See store for details. Edible Arrangements, the Fruit Basket Logo, and other marks mentioned herein are registered trademarks
of Edible Arrangements, LLC. 2014 Edible Arrangements, LLC. All rights reserved.
All-Star Dad Celebration