Gonzalez Latino Sci-Fi
Gonzalez Latino Sci-Fi
Gonzalez Latino Sci-Fi
1 3
Sleep Dealer is my first film. Its not anything like a Star Wars or a
Blade Runner. In many ways its a humble film. But its also an honest attempt to use science-fiction to say something new, and something
true, about our world today.
Alex Rivera, press kit for Sleep Dealer
What is science fiction (sci-fi), and why are there so few such works created by Latinos in the United States? While the first part of my question has already been explored in excellent detail by pioneering scholars
such as Darko Suvin, Fredric Jameson, and Brooks Landon, the second
part both taunts and tantalizes. The most direct answer suggests the
mystery surrounding the relative absence of sci-fi in Latino/a fiction.
Eric Garcias The Repossession Mambo (2009) and Junot Dazs tentatively
titled Monstro indicate that despite the significant forays into sci-fi worlds
by Latinos, their numbers remain remarkably low.
This state of Latino/a sci-fi is made all the more curious because, as
Philippe Mather has argued, the genres distinctive traits are not tied to
formal, aesthetic, or stylistic criteria but rather to thematic and contextual
factors (186). While Mather specifically explores the sci-fi film genre,
he situates his claim within the larger assertion that narrative devices and
formal aspects that authors use to construct sci-fi storyworlds are in general not inherently unique to the genre. As this observation applies to my
own exploration of Latino/a sci-fi, the implication is that the narratology
9781137366450_15_ch13.indd 211
8/29/2013 5:19:32 PM
212
CHRISTOPHER GONZLEZ
9781137366450_15_ch13.indd 212
8/29/2013 5:19:33 PM
LATINO SCI-FI
213
Figure 13.1 Luis Fernando Pea as Memo Cruz working as virtual laborer in
Sleep Dealer.
9781137366450_15_ch13.indd 213
8/29/2013 5:19:34 PM
214
CHRISTOPHER GONZLEZ
society and its culture (256). Advances and developments in technology invariably affect society at large in significant ways, as the advent of
the Internet, Facebook, Twitter, and so-called smartphones has revealed.
Idier continues:
Scenario technique is a tool for helping one to think about the consequences
of present decisions and to prepare for a changing environment. But doesnt
a serious science fiction (SF) story have the same purpose? In fact, the SF
story can go further, not only because of its environment or breadth of plot
but because an SF author is not afraid to break norms and established paradigms or cultures in order to explore human motivations and creations. In
addition, characters are used in SF stories so that readers can project themselves into the stories. Such emotional involvement is absent from scenarios.
It is certainly more difficult to control but probably more rewarding with
respect to the future of actual human organisations and societies. (259)
Idier aims to demonstrate how sci-fi stories can yield insights into future
sequences that the technique of positing certain scenarios cannot. Though
the scenario technique is used to think about how a particular situation and
its consequences may occur and how they can be handled (258), Idier sees
the value in creating a fully realized storyworld where technology advances
play out in a far richer environment than the rather sterile scenario.
I agree with Idiers argument that sci-fi stories can help us think about
and anticipate trends and trajectories of technological development as
they relate to sociopolitical environments. However, I would add that
one of the strengths of science fiction is to not only reflect how imagined societies have developed certain technologies but also how these
technologies have impacted the fictional societies in which they reside.
Moreover, audiences must necessarily draw comparisons between the
society of the sci-fi story and the social environment that serves as a basis
for comparison. Such comparisons are continuous when reading sci-fi
literature or viewing sci-fi films, thanks in large part to what MarieLaure Ryan identifies as the principle of minimal departure, which states
that audiences will assume the fictional world in question is the same as
the actual world until they have reason to believe otherwise. Because a
sci-fi world is a possible world where certain aspects generally taken for
granted must now be monitored by the audience, one of the outcomes of
reconstructing the sci-fi storyworld is its heightened level of comparison
to the actual world. This assertion is relevant to my examination of Sleep
Dealer, a film that compels its audience to go back and forth between the
sci-fi storyworld and early twenty-first-century United States.
This interaction among audience, the fictional world, and the actual
world is of particular interest, especially when we think of the immersive
9781137366450_15_ch13.indd 214
8/29/2013 5:19:34 PM
LATINO SCI-FI
215
9781137366450_15_ch13.indd 215
8/29/2013 5:19:35 PM
216
CHRISTOPHER GONZLEZ
them are Hollywood blockbusters made with the biggest of budgets, while
nations with very rich cinematic histories, such as France and Italy, have
made comparatively few contributions to the genre. There is, however, a
not-insignificant corpus of sf cinema produced in Latin America. These
films have mostly been ignored by critics and academics, both nationally
and internationally, and only in the past few years have they begun to show
signs of being rediscovered. (81)
Like Latin American sci-fi writings, Latin American sci-fi cinema is also
undergoing the process of recovery and reconsideration.
My point here is to emphasize, or rather dispel the notion that Latino
authors and filmmakers do not see sci-fi as an interesting and useful mode
of storytelling. As Latinos continue to grow as a subset of the US population, and as more and more Latinos signal a more divergent appetite for
popular culture, there can only be an increased production of Latino sci-fi
works of fiction and films in the United States. Filmmakers such as Rivera
and Robert Rodriguez, and even Mexican director Guillermo del Toro,
have helped carve out a space for Latinos in the cinematic sci-fi landscape.
To be sure, Latino literature and film, by and large, also concentrate
on societal concerns as they impact and relate to the Latino community. Indeed, Latino literature seeks to document or represent the Latino
experience in the United States by telling barrio bildungsroman, so much
so that such narratives have become heavy-handed tropes. That is why I
find the dearth of storytelling that unites issues of Latinidad and sci-fi so
striking; the two are overwhelmingly complementary. This lack of Latino
sci-fi narratives is steadily being addressed, as Samuel Saldivars essay on
the short-lived television show The Event and also Caprica in this volume indicates. As a welcomed addition to the corpus of Latino/a sci-fi,
Riveras Sleep Dealer effectively brings together the often-technologically
deprived environs of the barrio with the high-tech world of drone warfare and virtual experience.
Rivera, a New York-based director, received positive recognition for
Sleep Dealer s premiere at the Sundance Festival in 2008. His short but
impressive body of films shows that Rivera has often sought to unite
cutting-edge and near-future technology with issues of concern to the
Latino community. Papapap (1995) and Why Cyberbraceros? (1997) are
short works that both graft virtual technologies onto matters of immigration and labor. Ostensibly, these works led to the fruition of Sleep
Dealer. As an independent filmmaker with limited resources with which
to build the mega-dollar special effects that most audiences have come to
expect from Hollywood blockbusters, Rivera must rely on the ingenuity
of his creativity to design a rich, immersive storyworld for his audience.
9781137366450_15_ch13.indd 216
8/29/2013 5:19:35 PM
LATINO SCI-FI
217
In short, Sleep Dealer rises above its budgetary constraints, in large measure because of Riveras design and what Frederick Luis Aldama terms
will to stylea commitment to willfully designing narrative worlds
that seek to move audiences while eschewing simplistic conventions of
storytelling (13840).
9781137366450_15_ch13.indd 217
8/29/2013 5:19:36 PM
218
CHRISTOPHER GONZLEZ
9781137366450_15_ch13.indd 218
8/29/2013 5:19:36 PM
LATINO SCI-FI
219
9781137366450_15_ch13.indd 219
8/29/2013 5:19:36 PM
220
CHRISTOPHER GONZLEZ
strenuous and pays so little. The migrant workers who perform such difficult labor in the United States do not have benefits or health insurance,
nor do they enjoy the otherwise-standard hiring and firing practices. As
Angela C. Stuesse explains:
For migrants seeking employment, the passage of IRCA made it illegal to
be hired without papers, bolstering ever-growing black markets in the
realms of document falsification, identity theft, and under-the-table third
party labor contracting. Undocumented migrants in the United States
are more vulnerable today than ever before: paying hundreds of dollars
for jobs, promotions, and sick leave so that management will continue
choosing to look the other way; enduring low wages and poor working
conditions due to the uncertainty of being hired elsewhere; and suffering
crippling workplace injuries without adequate medical care or compensation because employers refuse to report the injuries to appropriate agencies
and their insurance carriers, just to name a few. (27)
Such workers do not have paid time off or vacation days. They are often
paid in cash while they move from state to state as the crops dictate. The
United States, as a result, is in the untenable position of decrying the
influx of undocumented workers while exploiting them strictly for their
ability to perform hard labor. Rivera pounces on this fact in order to create a storyworld in which technology has enabled the United States to
make full use of a Mexicans capacity to do work while using the same
technology to keep those workers bodies off of US soil. As all good
sci-fi demonstrates, the advanced technology depicted is not of central
concern to the story; it is the consequences of such technology on our
humanity that should make audiences sit up and take notice.
As I have argued elsewhere, one of the dangers of exploitative labor
practicesparticularly as they affect undocumented workersis that they
may inculcate the acceptance of the dehumanization of unskilled laborers
(Resisting). Of course, labor unions have helped ameliorate this deplorable situation in the United States, and Csar Chavez is celebrated for
his efforts in unionizing the farm workers of the United States in the
1960s and 1970s. But, in the ever-escalating debate on illegal immigration, increased deportations under the Obama Administration, and passage of anti-illegal immigration laws in states such as Alabamas HB 56
and Arizonas SB 1070, undocumented workers shrink into unobtrusive
silence as a result. There is a tacit agreement that is ongoing in the United
States regarding its undocumented workers that suggests the United
States wants, and arguably needs the labor of these workers but does not
wish to acknowledge the workers humanity. Many in the United States
desire machines that do not require legal status, living wages, or human
9781137366450_15_ch13.indd 220
8/29/2013 5:19:37 PM
LATINO SCI-FI
221
9781137366450_15_ch13.indd 221
8/29/2013 5:19:37 PM
222
CHRISTOPHER GONZLEZ
is to try to help his co-worker, but the shift supervisor quickly whisks
the fallen worker out of the area and out of sight. Rivera reinforces in
his audience the idea that the sleep dealers are expendable. That is to say,
their bodies are expendable. Once a workers body can no longer expend
the energy to power and control the remote machines, they are promptly
dispatched. Memo comes to understand that, like the river that once provided life and sustenance to Santa Ana Del Rio before it was harnessed by
the United States, his own body is being sapped of its energy in order to
feed the appetites of the nation to his north. In short, his corporeal self
and its kinetic potential is just another national export.
Rivera poses an interesting proposition in his film that comes in the
form of a sci-fi technology: the nodal interface. The promise of economic gain is one benefit to having the nodes, but the nodes are not
easily attained. In Sleep Dealer, the nodes function similarly to the typical
trope of border crossing that is often seen in narratives that depict the
USMexico border. In these traditional border narratives, as in the actual
world, those who wish to make the dangerous crossing often enlist the
aid of the often-dubious coyotes individuals who generally exploit and
violate the vulnerable border crossers. Similarly, those who are able to
provide people like Memo with nodes are labeled coyoteks. Once the nodes
are attained, people may use them as a delivery system not only for drugs
and alcohol, but also for monetary gain. Luz, Memos love interest in the
film, not only performs the procedure that gives Memo his nodes but also
betrays him by selling the memories of her experiences with him.
While Memo feels used by Luzs sale of their shared experiences, the
audience sees this as yet another manifestation of the dehumanizing
potential inherent in the nodal technology. Memos very existence, like
the reality television show mentioned earlier, can be purchased as a form
of entertainment by people nations away. Consistently throughout Sleep
Dealer, Memo is exposed to situations that erode at the edifice of his
humanity. And, as Ramirez is the impetus that begins Memos steady
loss of humanity, and vice versa, Rivera inevitably has the two characters
join forces in the final third of the film. Indeed, Memo and Rivera are
like two sides of the same coin: They are both devoted Latino sons, they
are both dutiful and hardworking, yet they reside on opposite sides of
the border. And while their small victory restores the flow of the river to
Santa Ana Del Rio, Rivera resists a neat ending. The nodal technology
that enabled many of the problems introduced in the film still exist by
its close, and there is no indication that Memo will do anything but continue his work as a sleep dealer. Ramirez, traitor to the US fight against
aqua-terrorism, must continue south, moving ever farther away from the
family he left behind.
9781137366450_15_ch13.indd 222
8/29/2013 5:19:37 PM
LATINO SCI-FI
223
9781137366450_15_ch13.indd 223
8/29/2013 5:19:38 PM