Comparison of A New, Minimally Invasive Strabismus Surgery Technique With The Usual Limbal Approach For Rectus Muscle Recession and Plication
Comparison of A New, Minimally Invasive Strabismus Surgery Technique With The Usual Limbal Approach For Rectus Muscle Recession and Plication
Comparison of A New, Minimally Invasive Strabismus Surgery Technique With The Usual Limbal Approach For Rectus Muscle Recession and Plication
SURGICAL TECHNIQUES
........................
Correspondence to:
Dr D S Mojon, Department
of Strabismology and
Neuro-Ophthalmology,
Kantonsspital, 9007 St
Gallen, Switzerland;
daniel.mojon@kssg.ch
Accepted 2 October 2006
........................
Aim: To present a novel, minimally invasive strabismus surgery (MISS) technique for rectus muscle operations.
Methods: In this prospective study with a non-concurrent, retrospective comparison group, the first 20
consecutive patients treated with MISS were matched by age, diagnosis and muscles operated on, with 20
patients with a limbal opening operated on by the same surgeon at Kantonsspital, St Gallen, Switzerland. A
total of 39 muscles were operated on. MISS is performed by applying two small radial cuts along the superior
and inferior muscle margin. After muscle separation from surrounding tissue, a recession or plication is
performed through the resulting tunnel. Alignment, binocular single vision, variations in vision, refraction,
and number and types of complications during the first 6 postoperative months were registered.
Results: Visual acuity decreased at postoperative day 1 in both groups. The decrease was less pronounced in
the group operated on with MISS (difference of decrease 0.14 logMAR, p,0.001). An abnormal lid swelling
at day 1 was more frequent in the control group (21%, 95% confidence interval (CI) 9% to 41%, 5/24 v 0%,
95% CI 0 to 13%, 0/25, p,0.05). No significant difference was found for final alignment, binocular single
vision, other visual acuities, refractive changes or complications (allergic reactions, dellen formation,
abnormal conjuctival findings). A conversion to a limbal opening was necessary in 5% (95% CI 2% to 17%, 2/
39) of muscles.
Conclusions: This study shows that this new, small-incision, minimal dissection technique is feasible. The MISS
technique seems to be superior in the direct postoperative period as better visual acuities and less lid swelling
were observed. Long-term results did not differ in the two groups.
PATIENTS
This study presents the results of the first 20 consecutive
patients operated on with the MISS technique at Kantonsspital,
St Gallen, Switzerland The investigation followed the tenets of
the Declaration of Helsinki. The president of the Ethical
Committee of Kanton, St Gallen, has approved the use of this
new technique.
Abbreviation: MISS, minimally invasive strabismus surgery
77
Figure 1 Schematic representation of the most important types of conjunctival openings reported in the literature. The eye is represented as seen by the
surgeon (upper eyelid is inferior). (A) Classical limbal approach with two radial cuts. (B) Variation of (A), with only one radial cut. (C) Conjunctival incision
parallel to the limbus close to the fornix. (D) Lower fornix incision. (E) Radial incision covered by the upper lid. (F) Paralimbal approach with an opening
placed halfway between the limbus and the muscle insertion.
Matching was performed in a masked manner without knowledge of surgical outcome. Two patients could not be matched
for all three criteria. One 51-year-old patient with large
exotropia with bilateral lateral rectus recession and unilateral
medial rectus plication was matched with another 26-year-old
patient with the same diagnosis and same operated muscles.
One 3-year-old patient with a large congenital esotropia with
bilateral medial rectus recession and unilateral lateral rectus
plication was matched for diagnosis and age. However, only
one patient with unilateral medial rectus recession and lateral
rectus plication could be found. This is the reason for the
different amount of eyes in the two groups. In the control
group, ages ranged from 4.6 to 75.4 years (mean (SD) 24.4
(20.5) years). Follow-up was identical to that described for the
MISS group. All study patients were re-examined at our
department 6 months later.
Outcome measures
Final alignment, binocular single vision, variations in vision,
refraction, and number and types of complications and
retreatments required during the first 6 months after surgery
were the outcome measures.
METHODS
Surgical technique for MISS
The whole surgical procedure is performed under the operating
microscope under general anaesthesia. All surgical steps can be
performed by oneself, so there is no need for an assistant. First,
a limbal traction suture (Silkam 6-0 or Safil 6-0, B Braun
Medical, Seesatz, Switzerland) is applied to rotate the eyeball
www.bjophthalmol.com
78
Mojon
Figure 2 Schematic representation of the new minimally invasive strabismus surgery technique. The eye is represented as seen by the surgeon (upper eyelid
is inferior). (A) Two small cuts are placed at the upper and lower borders of the muscle insertion. (B) The muscle insertion is dissected from surrounding tissue.
(C) The tendon is hooked. (DF) Muscle recession. (D) Two sutures are placed through the upper and lower parts of the muscle insertion. (E) The muscle is
disinserted. (F) The muscle is reattached after recession. (GI) Muscle plication. (G) Two sutures are placed at the upper and lower borders of the muscle at
the distance from the tendon insertion site corresponding to the plication amount. (H) Application of the iris spatula. (I) Plication. (J) Closure of both openings.
(K, L) Procedures if larger openings become necessary. (K) Anterior prolongation of both cuts. (L) Anterior prolongation and joining by a limbal cut.
www.bjophthalmol.com
79
away from the field of surgery (fig 2A). During surgery, a direct
contact of the traction suture with the cornea has to be avoided.
Then, two small radial cuts are performed, one along the
superior and the other along the inferior muscle margin
(fig 2A). The anterior margin of the cut is at the level of the
tendon insertion. The size of the cuts will depend on the
amount of muscle displacement that has to be achieved. As a
rule of the thumb, the opening size will be 1 mm less than the
amount of muscle displacement which has to be achieved. For
example, a recession or plication of 4 mm can be performed
through two 3-mm openings. Usually, for sizes .5 mm, an
opening of 2 mm less than the amount is sufficient. In patients
with reduced elasticity of the conjunctival tissue, slightly larger
openings will be necessary. With blunt Wescott scissors using
the two cuts for access, the episcleral tissue is separated from
the muscle sheath and the sclera (fig 2B). When the borders of
the muscles have been identified, the muscle is hooked. Then, a
meticulous dissection of the check ligaments and intramuscular
membrane is performed (fig 2C). This dissection is performed
67 mm backward to the insertion. The resulting tunnel allows
a recession or plication to be easily performed. We performed
plications however, the tunnel also allows resections. To
perform a recession, two sutures (Vicryl 7-0, Ethicon,
Spreintenbach, Switzerland) are applied to the superior and
inferior borders of the muscle tendon as close as possible to the
insertion (fig 1D). Then, the tendon is detached using a Wescott
scissor (fig 1E). If necessary, haemostasis is performed. After
measurement of the amount of recession, the tendon is
reattached with the two sutures to the sclera (fig 2F). The
tendon has to be stretched to avoid the middle part of the
muscle bowing backwards. To perform a plication, two sutures
80
Mojon
RESULTS
Table 1 shows the preoperative characteristics of patients
operated on with MISS and controls.
No statistical difference was found between the groups for
sex, age and number of muscles previously operated on. In two
of 39 (5%) muscles, conversion from a minimal opening to a
normal conjunctival opening was necessary to stop bleeding. In
both cases there was a cause for excessive bleeding. In one,
muscle scarring from previous surgery was unexpectedly
extensive. The other patient had a previously unknown
intake of acetyl-salicylic acid. Both patients did not develop
complications during follow-up. Table 2 summarises types of
strabismus of the patients operated on with the MISS
techniques and the controls.
Frequencies are identical for patients operated on with MISS
and controls as patients were matched for diagnosis. Table 3
shows the postoperative results of both groups.
The amount of surgery was similar in both groups. Visual
acuities decreased in both groups at day 1 after surgery. The
decrease was much less pronounced in the MISS group
(difference of decrease between groups 0.14 logMAR,
p,0.001). All other visual acuity comparisons (day 1 and
month 6) did not show significant differences. At month 6,
binocular vision was also similar in both groups, with an
increase for both groups after surgery. Only slight and similar
refractive changes were observed after month 6 in both groups
(for all eyes (0.5 dioptres (dpt) of spherical equivalent
respective astigmatism change). Proportions of successful final
alignment at month 6 were similar in both groups for both
criteria used. 65% (13/20) of patients operated on with MISS
and 60% (12/20) of controls had an alignment (10 prism
Eyes
Recessed muscles
Plicated muscles
Sex
Age (years)
Previously operated muscles
MISS, 20 patients
Controls, 20 patients
p Value
25
21
18
11/20 (55%)
27.1 (20.9)
2/39 (5%)
24
20
18
10/20 (50%)
24.4 (20.5)
2/39 (5%)
.0.1
.0.05*
.0.1
www.bjophthalmol.com
81
4/20
5/20
2/20
3/20
Exodeviations:
Primary exotropias
Exotropic microstrabismus
Essential infantile esotropia*
4/20 (20)
1/20 (5)
1/20 (5)
(20)
(25)
(10)
(15)
(n = 20).
*At time of surgery consecutive exotropia
DISCUSSION
Minimally invasive surgery is becoming important in almost
every facet of surgery, including eye surgery. Instrument
miniaturisation, endoillumination and optical improvements
have changed and will continue to influence the way in which
surgery is performed. In this study, the results of 39 horizontal
rectus muscles operated on with a novel MISS technique in 20
patients have been presented. Squint surgery is performed
through two small radial cuts along the superior and inferior
muscle margin (fig 2). Postoperatively, these openings remain
covered by the lids apart from during upgaze and excessive
lateral gaze, which minimises visibility of the surgical procedure during the immediate postoperative period. If a better
visibility of the operative site is needed, this type of cut can be
prolonged anteriorly (fig 2K) or even joined with a limbal cut
(fig 2L). In this patient series, this was necessary for two
operated muscles. Conversion was not associated with an
adverse postoperative course. The whole surgical procedure can
be performed with the same instruments used for standard,
limbal approach. There is no need for an assistant. Despite a
restricted conjunctival opening, the MISS technique allowed
adequate muscle exposure to perform displacements, minimising anatomical disruption. As a rule of the thumb, the opening
size necessary to perform a recession or plication will be
12 mm less than the amount of muscle displacement. The
exact operating time has not been monitored. The time
necessary to perform an MISS recession or plication, taken
from the time of anaesthesia, was approximately the same as
for the usual, limbal approach. With more expertise, MISS
procedures might also shorten the operating time. At 2 weeks
after surgery, the eyes often looked normal or nearly normal in
primary gaze position (fig 4).
A conjunctival opening situated at a reasonable distance from
the cornea should decrease the incidence of corneal dellen
20 controls/24 eyes
5.2 (1.2) mm
6.5 (1.8) mm
5.8 (0.5) mm
6.7 (2.7) mm
0.17 (0.24)
0.23 (0.33)
0.06 (0.06)
0.16 (0.30)
0.06 (0.01)*
0.06 (0.10)
0.26 (0.15)
0.20 (0.13)
0.05 (0.07)
0.07 (0.01)*
.0.1
.0.1
.0.1
.0.1
Alignment at month 6
Near and distance (10 pdpt
Near or distance (10 pdpt
.0.1
.0.1
4/25
1/25
2/25
0/25
4/24
1/24
4/24
5/24
Amount of surgery
Recession
Plication
Logmar visual acuity
Preoperative
Postoperative at day 1
Difference between preoperative and day 1
Postoperative at month 6
Difference between preoperative and month 6
Binocular vision at month 6
Worsening
Same
Improvement
Refractive changes at month 6
(16, 7 to 35)
(4, 0 to 20)
(8, 2 to 25)
(0, 0 to 13)
p Value
.0.05
.0.1
.0.1
.0.1
,0.001
.0.1
.0.1
(17, 7 to 36)
(4, 0 to 20)
(17, 7 to 36)
(21, 9 to 41)
.0.1
.0.1
.0.1
,0.05
.0.1
www.bjophthalmol.com
82
www.bjophthalmol.com
Mojon
REFERENCES
1 Darzi A, Mackay S. Recent advances in minimal access surgery. BMJ
2002;324:314.
2 Harrell AG, Heniford BT. Minimally invasive abdominal surgery: lux et veritas
past, present, and future. Am J Surg 2005;190:23943.
3 Agapitos PJ. Cataract surgical techniques. Curr Opin Ophthalmol
1991;2:1627.
4 Shaarawy T, Flammer J. Pro: non-penetrating glaucoma surgery a fair chance.
Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol 2003;241:699702.
5 Traverso CE, De Feo F, Messas-Kaplan A, et al. Long term effect on IOP of a
stainless steel glaucoma drainage implant (Ex-PRESS) in combined surgery with
phacoemulsification. Br J Ophthalmol 2005;89:4259.
6 Lakhanpal RR, Humayun MS, de Juan E Jr, et al. Outcomes of 140 consecutive
cases of 25-gauge transconjunctival surgery for posterior segment disease.
Ophthalmology 2005;112:81724.
7 Kreissig I. View 1: minimal segmental buckling without drainage. Br J Ophthalmol
2003;87:7824.
8 Watkins LM, Janfaza P, Rubin PA. The evolution of endonasal
dacryocystorhinostomy. Surv Ophthalmol 2003;48:7384.
9 Frueh BR, Musch DC, McDonald HM. Efficacy and efficiency of a small-incision,
minimal dissection procedure versus a traditional approach for correcting
aponeurotic ptosis. Ophthalmology 2004;111:215863.
ber Muskelvorlagerung. Klin Monatsbl Augenheilk
10 Harms H. U
1949;115:31924.
11 von Noorden GK. The limbal approach to surgery of the rectus muscles. Arch
Ophthalmol 1968;80:9497.
12 Willshaw HE. Rectus muscle surgery: how to do it. Trans Ophthalmol Soc UK
1986;105:5838.
13 von Noorden GK. Modification of the limbal approach to surgery of the rectus
muscles. Arch Ophthalmol 1969;82:34950.
14 Swan KC, Talbott T. Recession under Tenons capsule. Arch Ophthalmol
1954;51:3241.
15 Parks MP. Fornix incision for horizontal rectus muscle surgery. Am J Ophthalmol
1968;65:90715.
16 Velez G. Radial incision for surgery of the horizontal rectus muscles. J Pediatr
Ophthalmol Strabismus 1980;17:1067.
17 Santiago AP, Isenberg SJ, Neumann D, et al. The paralimbal approach with
deferred conjunctival closure for adjustable strabismus surgery. Ophthalmic Surg
Lasers 1998;29:1516.
18 Taban M, Behrens A, Newcomb RL, et al. Acute endophthalmitis following
cataract surgery: a systematic review of the literature. Arch Ophthalmol
2005;123:61320.