Seem 2440A/B - Engineering Economics First Term (2011 - 2012)
Seem 2440A/B - Engineering Economics First Term (2011 - 2012)
Machine II
80,000
25,000
5
15,000
For each machine, assume a three-year MACRS (GDS) recovery property and
depreciation class (i.e. recovery period = 3 years), with an effective income tax rate
of 50% and after tax MARR of 15% per year. Based on the after-tax PW analysis,
find the alternative that should be selected.
3. Assume the base period b is at the end of year 1 (i.e. b = 1). Let Ak and Rk be the
actual dollar and real dollar at the end of year k where 1 k N respectively.
Define the PW of the actual dollar and real dollar cash flows at the end of year 1 as
follows:
N
PWA ic %1 Ak P / F , ic %, k 1 ;
k 1
PWR ir %1 Rk P / F , ir %, k 1 .
k 1
Project A
(Estimated in Actual Dollars)
$100,000
112,000
136,000
150,000
Project B
(in todays purchasing power)
$ 80,000
100,000
120,000
140,000
If the average general price inflation rate is expected to be 4% per year and the real
rate of interest is 9% per year, show which alternative has the least negative
present worth in the base period.
5. (8-40) Your company must obtain some laser measurement devices for the next six
years and is considering leasing. You have been directed to perform an actualdollar after-tax study of the leasing approach. The pertinent information for the
study is as follows:
Lease costs: First year, $80,000; second year, $60,000; third through sixth years,
$50,000 per year. Assume that a six-year contract has been offered by the lessor
that fixes these costs over the six-year period.
Other costs (not covered under contract): $4,000 in year-zero dollars, and the total
increase rate is estimated to be 10% each year.
Effective income tax rate: 40%.
a. Develop the actual-dollar ATCF for the leasing alternative.
b. If the real MARR (ir) after taxes is 5% per year and the annual inflation rate (f)
is 9.524% per year, what is the actual-dollar after-tax equivalent annual cost for
the leasing alternative?
$600,000
$200,000
$100,000
$400,000
Suppose that the facilities in both Alternatives A and B have the zero salvage value.
The useful life of both alternatives is 50 years. Using an interest rate of 5%,
determine which alternative (if either) should be selected according to the AW
version of the conventional B-C ratio method. Include DN as one of the possible
alternatives in your analysis.
7. (10-20) The city of Oak Ridge is evaluating three mutually exclusive landscaping
plans for refurbishing a public greenway. Benefits to the community have been
estimated by a landscaping committee, and the costs of planting trees and
shrubbery, as well as maintaining the greenway, are summarized below. The citys
discount rate is 8% per year, and the planning horizon is 10 years.
A
75,000
4,000
Plan
B
50,000
5,000
C
65,000
4,700
20,000
18,000
20,000
a. Assume the city also considers DN as one of the possible alternatives. Use the
PW version of the modified B-C ratio method to recommend the best plan.
b. Repeat (a) with the AW version of the conventional B-C ratio method. Which
plan is the best?
c. Should the recommendation in (a) and (b) be the same? Why or Why not?
End