Why Read Rigveda (RL Kashyap, 1999)
Why Read Rigveda (RL Kashyap, 1999)
Why Read Rigveda (RL Kashyap, 1999)
by
R. L. KASHYAP
FOREWORD
Prof. R.L. Kashyap belongs to that rare brand of scholars combining proficiency in an
engineering field with almost equal depth and erudition in Vedic studies. He is a Ph.D. from
the Harvard University in U.S.A. and is currently holding the position of Professor of
Electrical and Computer Engineering at Purdue University, Lafayette, Indiana, U.S.A. His
association with Purdue University extends over more than three decades. He is the recipient
of many International awards and honors for his fundamental contributions to pattern
recognition and computer vision. He has authored over 350 papers, a majority of them
appearing in academic journals in the field of Computer studies. He has also guided some
fifty students in their Doctoral research work.
It is extraordinary that such an eminent teacher in an engineering branch is also known
and respected for his abiding interest and insight into Vedic studies. His recent book "Rig
Veda Samhita", co-authored by Prof. S. Sadagopan has been well received in Vedic circles.
The book was published by the Sri Aurobindo Kapali Sastry Institute, of Vedic culture of
which he is the Honorary Director. He has brought out an English translation of a Sanskrit
book "Vasishta Vaibhavam", by Sri Kapali Sastry, which is a biography of his teacher
Vasishta Ganapati Muni, a great Sanskrit poet, who used to be held in high esteem by both
Sri Aurbindo and the Mother.
We were truly fortunate that such a versatile scholar delivered a public lecture under the
auspices of our Institute on 11 March, 1999 on the subject, "Why read Rig Veda?" Having
regard to the enduring relevance and value of the lecture, we are issuing it as Transaction No.
102 of the Institute. We feel confident that it will be well received and appreciated both by
Vedic Scholars and by laymen interested in the Vedas.
K.R. Ramachandran
President
13-2-2000
IIWC
BACKGROUND
Rig Veda Samhita [1] is the most ancient book of the Sanatana Dharma, popularly
known as Hinduism; Since it dates to 4000 B.C.E or earlier, it is also the most ancient of the
scriptures of all religions of humanity.
Rig Veda Samhita is a vast book delineating spiritual and psychological wisdom, the
ideals of Vedic Society and its governance, the theories of manifestation of this Universe, and
ways in which human beings can develop their artistic, physical, mental, psychological and
intellectual powers and many other topics, including Mathematics.
In this essay, we will discuss how the ideals discussed in the Rig Veda are very relevant
for the modern age. This will be done by quoting the relevant verses of Rig Veda. We will
also compare briefly the ideals of the Rig Veda with the ideals portrayed in later scriptures
such as those of Christianity and Islam.
descriptive epithets in them we see that Agni is a cosmic power who performs all the actions
as stated in RV (1.1.1.). There is no mention of human priests lighting Agni. The hymn (1.44)
explicitly states that the cosmic powers Mitra and Varuna kindle Agni, a psychological power
in the subtle body of human beings.
Regarding the Upanishads, it is interesting to note that many of the famous quotations
of Upanishads are contained in the Rig Veda. The most famous concept of Upanishads
namely ekam sat, the One Existence, is already found in RV (1.164.49). The famous verse of
Mundaka Upanishad comparing the human soul and the Divine to a pair of birds is found in
RV (1.164.45). The phrase, 'all human beings are children of immortality, amrtasya putrah',
quoted frequently by Swami Vivekananda is often ascribed to sveteshvatara upanishad [4];
But it actually occurs in RV (10.13.1). We add more information later.
The second group of critics trace the problems of modern Hindu society such as
unsociability, casteism etc., to this ancient book. This criticism has absolutely no support
from the text of the Rig Veda Samhita, as will be clarified later. Moreover, in every society
all over the globe, there is a huge gap between the ideals propounded by various religions in
these societies and the actual practices. Attacking only the scriptures of Hinduism on this
basis but keeping silent on the gap between the theory and practice in other religions in other
societies is nothing but intellectual dishonesty.
CONCEPT OF FREEDOM
Freedom is a key idea in RV; all persons whatever their external condition-men,
women, married couples, householders, wandering mendicants and so on-have a right to tread
2
the paths of immortality. RV does not impose any rigid external prerequisites. RV itself does
not debar anyone from reading or following RV. RV even allows the voice of the skeptic who
does not believe in the existence of devas. In (8.100.3), a skeptic declares "who is Indra, who
has ever seen him". The rishi gives a reasonable reply in the next verse (8.100.4) without
invoking any threat of punishment in this world or the punishment in the life after death.
Look upon me here!
All that exists I surpass in my glory;
The Truth makes me mighty'
RV has no conception of a hell into which all its critics are cast. There is no great divide
between the so called spiritual life and worldly life as in later times. According to RV, every
being, not just the human being, develops according to his/her own self-law svadha. RV does
not speak of a Cosmic Controller who controls all beings, himself staying outside of them.
Every human being has to become aware of this self-law and follow the path of immortality
unique to him/her. In this learning process, the help of the devas is ever here.
Knowledge constitutes the bulk of RV. The range of knowledge contained in it is so
vast and so different from the more traditional types of knowledge found in the books like
Puranas making it very hard to get a comprehensive view of the RV. It reminds one of the
proverbial blind person trying to generalise the physical form of an elephant touching only
one particular part of the animal like its rope-like trunk, the iron-like tusk, leaf-like ear etc. As
a first step, we can group the verses under several categories like cosmology and cosmogony,
human beings and psychology, the role of devas like Agni, evil, suffering and conflicts, every
day life, the paths of immortality and so on. in ref. [6] the verses are grouped under different
yogas like Karma, Jnana, Bhakti, Raja etc.
The keynote of knowledge in RV is its integrality. It is not divided into several rigid
compartments. The knowledge is like a vast net in which each topic is intimately connected to
every other topic. Take any verse dealing with one of the topics mentioned above. This verse
brings in many other topics also. Similarly every dominant aspect of human personality is
intimately connected to the corresponding one in the cosmos. All the realms of mental
operations in a man like thinking, intellect, meditation, concentration and so on, are
associated with the cosmic world dyu, Heaven. Therefore when a person is thinking, he is in
touch with the cosmic world of Heave, Since all human beings are in touch with the same
world, we see here a neat explanation of the phenomenon of simultaneous discoveries by
persons in different continents. Again every human action also has a cosmic dimension. In
every action we see the dominant contribution of the devas. Thus both devas and humans are
collaborators or co-creators in all activities. Eventually every human being can achieve the
perfection natural to a cosmic power, deva. This comprehensiveness of knowledge
distinguishes RV from all other spiritual books.
Verses like (1.10.2) clearly state that the knowledge is infinite like a vast mountain with
many peaks and valleys. The acquisition of knowledge by each individual is unique. No two
paths are same. As (1.10.2) describes elegantly, we cannot envision all the details in one step.
From one peak only certain details are available. We have to go to a higher peak to get more
details.
The analogy of knowledge acquisition to mountain climbing appears for the first time in
modern times, in books dealing with the theoretical Physics [14] only at the beginning of
twentieth century.
Such comprehensiveness of knowledge is possible because the Supreme Divine or God,
3
the One without a Second, pervades all existence, both living and non-living. There are many
verses describing the spiritual presence of the transcendent God as well as of the God
immanent in all existence. Both RV and the Upanishads use the same word vaishvanara, the
Universal Divine Force, to describe the immanence of God in all aspects of creation ranging
from stone to herbs to man. Again the idea of devas, the distinct powers and personalities of
the One, conscious of Truth is described both at an individual level such as Agni, Indra and
also at the collective level as All-Gods vishvedevah.
symbolism. Veda itself says there is a secret in RV. That secret must be the symbolism. A
symbol attempts to describe an experience beyond the realm of the senses. Symbols can be
either auditory or visual. For persons who have the gift, hearing a word can create an
impression in the inner being which conveys the full power of the symbol. There are four
classes of symbols in the RV. Firstly, the devas Agni, Indra and so on and the devis Sarasvati,
Sarama, Mahi represent distinct types of divine powers and associated functions. In the
second class are Vrtra, Vala, Shushna, the powers of falsehood. The third class of symbols
consists of the common nouns like go, cow, ashva, horse, adri hill, apah, waters, nadi, rivers,
vrka, wolf etc. Lastly is the class of the names associated with the sages and poets like Kanva,
Kutsa.
Each member of these four classes represents a distinct psychological power which is
helpful or otherwise. The unravelling of the symbolism behind each word was done by Sri
Aurobindo [9] and Sri Kapali Sastry [10] using their intuition. There is considerable support
for the symbolism theory in our ancient books like Shatapatha Brahmana or the Brhad
Devata. But we do not have to merely believe what they say. We can set up concrete
objective tests to determine whether the symbolic meanings suggested by them are correct or
not. For instance, take the word "go which ordinarily means cattle. It and its synonyms like
usra occur in more than one thousand verses. Of course, many of these verses may involve
other members of the four classes like adri, hill. Regard all these words in these verses as
unknown. Substitute the symbolic meanings for the unknowns and see whether the verse
makes sense. For the verses involving "go", all the verses make excellent sense except those
where go" is used as a simile in which case it is an animal. Then all the phrases which
appears enigmatic or senseless become meaningful. 'go' stands for knowledge, each
individual "go" standing for one type of knowledge, adri is the symbol for the forces of
ignorance and in conscience as can be easily guessed.
The phrase 'they smashed the hill with 'go' means the forces of ignorance were
overcome by the forces of knowledge. The phrase 'they smashed the hill with their sound
means that the forces of ignorance were destroyed by the power of Mantra, the potent word.
We give the following table the symbolic meanings of some of the members of the four
classes.
The recovery of the symbolic meanings of individual words is only the first step. The
recovery of the deeper meaning of the verses needs much more work. Once this is done, the
consistency of the meaning of all the phrases in a verse and consistency of all the verses in a
hymn is assured. The wisdom of RV comes upfront.
TABLE 1
Agni: Fire; It is the cosmic power of heat and light and the will power united with
wisdom. Human will power is a feeble projection of this power. It can be strengthened by the
RV chants to Agni.
Indra :
He is the lord of the Divine Mind and Action. In Indian tradition, mind is not a
source of knowledge, it manipulates the knowledge to aid action. Indra battles
the evil forces on behalf of the human.
Vayu :
Wind; He is the lord of all the Life-energies, Prana which represent the passions,
feelings, emotions, abilities.
Ashvins :
The lords of bliss and divine physicians who render the human body free of
5
Varuna :
HUMAN PSYCHOLOGY
Rig Veda has a wealth of knowledge about human psychology. But like everything else
in the Veda, this knowledge is intimately related to the knowledge of cosmology, devas etc.
The seers of RV viewed a human being as a symbol of the Supreme Divine. This is the
natural meaning of the famous Purusha hymn (10.90) in RV. It is a grotesque interpretation to
claim that this hymn portrays the Supreme Person as having a physical form of the human
being, the so called anthropomorphic conception of God. The word Purusha is used in the
Veda both for the Supreme Divine as well as for the human. This word literally means a
dweller in the city puri or one who pervades everything. Every human being has a complex
inner structure of which the physical body is only one aspect, the other aspects being those
beyond the pale of the senses. In modern language used by the tantriks, every human being is
endowed with several bodies which are termed as subtle to distinguish them from the gross
physical body. The subtle body is indicated by the word sadana, sadma, yoni, etc., in many
verses. Each body is associated with a distinct psychological principle. There is an intimate
connection between the subtle bodies associated with a human being and the various worlds
of the cosmos of Rig Veda. Thus a key idea of the RV is that each human being's structure
mirrors that of the cosmos. This connection between the individual human and the cosmos
also affirms the connection between the corresponding bodies of all the different human
beings. For Instance, the individual human minds are in touch with one another. This feature
explains many of the well known facts such as thought-reading i.e., the reading of one
persons thought by another, the possibility of simultaneous discoveries in the scientific arena
and so on.
As mentioned earlier, the structure of human being replicates that of the macrocosm.
Each person has several different sheaths or bodies, one corresponding to each principle of
consciousness mentioned above. The same names are used for the sheaths also. However, in
most humans only the outer three sheaths associated with the worlds of earth antariksha and
dyau have developed; the fourth sheath termed as Mahas in Upanishads is not developed in
most humans.
The outermost sheath is the of matter, derived from the world of matter. Next s/he has
the sheath of life-energy which deals with ambitions, emotions, higher levels, feelings both
noble and petty, goals, urge to dominate, drives, desires to possess, anger, urge for
progression, the power of love, faith, sincerity, humility, aspirations, equality, peace,
generosity, goodness, emotion, passion, love. The mental sheath deals with our thoughts,
understanding, control of senses, intelligence, reason, intuition, ability to make decisions and
implement them, control of the organs of actions like speech, hand, legs etc., and the powers
of meditation, contemplation, concentration. Typically in an advanced person the sheath of
prana or the vital should be under the control of the mind. Often it is the reverse, the vital
overpowers the mental and orders the powers of reasoning to come up with reason for doing
6
the action, which may have no support of our secret inner being.
So when a human is reasoning, he is communing with mental world. When s/he is
involved with emotions like love and the powers of the higher vital s/he is communing with
the vital world, antariksha. Those, who are dubbed intellectual, commune mainly with the
vital and mental worlds.
In an ordinary human being, martya or marta, these different bodies are still in a
nascent state. All the associated energies are blocked as it were and the symbolic doors of the
respective rooms are closed or almost closed. When the doors are, at least, slightly open, a
person, while thinking, will be in touch with the world of dyau, while dealing with life
energies is in touch with the mid-world etc.
The key difference between the human being and the Divine is that the cosmic worlds
associated with the Divine are perfect. There is a sheath in human being corresponding to
every world. But these are in a process of evolution at different stages of development. This is
the reason for the distinctness of each human being. Each human being is at a different stage
of development. The rishis of RV reached a sufficiently high stage of development in all the
four sheaths. In most human beings even the third or mental sheath is not well developed,
leave alone the fourth sheath. All the psychological problems faced by the humans are
derived from the fact that these sheaths are not fully developed.
The Veda distinguishes between the ordinary mortal marta or martya and the wise
person vipra, rishi or kavi, one who has the vision of entities beyond the range of senses. It
tells how one can attain these states of consciousness and other states of mind.
The progress achieved in the humans is indicated in several verses. For illustration,
consider the action of rbhus, the divine artisans who prepare the subtle bodies of the human
beings. One of their actions is indicated by the enigmatic phrase 'They make four bowls out of
the one'. Sri Aurobindo explains the symbolism I In an ordinary human being, our physical,
vital and mental aspects are all mixed up. Each aspects wants to act independent of the other.
The physical body has its needs, the vital body forces its desires and ambitions on both the
physical body and mental body to the harm of the latter. The devas, rbhus isolate the warring
factions and restore order. Thus they form the physical body, vital body, mental body and the
body of light from the amorphous single one, the single bowl.
VEDA AND THE UPANISHADS
The Upanishads have always been regarded in India as the crown of the Veda. We will
briefly explore the relationship between the Upanishads and the Rig Veda Samhita. Contrary
to the claims made in [11] and elsewhere, several statements in the ancient Upanishads like
Chandogya can be traced to Veda Samhitas.
The cryptic symbolism used in Rig Veda prevented the deep knowledge of Veda
Samhitas from becoming widespread and the age of Rig Veda come to an end. Much later,
perhaps a millennia or so, attempts were made to recover the knowledge of the Vedas. The
Brahmana books like the Shaptapatha focussed mainly on the rituals whereas the Upanishads
attempted to recover the spiritual knowledge. As Sri Aurobindo states: "The rishis of the
Upanishads sought to recover the lost or waning knowledge of the Veda by meditation and
spiritual experience and they used the text of the ancient Mantras as a prop and authority for
their own intuitions and perception or else the Vedic word was a seed of thought and vision
by which they recovered old truths in new forms. What they found, they expressed in other
terms more intelligible to the age in which they lived". As examples of the first method, we
7
The implication is that the journey of life is mainly psychological, each person has to find a
path which is suitable for him or her. For instance (6.9.2) uses the analogy of a loom which
weaves cloth :
I know not the woof, I know not the warp, nor what is this web,
That they weave moving to and fro in the field of their Motion and labour (6.9.2).
Then (6.9.3) declares :
The deva Agni knows the warp, knows the woof,
He tells in their tune the things that must be spoken. (6.9.3) Again the deva guides the
human being from within. There are many references, one of which is (6.9.5).
An immortal Light set inward for seeing,
A swiftest mind within men that walk on the way (6.9.5).
The entire nature seems to commune with the rishi in (6.9.6).
'My ears range wide to hear and my wide eyes to see,
Wide this Light set in the heart; wide walks my mind..' (6.9.6).
This journey is described as a yajna, not a mere rite but a collaborative effort
companioned by the devas. It is also described as a battle against the supraphysical hostile
forces Vrtras and dasyus who want to oppose the journey towards the truth. The devas secure
the victory in these supraphysical battles on behalf of the humans. Again the journey is
described in numerous places as a ship in an ocean (1.99.1) taking the person to the shores of
knowledge. Another hymn (1.10.2) describes the journey as going from one peak of mountain
to another higher peak. Only at each peak does the person know what to do next. Whenever
any help is needed, the devas arrive and offer the help.
One of the striking features of the ideal of Vedic life is that there is no exhortation to
give up desire. All later Hindu and Buddhist scriptures from the Upanishads to the Gita
regard the overcoming of the desire as the first step in spiritualizing life. This feature together
with the mistranslation of some of the prayers of Vedic rishis as asking for cows and horses
have made many, both in India and in the West, to regard the RV as devoid of the higher
aspects' of spiritual life. This is a fundamental mistake.
Veda pursues the strategy espoused in the later yoga of devotion, bhakti yoga. It calls upon
the seeker to establish an intimate relationship with each deva, Agni, Indra and others, like
son, friend, father, mother etc. When the faith develops in these devas, then this faith gives
the certitude to the seeker that the devas will give whatever is needed. Then the hankering
after desires disappears. The perfect person is called in RV as a person whose desires have
been satisfied Aptakama, the same phrase being used in the Brhadaranyaka Upanishad [12].
It is interesting to observe that in RV there is no condemnation of the persons who are
skeptical of the existence of devas (8.100.3). There are many references to poets saying that
they recite the Vedas, still they are still plagued by a variety of troubles. RV has no
conception of hell. Here there is no question of the unbelievers of skeptics being thrust to hell
after their death.
ADITI AND INFINITY
She is the Goddess of infinity as the following verse unambiguously declares:
Aditi is Heaven, Aditi is mid-region,
9
10
REFERENCES
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
Kashyap, R.L. and Sadagopan. S. (editors), Rig Veda Samhitha, Sri Aurobindo Kapali
Sastry Institute of Vedic Culture, Bangalore, 1998.
Radhakrishnan, S., Indian Philosophy, Oxford University Press, 1946.
Zaehner, R.C., Hindu Scriptures Rupa paper back, 1992.
Sveteshvatara Upanishad, Sri R.K. Math, Madras.
Leela S.R., Glory of Vasishta Ganapati Muni, Translation of the Sanskrit book,
Vasishta Vaibhavam, Sri Aurobindo Kapali Sastry Institute of Vedic Culture,
Bangalore, 1999.
Bose, C. Abinash, Hymns from the Vedas (compilation), Asia Publishing House,
Bombay, 1996.
Griffith R.T.H. (tr), Hymns of Rig Veda, Motilal Banarsidas, (1873) 1973.
Wilson H.H. (tr), Rig Veda Samhita, original date of Pub, 1856-1880, Nag Publishers,
1977.
Aurobindo, Sri, Secret of the Veda, Sri Aurobindo Ashram, (1956), 1972.
Kapali Sastry, Collected works (11 volumes), Vedic discussion is in volumes 1,4,5,6
and 10.
Panikkar, Raimundo, Vedic Experience (Anthology), Motilal Banarsidas, 1977.
Brhadaranyaka Upanishad, Sri R.K. Math, Madras.
Eight Upanishads, Sri R.K. Math, Belur, Calcutta.
Joos, George, Introduction to theoretical Physics, Oxford University Press, 1934.
11