Strama 2015
Strama 2015
Strama 2015
Submitted To:
Prof. Ricardo Palo
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Banco de Oro Unibank, Inc. or BDO is a universal bank in the Philippines
involved Finance and Insurance industry and provides financial services that extends not
only to personal banking, but also corporate banking. It is owned by the SM Group of
Companies one of the countrys largest conglomerates, which is in turn owned by
Henry Sy. BDO is now the largest bank in the Philippines in terms of assets, loans and
deposits. Its market niche touches the corporate market, the middle market banking
segment and the retail or consumer market.
In the conducted external analysis of BDO (4.3.1.) and its competitor analysis
(4.2.2.), it is shown that BDOs is equipped in taking effective advantage of opportunities
and minimizing threats. The analysis show that there are opportunities present for BDO
to take, such that of the rise in demand for mobile banking applications, increase in
automotive loans and the unification into a single market come the 2015 ASEAN
Economic Integration which pose as challenges that BDO should overcome. However,
there are also threats that BDO should minimize. In the internal analysis (5.8) and the
financial analysis (5.3), it was shown that BDO is in a position that is proactively
upgrading and striving to cater to its clients and providing quality services. It shows the
strengths of BDO as a business, which should be utilized more in answer to
opportunities. Meanwhile, such analysis also showed BDOs weaknesses that should be
mitigated. it was also found that BDO is in a position to aggressively take on the
challenges posed by the opportunities stated. In doing so, the objectives for BDO
formulated were to increase in net income while maintaining expense, increase in
market share, increase in presence in rural areas and to invest more in technology. In
order to achieve such, based on the strategy formulation matrices (6.1. to 6.7.), it was
recommended for BDO to pursue intensive strategies which are that of product
development and market penetration and also horizontal integration.
I. INTRODUCTION
1. Nature of Business
Banco de Oro Unibank, Inc. or BDO is a universal bank that is involved in
providing financials services to individuals and corporate markets and specializes in
lending, deposit-taking, Foreign, Exchange, brokering, trust and investments, credit
cards, corporate cash management and remittances in the Philippines. BDO belongs to
the SM Group of Companies, one of the country's largest conglomerates, with
businesses spanning between retail, mall operations, property development, and
financial services owned by tycoon Henry Sy.
BDO provides services for both individuals and corporations. As for individuals or
also called as personal banking, it offers eBanking; with services such as phone
banking, ATM banking, online banking and mobile banking, trust and investments,
account management, credit card management, loans, remittances and insurance. BDO
also offers services to corporations such as cash management services, trade facilities,
investment banking, treasury, foreign exchange, investment advisory services,
insurance, leasing and financing, trust and investments and corporate credit card
management.
2. BDOs History
BDO had its beginnings on January 2, 1968 as it started as a thrift bank having
the name Acme Savings Bank while having only two branches in Metro Manila. In
November of 1976, Acme was acquired by Henry Sy and was renamed as Banco de Oro
Savings and Mortgage Bank.
In December of 1994, Banco de Oro became a Commercial Bank, and to portray
its new status as a bank, it was renamed Banco de Oro Commercial Bank, and in
September of 1996, BDO became a universal bank, which made BDO to change its
name to its current, Banco de Oro Universal Bank.
BDO is one of the banks owned by a Chinese-Filipino in the Philippines.
Examples of other include Metrobank and Chinabank. In order to remain competitive and
strengthen itself through vision, innovation and value, in 1997, BDO became involved in
insurance services by establishing a subsidiary called BDO Insurance Broker, thus
making it a, bancassurance firm.
In 1999, it expanded its insurance through partnership with Assicurazoni Generali
S.P.A., one of the worlds largest insurance firms, and Jerneh Asia Berhad, a member of
the Kuok Group in Malaysia. In March 2000, BDO partnered up with its insurance
affiliates, Generali Pilipinas Life Assurance Company and Generali Pilipinas Insurance
Company.
On June 15, 2001, BDO merged with Dao Heng Banks Philippine subsidiary.
The merger increased the number of BDOs branches from 108 branches prior to the
merger to 120 after the merger. BDOs expansion through its increasing number of
branches had become one of BDOs competitive advantages, and as it reached out to its
increasing number of depositors. The bank further expanded in April 2005, United
Overseas Bank sold 66 out of 67 of its Philippine subsidiarys branches to BDO, and as
it set to rationalize its operation from retail to wholesale banking, BDO, on March 22,
2006, after all United Overseas Bank completed its integration into BDO network, it
increased the number of its BDO branches to 220.
On August 5, 2005, BDO and SM investments, bought 24.76% of the shares of
Equitable PCI bank, the Philippines third-largest bank, and 10% of an Equitable PCI
affiliate, Equitable Card Network, one of the Philippines largest credit card issuers, from
the Go Family. On December 27, 2006 both Banco de Oro Universal Bank and Equitable
bank had agreed to merge, thus making the Banco de Oro-Equitable PCI bank. As of
February 2007, it became known as Banco de Oro Unibank, Inc.
As of March 31, 2014, BDO is the countrys largest bank in terms of total
resources, capital, customer loans, total deposits, and assets under management and
has about 23,600 employees. In December 2014, BDO had acquired Mindanaos largest
rural bank.
II.
In order to accomplish this paper the data requirements include that of financial
statements, operational highlights, financial projections and recent surveys. Industry
studies, trends, economic conditions are also required regarding the industry analysis.
To achieve the comparison between the subject company and its competitors,
information and background regarding top competitors are sought. Lastly, to complete
the paper, internal information on BDO is also gathered.
Sources are gathered mostly from BDOs website and annual reports.
Correspondence through phone calls and emails with BDO representatives were also
used. Other secondary sources were also gathered from the National Statistics
Coordination Board, National Statistics Office, National Economic Development
Authority, World Bank, Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas websites.
The financials for the years 2014 to 2016 are merely projected and should not be
taken as actual statements of BDO. Although this paper is submitted in 2015, it was
written in 2014, thus the study was based on 2013 information. It is also assumed that,
for financial projections, the tax treatment were the same and that there were no
dividend payments during the years projected. There are no direct citations found
throughout the paper for consistency purposes in the format. However, all the references
used are found in the bibliography. This is so as not to constitute as plagiarism.
It should be noted further this paper is limited only Banco de Oro Unibank, Inc.
who operates in the Philippines, however it must be said that there are BDO branches
abroad. The paper is focused mainly on industries serving in the financial and insurance
sector and that the study is for studying the performance of the company and its
strategic position.
COMPONENTS
1. Customers
PRESENC
E
Yes
SPECIFIC STATEMENT
In the phrase in every market we serve
implies that BDOs pool of customers is
large and diverse seeing as that it uses
Yes
With
the
statement
consistently
as
with
the
advancement
of
Yes
is evidently clear
that
BDO
has
No
Yes
profits
but
also
with
6. Philosophy
Yes
ownership
show
that
BDO
is
Yes
Yes
corporate
sustainability
For
Yes
of
its
accomplishments
and
milestones.
As to the general public and its customers, as well as potential investors, local or
foreign, BDOs employees must show the embodiment of these statements. They may
show success stories of BDO personnel in application of their mission and vision
statements. This is aside from the common practice of posting its mission and vision
statements in ATM screens and bank branches. Generally, it needs to consistent in the
companys behavior, statements and actions, and must bridge that gap between
employees to employees, employees to top management, the corporation to its
customer and collectively support the vision mission to the reality.
According to Republic Act No. 8791 or the General Banking Law of 2000,
in its Declaration of Policy, it recognizes the fiduciary nature of banking that requires the
highest standards of integrity and performance. This is why it is upon the State to
promote and maintain a stable and efficient banking and financial system by creating
and upholding laws not only intended for the supervision of banking and financial
institutions but also for the protection and benefit of the clients of such banks and
financial institutions.
The banking industry is an industry that is imbued with public interest that
requires itself to be regulated by the government. Mainly, the General Banking Act of
2000 governs all banking institutions through the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas and its
Monetary Board. It is imposed in the Monetary Board, the governance, supervision,
authority over such banking and financial institutions as well as to provide policy
direction. Aside from BSP Circulars, the banking industry is protected by the Philippine
Deposit Insurance Corporation. Being an industry generally involved with money,
capitalization requirements are specific and must strictly be followed. As well as
managerial requirements especially for universal and commercial banks.
4.1.2. Economic Developments
In 2013, the Philippines had earned roughly P11,546,104,000,000 as its
Gross Domestic Product according to National Statistics Coordination Board. From the
year 2000, the countrys GDP continually increases. It is in 2013 that the Philippine
Economy expanded by 7.2%. There were boosts in several sectors, especially in the
service sector. However, there were also slow downs in certain sectors such as imports
and construction. Also contributing to these slow downs are the impact of typhoons that
hit the country, which may have reduced the GDP growth.
challenges, such a rapid population growth, ethnic, religious and poverty problems. The
Philippines, being under the rule of Western powers for centuries, has left a mark which
had become a part of the Filipino identity. Over the years, the country had been witness
to many cultural and lifestyle trends that have influenced the banking industry.
The Philippines has a dense population but with an uneven distribution. It
has an estimated population of 101,112,799 Million and fifty percent of which is urban,
especially in Metro Manila, which has the highest density. For the last quarter of 2014, it
was recorded that the Philippines had a 6% unemployment rate, making the employment
rate at 94%. With, the large percentage of Filipinos who are employed, this contribute to
the growth of the banking industry. Their profit indicates the ability to engaged in banking
and financial activities.
Lifestyle and business trends affect the banking industry. Aside from
young adults to the elderly, banking trends for the young have been prevalent recently.
Junior savings accounts, jumpstart accounts and other savings plan for children. Also,
an increase in the number of universities and colleges partner up with banks in the
collection process of tuition fees.
4.1.4. Technological Developments
The banking industry is not easily swayed by technological trends,
however, when such a trend does, it leaves a huge impact. Banks are developing new
branch formats that consist of sturdier alternatives to the traditional bank branch.
Banking customers also now handle their banking transactions via smartphones and
tablets than through other channels. This makes the mobile banking channel a key
element in earning customer loyalty. Mobile banking is coupled with transactions with
other banking channels so as to deliver seamless service. There was a reported rise in
the use of a banks mobile banking application by 19% in the previous year. Despite the
large patronage of mobile banking, there is still a decline in the usage of bank branches,
ATMs and even online banking.
However, there is an increase in omnichannel consumers. Omnichannel
means accessing with more than one banking channels. Despite mobile banking rising
to mass appeal, clients still prefer combining digital and physical channels in banking.
Bain and Company, Inc. sees that this is critical for effective service, marketing and
selling, because customers expect to be able to hop from one channel to another. Said
company also provided that banks that pull ahead in loyalty by investing heavily in
mobile to better experience will reap financial benefits. While banks that lag investing in
such advantage will miss reaping the financial benefits as well as fall behind in
investment.
Behind this advantage, however, comes a small problem: hidden
defection. These small hidden defects that result to lesser customer satisfaction which
may result to bank switching. Banks that fail to respond against these defects risk profits.
Aside from defection, which is an entirely internal concern, there also exist a threat of
security breaches and attacks. Several causes of which is the crumbling personal
relationships between managers and customers and a reputation for security, also the
increase of digital assets in the banking and financial institutions.
4.2. Industry and Competitor Analysis
4.2.1. Porters Five Forces Model
PORTERS FIVE FORCES MODEL
Rivalry among competitors
High
Threat of substitutes
Medium
Threat of new entrants
Low
Low
Medium
their services. Moreover, the governments regulation also hinders banking in constantly
changing and updating their services without compliance with the requirements.
BDO
BPI
COMPETITORS
METROBANK
Critical Success
Weighted Rate
WS
Rate
WS
Rate
WS
Factors
Financial Position
.30
4
1.20 4
1.20
4
1.20
Customer Loyalty
.12
3
.36
3
.36
3
.36
Customer Service
.22
4
.88
4
.88
3
.66
Market Share
.16
4
.64
3
.48
4
.64
Innovation
.08
4
.32
4
.32
2
.16
Management
.12
4
.48
4
.48
4
.48
TOTAL
1.00
3.88
3.72
3.50
Ratings: 4 = Major strength, 3 = Minor strength, 2 = Minor weakness, 1 = Major
weakness
4.2.2. Competitive Profile Matrix
Banks are regulated by the Government through the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas
whose powers emanate from the General Banking Act of 2000. The Act mandates that
establishing universal and commercial banks require high capitalization. With such
capitalization, equates to profit. BDO, BPI and MTC are ranked equally based on their
respective profits for the previous year which is roughly 18,000-22,000 (in Million PHP).
Moreover, the financial position of a bank is what appeals to clients usually when
choosing, because such financial position, will in turn, affect the banks capability to
serve its clients.
Customer service received the second heaviest weight seeing as that the
services provided by the bank attracts the clients. These banking and financial services
are the lifeblood of the bank, without such services, there will be no business - no
service to be acquired by the clients. A bank with a wide range of services is preferable
for clients to so as to save the hassle of transacting with different banks to accommodate
their needs. BDO and BPI, with such wide range of services and, further, the
accessibility of such services play as a major strength against its competitors. Whereas,
MTC has lesser services and lesser accessibility than both BDO and BPI.
Bank assets are also critical success factors. BDO and MTCs market share are
relatively higher than that of BPIs thus receiving a higher rating. Such ranking
contemplated the banks receivables and deposits.
COMPETITORS
METROBANK
BDO
BPI
P4,919
P3,404
P3,466
In Billion PHP
Customer loyalty and management are given similar weight seeing that the way
how the bank is being managed affects its clients. Client satisfaction with the banks
services and its management contributes to the clients retention and loyalty with the
bank. All three banks received equal ratings for both factors.
Lastly, innovation in the banking industry is a critical success factor due to the
fact that technology has been integrated in banking and financing solutions such as
mobile and online banking. Further innovations that suit and adapt to social trends and
clients needs also contribute to client retention. BDO and BPI are rated higher than MTC
considering their services such as e-Banking, mobile banking, online banking and phone
banking; and remittance services.
WEIGHT
RATING
WEIGHTED SCORE
.20
.80
.12
.48
.03
.09
.05
.02
.20
.60
.10
.30
.05
.02
.03
.09
.07
.21
OPPORTUNITIES
THREATS
TOTAL
.15
.60
1.00
3.11
Opportunity 1 has been given the same great weight in the matrix. Aside
from the future integration, the adaptation of the people of mobile banking continues to
rise. Banking customers now handle more of their banking interactions, on average, via
smartphones and tablets than through any other channel and the mobile channel has
become a key element in the bid to earn customer loyalty as Bain and Company, Inc.
reports. In line with this, it gives BDO the opportunity to make most of the new mobile
capabilities, especially when not all banks are not capable of such services yet.
Philippine
economic
condition
also
had
provided
probable
opportunities to the banking industry. As the service sector remains strong, banks and its
services continue to remain strong. Moreover, the increase in demand for skilled Filipino
workers abroad in turn give an increase in remittances.
V. COMPANY ANALYSIS
5.1. Management
There are twelve duly elected Board of Directors for BDO. Henry Sy, Sr., aged
90, is BDOs Chairman Emeritus. He is the Founder and Chairman of SM Group of
Companies. His pioneering of the SM Malls, Shoemart Department Store and
Supermarket, earned him the title of the Philippines Retail King. He also become known
as the richest man in the Philippines.
Teresita T. Sy-Coson, aged 60, is the current Chairperson of BDO. Ms. SyCoson is also the Vice-Chairperson of SM Investments Corporation. Likewise, she also
holds other management positions in BDO affiliates and in the SM Group.
Jesus A. Jacinto, Jr., aged 66, serves as the Vice Chairman of the Board of
BDO and is concurrently the Chairman and President of BDO Insurance Brokers, Inc.
He also holds several key positions is the Banking industry, such as CityTrust Banking
and Citibank N.A.
Christopher A. Bell-Knight, aged 69, is the Director of BDO. He previously
served as BDOs Adviser for several years. He was the Vice President and Country
Head of The Bank of Nova Scotia. Mr. Bell-Knight had over four decades of experience
in the banking industry and a fourth of which was spent in credit and marketing.
Atty. Jose F. Buenaventura, aged 79, is an independent director of BDO. He
also has been a Senior Partner of the Romulo, Mabanta, Buenaventura, Sayoc & De los
Angeles Law Firm. Likewise, he serves as Corporate Secretary of Country Club
Development Corp., The Country Club, Inc. and Peter Paul Philippine Corp., and is the
Assistant Corporate Secretary of Johnson & Johnson Philippines, Inc.
Jones M. Castro, Jr., aged 65, serves as an independent director of BDO. He
served as Area Head for South and Southeast Asia of the Wells Fargo Bank, San
Francisco from 2009 to 2011. Mr. Castro likewise had over four decades of experience in
the Banking industry.
Chai Hong Cheo, aged 61, serves as one of BDOs directors. He also serves as
Managing Director of Group Credit (Middle Market) & Corporate Planning & Strategy at
United Overseas Bank Ltd. He also has over thirty years of experience in corporate
banking and finance.
Atty. Antonio C. Pacis, aged 73, is one of BDOs directors. He also serves as
Managing Partner of Pacis & Reyes Attorneys. Mr. Pacis also serves as a Corporate
Secretary of EBC Srategic holdings Inc., Armstrong securities Inc. and Paluwagan ng
Bayan Savings Bank.
Josefina N. Tan, aged 68, is one of BDOs directors. Ms. Tan serves as a
Secretary and Treasurer of PP & P Insurance Underwriter and East Star Realty Corp.
Ms. Tan serves as a Secretary of Precy Beauty Centre. She also serves as Vice
Chairman of the Board of Trustees of Miriam College.
Nestor V. Tan, aged 56, serves as a director of BDO and its President and Chief
Executive Officer. He was associated with Bankers Trust Company in New York, as Vice
President and the Barclays Group in New York and London, where he served as
Planning Director and Head of Strategic Planning for Corporate and Institutional
Services Group.
Jimmy T. Tang, aged 78, is one of BDOs independent directors. Mr. Tang serves
as the Chairman and President of the Avesco Group of Companies and as the President
of the Federation of Filipino-Chinese Chamber of Commerce and Industry. He also
serves as the President of Avesco Marketing Corporation.
Gilberto C. Teodoro, Jr., aged 49, is also one of BDOs independent directors.
He serves as a member of the Board of Directors of Philippine Geothermal Production
Company, Incorporated, Canlubang Sugar Estate and member of the Board or Advisors
of Seawood Resources, Incorporated. He serves as an Independent Director of BDO
Unibank, Inc. Mr. Teodoro served as Secretary of National Defense from 2007 to 2009
and was a Member of the Philippine House of Representatives from 1998 to 2007.
5.2. Marketing
Banco de Oros marketing division is headed by Mr. Rafael G. Besa, who is
Senior Vice President and Group head of Marketing Communications for Banco De Oro.
His division is made up of several marketing communicators and marketing
communication managers who are practicing advertising, branding, direct marketing,
marketing promotions and public relations for the BDO.
BDOs marketing unit is tasked with broadening its market through commercials,
advertising and promotions by showing BDOs different services and products as well as
its promotional offers. It also branches out its advertising by teaming up with other BDO
affiliates like the SM Group.
Return on Average
Equity
Return on Average
Common Equity
Return on Average
Assets
Net Interest Margin
Capital
Adequacy
Ratio
2013
2012
2011
14.2%
11.3%
11.4%
14.5%
11.5%
11.7%
1.6%
1.3%
1.0%
3.2%
3.4%
3.5%
15.5%
19.2%
15.8%
2012
1,241.5
14.5
39.5
154.4
2011
1,097.3
10.5
36.3
97.0
Resources
Net Profit
Operating Expenses
Equity
2013
1,672.8
22.6
43.3
164.4
Based on the table above, it shows steady 56% growth for BDO since 2011 in
terms of profit. The lending the business was one of its strongest points both in the large
corporate, middle market and small and medium enterprise segments as well as in the
personal loan sector, more particularly with automotive loans. It can also be noted that
there was a decrease in operating expense for BDO since 2011.
It was mentioned in one of BDOs reports that there was a seesaw ride in
equities, nevertheless, there was a huge increase in equity from 2011 to 2012 and
continues to increase in 2013.
PERSONAL
eBanking
o Online, Mobile, ATM and
Phone Banking Options
Savings, Checking Accounts and
Time Deposits
Trusts and Investments
Loans
o Personal, Home, Auto and
Business Loans
Credit Cards
Remittances and Insurance
Private
Bank
and
Wealth
Management Services
BUSINESS
Cash Management Services
Project Finance, Working Capital
and Small Business Loans
Foreign Exchange and Trade
Facilities
o Trade Settlement, Letters of
Credit, Trust Receipts and
Export Bill Purchases
Investment Banking
Business Insurance
Trusts and Investments
Leasing and Financing
Corporate Credit Cards and
Merchant Accreditation
Aside from conducting operations in the Philippines, BDO also established itself
in Hong Kong and keeps offices in other countries such as United States of America,
England, Germany, New Zealand and Japan. Anthony Chua serves as BDOs Executive
Vice President and Head for Global Operations. While Lorna Tan serves as one of
BDOs Senior Vice Presidents and as Chief Executive of BDO Hong Kong branch. The
BDO branch in Hong Kong offers Deposits for Savings and Checking Accounts in US
Dollars and HK Dollars, Deposit Related Services, Commercial and Industrial Loans,
Trade Services, Debit Cards and Remittance Services.
Information
System and IT Department is needed. Ricardo Martin is the Head of the Information
Technology Group. The department is tasked in controlling information online, especially
confidential client information and database. It also goes in hand with the Marketing
Group so as to establish its presence on the Web and for disseminating information
across BDO groups.
In its IT operations, BDO has implemented systems that make branch-based and
electronic services available to clients for a reasonable cost and for longer periods of
time. BDO puts itself if not ahead or at least at par with the local banking industry.
WEIGHT
RATING
WEIGHTED SCORE
.15
.45
.06
.18
.08
.24
.12
.48
.25
1.00
.08
.32
.10
.10
STRENGHTS
Experienced management
International presence
High capitalization
Skilled workforce
WEAKNESS
TOTAL
.08
.16
.04
.04
.04
.08
1.00
3.05
concern through investing in backup systems that will allow operations to continue with
limited disruption to customer services.
Aside from its major strengths, BDOs experienced management, upgraded
electronic banking services and its international presence are also considered as its
minor strengths. Given the fact the BDO is managed by one of the most successful
business owners and as well as experienced international bankers makes BDO a wellsupervised and managed banking and financial institution. Moreover, its upgraded
electronic banking services puts BDO at least a notch higher over its competitors who
offer no such service or an underdeveloped electronic banking service. It puts BDO in a
competitive stand over other banks. BDOs presence in Hong Kong and in other
international offices makes its banking services available to a wider scope of clients,
thus providing more service which may equal to more profit. As well as its ties with
international companies makes BDO open to more opportunities.
Having mentioned security as one of BDOs weaknesses, there is also BDOs
weak presence in rural areas, slow customer service and a decrease in capital adequacy
ratio. A weak presence in rural areas may show that its marketing strategy is either
ineffective or unfocused. BDO has less branches in rural areas which make its services
unavailable in these places.
Capital adequacy ratio is that which determines the banks capacity to meet the
time liabilities and other risks. A decreased capital adequacy ratio may show a
diminishing ability of BDO to meets its liabilities and risks. However, it is not at an
alarming rate of decrease, nevertheless, such decrease must be noted.
VI. STRATEGY FORMULATION
6.1. Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats (SWOT) Matrix
SWOT
STRENGTHS
(S1) Experienced
management
WEAKNESSES
(W1) Security in data
assets
MATRIX
OPPORTUNITIES
(O1) Rise in demand for
mobile banking applications
(O2) Increase in loyal
omnichannel customers
(O3) Harnessing mergers
and acquisition to access
the talents needed
(O4) Boosts in automotive
loans
(O5) Unification into a
single market come 2015
ASEAN Economic
Integration
(O6) Increase in strength
and profits from remittances
from OFWS
THREATS
(T1) Bank switching due to
hidden defection
(T2) Decrease in online,
ATM and branch usage due
to rise in mobile
applications
(T3) Possibility of crumbling
reputation for security and
relationship between
managers and customers
(T4) Vulnerability to security
breaches and attacks due
to increase in digital assets
in banking and financial
institutions
ST STRATEGIES
1. Improve security
measures and data
protection (S3, S4, S5, T1,
T3, T4)
2. Amplify marketing
strategies for other banking
channels (S4, S5, T2)
WT STRATEGIES
1. Improve mobile banking
and its security (W1, T1,
T3, T4)
2. Acquaint employees with
better and more efficient
systems of service (W4, T3)
3. Amplify advertising for
clients and investors to
increase (W2, W3, T2)
WO STRATEGIES
1. Acquire employees who
will help improve security
measures (W1, O3)
2. Acquire competitor banks
or smaller banks to
increase equity (W3, O3,
O5)
3. Use of improved mobile
banking applications and
amplified marketing
strategies (W2, W4, O1)
Based on the matrix above, the following strategies were generated; a) product
development
systems for security, better customer service and increase customer loyalty and increase
profit; b) market development to take advantage of the upcoming ASEAN Economic
Conservative
Aggressive
(4, 3.08)
Defensive
Competitive
The graph above shows that BDOs directional vector point to the upper right
quadrant, the Aggressive quadrant. This shows that BDO is in a prime condition to use
its strengths and take advantage of opportunities. It is also in such condition to
overcome weakness and mitigate threats. Intensive and diversification strategies are
more aligned to address this situation.
Stars
In the Internal Factor Evaluation (IFE) Matrix, BDO received a total weighted
score of 3.05 which suggests that BDOs strengths are capable of mitigating its
weaknesses, thus making it one of the strongest and most stable banks in the
Philippines. While in its External Factor Evaluation (EFE) Matrix, BDO received a total
weighted score of 3.11 which suggests that the external environment of the industry and
BDOs response to opportunities and threats.
Plotting these scores in the Internal-External (IE) Matrix, it appeared that such is
plotted in Cell I, the Grow and Build region. In such region, it suggests that the firm
should pursue intensive and vertical integration strategies such as market development,
product development, market penetration, horizontal integration, backward integration
and forward integration strategies.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Q4
Market Development
Market Penetration
Product Development
Forward Integration
Backward Integration
Horizontal Integration
Related Diversification
Q3
Q2
In the above illustration, BDO is located in Quadrant I. This entails that BDO has
a very strong strategic position. This means the BDO has an established competitive
advantage and makes use of it as long as possible. Strategies such as market
penetration, market development, product development and the vertical integration
strategies are relevant for such firms positioned in Quadrant I. With such position, it
means that firms can afford to take advantage of external opportunities and handle risks
aggressively if necessary.
6.6. Summary of Strategic Formulation Tools
STRATEGIES
Market Development
Market Penetration
Forward Integration
Backward Integration
Product Development
Horizontal Integration
Related Diversification
Unrelated
Diversification
TOTAL
5
5
5
3
2
2
3
1
In sum, the most prevalent strategies that came up in the previous matrices
presented, market development, market penetration, product development garnered the
highest total. Related diversification closely followed. While vertical integration strategies
and unrelated diversification trained in the end.
STRATEGIC ALTERNATIVES
Market
Developmen
t
Internal
Strength
Experienced
management
International
presence
Up-to-date
online banking
services
Strong support
units in I.T.
and R&D
High
capitalization
Skilled
workforce
Internal
Weakness
Security in
data assets
Less branches
in rural areas
Decrease in
capital
adequacy ratio
Slow customer
service
Total
Opportunities
Rise in
demand for
mobile
banking
applications
Increase in
loyal
omnichannel
customers
Harnessing
mergers and
acquisition to
Market
Penetration
Product
Development
Horizontal
Integration
AS
TAS
AS
TAS
AS
TAS
AS
TAS
.15
.06
.24
.06
.12
.18
.08
.12
.36
.36
.48
.36
.25
1.00
.75
.75
1.00
.08
AS
TAS
AS
TAS
AS
TAS
AS
TAS
.10
.08
.16
.32
.08
.24
.04
.12
.04
.08
.16
.04
.04
.04
.16
.04
1.00
W
AS
TAS
.20
.40
.60
.80
.20
.12
.12
.48
.24
.36
.03
AS
TAS
AS
TAS
AS
TAS
access the
talents needed
Boosts in
auto-loans
Unification into
a single
market come
2015 ASEAN
Economic
Integration
Increase in
strength and
profits from
remittances
from OFWS
Opportunities
Bank
switching due
to hidden
defection
Decrease in
online, ATM
and branch
usage due to
rise in mobile
applications
Possibility of
crumbling
reputation for
security and
relationship
between
managers and
customers
Vulnerability to
security
breaches and
attacks due to
increase in
digital assets
in banking and
financial
institutions
Total
Total of Sum of
Attractiveness
Score
.05
.10
.20
.05
.05
.20
.80
.40
.20
.60
.10
AS
TAS
.05
.05
.15
.20
.05
.03
.03
.06
.16
.12
.07
.15
.15
.15
.60
.60
AS
TAS
AS
TAS
AS
TAS
1.00
3.57
3.69
4.02
3.96
safer transactions which answer the issues on vulnerability of digital assets to breaches
and attacks as well as BDOs security. This objective answers BDOs goals in ten folds.
7.2. Recommendations
application should be developed. Such application should have the basic transactions
ready and available with a tap. Security should also be tightened, like having better
password and coding systems as well as back up systems.
Aside from online services, BDO must use technology to develop its
services in bank branches. This is to address its mission on the flawless delivery of
services. Using machines to make transactions faster or to make queues more
organized. BDO has to keep in mind that quality service should be its priority so as to
meet its objectives. To facilitate this product development, BDO must capitalize on its
strong support units in R&D and I.T. Departments. BDOs high capitalization is also an
indication that the company can afford such development.
2. Market Penetration
Being one of the top players in the banking industry and having the
largest market share in the industry, BDO should still exert efforts in market penetration.
One of its missions is to be the preferred banking institution in the markets it serves.
BDO cannot be complacent with its current position. Amplification of its marketing
strategies using its new products will help dig a deeper niche for BDO in its current
markets. BDO has to develop its market, but nonetheless it should not lose sight of its
current market where foundation is deeper. This also to address its issue in rural areas
which is already a penetrated market, but it has to amplify marketing strategies along
with other strategies to capture this market. Establishing more branches or ATMs in rural
areas should also increase its presence in the rural areas.
3. Horizontal Integration
Aside from establishing more branches or ATMs to increase presence,
BDO can acquire rural banks in the areas it needs to penetrate so as to lessen
competition and increase more presence in the area. This will in turn translate to an
increase in its relative market share which is another objective of BDO. Considering
BDOs high capitalization, it would be able to buy out a rural bank. Moreover, BDO has
experienced management as one of its strengths who may be capable of negotiating to
acquire other banks at better prices.
executives should be hire so as to manage the newly acquired bank. BDO may also
choose to retain the existing employees of the newly acquired bank.
Increase in
capital
adequacy
Increase in
equity
Financial
Increase in net
income
Feedback
Innovate
products
using latest
technology
Increase
customer
satisfaction
Growth in
number of
clients
Decrease
load
Internal
Process
time for
mobile bank
application
Increase in
capital
adequacy
Increase in
equity
Financial
Increase in net
income
Feedback
Increase
customer
satisfaction
Growth in
number of
clients
Conduct studies
and researches
for the
establishment of
a new bank
branch
Internal
Process
Improved
accessibility
of services
7.3.3. Below is a strategy map for horizontal integration wherein it is recommended that
BDO should acquire a rural bank to gain more presence in an already penetrated or
serviced geographical area, which are rural areas and to increase in market share
through buying out or acquiring the competition.
Increase in
market share
Increase in
equity
Financial
Increase in net
income
Feedback
Increase
customer
satisfaction
Growth in
number of
clients
Conduct
studies and
researches for
the acquisition
of a rural bank
Decrease in
time to acquire
another bank or
business
Internal Process
With the recommended strategies being mentioned, such will aid in the
achievement of the stated strategic and financial strategies. The implementation of the
strategies will translate to a change in the finances of BDO. The following are the
financial projections for BDO following the strategies and fulfillment of the stated
objectives:
Interest Income
Interest Expense
Net Interest
Income
Impairment Losses
Net Interest
Income after
Impairment Losses
Other Operating
Income
Other Operating
Expenses
Profit before Tax
Tax Expense
Net Profit
2013
2014
2015
2016
P54,104
(P13,440)
P59,514.4
(P13,440)
P71,417.28
(P13,440)
P92,842.46
(P13,440)
P43,166
P46,074.4
P57,977.28
P79,402.46
(P7,001)
(P7,001)
(P7,001)
(P7,001)
P36,165
P39,073.4
P50,996.28
P72,401.46
P31,844
P35,072.4
P42,086.88
P54,712.94
(P43,259)
(P43,259)
(P47,584.9)
(P57,101.88)
P24,750
(P2,104)
P30,886.8
(P2,625.38)
P45,498.26
(P3,867.35)
P70,012.52
(P5,951.06)
P22,646
P28,261.42
P41,630.91
P64,061.46
for interest and impairment losses were maintained and the tax expense rate was also
remained at 8.50%. Meanwhile, operating expenses remained the same only until 2014
and increase by 10% in 2015 and 20% in 2016. It is so because it is in 2015 when the
upgraded and improved mobile banking application will be launched. Such justified the
47.31% change in net profits from 2014. While in 2016, there will be establishment of the
new bank branch and the acquisition of a new rural bank. This supported the 53.88%
change in net profits from 2015 to 2016. The changes in the amounts are justified using
the strategies implemented as well as compliance of the financial objectives.
P1,672,778
P1,840,055.8
P2,208,066.96
P2,870,487.05
Total Liabilities
P1,508,424
P1,659,266.9
P1,991,120.28
P2,558,456.36
Total Stockholders
Equity
P164,534
P180,788.9
P216,946.68
P312,030.69
P1,672,778
P1,840,055.8
P2,208,066.96
P2,870,487.05
*2015
*2014
2013
2,208.0 1,840.1 1,672.8
41.6
28.3
22.6
47.6
43.3
43.3
216.9
180.7
164.4
2012
1,241.5
14.5
39.5
154.4
2011
1,097.3
10.5
36.3
97.0
The above table shows the financial highlights of BDO from 2011 to 2013 which
are based on its Annual Reports. While the amounts from 2014 to 2016 are gathered fro
the above statements which are projections supported by the strategies and objectives
formulated. It can be seen that there is a continuous increase in all aspects.
PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT
EXPECTED
ACTIVITIES
TIMETABLE
OUTPUT(S)
Improving BDOs mobile banking application
Research on latest
technology relevant
to banking and
security.
Convene regarding
research results
and developments
Arrive at a decision on
which systems and
software to purchase
Purchase software
and systems agreed
upon
Integrate software
purchase to existing
mobile banking
application
Brief employees
regarding the
features, uses and
possible issues and
its remedies
Testing of mobile
application for
employees and
select clients
3 months
(January 2014
to March 2014)
1 2 weeks
(April 2014)
1 week
(April 2014)
DEPARTMENT(S)
RESPONSIBLE
- Research and
Development (R&D)
Department
- Information
Technology (I.T)
Department
- Executive
Department
- R&D Department
- I.T. Department
- I.T. Department
- Accounting,
Finance, Treasury
Department
3 months
(April 2014 to
middle of June
2014)
Information
Technology
Department
1 week
(June 2014)
All Departments
1 month
(July 2014)
- Marketing
Department
- Operations
Department
- I.T. Department
- R&D Department
Convene regarding
testing results and
possible
developments and
adjustments to be
made
Adjustments and
final touches to the
application and
testing
Convene regarding
soft launch results
and discuss
adjustments need
Official Release of
the application
1 month
(August 2014)
1 month
(September
2014)
1 month
(October 2014)
2 months
(November to
December
2014)
January 2015
- Executive
Department
- R&D Department
- I.T. Department
- Marketing
Department
- Operations
Department
- I.T. Department
- R&D Department
- Marketing
Department
- Operations
Department
- I.T. Department
R&D Department
- Executive
Department
- R&D Department
- I.T. Department
- Marketing
Department
All Departments
MARKET PENETRATION
EXPECTED
ACTIVITIES
TIMETABLE
OUTPUT(S)
Establishing new branches in rural areas
Research regarding
Gather data and
areas for possible
research that will
3 months
establishment of new
aid in reaching a
(January to
branch, opportunity
decision on whether
March 2015)
analysis and market
to establish a new
research
branch
Convene with
management to
discuss data gathered
Reach a decision
on whether to
establish a new
branch and other
details regarding
such
1 week
(June 2015)
3 weeks
(June 2015)
1 month
(April 2015)
2 weeks
(July 2015)
Construction of the
new branch
Execution of plans
for the
establishment of the
new branch
5 months
(July to
November 2015)
Hiring of new
employees and
managers for new
branch
Acquire talents to
be as employees for
the new branch
1 month
(September
2015)
DEPARTMENT(S)
RESPONSIBLE
- R&D Department
- Marketing
Department
- R&D Department
- Marketing
Department
- Executive
Department
- Accounting &
Finance
Department
- R&D Department
- Marketing
Department
- Operations
Department
Executive
Department
- Executive
Department
- Legal Department
- Accounting &
Finance
Department
(Contractors)
- Executive
Department
- Accounting &
Finance
Department
Human Resource
Department
Training of new
employees
Integrate and
acquaint new
employees to BDO
Convene with
management regarding
plans for new branch
and strategize
Come up with
strategies and
management plans
for running the new
branch
Settlement of all
necessary items
and finalization of
contract between
contractors
1 month
(October 2015)
1 month
(November 2015)
1 month
(December 2015)
Start of operations
in the new branch
Amplify marketing
strategies in area of
new branch
Promote and
advertise new
branch in the area
(January 2016)
Convene with
management regarding
the progress and
operations of new
branch
Assess the
performance of the
new branch and
look for areas for
improvement
(July 2016)
(January 2016)
Human Resource
Department
R&D Department
- Marketing
Department
- Executive
Department
- Operations
Department
- Executive
Department
- Accounting &
Finance
Department
- Marketing
Department
- Executive
Department
- I.T. Department
- Operations
Department
- Marketing
Department
- I.T. Department
- R&D Department
- Executive
Department
- Operations
Department
- Accounting &
Finance
Department
capitalization, experienced management and strong support units in the R&D and I.T.
Departments. The acquisition will generate more profits seeing as the BDOs network
and operations will be expanding. This in turn will address one of BDOs mission that is
to create shareholder value through superior returns.
HORIZONTAL INTEGRATION
EXPECTED
ACTIVITIES
TIMETABLE
OUTPUT(S)
Acquiring/buying out a rural bank
Reach a decision
Convene and
on whether to
consult with
4 months
conduct research
management
(January to April
and analysis
regarding
2015)
regarding
integration
integration
Achieve a study that
Conduct research,
will be useful in
analyze
reaching a decision
2 months
opportunities and
to support the
(April to May 2015)
assess current
acquiring of a new
condition
bank
Come up with a
Look for banks that
short list of banks
1 month
are for possible
for possible
(June 2015)
acquisition
acquisition
Come up with pros
Convene and
and cons in banks
1 week
discuss banks on
in the short list for
(July 2015)
short list
further analysis
Further research on More in-depth study
1 month
banks in the short
on the banks in the
(July 2015)
list
short list
Convene and
Come up to a
discuss the results
decision on which
of the concluded
2 weeks
bank to purchase
research study on
(August 2015)
based on the
the banks in the
research conducted
short list
Negotiations with
Settle all legal
3 months
the management of
responsibilities,
(August to October
the bank to be
finances and other
2015)
acquired
necessary steps so
DEPARTMENT(S)
RESPONSIBLE
- R&D Department
- Marketing
Department
- Executive
Department
- R&D Department
- Marketing
Department
- Executive
Department
- R&D Department
- Executive
Department
- R&D Department
- Executive
Department
- R&D Department
- R&D Department
- Executive
Department
- Accounting &
Finance Department
All Departments
Finalize acquisition
and convene with
employees
regarding such
Arrange
management at
newly acquired
bank
Convene with new
management
regarding business
and steps to take in
furtherance of
Formally announce
to the public the
acquisition of the
new bank
as to acquire the
bank
Accomplish final
steps in acquisition
and to acquaint
employees with the
change
1 month
(November 2015)
All Departments
Fire or hire
employees and to
arrange
management at the
newly acquired
bank
1 month
(December 2015)
- Executive
Department
- Human
Resource
Department
- Operations
Department
1 month
(January 2016)
Executive
Departments
Announce to clients,
shareholders and
the general public of
the acquisition
(February 2016)
All Departments
7.5.4. Management
It is not necessary that BDO should change it Board of Trustees. BDO
has a good pool of talented managers. BDOs management needs to be more involved
and hands-on in the banking operations to get to a deeper level of what the bank needs
and in which direction should the bank go. The managers should convene more often to
discuss the steps BDO should take.
7.5.5. Marketing
With a growing market share due to the increase in presence in rural
areas through the establishment of a new bank branch and the acquisition of a rural
bank, it means that the number of clients served increase. With this said, there can be
an increase in the for more prospective clients. BDO then should amplify its marketing
strategies through a more dynamic, flexible and productive Marketing Department. Such
should be able to compete with the aggressiveness of the competitors. More training for
marketing managers are advised.
7.5.7. Operations
With many changes in the operations come 2015 and 2016 due to the
implementation of the strategies. It is required that the Operations Department polish
itself and align itself with the other departments to ensure successful implementation.
The Operations Department may need more employees seeing as that a larger market
has to be served by BDO due to the establishment of a new bank branch and the
acquisition of a rural bank.
FINANCIAL
Capital
Adequacy Ratio
Increase in
Market Share
LEARNING &
DEVELOPMEN
T
INTERNAL
PROCESS
FEEDBACK
Market Share
Increase by 20%
Lessen time to
innovate services
Time to develop
services
Decrease by 6 months
Increase
accessibility of
services
Lessen time in
loading for
mobile banking
applications
Lessen time to
convene,
negotiate and
acquire a bank
Lessen time to
establish a new
bank branch
Increase
customer
satisfaction in
rural areas
Growth of clients
(as to number of)
Number of clients
served, market
share
Increase by 10%
Time to respond of
the mobile banking
application
Decrease by 30 seconds
to 1 minute
Time to reach a
decision on the
acquisition of a bank
Decrease by 3 months
Time to establish a
new branch
Decrease by 3 months
Customer Feedback
Increase by 30%
Number of clients
Increase by 20%
VIII. BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. http://investing.businessweek.com/research/stocks/people/person.asp?
personId=10198974&ticker=BDO:PM
2. https://www.bdo.com.ph/corporate-governance/board-and-shareholder-matters
3. https://www.bdo.com.ph/corporate-governance/board-committees-andmemberships
4. http://www.reuters.com/finance/stocks/companyOfficers?symbol=BDO.PS
5. https://www.bdo.com.ph/hong-kong-home
6. https://www.bdo.com.ph/about-bdo/domestic-international-network
7. http://www.eiu.com/industry/Financial-services
8. http://www.bsp.gov.ph/downloads/Publications/2014/LTP_1qtr2014.pdf
9. http://www.bain.com/publications/articles/european-banking-bain-report.aspx
10. http://www.bain.com/publications/articles/rebooting-it-why-financial-institutionsneed-a-new-technology-model.aspx
11. http://www.bain.com/Images/BAIN_BRIEF_Building_the_retail_bank_of_the_futu
re.pdf
12. https://www.equitymaster.com/research-it/sector-info/bank/Banking-SectorAnalysis-Report.asp
13. http://www.bain.com/publications/articles/customer-loyalty-and-the-digicaltransformation-in-p-and-c-and-life-insurance.aspx
14. http://www.wavespartnership.org/sites/waves/files/documents/WAVES%20Policy
%20Note%20Philippines.pdf
15. http://www.worldometers.info/world-population/philippines-population/
16. http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.CBRT.IN
17. http://web0.psa.gov.ph/sites/default/files/2014%20PIF.pdf
18. http://www.nscb.gov.ph/poverty/default.asp
19. https://www2.fdic.gov/SDI/SOB/
20. http://www.philstar.com/business/2014/01/30/1284723/philippine-economyexpands-7.2-2013
21. http://www.bain.com/Images/BAIN_BRIEF_Why_cybersecurity_is_a_strategic_is
sue.pdf
22. http://www.bsp.gov.ph/downloads/regulations/gba.pdf
23. https://www.metrobank.com.ph
24. http://www.bpi.com.ph
25. Baxter, M., & Vater, D. (2013). Building the retail bank of the future. Boston,
Massachusetts: Bain & Company.
26. Baxter, M., Berez, S., & Padmanabhan, V. (2013). Rebooting IT: Why financial
institutions need a new technology model. Boston, Massachusetts: Bain &
Company.
27. Ali, S., Dixon, J., & Padmanabhan, V. (2014). Why cybersecurity is a strategic
issue. Boston, Massachusetts: Bain & Company.
28. Philippine Economic Update 2013 (World Bank Document)
29. Wealth Accounting and Valuation of Ecosystem Services (WAVES): Country
Report on the Philippines
30. Philippines in Figures 2011 to 2014 (National Statistics Office)
APPENDIX