Formalism
Formalism
Formalism
Pedagogy
William H. Thelin criticizes Maxine Hairstons approach to teaching composition
from a current-traditional standpoint, which she then mixes with the political.
He claims that No matter how sound the politics the student would have no
choice but to regurgitate that dogma in the clearest terms possible and to shift
concentration onto matters of structure and correctness.
Mary Ann Cain writes that formalism asserts that the text stands on its own
as a complete entity, apart from the writer who produced it. Moreover, Cain
says that one can regard textual products as teachable and still maintain that
being a writer is a "natural" act, one not subject to instruction. Composition,
like creative writing, has flourished under the assumption that students are
already writers, or have the capacity to learn-and that everyone should be
writers. Yet the questions composition tends to pose within this assumption are
not so much about which aspects of writing can or cannot be taught, but how
writing can be taught and under what conditions. In regards to formalist
composition, one must ask, to what extent is this need for academic
discourse real any more than the need for more imaginative writing is realexcept to perform some function, to get something done?.
Research
Formalism research involves studying the ways in which students present their
writing. Some ways formalism research is conducted involves allowing the text
to speak to the readers versus cutting out unintended meaning in a written
piece. Respectively, these two methods deal with language as the master
writer versus a teacher as the master writer.
Background
Russian Formalism
Examples
Oedipus
"Those eyes of yours, which now can see so clearly, will be dark."
" walk through a door in 1955 and come out another one in 1941"
Formalist critics praising the work on its character development and use
of literary devices
Also felt that Hamlet failed to adhere by the strict rules of classical
drama in structure and plot