Wind
Wind
Wind
Community Wind
Toolbox
Chapter 3:
This section focuses on project management and planning, two elements that are
essential to a successful 2-50 MW community wind project. Topics covered in this
section include putting together a reliable project team and understanding risks
and ways to mitigate them. The section also provides resources for creating a realistic project plan and timeline, as well as tips from experienced community wind
developers..
This section builds on an excellent previous publication, Community Wind: An
Oregon Guidebook prepared for the Energy Trust of Oregon by Northwest Sustainable
Energy for Economic Development in 2005, available at:
www.nwseed.org/publications
Putting Together the Project Team
Risk Management
Tips for Managing Community Wind Development
Conclusion
Additional Resources for Project Management and Planning
www.windustry.org
Caution
Example
P RO J E C T P L A N N I N G A N D M A N AG E M E N T
W I N D U S T RY S
Lawyers
Bankers
USDA
Contractors
Board
Elected
Officials
Equipment
Suppliers
State
Energy
Office
Accountants
CEO
Developer
Project Governance
As with any multi-million dollar business venture, launching a
community wind development effort requires a sound business
operations structure. This includes an experienced Chief
Executive Officer supported by team members, all of which are
described below. If you have never presided over an enterprise
of this scale, you may want to partner with a veteran project
executive to help you steer though major decisions and
management issues. Once your project is built, you will need to
ensure ongoing oversight for maintenance monitoring,
operations, and reporting on the various financial aspects of
the business.
Chief Executive Officer. Developing a community wind
energy project is similar to developing an ethanol plant. It takes
a dedicated and diverse team
to bring it into production,
including a strong Chief
For a community
Executive Officer and Board
project, it takes a
of Directors who will keep
person or a group
the project on track. The
that really believes
CEO should have experience
in it to lead and
in business, preferably in the
energy sector, and should
organize and to spur
have a strong understanding
the professionals on.
of the wind industry and the
Somebody has to
associated risks and rewards
volunteer to be the
of community wind developleader.
ment. The CEO is instrumental in developing relationships
Keith Bolin
with potential investors and
Hog Farmer and
financing institutions. These
Community Wind Developer
Bureau Valley, IL
are relationships that the
Investors
In addition to key team members, community wind projects have connections to many different members of the community as well as local, state,
and federal agencies and leaders. This picture shows the ribbon cutting for
Minwind I&II, a farmer owned wind project. See Minwind Case Study for
more information.
Photos: Windustry staff
P RO J E C T P L A N N I N G A N D M A N AG E M E N T
W I N D U S T RY S
Key Consultants
Putting together the right team to execute community wind
energy development is very important; you should consult with
others who have completed similar projects to learn about their
experiences with specific consultants, manufacturers, and
construction companies. You need to make sure that your
projects team of consultants consists of experienced and reliable
individuals with whom you have good rapport. Your project
will require expertise in areas that include but are not limited
to:
How many experts you decide to hire for your project will
depend on the Boards experience and level of comfort and
the time the Board is willing to devote in each of these areas.
If you have little expertise in wind energy, you may want to hire
experts for each of these project development aspects. Some
community wind developers may feel qualified to undertake
certain tasks themselves.
Wind Resource Assessment. Evaluating and documenting
the wind resource at your site is one of the most important
steps in the design of your project. For a commercial-scale
project, you will need to conduct extensive on-site data
collection and analysis. The wind data requirements to finance
a 50 MW project are often substantially more rigorous than
what lenders may require for a 2 MW project. Consulting a
meteorologist or wind assessment professional for input on
where turbines should be sited is required for some federal
grants, and is recommended for sites with complex terrain. A
meteorologist or site modeling specialist can confirm the best
positions for the equipment and for the projects expected
output.
Environmental Impact Studies. For many community
wind projects, an environmental impact assessment is required.
Professional scientists can help negotiate study protocols and
conduct a scientifically sound field survey. A defensible set of
environmental studies is important for obtaining permits and
community support. Many grants come with requirements for
who needs to perform the study and what it must cover.
Consulting with local, state, and federal wildlife and
environmental agencies will help you to understand what
expertise will be required to complete environmental impact
studies.
Interconnection Design. The utility your project
interconnects to will design the interconnection system for your
wind project, but it may be a good idea to contract with an
engineer who is independent of the utility to help design the
interconnection system, ensure that the utilitys plans are within
reason, and confirm that associated costs are realistic.
Construction managers are often able to recommend an
engineer with interconnection experience.
Construction Management. The construction manager is
a critical team member, responsible for overseeing construction
of the project and operating within budget and schedule
constraints that may be imposed by power purchase agreements
P RO J E C T P L A N N I N G A N D M A N AG E M E N T
W I N D U S T RY S
Foundation Design. The turbine foundation is a sitespecific structure, and it must be properly designed to bear the
substantial loads placed on it by the wind turbine. A civil
engineer will be consulted to conduct soil tests and
recommend a foundation design, or to create a new design as
the case warrants. Your turbine manufacturer may be able to
provide a list of engineers who have previously designed
foundations for their turbines.
Legal Assistance. You will most likely have to hire multiple
attorneys with different areas of expertise to see the project
through to fruition. Power purchase agreements, turbine
procurement, project financing, land control, and various
associated contracts are specialized to the independent power
industry. Some attorneys also specialize in permitting and
environmental compliance. These parts of a community wind
development process must meet industry standards. A
community wind project is a multi-million dollar investment
and it is worthwhile to consult attorneys experienced in
corporate and tax law to make sure that your assets are
protected should the project not perform as expected.
Risk Management
Wind projects often have a protracted period of at-risk investment.
Until all permits, financing, and equipment are obtained, risk
remains that the project will not be completed. It is therefore
essential to be prepared to face and manage risks.
The right project team, including a project manager who is
familiar with the associated risks, should be able to incorporate
risk mitigation into a successful management plan.
Wind project development risk factors, or sources of risk, fall
into three main categories:
1. Energy Production Factors
- Wind resource
- Equipment
- Operations and maintenance
- Force majeure
2. Other Revenue Factors
- Value of energy produced
- Tax benefit allocation
- On-again/off-again tax subsidies
- Transmission
COMMUNITY WIND
DEVELOPER TIP
P RO J E C T P L A N N I N G A N D M A N AG E M E N T
W I N D U S T RY S
can more easily mitigate some than others. Ratings of risk levels
shown in the table illustrate how much of a factor each risk plays
in the overall project plan. A one-star rating is typically easy to
deal with, if you have planned appropriately. Five stars means
that you have no control over this risk or that it should be
evaluated early in the development process because it represents
a potentially fatal flaw one that can terminate a project.
The following is adapted from similar tables found in Community Wind:
An Oregon Guidebook prepared by Northwest SEED and Community
Wind Financing published by the Environmental Law & Policy Center.
R I S K FAC TO R S
Mitigation
Wind Resource
Fully insuring the project mitigates your financial loss due to force
majeure (acts of nature). This will add to project costs but will
provide much needed peace of mind against the loss of your
investment. Financing institutions will probably not lend capital
to a project without proper insurance.
LEVEL OF RISK
Equipment
LEVEL OF RISK
LEVEL OF RISK
Force Majeure
(Acts of Nature)
LEVEL OF RISK
P RO J E C T P L A N N I N G A N D M A N AG E M E N T
W I N D U S T RY S
R I S K FAC TO R S
Issues
Mitigation
This risk can be mitigated with careful siting within the utility
system, relocation, or resizing of the project. Be flexible with these
variables so that when interconnection study results come back,
your project plan is not so rigid as to kill your project.
Issues
Mitigation
Permits
LEVEL OF RISK
LEVEL OF RISK
On-again/ Off-again
Tax Subsidies
LEVEL OF RISK
Transmission
LEVEL OF RISK
LEVEL OF RISK
Environmental Impacts
LEVEL OF RISK
P RO J E C T P L A N N I N G A N D M A N AG E M E N T
W I N D U S T RY S
R I S K FAC TO R S
Issues
Mitigation
Public Acceptance/Politics
Objections from the public can range widely and are hard
to predict. Some neighbors may be concerned about noise
from the turbines, while others may not want to have
turbines visible on the landscape or see them as
encroachment of civilization in a rural area.
LEVEL OF RISK
Site Control
LEVEL OF RISK
Construction
LEVEL OF RISK
Feasibility Study
To determine whether significant resources should be spent to
move a project forward, it is wise to hire an outside firm to
perform a feasibility study. This study will help you to better
understand the market that the project is entering into, aid in
developing a comprehensive business plan, and consider many
of the fatal flaw tests up front. There are many consulting
firms with experience in wind energy project development that
can help to draft a portion or all of the feasibility study.
Items typically included in a feasibility study are1:
P RO J E C T P L A N N I N G A N D M A N AG E M E N T
W I N D U S T RY S
Task Name
J
Year 3
J F
Development Phase
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
Business Model
Determine ownership rights, capital contributions,
distrubutions and allocations
Establish business policies & documentation
Execute partnership contracts
0%
0%
9/6
0%
Resource Assessment
Preliminary wind assessment
Review site on available wind map
Hire a wind resource consultant
Collect and analyze data from nearby monitoring sites
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
Site assessment
Inspect site
0%
0%
0%
0%
5%
0%
0%
0%
0%
40%
Land Control
Determine existing Right-of-Way, easements
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
7/14
P RO J E C T P L A N N I N G A N D M A N AG E M E N T
W I N D U S T RY S
Task Name
J
Year 2
J F
Year 3
J F
Financing
Generate balance sheet, cash flow & income statements
Research eligibility requirements for incentives
0%
21%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
Utility Interconnection
Complete interconnection application
0%
0%
0%
0%
5/25
0%
0%
0%
1/31
0%
Construction Preparation
Investigate potential contractors and solicit estimates
Soil borings and foundation design
0%
0%
0%
3/14
100%
Construction Phase
Site preparation
Grading, road improvements/construction, fencing &
erosion control
Substation construction/ improvements and testing
Trenching, cable-laying and transformer installation
Foundation and crane pad construction
0%
0%
0%
0%
Turbine installation
Turbine and tower transportation
0%
0%
Complete Interconnection
0%
10/31
O&M Phase
Ongoing project management & financial oversight
Perform routine maintenance checks and repairs
Decommissioning and site restoration (end of project)
Critical
Milestone
Critical Split
Summary Progress
Critical Progress
Summary
Task
Project Summary
Split
External Tasks
Task Progress
External Milestone
Baseline
Deadline
Baseline Split
Contractor Task
Baseline Milestone
Owner Task
P RO J E C T P L A N N I N G A N D M A N AG E M E N T
W I N D U S T RY S
COMMUNITY WIND
DEVELOPER TIP
Realism
Be realistic about the outcomes of your project. Being
overly optimistic in assumptions about your project
financials can jeopardize the entire venture.
Make Friends
Networking is key to success. Learn from others who
have traveled the path before you. This can add
valuable insight to your project. Aiding other
developers today by lending expertise or contributing
capital can reap rewards tomorrow when you in turn
need assistance in developing your own project.
P RO J E C T P L A N N I N G A N D M A N AG E M E N T
10
W I N D U S T RY S
Conclusion
Developing a farmer-owned community wind project has many
analogies to constructing an ethanol cooperative. Farmers own
corn and other feed stocks that can be utilized to create
bio-fuels. Communities that possess a robust wind resource
have the opportunity to develop wind projects themselves or
market their natural resource and be a partner in its
development. Participating in an ethanol cooperative provides
larger rewards than simply selling corn to a company that will in
turn process the corn into ethanol and sell it at a much higher
margin than the farmer is receiving for producing the raw
commodity. Owning the wind turbines and directly benefiting
from the sale of electricity and incentives yields a much higher
return than just simply leasing land to a developer for periodic
payments.
Community wind projects can be complex and may involve
many different experts and stakeholders. You may have the
P RO J E C T P L A N N I N G A N D M A N AG E M E N T
11