Amit SAIL Valuation Report
Amit SAIL Valuation Report
Amit SAIL Valuation Report
250
200
150
100
50
10/1/09
11/1/09
12/1/09
1/1/09
4/1/09
5/1/09
6/1/09
7/1/09
9/1/09
1/1/10
2/1/09
3/1/09
8/1/09
2/1/10
SAIL SENSEX BSE-METAL
Steel consumption in India is growing at a rate of 12%, a trend persist as the country enters into
Steel development phase. Construction/Infrastructure accounts for 60% of domestic steel
demand, Engineering(Approx 30%), Auto sector(approx 8%).In the union budget 2010-11 it has
planned to spend Rs 1,77,000 Cr. Mega projects in power, ports, railway, roads will increase the
demand of steel.
SAIL makes both flat (52%) & long (36%) products. It also makes value added products such as
pipes, plates and coated products. Alloy & special steel contributes to 6% of sales. SAIL has not
expanded its installed capacity in this financial year so; we expect its saleable steel volume will
grow by 9.44% in FY 10 & by 11% in FY 11 and subsequently by a higher rate as its new
capacity is expected to increase in FY12. It will increase its hot metal production beyond 26
Mtpa.
Sail’s EBITDA margin compare favorable with its domestic peers. This is possible due to its
ongoing integrated operations, technological up gradation.
2. KEY RISKS
2.1. Delay in renewal of leases for Iron ore mines
SAIL currently meets its all iron ore requirements of ~23 mtpa from captive sources. When its
iron ore capacity is fully commissioned, its iron ore requirements will rise to ~43 mtpa. It has
looking for new mines for meets its requirements. There has been delay in renewal of leases from
the Chiria mines (Jharkhand) while further delay will be a risk.
The EBITDA will grow by 23.69% in FY10 to touch Rs 101662.4Mn from Rs 90234.70 Mn in
FY09. EBITDA is expected to grow by CAGR of 16.37% from FY10 to FY11.
We anticipates that PAT would grow by 15.36% to Rs 71234.68 Mn in FY10 from Rs 61478.10
Mn in FY09. We expect PAT to grow by CAGR of 19% in next 3 years.
4.2. Revenue
4.3. Plant-Wise:
Bhilai steel plant have highest share of sales among integrated plants.
Bokaro steel plant have high share of sales after Bhilai steel plant.
Alloy steel plants have fewer shares of sales among all plants of SAIL.
4.4. Product-Mix:
Saleable steel is likely to be contributing about 90% of total sales turnover.
Semis component in sales of saleable steel is 12% of 5 integrated steel plants.
Special steel production 3.44 Mt which is increased by 20% in FY10 from FY09.
Production through concast 6.8 Mt which is 3% higher in FY10 from FY09.
Sale of other product like ingots, pig iron, scraps, coal chemicals etc. likely to contribute
5% of total sales turnover.
Shares of round likely to increase 10% to 20% by 2012.
Shares of structurals likely to increase 5% to 15% by 2012.
4.5. Others:
Higher sales volume is expected because of higher average price realization due to higher
sales of value added products, good product-mix and better quality of techno economic
parameters.
Major demand of growth expected to come from Railways, Automobiles, power projects,
Oil & gas and Highways.
2. Staff costs are expected to be in the range of 17-18% from FY09 to FY11 of sales. However
company will increase its production capacity which will help company achieve economies
of scale. Wage revisions are not expected to happen in the coming years.
4. Depreciation will takes into account the capital investment being made from FY08 to FY11.
5. Tax Rate- has been taken at 33% for the coming years.
5. VALUATIONS
SAIL’s stock is valued at Rs 202.82 based on my DCF valuation, which is 13% down from the
current levels.
All parameters like EBITDA, PAT are expected to grow at 23.69%, 16.60% respectively in 2010
but the sales would declined by 0.56%. These would further grow at a CAGR of 21%, 19% &
20% respectively for next four years up to 2014.
We expect the automobile sector to grow in a double digit and huge demand comes from
construction sector. Demand of steel is increasing in engineering sector, railways, and in
defence sector.
Large sales network and service network gives substantial customer reach and loyalty.
DCF Sensitivity
The DCF valuation is relatively sensitive to the continuing growth rate and the discounting factor
used. The base case uses continuing growth rate of 8% in 2014 onwards. Considering 10 year
government bond yield and risk premium as per Leman brother’s report gives the WACC
13.02%.We have analyzed the DCF sensitivity with respect to different scenarios with different
combination of growth rates and cost of capital. Our fair price for the stock will based on the
terminal growth rate of 8%, owing to higher growth rate in automobile and infrastructure
segment which is the major contribution in steel industry.
6. BUSINESS ANALYSIS
Steel Authority of India Limited (SAIL) is among the top ten public sector, steel maker in India.
It is a fully integrated iron and steel maker, producing both basic and special steels for domestic
construction, engineering, power, railway, automotive and defense industries and for sale in
export markets. Its strength has been the diversified range of quality steel products catering to the
domestic, as well as the export markets and a large pool of technical and professional expertise.
The company has the distinction of being India’s largest producer of iron ore and of having the
country’s second largest mines network. This gives SAIL a competitive edge in terms of captive
availability of iron ore, limestone, and dolomite which are inputs for steel making.
SAIL incorporated in 1973 by Government of India. It’s headquarter is situated at New Delhi.
The chairman of SAIL is Mr.S.K.Roongta. It has five major steel plant units at Bhilai, Bokaro,
Durgapur, Rourkela, & Burnpur and three special steel plants at Salem, Durgapur & Bhadravati.
All the units having combined capacity of 15.2 Mt of crude steel and 12.5 Mt of saleable steel.
SAIL was made responsible for managing five integrated steel plants at Bhilai (production
capacity of 4.22 MTPA saleable steel), Bokaro (3.86 MTPA), Durgapur (1.7 MTPA), Rourkela
(1.94 MTPA) and IISCO (west Bengal) (0.40 MTPA). It also manages the Alloy Steel Plant (0.14
MTPA), the Salem Steel Plant (0.18 MTPA) and the Visvesvaraya Iron and Steel Plant (.13
MTPA). It has a subsidiary in Maharashtra (Maharashtra Elektromelt Limited).
TYPES PRODUCTS
Blooms, Billets,
Semis product Slabs
Structural crane rail bars,
Rods & Rebars,
Long product Wire rods
HR coils, Sheets & skelp,
Plates, CR coils& sheets,
GC sheets/Gpsheets,
Flat products Coils tinplates, Electrical steel
Tubular products Pipes
Rail wheels, Axles,
Railway products Wheel sets
A. Consultancy Services Design & Engineering Bankable project proposals, Detailed project reports etc.
Services
Project Management Plant erection & construction, Procurement & inspection, project planning,
Services Monitoring & Supervision
HR and Training Services Training Needs Assessments and Training Module Development, Setting up
Training Systems and Facilities
B.Management Services . Total Quality Management and ISO: 9001 Certification Assistance, Corporate
Planning, Benchmarking, Corporate Restructuring, Software Development and
System Design etc.
C. Research & Development - Transfer of technologies, contract research, specialized testing services & Training
7.4. Promotion
For promotion SAIL has adopted 79 villages as model steel villages across 8 states for
development of education, roads, sanitation, and medical facilities. It has established 61 primary
health centres and 35 hospitals to provide healthcare services. For awareness of public about the
ranges of products SAIL publish its market share and size.
8. SEGMENTAL ANALYSIS
It, s major plants are located in eastern
zone and major consumption parts are
located in south & west zones. Bhilai
steel plant contributes 36 % of
revenue; it produces 3.15 MT of
saleable steel. Bokaro steel plant
contributes 24% of total revenue.
Rourkela steel plant produces 1.67 MT
of saleable steel whereas Durgapur
steel plant produces 1.58 MT of
saleable steel annually.
Source: Bseindia
8.1. Competition
Rivalry is intense due to pressure from both Indian and foreign companies which may affect its
revenues. The Indian Steel industry is highly competitive. As an Integrated steel manufacturer
company’s direct competitors includes:
Tata Steel – It is a largest private sector steel company, incorporated in 1907. Tata
Steel’s products include hot and cold rolled coils and sheets, galvanized sheets, tubes,
wire rods, rings and bearings.
ISPAT – It is also one of the largest producers of HRC in India. It has signed a MOU
with Jharkhand government for setting up a 1980MW coal based power plant.
JSW – It is 3rd largest steel maker in India, consisting of most modern, eco- friendly steel
plants with the latest technologies for both upstream & downstream processes.
8.2. Issues, concerns and Challenges
Major Producers
Also known as Integrated Steel Producers (ISPs), this group includes large steel producers with
high levels of backward integration and capacities of over 1 MT. Steel Authority of India Limited
(SAIL), Tata Steel, JSW Steel Limited (JSWSL), Essar Steel Limited (Essar) and Ispat Industries
Limited (Ispat) form this group. SAIL, TISCO and RINL produce steel using the blast
furnace/basic oxygen furnace (BF/BOF) route that uses iron ore, coal/coke as the basic input mix
for producing finished steel, Essar and Ispat employ Electric Arc Furnace (EAF) route that uses
sponge iron, melting scrap or a mix of both as input and JSWSL uses COREX, a revolutionary
technology for making steel using basically iron-ore and coal.
Capacity expansion-SAIL has drawn up aggressive modernization & expansion plans of all the
plants and mines simultaneously to achieve hot metal production of over 26.2 million tones by
the year 2012 from current level of 14.4 million tones.
Launch of new products -The Company introduced several new products in the domestic market
during the year:
HCR-EQR TMT for earthquake resistant construction
Rock bolt TMT for tunnel construction
EN series HR coils for LPG cylinders
MC 12 HR coils for chains etc.
Bhilai Steel Plant developed high strength vanadium rails
Durgapur Steel Plant produced S-profile loco wheels for high speed locos and
Rourkela Steel Plant rolled special plates which were used in the indigenously
built rocket PSLV C-7
10.4. MOU
MOU with ministry of Railways, NMDC and state Government of Chhattisgarh f for
construction of a new Railway line from Dall Rahjehra to Jagdalput via Rowghat.
MOU signed between SAIL, RINL and NMDC for setting up a green field Steel
Plant in Chhattisgarh
Government of India has given formal approval for development of SEZ in the area
adjoining Salem Steel Plant. SAIL will be developing SEZ in collaboration with IL&FS
IDC
10.5. Focus on Value Added Product, Rural Demand & Distribution channel
SAIL today is one of the largest industrial entities in India. Its strength has been the diversified
range of quality steel products catering to the domestic, as well as the export markets and a large
pool of technical and professional expertise. It is also undertaking promotion programmes where
it brings new products in the market. Its new products include Earthquake resistant TMT wire
rods with improved corrosion resistance, e-payment and e-receipts introduced for customer
services, Armor steel plates for defense sector, Low carbon HR/CR steel for auto bodies, Wide
area network through VSAT installed in all mines. Largest distribution network-covers 602 (out
of 603) districts & crossing 2000 dealers in India.
Balance Sheet of Steel Authority of India Ltd.
Particulars FY08 FY09 FY10(E) FY11(E) FY12(E) FY13(E) FY14(E)
Gross Asset 309,227.30 327,286.90 408,659.75 428,678.16 721,055.15 741,015.15 756,559.43
Accumulated Depriciation 193,514.20 204,598.60 218,052.90 233,510.40 253,858.37 277,557.77 305,075.41
Capital WIP 23,895.50 65,442.40 64,069.55 264,051.14 1,674.15 1,714.15 1,169.87
Net Fixed Asset 139,608.60 188,130.70 254,676.40 459,218.90 468,870.93 465,171.53 452,653.89
Investments & Deposits 5,382.00 6,527.00 10,527 5,527 5,527 15,527 25,527
Investment & Deposits/(Cash+Inv &deposits) 3.76% 3.46% 4.20% 4.20% 4.20% 4.20% 4.20%
Current Asset 263,176.20 345,108.70 335,699.20 345,866.07 381,746.45 491,220.40 628,272.39
Cash (balancing figure) 137,594.40 182,285.30 192,323 180,986 182,293 236,238 338,704
Other Current Assets 2,730.80 10,144.70 4,930.59 6,839.60 10,572.47 10,495.13 12,886.55
Inventories 68,572.30 101,214.50 86,406.97 97,542.73 116,810.93 153,774.48 171,722.73
Trade Debtors 30,481.20 30,243.60 30,036.49 34,508.59 42,181.73 52,908.48 61,432.63
Loans and Advances 23,797.50 21,220.60 22,001.94 25,988.66 29,888.80 37,804.42 43,526.89
Interest Receivable/Accrued
Current Liabilities & Provisions 131,987.50 171,216.00 145,891.53 167,613.16 220,642.87 256,984.05 298,387.04
Net Current Asset 131,188.70 173,892.70 189,807.67 178,252.91 161,103.57 234,236.35 329,885.35
Miscellaneous Items 594.80 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Deffered Tax (Net)
Total net assets 276,774.10 368,550.40 455,011.06 642,998.81 635,501.50 714,934.88 808,066.24
Non-Current Liabilities
Secured Debt 9,253.10 14,736.00 34,336.67 63,835.51 37,907.70 35,811.13 29,586.21
Non-secured debt & Trade deposit 21,199.30 60,651.90 83,845.66 178,619.75 113,865.45 97,880.14 84,073.18
Deferred Tax Liabilities 15,686.00 13,321.50 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Deferred Paymaent Credit 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Total Liabilities 46,138.40 88,709.40 118,182.33 242,455.26 151,773.15 133,691.27 113,659.40
Contingent Liabilities
Share Capital 41,304.00 41,304.00 41,304.00 41,304.00 41,304.00 41,304.00 41,304.00
Reserve and Surplus 189,331.70 238,537.00 295,524.74 359,239.56 442,424.35 539,939.60 653,102.84
Total Stock Holder's Equuity 230,635.70 279,841.00 336,828.74 400,543.56 483,728.35 581,243.60 694,406.84
Total liabilities and stockholder's Equity276,774.10 368,550.40 455,011.07 642,998.81 635,501.50 714,934.87 808,066.24
Profit and Loss Account of SAIL
Particulars FY05 FY08 FY09 FY10(E) FY11(E) FY12(E) FY13(E) FY14(E)
Net Sales 412446.40 431500.80 429092.74 492979.88 648949.63 755835.45 877608.94
% Growth 17.36% 4.62% -0.56% 14.89% 31.64% 16.47% 16.11%
Total Revenue 425475.20 450524.00 450842.01 510395.94 671875.81 782537.71 908613.23
% Growth 18.24% 5.89% 0.07% 13.21% 31.64% 16.47% 16.11%
EXPENDITURES
Staff Costs 79190.20 84015.10 59216.14 79065.94 104080.95 121223.70 140754.18
% of Net Sales 19.20% 19.47% 13.80% 16.04% 16.04% 16.04% 16.04%
Other Manufacturing/Operating costs 179632.50 229826.30 234593.19 254441.18 334941.68 390108.55 452959.37
% of Net Sales 43.55% 53.26% 54.67% 51.61% 51.61% 51.61% 51.61%
Miscellaneous Expenses 26796.20 38228.20 33621.00 37770.68 49720.63 57909.91 67239.84
% of Net Sales 6.50% 8.86% 7.84% 7.66% 7.66% 7.66% 7.66%
Total Expenditures 285618.90 352069.60 327430.33 371277.80 488743.26 569242.15 660953.39
% of Net Sales 69.25% 81.59% 76.31% 75.31% 75.31% 75.31% 75.31%
EBITDA 126827.50 90234.70 101662.40 121702.08 160206.37 186593.30 216655.56
EBITDA Margin % 30.75% 20.91% 23.69% 24.69% 24.69% 24.69% 24.69%
Growth % 22.04% -28.85% 12.66% 19.71% 31.64% 16.47% 16.11%
Depreciation & Amortisation 12354.80 12851.20 13454.30 15457.50 20347.97 23699.40 27517.64
EBIT 114472.70 77383.50 88208.10 106244.58 139858.40 162893.90 189137.92
Financial Charges 2509.40 2532.40 3636.96 4789.72 7589.08 7664.72 9016.75
Other Income 13028.80 19023.20 21749.28 17416.06 22926.18 26702.26 31004.29
Inter Account &Adjustments pertaining to earlier years 0.00 0.00
PBT 124992.10 94034.50 106320.41 118870.92 155195.51 181931.44 211125.46
Pre-tax Margin % 30.31% 21.79% 24.78% 24.11% 23.91% 24.07% 24.06%
Tax 39319.50 32286.40 35085.74 39227.40 51214.52 60037.38 69671.40
Effective Tax Rate % 31.46% 34.33% 33.00% 33.00% 33.00% 33.00% 33.00%
Adjusted PAT 85672.60 61748.10 71234.68 79643.52 103980.99 121894.07 141454.06
Net Profit Margin % 20.77% 14.31% 16.60% 16.16% 16.02% 16.13% 16.12%
Growth in Adjusted PAT % 32.47% -27.93% 15.36% 11.80% 30.56% 17.23% 16.05%
Extrodinary Income 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Reported PAT 85672.60 61748.10 71234.68 79643.52 103980.99 121894.07 141454.06
Shares In Issue 4130.81 4131.71 4131.71 4131.71 4131.71 4131.71 4131.71
Adjusted EPS 20.74 14.94 17.24 19.28 25.17 29.50 34.24
Growth % 32.39% -27.94% 15.36% 11.80% 30.56% 17.23% 16.05%
Changes in Current Assets (excluding cash) (17893.90) (37241.60) 19447.40 (21503.58) (34574.35) (55528.57) (34586.30)
Changes in Current Liabilities 22872.90 39228.50 (25324.47) 21721.63 53029.72 36341.18 41402.99
Changes In WC(CA-CL) 4979.00 1986.90 (5877.07) 218.04 18455.37 (19187.39) 6816.69
Cash Generated From Operations 143541.40 110233.00 117534.61 139336.18 201587.92 194108.17 254476.53
Direct Taxes Paid 39319.50 32286.40 35085.74 39227.40 51214.52 60037.38 69671.40
Others 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Net Cash Generated From Operations 104221.90 77946.60 82448.88 100108.78 150373.41 134070.79 184805.13
Capital Expenditure (CAPEX) (22010.50) (59606.50) (80000.00) (220000.00) (30000.00) (20000.00) (15000.00)
Investments (244.10) (1145.00) (4000.00) 5000.00 0.00 (10000.00) (10000.00)
Others 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Net Cash Used In Investing Activities (22254.60) (60751.50) (84000.00) (215000.00) (30000.00) (30000.00) (25000.00)
Net Increase in Cash and Cash Equivalents 41496.10 44690.90 10037.90 (11336.71) 1306.03 53945.38 102465.69
Cash and cash equivalents At the beginning 96098.3 137594.4 182285.3 192323.2 180986.49 182292.52 236237.9
Net Increase in Cash and Cash Equivalents 41496.10 44690.90 10037.90 -11336.71 1306.03 53945.38 102465.69
Cash and cash equivalents At the end 137594.40 182285.30 192323.20 180986.49 182292.52 236237.90 338703.59
Financial Ratio