B Plan 9
B Plan 9
B Plan 9
Page | 1
INDEX
1. Executive Summary
2. Category / Product / Service Description
3. Market Analysis and Customer Segmentation
4. Market Entry Strategies
5. Competitive Analysis
6. Organization Structure
7. Strategy and Implementation Plan
8. Operations Management, Sourcing and Supply Chain
9. Financial Statements (Funding, Ratios, Break-Even Analysis, Financial
Projections for next 5 years)
Page | 2
Page | 3
has led to a lot of health related problems and disorders. This gap faced especially by
working couples and students is what needs to be addressed.
At NutriPlate, we address the need of healthy eating and generating awareness about
the benefits of nutritious food on lifestyle. We combine the elements of hygiene, healthy,
taste, and convenience for our calorie conscious customers. Our business concept is to
give a healthier twist to everyday cooking. Now more than ever, people are looking for
health benefits in their food choices. As a result, they are redefining the value of food
beyond simply taste, price, and convenience.
Our target audience are office goers, working women, students to whom we can provide
diet food tiffins at location convenient to them, may that be office or home or educational
institutions. The tiffin business is thriving and is unorganized in nature. With the plush of
working professionals in India, food is an undying business. With innovation in terms of
variety in meals catering to the vegetarians and non-vegetarians, a health check up
card to map the progress of the customer and packaging of food, we wish to change the
tiffin industry and bring about a formidable change in the eating habits of Indian.
Page | 4
Objectives:
1. To enhance the portability and accessibility of health food
2. To liberate the Indian working class from the hassles of everyday cooking
3. To create a service based company with the primary goal to address the
customer needs in terms of good quality and nutritious food which also provides
energy.
Mission:
1. To provide the customer with tasty yet nutritious food.
2. Become a household tiffin name for every working class Indian.
3. Meeting more than the customers expectations
Philosophy:
Our philosophy is to provide healthy diet food made under hygienic conditions
and the best quality health food for our health conscious customers.
Page | 5
sCategory Description
The Indian Food Retail Category:
India is the world's second largest producer of food next to China, and has the potential
of being the biggest with the food and agricultural sector. The total food production in
India is likely to double in the next ten years and there is an opportunity for large
investments in food and food processing technologies, skills and equipment. Health
food and health food supplements are another rapidly rising segment of this industry
which is gaining vast popularity amongst the health conscious. One of most promising
sub-sectors or verticals is the ready to eat/packaged food/tiffin service options.
Growing at the rate of 30%, the Indian food retail is going to be the major driving force
for the retail industry. Food accounts for the largest share of consumer spending. Food
and food products account for about 50% of the value of final private consumption. The
Indian food industry is projected to grow by US$ 100 billion to US$ 300 billion by 2015.
And the retail food sector which is currently at US$ 70 billion is expected to rise to US$
150 billion by 2025.
There are various factors paving the way to revolutionizing food retailing in India.
Among them few are:
Page | 6
According to Euro-monitor, Indians spend US$ 64 billion annually on eating out, which
includes $13 billion on eating in quick-service restaurants (QSRs) such as McDonald's
and Costa Coffee, propelling the industry to grow at 25-30 per cent annually.
Data-monitor states that the role of working women is also one of the driving forces for
the growth of the Ready to eat market in India. This is as women today have very little
time to get involved in regular household chores like cooking. They would prefer to have
eat a freshly cooked meal which caters to all their needs than make one.
Lifestyle changes have necessitated modifications in most urban Indians' diet regime in
terms of meal time fragmentation and diet diversification. With these changes, it has
increasingly become a challenge for Indians to maintain a diet that is balanced and
convenient, yet caters to the Indian taste buds. The desire to eat fresh food among
Indians is currently so prominent that it even overshadows the desire for consumers to
seek variety and authenticity. This was corroborated by the findings of the recent Datamonitor consumer survey, where consumers across all the age groups said that they
value 'Freshness' claims more than authenticity and originality.
Product description:
We would call ourselves as the modern day dabbawalla. Observing the need for health
food at corporate offices, hostels and alike, we idea-ted on a business for cooking and
delivering diet food. We not only use the supply chain of the local dabbawallas but also
supply meals that are low calorie-d.
Our body converts the food we eat into energy. The unit of measurement of this energy
is the Calorie. The foods we eat differ in their calorie content; some are calorie rich
mithai and oily subzis while others are less so salads and fruits. The extra calories
which your body does not burn are converted and stored as fat.
Page | 7
The essence of managing your weight is balancing the amount of calories you eat with
the amount of calories you burn or use in your daily life.
Getting your calorie intake right is just the first step. Even more important is ensuring
that you get calories from the right sources. Foods vary in the amount of calories they
contain. At NutriPlate, we provide balanced, calorie counted meals. Each meal is sent to
you with the number of calories and constituent nutrients
The best way to manage your weight is to watch what you are eating and to increase
your activity as simple as a 30 minute walk in the morning / evening / post lunch.
However, since people are restricted by time, work, commitments, etc. it makes it
difficult for them to go for walks or indulge in physical activity which is where NutriPlate
bridges the gap. One can be fit by maintaining a healthy and nutritional food intake.
NutriPlate is targeted at the young corporates who are restricted by time to carry their
own home-cooked diet meal that helps them stay active. The working couples, students
staying as paying guests or in hostels that never had an option for diet meals can now
look forward to our service. A significant lifestyle improvement can take place with our
services. People suffering from metabolic disorders and weight issues will benefit the
maximum.
Procurement:
A vendor selected on the basis of competitive bidding would be signed up. Traders from
APMC market at Vashi (the wholesale grain and vegetable market) would be given
contracts for continuous supply of whole grains, vegetables, fruits, spices and other
daily consumables. The supply from this market would enable NutriPlate to achieve
economies of scale, raw materials at wholesale prices and help in cost cutting while
maintaining quality. The contract will be renewed on a yearly basis.
Page | 8
dabbawallas, all with an extremely small nominal fee and with utmost punctuality.
According to a recent survey, they make less than one mistake in every 6 million
deliveries, despite most of the delivery staff being illiterate.
A collecting dabbawala, usually on bicycle, collects dabbas either from a worker's home
or from the dabba makers. As many of the carriers are illiterate, the dabbas have some
sort of distinguishing mark on them, such as a colour or group of symbols.
About The Nutan Mumbai Tiffin Box Suppliers Trust:
NutriPlate will collaborate with this supply chain to cover a large span of the market
share.
This service was originated in 1880. In 1890, Mahadeo Havaji Bachche started a lunch
delivery service with about 100 men. In 1930, he informally attempted to unionize
the dabbawallas. Later a charitable trust was registered in 1956 under the name
of Nutan Mumbai Tiffin Box Suppliers Trust. The commercial arm of this trust was
registered in 1968 as Mumbai Tiffin Box Supplier's Association. The present President
of the association is Sopan Laxman Mare. Nowadays, the service often includes
cooking of food in addition to the delivery.
A collecting dabbawala, usually on a bicycle, will collect dabbas from the NutriPlate
kitchen after NutriPlate has successfully packed the tiffins. As the dabbawallas are
illiterate, we will be marking a code on each dabba. An example of a code, VLP 9E12 E
3.
This means,
VLP= Vile Parle (Suburb in Mumbai)
9E12= Code for dabbawallas at destination
E= Express Towers (Building name)
12= Floor number
E= Code for dabbawallas at residential station
3= Code for destination station (eg. Nariman Point)
Page | 10
The dabbawala will then take them to a designated sorting place, where he and other
collecting dabbawallas sort (and sometimes bundle) the lunch boxes into groups. The
grouped boxes are put in the coaches of trains, with markings to identify the destination
of the box (usually there is a designated car for the boxes). The markings include the
rail station to unload the boxes and the building address where the box has to be
delivered. At each station, boxes are handed over to a local dabbawala, who delivers
them. The empty boxes, after lunch, are again collected and sent back to the NutriPlate.
The service is almost always uninterrupted, even on the days of severe weather such
as monsoons. Dabbawallas are generally well accustomed to the local areas they cater
to, and use shortcuts and other low profile routes to deliver their goods on time.
Delivery:
For Lunch a customer can avail of any of the two depending on his location.
1. Dabbawallas- Only for Lunch & services spanning entire city
Page | 11
The cuisines that inspire our menu are Indian (South Indian, Gujarati, Rajasthani) and
Continental.
Variety offered:
Everyday meals Lunch and Dinner
We at NutriPlate understand the importance of satisfying the taste buds of people with a
sweet tooth. Hence, our menu consists of dessert. NutriPlate maintains this 3 course
meal for both Lunch and Dinner.
For example:
Starters
Alternate 1
Alternate 2
Meal
Dessert
chapattis/brown rice
Theplas
low-fat halwa
low-fat custard
Page | 12
are provided meet specific requirements and characteristics, such as being dependable,
satisfactory, safe and fiscally sound.
Quality control also might involve evaluating people. If a company has employees who
don't have adequate skills or training, have trouble understanding directions or are
misinformed, the quality of the company's products or services might be diminished.
This is especially important for service-oriented companies, because the employees are
the product that they provide to customers.
NutriPlates Quality Control will measure and strive to improve quality in 4 different
departments of the business.
Quality Control spanning different departments
Operations
Human Resource
Efficiency of employees
Environment
Page | 13
2. Packaging:
Once the meal is prepared, it will go through a round of quality check, right from
its taste to right amount of quantities filled in clean containers to its packing. The
packaging of the meal will differ from lunch to dinner.
Since Lunch is delivered by the Dabbawallas and collected on the return route,
tiffin boxes are used to pack the meals for lunch. However, since the area under
delivery for dinner meals are restricted to nearby locations, delivered in our NutriPlate
Van, the packing of the meals differs. The dinner meals will be packed in Plastic plates,
foil, thermacol and other disposable material.
Portion Control:
One reason that can impact our success and efficiency will lie in portion control. The
cooks will know exactly how much of each ingredient to put in every dish while the
packing department will ensure the right amount of quantity in each tiffin and each plate
for lunch and dinner respectively.
Pricing:
Since our menu contains health food, our prices will be
Lunch
Dinner
Vegetarian
INR 120.00
INR
120.00
Non Vegetarian
INR 160.00
INR
160.00
Jain food
INR 100.00
INR
100.00
Page | 14
Page | 15
5. Bio-citizens are people who form networks based on biological or health similarities,
and who may engage in collective action as a result of their shared identities. The
abundance of social networking tools and platforms now available online has
facilitated the ability of people with similar health values or conditions to share and
generate information. As a result, food and health affinity groups are proliferating
online. We will have an online social networking site, with health affinity groups that
span interests and needs from food allergies, diabetes, new mothers, and people
with hypertension.
6. Assess Green Health in the Purchasing Cycle. Green health is part of the larger
health and wellness trend. Already we see people making a number of tradeoffs in
their food purchasing decisionshealth has joined taste, price, and convenience as
an important dimension of choice for shoppers. Green health, whether it is the
concern for personal health or the sustainability of the environment, may soon begin
to reorder these tradeoffs. For the market segment that is already embracing green
values, it will be important to signal and communicate product attributes that speak
to green values. Some food manufacturers are already including this kind of
information in their packaging, but the demand for all that is green will also extend to
the food retailer as consumers seek companies that are aligned with their values
and aspirations.
7. It was estimated in 2007 that the dabbawala industry was still growing by 5-10% per
annum.
Page | 17
8. Although the service remains essentially low-tech, with the barefoot delivery men as
the prime movers, the dabbawallas have started to embrace technology, and now
allow booking for delivery through SMS. An online poll on the web site ensures that
customer feedback is given pride of place. The success of the system depends on
teamwork and time management. Such is the dedication and commitment of the
barely literate and barefoot delivery men (there are only a few delivery women) who
form links in the extensive delivery chain, that there is no system of documentation
at all.
Page | 18
Market Segmentation
Distinct target populations are addressed by NutriPlate. They are as follows:
1. The first target population is based on their income:
1. Middle Class Clients:
This group does not have a huge amount of income, believes that it is costly
having nutritious packed meals every day, is willing to pay but tries to minimize
the cost. Therefore, we have made Mini and Combo meals for such clients. They
can also buy salads, soups and wraps as individual items from us.
Page | 19
3. The third target population is based on the weight issues people have:
1. Customized diets for gaining weight
2. Customized diets for losing weight
Page | 20
To reach the different groups does not require a distinctly different strategy. What
differentiation it will require is different menu offerings to satisfy the different groups.
The upper-end menu items are cost prohibitive for the middle class target segment.
Page | 21
Page | 22
Our marketing strategy will be based on developing visibility among the potential
customers. This will be accomplished by targeted advertising campaign.
1.
The advertisements will be placed in various local newspapers: This will really be a
cost-effective way to reach the local markets. The rates are generally affordable, as the
paper has a shelf life of at least a week. 90 percent of results come in the first four days,
but results will still come in up to six weeks after delivery. We will try to get an early
right-hand page and design the ad with a benefit-oriented headline.
2.
Magazine Advertising: We will target the working professionals and students through
magazines. With the help of health and wellness magazines, we will target customers
with health and weight issues. It is usually pretty easy to judge who is reading the
magazine by the types of articles, as well as the other advertisers. People reading
magazines will pay attention to the ads, as the ads generally represent their direct
interest. We will use an early right-hand page and make sure that our ad fits the style of
the magazine. We will also use powerful photos to show the benefits after eating food
from NutriPlate. We will also write articles instead of just advertising.
3.
4.
Press Releases: This is where we will fax, or e-mail media outlets a story on our
business and encourage them to publish it as free advertising. We will make sure that
we have a noteworthy angle to our article; it is be well written and print ready. These
articles will be written by experts and professionals who will guide the masses and at
the bottom of the article, we will mention our services and contact details.
5.
Mailbox Drops: We will go full quality and deliver larger catalogs. This is because larger
catalogs seem to be kept and read. We will determine which areas respond the best
and then do them accordingly.
Page | 23
6.
Yellow Pages: Statistics show that more than 35 percent of the people turn to the
Yellow Pages when they are ready to purchase something or need to find information
about a certain service or company. Also, response increases with an increase in ad
size, or Unit Display (UD) size. The increase in responses is one for a 1 UD, four for a 2
UD, seven for a 3 UD, and eleven for a 4 UD. Therefore, the bigger the better. We have
to keep in mind that our readers are already buyers; they are just deciding from whom
they should buy from and, thus in general, they will call three advertisers before making
a decision. Therefore, we will run a benefit-filled headline, use keywords so that people
know what we do and make sure that our phone numbers are big and in the bottom
right-hand corner.
7.
Billboards and posters: Billboards and posters are excellent as a directional medium.
That means we can use billboards to tell people to take the next left, or that you are five
minutes away. We will put up a great picture, and a short, simple headline along with
easy response instructions.
8.
Postcard Mailings: This is where we will send prospects a postcard that advertises our
business. They will make for an ideal teaser- that is, they wont tell the prospects the
whole story.
9.
Internet/ Web pages: People use the internet to research a purchase, so a web page is
a must. We will make sure that we submit our site to all different search engines often.
We will fill our site with interesting information. This is why people will visit us in the first
place.
10.
Host Beneficiary: This is where we will promote ourselves to the customers of another
business. This is especially good when we are friends with the other business people
who have customers who fall into our target market.
11.
Write a book: This is an instant way to develop credibility. We will market ourselves as
experts and give the book away for free in order to get leads. Of course, it neednt be a
full book- a small ten page booklet would be enough.
Page | 24
12.
Seminars and Events: Holding free or paid seminars is a great way to get your
prospects in the same room all at once. Since our service is informational, it will suit our
business. We will ensure that we have good speakers who are interesting to hear as
they would speak about health and wellness being an important ingredient in todays
life. Also our speakers would motivate people to switch from their existing lifestyle to a
new healthy one. The venue for the seminar would be centrally located with ample
parking. We will also check what time our target market prefers-some groups prefer
morning while others an evening seminar.
13.
Referrals: We will reward people who introduce their friends to us and turn them into
our customers. The key is not taking referrals for granted but rewarding those who shall
be our best ambassadors.
14.
Testing and measuring can help increase your number of leads: If we want to make a
sale, we first have to generate leads. And if we first want to increase the amount of
business we do, we need to increase the number of leads we generate. We need to get
more people to visit our business with the view of buying from us. But for this, we need
to know the methods that will work to increase our leads. If we dont know whats
working and whats not, we cant possibly make informed decisions. We may keep
running an ad that never results in a sale. We will create a tally sheet and include all
the possible ways people could hear about us. We will keep records of where all leads
are derived from and how much they spend. We will monitor how every single product
sells, and why it sells.
15.
Increase Range or Variety: The more you have, the more options you can give the
customer, and the more individual tastes you can cater to. This will also give us a more
competitive edge over the others.
16.
Sample meals and Demonstration videos: People like to see with their own eyes, and
experience the product before they buy. We will offer a sample meal to the prospects
and also upload various videos online showing our hygienic procedures and the look of
the nutritious and tasty food when ready.
Page | 25
17.
Increase product knowledge: We understand that people like to buy from people who
seem to know what theyre talking about. It gives them a sense of security. Hence, we
will ensure that all our team members are as well educated about our products and
services as we are.
18.
Sell on Emotion and Dreams: People tend to make their decisions based on emotion,
not logic. In fact, emotion represents 88 percent of most purchasing decisions. We will
emphasize on how our service is going to change their lives. We will focus on the
emotional benefits of our service and spell out the benefits. We will also ask emotionally
focuses questions.
19.
Site tours: Inviting people to take a tour of our site will really boost our credibility. If
people see how things are made, and how diligently the workers smile and work, they
are more likely to believe us when we talk about quality.
20.
Under promise and Over deliver: We will actually do more than we promise. We believe
that if we just do what we promise, we will probably get our customers back the next
time. But if you do what you promise plus a whole lot more than they were expecting,
we will have customers for life.
21.
Run a Frequent Buyers Program or VIP Card: This will be for prospects that are not
interested in our full course meals but may be interested in our individual items like
salads, soups, wraps etc. This is a classic method of getting customers back. We will
give them a card that will get stamped each time they buy. We will offer every tenth
purchase for free.
22.
Social groups: We will also form social groups where people feel that they belong
somewhere. People with similar problems or goals can be a part of one group. Here,
they can help each other by sharing new ideas and thoughts and also motivating each
other. Our counselors will also be a part of these groups and guide them along.
Page | 26
Competitive Analysis
Our competitors are any providers of prepared foods; this includes food vendors,
restaurants and street food carts. We compete with them by offering a more user
friendly ordering system, providing hygienic and healthy food, offering a variety of food
choices and aiming to reduce weight and metabolic issues.
A survey found that the major problems with tiffin companies were employee turnover,
inconsistent food quality because of shifting suppliers, and dirty food containers
(particularly stains on the plastic containers). Customers surveyed indicated
dissatisfaction with existing tiffin suppliers. They also complained of food being
tasteless, unhygienic and unhealthy. Based on this survey, it can be inferred that there
is room for improvement in food quality and delivery. Also, one noted trend among
these tiffin suppliers is the switch from metal tiffins to the use of plastic tiffins, which
leads to significant waste and issue of stains highlighted above. We wish to fill this wide
gap and generate happier and highly satisfied customers.
Our Competitive Edge
Our competitive edge is the attention to servicing customers and an inventive approach
to cuisines. By making customer satisfaction a priority, over time, the local customers
will come to appreciate the attention that their needs are given and will form a long
lasting relationship with us. Also, with our innovative approach to food meals, we will
take the knowledge of innovative cuisine and will create inventive, colourful and
delicious alternatives.
Page | 27
Management/Organization Structure
Since we are new in the market, we begin as a Flat Organization structure.
A Flat organization (also known as horizontal organization) refers to an organizational
structure with few or no levels of intervening management between staff and managers.
The idea is that well-trained workers will be more productive when they are more
directly involved in the decision making process, rather than closely supervised by many
layers of management.
This structure is generally possible only in smaller organizations or individual units
within larger organizations. When they reach a critical size, organizations can retain a
streamlined structure but cannot keep a completely flat manager-to-staff relationship
without impacting productivity. Certain financial responsibilities may also require a more
conventional structure. Some theorize that flat organizations become more traditionally
hierarchical when they begin to be geared towards productivity.
The flat organization model promotes employee involvement through a decentralized
decision-making process. By elevating the level of responsibility of baseline employees
and eliminating layers of middle management, comments and feedback reach all
personnel involved in decisions more quickly. Expected response to customer feedback
becomes more rapid. Since the interaction between workers is more frequent, this
organizational structure generally depends upon a much more personal relationship
between workers and managers.
Page | 28
Managers of departments
Production
Finance
Research
Sales
Working Teams
Personnel Plan:
1. Dieticians/nutritionists: Two
Two dieticians cum nutritionists will be hired for rendering their services to NutriPlate,
their role is defined as:
Designing the menu for Lunch and Dinner they will consider the 3 varieties
offered by NutriPlate Vegetarian, Non-vegetarian, and Jain meals for Lunch and
Dinner six menus (3varieties x 2meals) will be planned for the 6 days of the
week. Hence designing 36 combinations of meals per month (6per day x 6days)
while conforming to the standard of a 3 course meal.
2. Cooks: Five
Five cooks will be permanently hired to prepare the food for Lunch and Dinner.
Page | 29
These cooks will be rotated for the dinner shift on a daily basis, as the
requirement for the Dinner shift is only three cooks compared to the 5 cooks
working for Lunch. This will also ensure equal distribution of work throughout the
week.
Washing Utensils/tiffins
Cleaning premises
Washing vegetables
Cutting vegetables
4. Packers: Four
Four people will be hired permanently to pack the food in tiffins and provide them to
the customers.
Due to the difference in the order quantity demanded between lunch and dinner,
the idle packers during the night shift will accompany the driver of the delivery
van in delivering the meals to customers.
5. Driver: One
One driver will be employed for the van. He will also be hired permanently.
Page | 30
Search for the vendors for the raw material, food items, packaging material,
utensils and other fixed assets.
Fixing the rotation cycle for the cooks for dinner during the week
Ensuring the employees follow the dress code and guidelines in the premises
regarding cleanliness and hygiene
Page | 31
Manage funds
Personnel plan will be done permanently for tiffin system facility. While for corporate
and other events, personnel planning will be done temporarily and as per requirement.
Page | 32
Customer satisfaction
One of our biggest strengths is that we provide quick service. The biggest advantage of
this is that it saves a lot of time for our customers. And in this modern world, time is
money hence; quick service is the biggest strength for any company
Though our prices are moderate, our quantity is more and hence it is value for our
customers money. It will help us generate more and more happy customers.
The advertisements of our nutritious food will be spread over all around unlike other
typical dabbawallas and tiffin services. This will make us popular in the market and will
add to the appeal .One of the most important people in the buying decision are the kids
who are influenced by the ads they see around them and who in turn influence their
parents. This is because nowadays even kids are conscious of their looks and know the
importance of being strong and healthy while maintaining a toned look. Hence it boosts
the sales.
Weakness:
preferences and taste. The health food industry cannot cater to all the tastes and
Page | 33
preferences of people. For e.g. some people eat Non Veg and some dont eat non
veg, thus creating a problem. .Another difference in preference can be seen in the
choice of the type of food. Some people prefer South Indian while some prefer North
Indian. So we need to appoint different cooks for different cuisines. This increases our
costs
Lack of customization Our tiffin food is usually pre-made and pre-packed and not
fresh from the oven. So once the dish is made it cannot be altered according to the
customers choice or preference. For
decided and after we have dispatched his food pack, he is in the food to have
something else, he will have to place a new order with us and also, it will be very difficult
for us to prepare a new item for him at such short notice.
Opportunity:
Hectic lifestyles: Nowadays, individuals are getting a lot busy with their work. They do
not get even ten minutes to have a proper meal. Hence, they pick up any tit bits from
their nearest canteen and munch on it in five minutes. We have an opportunity here, as
we deliver even small bites to customers who do not have time to eat full course meals.
Threats:
Page | 34
Canned food stuff and ready to eat meals- Nowadays ready to eat products are
more in demand in the market owing to the fact that consumers have to take
minimum trouble in preparation out of which the results are healthy food, rich
nutritional value, easy on pockets and higher value for money as compared to the
foods available from a tiffin service provider.
Page | 35
Distribution channel of Dabbawallas is the backbone for our Lunch meal deliveries. Any discord
with the link will create havoc in our supply chain. To overcome this, we are looking at building
our own distribution channel after the 1st 5 years for the lunch meals through our own delivery
vans
Page | 36
Demand is relatively price inelastic when health conscious customers prioritise their health.
There are few or hardly any substitutes available for diet food meals.
Value Chain
Page | 37
Procurement
Inbound Logistics
Operations
Outbound logistics
Marketing and
Sales
Primary Activities
Services
Sales
and
Marketing-examples:
Customer
management,
Order
taking,
Page | 38
Administrative,
finance
infrastructure-
Legal,
Accounting,
Finance
management
Organizations need to consider not only the behaviour of current competitors, but also
the potential for other organizations to enter the market. The important issue here is
assessing the level of barriers to entry. For example, in sectors where brand recognition
is important, new entrants need to spend heavily to build a brand. In other sectors, the
minimum economic scale of operations may be high, thereby requiring heavy capital
investment by new entrants.
An organization needs to consider not only those competitors offering similar products
or services, but also those offering products or services that may act as substitutes. For
example, cheaper tiffin services now suffer considerable competition from supermarkets
selling high-quality, easily prepared ready meals to eat at home as a substitute for
tasty and easily available food.
Porter argues that the degree of competitiveness or rivalry within an industry depends
on the availability of substitutes, the strength of suppliers and buyers (customers), and
the threat of new entrants (which in turn depends on the ease of entry). Thus health and
wellness research, with its high entry costs, sophisticated technology and patent
protection, has low levels of rivalry and high margins and profitability. Only the growing
power of customers (health services) threatens this profitability. In the restaurant
business, in contrast, the entry barriers and start-up costs are low, customers have a
wide choice and therefore considerable bargaining power, and there is a range of
Page | 39
substitutes. The restaurant trade is highly competitive and margins and profitability are
generally low.
Why eat our tiffin?
a. Our food is prepared from fresh and premium quality ingredients
b. Spice, salt and oil content of the food are low and thus, is suitable for daily
intake.
c. We deliver food in a disposable microwavable packing for dinner and clean steel
utensils for our lunch packed meals
d. Menu for the whole week is designed keeping following parameters in mind:
e. Timely delivery of meal: For our meal delivery, we have a tie up arrangement
with the famous Dabbawallas, who are six sigma certified for delivering right tiffin,
at the right location at the right time.
f. By the virtue of this tie up, we can deliver lunches all across Mumbai. Meal
delivery areas For Lunch:
i.
ii.
iii.
Inbound
logistics
Operations
Outbound
logistics
Marketing
and Sales
Services
Procurement
Infrastructure
Technological Development
Support Activities
Helps an organization identify how it creates value for customers and locate
where its sources of competitive advantage lie.
Page | 41
advantage.
Michael Porter introduced a generic value chain model that comprises a sequence of
activities found to be common to a wide range of firms. (Developed in the early 1985 by
Harvard Business School Professor Michael Porter in his book "Competitive Advantage:
Creating and Sustaining superior Performance").Most mangers know that their
organizations value chain represents the sequence of activities necessary to create a
product or service, produce or deliver it, market and sell it to customers, distribute or
provide it to those customers while ensuring necessary post sales service is completed.
They also know that internal firm infrastructure activities such as human capital
development or procurement support the main stages in the value chain. What
managers sometimes arent as knowledgeable of is the fact that the value chain within a
firm or industry is actually comprised of a very specific model of performance that
depicts the discrete stages of organizational value creation. Further, they dont always
use the model to compare and contract activities across firms for the purpose of
determining where competitive advantages lie.
Profit Margin:
Depends on the Effectiveness in performing these Supporting Activities Efficiently"
- Revenues (customer is willing to pay for the products) must exceed the cost of the
activities in the value chain.
Generate Superior Value: A competitive advantage may be achieved by reconfiguring
the value chain to provide lower cost or better differentiation.
Use the value chain model to define a firm's core competencies and the activities in
which it can pursue a competitive advantage:
Cost advantage: Better understanding and reducing costs
Differentiation: Focus on those activities associated with core competencies and
capabilities
Page | 42
Define the value chain is define via a cost analysis, by assigning costs to the
value chain activities
Accounting reports are studied in order to modify or reallocate costs and produce
value creating activities.
NOTE
1- A firm develops a cost advantage by controlling these drivers better than do the
competitors.
2-
Reconfigure
the
value
chain.
sales
approach.
*Goal: offer the customer a level of value that exceeds the cost of the activities,
Page | 43
resulting in a profit margin. The term Margin implies that organizations realize a profit
margin that depends on their ability to manage the linkages between all activities in the
value chain Porter. In other words, the organization is able to deliver a product / service
for which the customer is willing to pay more than the sum of the costs of all activities in
the value chain.
The model can and should be reconfigured to account for activities specific to the
industry in which the firm competes. For example, in a service industry - such as
professional services - inbound logistics might be replaced with methodology
development or client acquisition. Regardless of industry however, the value chain
Porter is a powerful framework for analyzing both industry and firm specific activities.
Page | 44
Obtain the provisional DIN by filing application Form DIN-1 online. This form
is on the Ministry of Corporate Affairs 21st Century (MCA 21).The provisional
DIN is immediately issued (Provisional DIN is valid for a period of 60 days.
The application form must then be printed and signed and sent for approval
to the ministry by courier along with proof of identity and address:
Page | 45
The concerned authority verifies all the documents and, upon approval, issues a
permanent DIN. It takes about 3-5 days to issue the permanent DIN.
The RoC in Mumbai has staff members working full time on name reservations
(approximately 3 but more if the demand increases). A maximum of 6 suggested
names can be submitted, they are then checked by RoC staff for any similarities
with all other names in India.
The MCA receives approximately 50-60 applications a day. After being cleared
by the junior officer, the name requests are sent to the senior officer for approval.
Once approved, the selected name appears on the website. Applicants need to
keep consulting the website to confirm that one of their submitted names was
approved.
In practice, it takes 2 days for obtaining a clearance of the name if the proposed
Page | 46
3. Pay stamp duties online, file all incorporation forms and documents online
and obtain the certificate of incorporation
For registration, the following forms are required to be electronically filed on the
website of the Ministry of Company Affairs:
The agreement, if any, which the company proposes to, enter into with any
individual for appointment as its managing or whole time director or manager.
A copy of the letter of the Registrar of Companies intimating the availability of the
proper name.
The promoters, as being the subscribers to the Memorandum and Articles should
be the same person whose names are appearing in the original application for
availability of name (e-Form 1A). If the names have changed, ROC will not
register the company until and unless, the name is got re-validated with the new
subscribers as applicants, by paying another fee of Rs 500.
Under the Income Tax Act, 1961, each person must quote his or her permanent
account number (PAN) for tax payment purposes and the tax deduction and
collection account number (TAN) for depositing tax deducted at source. The
Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) has instructed banks not to accept any
form for tax payment (Chalan) without the PAN or TAN, as applicable.
Page | 48
The National Securities Depository Limited (NSDL) has also launched PAN
operations effective June 2004, setting up TIN Facilitation Centers. The PAN
application is made through the above mentioned service centers on Form 49A,
with a certified copy of the certificate of registration, issued by the Registrar of
Companies, along with proof of company address and personal identity. A fee of
INR 94 (plus applicable taxes) applies for processing the PAN application.
IT PAN Service Centers or TIN Facilitation Centers will supply PAN application
forms (Form 49A), assist the applicant in filling up the form, collect filled form and
issue acknowledgement slip. After obtaining PAN from the Income Tax
department, UTIISL or NSDL as the case may be, will print the PAN card and
deliver it to the applicant.
The application for PAN can also be made online but the documents still need to
be physically dropped off for verification with the authorized agent.
5. Obtain a tax account bumber for income taxes deducted at source from the
Assessing Office in the Mumbai Income Tax Department
Page | 49
collecting tax. The provisions of Section 203A of the Income Tax Act require that
all persons who deduct or collect tax at the source must apply for a TAN. The
section also makes it mandatory for the TAN to be quoted in all tax-deducted-atsource (TDS) and tax-collected-at-source (TCS) returns, all TDS/TCS payment
Chalans, and all TDS/TCS certificates issued. Failure to apply for a TAN or to
comply with any of the other provisions of the section is subject to a penalty of
INR 10,000/- .
The application for allotment of a TAN must be filed using Form 49B and
submitted at any TIN Facilitation Center authorized to receive e-TDS returns.
Locations of TIN Facilitation Centers are at www.incometaxindia.gov.in and
http://tin.nsdl.com. The processing fee for both applications (a new TAN or a
change request) is INR 60 (plus applicable taxes).
After verification of application, the same is sent to Income Tax Department and
upon satisfaction the department issues the TAN to the applicant. The national
government levies the income tax. Since outsourcing, any authorized franchise
or agent appointed by National Securities Depository Services Limited (NSDL)
can accept and process the TAN application.
The application for TAN can be made either online TAN can be through the
NSDL website www.tin-nsdl.com or offline. However, after the payment of the fee
by credit card, the hard copy of the application must be. Upon payment of the fee
through credit card, the hard copy of the application is required to be physically
filed with NSDL.
Copy of Income Tax Assessment Order having PAN or copy of PAN card
The applicant fills in an application and is then allotted a social security number.
The Provident Fund registration focuses on delinquent reporting, underreporting,
or non-reporting of workforce size. Provident Fund registration is optional if
workforce size is not more than 20.
As per an internal circular, the code number is to be allotted within 3 days from
the date of submission, if the application is complete in all respects. However, in
many cases applicants have received the intimation letter with the code number
in 12 to 15 days.
As per the Employees' State Insurance (General), Form 01 is the form required
to be submitted by Employer for registration. It takes 3 days to a week for the
Employer Code Number to be issued. The "intimation letter" containing the Code
Number is sent by post to the employer and that takes an additional couple of
days.
benefit, the identity cards will be delivered to the insured persons directly by the
ESI Corporation rather than through the employers.
The ESI Act applies to all establishments employing 20 or more persons. The
ESI Act provides for sickness benefits, medical relief, maternity benefits for
women workers, compensation for fatal and other employment injuries, etc.
Every employee who receives wages up to Rs. 10,000 per month is covered by
this Act.
Page | 54
a. FSSA will be aided by several scientific panels and a central advisory committee
to lay down standards for food safety. These standards will include specifications
for ingredients, containments, pesticide residue and biological hazards and
labels.
b. The law will be enforced through State Commission of Food Safety and local
level officials.
c. Everyone in the food sector is required to get a license or a registration which
would be issued by local authorities.
d. Every distributor is required to be able to identify any food article to its
manufacturer, and every seller to its distributor. Anyone in this sector should be
able to initiate recall procedures if he finds that the food sold had violated
specified standards.
The Food Safety Standards Act brings under one roof all of the followinga. Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, 1954.
b. Fruit Products Order, 1955.
c. Meat & Food Products Order, 1973.
d. Vegetable Oil Products (Control) Order, 1947.
e. Edible Oils Packaging (Regulation), 1988.
f. Solvent Extracted Oil, Deoiled Meal & Edible Flour (Control) Order, 1967.
g. Milk & Milk Products Order, 1992.
h. Any order under essential commodities Act, 1955 (10 of 1955) relating to
food.
The Act also aims to establish a single reference point for all matters relating to food
safety and standards, by moving from multi- level, multi- departmental control to a single
Page | 55
line of command. To this effect, the Act establishes an independent statutory authority
the Food Safety and Standard Authority of India with head office at Delhi. Food Safety
and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) and the State Food Safety Authorities shall
enforce various provisions of the Act. FSSAI has been mandated with the following key
objectives with reference to Registration and Licensing of Food Business Operators:
Framing of Regulations to lay down the Standards and guidelines in relation to
articles of food and specifying appropriate system of enforcing various standards
thus notified.
In exercise of the powers conferred under section 92 of the Food Safety and Standards
Act, 2006, FSSAI has proposed Draft of Food Safety and Standards Regulation, 2010
under which Part 3.2 makes it mandatory for all Food Business Operators in the country
to be registered or licensed in accordance with the procedures laid down in the
regulation. Hence Licensing or Registration of Food Business Operators (FBOs) shall
be an important activity under FSSAI; this not only envisages integrating the individual
licensing activities of various divisions of FSSAI under a single Licensing System, at
Central or State Level, but also requires Registration of all Food Business Operators
using Local Administration Bodies, when their activity does not require a License. All of
these are covered under the Food Safety & Standards Regulation, 2010 under
deliberation.
Page | 56
Personnel hygiene
Portability of water
Product Standards
This order was earlier implemented by Ministry of Food Processing Industries (now by
FSSAI) through the Directorate of Fruit & Vegetable Preservation, Headquarter at New
Delhi. The Directorate has five regional offices with headquarter located at Delhi,
Mumbai, Kolkata, Chennai and Guwahati as well as a sub-office at Lucknow under
Northern Region. The field officers of the Regional Offices undertake periodic
inspections of the manufacturing units to ensure maintenance of hygienic conditions in
the factory and draw random samples of products from the factories as well as from
markets which are analyzed in the laboratories to test their conformity according to the
specifications laid under FPO.
The Central Fruit Product Advisory Committee comprising of the officials of concerned
Government Departments, Technical experts, representatives of Central Food
Technology Research Institute, Bureau of Indian Standards, Fruits and Vegetable
Processing Industry and Consumer Organization for recommending amendments in the
Fruit Product Order.
growing animal protein in India. Per capita consumption of meat products has grown
from 870 grams in 2000 to about 1.68 kg in 2005.This is expected to grow to 2Kg in
2009.
Indian consumers prefer to buy fresh meat from the wet market, rather than processed
or frozen meats. A mere 6% of production (about 100,000 MT) of poultry meat is sold in
processed form. Of this only about 1% undergoes processing into value added products
(Ready-to-eat/ Ready-to-cook). Processing of large animals is largely for the purpose of
Exports.
Meat & Meat Products are highly perishable in nature and can transmit diseases from
animals to human-beings. Processing of meat products is licensed under Meat Food
Products Order,(MFPO) 1973 which was hitherto being implemented by Ministry of food
Processing industries w.e.f. 19.03.2004 on being transferred from the Directorate of
Marketing Inspection, Ministry of Agriculture.
The main objectives of the MFPO, 1973 are to regulate production and sale of meat
food products through licensing of manufacturers, enforce sanitary and hygienic
conditions prescribed for production of wholesome meat food products, exercise strict
quality control at all stages of production of meat food products, fish products including
chilled poultry etc.
Under the provision of MFPO all manufacturers of meat food products engaged in the
business of manufacturing, packing, repacking, relabeling meat food products meant for
sale are licensed but excluding those manufacturers who manufactures such products
for consumption on the spot like a restaurant, hotel, boarding house, snack bar, eating
house or any other similar establishment.
Production of meat is governed under local by-laws as slaughtering is a state subject
and Slaughterhouses are controlled by local health Authorities. The current meat
production is estimated at 1.9 million MT; out of which about 21% is exported.
India exports more than 500,000 MT of meat of which major share is buffalo meat.
Indian buffalo meat is witnessing strong demand in international markets due to its lean
Page | 59
character and its near organic nature. India is the 5th largest exporter of bovine meat in
the world. Indian buffalo meat exports have the potential to grow significantly.
Due to emerging health threats of the diseases communicable to Human through meat,
the meat consumers are more vigilant towards the wholesomeness of the meat and
demanding meat and poultry products processed in clean and sanitary environment In
metros and urban areas there are upcoming demands for convenience items such as
semi cooked, ready-to-eat, ready-to-cooked meat food products.
The Standards of quality prescribed under the Schedule have been tightened.
The requirement where which are vogue and non measurable and thus open to
arbitrary interpretation have been done away with.
In order to ensure availability of safe and quality edible oils in packed form at predetermined prices to the consumers, the Central Govt. promulgated on 17th September,
1998, an Edible Oils Packaging (Regulation) Order, 1998 under the Essential
Commodities Act, 1955 to make packaging of edible oils, sold in retail, compulsory
unless specifically exempted by the concerned State Govt.
Salient Features
Edible oils including edible mustard oil will be allowed to be sold only in packed
form from 15th December, 1998.
The packer will have to have his own analytical facilities or adequate
arrangements for testing the samples of edible oils to the satisfaction of the
Government.
Only oils which conform to the standards of quality as specified in the Prevention
of Food Adulteration Act, 1954 and Rules made there under will be allowed to be
packed.
Each container or pack will have to show all relevant particulars so that the
consumer is not misled, so also the identity of the packer becomes clear.
Edible oils shall be packed in conformity with the Standards of Weights and
Measures (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 1977, and the Prevention of Food
Adulteration Act, 1954 and Rules made there under.
The State Governments will have power to relax any requirement of the
packaging order for meeting special circumstances.
Solvent Extracted Oil, De-oiled Meal and Edible Flour (Control) Order, 1967
The Order is basically a quality control order to ensure that the solvent extracted oils in
particular are not reached to the consumers for consumption before the same are
Page | 61
refined and conformed to the quality standards specified in the Order for the purpose.
Standards for the solvent (hexane), which is to be used for extraction of oil from the oilbearing materials, have also been specified so as to eliminate possible contamination of
oil from the solvent used.
Salient Features
Governs the manufacture, quality and movement of solvent extracted oils, deoiled meal and edible flour;
Eliminates the possibility of diversion of the oils for uses not intended.
Prohibit by, offer to buy, use or stock for use, any solvent not conforming to the
quality standards for extraction of vegetable oils, and Specifies particulars to be
declared on the label affixed to the container.
Milk & Milk Product Amendment Regulations - 2009 (MMPR-09) DIVISION (MMPO,
1992 has been renamed as MMPR, 2009 )
Consequent upon de-licensing of Dairy Sector in 1991 under Industrial Development &
Regulation Act, the Department of AH, and Dairying & Fisheries had promulgated the
Milk and Milk Product Order (MMPO) 1992 on 9/6/92 under section 3 of the Essential
Commodities Act 1955. The objective of the order is to maintain and increase the supply
of liquid milk of desired quality in the interest of the general public and also for
regulating the production, processing and distribution of milk and milk products. As per
the provisions of this order, any person/dairy plant handling more than 10,000 liters per
day of milk or 500 MT of milk solids per annum needs to be registered with the
Registering Authority appointed by the Central Government.
There is no restriction on setting up of new dairy units and expansion in the milk
processing capacity, while noting the requirement of registration is for enforcing the
Page | 62
prescribed Sanitary and Hygienic Conditions, Quality and Food Safety Measures as
specified in Vth Schedule of MMPO-1992. In order to comply the provisions of Para 5
(5) (B) of MMPO-92, two inspection agencies i.e. National Productivity Council (NPC)
and Export Inspection Council (EIC) of India have been notified for annual inspection of
registered dairy units, on rotation basis.
As per present provisions, the dairy unit handling up to 200.0 TLPD of milk or 10,000
MT of milk solids per annum. Where the entire activity of procurement, processing and
marketing of the dairy units lies within the State or Union Territory, the Registering
Authority shall be an officer of the concerned State Govt. or U.T. and the dairy unit
handling more than 200.0 TLPD of milk or 10,000 MT of milk solids per annum shall be
registered by the Central Registering Authority. Accordingly Registering Authority shall
deal with applications of registration and issue Registration Certificate under this order
and perform within its jurisdiction.
Since inception the Central and the State Registering Authorities have registered 803
dairy units with combined milk processing capacity 881.50 lakh litres per day in
Cooperative, Private and Government Sector upto 31.03.2008.Further the Central
Registering Authority (CRA) has granted 12 new registration with the milk processing
capacity of 25.0 LLPD (nine dairy unit for milk processing and remaining three units for
marketing / trading), enhanced the milk processing capacity of 14 dairy units and
cancelled the registration of 10-dairy unit during 2008-09.Now it has been subsumed as
milk and milk products regulations under Section-99 of the Food Safety& Standards Act2006 .
Alongwith the licenses mentioned above, NutriPlate being a startup company would
require the following:
1. Registration of our company
2. Electricity and water connection clearance post approval from the respective
Maharashtra government.
Page | 63
Page | 64
From these collection points they assemble at the nearest railway station which
is the Aggregation point
The next mode of transport is the trains where the carriers containing lunch
boxes are transported to the destination railway stations
From every Destination station the dabbas are carried over carts, cycles and
carriers to the destination zones which are given a specific number
From these zones, the lunch boxes are carried to the offices or workplaces which
reach by lunchtime
From here the reverse process of delivering the empty lunch boxes back to
homes starts
All through the above process, there is no slack at any point of time
Traffic Jams, pedestrians, delays in train and signals do not stop the functioning.
The trademark white cap wore by these Dabbawallas are known to everyone
including the police who dont interfere in their process.
Page | 65
2. Coding System
9 RC 14: Code for Dabbawallas at destination. This user code is different for
each customer
3. Employees
All the employees or Dabbawallas are the stakeholders in this organization. This is the
source of their motivation. Most of the employees are illiterate and rest is school
dropouts. However they are literate enough to understand the codes and comprehend
which lunch box belongs where. They are given basic idea about writing the alphabets
and numbers on the boxes on joining the organization. Every Dabbawala takes about 3
hours for completing his assignment and has to cover 60-70 km on foot, carts, cycles
Page | 66
and carriers combined. Alcohol consumption is strictly avoided during work hours. The
employees monthly salary is about Rs.6000 per month.
Key Features of the Dabbawallas organization:
Dabbawallas are well used to the local areas where they are functioning and
make use of short cuts to save time
During the working hours, they do not take a break or rest and thus no slack is
present in the system
They do not use vehicles which require fuel which makes them 0% Fuel reliant
They do not use any modern technology for carrying out the logistics
There are no disputes between the employees and no presence of any union
Unique organization with Six Sigma designation and 99.99% rate of performance
Cost of Service per lunch box = Rs. 450 per month and is standard price for all
Page | 67
Page | 68
J-I-T Inventory
Companies attempt to minimize the amount of inventory they maintain because of the
high cost of holding it. Many inventory holding costs are obvious: financing, warehouse
space, supervision, theft, damage, and obsolescence. Other costs are hidden:
diminished motivation, sloppy work, inattentive attitudes, and increased production time.
Many businesses have been able to simultaneously reduce their inventory holding costs
and increase customer satisfaction by making products available just in time (JIT) for
customer consumption.
For example, Wraps that are cooked to order are fresher and more individualized than
those that are prepared in advance and stored until a customer orders one. Many tiffin
service providers have discovered that JIT systems lead not only to greater customer
satisfaction but also to lower costs through reduced waste.
OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
Operations scheduling forms a very important part and acts as the back bone for the
performance of the manufacturing or the service organizations. With the help of the
operations scheduling, two very important factors or the aspects of the resources within
an organization that can be pertained are as follows
1. Allocating the resources within an organization.
2. Setting up the time table.
It has been observed that the operations scheduling has a direct affect on the
effectiveness of the production function.
Page | 69
Time Schedule:
1. Lunch:
Preparation of vegetables before cooking: 8 am
Pre-packaging preparation: 9 am to 10 am
Page | 70
2. Dinner:
Preparation of vegetables before cooking: 5 pm
This includes washing, boiling, steaming, cutting, sorting of vegetables.
Cooking commencing time: 5.30 pm
Loading: 15 mins
Customer Receival: 8 pm to 9 pm
Page | 71
Efficiency (tiffins)
30
180
720
Vehicle cost
The vehicle used for delivery purpose for dinner meals is a Tata Magic Ace bought on
EMIs of Rs.20,000 per month with an initial deposit of Rs.10,000 which will be paid for
in 12 months since the commencement of business, as the mini-truck is used only for
dinner delivery service.
Page | 72
The Tata Ace is a mini-truck (similar to Japanese Kei truck) launched in May 2005 by
Tata Motors in India. It is in competition with the prevalent three-wheeled goods carriers
from Bajaj Auto, Piaggio, Mahindra and Force Motors.
It has an all-steel cabin. It offers a flexible seating capacity of 4-7 passengers with
adequate legroom which can then be converted to store the 300-odd dinner meals
plates. The Magic offers high fuel efficiency and very low maintenance. The 12-inch
tyres provide higher ground clearance, and the rigid front axle is designed to handle
tough roads. The Magic's turning radius of 4.3 metres (14.1 ft) is nimble enough to
navigate the bylanes and traffic of the suburbs.
Page | 73
The Magic meets BS-III emission norms and has been developed for use in any market
be it urban, semi-urban or rural. It is backed by a 36,000 km/12-month warranty.
Fuel Cost
Mumbai CNG Price = 33.1 Rs/Kg While the Most Recent price change date: Friday,
February 17, 2012.
Following the accounting principle of conservatism, we have assumed the mileage for
1kg CNG is 12km in our vehicle Tata Magic Ace.
Offices, Residences, Paying Guests, Hostels are the target market for the business. We
see a potential market for both Lunch and Dinner. The details of which are given below1. Lunch:
The Dabbawalla Distribution will be used as a channel distribution for Lunch. The
following are the minimum potential demand:
*estimated on the basis of accounting principle of conservatism:
Location
MIDC Andheri
100
100
Lokhandwala
80
churchgate
60
Marine Lines
60
Stock Exchange
60
VT/Crawford/Fort
50
Powai
50
Page | 74
Colaba
50
Dadar
50
lower Parel
40
Total
700
Lokhandwala
50
Juhu
50
Versova
50
Bandra(W)
50
Vile Parle
40
Khar
40
Santa Cruz(W)
20
total
300
Page | 75
Assumptions:
All assumptions have been made in view of the accounting principle of conservatism.
There are no liabilities of the business as everything is paid in Cash and there are no
transactions on credit.
Meal type
part of
lunch QTY.
dinner QTY.
total output
veg
50%
350
150
non veg
35%
245
105
jain
15%
105
45
TOTALS
100%
700
300
Page | 76
Vegetables
After discount
Tomato
INR
INR
20.00
INR
15.00
INR
20.00
40.00
Cucumber
INR
30.00
Carrot
INR
40.00
Onion
Brinjal
INR
INR
15.00
7.50
INR
INR
20.00
INR
30.00
INR
20.00
INR
20.00
INR
20.00
INR
17.50
INR
50.00
INR
45.00
INR
50.00
INR
20.00
INR
20.00
40.00
Peas
INR
60.00
Beans
INR
40.00
Bittergourd
INR
40.00
Cauli - Flower
INR
40.00
Cabbage
INR
35.00
Lettuce
INR
100.00
Spinach
INR
90.00
Coriander
INR
100.00
Capsicum
INR
40.00
Drum Sticks
INR
Page | 77
40.00
Bajri
INR
INR
11.00
INR
35.00
INR
20.00
INR
20.00
INR
20.00
22.00
Fenugreek
INR
70.00
lady finger
INR
40.00
chillies
INR
40.00
ginger
INR
40.00
FRUITS
After discount
Apple
INR
INR
50.00
INR
50.00
INR
50.00
INR
30.00
INR
20.00
100.00
Pomegranite
INR
100.00
Grapes
INR
100.00
Sweet lime
INR
60.00
Papaya
INR
40.00
Coconut
Orange
INR
INR
15.00
7.50
INR
INR
50.00
100.00
However relatively, the discount offered on grains and non vegetarian items are lesser
compared to the economies enjoyed in purchase of vegetables.
Page | 78
Grains
After Discount
Lentils/ Dals
INR
INR
80.00
60.00
INR
INR
40.00
30.00
INR
INR
25.00
15.00
INR
INR
60.00
50.00
Non Vegetarian
After Discount
Chicken
INR
INR
200.00
125.00
INR
INR
190.00
115.00
sugar
Wheat flour
rice
Fish
Types
Veg
INR
24.05
Fruit
INR
36.79
Grains
INR
38.75
Nonveg
INR
120.00
Intake of No. of Units(in grams) of each type in a standard 300 grams meal served
by NutriPlate for Lunch or Dinner
Types
Grams
Kg
veg
125
0.125
INR
Page | 79
3.01
grains
125
0.125
INR
4.60
fruit
50
0.05
INR
1.94
Non veg
125
0.125
INR
15.00
However essential items which cant be quantified for each meal, are assumed to be
100% of this cost, applying the accounting principle of conservatism.
These essentials include:
Salt, Oil, Gas, Detergent, Spices, Ghee, Milk, salt, Olive oil, Butter, etc
INR
per kg
INR
(grain,veg,fruits, essentials)
per kg
1,133.50
68.70
Page | 80
INR
515,227.27
per kg
Purchase of raw material
INR
6,182,727.27
per kg
*The demand per day being 1000 meals per day, with each meal being 300 grams(0.3
kg) and made for 25 working days of the month, the production of meals per month is
7500 kg
3. Employee Salaries
FIXED
salary
Number
total
INR
INR
EMPLOYEES
cooks
20,000.00
dieticians
100,000.00
INR
60,000.00
packers
120,000.00
INR
9,000.00
helpers (all day
INR
operations)
10,000.00
driver
INR
INR
INR
36,000.00
10
INR
100,000.00
12,000.00
INR
12,000.00
Totals
Total salaries per month
INR
368,000.00
INR
Page | 81
4,416,000.00
4. Dabbawalla service
300
35
Carrying capacity of 1
dabbawala
700
20
Hence
% of dabbawallas
0.4 %
INR
2,520,000.00
INR
month
210,000.00
5.
Fixed Assets
Page | 82
Assets:
Capacity
Qty
Rs.
Total
Cost
Modular
6" * 4"
Kitchen
Food
42,000.0
42,000.0
4,000.00
16,000.0
Processor
0
Juicer Mixer
Grinder
4,000.00
16,000.0
0
Electric
5.4l
Cooker
3,000.00
12,000.0
0
Refridgerator
600l
Microwave
30liter
oven
Toasters &
2
60,000.0
120,000.
00
16,000.0
64,000.0
2,400.00
7,200.00
4,000.00
16,000.0
Sanwitch
Makers
Stove/Burner
0
Induction
Cook Top
4,000.00
24,000.0
0
Dish Washer
2
34,000.0
68,000.0
Page | 83
Hand
Water
2,000.00
8,000.00
15,000.0
60,000.0
2,200.00
4,400.00
5,000.00
10,000.0
Blender
Aata Maker
4.5kg
20l
Purifier
Vacuum
Cleaner
0
Lights
10
Celing fans
2,500.00
1,000.00
6,000.00
900.00
2,700.00
35,000.0
70,000.0
8,000.00
16,000.0
exhaust
Fans
Computer &
Assesories
Invertor
250.00
800va
0
Air
1.5l
Conditioner
3star
Coffee
10cup
Maker
Electic Kettle
2
30,000.0
60,000.0
1,500.00
4,500.00
1,500.00
4,500.00
Page | 84
Food
Warmers
2,000.00
10,000.0
0
vessels
idli pans
48
30
pieces
700.00
21,000.0
/tray
saucepans
kadhais
1,500.00
7,500.00
3,000.00
15,000.0
0
spatulas
20
variety
300.00
6,000.00
4,500.00
22,500.0
spoons
saucepots
gallon
s
hometo
Set
8,000.00
24,000.00
wn
Totals
Machinery & Equipment TOTAL
Furniture TOTAL
715,800.00
24,000.00
Page | 85
INR
739,800
INR
493.2
*Assuming life span of fixed assets is 5yrs and 300 working days in a year
In Dec 2012, a vehicle(Tata Magic Ace) bought on 1st Jan 2012 on EMIs of Rs.20,000
for 12months with a deposit of Rs.10,000 becomes a fixed asset for the year 2013.
Hence in The Balance sheets, the value of the vehicle is added in 2013.
A 2nd vehicle (Tata Magic Ace) is bought in the year 2015 on EMIs, which is then again
converted into a fixed asset of Rs.2,40,000 but after assuming a depreciation this value
is now Rs.48000 (assuming life span of 5yrs)
Page | 86
6. Packaging
Per month qty requirement
cost
dinner
Plastic Plates
Foil
lunch
Steel Dabbas
(1time investment)
400.00
Plastic Fork
Total of 1 month
INR 226,666.67
Total of 1 yr
INR 2,720,000.00
7. Utilities
quantity
cost
total/month
requirement
Aprons
38
950.00
300.00
Page | 87
cleaning cloth
10
2,000.00
200.00
38
people)
760.00
20.00
Measuring Cups
10
166.67
200.00
Storage Containers
20
666.67
400.00
Chopping board
5 500
416.67
Brooms
300.00
Cleaning Supplies
(6piece knife)
(combination of items)
Sponges
100.00
2,000.00
500.00
10
100.00
10.00
10
1,000.00
100.00
8. Other Expenses
Particulars
Amt for a yr
for a month
Rent
1440000
120000
Insurance
500000
41666.66667
Maintenance
600000
50000
Page | 88
fuel
14400
1200
Marketing and
240000
20000
Legal
120000
10000
Telephone
12000
1000
240000
20000
Advertisement
(variable)
vehicle
VEG
NON VEG
JAIN
INR
INR
INR
66.25
90.24
50.00
profit %
81.12
77
100
selling price
INR
INR
INR
120.00
160.00
100.00
cost *
When meals per day are 1000 and working days of the year are 300,
Page | 89
INR 14.72
INR 12.00
INR 19.08
INR 43.07
INR 0.49
INR 9.07
Utilities
INR 0.33
Other expenses
INR 10.55
DINNER
REVENUE
VEG
NONVEG
JAIN
TOTAL
INR
INR
42,000.00
18,000.00
INR
INR
39,200.00
16,800.00
INR
INR
10,500.00
4,500.00
INR
INR
91,700.00
39,300.00
Page | 90
Lunch
Dinner
INR
INR
27,510,000.00
11,790,000.0
0
VEG
NON VEG
JAIN
TOTAL
Lunch cost
dinner cost
INR
INR
23,188.50
9,937.93
INR
INR
22,108.89
9,475.24
INR
INR
5,250.00
2,250.00
INR
INR
50,547.39
21,663.17
Cost PER
Lunch
Dinner
15164217.1
6498950.186
YEAR
Now, finding the total revenue and cost per day (for both lunch and dinner).
Using the above four tables we can get,
Page | 91
Revenue
INR
cost
INR
per day
131,000.
per
72,210.5
00
day
per
INR
pe
INR
month
3,275,00
rmo
1,805,26
0.00
nth
3.94
INR
per
INR
39,300,0
yr
21,663,1
per yr
00.00
67.29
vehicle
INR
10,000.00
vendor
565,000.00
TOTAL
INR
DEPOSITS
575,000.00
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
INR
INR
INR
INR
INR
1,260,
1,272,00
1,272,00
1,284,000.00
1,296
000.00
0.00
0.00
,000.
00
We have assumed the mileage for 1kg CNG is 12km in our vehicle Tata Magic
Ace
Prepaid expenses for the consecutive years increases proportionately to the rise
in expenses
Every consecutive year we invest 10% of our profit into the business
We have assumed that our sales grows to 8 % and 9 % for the years 2013-14
and 2014-15 and this implies that our expenses would also increase from 6 %
but it stays constant for 2013-14 and 2014-2015. This anomaly is because we
assume that by the 3rd year we would enjoy economies of scale.
Page | 93
20132012-13
14
2015- 20162014-15
16
2017
sales
growth
7%
8%
9%
9%
12 %
5%
6%
6%
7%
8%
rise in
expenses
Inventory is zero
As we are a food service business where no inventory of finished goods can be
maintained, while inventory of raw materials is also nil, as our vendor contract for
raw material supply states that supplies be made to Nutriplate for 5 days in a
month, to maintain fresh raw material and to avoid wastage of food.
Tax is zero
Financial Statements:
Funding:
It is a critical part for any business. Without money it becomes difficult to carry out day
to day operations. Funding can be availed from banks, friends, family or venture
capitalists.
The NutriPlate project would be funded by the 3 partners themselves. No outside
funding or any bank loan is availed to run the start - up company. Each partner would
bring in capital from own sources into the business.
Ratios:
Financial ratios are useful indicators of a firm's performance and financial situation.
Most ratios can be calculated from information provided by the financial statements.
Financial ratios can be used to analyze trends and to compare the firm's financials to
those of other firms. In some cases, ratio analysis can predict future bankruptcy.
Financial ratios can be classified according to the information they provide. The
following types of ratios are used for our company:
1. Proprietary ratio: This ratio indicates the extent to which Tangible Assets are
financed by Owners Fund.
Proprietary Ratio = (Tangible Net Worth/Total Tangible Assets) x 100
29,126,778.17/1,922,960.00 = 15.15
The ratio will be 100% when there is no Borrowing for purchasing of Assets.
Page | 95
3. Operating Profit:
Operating Profit = Operating Profit/Net Sales x 100
Page | 96
39,300,000.00/1,775,000.00= 22.14
Page | 97
7. Return on Assets:
Return on assets is a measure of how effectively the firm's assets are being used
to generate profits. It is defined as:
Return on Assets = Net Profit After Tax/Total Assets
20,194,552.73/1,922,960.00 = 10.50
39,300,000.00/1,775,000.00 = 22.14
Return on equity is the bottom line measure for the shareholders, measuring the
profits earned for each rupee invested in the firm's stock. Return on equity is
defined as follows:
Page | 98
Page | 99
Breakeven Analysis
NutriPlate Company Ltd
2012
Cost Description
Variable Costs
Cost of Goods Sold
6,283,047
5,188,065
Fixed Costs
Salaries (includes payroll
taxes)
4,416,000
600,000
Advertising
240,000
2,774,400
120,000
1,440,000
Telephone
12,000
Insurance
500,000
Packaging
2,883,200
12,985,600
11,471,112
Page | 100
241,593
Breakeven Analysis
NutriPlate Company Ltd
2012
Cost Description
Variable Costs
Cost of Goods Sold
Raw Materials (only
non veg)
6,283,047
6,182,727
Fixed Costs
Salaries (includes
payroll taxes)
4,416,000
600,000
Advertising
240,000
2,774,400
120,000
1,440,000
Telephone
12,000
Insurance
500,000
Packaging
2,883,200
12,985,600
12,465,775
Page | 101
186,147
Breakeven Analysis
NutriPlate Company Ltd
2012
Cost Description
Variable Costs
Cost of Goods Sold
Raw Materials (only non
veg)
6,283,047
5,188,065
Fixed Costs
Salaries (includes payroll
taxes)
4,416,000
600,000
Advertising
240,000
2,774,400
120,000
1,440,000
Telephone
12,000
Insurance
500,000
Packaging
2,883,200
12,985,600
Page | 102
11,471,112
259,712
Financial Projections:
Opening Day Balance Sheet:
Opening Day Balance Sheet
NutriPlate Company Ltd
Assets
Current Assets
Cash in Bank
Rs.
1,200,000
Utilities
Rs.
8,360
Prepaid Expenses
Rs.
575,000
Rs.
1,783,360
Rs.
715,800
Rs.
24,000
Rs.
739,800
Fixed Assets
Total Assets
Rs.
2,523,160
Page | 103
Rs.
Rs.
Long-term Liabilities
Rs.
Total Liabilities
Rs.
Rs.
2,523,160
Rs.
2,523,160
Current year
2012
Sales
Rs.
39,300,000
Rs.
6,283,047
Gross Profit
Rs.
33,016,953
Rs.
4,416,000
Maintenance
Rs.
600,000
Advertising
Rs.
240,000
Operating Expenses
Page | 104
Rs.
2,774,400
Rs.
120,000
Rs.
1,440,000
Telephone
Rs.
12,000
Insurance
Rs.
500,000
Packaging
Rs.
2,720,000
Total Expenses
Rs.
12,822,400
Rs.
20,194,553
Income Taxes
Rs.
Rs.
20,194,553
1st year
2013
Sales
Cost/ Goods Sold (COGS)
Gross Profit
Rs.
Rs.
Rs.
42,051,000
6,728,160
35,322,840
Operating Expenses
Salary (Office & Overhead)
Maintenance
Advertising
Rs.
Rs.
Rs.
4,636,800
630,000
252,000
Rs.
Rs.
Rs.
Rs.
Rs.
Rs.
Rs.
2,673,120
126,000
1,512,000
12,600
525,000
2,856,000
13,223,520
Page | 105
Rs.
Rs.
Rs.
22,099,320
22,099,320
Page | 106
2nd year
2014
Sales
Cost/ Goods Sold (COGS)
Gross Profit
Rs. 42,444,000
Rs. 6,791,040
Rs. 35,652,960
Operating Expenses
Salary (Office & Overhead)
Maintenance
Advertising
Rs.
Rs.
Rs.
Rs. 2,700,864
Rs.
127,200
Rs. 1,526,400
Rs.
12,720
Rs.
530,000
Rs. 2,883,200
Rs. 13,351,744
Rs. 22,301,216
Rs.
Rs. 22,301,216
4,680,960
636,000
254,400
Page | 107
3rd year
2015
Sales
Cost/ Goods Sold (COGS)
Gross Profit
Rs. 42,837,000
Rs. 6,853,920
Rs. 35,983,080
Operating Expenses
Salary (Office & Overhead)
Maintenance
Advertising
Rs.
Rs.
Rs.
Rs. 2,700,864
Rs.
127,200
Rs. 1,526,400
Rs.
12,720
Rs.
530,000
Rs. 2,883,200
Rs. 13,351,744
4,680,960
636,000
254,400
Page | 108
4th year
2016
Sales
Cost/ Goods Sold (COGS)
Gross Profit
Rs. 42,837,000
Rs. 6,853,920
Rs. 35,983,080
Operating Expenses
Salary (Office & Overhead)
Maintenance
Advertising
Rs.
Rs.
Rs.
Rs. 2,728,608
Rs.
128,400
Rs. 1,540,800
Rs.
12,840
Rs.
535,000
Rs. 2,910,400
Rs. 13,479,968
4,725,120
642,000
256,800
Page | 109
5th year
2017
Sales
Cost/ Goods Sold (COGS)
Gross Profit
Rs. 44,016,000
Rs. 7,042,560
Rs. 36,973,440
Operating Expenses
Salary (Office & Overhead)
Maintenance
Advertising
Rs.
Rs.
Rs.
Rs. 2,756,352
Rs.
129,600
Rs. 1,555,200
Rs.
12,960
Rs.
540,000
Rs. 2,937,600
Rs. 13,608,192
4,769,280
648,000
259,200
Page | 110
Beginning
Projected
2012
2013
Assets
Current Assets
Cash in bank
Prepaid expenses
Total Current Assets
1,200,000.00
Rs.
Rs.
1,260,000.00
575,000
603,750
Rs.
1,775,000.00
1,863,750
Rs.
143,160.00
Fixed Assets
Machinery & equipment
Furniture & fixtures
Rs.
4,800
191,160.00
4,800
Rs.
147,960.00
Rs.
195,960.00
Total Assets
Rs.
1,922,960.00
Rs.
2,059,710.00
Current Liabilities
Taxes payable
Total Current Liabilities
Total Liabilities
0
Rs.
Rs.
0
Rs.
Rs.
Page | 111
Owners' Equity
Invested capital
Rs.
8,932,225
Rs.
10,951,681
Retained earnings
Rs.
20,194,553
Rs.
22,099,320
Rs.
29,126,778
Rs.
33,051,001
Rs.
29,126,778
Rs.
33,051,001
Page | 112
Projected
2015
1,272,000.00
1,272,000.00
609,500
609,500
1,881,500.00
1,881,500.00
191,160.00
Rs.
299,600.00
4,800
4,800
195,960.00
Rs.
304,400.00
2,077,460.00
2,185,900.00
Current Liabilities
Taxes payable
Total Current Liabilities
0
0.00
0
0.00
Total Liabilities
0.00
0.00
Rs. 13,161,612.71
Rs.
15,391,734.31
Assets
Current Assets
Cash in bank
Prepaid expenses
Total Current Assets
Fixed Assets
Machinery & equipment
Rs.
Total Assets
Rs.
Owners' Equity
Invested capital
Page | 113
Retained earnings
Rs.
22,301,216
Rs.
35,462,829
Rs.
22,631,336
Rs.
38,023,070
Rs. 35,462,828.71
Rs.
38,023,070.31
Projected
2016
Projected
2017
Current Assets
Cash in bank
1,284,000.00
1,296,000.00
Prepaid expenses
Total Current Assets
615,250
1,899,250.00
621,000
1,917,000.00
Assets
Fixed Assets
Machinery & equipment after dep
Furniture & fixtures after dep
Total Fixed Assets (net
depreciation)
Total Assets
Rs.
395,600.00
Rs.
4,800
395,600.00
4,800
of
Rs.
400,400.00
Rs.
400,400.00
2,299,650.00
2,317,400.00
Current Liabilities
Taxes payable
Total Current Liabilities
0
0.00
0
0.00
Total Liabilities
0.00
0.00
Owners' Equity
Page | 114
Invested capital
Retained earnings
Total Owners' Equity
Rs. 17,654,867.91
Rs.
22,503,112
Rs.
40,157,980
Rs. 19,905,179.11
Rs.
23,365,248
Rs.
43,270,427
Rs. 40,157,979.91
Rs. 43,270,427.11
Page | 115
Rs.
Rs.
39,300,000.00
(9,003,047.27)
(4,416,000.00)
25,880,952.73
25,880,952.73
739,800.00
29,126,778.17
739,800.00
29,126,778.17
55,747,530.90
1,200,000.00
56,947,530.90
Rs.
Rs.
42,051,000.00
(9,453,199.64)
(4,636,800.00)
27,961,000.36
27,961,000.36
147,960.00
147,960.00
33,051,000.71
33,051,000.71
61,159,961.08
56,947,530.90
118,107,491.97
Rs.
Rs.
22,301,216.00
(9,543,230.11)
(4,680,960.00)
8,077,025.89
8,077,025.89
35,462,828.71
35,462,828.71
43,539,854.61
118,107,491.97
161,647,346.58
Page | 117
Rs.
Rs.
22,631,336.00
(9,543,230.11)
(4,680,960.00)
8,407,145.89
8,407,145.89
542,200.00
38,023,070.31
542,200.00
38,023,070.31
46,972,416.21
161,647,346.58
208,619,762.78
Rs.
Rs.
22,503,112.00
(9,633,260.58)
(4,725,120.00)
8,144,731.42
8,144,731.42
Page | 118
40,157,979.91
40,157,979.91
48,302,711.33
208,619,762.78
256,922,474.12
Rs.
23,365,248.00
(9,723,291.05)
(4,769,280.00)
8,872,676.95
-
8,872,676.95
Rs.
43,270,427.11
43,270,427.11
52,143,104.06
256,922,474.12
309,065,578.18
Page | 119
Future:
The business of nutraceuticals is pegged at Rs 6,000 crore and growing at 20 percent. There is
increased awareness of health products among consumers, increased burden of diseases, and
higher disposable incomes to be the key reasons behind the rise in sales for this segment. With
37 percent of consumers shopping from large-format retail stores, modern food retail will double
from Rs 315, 000 crore to 675,000 crore by 2025. Not only physical retail stores, but online retail
too is growing at 50 percent and has a huge potential.
Talking about the future of health-related products, the word health has innumerous meanings.
Be it a teenager or an elderly, the concept of health and healthy food varies vastly. So, first we
need to educate the consumers as to what healthy, nutrient, and wellness-products are and
what they offer. Consumers can be educated and made aware of health products through
advertisements and so brands should invest more on marketing strategies. Make your products
innovative and talk more about the benefits. In order to drive penetration in the market, we know
about the right product placement at the right areas and have the clear focus on our target
group.
The fresh food demand continues to remain high. India continued to see a growing number of
mid- and high-income consumers with aspirations to move up the value chain in 2010, with this
trend keeping demand for fresh food high in the year. The rise in demand was intense enough
to put strains on production, even though India is in the top five countries globally in terms of
producing and consuming fresh food. Better retail distribution also meant that availability
improved throughout the country, as retailers and food companies expanded into underdeveloped rural and semi-urban areas.
Rising prices are a cause of concern. 2010 was marked by sharp spikes in both consumption
and prices in practically every fresh food product category, from vegetables to fruits. Prices
were boosted by a number of factors in 2010. In addition to the impact of growing consumption
linked to higher disposable incomes, errant rainfall in key production areas and natural disasters
in and around India further put pressure on prices. Food price inflation climbed to as high as
18% in 2010, causing public outcry and a slew of government measures to ease prices, from
price control to imports. Prices did fall by the end of the year but 2010 overall took fresh food
Page | 120
Page | 121
The present paper looks at the impact of globalization on both the demand side and the supply
side of the food system in India. There are six key stylized facts characterizing the changes in
food demand in Asia. These facts pertain to changes in the consumption of rice, wheat, protein
and energy-dense foods, and diet diversification. There is a two-stage process of diet
transformation. During the first stage consumers move away from inferior goods to superior
foods and substitute some traditional staples with primary food products that are more prevalent
in western diets. In the second stage the influences of globalization are much more marked with
increased consumption of proteins, sugars, fats and temperate zone products. The figures on
the demand structure for food in India are consistent with our analysis of a two-stage process of
dietary change. As the demand profile changes with economic growth and globalization, so the
supply systems must adapt to accommodate this change.
The driving forces of diet and nutrition change
Since the 1980s India has enjoyed quite remarkable economic growth. Incomes have been
steadily rising and per capita real expenditure has increased across all groups. Significantly,
and consistent with high rates of growth, the proportion of per capita expenditure on food items
has fallen. Economic growth has been accompanied by rising urbanization (see tables 1 and 2).
Indian cities are expanding with substantial increases in the growth rates predicted in the next
thirty years.
Reforms introduced in the 1990s have been successful at maintaining these rates of growth.
Tables 2, and 3 provide a picture on the nature of urbanization in India. In 1950, the degree of
urbanization was estimated at 17.3%. By 2000, this figure stood at 28% and it is projected that
by 2030 the figure could be as high as 41%
Increased urbanisation has seen the rise of the middle classes and it is predominantly the
lifestyle preferences of this group that mark a change with the past. Moreover, economic growth
alters the structure of the labour force in urban areas characterised by increased female
participation with important consequences for the family diet. As more women enter the labour
force, the traditional role of the Indian housewife to be in charge of food preparation is eroding.
Whilst women may still have prime responsibility for providing the daily meals, the nature of
these meals may change. The consumption of ready made meals, or foods that cut the long
preparation time of traditional dishes, are likely to be a predominant feature of the diet for
families where there is a high female participation rate. Chapatti-mixes for example can be
Page | 122
likened to the availability of ready-made bread mixes in developed countries. Both are designed
to appeal to women whose opportunity cost of time is high.
Moreover, working couples with no children may enjoy on average higher disposable incomes
and are thus likely to consume food outside the home on a regular basis. It should be noted that
whilst the emergence of the nuclear family is growing, India is still far from having the same
numbers of two-income families that characterize labour markets of developed nations. With
further increases in economic growth and greater integration in the global market, this may
change more rapidly and consequently, we may see an even stronger upward shift in demand
for convenience processed food.
Increased economic growth not only brings about divergences in the diets between different
socio-economic groups but also across the age divide. Food preferences of older age groups
tend to be relatively static over time. Where there is increased income for consumption, food
preferences still tend to remain within an identifiable traditional boundary. Whilst there may be
increased expenditure on superior foods, these tend to be prepared according to long-standing
customs and practices. Younger generations are more influenced by new foods particularly
when these are introduced through an advertising campaign that targets the group specifically.
The divergence between the dietary habits of young and old tends to persist over a long-time
horizon if not indefinitely. Generally, lifetime eating habits form at a young age and are difficult
to reverse as age increases (see FSA, 2002; HPA, 2001 ).
The process of diet transformation in India can be seen as involving two separate stages:
(i)
Income-induced diet diversification. At the start of the process of faster economic growth,
Diet globalisation. As globalisation begins to exert its influence, we see the adoption of
markedly different diets that no longer conform to the traditional local habits.
During income-induced diet diversification, economic prosperity enables consumers to afford a
more varied and balanced diet and to demand nutritionally superior food products. In this stage,
the demand for food would still be largely directed towards traditional foods with positive income
elasticities of demand as opposed to foods that display negative elasticities. Consumers
typically move away from rice consumption or may consume higher quality varieties of rice.
Increased consumption of wheat, in the form of bread and other wheat-based products, such as
Page | 123
During the 1980s, consumption of both animal and vegetable products increased very
substantially. Among the animal products, the largest proportional increase was in the
consumption of milk. Among the vegetable products there were large increases across all food
groups, but particularly for rice, pulses, wheat and cereals. Rice and pulses are essential
components of the traditional diet. The 1980s also saw an increase in the consumption of spices
and oil crops. Overall, the structure of food consumption has not changed markedly during the
decade, but there was a rise in demand across all the main food groups.
The 1990s, by contrast, saw a significant change in the pattern of food consumption. There was
a marked increase in the consumption of animal product, especially animal fats, whereas the
increase in the consumption of vegetable products was relatively modest. Among vegetable
products, there were large increases in the consumption of wheat, starchy roots, vegetable oils,
sugar and sweeteners, and fruits, whereas the consumption of rice, pulses and cereals has
declined. These are evidence of a structural break relative to the previous decade. The 1990s
were associated with the consumption of significantly larger amounts of energy-dense foods in
the form of fats, oils and starchy roots. Whilst starchy roots represent a staple, the considerable
increase in the 1990 captures the increased consumption of potatoes, a food with strong
associations with energy-dense food products such as fries and potato chips. The decline in the
consumption of rice and pulses and the increase in the consumption of wheat are particularly
significant. It is important to note that the use of wheat in the diet is changing as well, since
there is a move away from the traditional chapatti to more commercialised bread products
similar to those found in the West. This pattern is indicative of a specific move to a more
western diet in the early stages of diet transformation. Traditionally, wheat represented a key
staple in the north of India whereas in the south rice tended to dominate the habitual diet. With
economic growth, dietary preferences in the south are moving away from rice towards wheat
whereas in the north preferences are veering more towards rice. The net effect for India as a
whole is a decline in total rice consumption given the neagtive income elasticity of demand for
rice.
The values of the income elasticity of demand for the different categories of food can help us
understand the changing food consumption patterns by Indian households. As income
increases, the structure of consumption will shift away from low-elasticity towards high-elasticity
food. This can certainly be extremely valuable for predicting the demand for the different food
categories by Indian households as a result of income growth during the first phase of diet
diversification
Page | 125
The figures on consumption patterns and elasticity for the staples reveal a clear direction away
from what are regarded as inferior foods. However, what these figures do not fully capture is the
changing nature of the household food basket itself. The demand for wheat is rising but more
precisely it is increased household demand for bread that is rising. Additionally, while we see
that consumption of fruits and vegetable is rising it is also clear that consumption of temperate
zone fruits and vegetable accounts for an increasing share of this.
Diet diversification and health
The process of diet transformation has far-reaching consequences for public health. The
adoption of a more varied and nutritionally balanced diet, typical of income-induced diet
diversification, generally leads to a substantial improvement in public health indicators. The
health implications of the globalisation of diets are less clear-cut. On the one hand, the
availability of a much broader range of food products enables consumers to overcome the
limitations of the traditional local diets in terms of availability of resources. Also, the process of
food standardization that is put in place by large food distributors and supermarket chains can
ensure higher levels of food hygiene. Both these aspects would be associated with an
improvement in health indicators.
The incidence of moderate and severe malnutrition in India for children between the ages of one
and five has fallen markedly across all states. In 1991-2, severe malnutrition for India stood at
11.1% but by 2000-1, the figure has fallen to 6.4%. Moderate malnutrition too has fallen for the
same periods from 45.1% to 41.3%. Table 6 gives a detailed breakdown for all states.
The reduction in severe malnutrition is explained precisely because of diet diversification. From
table 4 it can be seen that there is amarked increase in the consumption of milk, animal protein
and fruits and vegetables all of which combined can explain the reduced incidence of
malnutrition.
On the other hand, the increased consumption of highly-calorific and more energy-dense food
could lead to increased incidence obesity and of diet-related diseases, like diabetes, coronary
heart disease and certain types of cancer. It seems clear that dietary patterns are contributing to
a clear change in the trends of chronic diseases in India. There is clear evidence of a
demographic, epidemiological and nutrition transition in India that is fuelling the epidemic of
chronic diseases and obesity, particularly in the urban areas. The mechanisms and institutions
Page | 126
that drive economic growth and consequently globalization are primarily concentrated in urban
centres with a lagged effect in rural areas.
Urbanization, food consumption patterns and food security are strongly related. Table 9 shows
that in some cities a large part of urban growth can be attributed to the growth of the informal
urban economy, with households living in slum accommodation on the peripheries of urban
centres. Supermarkets and fast food outlets etc. tend to target the middle-classes and so the
location of these enterprises is likely to be in areas that are inhabited by or serve these higher
income groups.
The food consumption patterns of poor migrants in the urban slums are different from those in
the formal urban economy who enjoy substantially higher incomes. Urban slums are often
characterised by copycat street foods, that is, food stalls that seek to mimic the branded
products of fast food outlets. Moreover these street vendors are part of the unregulated
economy and this has implications in terms of food safety which could exacerbate the poor
health effects of a nutritionally- deficient diet.
The development literature has not focused specifically on the analysis of the dietary habits of
the urban poor, precisely because the overwhelming majority of Indias poor live in rural areas.
However, the consumption patterns of the urban poor cannot be ignored, particularly given the
rate of urban expansion, and are likely to differ markedly from those of the rural poor.
An important social aspect of the globalization of the diet is that, once the traditional food
consumption habits have been displaced by the new consumption patterns, the change
becomes largely irreversible. Processed food is both easier to prepare and less time-intensive
than the traditional food. The skills required to prepare the local food that have been developed
over centuries and had been passed on from generation to generation can easily be lost. The
globalized diet therefore becomes an absorbing state, in the sense that it would be virtually
impossible for the dietary habits to revert back to the old traditional ones. This process is very
visible in Western countries, where the availability of convenience food is leading to a rapid loss
in the ability of households to prepare the traditional recipes. The globalization of diets would
therefore have critical implications for the whole food culture of the country, leading to a cultural
homogenization to the global model.
Transformation of Food Supply Systems
Page | 127
India is beginning to observe a dramatic change in food supply systems in response to rapid
urbanization, diet diversification, and the liberalization of foreign direct investment in the food
sector. The observed changes are in both the retail sector as well as in the production sector.
This section describes the changes in food supply systems, with a particular emphasis on
provisioning the cities. It then proceeds to examine the implications for domestic production and
the specific impact on small farmers.
Feeding the burgeoning urban masses is one of the most important food policy challenges
facing India today and for the foreseeable future. There are three specific dimensions to the
issue of feeding the cities. The first stems from the quantitative aspect. Towns are getting larger
and so the size of the urban market is expanding. This requires not only increases in total urban
food supply, but also the establishment of large suppliers in order to manage the increased level
of activity in the market. The second dimension derives from the qualitative aspect of demand
changes in cities. The rapid diversification of the urban diet cannot be met by the traditional food
supply chain. It requires in effect the commercialization and diversification of domestic
production systems and/or increased food imports. The third dimension draws from the location
of urban centres. Indias most populous cities and towns tend to be located on the coast.
Importing food to satisfy the changing food demand could be relatively easier and less costly
than acquiring the same food from the domestic hinterlands. There will be a growing choice, at
the margin, between domestic supply and imports, although one would suspect that both would
rise in absolute terms.
The change in urban food demand is almost simultaneously accompanied by changes in retail
preferences. Western style marketing outlets are gaining a foothold in most Indian cities. Whilst
income-induced diet diversification may be met by local suppliers with few changes to the
existing production environment, the second stage of diet globalization requires a shift away
from traditional products. A globalization result in a significant increase in the size of the
domestic food market and this generates powerful incentives for foreign suppliers and
supermarkets to enter the food sector. Trade liberalization greatly facilitates the widespread
establishment of global supermarket chains and fast food outlets and thus speeds up the
diffusion of homogenous foods and of a global diet in the Indian market
Vertically integrated food supply chain that links input suppliers, producers, processors,
distributors and retailers becomes essential for meeting the changing demand requirements as
efficiently as possible.
Page | 128
Integration arrangements may differ. At one end of the spectrum the decision- making authority
of the farmer is displaced further down the production line to the processor or retailer (who may
be one and the same) so that farmers essentially are employed by these large processing firms
(see Reardon and Barrett 2002). Importantly though, there are ways in which small farmers can
enter the chain at various points in the production line without compromising their autonomy.
For example, farmers may sell their produce at a particular point and not be tied in any further.
In this case, the farmer may be guaranteed a buyer but if there is a collapse in product price the
farmer is no more protected than if he were operating at subsistence level. Thus, the nature of
the contractual arrangement can vary and need not necessarily involve reducing the decisionmaking authority of individual producers.
Vertically integrated firms are necessary to meet the changing tastes of consumers located in
urban areas. This need not have adverse consequences for Indian agriculture by any means. In
fact, integration may bring benefits. Vertically integrated firms can play an important role in
disseminating technologies to allow agricultural transformation. Moreover, they can facilitate the
process of improving product quality. Foreign-owned firms in particular, may be a source of
capital and provide export opportunities. The net effect of a highly integrated agricultural system
is difficult to predict a priori. Whilst there may be genuine concerns over the long- term
livelihoods of small farmers, there are also clear benefits.
Income-induced diet diversification has the potential for generating a tension between small and
large domestic suppliers. Given the larger scale of production, large farmers could have an
advantage over small farmers in terms of their ability to make use of more cost-effective
production techniques. If conditions for increasing returns in production are met, then many
small producers may effectively be driven out of the production sector. In their place, we could
see the emergence of monopolistic suppliers consisting of large firms that employ more costeffective technologies and operate under increasing returns to scale. Or, with proactive
government support, small farmers could become increasingly commercialized and integrated
into the market.
During diet globalization, domestic suppliers could face strong competition from foreign
suppliers. It is important during this stage for domestic suppliers to signal that they can adapt
production to meet the procurement requirements of large food outlets. Domestic producers
have a comparative advantage over foreign producers of fresh produce. Fresh foods are costly
to transport and store for prolonged periods. If domestic agriculture can produce the goods
Page | 129
locally, then they have a cost advantage over foreign competitors. In India, we are already
beginning to see agricultural diversification and the emergence of contracts between farmers
and large food outlets.
Whilst there are challenges faced by domestic producers during the process of diet
diversification, globalization brings with it some important opportunities. The dynamic nature of
the transformation of the food market places a new urgency on domestic farmers to modernize.
Previously, Indian agriculture could be characterized as quite static, focusing predominantly on
traditional cereal and rice production mostly in a subsistence context. Liberalization of
agricultural markets requires the need to move out of subsistence agriculture to one that is
commercial in nature.
Moreover, the exposure of Indian farmers to international competition can be seen as a very
real opportunity to supply world markets with foods for which India enjoys a comparative
advantage. Thus, whilst diversification is important, rice and cereals should not be totally
ignored. The challenge here is for farmers to produce those varieties of rice and cereals for
which world demand is growing. For example, the rising export demand for basmati rice.
Indian agriculture is responding to the changing domestic demand and the effects of
globalisation. This is happening through both public and private investment. The Indian
government, recognizing the increasing demand for fruits and vegetables, has dramatically
increased investment in horticultural production in the last 15 years and this is expected to stand
at Rs 20 billion by the next five-year plan.
Page | 130