Article and Review On McCormick

578
E/IL9 (1998), 574-593
with contributions by Francesa Morettl and

LuLsa Antoniolli.
Galgano devotes particular attention to the
relationships between civil law and commercial law and in particular, to the new theme of
lex mercatoria. This is defined as a creation of
the entrepreneurial class which, without the
mediation of the legislative powers, tends to
give life to uniform laws that are able to
overcome the obstacles determined by the
diversity of different national systems.
The internationalization of markets and the
creation of the new lex mercatoria represent
the binding thread that ties together the other
parts of the Atlas. A clear result of this is that
the need for uniformity, particularly felt in this
field, is not so strongly perceived in areas of
the judicial system, such as the law of succession and family law as examined in the
text by Paolo Cendon inasmuch as these
areas are concerned with aspects of property.
The topic which attracts the greatest
amount of space and depth is that of contract
In particular, Galgano closely examines the
different categories of legal transaction,
especially those relevant to the different forms
of contract formation between parties dealing
at a distance; hence, that of the principles of
causality and abstractness (written by Pier
Giuseppe Monatert). An outline of the transfer
of personal property between parties under
legal systems influenced by common law and
French civil law is amply treated by Galgano,
while those systems inspired by German codification are dealt with by Herbert Kronke.
The overall picture of the procedures relating
to the transferral and acquisition of personal
property is completed when the considerations dealt with in the last section of the Atlas
are linked to those regarding the acquisition of
personal property by means of possession. In
Chapter 3 Galgano concentrates on the solutions adopted in the various legal systems,
highlighting the originality of the Italian
system where similarities can only be found
with Swedish law.
The topic of responsibility is considered not
only under the guise of contractual responsibility but also that of responsibility within
Tort. The former is examined by Galgano,
who illustrates the system as outlined by the

Code of Napoleon. Daniela Memmo. on the
other hand, concentrates on the German
model, while Luciana Cabella Pisu describes
the laws currently in force in common law
countries.
The outline of responsibility in tort is
examined by Franco Ferrari, who highlights
the difference between the French and German models. The discussion of civil responsibility in common law countries is written by
Paolo Gallo.
The focus in the last chapters of the Atlas is
on a discussion of various topics which are of
significant importance in international trade.
The trust, for example, is the object of a
comparison with the concept of Flducla
Romanistlca. The Atlas also examines other
instruments, such as securities and the application of the laws of insolvency both in
relation to persons involved in business and
those not involved in business (civil insolvency). Further, Industrial property and individual
economic activity
(individual
businesses) are examined, with particular
attention to their being subjected to a limited
doctrine of responsibility.
Special mention should be made of the
chapter on the international sales contract, in
which Galgano analyses the Vienna Convention of 11 April 1980 regarding International
sales of movable goods.
In conclusion, Francesco Galgano's Atlante
di diritto privato comparato is a very Interesting
and useful work. Its accurate synthesis of the

different legal systems throughout the world
will be precious for practitioners as well as for
scholars and students.
University di Bologna
Enrico Al Mureden
McCormick, John. European Union:

Politics and Policies. Boulder, CO:
Westview Press, 1996. Pp. xiii, 208.
Index. $21.95.
Jacques Delors once commented that history
was accelerating, and that the European
Union had to respond accordingly. Respond it
has, and coming thick and fast are a new
Book Reviews
Treaty, the Euro and all that implies, and
Enlargement
So it is a major weakness of John McCormlck's general introductory text The European
Union: Politics and Policies, that it was finalized
some time ago and thus throws virtually no

light on these recent developments. Curiously
and less forgivably, it also seems to peak with
the Single European Act and the Single Market Programme. It does limited Justice to
subsequent events, notably the geopolitical
rupture of 1989 and German unification; the
Treaty of Maastricht gets patchy treatment
and the 1995 enlargement is barely mentioned. Certainly, readers willfindlittle illumination in the explanation of the Euro as
exchange-rate cooperation (rather than a
replacement for it with monetary policy internalized and unified). Nor will they be much
the wiser on the forces behind the inexorable
emergence of 'security and Justice' issues
(culminating post-McCormick in littleremarked but fundamental provisions of the
Treaty of Amsterdam).
On the other hand, McCormick's book has
several merits: it is readable, and breaking
the subject into digestible chunks It gives
an overview of theory, history, form (the
institutions) and substance (the policies): all
this in a manageable 300 pages. There are
gaps (competition policy is one), the simplified
sometimes tips over into the simplistic (on
French peasant farmers, for example, or on
the so-called democratic deficit), and some
thematic Juxtapositions can be odd (the Court
of Auditors lumped with the Court of Justice?).
But the treatment makes a change from the
usual long march through the institutions.
Moreover, McCormick's judgments are mostly
fair, notably avoiding the problem-dominated
nature of much discourse on the EU.
All the more reason to regret that he did not
proffer more insight for his newcomer readers:
to point out for example, that widening and
deepening are not mutually exclusive but go
hand-in-hand; or that the importance of
qualified majority voting or co-decision lies
less in the detail than in their effect on
negotiating behaviour; or that the fundamental feature of CAP reform is a shift from price
579
support to income support with different

effects on the different agricultural lobbies.
The EU Is not an abstract game of 'Go' for
political scientists, but a practical process
aimed at resolving practical albeit longterm problems.
On the political science front the notion of
'consociationalism' another snappy bit of
terminology for the pubs and cafes clearly
has McCormick's preference as an explanatory model for the way the EU works. This
'government by a coalition representing the
different groups in [a divided] society' may
well be worth probing deeper. At least it gets
us out of the sterile federal-confederal rut. It
remains a somewhat one-dimensional view,
however, and different models may apply to
different sectors: a fully federal economic
system alongside a confederal foreign policy,
with security and justice somewhere between.
The EU as 'post-modem' state? Something for
the next edition.
Fletcher School of Law
and Diplomacy Tufts University
Nigel Evans
Wetterstein, Peter (ed.). Harm to the

Environment The Right to
Compensation and the Assessment of
Damages. Oxford: Clarendon Press,
1997. Pp. xvii, 2 6 3 . Index.
This volume of collected papers resulting from
a 1995 seminar in Turku/Abo (Finland) has
all the elements that seem to make environmental topics so very attractive to some
international lawyers and so very suspect to
others: a mixture of comparative and international, public and private, law and policy;
lata and ferenda, fascinating and irritating. At
the risk of spoiling some of the fun in the
medley, the present review will try to separate
the general environmental discourse of the
book from its specific international aspects.
1. The lead paper by Brian Jones ('Deterring, Compensating, and Remedying Environmental Damage: The Contribution of Tort
liability') illustrates the old dilemma of traditional tort Jurisprudence facing new technological risks. The rationale for various 'strict'

Article and Review On McCormick

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Article and Review On McCormick

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Article and Review On McCormick

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

578

E/IL9 (1998), 574-593

with contributions by Francesa Morettl and

who illustrates the system as outlined by the

and useful work. Its accurate synthesis of the

McCormick, John. European Union:

some time ago and thus throws virtually no

support to income support with different

Wetterstein, Peter (ed.). Harm to the

You might also like

Pfad - The Proxy pFad of © 2024 Garber Painting. All rights reserved.