Measurement of Adjustable Speed Drives With Fluke Meters
Measurement of Adjustable Speed Drives With Fluke Meters
Measurement of Adjustable Speed Drives With Fluke Meters
Fluke Corporation 1
Table of Contents
Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 3
Troubleshooting Philosophy ...................................................................................................... 3
Making Safe Measurements (Sidebar) ..................................................................................... 4
Safety Ratings for Electrical Test Equipment .............................................................................. 4
Adjustable Speed Drive Theory ................................................................................................. 6
Simple Things First ...................................................................................................................... 8
Resistance Measurements ............................................................................................................. 8
Voltage Drops .................................................................................................................................. 8
Temperature Measurements .......................................................................................................... 8
Motor Measurements .................................................................................................................... 9
Temperature Measurements .......................................................................................................... 9
Overloading ..................................................................................................................................... 9
Voltage Measurements ................................................................................................................... 9
Current Imbalance Measurements .............................................................................................. 10
Single Phasing .............................................................................................................................. 11
Overvoltage Reflections - Theory (Sidebar) .............................................................................. 12
Overvoltage Reflections - Troubleshooting ............................................................................... 14
Bearing Currents ........................................................................................................................... 17
Leakage Currents .......................................................................................................................... 17
Measurements at the Inverter .................................................................................................. 18
Control Circuit Noise ..................................................................................................................... 18
Volts/Hertz Ratio ........................................................................................................................... 18
Inverter Drive Circuits .................................................................................................................. 18
Voltage Source Inverters .......................................................................................................... 18
PWM Inverters ........................................................................................................................... 19
The DC Bus .................................................................................................................................... 20
DC Voltage Too High ................................................................................................................. 20
DC Voltage Too Low ................................................................................................................. 21
AC Line Input ................................................................................................................................. 22
Diode Bridge .............................................................................................................................. 22
Voltage Notching ....................................................................................................................... 23
Voltage Unbalance .................................................................................................................... 23
Harmonics and IEEE-519 Compliance ................................................................................... 24
ASD Measurement Guide for Fluke Test Instruments ......................................................... 26
2 Fluke Corporation
Introduction
Most experienced motor
technicians are well prepared
to deal with traditional three
phase motor failures caused
by water, dust, grease, failed
bearings, misaligned motor shafts,
or even just old age. However,
modern electronically controlled
motors, more commonly referred
to as adjustable speed drives,
present a unique set of problems.
This application note will focus
on electrical measurements that
can be used to diagnose bad
components and other conditions
that may lead to premature
motor failure in adjustable speed
drives (ASDs).
Troubleshooting Philosophy
Fluke Corporation 3
4 Fluke Corporation
CAT III
CAT II
CAT I
Examples
Refers to the origin of installation, i.e. where low-voltage connection
is made to utility power.
Electricity meters, primary overcurrent protection equipment.
Outside the building and service entrance, service drop from the pole to
building, run between the meter and panel.
Overhead line to detached building, underground line to well pump.
Overvoltage
Category
Working Voltage
Peak Impulse Transient
(dc or ac-rms to ground)
(20 repetitions)
CAT I
600V
CAT I
CAT II
Test Source
(Ohm = V/A)
2500V
30 ohm source
1000V
4000V
30 ohm source
600V
4000V
12 ohm source
CAT II
1000V
6000V
12 ohm source
CAT III
600V
6000V
2 ohm source
CAT III
1000V
8000V
2 ohm source
Fluke Corporation 5
DC Link
DC Voltage
Input Converter
Output Inverter
Line Voltage
To Motor
Current
Control Circuits
Display
Operator
Controls
6 Fluke Corporation
Process
Feedback/
Control Signal
Horsepower
Torque =
=
Speed
(V x I x Eff)
x 5250
746
120 x Hz
no. of poles
Induction Motor
3 AC Input
Controlled Rectifier
Six-Step Inverter
Figure 3. Simplified diagram of a voltage source inverter with output current and voltage waveforms
distorted (non-sinusoidal),
the large motor inductance
will smooth out the current
waveform so to the motor,
it looks more like the dashed
lines superimposed on the
voltage waveform in Figure 4.
The nearly sinusoidal current
waveform in the bottom of
Figure 4 shows that the motor
is in fact only responding to
the RMS voltage of the pulses.
To summarize, the voltage
part of the V/Hz ratio is controlled
by varying the pulse width of
the pulses, thereby varying
the RMS voltage, even with a
constant peak-to-peak voltage.
The frequency part of the
V/Hz ratio is controlled by the
modulation frequency which
is the time period comprising one
positive set of pulses and one
negative set of pulses. It is the
modulation frequency that the
motor is responding to and only
a very small amount of the high
frequency pulses can be seen in
the motor current waveform.
indicates VRMS
Figure 4. Simplified diagram of a pulse width modulated inverter with current and voltage waveforms taken at the motor terminals
Fluke Corporation 7
Resistance measurements
This is probably the least
preferred of the three methods,
but will still detect completely
open circuits or leakage paths
to ground that are resistive.
Keep in mind however, that
most ohmmeters use small
amounts of current in their
measurements and may read
a good connection, when in
fact the connection may open
circuit when a large amount
of current attempts to conduct
through it. This is also known
as contact resistance.
Voltage drops
Check for voltage drops
across the various connections.
Compare with the other two
phases. Any significant variation
between phases, or more than
2-3% (depending on motor
current and supply voltage)
at each connection, should
be suspect.
Temperature
measurements
Figure 5. The 1 mV/degree output of the Fluke 80T-IR can be used with any DMM
capable of reading millivolts. The Fluke ScopeMeter instruments can read out
directly in Fahrenheit or Celsius.
8 Fluke Corporation
An inexpensive infrared
temperature probe used
with a handheld DMM is a
fast and easy way to check
for bad connections. Any
significant increase in
temperature at the connection
terminal will indicate a bad
connection or contact resistance
due to I2R heat loss. If the
temperature of the terminal
was not previously recorded
onto your system diagram,
compare with the other two
phases. More on how to use
temperature measurements
to diagnose motor and drive
problems is discussed in the
following sections.
Motor Measurements
Temperature
measurements
Temperature is a key indicator
of a failing, or overloaded motor.
Use an infrared temperature
probe such as the 80T-IR from
Fluke to measure motor temperatures at key points including; bearing locations and motor
terminal block connections (if
one exists), as well as the motor
housing itself. Are the readings
close to what was measured
when the motor was operating
normally? If these readings
werent taken before, is the
motor operating temperature
within the NEMA classification
for that motor? If the answers
to these questions are yes,
then you may want to move to
the ASD controller for the next
measurements, or you can go
ahead and make the following
measurements just to be sure.
What next?
If mechanical load requirements and behavior seem normal, then its
possible some of the motor windings have become shorted and are the
source for increased current, heat and loss of torque. Things to check
for now are current imbalance, single phasing, voltage imbalance and
something unique to PWM drives, overvoltages caused by reflected
voltage waves. High motor shaft voltages, a problem also associated
with PWM drives, could explain excessive bearing temperatures and
premature bearing failure. How to test for these conditions is described
in the following paragraphs.
Voltage measurements
Fluke Corporation 9
Current imbalance
measurements
x 100 = 2.39%
10 Fluke Corporation
mA
A
FLUKE 87
T1
A
T2 80i-400
T3
mA
mA AA COM
COM
10A MAX
FUSED
400mA MAX
FUSED
T1
30A
T2
35A
T3
30A
1000V MAX
T1
T3
A
B
T2
Rolled Phases
Unbalanced caused Unbalanced caused
by supply
by motor
T1
30A
T1
30A
T2
30A
T2
35A
T3
35A
T3
30A
Single phasing
Single phasing results from the
total loss of one of the phase
voltages applied to a three
phase ac induction motor and
can be a tricky problem to
detect. In an ASD application,
this would usually be caused by
an open connection at either
end of the cabling between the
motor and drive, or an open in
one of the conductors in the
cable itself. Its also possible
one of the insulated gate bipolar
transistors (IGBT) which are
the devices that drive each
phase of the motor, could have
become open circuit, although
some ASDs are able to detect
this condition.
Fluke Corporation 11
Figure 9. Impact of rise time and cable length on magnitude of reflected voltages
12 Fluke Corporation
lc (ft)
= 2x10-9 * lc
500 (ft/sec)
Fluke Corporation 13
Overvoltage reflections
troubleshooting
As mentioned earlier, fast rise
times on the ASD output pulses
and long cable runs between
the ASD and the motor will
cause overvoltage reflections
approaching double the DC
bus voltage and even higher.
An oscilloscope is required to
discover the full extent of this
problem, as seen in Figures 10
and 11 below.
14 Fluke Corporation
0.1 s
2.8 feet
3.1 feet
0.2 s
5.5 feet
6.3 feet
0.5 s
14 feet
16 feet
0.7 s
19 feet
22 feet
1 s
28 feet
31 feet
1.5 s
42 feet
47 feet
2 s
55 feet
63 feet
3 s
83 feet
94 feet
4 s
111 feet
125 feet
5 s
138 feet
156 feet
6 s
166 feet
188 feet
7 s
194 feet
219 feet
8 s
221 feet
250 feet
9 s
249 feet
281 feet
10 s
277 feet
313 feet
Table 3. Maximum cable lengths for various rise times and reflection coefficients before peak
voltages begin to exceed 1.15 times the DC bus voltage
Fluke Corporation 15
Filter Remedy 2:
Typical effect of the
series reactor measured
at the motor terminals
Figure 14
Series Reactor
Dependent on cable
length.
Dependent on size of
system.
Losses dependent on
motor kVA
Losses dependent on
motor kVA
Size/cost dependent on
motor kVA.
Size/cost dependent on
motor kVA.
Table 4.
16 Fluke Corporation
Bearing currents
When motor shaft voltages
exceed the insulating capability
of the bearing grease, flashover
currents to the outer bearing
will occur, thereby causing
pitting and grooving to the
bearing races. The first signs
of this problem will be noise
and overheating as the bearings
begin to lose their original
shape and metal fragments mix
with the grease and increase
bearing friction. This can lead to
bearing destruction within a
few months of ASD operation
and is thus expensive in motor
repair and downtime.
There is a normal, unavoidable
shaft voltage created from the
stator winding to the rotor shaft
due to small dissymmetries of
the magnetic field in the air gap
that are inherent in the design
of the motor. Most induction
motors are designed to have a
maximum shaft voltage to frame
ground of < 1 Vrms.
Another source of motor
shaft voltages are from internal
electrostatic coupled sources
including; belt driven couplings,
ionized air passing over rotor
fan blades, or high velocity air
passing over rotor fan blades
such as in steam turbines.
Under 60 Hz sine wave
operation, the bearing breakdown voltage is approximately
0.4-0.7 volts. However, with
the fast edges of the transient
voltages found with PWM
drives, the breakdown of the
insulating capacity of the grease
actually occurs at a higher
voltage about 8-15 volts.
This higher breakdown voltage
creates higher bearing flashover
currents, which causes increased
damage to the bearings in a
shorter amount of time.
Research in this area has
shown that shaft voltages
below 0.3 volts are safe and
would not be high enough for
destructive bearing currents to
occur. However, voltages from
0.5-1.0 volts may cause harmful
bearing currents (>3A) and
shaft voltages > 2 volts may
destroy the bearing.
Leakage currents
Leakage currents (common
mode noise) capacitively coupled
between the stator winding
and frame ground will increase
with PWM drives as the capacitive
reactance of the winding
insulation is reduced with the
high frequency output of the
drive. Therefore, faster rise times
and higher switching frequencies
will only make the problem
worse. It should also be noted
the potential increase in leakage
currents should warrant close
attention to established and
safe grounding practices for the
motor frame. The increase in
leakage currents can also cause
nuisance tripping of ground fault
protection relays, override 4-20
mA control signals, and interfere
with PLC communications lines.
Measure common mode noise
by placing the current clamp
around all three motor conductors. The resultant signal will be
the leakage current.
A common mode choke along
with a damping resistor can be
used to reduce leakage currents
(Figure 15). Also, special EMI
suppression cables can be used
between the drive output and
the motor terminals. The copper
conductors of the cable are
covered with ferrite granules
which absorb the RF energy
and convert it to heat. Isolation
transformers on the ac inputs will
also reduce common mode noise.
Induction Motor
3 AC Input
M
Common Mode
Choke
Diode Rectifier
PWM Inverter
Figure 15. Common mode choke with dampening resistor to reduce leakage currents
Fluke Corporation 17
AC Coil
Anode
87
MIN MAX
RANGE
40
HOLD
REL
Hz
SCR
mV
Gate
mA
A
OFF
mA
Cathode
10A MAX
FUSED
COM
400mA MAX
FUSED
1000V MAX
PWM inverters
Many of the newer fractional
horsepower PWM drives are
integrated to the point where
the input diode block and IGBTs
are potted into a single throwaway module that is bolted to
the heat sink. The cost of these
units rarely justify the time to
repair, if replacement parts
are even available. However,
the larger horsepower drives
starting in the 5-25 horsepower
range, have components that
are accessible and become
economically feasible to repair.
If it has been determined that
the drive inverter is the source
of an improper voltage being
applied to the motor, then use
the following procedure to
isolate which IGBT(s) is failing
in the output section.
Fluke Corporation 19
0.15
0.14
0.13
0.11
0.12
0.10
0.09
0.07
0.08
0.05
0.06
0.03
0.01
0.02
0.00
-0.01
-0.02
-0.03
-0.04
Volts
50
Figure 19. Transient time and date stamp retrieved using FlukeView software
20 Fluke Corporation
Fluke Corporation 21
+DC
87
MIN MAX
RANGE
40
HOLD
REL
Hz
AC Input
mV
mA
A
OFF
DC
Figure 22. Voltage flat-topping caused by
harmonic currents
22 Fluke Corporation
mA
10A MAX
FUSED
COM
400mA MAX
FUSED
!
1000V MAX
Voltage unbalance
While voltage unbalance at
the motor terminals (discussed
earlier) can adversely affect
motor operation, it can also
cause problems at the line side
of the drive. ANSI C84.1-1989
recommends 3% maximum
voltage unbalance at the point
of common coupling (PCC)
with the utility under no load
conditions, while the IEC
recommends 2% (see previous
section to determine % voltage
unbalance). However, as little
as 0.3% voltage unbalance on
the input to a PWM inverter
can cause voltage notching
and excessive current to
flow in one or more phases
which can cause tripping of
the ASDs current overload
fault protection.
While the 0.3% voltage
unbalance is an extreme case
compounded by a lightly loaded
motor, an oscilloscope will be
required to view the notching
problem. An accurate DMM will
be needed to make the voltage
measurements required for
the % voltage unbalance
calculation. The Fluke 87, 863
and 867B are good choices for
this measurement because of
their accuracy and resolution.
A common cause of this
problem is single phase loads
dropping in or out on the same
feed as the three phase ASD.
The trend mode of the Fluke
ScopeMeter Test Tool can be
used to help isolate which
single phase load is causing
the most problem. Additionally,
providing a stiffer source by
increasing the kVA rating of
the transformer, or by providing
a separate feed for the ASD
will minimize or eliminate
this problem.
Fluke Corporation 23
24 Fluke Corporation
Individual Voltage
Distortion (%)
Total Voltage
Distortion (%)
3.0
5.0
Below 69 kV
h<11
11-16
h>34
TDD
Related Assumption
<20
4.0
2.0
17-23 23-34
1.5
0.6
0.3
5.0
Dedicated system
20<50
7.0
3.5
2.5
1.0
0.5
8.0
50<100
10.0
4.5
4.0
1.5
0.7
12.0
100<1000
12.0
5.5
5.0
2.0
1.0
15.0
>1000
15.0
7.0
6.0
2.5
1.4
20.0
Figure 26. Voltage waveform, harmonics graph and text data from the Fluke 41B Power Harmonics Analyzer
Fluke Corporation 25
Fluke 39/41B
Power Analyzer
CAT III 600V
Fluke 87
CAT III 1000V
867 B GMM
CAT III 1000V
ScopeMeter B Series
CAT III 600V
ScopeMeter 123
CAT III 600V
Resistance
Low Voltage
Temperature
w/accessory
w/accessory
w/accessory
w/accessory
Motor Voltage
without
overvoltages
present
Motor Voltage
overvoltages
present
Motor Current
clamps with
current output
only
clamps with
current output
only
Volts/Hz
80i-1000s, 80i-500s, or
80i-110s current probes
recommended
80i-1000s, 80i-500s, or
80i-110s current probes
recommended
DC Bus
Voltage
Distortion
Limited
Harmonics
Component
tests
Transients
and Surges
> 1 msec
> 1 sec
> 40 ns
> 40 ns
Measurement Type
80i-1000s
AC current clamp 1 mV,
10 mV or 100 mV/Amp
80i-500s
AC current clamp
1 mV/Amp
To 1,000 amps
To 500 amps
To 100 amps
To 400 amps
To 100 kHz
To 10 kHz
To 100 kHz
To 5 kHz
DC
AC RMS
Waveform Details
80I-400
AC current clamp
1 mA/Amp
To 100 amps
26 Fluke Corporation
80i-110s
AC/DC current clamp
10 mV, 100 mV/Amp
867
87
GRAPHICAL MULTIMETER
100ms
k
0
MIN MAX
RANGE
40
HOLD
REL
Hz
FREEZE
mV
SAVE
PRINT
Hz
MIN
MAX
RANGE
OFF
mA
A
SET UP
TOUCH
HOLD
WAKE UP
OFF
COMPONENT
TEST
V
mV
LOGIC
mA
COM
Hi Z
V
ALL INPUTS
1000V MAX
CAT
mA / A
COMPONENT
TEST
10A MAX
FUSED
400mA MAX
FUSED
1000V MAX
320mA MAX FUSED
1000V MAX
LOGIC
1000V MAX
mA / A
EXT TRIG
COM
Fluke 87
ScopeMeter B Series
ScopeMeter 123
Model 39/41B
High performance
Three-phase readout of
bandwidth
2
3 digit, >3000 count
display
Min/Max/Trend Plot
recording
Frequency, duty cycle,
pulse width
Direct readout in amps
and C/F
True-rms, backlit display,
40 nS glitch capture
Touch Hold and Relative
modes
Print Screen capability
Three-year warranty
3 /
INPU
100A T
MAX pk
OUT
100m PUT
10m V/A
OFF V/A
OL
ON
ZE
RO
dc
0.1 mA to 10A, all fused
33/4 digit, 4000 count
digital display
Analog bar graph pointer
Min/Max/Avg recording
Frequency, duty cycle,
capacitance
Input AlertTM
True-rms, backlit display,
1 ms peak hold, 41/2 digit
mode
Touch Hold and
Relative modes
Lifetime warranty
multimeter with
waveform display
0.025% basic dc accuracy
32,000 count display
1 MHz waveform display
bandwidth
2 Hz to 10 MHz
frequency measurement
LCD backlight
Resistance/conductance/
continuity
Amps, mA, A
Duty cycle/pulse width/
period
Capacitance to 10,000 F
Min/Max/Avg with Time
Stamp
TrendGraphTM plotting
Built-in RS-232TMinterface
with FlukeView 860 PC
software
80i-110s
Optional accessory.
ON
F
OF
80i-1000s
Optional accessory. AC
current 100 mA to
1000A rms continuous,
1400A rms peak. BNC
connection.
Use with 39/41B or
ScopeMeter
80i-500s AC
Measures ac and dc
current in two ranges
from 50 mA to 100A.
Best accuracy is 3% and
frequency response is dc
to 100 kHz. BNC
connection.
FlukeView Software
80T-IR
For fast non-contact
temperature measure-ments.
Range: -18C to 260C (0F to
500F). Accuracy: 3% of
reading or 3C (5F) whichever is greater. Internal switch
selection for C or F. For use
with DMMs or ScopeMeter.
80i-400
1-400A
3% of Rdg
30 mm (1.18 in)
1 mA/Amp
detailed analysis
Fluke Corporation 27
Application Notes
In Tune with Power Harmonics
Literature #B0221UEN
Electrical Power Circuit Measurements for ScopeMeter
Literature #B0241UEN
ABCs of Multimeter Safety
Literature #B0317UEN
Electrical Troubleshooting with
Fluke Multimeters
Literature #B0171UEN
Educational Videos
ABCs of Digital Multimeter Safety
P/N 609104
Understanding and Managing
Harmonics
P/N 609096
Acknowledgments
[1] A. von Jouanne, P. Enjeti, V. Stefanovic,
Adjustable Speed AC Motor Drives: Application Problems and Solutions, Seminar notes,
pp. 3.1-6.20, PowerSystems World Conf. 1996
[2] IEEE Recommended Practices and Requirements for Harmonic Control in Electrical
Power Systems - Std 519, New York, NY: IEEE
Inc., 1992
[3] EC&M, Practical Guide to Motors and Motor
Controllers, pp. 9-16, Intertec Electrical
Group, 1991
Special thanks to Dr. Annette von Jouanne for
her assistance preparing this application note
and to Oregon State University for the use of
their Motor Systems Resource Facility.
28 Fluke Corporation