111807909
111807909
111807909
Introduction
Starbucks is the worlds largest coffeehouse company with a presence in 65 countries
around the globe. As coffee shops were nearing saturation in the US and Europe, Starbucks
identified the potential for expanding in emerging markets like China and India (Agrawal
and Sharma, 2012). Though China is mainly a tea-drinking nation, Starbucks won the
Chinese consumer with its localization and customization strategies. Starbucks success in
China encouraged the company to enter India, which too is primarily a tea-drinking
nation. India is one of the emerging markets where personal disposable income per capita
doubled between 2000-01 and 2009-10, resulting in vastly improved purchasing power
(Deloitte, 2011). The upper and middle class segments in urban India were spending more
money in coffeehouses. Moreover, Starbucks believed in the size of the Indian economy,
the rising spending power of Indians and the growth of caf culture among the Indian youth,
which would hold strong potential for its growth. The company had been planning to enter
the Indian market since 2006, but FDI restrictions had dissuaded it from doing so.
Eventually, in 2011, the company signed an MoU with Indias Tata Group to tap the
Indian market potential. In January 2012, it formed a 50-50 joint venture with the Tata
and established its first outlet in October 2012. By March 2014, the number of stores had
increased to 50. Initially, Starbucks received good response; but then, the company faced
several challenges in achieving sustained growth, such as competition from other coffee
*
2015
IUP. All Rights Reserved.
Case
Study
45
(and tea) outlet chains, high prices of its products, and obtaining appropriate retail
locations and talent pool.
Starbucks mission is to inspire and nurture the human spirit one person, one
cup, and one neighborhood at a time. Starbucks aspires to establish itself as a
place after home and office a third place concept, and describes itself as the
neighborhood location where people can drop by to have a cup of coffee and
chat with their family and friends.
Starbucks has its own coffee farms, roasters and carefully followed recipes to
provide the universally acclaimed Starbucks experience to its customers.
Starbucks outlets maintain an elite and exotic ambience, which is also changed
in accordance with the season.
Customer service has always been a top priority for starbucks. A manager at
Starbucks receives at least 80 h of training, while a barista receives 40 h of
training before being allowed to make drinks.
It follows sensory branding by way of the consistent and distinct smell of freshly
ground coffee beans at its stores.
Background
Here, we discuss Starbucks business strategies and the companys penetration into foreign
markets. These are relevant to the present case study because they provide an overview
regarding the beginning and struggle of Starbucks as a foreign brand, in a market with a
different environment. They also demonstrate the marketing strategies employed by
Starbucks in order to enter a non-coffee-drinking market. Although these references do
not specifically discuss Starbucks in India, they are useful because they provide the
necessary background and insights.
47
spurred economic growth resulting in higher disposable incomes, which made consumers
demand luxury goods. Since Starbucks was perceived as an affordable luxury, it became an
almost instant success.
Luttinger and Dicum (2006) also spotted out reasons for Starbucks being successful. They
pointed to the fact that Starbucks emerged at the right time, thereby meeting cultural needs
in society to become a successful brand. Apart from the fact that Starbucks was leading the
way in introducing high quality specialty coffee to the masses, it is also stressed how
Starbucks was able to meet a cultural need in society, identified as the need for the so-called
Third Place. The third place is an informal public place between home and work, where
people can meet and gathera place which encourages customers to relax and linger.
Thompson and Arsel (2004) highlighted that the root cause of Starbucks success is
its use of a multiplex communication strategy, which is linked strongly to its branding
strategy as well. This strategy not only relates to the rational mind of the consumers and
influences their rationale behind preferring Starbucks, but also appeals to the consumers
values and beliefs. In this way, Starbucks has differentiated itself from competitors who
have not applied a multiplex strategy, and have hence left the leading role in the speciality
coffee business to Starbucks.
itself. Along with being in prime locations, Starbucks also adjusted the furniture, store
layout, artwork and menu to appeal to Chinese customers. The Starbucks proposition in
China was impressive. But the people did not go there for the coffee. They went there to
present themselves as modern Chinese in a public setting. The local Chinese customers
who made up 70% of the chains business came for business meetings, dates, or to relax
during shopping breaks. Therefore, Chinese Starbucks provided extra seating to
accommodate customers who wanted to linger.
Rein (2012) explained the advertising strategy followed by Starbucks as once
Starbucks decided to enter China, it implemented a smart market entry strategy. It did not
use any advertising and promotions that could be perceived by the Chinese as a threat
to their tea-drinking culture. Instead, it focused on selecting high-visibility and hightraffic locations to project its brand image. It mostly depended on the people to spread
goodwill through word of mouth.
1,480
Barista
168
Costa Coffee
82
Source: Technopak
Case Study
49
years of experience and knowledge about various cultures across the world, which gives it
an edge in international operations. Its success in tea-drinking countries like China and
Japan has to be given due credit; and the company will surely benefit from these
experiences when it enters the Indian market.
Against this backdrop, the case study aims to analyze the challenges and opportunities
that Starbucks would face in the Indian market, and the marketing strategies that it should
follow in the Indian market to replicate its astounding international success in India.
51
Products
Starbucks
80 items on menu
2.
Market Segment
Mass market
3.
Target Customers
Business executives
4.
30-45 years
16-30 years
5.
Price
Premium
Affordable
6.
Pricing Strategy
Standard pricing
Differential pricing
7.
Location
72 outlets in 7 states
across India
8.
Store Format
Single format
Multiple formats
(Regular caf, Premium
Lounge, CCD Square,
Kiosks and Vending
Machines)
9.
Promotion
Starbucks Card
Aspirational Brand
Affordable Brand
High
Medium
Real Estate: Though more and more malls are coming up in Indian cities, high streets will
continue to remain important, and getting the best locations at the right price is a huge
challenge.
People: Recruiting high quality baristas and front-end staff is difficult as these jobs involve
a rigorous process-driven approach.
Tata Coffee, Indias largest coffee producer, has rich expertise in the bean-to-cup
value chain, with a strong focus on quality. It has an internationally certified
52
(ISO: 22000) roast and ground unit at Kushalnagar in Karnataka. Thus, sourcing
of coffee beans from Tata Coffee reduces cost by saving on import duty, while
maintaining consistent quality.
The other major advantage of the alliance is the knowledge and understanding
of the Indian market brought in by Tata Global Beverages (Vasudha, 2011).
Tata also has local knowledge of the real estate market and provides
opportunities to leverage on capabilities in this area.
Tata would also be of help to Starbucks in dealing with the local bureaucracy and
politicians.
There is scope for integrating Starbucks into Taj Hotels, and the possibility of
bringing food from the Taj into the Starbucks stores.
Also, Tata Tea is a prominent player in the tea market, with 18.4% share.
Starbucks will also benefit from Tatas experience in the Indian market regarding
different tastes in different regions, thus making sure that it offers the most
preferable blend of both tea and coffee to customers.
There would also be opportunity to serve Starbucks coffee in the Tata alliance
airlinesAir Asia and Vistara.
Certainly, the joint venture with the Tatas will benefit Starbucks in several ways,
from sourcing and roasting coffee beans to customizing offerings and dealing with local
bureaucracy.
Strengths
Both Starbucks and Tata Global Beverages have a strong brand image.
Both companies are adept at delivering product innovation and premium quality
experience to customers in different parts of the world.
Weaknesses
High prices which cannot be afforded by many.
High rental and real estate cost.
Case Study
53
Opportunities
The coffee consumption in India is expected to grow at a compound annual
growth rate of 6%.
Threats
Intense competition from the established Indian coffeehouses like CCD.
Threat of substitute products, especially of tea.
Increasing health concern regarding the negative effects of coffee.
54
Ice coffee can be included in Starbucks menu as Indians have a preference for
it because of high temperatures during summer.
The taste preferences of Indians are very different as compared to the people in
the West. Competitors like Costa Coffee are offering apple and coconut flavored
products such as coconut hot chocolate suiting Indian taste. Likewise, Starbucks
should supplement its menu with local flavors and varieties.
A majority of Indians drink tea much more than coffee. Since Tata Tea is the
second biggest tea brand in the world, Starbucks can leverage on this advantage
and offer tea-based products in addition to the premium Starbucks coffee.
Catering to the North Indian taste, paneer-based and non-vegetarian items can
be introduced in the menu along with flavors based on Indian spices.
Price: Pricing plays a crucial role in the successful reach of the products to customers. Indian
consumers are perhaps among the toughest lot in the world to convince on the price-value
relationship. They are very cost-conscious and look for value in whatever they pay for.
Therefore, Starbucks pricing strategy should match with the Indian consumer behavior.
Historically, Starbucks has retained its US pricing model in almost every market
that it has entered, i.e., Starbucks has only one format of stores and one
approach to pricing in all countries where it operates. However, in India, to
target different segments of customers such as college students, business
executives and foreign travelers, Starbucks should have different formats of
stores and follow differential pricing strategy.
Starbucks being a premier coffee brand, whose target market includes people
with higher disposable income, the location of the stores can be in hypermalls,
in multiplex theaters, and near IT parks and cultural venues.
CCD and Barista Coffee are primarily targeting the major cities. Therefore,
Starbucks could aim to enter smaller cities which have market potential, as people
there are more likely to be brand-loyal as opposed to customers in the large cities.
Starbucks can open in-stores in Croma, Star Bazaar, Trent and also in the hotels
belonging to the Tata Group.
As the real estate cost is shooting up within the cities, Starbucks can
concentrate on motels to target travelers along popular national highways.
As coffee chains are seen as places to socialize and people aged 25-40 years are
mainly the target group, Starbucks may consider opening a new type of outlet
to target this group.
Case Study
55
Promotion: Promotion is extremely important for drawing the attention of the consumers
and thereby gaining market share.
Starbucks can also take to social media marketing in a big way. Through
communications via e-mails, Facebook, etc., customers can be encouraged to
engage with the brand and gift Starbucks mugs with personalized name and
message to their loved ones.
Starbucks card can be promoted a convenient way to pay for ones drinks and
also earn rewards for ones purchase.
Starbucks can leverage on the Tata network for promotion. Tata owns
enterprises such as Taj Hotels, Westside, Landmark Bookstore and Air Asia,
which focus on premium category customers, and these can be used to reach out
to the targeted segment.
Starbucks long-term success in India will call for a presence in many more cities and
in several different formats. This would mean expanding into smaller cities such as
Chandigarh, Guwahati, Indore, Jaipur, Kochi and Ludhiana, where disposable incomes may
be high but the willingness to hand over a three-figure sum for a cup of coffee may be yet
to develop. To become a success, Starbucks will have to widen its appeal with a pan-India
presence. However, if it adopts premium pricing to recover at least a part of the exorbitant
real estate and other costs that it would have to bear, it runs the risk of alienating a
significant portion of prospective customers (Gopalan, 2014).
References
1. Agrawal A and Sharma M (2012), Starbucks, Tata Venture to Open First India Store
by August, Bloomberg.
56
57
19. Rein S (2012), Why Starbucks Succeeds in China and Others Havent. Retrieved
from USA Today website: http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/money/industries/food/
story/2012-02-12/cnbc-starbucks-secrets-of-china-success/53040820/1.
20. Thompson C and Arsel Z (2004), The Starbucks Brandscape and Consumers
(Anticorporate) Experiences of Glocalization, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 31,
No. 3, pp. 631-642.
21. Vaidyanathan R (2012), Coffee vs. Tea: Is India Falling for the Cappuccino?, BBC,
February 9.
22. Vasudha M (2011), Starbucks-Tata Alliance: Brewing a Fresh Strategy for India,
Amity Research Center.
Reference # 25J-2015-09-04-02
58
Copyright of IUP Journal of Brand Management is the property of IUP Publications and its
content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the
copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email
articles for individual use.