Hard Question
Hard Question
Hard Question
answer
hard
interview
questions
...and everything else you need
to know to get the job you want
Charlie Gibbs
howtobooks
How to
answer
hard
interview
questions
...and everything else you need
to know to get the job you want
Charlie Gibbs
howtobooks
CONTENTS
PREFACE
xi
1
2
3
5
6
6
10
31
34
35
38
39
40
40
41
41
44
45
45
48
50
51
51
51
VI
54
54
55
56
57
60
67
71
75
79
82
86
92
95
97
101
105
109
113
113
115
117
117
122
122
127
60
CONTENTS
VII
10
TELEPHONE INTERVIEWS
130
11
133
133
136
137
138
140
142
144
147
149
151
154
156
157
159
Index of questions
165
Index
169
PREFACE
At the point of publication of this second edition, the world is in the
middle of the most severe economic downturn in decades. As more and
more companies go to the wall, an inevitable consequence is a swelling of
the ranks of those without a job. Each one of those people who lose their
job is potentially a direct competitor of yours for the job you want. Never
has it been more important for an individual to have an edge at interview.
I hope that I can help you gain that competitive advantage by equipping
you with the insider knowledge you need to get the job you want. Please
take advantage of my offer to answer a question you may have personally.
I would love to hear from you.
We are now living in a world where changing jobs is considered a
natural thing to do. Only a generation ago, my father being a prime
example, it was common for people to clock up 20, 30, 40+ years of
service with the one organisation. Most of us cannot conceive of
remaining with the one employer for the vast majority of our working
lives. It is a combination of the increase in individual aspirations and the
nature of commerce which has brought about this change. The
consequence is that practically all of us, whether by choice or
circumstance, will be required to seek employment elsewhere and will
need to go through the whole process of job seeking, applying and then
being scrutinised in some way (the interview still being the most
common example), before we can actually spend that first pay cheque.
I will briefly cover the search and application process. However the main
thrust of this book is the employment interview itself.
Its getting on for twenty years now that I have been fortunate enough
(some might say unfortunate enough) to be on the side of the desk
where sits that scariest of dragons: the interviewer. During that time I
have seen candidates who have inspired me to almost offer them the
job there and then and not let them leave the building until theyve
signed a contract. Ive seen candidates excuse themselves to go and
XI
XII
throw up due to nerves. Ive seen candidates who have tried to convince
me that they were doing me the greatest favour in the world by
deigning to come for interview. Ive seen candidates whom Ive thought
were mute, such was their reticence. Ive seen candidates whose
vocabulary ranged all the way from yes to no. Ive seen candidates
who gave me such detailed answers to my questions that I was on the
verge of losing the will to live.
The sheer variation of quality in the performance of interviewees has
prompted me to distil what Ive learned into one manageable body of advice
which, I hope, will give you the edge when it comes to getting that job.
What follows are my tips on how to prepare for the interview itself, how
to conduct yourself at the interview and, most crucially perhaps,
examples of the kind of answers we interviewers REALLY want to hear.
These are grouped into categories known as competencies as the
approach most modern organisations take these days is the
competency-focused interview. After all, we, as professional managers,
are trying, on behalf of our organisations to secure the services of the
most wonderful, motivated, efficient and productive employee, while
trying to show how clever we are at recruitment at the same time!
The interviewer(s) are never the enemy. They may use methods which
you think are in turn obvious, brutal or downright devious, but
remember it is all in the cause of getting the right person for the job
who will fit in because of their skill set, personality and attitude for
cultural fit is really important in terms of the likely longevity of their
term in post. One day you may very well be sitting where they are and
Ill bet you will be able to justify your approach for the cause!
Finally, if you have been asked a particular question in the past that
stumped you, or you are anticipating a question that I havent covered
in this edition, you are welcome to email me your question and I will
personally give you a considered response. Send your question to:
charlie.gibbs@live.co.uk.
I hope you will find this book useful and I wish you every success in
your chosen career.
Charlie Gibbs
Chapter 1
the pot luck that is generic press advertising. Choose where you search
for your next job carefully.
OK, so youve now seen an advert that has caught your eye and you are
sure you want to apply. Firstly, does the advert say that applications are to
be made by supplying a curriculum vitae plus covering letter or via
application form? Lets look at some pointers for dealing with each of these.
Once you are happy with your draft, transfer the detail to the original
form. Always write application forms in your neatest hand and in
black ink for preference as this photocopies well. Never use any other
colour except black or blue inks.
Once you have completed the form, photocopy it for your own
records. You may wish to take it to interview with you to refer to.
Draft a covering letter to go with your form. Keep it brief and always
use the term Dear Mr Smith, or whatever the recruiters surname is.
Dont be tempted to use their forename, even if the advert has it on,
as this is over-familiar. Never write Dear Sir or Madam as it too
demonstrates a lack of attention to detail.
Curricula vitae
I will leave it to you to decide on the style and content of your
curriculum vitae. There are many sources which will advise you on these
aspects. Here are some brief pointers:
I
I
I
I
Imagine your delight, constant reader, when two weeks later you receive
on lovely headed paper an invite to attend an interview for this
potentially wonderful new job! Thats when your hard work really
begins. In Chapter 2 I will explore what you need to be thinking about
before you actually attend the interview.
CHAPTER 2
ASSESSING YOURSELF
Before you even embark on your journey of securing that fantastic job,
it is advisable to take stock and do some self-assessment. In understanding what you are looking for in a job you can develop clear goals
and targets to assist you. You shouldnt enter into looking for a new job
frivolously. This is a potential life-changing decision after all!
There are many factors which may influence you reaching the decision
to either begin work or change job. Maybe you feel you have not had
the breaks you deserve this far. Maybe youve been overlooked in the
past for promotion or development. Maybe you think circumstances are
not right for you to have the job you want. Im with George Bernard
Shaw on this one, who said:
People are always blaming circumstances for what they are. I dont
believe in circumstances. The people who get ahead in this world are
people who get up and look for the circumstances they want; and if
they cant find them, make them.
the areas they require rather than simply seeking confirmation of the
information contained in your CV.
Have a look at the descriptions of competencies listed below.
Competencies tend to fall into broad categories such as those
described below.
Commercial awareness
Defined as: The individual understands how organisations work; can
apply commercial and financial principles; demonstrates an active
interest in the financial performance of the organisation in terms of
profit and loss, cash-flow, added value, routes to market,
competitiveness, etc.
Leadership of change
Defined as: The individual works with others to implement change; helps
to clarify and avoid ambiguity; willingly accepts change; takes
responsibility for driving things forward; can identify and initiate change;
understands the interconnectivity of departments and how change
affects others.
Leadership skills
Defined as: The individual demonstrates an ability to share a sense of
vision and common purpose; has respect of others through words and
deeds; inspires loyalty and commitment; has an adaptable leadership
style depending on individuals and circumstances; can create and build
teams; is inspirational and enthusiastic; demonstrates empathy; can
transform strategic objectives into firm actions.
Continuous improvement
Defined as: The individual demonstrates the ability to identify the actions
needed to make things happen in a quality-oriented way; can ensure
these actions are carried out; seizes opportunities to make improvements;
establishes conditions to ensure continuous improvement; can plan and
organise tasks; can challenge the status quo.
Customer awareness
Defined as: The individual can demonstrate an ability to meet and exceed
customer expectations; recognises the prime importance of the customer;
can anticipate future customer needs; goes the extra mile for the
customer; takes responsibility for developing long-term relationships
with customers; forges partnerships that contribute to future growth
opportunities for both customer and own organisation.
10
LEVELS OF COMPETENCE
Interviewers will often have already defined the levels of competence
the potential jobholder will need to possess in each of these categories
prior to the interview. Their ideal candidate will score above the
minimum level against each particular competence. However,
interviewers also live in the real world (hard to believe, I know) and may
recognise that they are unlikely to find someone who straightaway
exceeds their minimum requirements. More often than not, the
candidate who has the highest overall score will be the one that
receives the offer. The fact that you may score lower on one or more
competencies does not necessarily mean that you wont be offered the
job an enlightened employer will then build training into your
induction period which will address these shortcomings.
Which level of each of these competencies do you currently possess? It
is easily understood that someone can be OK at something or brilliant
at something in everyday life. But how do employers stratify the level of
competence an individual has? Many organisations have gone through
a long and painful process of examining their competencies and putting
into words what each level of competence looks like. Below is a typical
example of the type of analysis that has been done in the real world.
TASK
Get a piece of paper and a pen. Read through each competency
level description in turn and write down which level you believe
you are operating at currently. Once complete, you will have
created a fairly comprehensive Competency Profile of yourself. This
process is an excellent way for you to focus your mind on what
skills you actually have. Once you have a self-awareness of your
skills, this will enable you to speak so much more eloquently to
your prospective employer. I have rated these levels 15, with 5
being the highest.
11
12
13
Strategic thinking
Level 1 strictly speaking, there is no Level 1 competence in this
competency.
Level 2 understands greater organisational context, markets and
competitors.
Demonstrated by:
I Understands relationship between own role and business strategy in
the short term.
I Can interpret some business strategy in the terms of operational
plans.
I Uses customer feedback to make improvements.
I Gives some consideration to external factors.
Level 3 can maintain an overview of complicated situations with an
eye on detail.
Demonstrated by:
I Sees beyond the immediate needs of their own area to understand
the interconnectivity of departments.
I Has an eye on the future at all times.
I Maintains an overview of complex situations but controls the finer
details.
I Understands the impact of strategies on the medium to longer term.
Level 4 sets plans and objectives with a view to the future success of
the organisation in terms of technical and people issues.
Demonstrated by:
I Understands the impact of strategies in the long term.
I Has cognisance of people issues.
14
I
I
Relationship building
Level 1 makes efforts to build and maintain a network of internal and
external contacts.
Demonstrated by:
I Uses others to complete tasks.
I Responds helpfully to requests for information.
I Is courteous and honest in dealing with others.
I Is aware of own impact on others.
I Keeps others informed of own progress in work.
Level 2 understands the value of building up sound working
relationships.
Demonstrated by:
I Puts sustained efforts into building relationships.
I Uses both formal and informal channels to communicate with others.
I Checks understanding when communicating.
I Can identify key decision-makers.
I Is aware of the importance of including the right people at the
right time.
15
16
Commercial awareness
Level 1 shows a level of interest in internal and external
business issues.
Demonstrated by:
I Finds out about how the organisation works.
I Knows who the organisations competitors are.
I Knows who the organisations main customers are.
I Seeks to develop general business knowledge.
I Keeps up to date with current affairs.
Level 2 can analyse in terms of profit and loss, cash-flow and added
value.
Demonstrated by:
Understands basic financial and commercial terminology.
I Keeps abreast of current business performance.
I Keeps abreast in terms of product and market development.
I Understands how own role/department contributes towards business
success.
I Is aware of cost implications and their effect on the bottom line.
I Seeks to maximise productivity and reduce costs wherever possible.
I
17
Leadership of change
Level 1 can successfully adapt to changing conditions and
circumstances.
Demonstrated by:
I Endeavours to be resilient in situations which may appear unclear or
contradictory.
I Shows a willingness to broaden skills and try alternative work.
I Understands the need for progressive change.
I Can adapt quickly and successfully to change.
I Assimilates new ways of working well.
18
Level 2 enjoys the change agenda and willingly accepts the need for
change in methodologies, materials, workflows or technology.
Demonstrated by:
I Understands how change supports the vision of the business and
links with business strategy.
I Anticipates and plans for change in own function.
I Actively cooperates in implementing change.
I Demonstrates an awareness of the big picture.
I Sees change as a positive thing in respect of career-enhancing skills.
Level 3 identifies ways to improve the organisation and encourages
others to do the same. Takes on responsibility for driving the change
agenda.
Demonstrated by:
I Can articulate the benefits of change and shows confidence about
taking on different tasks and activities.
I Works well within a continuously changing and improving
environment and helps others do the same.
I Leads change with vigour and enthusiasm.
I Can produce own innovations and is prepared to take risks with new
ideas and concepts.
I Supports people through the emotional impact of change.
Level 4 frequently identifies and initiates change affecting specific
organisational operations.
Demonstrated by:
I Prepares and implements plans for the changes taking into account
the material and people factors necessary to make the
implementation work.
I Conducts changes with an eye on minimising disruption to outputs
and quality.
19
Leadership skills
Level 1 in deeds and words, gains the respect and confidence of
colleagues.
Demonstrated by:
I Able to give guidance and support to colleagues.
I Gains the confidence and respect of the team and supports them in
achieving targets.
I Clearly communicates individual and team goals.
I Generates plans instructions and directions.
I Continually reviews progress and gives clear and specific feedback.
20
21
Continuous improvement
Level 1 completes tasks within the allotted time and with the
correct quality.
Demonstrated by:
I Pays attention and challenges processes and content.
I Typically gets things right first time and within timescales.
I Plans own time and resources to meet the tasks ahead.
I Can prioritise work in order of importance and urgency.
Level 2 can challenge the status quo and generate new ideas.
Demonstrated by:
I Searches for new solutions to make required improvements.
I Challenges current working practices in order to identify areas for
improvement.
I Can manage multiple tasks to meet a goal.
I Adapts own working practices to meet new requirements.
Level 3 knows how to plan and organise tasks.
Demonstrated by:
I Good at mapping out processes in order to get things done.
I Can use resources such as people, materials, machinery, etc.
effectively in order to achieve targets.
22
I
I
Customer awareness
Level 1 understands that the customer is important to the
organisation. (Note: Customers in this sense can mean internal as well
as external customers.)
Demonstrated by:
I Recognises the importance of internal and external customers.
I Treats every customer respectfully.
I
I
I
23
24
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
25
26
Influencing skills
Level 1 behaves in a straightforward and transparent way that sets a
positive example.
Demonstrated by:
I Wins respect and influences others by own behaviour.
I Is confident and determined.
I Sets a positive example.
I Encourages others to challenge and does not mind being challenged.
I Communicates clearly both orally and in written form.
Level 2 is aware of the impact on others, is a clear communicator,
speaks and writes clearly, is a good listener.
Demonstrated by:
I Regularly shares own views in a clear manner.
I Can articulate the key points of an argument.
I Can be assertive when working with others.
I Observes and listens and understands what is being said.
I Demonstrates integrity when dealing with others at all times.
Level 3 has the personal stature and capability to influence a broad
range of people including key decision-makers.
Demonstrated by:
Displays a variety of styles of action from diplomatic to assertive.
I Uses the appropriate approach to diffuse difficult situations.
I Is able to compromise when necessary.
I Identifies key influencers and focuses on their requirements.
I Demonstrates confidence clearly in all communication scenarios.
I
27
28
29
30
Level 3 understands how and when to set team objectives and utilises
the talent of all team members.
Demonstrated by:
I Able to capitalise on the strengths of team members.
I Makes use of everyones innate abilities.
I Recognises the cultural aspects of teamworking.
I Is a champion for diversity.
I Defines success as when the whole team contributes and shares in
the glory.
Level 4 looks for opportunities for inter- and intra- teamworking to
achieve bigger business goals.
Demonstrated by:
Can put personal needs aside in order to concentrate on team needs.
I Suggests ways of teams working together to achieve business goals.
I Suggests formation of new teams to satisfy the needs of particular
projects.
I Can identify factors which hinder team performance.
I Strives to assist the team in developing its own identity.
I
Phew! Quite a list, Im sure you will agree. It can be quite cathartic to go
through this exercise. The information you glean from doing this will
31
not only give you a general sense of what your competence levels are at
this moment in time, but it can also advise you when you are revising
the content of your curriculum vitae. Perhaps some of the terminology I
have used here has caused you to think Yes! Thats exactly what I do! If
so, Im glad. Use these terms to expand on your role and responsibilities
detailed in your CV. It is often difficult to find a form of words that fully
describes what it is you do exactly. Im sure there are some phrases here
you can adapt for your own use.
32
EXAMPLE
You are going for a job with a company which manufactures parts
for the production of cigarettes. Your research tells you that you
the company has enjoyed growth over the past 20 years and
shows no sign of declining. However, the recent introduction of
anti-smoking legislation in the UK has made you think that this
company must be doing something right in order to continue
growing. You dig around some more and find that in the UK
smoking is actually in decline through a combination of the new
legislation and through greater awareness of health issues by the
general public. Ergo, the only reason the company can still be
growing is because they are selling outside of the UK.
You do some more searching and find that the worlds growth
markets are India, China and other developing countries. Now, it is
tempting to then just drop into your conversation with the
33
TIP
Companies which are public limited companies (PLCs) are duty
bound to supply copies of the most recent Annual Report to anyone
who requests one. Find out the registered address of the company
and telephone their Public Relations Department for a copy.
Lastly, but not least, how much information on the post you are
applying for is actually contained in that job advert? Not much, Ill
wager. Enough to capture your interest, sure, but enough to decide
34
whether or not this really is the job for you? Probably not. Telephone or
e-mail the Human Resource Department and ask them for a copy of the
formal job description. This should have much more detail than the
advertisement and again provide you with clues on how to prepare.
TIMING IS EVERYTHING
There is an old saying relating to appearing for an interview: If you are not
ten minutes early, then you are ten minutes late! Do you know, its true!
If you are way too early it may appear that you have (a) not researched
the travel time; (b) are a tad desperate to impress; (c) have poor time
management skills. Be aware of potential road traffic issues if you are
travelling by car and make sure all public transport selections will have
you arriving in plenty of time. Take along with you the original
invitation letter which will give you the organisations telephone
number should you have to call ahead and explain that you are going to
be delayed. If you do not have a mobile phone, make sure you have
change for a payphone.
Ten minutes is almost respectful. It allows the organisation plenty of
time if they have not finished their preparations just yet and you are the
first candidate.
It may well be that the previous candidates interview is extended a little
or they are late in seeing you. However fed up you are at this obvious
personal slight, please do not let it show on your face! Remember, you
might just be grateful for the interest you have generated in them
whereby they dont notice the passage of time and your allotted time
runs on!
35
36
37
38
39
interviewers have set the room up in a more casual manner, e.g. with
their chairs at 45 degrees to you, then place it at your feet on the side
that faces them. If possible utilise clear-covered folders rather than have
them within a posh leather folio.
It is a good idea to take a notepad and pen with you too. At the outset of
the interview ask if it is all right for you to take notes during the
employers input as you may wish to ask questions based on what they say.
CHAPTER 3
LEGISLATION THAT
EMPLOYERS NEED TO
COMPLY WITH
While it is not the purpose of this text to be a reference book on
employment law, I have included this chapter to make you aware of the
legislative aspect of recruitment. Employers have to ensure they comply
with the varying pieces of law and regulations or suffer not only
punitive fines but also immeasurable damage to their reputation as an
employer. Discrimination claims of all types are heard in the
employment tribunals in Scotland, England and Wales. Employers may
also be liable to make compensatory awards to those whom they have
wronged. If you have a basic awareness of what an employer can and
cannot do in the interview situation, then you are more likely to know
whether or not you have the right to seek remedy at tribunal.
At the end of the chapter, I will briefly discuss employment tribunals
should you decide to make a claim if you believe you have been
unlawfully discriminated against when you have applied for a job and
failed to be appointed. Note: This legislation applies in the United
Kingdom only.
L E G I S L A T I O N T H A T E M P L OY E R S N E E D T O C O M P LY W I T H
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
41
42
L E G I S L A T I O N T H A T E M P L OY E R S N E E D T O C O M P LY W I T H
I
I
43
An employer cannot claim that a GOQ applies if there are enough other
members of staff of the appropriate sex to cover the duties in question.
For example, it would be unlawful for an employer to restrict a vacancy
in a clothes shop to women on the grounds that part of the duties
involved assisting in the changing room if there were enough women
sales assistants already employed to cover that aspect of the job.
But how can I find out if I was rejected for a post because of
my sex?
In order to successfully make a claim of direct sex discrimination, you
have to show that you would have been appointed if not for your sex.
You can do this by showing that you were better qualified and
experienced than the successful candidate. You may know little about
the employer and his recruitment practices; you may not know anything
about the successful candidate. In these circumstances, it is important
44
L E G I S L A T I O N T H A T E M P L OY E R S N E E D T O C O M P LY W I T H
45
46
I
I
L E G I S L A T I O N T H A T E M P L OY E R S N E E D T O C O M P LY W I T H
47
What is reasonable?
If the adjustment you require is a reasonable one then the employer
must make it. However, an employer may say that the adjustment you
require is not 'reasonable' in the circumstances. For example because:
I
I
I
I
I
I
48
I
I
Disability-related discrimination
Disability-related discrimination happens when an employer's treatment
of the disabled person is for a reason related to their disability and is less
favourable than the way in which others, to whom that disability-related
reason does not apply, are or would be treated and which the employer is
unable to justify and/or when the employer has failed to make a
reasonable adjustment, which would have made a difference to the
reason the employer has given justifying its less favourable treatment.
To work out if disability-related discrimination has happened to you,
you need to identify whether a disability-related reason is a factor in
the treatment you are receiving and identify in what way the treatment
that you are receiving is less favourable compared to others to whom
the disability-related reason does not apply, and consider whether the
explanation for the treatment, if any, put forward by the employer could
justify the discrimination. This means that you would have to look at
whether there is a strong link between the explanation given for your
treatment and your circumstances. You would also have to consider
whether the explanation carried real weight. You would also need to
consider whether the employer had failed to make a reasonable
adjustment and, if so, whether, had an adjustment been made, it would
have made a difference to the explanation that the employer used to
justify the less favourable treatment.
L E G I S L A T I O N T H A T E M P L OY E R S N E E D T O C O M P LY W I T H
49
50
Second combination:
I
L E G I S L A T I O N T H A T E M P L OY E R S N E E D T O C O M P LY W I T H
51
52
process you are known as the claimant and your opponent as the
respondent. Together you are known as the parties to a claim.
You can bring claims against individual employees who you believe have
discriminated against you as well as the employer. It is important to
name individual employees as respondents as well as the employer if
there is any possibility that the employer might be able to persuade the
tribunal that it took reasonable steps to prevent the discrimination you
are complaining about.
To help you decide whether or not to take a claim to the tribunal, it is
worth considering what you hope to achieve and whether this is
something the tribunal can order if your claim succeeds. A tribunal can:
I
I
Like all legal environments, there are certain burdens of proof before a
claim can be successful and a number of decisions regarding the shift in
the burden of proof in discrimination cases have been heard in the
Court of Appeal. The court states that, when considering discrimination
cases, a tribunal has to conduct a two-stage exercise.
First the claimant has to prove discrimination (i.e. facts from which the
tribunal could conclude that, in the absence of an adequate explanation,
L E G I S L A T I O N T H A T E M P L OY E R S N E E D T O C O M P LY W I T H
53
CHAPTER 4
UNDERSTANDING THE
EMPLOYERS PERSPECTIVE
Knowing what employers will be doing and thinking will give you an
insight into their processes and thoughts. This will help you better
prepare for your interview.
PREPARATION
In order to get the best out of any interview, employers should have
prepared thoroughly. Once they have shortlisted candiates and decided
on the interview date, they should have tried to find a good location - a
quiet office or room which is free from interruptions and suitable for all
candidates. They should have considered whether any of the candidates
attending are disabled, as it may be necessary to consider whether any
adjustments to the process need to be made, such as holding the
interview in a brightly lit or wheelchair accessible room. Hopefully they
will use a room that will create a good impression!
Good practice states that two managers and an HR representative are
present at interviews to minimise any bias and provide protection
against any discrimination claims that the candidate could make from a
one-to-one interview. Obviously the size and the resources of the
organisation will have a bearing on who actually interviews.
Be aware that when employers use two or more interviewers, they may
have agreed in advance who should ask which questions. This may
mean your head turns from interviewer to interviewer like watching a
tennis match!
54
U N D E R S T A N D I N G T H E E M P L OY E R S P E R S P E C T I V E
55
56
Hmm, let me think about that for a moment to make sure they are
aware that you havent just gone blank.
They will probably take notes throughout the interview, so dont be put
off by the lack of eye contact.
At the end of the interview, the interviewer may make sure that you are
familiar with the terms and conditions of the job and that they are
acceptable. You should be informed what will happen next and when a
decision will be made. If not, ask!
Since a contract of employment can be formed by a verbal offer and
acceptance, interviewers should ensure that they do not use words that
could be construed as an offer unless this is what they intend. In most
cases and particularly where the job offer is to be made is subject to
conditions such as satisfactory references it is likely that your
interviewer will say at best that they will recommend that an offer be
made or that an offer will be sent out in due course. The most common
approach is to make the offer afterwards. Interviewers will be aware that
promises made to successful candidates at their interview can end up as
part of their contract of employment, so are likely to be cagey in going
into too much detail about what any offer would entail. Remember,
statements made at interview can also be used as evidence of the terms
of the contract if there is subsequently a dispute about its content.
CHAPTER 5
CONDUCTING YOURSELF AT
THE INTERVIEW
There is a variety of different types of interview: such as one-to-one,
panel and group interviews. The style of the interviewers will vary too
some will seem very stern and assertive while others will be more
welcoming and engaging. In every case though, there are basic
principles that you should adopt in how you deport yourself and behave
during the interview.
I make no apologies for using the word behave as there used to be a
(now discredited) style of interview where the interviewers were
deliberately antagonistic, the idea being to see if they could get the poor
candidate to behave as they would when working under pressure.
Thankfully, this practice is very rare these days and you are unlikely to
have to suffer the torment of this.
OK, basic principles then
I
I
I
When you first enter the room make sure you have good posture and
make eye contact with everyone in the room.
As you are introduced to everyone, give a firm (not too firm)
handshake. If you are prone to sweaty palms, make sure you
discreetly wipe them before you commence shaking hands.
Scan the room layout once only and maintain eye contact with the
lead or only interviewer.
Look alert and wait to be asked to sit down.
If you are offered a tea or coffee, politely decline. Its only another
thing that can go wrong like spilling it down yourself or worse still
knocking it over!
57
58
Ok, so the interview is under way. You may be asked to talk through
your career to date. This is where your copy of your CV comes in handy
to have in front of you. As I said in Chapter 2, its amazing what a visual
prompt can do for the memory. When talking about your career to date,
dont repeat merely what it says on your CV. Your interviewers will have
read it already and are looking for you to expand on what it contains. If
youve done your own competency profiling as I suggested in Chapter 2,
you will be able to talk about your various positions in terms of your
competencies and, more importantly, achievements. Always accentuate
anything of note that you were responsible for. Beware, however, of
over-exaggerating your role in the success of an organisation. In a
recent reality TV show that sought a budding entrepreneur to work with
a highly successful and well-known London-based businessman, a
contestant claimed that through her efforts her company increased its
turnover by several million pounds. What? By yourself? asked the
stony-faced interviewer. The resultant spluttering of the contestant was
C O N D U C T I N G YO U R S E L F A T T H E I N T E R V I E W
59
Note
1. In NLP, practitioners are advised to match, as if in a mirror, the
gestures, postures and even breathing rates of the person they are
attempting to establish rapport with. NLP holds that subconscious
signals are sent to the other person which guides them into thinking
favourably of you.
CHAPTER 6
COMMON INTERVIEW
QUESTIONS AND HOW TO
ANSWER THEM
QUESTIONS ABOUT YOUR DRIVE FOR
ACHIEVEMENT
60
61
By all means use the net, but dont just settle for the party line. Find out
who their competitors are and what they are saying. Find out the
registered office of the company and telephone their marketing
department and request that they send out to you a copy of the most
recent annual report. By law in the UK, PLCs must comply with this
request from any person. I have had some fun over the years reminding
junior clerks of this!
Can you imagine interviewing five people and all of them trot out the
same facts and figures taken from the same source? What if the sixth
interviewee reminds you that at the moment you are only number two
in the world market; however, the CEO has a strategy in place to take
you to number one, and that involves No contest! Get him/her back
for a final interview!
Im asking you to be a bit smarter than the average bear on this one. Be
creative about how you illustrate what you know about their company.
If you are asked this question at interview and you are unprepared for it
you will probably make a hash of it. No question. Its the interviewer
mining that negativity seam again and your auto-response will be to go
into denial about it. After all, someone as brilliant as me gets it right
first time, every time, dont I?
The trick here is to recall a time when, although the eventual outcome
was positive, the success was down to either your intervention or your
realisation that what you were doing first time round was not working.
Theres no shame in admitting that your initial approach to a situation
turned out to be less effective than youd hoped, but through your well
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
country. This would tell me that this is still a growing market for them
to invest in new plant, and they might see benefits from economies of
scale as they get larger, which would drive their costs down, making
them more profitable and therefore more competitive. I also saw that
XYZ have developed a new process which reduces the baking time of a
loaf by 20 per cent. This will also make them tough to compete against.
I would say in order to secure the long-term success of your business
you will need to ensure that you are keeping up with technological
advances in the manufacture of your product. You will also have to tie
your suppliers down to deals that secure your supply of raw material,
with minimal fluctuations in price, and you will need to ensure that
your distribution system is at least as good as your competitors to
enable you to keep abreast of them in terms of getting goods to
market as fresh as is possible.
This answer demonstrates your commercial and business acumen by
offering the employer a chance to see that you can develop an opinion
based on various sources of information and not just regurgitate the
corporate blurb.
71
This question can be answered equally well from the point of view of a
subordinate or a manager. As a manager your relationship with your
72
direct reports will often influence how well your department performs,
therefore its imperative you get your team pulling for you as much as
they are pulling for themselves. A typical answer might be:
When I took over as Team Leader in my last job, I realised that Id have
to gain credibility really quickly. I decided not to trot out the old
platitudes about my door always being open etc., but rather tried to
make myself seem grounded and definitely on their side. I knew that
one of the team had applied for my job and had the potential to
undermine me from within, so one of my first tasks was to take him
aside (I did 1-2-1 meetings with all of my staff in my first week) and
shared with him my views on being new in the role. I told him I needed
someone whom I could trust, to be my guide to office politics and to
steer me through the minefield of the organisations policies and
procedures. He was delighted to be separated out from the rest of the
team like that, to be treated like a trusted aide so quickly. However, I
knew this was a high-risk strategy as he might have reacted negatively
in a fit of pique, but thankfully it turned out well.
From a subordinates position, a good answer might be:
When I first joined the team I realised that I had to fit in really quickly. I
made sure I asked lots and lots of questions relating to my job, but I
took an interest in peoples personal lives too without prying of
course. I made sure that I remembered peoples partners names etc.,
and to ask how their children had got on at sports day, for example, if
a colleague happened to mention she was excited about her son
taking part. I was scrupulous in meeting deadlines or getting back to
people when I said I would and I was always honest enough to admit
when I didnt know something or couldnt help someone. That way
people would trust me and I would be seen as credible and reliable.
73
This question is not only about you having self-awareness, but also the
ability to spot such traits in others. You can use a bit of poetic licence
here if you wish. After all, if you describe this person in the correct way,
it could be Hamish McTavish from Glasgow (who might not even exist)
to Sir Richard Branson (who may or may not be as you describe him).
Either way, the crux of the matter here is for you to describe this person,
ficticious or otherwise, using the right type of adjectives.
I used to work with this chap called Ewan. Ive never seen someone
who could get so many people to do things for him when he needed
them to or to be so readily accepted in any company. From my
observations of him I saw that he always communicated in the same
relaxed and friendly manner with everyone, no matter what their
position in the company. Hed occasionally work late in order to get
things completed for other people. He genuinely seemed to care about
others and always made a point of being extra helpful to new people. I
once asked him what he thought he did that made people trust him,
and he simply told me that he always treated others like he expected to
be treated: he was truthful, kept his promises, didnt make excessive
demands on others, and acted on the basis that people are intrinsically
good and would rather do you a good turn than a bad one. I suppose
you might say that some couldve thought him nave, but I didnt. He
lived up to his own ideals which made people round about him live up
to them too.
74
this to get such a bland answer as that would they? No. If you didnt
answer no at this point, go stand in the corner and come and see me at
home time.
What they are getting at here is are you self-aware enough of your
own behaviours and how they affect others? Can you adapt depending
on the character or nature of who you are with?
Im conscious that I dont dominate the conversation when I meet new
people. I genuinely like people, so I ask a lot of questions not enough
to be accused of prying, but I always try and remember the details of
what they say to me. Maybe its their interests, or things theyve said
about their family. I then drop it into conversation and the response is
usually positive.
75
The initial question here is almost designed for anyone who ever took a
marketing course in the past or has a basic grasp of common sense (I
know, I know, its in short supply).
Well I think first and foremost your organisation has built up its brand
to a point where people automatically think of you when they think of
(their product/service here). My view is that people regard Company
XYZ as one of the leaders in their field supplying this particular market
in such a way that people know what to expect: a good product at a
good price at the right time.
76
your margin, and you can only increase your margin by either raising
selling prices or reducing selling costs. I dont really know enough
about your particular business model to offer a serious opinion on
what I think you should do. Do we have time to explore this further?
Here again we have used honesty in admitting we dont have all the
facts. The candidate who makes bold statements on how the people
interviewing him have actually got it all wrong thus far is not brave,
merely foolish! Again, you have shown good time awareness by asking if
there is enough time to go deeper into this question.
77
78
went through the machine, doing away with Post-it notes, etc. It just
dawned on me that the biggest cost for us was peoples time, so the
more time we could save, the better. I then realised that it was actually
other peoples time in coming to see me and my colleagues that was
the biggest waste, so I came up with the intranet idea.
When you come up with your own answer to this question, be sure to
incorporate an element of you comparing options and going for the
most practical/cost-effective/easily achieved, etc.
79
The clue to a good answer for this question is in the use of the word
major. Your interviewer is not looking for some answer in relation to
how you changed suppliers for the photocopy paper for example. This is
BIG change they are on about. Granted, you may not have been subject
to big change, as not everybody has, so if you havent, just say so.
I worked for an organisation which was a plc and the culture and style
of how we worked was very much as youd expect from a large
organisation. We had the best equipment, flexible working practices,
cheap gym membership, etc. However, the companys shares were
bought by a group of venture capitalists and thats when the changes
80
began. After a while, once the dust had settled, we started to get visits
from people who were working on a synergy project. We soon found
out that this meant they were looking for ways to identify savings by
seeing where we had functions and processes that could be carried out
by the new owners existing staff and they could cut costs by axing
people and jobs at our end. After the HR function was moved to their
head office along with finance and marketing, we realised that we
werent in Kansas any more and that things were going to be a lot
different. Where we always had a human being to talk to in relation to
personnel matters, we now had to talk to a voice on the end of the
phone and our calls were logged and we were given a case number.
Most people hated this and many complaints were lodged about it. I
had heard of the Business Partner approach to HR which has first-line
managers carrying out many of the less complex functions of HR. I
looked into this and suggested to my department head that all firstline managers get a grounding in discipline, grievance, recruitment
and the like so that we could deal with our team members basic stuff
without them having to phone this hated hotline. He put the idea up
the chain of command and Im pleased to say that we had a number of
seminars on personnel subjects and we were given basic guide books
to help us out. So what started off as a terrible situation turned out to
be one where a lot of us were pleased to be receiving new and
interesting training, and we provided a solution to the problem of
there not being a human face there when people had problems.
81
82
83
This is the classic version of this question. This is the big pink neon sign
that says: Cmon! Show us just what a brilliant leader you are! You can
adapt your answer to fit depending on whether or not you have
experience in leadership.
I was working as a member of the production staff at XYZ Co. and this
year they conducted an employee satisfaction survey. Once all the
results were in, a focus group was formed to look at the results. I was
nominated from our area to be part of this group. I thought at first it
was just a matter of turning up and expressing my opinion about the
results. I quickly found out that the company was deadly serious about
making changes based on the results of this survey. One of the results
that came out was that people often felt that they were kept in the dark
about what was going on with the company. Mushroom management
was the way one person described it! An action was formulated that
stated a sub-group would examine the options for improving
communications on site and I was designated the action point owner. I
was given a free hand to choose three or four people from the entire
workforce both blue and white collar to work on this with me. I had a
timescale for feeding back recommendations to the focus group. I
thought the best approach would be to have team members with
different skill sets to help us achieve our goal which was effectively to
provide the employees by suitable means with the type of information
that they wanted to hear. I thought about the various elements of the
action point and had an idea of who I wanted in the team. I convened a
meeting quickly and designated each team member with a particular
role. I had a secretary devise, distribute and collate the results of a simple
questionnaire to determine what exactly people wanted to know about; I
chose one chap from our buying department and he was tasked with
finding out exactly what ways we could use to get our message across.
84
85
86
87
Office-based example:
I worked for company XYZ Ltd in their purchasing department. In the
days before routine ordering via e-mail or the ability to order online,
for urgent orders we used to fax them to our suppliers. Now, being a
really busy office with many urgent orders, we were sending loads and
loads of faxes every day. We had recently had a circular memo
reminding us of the costs of leaving lights on etc. and that our
telephone bills were really high. I noticed one day that when we were
sending faxes, the last page of the order documents often only had a
little bit of text at the top and a lot of plain paper underneath. This
wasnt planned; it was just the way the text wrapped from one page to
the next when it came off the printer. It struck me that every time we
sent a fax like that we were paying for a piece of plain paper to go
through the fax machine and this was at our expense because the
telephone link with the receivers fax machine was still open. I made a
suggestion to the office manager that we tear off any white paper at
the end of the fax to use as scrap paper people used to use Post-it
notes for scribbling on and that way, when the last, short page went
through the machine, the fax would cut off and shorten the time we
were on the phone line. Now Ive no idea how much we saved in terms
of the phone bill, but I did see loads of home-made scrap pads from
the saved pieces of paper, so it must have been a reasonable amount.
Employers love this type of story. Anything that you have done to save
them money translates directly to the bottom line. Each
pound/dollar/euro/whatever saved in expenditure is one they can
reinvest in the company to secure its future! Never, ever think a small
contribution like the one illustrated here would go unnoticed, and it will
always earn you brownie points in an interview.
88
Production-based example:
When I worked for Mega Crisps Ltd at their potato crisp factory, I was
employed as a machine setter. One of my jobs involved removing a circular
drum which had around 20 sharp blades in its circumference through
which the potatoes passed to be sliced into their final thickness before
they were fried, flavoured and bagged. I was instructed to watch a display
which showed an ever reducing time reading counting down from four
hours down to zero. At that point, I was to remove the drum and replace
the blades before putting it back into production. The blades which sliced
the potatoes only had a production life of four hours before they became
too blunt to slice cleanly. I realised after a bit that I was taking a drum
offline, replacing the blades, then putting the drum back into production
again. The whole time that this took was around 35 minutes from taking it
off to putting it back again. Id then wait until the next line was due to be
dealt with. This might mean a wait of around 45 minutes before the next
one was due. I just had to busy myself with cleaning etc., but a lot of the
time I was just mooching around waiting to work again. It struck me that
if we only had one more drum, I could fill that up with blades while all the
machines were operating and then use it to replace the first one as soon
as Id taken it offline. This operation only took five minutes, so the line was
only unproductive for five minutes instead of 30. Id then replace that
drums blades and wait for the next one to require changing and so on and
so forth. So over a shift we got an additional 60 minutes of production
time for each line. This meant a massive leap in productivity over the year.
I got a cash award for that suggestion.
The above was an actual example given to me during an interview. Its a
great example because the candidate didnt just follow instructions. He
demonstrated a genuine interest in his own job and how he could
contribute to the productivity levels. He was directly responsible for
increasing the profitability of his organisation and was rightly rewarded
for it. Now not everyone will have such an obvious example that they
can quote at interview, but I would urge you to think hard about the
time when you perhaps acted outside your strict remit and gave that
little bit extra for your employer.
89
90
What prevents me from getting it all done? Well, the usual things, I
suppose: telephone calls, e-mails, colleagues and bosses interrupting
me! My approach is to try and be disciplined with my time. I will have set
times for answering e-mails or making calls where possible, although
you have to be flexible too to cope with what the job throws at you.
What you have done here is demonstrated an excellent grasp of timemanagement skills as taught by many reputable and fine
organisations. Even if you dont employ such techniques, at least be
aware of them so that you might quote them in the interview situation.
91
92
For all customer-facing roles you can almost guarantee that this
question will come up. A business can only grow in two ways.
93
94
Its clever to put this last bit in, as all companies would like to pride
themselves on their level of customer service, and would see themselves
in you by your obviously highly developed customer service skills!
Again, the temptation here is to cite some example where you climbed
up to the summit of Mount Everest, sought out the expedition leader
and said: Here, you left your change on the counter! Interviewers are
realistic (honest) so a more mundane example of where you just did
that little bit extra and helped someones day be that little bit better is
perfectly acceptable here.
We received a request in our office for an application form for an
office role we had advertised. One of the guys came in from the shop
floor with his greasy overalls and mucky hands to collect one. He was a
bit self-conscious given the nature of the role he was applying for was
white collar and he had always been a blue collar worker. During the
process of getting the blank form I chatted to him the whole time
telling him how good it was that he was applying and how he would
stand a good chance of getting it with his experience in the company
etc. As well as giving him the form, I gave him an A4 envelope so he
wouldnt need to fold the form, and then put the whole shebang into a
bigger envelope so the stuff wouldnt get dirty from his hands. The look
on his face made me realise that I had made a good impression on him.
This was backed up later after he didnt get the job when he popped in
to see me to say thanks for the support.
Nothing earth shattering, but a touching little story which shows
your skills.
95
96
97
98
99
Yes, I have had conflicts in the past. Never major ones, but certainly
there have been situations where there was a disagreement that
needed to be resolved. I've found that when conflict occurs, it's
because of a failure to see both sides of the situation. Therefore I ask
the other person to give me their perspective and at the same time ask
that they allow me to fully explain my perspective. At that point, I
would work with the person to find out if a compromise could be
reached. If not, I would submit to their decision because they are my
superior. In the end, you have to be willing to submit yourself to the
directives of your superiors, whether you're in full agreement or not.
100
I think the people I find most hard to persuade are people who have
opinions based solely on prejudice or bias. People who are bigoted,
racist, misogynistic, etc. can often have views that are so entrenched
that they are unlikely ever to change. I think you have to make a
judgement call as to whether or not it is really your place to attempt to
change these people, or whether or not you have to accept that while
you may disagree strongly with their views, you might still have to
work with them. Of course, you might be forced into a situation where
you have to confront someone about their views if it is against your
employers dignity and diversity policy for instance, but you can still
ask them politely to keep such views to themselves in the working
environment. I think you have to develop your own skills in deciding
when enough is enough-when you are not going to get that sale,
when you are not going to convince your boss to give you that rise, or
when its simply time to stop banging your head against a brick wall!
This answer conveys some good points. It shows that you are aware that
you can never change the world entirely, that you can employ
diplomatic skills when necessary, and that you can also cry enough!
when it is warranted.
101
Now doesnt that sound better? I can hear you breathe out as you read
this new, more touchy-feely version of the old classic. In fact, they are
exactly the same question and really designed to illicit the same kind of
answer. Think of it like this: why would an interviewer expect you to tell
him something about you that absolutely rules you out of getting the
job? It wouldnt make any sense. It would be asking you to prove a
negative. An interviewers job is not only to find out if the candidate is
the best fit for the job now, but also to see if they can grow within the
company and expand on their existing skills and ultimately become a
more valuable asset to the company.
A good answer to this question might be:
102
103
I remember the time when one of our more junior members of staff
was struggling to get to grips with the human resource software we
had. She had been given the usual training that we all had and a
photocopied manual. To be honest, the manual was like one of those
flat-pack instruction booklets, and not much good to anyone really.
She was the type of person who didnt like to complain and
occasionally took flak for mistakes she had made. I took her to one side
and asked if I could assist. We agreed that for half an hour each
lunchtime I would sit with her and we would go through the parts of
the package that she was less than sure about. In the end it took about
two or three weeks, but I was happy to help her and she rarely made
mistakes like she had before again. On my birthday she bought me a
big bunch of flowers to say thank you. I was really made up!
Remember, interviewers very rarely ask a single question and let you answer
it fully before moving onto the next one. They may wish to drill down into
what youve initially told them, so be prepared for this. For example:
Now instantly you are thinking back to the last formal course or
qualification you took. In the words of George Gershwin, It aint necessarily
104
105
The last time I worked as part of a team was when I worked for XYZ Co.
I was part of a team in a call centre which sold new and renewed
existing motor and home insurance policies. The team I worked in was
around 10 or 12 in number and the group was fairly stable with not
many starters or leavers. I really appreciated the fact that the team
106
107
others. These people are often natural coaches and mentors, and while
they may not have any leadership type of job title on their contract, are
as much a driving force behind a teams performance as their appointed
leader. So, even if you have not held a leadership position, you may be
able to describe instances where you influenced others.
I remember this time at XYZ Co. when I was working as part of a team
who were brought together to plan and execute an office move to
another building. The management thought it was a good idea to get
people involved from all areas of the company, although some cynics
said it was to get it done on the cheap rather than hiring a specialist
firm. I tend to think that the management were enlightened enough to
think that the whole experience might just be good in terms of the
team members personal development as well as tapping into the
existing talent pool. We were led by a manager who had had some
experience in project management and the firm didnt appear to be
taking too big a risk by appointing her. In the early meetings I was
aware that we were going through a normal process of jostling for
position, trying to bags the better tasks of the project and finding our
niche in the whole thing. I know from my studies of group dynamics
that new teams go through a stage of storming initially, they then
settle and find their shape in the forming phase and then work
unconsciously and consciously together in a stage known as norming.
That is they all work to the same standards. I was acutely aware that
our project leader, while very hot on detail and the mechanics of
project management, failed to recognise what I was seeing which was
that people were being paired up to work on elements of the move in a
very haphazard way. She was not taking notice of what peoples
backgrounds were or attempting to play to their strengths. After a
while it became clear that a number of people in the team were really
quite unhappy and when I asked them if they had brought it to our
project leaders attention, they said they didnt want to upset her or
rock the boat. After I realised that around half the team of 12 were
108
109
110
organisation may like to hear you say: Mahatma Ghandi so I can learn
what his struggle was like for him first hand; Bill Gates to ask him why he
has decided to dedicate most his fortune to charitable enterprises rather
than leaving it to his children; and Stephen Fry, because the conversation
would never falter with Stephen there!
A good tip is to always include Stephen Fry as he is (apparently) the
most popular choice for a dinner guest in the UK and the chances are
your interviewers wouldve picked him too!
If the company concerned was very entrepreneurial, you may wish to
choose Freddie Laker, Richard Branson and Sir Alan Sugar probably the
most famous entrepreneurs of modern times.
You get the idea.
111
If we were risk managers and decided to examine the pros and cons in
two columns on a flip-chart, Im sure we would find many more entries
in the cons column than in the pros column. This question would
appear to be one where the answer is open to debate. I dont think so, as
well as being in HR I am also a manager and I would much rather not
have to deal with the complications resulting from personal
relationships going sour which they quite often do! Id opt for the
easy life every time as would all of the colleagues I recently polled.
Here are some for you to consider what kind of answer you might give:
112
CHAPTER 7
FIRST-ROUND INTERVIEWS
Questions at this stage from you will be directed squarely at the nature
of the employers business and the role for which you are applying.
For example:
I have deliberately used the word share here as it shows them that you
are aware that this is potentially sensitive information. It gives them an out
113
114
if they cant tell you this type of information without it being an awkward
moment. You should be asking this question to get a feel what the overall
prospects are for this company. After all, you dont want to join a firm that
makes umbrellas when we are heading for ten years of drought!
This question is the polar opposite of the classic question they might
ask you on where you see yourself in five years time. Depending on your
role, further development may not be a must for you. However, be
aware that many professional organisations require their members to
demonstrate continuing professional development (CPD) and a firm
which would not give you the opportunity to do this would not be good
for your longer-term career prospects. It is possible that the
organisation may not have a robust system in place for identifying
talent within and developing it further. Gauge their response carefully
as they may waffle on a bit about how training is always available to fit
the needs of the company etc. You should be able to tell if its a sincere
answer or not. Alternatively, completely turn it back on them by asking:
Q U E S T I O N S YO U C A N A S K A T YO U R I N T E R V I E W
115
they are criticised for under performing during the year but have had no
indication during that year that they were failing. Try this question:
Once they have answered this question, you will at least know how high
you have to aim for!
FINAL-STAGE INTERVIEW
All your hard work and preparation for the first interview has paid off
and theyve asked you back for a final look at you. It may well be that
they want you to jump through more hoops such as delivering a
presentation or completing psychometric tests as well as a face-to-face
interview. I will leave it to other publications to counsel you on these
aspects of recruitment so here we will dwell on your proactive
contribution to this conversation.
If you have been wise, you will have done further research into the
company, its business and the market it operates in. You will be aware
116
of the trends and threats to their operation. You will, in short, be a good
person for them to choose to deliver a presentation on their company,
so in-depth will your knowledge of them be! Now is the time for you to
ask them questions that not only elicit answers from them that assist
you in making your decision about whether or not you want to work for
them, but also demonstrate your understanding of your research and
also what was said to you during the initial interview. This is the time to
also get a flavour of what it is actually like to be an employee of
Company XYZ.
Some examples:
CHAPTER 8
QUESTIONS ASKED BY
READERS
The following three questions are actual questions I received from
readers of the first edition of this book who took advantage of the Ask
the author offer. I have reproduced them below verbatim, along with
the answers I gave them.
Dear Charlie,
I found your book really good to read and it helped me with my
interviews, there is one question though that Im not sure is covered
and I was wondering if you could help me with it. Can you please help
me answer it, I come from a finance and project background.
Regards,
Akbar
I
I
I
117
118
Akbar
Thanks for your comments.
I cannot say what would be normal for your methods of research for
your particular field. However, as well as listing what would be obvious
to most in your game, think about 'off the wall' methods, for example in
the HR game, HR managers are researching candidates on Facebook and
MySpace. So think about unusual ways of finding out about your
subject. Make sure that you incorporate any failures you had on the
way; how you felt about the whole thing; include perhaps asking a
mentor or trusted colleague.
Hope this helps
Charlie
Excellent. That was gold dust. Please continue with your writing and I
look forward to a new edition of your book. I found it to the point, up to
date and lacking jargon (most importantly!).
Thanks for the reply.
Akbar
Dear Mr Gibbs,
I recently purchased your book 'How to answer hard interview
questions', and have found the book very useful so far.
Regarding your offer to give some input into a potential question that is
not covered in the book, could you give me some insight into answering
a question relating to the below scenario:
The position I am applying for will be as a joint project manager. The
other project manager is in another organisation, has been working on
the project for quite a while, and has expertise in the general project
119
area. I on the other hand, have very little familiarity with the project,
and very little expertise.
Could you please give me some advice on how I should prepare my
answer to a question on how I would approach the above situation, if I
was successful?
Thanks in advance.
Garry
Well Gary, what you have to do is make yourself different from your
competitors all of whom are in the same boat as you!
Can you research what the job will entail? Is there a job description for
this post? If so, you will have to demonstrate what attributes you have
that match the job description.
You must get speaking to people who are currently working on the
project as soon as possible before your interview. Get the good, the bad
and the ugly from them. This will inform your approach at interview.
You need to impress on your interviewers how you can pick things up
quickly; how you are adaptable and have attention to detail; for
example: you have spelled experience twice in your email to me
e-x-p-e-r-i-A-n-c-e and there are some other spelling mistakes.
Make sure you always use the spell-check facility.
Good luck
Charlie
120
Dear Charlie,
I have read your book on answering hard interview questions, however I
would like to ask a question which relates specifically to salary.
I have a second interview for an audit manager position with a
multinational organisation next week. The first interview went really
well and the second stage comprises psychometric tests and a
competency based interview where I will be asked to describe my
actions in different business situations. Once this is complete and its
my chance to ask questions, should I approach the salary and benefits
situation, or say nothing and assume they will go into detail with the
recruitment consultant if I am successful? They have already explained
the benefits in general with him before the first interview, but were
reluctant to go into salary detail at that stage.
If I approach the subject it might look too presumptuous, but if I say
nothing it could look as though I'm not interested?
Please advise,
Andy
Andrew
Thank you for your question.
This has always seemed a bit of a dilemma! Do I say nothing and appear
lassaiz faire? Do I ask for something and appear greedy?
The position you describe seems to be fairly senior, so they will expect
you to act with the utmost professionalism.
You must ask yourself what would be gained by asking what the package
is at the 2nd interview. I'm guessing the reality is that its just natural
curiosity! If they told you then, and it didn't match your expectations,
your face may give this away and it may subconsciously register
negatively in their minds.
121
You say that you are there via an agency. That is always good from the
candidate's point of view, because if you do enter into a negotiation
with your potential employer, it will be less awkward as you have the
agent as a buffer.
My advice is to be concerned strictly with the role and whether it is
right for you remember, an interview is as much about seeing if the
role is what YOU want as it is to see if you are what THEY want!
If the job is right for you, then display some passion at the second
interview. Leave them with the impression that you are dead keen
without being creepy and coming over as desperate!
Once you get the offer via the agent, then your curiosity will be satisfied
and you can then think about whether or not it meets your
expectations!
Thank you for buying my book and the very best of luck with your
interview!
Kind regards
Charlie Gibbs
CHAPTER 9
123
For all that has been written about getting a job in a difficult economy,
and for all of the advice that you have probably received from friends
and family, not much is said about dealing with the other side of coin
about not getting the job.
Although rejection happens so often in the crowded job market, there is
still a strange kind of denial about it. It is one of those ugly realities that
only seem approachable through statistics and ratios that compare
applicants to openings.
Post-graduate placement programmes, for example, tend to focus on
the positive. They want you to hope for the best and make their
graduates believe in their chances, so they may not spend time talking
about worst-case scenarios or how to deal with bad news. But you
should take a moment to think about rejection. How will you respond if
you do not get the job? How you handle that scenario can be as
important as what you say or do during an interview.
Some forms of rejection are less painful than others. If you applied for a
position and never made it to the interview stage, receiving a rejection
letter in the post may be disappointing, but it isn't usually devastating.
After all, the recruiter never saw you face to face. They don't know what
you are like or how you conduct yourself in a professional conversation.
They have not seen you work or heard you speak passionately about
your achievements.
In short, they have not rejected you personally and, conversely, you have
not had the chance to size them up and get a sense of how you would
fit in with the department and the organisation as a whole. In a sense, it
has all been a paper transaction.
All the recruiter knows of you is what's on your cover letter and CV, so,
if you want to think about this constructively, your attention should be
124
focused on those materials. Did you tailor your cover letter to meet the
needs and requirements as they were set out in the job ad, or did you
send a generic cover letter? Have you honestly assessed your CV and
given serious thought as to how you could make it more competitive
and more enticing? Do you need more experience? Could you be more
active professionally? Do you need to gain a higher profile in your field?
Do you need to get more involved in professional organisations?
Now, say that you do make it past the application stage. You are called in
for an interview but, alas, do not get the job. The sense of personal
rejection is far more acute, and the emotional consequences more severe.
In a competitive market, getting an interview is a feat that can actually
make you believe, often cruelly, that you might get the job. The odds
have dramatically improved in your favour; where you were 1 of 150,
now you are 1 of 5 or 10.
As calm and collected as you might try to be about it all, you might not
be able to help daydreaming about job offers or planning your future
with the firm. And, since what largely determines whether you move on
or go home is how you present yourself and your performance during
this process, it is hard not to take a rejection at this stage of the game
personally and not to feel that somehow they just did not like you.
Rejected after an interview, your initial impulse may well be to return
the blow that you have been dealt in some way, shape, or form. If
someone does call to give you the news, you may feel like telling them
Huh! I didnt really want your stupid job anyway! in a ya-boo-sucks
kind of way. Or if they have notified you by post, you may be inclined to
send them a scathing letter in return that burns a hole through their ink
blotters and forces them into a life of watching daytime TV and
listening to old Gary Glitter records.
125
But, while it may make you feel better temporarily, with every damning
word and every seething syllable, you will, in more ways than one, be
cutting your own throat, professionally speaking. An emotional outburst
after a rejection can make navigating a tight job market all the more
complicated, awkward and difficult, because you may have to see or
work with these people again in some other professional capacity. It is
amazing how small some of these disciplines can actually get. You may
suddenly spot a member of the recruitment panel on a committee at a
professional conference or see them in the audience when you deliver a
speech. It could be that you run across them again in a more mundane
capacity. Either way, its going to be excruciatingly embarrassing for you!
Networking is part of many jobs, so, by offending a recruiter, you could
also be offending a network and burning more bridges than you realise.
And (yes theres another and), even though you have been rejected for
the job in question, you never really know how things will work out.
New starts do not always stay put or keep their jobs. Some simply do
not fit in as well as the recruiters thought that they would. Others move
on after a short while because their dream job was something else or
somewhere else. In addition, departments often find themselves with
sudden retirements or extended leaves of absence. If you had just
recruited for a position and had an excellent first choice but another
really good candidate, and you suddenly had to hire for the role again,
where would you look first?
If getting a your dream job is like winning the lottery, then maybe the
catchphrase still applies: You cant win it unless you are in it.
And though you may be inclined to believe that they did this to you just to
see you suffer, the fact is that recruiters are people, too. Not too long ago,
they were sitting in a similar seat, dealing with the same stress and
responding to the same types of questions. They probably hate rejecting
you just as much as you hate being rejected. They have also had to give up
their valuable time to conduct the recruitment process.
126
Your anger, your bitterness, and your insults will not mortally wound
them or make them change their minds and realise the error of their
ways. In the end, it will only confirm their decision to reject you.
For all of the negatives that go along with being rejected, then, there
still can be some positive spin-offs. Whether it leads to a job down the
road or it adds to your list of contacts or not, you should still try to
think about the experience in constructive terms, in the same way that
you would revise your cover letter and CV for future searches.
Make a note of questions that you had difficulty with or questions that
stood out in your mind. Also, make a list of questions that you could
have asked. Think about how you handled yourself and how you
prepared. Were you able to effectively elaborate on the information that
you provided in your initial application? Did you do some research on
the company before you were interviewed? If you think that your
interview skills need work, then you might want to set up a mock
interview or make an appointment with a career adviser to talk about
how you conduct yourself through the process. You could also consult
with your careers adviser if you had questions about what you said or
did during the interview itself.
The interview process does not, and should not, end just because you
were rejected. In a sense, the rejection is still a part of the interview. It
gives you yet another chance to demonstrate your maturity, to show
your understanding of the profession and the hiring process, and to
prove to the recruiter that you are a worthy candidate, even if you are
not its first choice. It certainly is a possibility that you should be ready
for, because, depending upon how you handle it, it could conceivably be
that situation that makes it your year after all.
Of course, if you DO put into practice some or all of the techniques I
have outlined in this book, then this chapter may not be of any use to
you at all!
127
128
Always stick to the reasons youve given for leaving. Telling your
manager one thing and your co-workers another risks compromising
your professionalism and making your last few weeks feel awkward.
If youve done everything a loyal employee is expected to have done and
youve performed well in your role, the chances are your organisation
wont want to see you go. The most likely way an employer will try and
make you stay is by offering you a pay rise either equal to or above
what youve been offered in your new job.
You should take any counter offer they make you seriously and carefully
consider how you would feel about staying in the same job but with a
better salary. This may help remind you of the other reasons you have
for leaving and help you make your decision.
Employers may also try to get you to stay by promising you a promotion
and increased responsibility. Again, you should think carefully about what
this means but dont forget that youll be working in the same organisation,
with the same people and probably under the same manager.
Whatever the length of your notice period, youre legally obliged to
work it, unless your employer is willing to waive it. Look at your written
contract of employment. You should find details of your notice period
there. Otherwise, you should allow between two weeks and a month. Be
aware that the remedy an employer has against an employee who does
not work their notice is to try to recover any losses they may sustain or
claim damages against you in a court of law. Now, depending on the
nature of your role, and how important you are to the organisation will
determine the employers willingness to resort to litigation.
Its easy to imagine your notice period as a time to relax and stop
making an effort, but this shouldnt be the case. Youll likely have plenty
to keep you busy, finalising any outstanding work and ensuring you
129
CHAPTER 10
TELEPHONE INTERVIEWS
Telephone interviews are being used more and more these days as they
are extremely time efficient for the recruiter. Once used only by
recruitment agencies, many private organisations use these as an initial
filter. Undoubtedly you will come across these at some stage in your
career, so its best to have some idea what to expect beforehand.
Think about what you are trying to achieve here. Its not about actually
securing the job at this stage. Its about getting to the next level which
involves a face to face interview
Everything I have said previously about you doing research on the
organisation still applies. The advantage you will have this time is that
you can have all your research notes in front of you to refer to, rather
than having to commit it all to memory. This goes for your CV and
covering letter too. Have them in easy reach. Even better, why not
prepare a reference sheet with points to jog your memory on specific
tasks you have worked on, achievements you have made or projects
youve taken part in?
When you agree to an appointment for a telephone interview, make
sure that you choose a time where you know you can definitely be in an
environment conducive to you giving your best. That means no
interruptions, no background noise, etc. If you can, make sure you
receive the call on a landline. Then there is no worry about batteries
going flat or reception being lost. You will be more likely to be relaxed
and give a better account of yourself in this type of environment.
130
TELEPHONE INTERVIEWS
131
The biggest drawback, from both the recruiters and the candidates
point of view, is the lack of visual feedback during the conversation.
These subtle, visual clues to how well we are doing are denied us, so we
must be focused and alert to picking up on purely verbal indications. If
the interviewer is good at what they do, they will have prepared well at
their end and the call will have a clear structure and purpose. This is
good for you as it stops the conversation straying into areas which may
have pitfalls in them for you.
In your responses, try to be clear and concise. Remember that the
reason a telephone interview is happening in the first place is to speed
up the whole recruitment process, so highly detailed, long-winded
answers are not called for here. I would also suggest that you make sure
that your diction is good so the interviewer understands you clearly. If
anything, slow down your speech slightly to allow extra time for the
interviewer to make written notes about what you are saying. If you
dont have shorthand skills and have ever tried to capture peoples
words verbatim, you will know exactly how difficult that is! Do what
works for you. Some people have found that standing up during a
telephone interview helps them focus (no opportunity to doodle) and
helps with their breathing and posture. This translates into sounding
composed over the telephone.
You may want to rehearse beforehand. Try writing your own set of
questions and have someone telephone you and ask you these
questions. Remember that this is unlikely to be the hiring stage, so the
questions are unlikely to be complex or demanding. Get them to write
down your responses and add their own critique. Analyse these notes
and amend your approach accordingly.
Part of the purpose of the telephone interview, from the recruiters
perspective, is to find out how much you want the job and (in the case
of sales jobs) whether you have closing skills.
132
CHAPTER 11
FURTHER TYPICAL
INTERVIEW QUESTIONS
Earlier in the book you had the opportunity to see the kinds of answers
that interviewers are really looking for. However, there are a million and
one other subjects that you could be asked questions on, and I have
included here just a selection for you to look at. This is like an exam: you
may broadly know what will be covered, but not the actual questions. As
you look at them, try and formulate the type of answer you would give
to each one using the guidelines previously provided.
I
I
I
I
I
I
133
134
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
135
I
I
I
I
I
I
136
STRATEGIC THINKING
Able to take a broad view of industry, its threats and opportunities, and
use them to identify areas of business potential that can be exploited.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
137
RELATIONSHIP BUILDING
Puts sustained effort into building influential relationships.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
138
COMMERCIAL AWARENESS
Recognises how businesses work, and understands and applies
commercial and financial principles.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
139
I
I
I
I
I
I
140
LEADERSHIP OF CHANGE
Identifies ways to improve our business. Engages with all colleagues to
support them through ambiguity and transition.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
141
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
142
LEADERSHIP SKILLS
Creates and communicates a compelling vision and sense of purpose.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
143
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
144
CONTINUOUS IMPROVEMENT
Identifies the processes needed to make things happen in a qualityoriented way and to get things actioned.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
145
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
146
I
I
I
147
CUSTOMER AWARENESS
Dedicated to meeting and exceeding the expectations and requirements
of all customers.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
148
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
149
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
150
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
151
INFLUENCING SKILLS
Influences, convinces or impresses others in a way that results in
acceptance, agreement or behaviour change.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
152
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
What advice might you give to someone struggling with his or her
communication?
How might you improve your own written communication?
What steps have you taken to do this?
153
I
I
I
I
I
154
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
155
I
I
I
I
I
I
Has there been a time when it was inappropriate and you had to
adapt it?
I
I
I
156
TEAMWORKING SKILLS
Works cooperatively and productively with all colleagues.
I
I
157
SPECIALIST KNOWLEDGE
Has the appropriate background knowledge and expertise and
understands technical or professional aspects of work.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
158
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
160
161
St Peter was waiting for her once more and said, Now its time to spend
a day in Heaven, and off she went on the up escalator to Heaven.
For the next 24 hours the HR manager spent all her time lolling around
on clouds, plucking her harp and preening her wings and singing
sweetly, all of which was just about as pleasant as her time in Hell.
At the end of her day, St Peter returned and said to her, Youve spent a
day in Heaven and a day in Hell. Now you must choose which one
where you will spend eternity.
The woman thought for a bit then said, Well Heavens nice, of course,
but actually I had a better time in Hell, so I think Ill choose Hell.
The woman was dispatched down the escalator to Hell but when she
got there this time there before her stood a desolate wasteland, with
stinking piles of rubbish and the people were wailing and full of sorrow.
At that, the devil popped up and put his arm round her shoulder.
Everything OK? he said.
I dont understand, the HR manager stammered. When I was here
before everything was wonderful, we ate fantastic food and everyone
was happy.
Ahh said the Devil When you were here before we were recruiting.
Now you are staff...
The following represents (allegedly) true comments made by line
managers on employees annual appraisal forms:
I
Since my last report, this employee has reached rock bottom and has
started to dig.
162
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
163
INDEX OF QUESTIONS
QUESTIONS ABOUT YOUR DRIVE FOR ACHIEVEMENT
Tell me what you know about our business?
Give an example of when youve experienced a setback.
What have you done to progress your education to date?
166
I
I
I
INDEX OF QUESTIONS
167
168
I
I
Tell me about a time when you had to get people to work together more
supportively.
I
I
I
INDEX
achievement drive 6, 1113, 604,
1334
annual reports 61
application form 2
assessment, self 6
Asylum & Immigration Act 1996
4850
Blair, Tony 82
body language 59
Callaghan, James 82
clothes 347
commercial awareness 7, 1617,
758, 1389
competence, level of 9, 58
competencies 2, 6, 7
competency profiles 81
competitors 12, 16
conflict 84, 99
continuous improvement 7, 224, 68,
79, 8690, 1446
curriculum vitae (CV) 2, 3, 38, 58, 124
customer awareness 7, 224, 926,
14951
Data Protection Act 51, 56
decision making 8, 245
development, self and others 8, 278,
1014, 114, 1545
diplomacy 84
Disability Discrimination Act 1995
458
dispute 99
Dragons Den 39
Eisenhower, Dwight D 82
employers perspective 546
Employment Equality Regulations
2003 51
employment tribunal 513
eye contact 56
170
taking to interview 37
teamworking 8, 2930, 68, 1059, 156
timing 34, 76
Trade Union & Labour Relations Act
1992 45
vacancies, hidden 1
Wattleton, Faye 82