Appendix II
Appendix II
Appendix II
NORTH KARANPURA
SUPER THERMAL POWER PROJECT
(3 X 660 MW)
DOC.NO.4410-301B-PVH-U-001
NorthKaranpura STPP
Barrage Gate design
DESIGN DATA
Materials
Permissible stresses for skinplate, vertical stiffener , horizontal girder & end vertical girder
yield stress ( Yp ) bending stress shear stress combined stress Bearing stress
0.45 Yp 0.35 Yp 0.6 Yp 0.65 Yp
2 2 2 2 2
t =< 20mm 2550.00 kg/cm 1147.50 kg/cm 892.50 kg/cm 1530.00 kg/cm 1657.50 kg/cm
20mm < t <
2 2 2 2 2
40mm 2448.00 kg/cm 1101.60 kg/cm 856.80 kg/cm 1468.80 kg/cm 1591.20 kg/cm
2 2 2 2 2
t => 40mm 2346.00 kg/cm 1055.70 kg/cm 821.10 kg/cm 1407.60 kg/cm 1524.90 kg/cm
5.0 m
Total load 3.00 T/m2
bottom unit
Sill EL 432.00 5.00 T/m2
LOADING DIAGRAM
Panel
D
Panel
A
0.5
0.5
Panel B
0.300
Panel type A B B D
Panel size 0.5 x 0.3 0.65 x 0.5 0.7 x 0.5 0.5 x 0.35
Boundary 3 edges fixed & 1 3 edges fixed & 1
conditions long edge free all four edges fixed all four edges fixed long edge free
L/B ratio 1.6670 1.300 1.40 1.4290
Pressure at
centre of panel
(kg/cm2) 0.485 0.4375 0.3700 0.318
Bending Bending stress Bending Bending
stress factor stress stress factor stress coeffic stress factor stress
coefficients k (kg/cm2) coefficients k (kg/cm2) ients factor k (kg/cm2) k (kg/cm2)
11x 23.00 91.06 3x 45.5 451.39 3x 45.5 381.7 23.50 82.90
11y 14.00 55.43 3y 13.65 135.42 3y 13.65 114.52 14.20 50.09
12x 25.80 102.15 4x 10.29 102.08 4x 10.29 86.33 20.50 72.32
12y 87.00 344.4 4y 34.3 340.28 4y 34.3 287.78 72.50 255.76
13x 67.50 267.24 59.50 209.90
13y 20.80 82.35 18.20 64.21
14x 112.00 443.4 82.00 289.28
14y 34.80 137.78 22.70 80.08
15x 61.00 241.51 48.00 169.33
The actual stress are less than permissible stress .Hence safe.
HORIZONTAL GIRDER DESIGN
0.3175
5.00 0.49 4.70 0.4375 4.05
0.3700 3.35 3.00
Sk = 2.97
Moment Distribution
A1 A AB BA BC CB CC1
D.F. 0.00 1.00 0.5185 0.4815 1.00 0.00
FEM 0.2205 -0.1563 0.1517 -0.1539 0.1482 -0.1908
Bal A&C -0.0642 0.0426
c.o -0.0321 0.0213
total 0.2205 -0.2205 0.1196 -0.1326 0.1908 -0.1908
bal 0.0067 0.0063
0.2205 -0.2205 0.1264 -0.1264 0.1908 -0.1908
direct shear 1.4550 1.4578 1.3860 1.3367 1.2534 1.1113
elastic shear 0.1449 -0.1449 -0.0921 0.0921
1.4550 1.6027 1.2411 1.2446 1.3454 1.1113
reactions 3.0577 2.4857 2.4567
3.0577 2.4857 2.4567
Bending stress at
2
i) top of skin plate = 703.74 kg/cm
2 2
ii ) bottom flange of girder = 1012.01 kg/cm < 1147.50 kg/cm (permissible stress)
2
iii ) junction of web and skin plate = 681.92 kg/cm
2 2
Shear stress = 184.41 kg/cm < 892.50 kg/cm (permissible stress)
L = 10.00 m B
B = 9.65 m
w = 3.06 T/m L
Weld details
SF(V)= 14.75 T
Ixx 182999 cm4
Section properties
Ytop 6.98 cm
Ybottom 14.07 cm 12 X 1.05 12.60
Ixx 1524.13 cm4
Ztop 218.29 cm3 1.0 X 20 20.00
Zbottom 108.34 cm3
Zjunction 256.93 cm3
Bending stress at
i) top of skin plate = 270.10 kg/cm2
ii ) the bottom of web = 544.22 kg/cm2
iii ) junction of web and skin plate = 229.48 kg/cm2
14.75 9.60
1.01 T.m
Reactions 0 X 0 0
Ra 17.15 T
Rb 21.45 T
Max.reaction 21.45 T
Max.BM 2.21 T.m 13
1.6 X 48 154
Section properties
Yt 24.00 cm
Yb 24.00 cm
4
Ixx 29491.2 cm
3
Zt 1228.80 cm Area = 154
3
Zb 1228.80 cm Igg Ax
0.00 0.0
29491 0.0
4
29491 0.0 29491.2 cm
Bending stress at
i) top of skin plate = 180.09 kg/cm2
ii ) bottom of girder = 180.09 kg/cm2 Safe.
Provide 6mm fillet weld between skin plate and end vertical plates.
ROLLER DESIGN
Material IS:2004 Cl.4
UTS 6324 kg/cm2
Permisible contact stress 10118 kg/cm2
0.126
Material IS:1570 PART V 20Cr 13
2
U.T.S. 6600 kg/cm
2
Allowable bending stress = 0.2*UTS 1320 kg/cm
2
Allowable shear stress = 871.20 kg/cm
Provide 170mm dia pin d= 9.00 cm dia at ends 6.00 cm
3
Section modulus z= 71.57 cm
2
area a= 28.27 cm
2
Bending stress 794.24 kg/cm
2
Shear stress 379.31 kg/cm
ROLLER BEARING
Provide spherical roller bearing SKF 22218E
Internal dia 90 mm
External dia 160 mm
breadth 40 mm
Static capacity of bearing = 375.00 KN > 1.5 times wheel load = 315.63 KN
Design of wheel track
Material IS:1570 PART V 20Cr 13
Max.wheel load(P) 21.45 T
radius of wheel ( r ) 15.0 cm
tread width ( l ) 8.0 cm
2
Young's modulus ( E ) 2100000 kg/cm
Min thickness of wheel track for line contact = 1.55*0.786*6*(P*r/l*E)0.5
1.012 cm
Provide 15cm X 1.2cm size track plate.
15 X 1.2 18
Check for bending stress
20 X 1.2 24
Area 122 cm2
Ytop 16.00 cm
Ybot 18.00 cm 1.6 X 30 48
Ixx 22281.07 cm4
Ztop 1392.85 cm3
Zbot 1237.61 cm3 20 X 1.6 32
33
Area 122
1/3
fb=0.5*(P/Z)*((Es/Ec)*(I/w))
P 21.45 T Grade of 2nd stage concrete = M25
3 2
Z 1392.852005 cm scbc = 10 N/mm
Es/Ec 6.761234038 fck = 25 N/mm2
4 2
I 22281.06536 cm m = Es/Ec Ec 301720.1 kg/cm
2
w 20 cm m= 6.76 Es 2040000 kg/cm
w = width of track base in contact with concrete
2
bearing stress concrete = 0.25 * fck = 63.75 kg/cm
fb = 150.8925725 kg/cm2
l = a+b
a = center of track to edge of concrete + half of track width
b = half width of bottom flange of track base
a= 35 cm
b= 10 cm
l= 45 cm
a
shear stress = 3.42 kg/cm2
Top unit
3.0 m
3.00 T/m2
LOADING DIAGRAM
Panel
C
Panel
B
Panel
A
0.5
0.5
Panel B
0.450
Panel type A B D
Panel size 0.5 x 0.45 1.45 x 0.5 1.1 x 0.5
Boundary 3 edges fixed & 1 3 edges fixed & 1
conditions long edge free all four edges fixed short edge free
L/B ratio 1.1110 2.900 2.2000
Pressure at
centre of panel
(kg/cm2) 0.2775 0.1825 0.055
Bending Bending Bending stress
stress factor stress stress factor stress factor stress coeffici
coefficients k (kg/cm2) coefficients k (kg/cm2) k (kg/cm2) ents
11x 22.50 114.68 3x 50 206.92 28.07 35.01 16x
11y 13.00 66.26 3y 15 62.07 9.13 11.39 16y
12x 15.50 79.00 4x 10.29 42.58 8.51 10.61 17x
12y 51.50 262.5 4y 34.3 141.94 28.38 35.39 17y
13x 48.00 244.65 46.66 58.19 18x
13y 14.80 75.43 14.00 17.46 18y
14x 53.00 270.1 50.80 63.36 19x
14y 16.20 82.57 15.24 19.01 19y
15x 37.00 188.59 28.78 35.89 20x
The actual stress are less than permissible stress .Hence safe.
HORIZONTAL GIRDER DESIGN
Bending stress at
2
i) top of skin plate = 703.09 kg/cm
2 2
ii ) bottom flange of girder = 938.46 kg/cm 1147.50 kg/cm
2
iii ) junction of web and skin plate = 682.17 kg/cm
2
Shear stress = 168.27 kg/cm
L = 10.00 m B
B = 9.65 m
w = 2.79 T/m L
Weld details
SF(V)= 13.46 T
4
Ixx 174527 cm
Section properties
Ytop 6.98 cm
Ybottom 14.07 cm 12 X 1.05 12.60
Ixx 1524.13 cm4
Ztop 218.29 cm3 1.0 X 20 20.00
Zbottom 108.34 cm3
Zjunction 256.93 cm3
Bending stress at
i) top of skin plate = 270.10 kg/cm2
ii ) the bottom of web = 544.22 kg/cm2
iii ) junction of web and skin plate = 229.48 kg/cm2
-5.89
8.25
S F diagram
9.68 T.m
Reactions
Rb 7.57 T
Ra 14.14 T
Max.reaction 14.14 T
Max.BM 2.02 T.m 13
1.6 X 48 154
Section properties
Yt 24.00 cm
Yb 24.00 cm
Ixx 29491.2 cm4
Zt 1228.80 cm3 Area = 154
Zb 1228.80 cm3 Igg Ax
0.00 0.0
29491 0.0
4
29491 0.0 29491.2 cm
Bending stress at
i) top of skin plate = 164.33 kg/cm2
ii ) bottom of girder = 164.33 kg/cm2 Safe.
Provide 6mm fillet weld between skin plate and end vertical plates.
ROLLER DESIGN
Material IS:2004 Cl.4
UTS 6324 kg/cm2
Permisible contact stress 10118 kg/cm2
0.126
Material IS:1570 PART V 20Cr 13
2
U.T.S. 6600 kg/cm
2
Allowable bending stress =0.2*UTS 1320 kg/cm
2
Allowable shear stress = 871.20 kg/cm
Provide 170mm dia pin d= 9.00 cm dia at ends 6.00 cm
3
Section modulus z= 71.57 cm
2
area a= 28.27 cm
2
Bending stress 523.63 kg/cm
2
Shear stress 250.08 kg/cm
ROLLER BEARING
Provide spherical roller bearing SKF 22218E
Internal dia 90 mm
External dia 160 mm
breadth 40 mm
Wheel bearing 8 160/90 (OD/ID) with 40mm width MAKE SKF 22218E
17 Bottom seal clamp ( cut to shape ) 1 9.700 0.016 0.085 7.850 0.10 -0.028 -0.003 IS:2062
18 Bottom seal Retainer ( cut to shape ) 1 9.7 0.036 0.012 7.85 0.03 -0.018 -0.001 IS:2062
20 Side seal clamp 2 5.200 0.050 0.016 7.850 0.07 -0.034 -0.002 IS:2062
21 side seal base 2 5.200 0.050 0.012 7.850 0.05 -0.006 0.000 IS:2062
22 Splice plate for skin plate 2 10.200 0.200 0.010 7.850 0.32 0.000 0.000 IS:2062
23 bracings plates 1 38.000 0.018 1.000 1.000 0.67 0.762 0.513 IS:2062
16.10 t 4.474 t-m
Symbol
Span of Gate w 9.5 m
Height of Gate h 5 m
Design Head H 5 m
Estimated Weight G
FRL 437 m
Sill Level 432 m
Gate Weight = 16 T
Hoist Capacity
Gate Details
Specific weight of Steel 7.85 T/m3
Gate Inside the Groove in Width Side 0.075 m
Gate Inside the Groove in Top 0 m
Gate width from Centre Line of Seal 9.65 m
Gate Height from Centre Line of Seal 5 m
Precompression Force 0.1 T/m
Type of Seal
Fluro Carbon Claded Rubber Seal 0.2 0
Rubber Seal 1.5
Gate Wheel
Diameter of Wheel 300 mm
Width of Wheel 80 mm
Coefficient of Friction for Wheel Bearing
Ball/Roller Bearing 0.015 1
Bush Bearing 0.5
Coefficient of Rolling Friction for Wheel 1
Bearing/Bush for Wheel Axle
ID of Bearing 90 mm
OD of Bearing 160 mm
Width of Bearing 40 mm
2
Water Load on Gate 0 T/m
Total Water Load on Gate(P) = 120.625 T
5
2
5 T/m
Wheel Friction
Wheel Friction = P/R(f axr+f r)
Wheel Friction = 1.558 T
Buoyancy Force
Uplift Force
Uplift Force = 2.03 T
BARRAGE GATE
North Karanpura(660MWx3)
(JHARKHAND)
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
1. DESCRIPTION
The proposed Electrically Operated Rope Drum Hoist shall be designed for 25 tonnes capacity
for the operation of 9.5 M x 5 M size Barrage Gate as per the provisions contained in IS: 6938-
2005.
The Barrage Gate shall be lift and lowered by means of proposed rope drum hoist under flowing
water conditions. The rope drum hoist shall be installed on the hoist bridge duly supported on
concrete column of adequate height so as to bring out the gate out of gate groove above deck
level i.e. EL 438.0 M.
2.TECHNICAL REFERENCES
a. Technical Specifications
b. IS: 6938 2005 Code Practice for Design of Rope Drum Hoist & Chain Hoist for
Hydraulic Gates.
d. IS: 807 2007 Code of Practice for design, manufacture, erection and testing of cranes
and hoists.
3.TECHNICAL DATA :-
a. Capacity of Hoist - 25 MT
1 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
4. MATERIAL SPECIFICATIONS
5. MECHANICAL STRENGTH
SL.No. Material & Strength
1. Structural Steel IS2062
Y.P. = 250 N/mm2 for thickness < 20mm
Y.P. = 240 N/mm2 for thickness > 20mm and <40mm
Y.P. = 230 N/mm2 for thickness > 40mm
U.T.S = 410 N/mm2
Structural Steel IS: 2062 E250 BR
Y.P. = 230 N/mm2 for thickness > 40mm
U.T.S = 410 N/mm2
2. Forged Steel-
IS:2004 Class 4 IS:2004, Class5 IS:1570, 55C8
Y.P. = 320 N/mm2 Y.P. = 350 N/mm2 Y.P.= 540 N/mm2
U.T.S = 620 N/mm 2 U.T.S = 710 N/mm2 U.T.S = 800 N/mm2
3. Cast Steel
IS:1030 IS:1030 Gr.340- GR-3 AS PER IS: 2707-1996
Gr. 280-520 W 570 W
Y.P. = 280 N/mm2 Y.P. = 340 N/mm2 Y.P.= 370 N/mm2
U.T.S = 520 N/mm 2 U.T.S = 570 N/mm2 U.T.S = 700 N/mm2
4. Aluminium Bronze
IS: 305 Gr. AB2
U.T.S = 640 N/mm2
5 Stainless Steel
AISI420
Y.P. = 2
490 N/mm
U.T.S = 2
690 N/mm
2 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
6.ALLOWABLE STRESSES
A. Rope drum :
IS:1030 Gr.340-570 W
Compressive stress:
2
a. Normal Condition = 0.17x5810.4 = 987.77 kg/cm
b. Break down condition:-
2
80% of YP = 0.8x3465.85 = 2772.68 kg/cm
Bending Stress
2
a). Normal Condition = 0.2 UTS = 0.17x5810.4 = 987.77 kg/cm
b). Brake Down Condition
80% of YP = 0.8x3465.85 = 2772.68 kg/cm2
Combined stress
a). Normal Condition - 0.24 UTS = 0.24x5300.71 = 1431.19 kg/cm2
b). Brake Down Condition:-
2
80% of YP = 0.8x2854.23 = 2283.38 kg/cm
3 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
v) Bending stress
Normal conditions = 0.5 X YS = 0.5x2548.42 = 1274.21 kg/cm2
B D T condition= 1.33 X Allowable stress = 1.33x1274.21 = 1694.7 kg/cm2
4 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
a. Normal Condition
2
Bending stress without keys = 0.2x6320.08 = 1264.02 kg/cm
2
Bending stress with keys = 0.75x1264.02 = 948.02 kg/cm
2
Torsional stress without keys = 0.3x3261.98 = 978.59 kg/cm
80% of YP
5 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
a. Normal Condition
2
Bending stress without keys = 0.2x7237.51 = 1447.5 kg/cm
2
Bending stress with keys = 0.75x1447.5 = 1085.63 kg/cm
2
Torsional stress without keys = 0.3x3567.79 = 1070.34 kg/cm
6 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
7.0 DESIGN OF HOIST MECHANISM
Hoist Capacity = 25 MT
Lifting lowering speed = 0.7 m /min. 5%
No. of falls of wire rope = 2 falls / drum (side)
No. of drums = 2 (TWO)
Total lift provided = 6.5 meters
7.1 MOTOR
Total load on Rope = M= 25 0 (Weight of wire rope)
= 25 T
Lifting Speed = V= 0.7 M/min
Rope Drum Running effy. = 0.95 as per IS:6938-2005 for Bronze Bearing
Pulley running efficiency (A.F.
0.98 as per IS: 6938-2005
Bearing) =
(Total 1No. of Pulley per side) Pulley efficiency = 0.98^1 = 0.98
Worm reduction efficiency = 0.7348
Gear Running efficiency = 0.95 per stage. As per IS: 6938-2005
Number of pair of open spur gears used = 2
Total open gear running efficiency = 0.95^2 = 0.9
Overall running efficiency = Rope drum efficiency x Open gear Efficiency x Pulley
efficiency x Worm gear box efficiency.
E = overall running efficiency = 0.95x0.98x0.7348x0.9 = 0.62
MVS 25x0.7
Motor KW Required = = = 4.61 kW
6.12 E 6.12x0.62
Motor selected 5.5 kW ( 7.5 HP), 925 r.p.m, sq, cage, 40% CDF,
150 Starts / hr., TEFC, Fr. Size 132S Make: Bharat Bijlee. POT 2.75
Rope Drum Starting effy. = 0.93 as per IS:6938-2005 for bronze bearing
Pulley starting efficiency (A.F. Bearing) = 0.95 as per IS: 6938-2005
Worm reduction Starting efficiency = 0.46
Gear starting efficiency = 0.93 per stage. As per IS: 6938-2005
Number of pair of open spur gears used = 2
Total open gear starting efficiency = 0.93^2 = 0.86
(Total 1No. of Pulley per side) Pulley efficiency = 0.95^1 = 0.95
Overall starting efficiency = Rope drum efficiency x Open gear Efficiency x Worm gear
box efficiency.
Es = overall starting efficiency = 0.93x0.46x0.86x0.86 = 0.35
Overall running eff. Starting torque
Ratio = <
Overall starting eff. Running torque
0.62 Starting torque
Ratio = <
0.35 Running torque
Ratio = 1.77 < 2.75
7 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
7.4 Flexible Coupling (B/w G.B O/P Shaft & line Shaft & b/w line shaft & pinion shaft)
1.5xHPx100x70x0.7348 1.5x7.5x100x70x0.7348
H.P. /100 r.p.m. = = = 31.28
2xr.p.m 925x2
Required Torque rating of 1.5x7.5x716.2x70x0.7348 1.5x7.5x716.2x70x0.7348
= =
coupling 2xr.p.m 2x925
= 224.02 kg-m
Coupling selected Flexible Geared coupling-size 103
H.P. /100 r.p.m. 61.5 Max. Torque rating 440 kgm
Make: - New Allenberry
7.5 DESIGN OF WIRE ROPE
WIRE ROPE:-
Total Load on Ropes = Capacity + wt. of wire rope = 25 + 0= 25 T
No. of falls on each drum = 2 Nos
Pulley efficiency, = 0.95 per Pulley with A.F. Bearing
Wire rope tension = W/2 {(1- )/ (1- n)}
= 25000x(1-0.95)/2x(1-0.95^2) = 6410.26 kg
= 62.88 kN
Min breaking strength required, = FOS XRope Tension = 6x62.88
= 377.28 kN
8 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
Proposed 28 mm dia. wire rope, 6X36 construction, right hand lay,
2 2
fiber core, Improved Plow steel, UTS= 1960N/mm or 200kg/mm ,galvanized
, having breaking Load of 507 KN/ 51681.96 kg
MAKE: USHA MARTIN/FORT WILLIAM INDUSTRIES LTD.
Galvanization Factor- 0.9
sc = 1x6410.26/(3.05x3.5)
= 600.49 kg/cm2 < 987.77 kg/cm2
1
20
13
35
750
652
748
9 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
2. GROOVES DETAILS
= 706 mm
706
= 21532.4 kgcm
= 113141 kgcm
= 12377.04 cm
10 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
7.7 SELECTION WORM REDUCER
4XV where,
Motor r.p.m = 925 Drum R.P.M. = PXD V - is Velocity in m/min,
D - is Rope drum P.C.D.
Service Factor for 12 hours/day Operation and Medium Impulsive load= 1.25 for NAV gears
Make:NAW/Shanthi Gear.
11 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
12 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
8. DESIGN OF SHAFT
8.1. Design of Drum Shaft- Shaft 1
A) When Rope Tension Is On Gear Wheel Side
Vertical loads
12590.3 kg 300 kg
A1 C1 D1 B1
12590.3x76+300x6.5
RVA1 =
95.2
= 10071.56 kg
RVB1 = 12590.3+300-10071.56 = 2818.74 kg
13 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
Horizontal loads:-
1857.18 kg
A2 C2 B2
19.2
95.2 cm
RHB1
RHA1
0
Horizontal load at C2 due to load on w1 gear = 5102.57 x tan 20
= 1857.18 kg
1857.18x76
RHA1 = = 1482.62 kg
95.2
14 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
When the Rope Tension Is On Non-Gear Wheel Side
Vertical loads
6180.04 kg 6710.26 kg
A3 C3 D2 B3
A4 C4 B4
19.2
95.2 cm
RHB2
RHA2
Horizontal load at C4 due to load on w1 gear = 5102.57 x tan 20 0
= 1857.18 kg
1857.18x76
RHA2 = = 1482.62 kg
95.2
RHB2 = 1857.18-1482.62 = 374.56 kg
15 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
Resultant load at A3 / A4 = (5391.8^2+1482.62^2)^0.5 = 5591.93 kg
Resultant load at B3 / B4 = (7498.5^2+374.56^2)^0.5 = 7507.85 kg
Resultant B.M. at C3 & C4 = (5391.8^2+1482.62^2)^0.5x19.2
= 107365.04 kgcm
Resultant B.M. at D2 = (7498.5^2+374.56^2)^0.5x6.5
= 48801.02 kgcm
Bending stress in shaft = M / Z = 107365.04/215.69 = 497.77 kg/cm2
2
< 1264.02 kg/cm
Resultant Load at C3 / C4 = (6180.04^2+1857.18^2)^0.5
= 6453.06 kg
Resultant Load at D2 = (6710.26^2+374.56^2)^0.5
= 6720.71 kg
Shear stress = 6720.71/132.73 = 50.63 kg/cm2
< 978.59 kg/cm2
8.2. Design of Bush
A)At Gear Wheel W1
Resultant load at C1 & C2 and C3 & C4= 12726.54 kg
Shaft Dia. = 130 mm
Min. thickness of bush = 0.08x130+3 mm
= 13.4 mm
Provided thickness = 15 mm
Proposed to provide Al. bronze Gr. AB-2, IS: 305 with ID = 130 mm OD = 160 mm
Length = 120 mm
Bearing stress in bush = 12726.54/(13X12) = 81.58 < 260.958 kg/ cm2
B) At Non-Gear Wheel End
Resultant load at D1 & D2 = 6720.71 kg
Shaft Dia. = 130 mm
Min. thickness of bush = 0.08x130+3 mm
= 13.4 mm
Provided thickness = 15 mm
Proposed to provide Al. bronze Gr. AB-2, IS: 305 with ID = 130 mm OD = 160 mm
Length = 60 mm
Bearing stress in bush = 6720.71/(13X6) = 86.16 < 260.958 kg/ cm2
16 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
8.3. Design of Shaft- P1W2
Vertical loads
1918.67 kg 5485.04 kg
A5 C5 D4 B5
17 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
RHA3 = (622.02x27.6+1857.18x15.4)/45
= 1017.07 kg
RHB3 = 622.02+1857.18-1017.07
= 1462.13 kg
Resultant Load at C5 / C6 = (1918.67^2+622.02^2)^0.5
= 2016.98 kg
Resultant Load at D4/ D5 = (5485.04^2+1857.18^2)^0.5
= 5790.92 kg
Resultant Load at RVA3/RHA3 = (3053.89^2+1017.07^2)^0.5
= 3218.8 kg
Resultant Load at RVB3/RHB3 = (4349.82^2+1462.13^2)^0.5
= 4588.98 kg
Resultant B.M. at C5/C6 = 3218.8x17.4
= 56007.12 kgcm
Resultant B.M. at D4/D5 = 4588.98x15.4
= 70670.29 kgcm
Torque transmitted by P1W2 shaft = 1708.99x39.6
= 67676 kgcm
2 2
Equivalent Torque = (M + T ) = (70670.29^2+67676^2)^0.5
= 97848.51 kgcm
Equivalent Bending moment = 0.5x(70670.29+97848.51)
= 84259.4 kgcm
Proposed 110 shaft confirming to IS:2004 Class 4 having UTS
6320.08 kg./cm & YP = 3262 kg./cm
Shaft diameter at bearing 90 mm
x 11^3
Zxx of shaft = = 130.67 cm3
32
x 11^3
Zpp of shaft = = 261.34 cm3
16
x 9^2
C.S. area = = 63.62 cm2
4
18 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
Vertical loads
1828.67 kg
A7 D6 B7
15.4 29.6
45 cm
RVA5 RVB5
1708.99
= + 10
Cos 20
= 1818.67 + 10 = 1828.67 kg
1828.67x29.6
RVA5 = = 1202.86 kg
45
19 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
Horizontal loads
622.02 kg
A8 D7 B8
15.4 29.6
45 cm
RHA5 RHB5
0
Horizontal load at D7 due to tooth load on P2= 1708.99 x tan 20
622.02 kg
622.02x29.6
RHA6 = = 409.15 kg
45
RHB6 = 622.02-409.15 = 212.87 kg
Resultant Load at D6 / D7 = (1828.67^2+622.02^2)^0.5
= 1931.56 kg
Resultant Load at RVA5/RHA5 = (1202.86^2+409.15^2)^0.5
= 1270.54 kg
Resultant Load at RVB3/RHB5 = (625.81^2+212.87^2)^0.5
= 661.02 kg
Resultant B.M. at D6/D7 = 661.02x29.6
= 19566.19 kgcm
Torque transmitted by P2 shaft = 1708.99x7.6
= 12988.32 kgcm
Equivalent Torque = (M2 + T2) = (19566.19^2+12988.32^2)^0.5
= 23484.72 kgcm
Equivalent Bending moment = 0.5x(19566.19+23484.72)
= 21525.46 kgcm
Proposed 70 shaft confirming to IS:2004 Class 4 having UTS
6320.08 kg./cm & YP = 3262 kg./cm
Shaft diameter at bearing 60 mm
x 7^3
Zxx of shaft = = 33.67 cm3
32
20 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
x 7^3
Zpp of shaft = = 67.35 cm3
16
x 6^2
C.S. area = = 28.27 cm2
4
Equivalent Bending stress = 21525.46/33.67
= 639.31 kg./cm < 1137.62 kg./cm
Equivalent Torsional stress = 23484.72/67.35
= 348.7 kg./cm < 880.73 kg./cm
Direct Shear Stress = 1270.54/28.27
= 44.94 kg./cm < 733.94 kg./cm
Bending Stress = 19566.19/33.67
= 581.12 kg./cm < 948.02 kg./cm
Torsional Shear Stress = 12988.32/67.35
= 192.85 kg./cm < 733.94 kg./cm
Combined Stress = (581.12^2+3x192.85^2)^0.5
= 670.28 kg./cm < 1957.19 kg./cm
8.5. BEARINGS
(i)For Shaft P1W2
Max load on Plummer block brg. = 4588.98 kg.
Min. capacity of bearing = 1.5X4588.98 = 6883.47 kg.
= 67526.84 N
Proposed Plummer Block SNL520 ,MAKE FAG/SKF with 22220 EK
bearing and H320 adaptor sleeve having dynamic capacity 433000 N
and static capacity 490000 N
Both static & dynamic capacity is much more than 67526.84 N
Max. Horizontal Load on Plummer Block = 1462.13 kg.
Max. Vertical Load on Plummer Block = 4349.82 kg.
Proposed M 24 bolts as per IS:1367-3/ IS1363, Gr. 5.8
Number Bolt per Plummer Block = 2
Cross Sectional Area of one bolt = 3.4x2.4^2x0.85/4= 3.85 cm
Shear stress in bolt = 1462.13/(3.85x2) = 189.89 kg./cm
0.3XY.S
Allowable Shear Stress = = 0.3x400x100/(1.2x9.81)
1.2
= 1019.4 kg./cm Hence safe
Tensile stress in bolt = 4349.82/(3.85x2) = 564.91 kg./cm
100X400X120
Allowable tensile Stress =
235X9.81
= 2082.1 kg./cm Hence safe
21 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
Grade of Bolt is 5.8 YS of bolt is 400 N/mm2 . Material of Bolt will be as per
IS-1367-3/IS:3640, Bolt size M 24 x 150 mm Long.
(ii)For Shaft P2
Max load on Plummer block brg. = 1270.54 kg.
Min. capacity of bearing = 1.5X1270.54 = 1905.81 kg.
= 18696 N
x 6^3
Zpp of shaft = = 42.41 cm3
16
22 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
9 DESIGN KEY
23 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
24 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
e) Drum shaft
i) When the rope tension is on gear wheel side.
Vertical loads
24073.06 kg 300 kg
A11 C11 D11 B11
RVA11 = 24073.06x76+300x6.5
95.2
= 19238.47 kg
RVB11 = 24073.06+300-19238.47 = 5134.59 kg
Horizontal loads:-
3598.92 kg
A21 C21 B21
19.2
95.2 cm
RHB11
RHA11
0
Horizontal load at C21 due to load on w1 gear = 9887.94 x tan 20
= 3598.92 kg
25 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
3598.92x76
RHA11 = = 2873.09 kg
95.2
RHB11 = 3598.92-2873.09 = 725.83 kg
Resultant B.M. at C11 / C21 = (19238.47^2+2873.09^2)^0.5x19.2
= 373474.98 kg
Resultant B.M. at D11 = (5134.59^2+725.83^2)^0.5x6.5
= 33706.65 kg
3
Zxx of shaft = 215.69 cm
C.S. area = 132.73 cm2
26 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
RVB21 = 11272.53+13100.53-9893.55
= 14479.51 kg
Horizontal loads:-
3598.92 kg
A41 C41 B41
19.2
95.2 cm
RHB21
RHA21
0
Horizontal load at C41 due to load on w1 gear = 9887.94 x tan 20
= 3598.92 kg
3598.92x76
RHA21 = = 2873.09 kg
95.2
27 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
28 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
Resultant Load at C51 / C61 = (3700.08^2+1231.3^2)^0.5
= 3899.58 kg
Resultant Load at D41/ D51 = (10577.53^2+3598.92^2)^0.5
= 11173.02 kg
Resultant Load at RVA31/RHA31 = (5889.25^2+1986.83^2)^0.5
= 6215.36 kg
Resultant Load at RVB31/RHB31 = (8388.36^2+2843.39^2)^0.5
= 8857.17 kg
Resultant B.M. at C51/C61 = 6215.36x17.4
= 108147.26 kgcm
Resultant B.M. at D41/D51 = 8857.17x15.4
= 136400.42 kgcm
Torque transmitted by P1W2 shaft = 3382.97x39.6
= 133965.61 kgcm
2 2
Equivalent Torque = (M + T ) = (136400.42^2+133965.61^2)^0.5
= 191185.41 kgcm
Equivalent Bending moment = 0.5x(136400.42+191185.41)
= 163792.92 kgcm
Zxx of shaft = 130.67 cm3
Zpp of shaft = 261.34 cm3
C.S. area = 63.62 cm2
Equivalent Bending stress = 163792.92/130.67
= 1253.49 kg./cm < 1957.19 kg./cm
Equivalent Torsional stress = 191185.41/261.34
= 731.56 kg./cm < 1957.19 kg./cm
Direct Shear Stress = 8857.17/63.62
= 139.22 kg./cm < 917.43 kg./cm
Bending Stress = 136400.42/130.67
= 1043.85 kg./cm < 1957.19 kg./cm
Torsional Shear Stress = 133965.61/261.34
= 512.61 kg./cm < 917.43 kg./cm
Combined Stress = (1043.85^2+3x512.61^2)^0.5
= 1370.4 kg./cm < 1957.19 kg./cm
29 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
h)Design of Shaft P2
Vertical loads
3610.08 kg
15.4 29.6
45 cm
RVA51 RVB51
Load acting at D61 = Tooth load of P2 + Weight. Of P2
3382.97
= + 10
Cos 20
= 3600.08 + 10 = 3610.08 kg
3610.08x29.6
RVA51 = = 2374.63 kg
45
RVB51 = 3610.08-2374.63 = 1235.45 kg
Horizontal loads
1231.3 kg
15.4 29.6
45 cm
RHA51 RHB51
0
Horizontal load at D71 due to tooth load on P2= 3382.97 x tan 20
1231.3 kg
1231.3x29.6
RHA61 = = 809.92 kg
45
RHB61 = 1231.3-809.92 = 421.38 kg
Resultant Load at D61 / D71 = (3610.08^2+1231.3^2)^0.5
= 3814.29 kg
Resultant Load at RVA51/RHA51 = (2374.63^2+809.92^2)^0.5
= 2508.95 kg
Resultant Load at RVB51/RHB51 = (1235.45^2+421.38^2)^0.5
= 1305.3 kg
Resultant B.M. at D61/D71 = 1305.33x29.6
= 38637.77 kgcm
30 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
31 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
(ii)For Shaft P2
Max load on Plummer block brg. = 3814.29 kg.
Min. capacity of bearing = 1.5X3814.29 = 5721.435 kg.
= 56127.28 N
32 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
2nd Pinion 19 3 57
33 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
Total reduction of Gear/Pinion/Sprocket = 59x73x73x25/(19x19x19x25) = 45.84
0
Total angle of movement of dial = 22.87x360/45.84 = 179.61
0
Movement of Dial needle for one meter lift = 179.61/6.5 = 27.6
MAKE: - Sprocket - Rol-kobo/SKF
Chain Rol-kobo/SKF
12. GATE PULLEY & BALANCING PULLEY:-
12820.52 kg
70 70
140 cm R2
R1
R1 = R2 = 6410.26 kg
Pin dia.= 100 mm
x 10^3
Zxx of shaft = = 98.17 cm3
32
x 10^2
C.S. area = = 78.54 cm2
4
34 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
70 70
140 cm
R2
R1
R1 = R2 = 9190.05/2 = 4595.03 kg
Pin dia.= 100 mm
35 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
x 10^3
Zxx of shaft = = 98.17 cm3
32
x 10^2
C.S. area = = 78.54 cm2
4
Max. B.M. = 4595.03x7 = 32165.21 kgcm
36 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
Design of weld of cheek plate with cross beam:-
Length of weld provided = 2x 40 + 40 = 120 cm
8 mm fillet weld
Weld Strength of 12 mm fillet weld in normal condition = 0.707x 1.2x (0.3 x 2550)
= 649.026 kg/cm
Weld Strength of 12 mm fillet weld in B.D.T. condition = 0.707 x 1.2 x (0.375 x 2550)
= 811.283 kg/cm
i) Load per unit length in Normal condition = 10180.1/120= 84.8342 kg/cm
< 649.026 kg/cm
ii) Load per unit length in B.D.T.condition = 19451.82/120= 162.1 kg/cm
< 811.283 kg/cm
14. Rotary Type Double acting Limit Switch:-
Mounted on P1 & W2
Total number of turns of rope drum for entire lift of operation is = 5.52
(87x5.52)
Rotation of P1 & W2 shaft for gear = = 22.87
21
No. of Pitch PCD
teeth
Sprocket 1 21 9.525 63.91
Sprocket 2 25 9.525 75.997
(22.87x21)
Rotation of rotary limit switch = = 19.2
25
Used Rotary Geared limit switch having Gear Ratio 40: 1,
MAKE: - Sprocket - Rol-kobo/SKF
Chain Rol-kobo/SKF
Limit Switch - Speed-O-Control/BCH
15. Manual Drive Mechanism:-
Load / Rope = 6410.26 kg
Torque on each drum = 6410.26x37.5 = 240384.75 kgcm
Torque on each cross shaft = 467555
240384.75x21x19/(87x99xeffy.
x (23/117) (21/98)/effy. Of
Ofdrum
drum&&end
endgears
gears)
= 240384.75x21x19/(87x99x0.95^3) = 12988.4 kgcm
Torque on output shaft of worm reducer = 12988.37x2 = 25976.74 kgcm
Torque on input shaft of worm reducer = 25976.74/(70xeff. Of worm reducer)
= 25976.74/(70x0.7348) = 505.03 kgcm
37 of 38
DESIGN OF MECHANICAL COMPONENTS OF
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-002
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
No. of Pitch PCD
teeth
Sprocket 1 27 12.7 109.4
Sprocket 2 57 12.7 230.54
Arrangement of the rotary incoder to provide the signal for digital gate position indicator shall be
installed on the line shaft with the help of split type duplex sprocket. Digital gate position
indicator installed in the control panel located in the barrage control room. Digital gate position
indicator connected with transducer with the help of 4 core screened armoured cable.
ROTARY ENCODER: - ENC- 50/6-360 ABZ/8-30V
38 of 38
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING
STRUCTURE FOR 25T ROPE
DRUM HOIST
BARRAGE GATE
North Karanpura(660MWx3)
(JHARKHAND)
1. Description
Hoist Capacity = 25 T
Crowd Load = 500 kg/m2
Weight of Chequered Plate = 47.1 kg/m2
Impact Factor = 1.32
BDT Factor = 2.75
2. Mechanical Strength of Proposed Materials
Y.P
Material Material Specification
(Kg/cm2)
Structural Steel
upto 20th. 2548
IS:2062, Gr.-A & B
Over 20 upto 40th. 2446
Over 40th. 2344
Material for Structure IS:2062 Gr.-A & B ( Reference IS: 800 / 1984 )
Allowable Bending stress = 0.66 x 2548 = 1681 Kg/cm2
2
Allowable shear stress = 0.4 x 2548 = 1146 Kg/cm
Allowable Bearing stress = 0.75 x 2548 = 1911 Kg/cm2
BDT Condition = 0.8 x 2548 = 2038 Kg/cm2
Bolts
Bolts provided as per IS-1367, Cl.-4.6
YS of bolt is 240 N/mm2.
0.3XY.S 0.3x240X100/(1.2 x9.81)= 611.62 kg/cm2
Allowable Shear Stress = =
1.2
BDT Condition = 0.8x2446.48 = 1957.19 Kg/cm2
Bolts provided as per IS-1367, Cl.-5.8
YS of bolt is 400 N/mm2.
0.3XY.S 0.3x400X100/(1.2 x9.81)= 1019.37 kg/cm2
Allowable Shear Stress = =
1.2
BDT Condition = 0.8x4077.47 = 3261.98 Kg/cm2
Bolts provided as per IS-1367, Cl.-6.8
YS of bolt is 480 N/mm2.
0.3XY.S 0.3x480X100/(1.2 x9.81)= 1223.24 kg/cm2
Allowable Shear Stress = =
1.2
BDT Condition = 0.8x4892.97 = 3914.37 Kg/cm2
3. Loads at different locations
3.1 Loads & Self Weight for Rope Drum Hoist Arrangement
Normal Condition BDT Condition With Impact
Rope Tension = 6410.26 kg 12800.53 kg 8461.5432 kg
A = 7507.85 kg A = 14497.69 kg A = 9910.36 kg
B = 10180.1 kg B = 19451.82 kg B = 13437.73 kg
C = 4588.98 kg C = 8857.17 kg C = 6057.45 kg
D = 3218.8 kg D = 6215.36 kg D = 4248.82 kg
E = 661.02 kg E = 1305.3 kg E = 872.55 kg
F = 1270.54 kg F = 2508.95 kg F = 1677.11 kg
G = 9190.05 kg G = 18226.85 kg G = 12130.87 kg
1 of 22
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING STRUCTURE FOR
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-003
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
3.2 Self Weight for Rope Drum Hoist
Self weight of the Rope drum Assembly = 2000 kg
(Excluding weight of rope drum, gears, pinions, overload arrangements as the same has already
included in the reaction at various location of hoist)
Self weight per unit length of the rope drum Assembly= 2000/(6.35) = 314.96 Kg/m
(Note: 8.687m is perimeter of the base frame for the hoist supporting structure of rope drum assembly)
Self weight of Drive Unit Assembly = 1000 kg
Self weight per unit length of the Drive Unit Assembly = 1000/5.55
= 180.18 Kg/m
(Note: 8.801m is perimeter of the base frame for central drive unit assembly)
4. Layout of the Hoisting Arrangement of the Rope Drum Hoist
Hoist platform is assembly of the beams having load bearing beams number A to K. Others beams for
have also been provided in open space to support chequered plate. Details of the same same not shown
in the layout.
Location Location of
of Leg Leg
Beam :J
E2 G2 H2 I2 I2 H2 G2 E2
J1
J1
375
Balancing
Sheave
C/L of
D1 Beam :H Beam :D
D2 D2 D1
925
Beam :G Beam :E
C/L of Rope B C/L of Rope
A Drum
B Drum A
FLOW
488
2600
Beam :F
375
G C/G of F1 G
F2 F2
A1 F1 Gate A1
83 C1 C2 C2 Beam :C
C/L of P1W2 C1
C D Shaft D C
472 Beam :A
794
C/L of P2
E F Shaft Beam :I F E
B1 B1
B2 B2
132 A2 Beam :B A2
423 450
Beam :K
K1 H1 I1 I1 H1 G1 E1
E1 G1
1800 1025 750 1900 550 1900 750 1025 1800 K2
2 of 22
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING STRUCTURE FOR
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-003
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
Load, Stress & Deflection in beam A under Impact loading
Reaction at A1 = (6057.45X604+872.55X132+0.55016X794^2/2)/794
= 4971.41 kg = 4.97 T
Reaction at A2 = 6057.45+872.55+0.55016X794-4971.41
= 2395.42 kg = 2.40 T 371.7
Maximum bending moment = 4971.41X19-550.16X0.19X9.5 = 93463.8 kgcm
ISMC = 300 75
Area of Beam = 28.5 cm2 11.4
2
Area of web = 10.99 cm
Ixx = 1830 cm4 6.2
4
Iyy = 141 cm
200
Zxx = 181 cm3
Zyy = 26.4 cm3
D = 200 mm 13.6
T = 11.4 mm
L = 79.4 cm
rx = 8.02 cm
ry = 2.2 cm
d1 = 20 cm
t = 0.62 cm
d1/t = 32.3 < 85.00 Hence stiffners are not required
Refer Table 6.1 B - IS :800-1984 D/T = 17.5 L/ry = 36.09
( On conservative side )
2
Permissible bending stress = 1632 kg/cm
As per IS:800 Cl. No.-6.2.3
Bending Stress on Beam A= 93463.75/181
= 516.37 kg/cm2 < 1632 kg/cm2 SAFE
Shear Stress on Beam A = 4971.41/10.99
= 452.36 kg/cm2 < 1146 kg/cm2 SAFE
Deflection of the Beam A
d= (79.4^3/(2.1X10^6X1830))X((5X550.2X0.79/384)+(6057.5/48)X(3X190/794-4X(190/794)^3)
+(872.55/48)X(3X662/794-4X(662/794)^3)
d= 0.01 cm
Permissible Deflection = L/800 = 0.1 cm SAFE
3 of 22
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING STRUCTURE FOR
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-003
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
Welding :-
Max. shear force on the Beam = 7173.11 kg
Length of the Weld = 180 mm
Fillet size is 6 mm, Shear area = 18X0.6X0.707X2 = 15.27 cm2
Stress= 7173.11/15.27
= 469.75 kg/cm2 < 2038 kg/cm2 SAFE
6. Design of Beam : BB
Load, Deflection & Stress in beam BB under Normal Condition
687.87 kg/m
A2
B1 B2
575 450
1025
4 of 22
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING STRUCTURE FOR
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-003
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
Maximum bending moment = 2274.55X45-687.87X0.45X22.5
= 95390.07 kgcm
Bending Stress on Beam BB= 95390.07/428
= 222.87 kg/cm2 < 2156.99 kg/cm2 SAFE
Shear Stress on Beam BB = 2274.55/21.28
= 106.89 kg/cm2 < 1524.18 kg/cm2 SAFE
Thermal Expansion of the beam = 0.000012XDTXL (As per IS:800 CL. No.-3.3.4)
DT = 25
L = 1025 mm
2
E = 2140672.78 kg/cm
Thermal Expansion of the beam = 0.3075 mm
Welding :-
Max. shear force on the Beam = 1696.31 kg
Fillet size is 6 mm, Shear area = 25X0.6X0.707X2 = 21.21 cm2
Stress= 1696.31/21.21
= 79.98 kg/cm2 < 1621.8 kg/cm2 SAFE
7. Design of Beam : CC
Load, Deflection & Stress in beam CC under Normal Condition
687.87 kg/m
A1
C1 C2
575 450
1025
5 of 22
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING STRUCTURE FOR
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-003
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
Deflection of the Beam CC
d= (102.5^3/(2.1X10^6X6420))X((5X687.9X1.025/384)+(4971.4/48)X(3X450/1025-4X(450/1025)^3))
d= 0.01 cm
As per IS :807
Permissible deflection = L/800 = 0.13 cm SAFE
Load & Stress in beam CC under BDT Condition
Reaction at C1 = (7173.11X450+0.68787X1025^2/2)/1025
= 3501.7 kg = 3.50 T
Reaction at C2 = 7173.11+0.68787X1025-3501.7
= 4376.48 kg = 4.38 T
Maximum bending moment = 4376.48X45-687.87X0.45X22.5
= 189976.92 kgcm
Bending Stress on Beam CC= 189976.92/428
= 443.87 kg/cm2 < 2156.99 kg/cm2 SAFE
Shear Stress on Beam CC = 4376.48/21.28
= 205.66 kg/cm2 < 1524.18 kg/cm2 SAFE
Thermal Expansion of the beam = 0.000012XDTXL (As per IS:800 CL. No.-3.3.4)
DT = 25
L = 1025 mm
E = 2140672.78 kg/cm2
Thermal Expansion of the beam = 0.3075 mm
Welding :-
Max. shear force on the Beam = 3141.38 kg
Fillet size is 6 mm, Shear area = 25X0.6X0.707X2 = 21.21 cm2
Stress= 3141.38/21.21
2 2
= 148.11 kg/cm < 1621.8 kg/cm SAFE
8. Design of Beam : D
457.54 kg/m
D1 D2
1025
6 of 22
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING STRUCTURE FOR
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-003
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
Maximum bending moment = 234.49X51.25-457.54X0.5125X25.625
= 6008.83 kgcm
ISMC = 300 90
2
Area of Beam = 46.3 cm 13.6
Area of web = 21.28 cm2
Ixx = 6420 cm4 7.8
4
Iyy = 313 cm
300
3
Zxx = 428 cm
Zyy = 47.1 cm3
D = 300 mm 13.6
T = 13.6 mm
L = 102.5 cm
rx = 11.8 cm
ry = 2.6 cm
d1 = 30 cm
t = 0.78 cm
d1/t = 38.5 < 85.00 Hence stiffners are not required
Refer Table 6.1 B - IS :800-1984 D/T = 22.1 L/ry = 39.42
( On conservative side )
Permissible bending stress = 1621.8 kg/cm2
Bending Stress on Beam D = 6008.83/428
= 14.04 kg/cm2 < 1621.8 kg/cm2 SAFE
Shear Stress on Beam D = 234.49/21.28
= 11.02 kg/cm2 < 1146 kg/cm2 SAFE
Deflection of the Beam D
d= (102.5^3/(2.1X10^6X6420))X((5X457.5X1.03/384)+(4971.4/48)X(3X/1025-4X(/1025)^3)
d= 0.0000 cm
Permissible Deflection = L/900 = 0.11 cm SAFE
Thermal Expansion of the beam = 0.000012XDTXL (As per IS:800 CL. No.-3.3.4)
2
DT = 25 L = 1025 mm E = 2140672.78 kg/cm
Thermal Expansion of the beam = 0.31 mm
Welding :-
Max. shear force on the Beam = 234.49 kg
Length of Weld = 250 mm
Fillet size is 6 mm, Shear area = 25X0.6X0.707X2 = 20.36 cm2
Stress = 234.49/20.36
= 11.52 kg/cm2 < 2038 kg/cm2 SAFE
9. Design of Beam : E
1163 kg/m
B1 C1 A D1
E1 E2 500
423 794 458 550 375
2600
Self Weight of Beam E = 75 kg/m
Load due to self weight of chequered plate and crowd load = (500+47.1)X1.4125
= 772.78 kg/m
Load due to self weight of Rope Drum Assembly & Beam = = 75+314.96 = 389.96 kg/m
Total UDL Load = 772.78+389.96 = 1162.74 kg/m
Load, Stress & Deflection in beam E under Impact loading
Reaction at E1 = (1404.2X2177+2535.1X1383+9910.36X925+234.49X375-1.163X2600^2/2)/2600
7 of 22
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING STRUCTURE FOR
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-003
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
= 4571.95 kg = 4.57 T
Reaction at E2 = 1404.18+2535.1+9910.36+234.49+1.16274X2600-4571.95
= 12535.30 kg = 12.54 T
Maximum bending moment = 12535.3X92.5-234.49X37.5-1162.74X0.925X46.25
= 1100978.4 kgcm 250
Area of Beam = 92.6 cm2 12
Area of web = 32.6 cm2
4
Ixx = 20030.96 cm 10
Iyy = 3127.72 cm4
326
Zxx = 1144.63 cm3
Zyy = 250.22 cm3
D = 350 mm 12
T = 12 mm
L = 260 cm
rx = 14.71 cm
ry = 5.81 cm
d1 = 32.6 cm
t = 1 cm
d1/t = 32.6 < 85.00 Hence stiffners are not required
T/t = 1.2 < 2.00
As per IS:800 Cl. No.-6.2.3
Le= 0.85x2600/10 cm = 221 cm
Le/ry= 221/5.81
= 38.04
Y = 26.5 10 5
2
Le
r
y
= 26.5X10^5/(38.04^2)
= 1831.32 Mpa
fcb = 1831.32 Mpa
fy = 250 Mpa
Permissible bending stress
f cb f y
f bc 0.66 1.4
(f cb f y1.4 )1 1.4
= 0.66X1831.32X250/((1831.32^1.4+250^1.4)^(1/1.4))
= 158.11 Mpa
= 1611.72 kg/cm2
Bending Stress on Beam E= 1100978.4/1144.63
= 961.86 kg/cm2 < 1611.72 kg/cm2 SAFE
Shear Stress on Beam E = 12535.3/32.6
= 384.52 kg/cm2 < 1146 kg/cm2 SAFE
Deflection of the Beam E between supports
d= (260^3/(2.1X10^6X20031))X(((5X1162.7X2.6/384)+(1404.2/48)X(3X423/2600-4X(423/2600)^3)
+(2535.1/48)X(3X1217/2600-4X(1217/2600)^3)+(9910.36/48)X(3X1675/2600-4X(1675/2600)^3)
+(234.49/48)X(3X2225/2600-4X(2225/2600)^3)
d= 0.12 cm
Permissible Deflection = L/800 = 0.330 cm SAFE
8 of 22
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING STRUCTURE FOR
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-003
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
Load & Stress in beam E under BDT Condition
Reaction at E1 = (1856.7X2177+3501.7X1383+14497.69X925+234.49X375-1.163X2600^2/2)/2600
= 7097.02 kg = 7.10 T
Reaction at E2 = 1856.71+3501.7+14497.69+234.49+1.16274X2600-7097.02
= 23106.62 kg = 23.11 T
Maximum bending moment = 23106.62X92.5-234.49X37.5-1162.74X0.925X46.25
= 2078825.5 kgcm
Bending Stress on Beam E = 2078825.5/1144.63
2 2
= 1816.16 kg/cm < 2143.59 kg/cm SAFE
Shear Stress on Beam E = 23106.62/32.6
= 708.79 kg/cm2 < 2038 kg/cm2 SAFE
Thermal Expansion of the beam = 0.000012XDTXL (As per IS:800 CL. No.-3.3.4)
DT = 25
L = 2600 mm
E = 2140672.78 kg/cm2
Thermal Expansion of the beam = 0.78 mm
Welding :-
Max. shear force on the Beam = 23106.62 kg
Length of Weld = 326 mm
2
Fillet size is 6 mm, Shear area = 32.6X0.6X0.707X2 = 27.66 cm
Stress = 23106.62/27.66
= 835.38 kg/cm2 < 2038 kg/cm2 SAFE
10. Design of Beam : F
150 kg/m
G
F1 F2
262 488
750
9 of 22
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING STRUCTURE FOR
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-003
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
t = 1 cm
d1/t = 25.0 < 85.00 Hence stiffners are not required
Refer Table 6.1 B - IS :800-1984 D/T = 27.0 L/ry = 7.92
( On conservative side )
As per IS:800 Cl. No.-6.2.3
Le= 0.85x750/10 cm
= 63.75 cm
Le/ry= 63.75/9.47
= 6.73
26.5 10 5
Y = 2
Le
r
y
10 of 22
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING STRUCTURE FOR
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-003
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
Welding :-
Max. shear force on the Beam = 11915.85 kg
Length of the Weld = 250 mm
Fillet size is 6 mm, Shear area = 25X0.6X0.707X4 = 42.42 cm2
Stress = 11915.85/42.42
= 280.9 kg/cm2 < 2038 kg/cm2 SAFE
Supporting Bracket for Equaliser Sheave
Load on each Equalizer Sheave Bracket under Impact condition = 6065.43 kg
200
Pin Diameter = 100 mm
Shear Stress = 6065.43/(2X1.6X8)
500
= 236.93 kg/cm2
2
< 1146 kg/cm SAFE
130
Bearing Stress = 6065.43/(1.6X10)
= 379.09 kg/cm2
2
< 1911 kg/cm SAFE 16 300
Tensile Stress at Minimum Crosssection = 6065.43/((30-10)X1.6)
= 189.54 kg/cm2
< 1681 kg/cm2 SAFE
Load on each Equaliser Sheave Bracket under BDTcondition = 9113.43 kg
Shear Stress = 9113.43/(2X1.6X8)
= 113.92 kg/cm2 < 2038 kg/cm2 SAFE
Bearing Stress = 9113.43/(1.6X10)
2
= 569.59 kg/cm2 < 2038 kg/cm SAFE
Tensile Stress at Minimum Crosssection = 9113.43/((30-10)X1.6)
= 284.79 kg/cm2
< 2038 kg/cm2 SAFE
Welding :-
Max. shear force on the Bracket Plate= 9113.43 kg
Fillet size is 6 mm, Shear area = 20X0.6X0.707X2+30X0.6X0.707 = 29.69 cm2
Stress = 9113.43/29.69
= 306.95 kg/cm2 < 1146 kg/cm2 SAFE
11. Design of Beam :G
876 kg/m
B2 F D C2 F2 B D2
G1 G2
423 132 472 190 83 375 550 375
2600
Self Weight of Beam G = 75 kg/m
Load due to self weight of chequered plate and crowd load = (500+47.1)X0.8875
= 485.55 kg/m
Load due to self weight of Rope Drum Assembly & Beam = = 75+314.96
= 389.96 kg/m
Total UDL Load = 485.55+389.96 = 875.51 kg/m
11 of 22
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING STRUCTURE FOR
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-003
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
Load, Stress & Deflection in beam G under Impact loading
Reaction at G1= (1696.3X2177+1677.1X2045+4248.8X1573+3141.4X1383+4293.97X1300
+13437.73X925+234.49X375+0.87551X2600^2/2)/2600
= 15080.65 kg = 15.08 T
Reaction at G2 1696.31+1677.11+4248.82+3141.38+4293.97+13437.73+234.49+0.87551X2600-
= 15080.65
= 15925.49 kg = 15.93 T
Maximum bending moment = 15925.49X92.5-234.49X37.5-0.87551X925X46.25
= 1426859.04 kgcm
Section of Beam at Center 250
Area of Beam = 92.6 cm2 12
Area of web = 32.6 cm2
Ixx = 20030.96 cm4 10
4
Iyy = 3127.72 cm
326
3
Zxx = 1144.63 cm
Zyy = 250.22 cm3
D = 350 mm 12
T = 12 mm
L = 260 cm
rx = 14.71 cm
ry = 5.81 cm
d1 = 32.6 cm
t = 1 cm
d1/t = 32.6 < 85.00 Hence stiffners are not required
T/t = 1.2 < 2.00
As per IS:800 Cl. No.-6.2.3
Le= 0.85x2600/10 cm
= 221 cm
Le/ry= 221/5.81
= 38.04
Y = 26.5 10 5
2
Le
r
y
= 26.5X10^5/(38.04^2)
= 1831.32 Mpa
fcb = 1831.32 Mpa
fy = 250 Mpa
Permissible bending stress
f cb f y
f bc 0.66 1.4
(f cb f y1.4 )1 1.4
= 0.66X1831.32X250/((1831.32^1.4+250^1.4)^(1/1.4))
= 158.11 Mpa
= 1611.72 kg/cm2
Bending Stress on Beam G= 1426859.04/1144.63
= 1246.57 kg/cm2 < 1611.72 kg/cm2 SAFE
Shear Stress on Beam G = 15925.49/32.6
2 2
= 488.51 kg/cm < 1146 kg/cm SAFE
12 of 22
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING STRUCTURE FOR
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-003
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
Deflection of the Beam G
d= (260^3/(2.1X10^6X20031))X(((5X875.5X2.6/384)+(1696.3/48)X(3X423/2600-4X(423/2600)^3)
+(1677.11/48)X(3X555/2600-4X(555/2600)^3)+(4248.82/48)X(3X1027/2600-4X(1027/2600)^3)
+(3141.38/48)X(3X1217/2600-4X(1217/2600)^3)+(4293.97/48)X(3X1300/2600-4X(1300/2600)^3)
+(13437.73/48)X(3X1675/2600-4X(1675/2600)^3+(234.49/48)X(3X2225/2600-4X(2225/2600)^3)
d= 0.23 cm
Permissible Deflection = L/800 = 0.330 cm SAFE
Load & Stress in beam Funder BDT Condition
Reaction at G1= (2274.6X2177+2509X2045+6215.4X1573+4376.5X1383+6423.5X1300
+19451.82X925+234.49X375+0.87551X2600^2/2)/2600
= 21270.22 kg = 21.27 T
Reaction at G2 2274.55+2508.95+6215.36+4376.48+6423.5+19451.82+234.49+0.87551X2600-
= 21270.22
= 22491.26 kg = 22.49 T
Maximum bending moment = 22491.26X92.5-234.49X37.5-0.87551X925X46.25
= 2034192.76 kgcm
Bending Stress on Beam G = 2034192.76/1144.63
= 1777.16 kg/cm2 < 2143.59 kg/cm2 SAFE
Shear Stress on Beam G = 22491.26/32.6
2 2
= 689.92 kg/cm < 2038 kg/cm SAFE
Thermal Expansion of the beam = 0.000012XDTXL (As per IS:800 CL. No.-3.3.4)
DT = 25
L = 2600 mm
E = 2140672.78 kg/cm2
Thermal Expansion of the beam = 0.78 mm
Welding :-
Max. shear force on the Beam = 22491.26 kg
Length of Weld = 326 mm
Fillet size is 6 mm, Shear area = 32.6X0.6X0.707X2 = 27.66 cm2
Stress = 22491.26/27.66
2 2
= 813.13 kg/cm < 1146 kg/cm SAFE
12. Design of Beam : H
774.91 kg/m
F1
H1 H2
1300 1300
2600
Self Weight of Beam H = 50 kg/m
Load due to self weight of chequered plate and crowd load = (500+47.1)X1.325
= 724.91 kg/m
Total UDL Load = 50+724.91 = 774.91 kg/m
Load, Stress & Deflection in beam H under Impact loading
Reaction at H1 = (7949.4X1300+0.77491X2600^2/2)/2600
= 4982.08 kg = 4.98 T
Reaction at H2 = 7949.4+0.77491X2600-4982.08
= 4982.09 kg = 4.98 T
Maximum bending moment = 4982.08X130-774.91X1.3X65
= 582190.51 kgcm
13 of 22
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING STRUCTURE FOR
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-003
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
ISMC = 300 140
2
Area of Beam = 58.6 cm 13.1
Area of web = 23.1 cm2
Ixx = 8990 cm4 7.7
Iyy = 486 cm4
300
Zxx = 599 cm3
3
Zyy = 69.5 cm
D = 300 mm
T = 13.1 mm
L = 260 cm
rx = 12.4 cm
ry = 2.86 cm
d1 = 30 cm 13.1
t = 0.77 cm
d1/t = 39.0 < 85.00 Hence stiffners are not required
Refer Table 6.1 B - IS :800-1984 D/T = 22.9 L/ry = 90.91
( On conservative side )
Permissible bending stress = 1336.2 kg/cm2
Bending Stress on Beam HH= 582190.51/708.41
= 821.83 kg/cm2 < 1336.2 kg/cm2 SAFE
Shear Stress on Beam HH = 4982.09/50
2 2
= 99.64 kg/cm < 1146 kg/cm SAFE
Deflection of the Beam HH between supports
d= (260^3/(2.1X10^6X10821))X((5X774.9X2.6/384)+(4982.1/48)X(3X1300/2600-4X(1300/2600)^3)
d= 0.12 cm
Permissible Deflection = L/800 = 0.330 cm SAFE
Load & Stress in beam HH under BDT Condition
Reaction at H1 = (11915.85X1300+0.77491X2600^2/2)/2600
= 6965.31 kg = 6.97 T
Reaction at H2 = 11915.85+0.77491X2600-6965.31
= 6965.31 kg = 6.97 T
Maximum bending moment = 6965.31X130-774.91X1.3X65
= 840010.41 kgcm
Bending Stress on Beam HH = 840010.41/599
= 1402.35 kg/cm2 < 1777.15 kg/cm2 SAFE
Shear Stress on Beam HH = 6965.31/23.1
2 2
= 301.53 kg/cm < 2038 kg/cm SAFE
Thermal Expansion of the beam = 0.000012XDTXL (As per IS:800 CL. No.-3.3.4)
DT = 25
L = 2600 mm
E = 2140672.78 kg/cm2
Thermal Expansion of the beam = 0.78 mm
Welding :-
Max. shear force on the Beam = 6965.31 kg
Length of the Weld = 180 mm
Fillet size is 6 mm, Shear area = 18X0.6X0.707X2 = 15.27 cm2
Stress= 6965.31/15.27
2 2
= 456.14 kg/cm < 1146 kg/cm SAFE
14 of 22
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING STRUCTURE FOR
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-003
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
13. Design of Beam : I
I1 I2
2600
300
L = 260 cm
rx = 11.8 cm
ry = 2.6 cm 14
d1 = 30 cm
t = 0.78 cm
d1/t = 38.5 < 85.00 Hence stiffners are not required
Refer Table 6.1 B - IS :800-1984 D/T = 22.1 L/ry = 100.00
( On conservative side )
Permissible bending stress = 1305.6 kg/cm2
Maximum bending moment = 9.23X260^2/8 = 77993.5 kgcm
Bending Stress on Beam II= 77993.5/428
2 2
= 182.23 kg/cm < 1305.6 kg/cm SAFE
Shear Stress on Beam II = 9.23X260/21.28
= 112.77 kg/cm2 < 1146 kg/cm2 SAFE
Deflection of the Beam II
d= (260^3/(2.1X10^6X6420))X((5X922.8X2.6/384)
d= 0.040 cm
Permissible Deflection = L/800 = 0.33 cm SAFE
Thermal Expansion of the beam = 0.000012XDTXL (As per IS:800 CL. No.-3.3.4)
DT = 25
L = 2600 mm
E = 2140672.78 kg/cm2
Thermal Expansion of the beam = 0.78 mm
15 of 22
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING STRUCTURE FOR
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-003
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
Welding :-
Max. shear force on the Beam = 2399.23 kg
Length of the Weld = 250 mm
Fillet size is 6 mm, Shear area = 25X0.6X0.707X2 = 21.21 cm2
Stress= 2399.228/21.21
= 113.12 kg/cm2 < 1146 kg/cm2 SAFE
14. Design of Beam :J
322 kg/m
G2 H2 I2 I2 H2 G2 E2
E2
J1 J2
1050
Iyy = 26702.51
3
Zxx = 12261.55 cm
Zyy = 1335.13 cm3
D = 1100 mm 25
T = 25 mm
L = 1150 cm
rx = 42.81 cm
ry = 8.52 cm
d1 = 105 cm
t = 1.6 cm
d1/t = 65.6 < 85.00 Hence stiffners are not required
D/T = 44.0 L/ry = 134.98
As per IS:800 Cl. No.-6.2.3
Le= 0.85x11500/10 cm
= 977.5 cm
Le/ry= 977.5/8.52
= 114.7
26.5 10 5
Y = 2
Le
r
y
= 26.5X10^5/(114.73^2)
= 201.32 Mpa
16 of 22
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING STRUCTURE FOR
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-003
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
fcb = 201.32 Mpa
fy = 250 Mpa
Permissible bending stress
f cb f y
f bc 0.66
(f cb1.4 f y1.4 )1 1.4
= 0.66X201.32X250/((201.32^1.4+250^1.4)^(1/1.4))
= 89.51 Mpa
= 912.44 kg/cm2
Bending Stress on Beam J= 9725500.47/12261.55
= 793.17 kg/cm2 < 912.44 kg/cm2 SAFE
Shear Stress on Beam J = 36494/368
= 99.17 kg/cm2 < 1146 kg/cm2 SAFE
Deflection of the Beam J
d= (1150^3/(2.1X10^6X674385.4))X(((5X322X11.5/384)+(12535.3/48)X(3X1800/11500-4X(1800/11500)^3)
+(15925.49/48)X(3X2825/11500-4X(2825/11500)^3)+(4982.09/48)X(3X3575/11500-4X(3575/11500)^3)
+(1199.61/48)X(3X5475/11500-4X(5475/11500)^3)+(1199.61/48)X(3X6025/11500-4X(6025/11500)^3)
+(4982.09/48)X(3X7925/11500-4X(7925/11500)^3)+(15925.49/48)X(3X8675/11500-4X(8675/11500)^3)
+(12535.3/48)X(3X9700/11500-4X(9700/11500)^3)
d= 0.88 cm
Permissible Deflection = L/800 = 1.440 cm SAFE
Load & Stress in beam J under BDT Condition
Reaction at J1= (23106.6X9700+22491.3X8675+6965.3X7925+1199.6X6025+1199.6X5475
+6965.31X3575+22491.26X2825+23106.62X1800+0.322X11500^2/2)/11500
= 55614.3 kg = 55.61 T
23106.6+22491.3+6965.3+1199.6+1199.6+6965.31+22491.26+23106.62+3703-
Reaction at J2 = 55614.3
= 55614.31 kg = 55.61 T
Maximum bending moment = 55614.3X575-23106.62X395-22491.26X292.5-6965.31X217.5-
1199.614X27.5-322X5.75X287.5
= 14192169.24 kgcm
Bending Stress on Beam J = 14192169.24/12261.55
= 1157.45 kg/cm2 < 1213.55 kg/cm2 SAFE
Shear Stress on Beam J = 55614.31/168
= 331.04 kg/cm2 < 2038 kg/cm2 SAFE
Thermal Expansion of the beam = 0.000012XDTXL (As per IS:800 CL. No.-3.3.4)
DT = 25
L = 11500 mm
E = 2140672.78 kg/cm2
Thermal Expansion of the beam = 3.45 mm
Welding :-
Max. shear force on the Beam= 55614.31 kg
Fillet size is 6 mm, Shear area = 40X0.6X0.707X2+105X0.6X0.707 = 78.48 cm2
Stress = 55614.31/78.48
2 2
= 708.64 kg/cm < 1146 kg/cm SAFE
17 of 22
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING STRUCTURE FOR
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-003
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
15. Design of Beam :K
322 kg/m
G1 H1 I1 I1 H1 G1 E1
E1
K1 K2
1800 1025 750 1900 550 1900 750 1025 1800
11500
Self Weight of Beam K = 322 kg/m
Total UDL Load = 322 kg/m
= 322 kg/m
Load, Stress & Deflection in beam K under Impact loading
Reaction at K1= (4572X9700+15080.7X8675+4982.1X7925+1199.6X6025+1199.6X5475
+4982.08X3575+15080.65X2825+4571.95X1800+0.322X11500^2/2)/11500
= 27685.79 kg = 27.69 T
Reaction at K2= 4572+15080.7+4982.1+1199.6+1199.6+4982.08+15080.65+4571.95+3703-27685.79
= 27685.80 kg = 27.69 T
Maximum bending moment = 27685.8X575-4571.95X395-15080.65X292.5-4982.08X217.5-
1199.614X27.5-322X5.75X287.5
= 8053426.59 kgcm
400
2
Area of Beam = 368 cm 25
Area of web = 168 cm2
4
Ixx = 674385.42 cm 16
4
1050
Iyy = 26702.51 cm
Zxx = 12261.55 cm3
Zyy = 1335.13 cm3
D = 1100 mm 25
T = 25 mm
L = 1150 cm
rx = 42.81 cm
ry = 8.52 cm
d1 = 105 cm
t = 1.6 cm
d1/t = 65.6 < 85.00 Hence stiffners are not required
D/T = 44.0 L/ry = 134.98
As per IS:800 Cl. No.-6.2.3
Le= 0.85x11500/10 cm
= 977.5 cm
Le/ry= 977.5/8.52
= 114.7
26.5 10 5
Y = 2
Le
r
y
= 26.5X10^5/(114.73^2)
= 201.32 Mpa
fcb = 201.32 Mpa
fy = 250 Mpa
18 of 22
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING STRUCTURE FOR
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-003
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
Permissible bending stress
f cb f y
f bc 0.66 1.4
(f cb f y1.4 )1 1.4
= 0.66X201.32X250/((201.32^1.4+250^1.4)^(1/1.4))
= 89.51 Mpa
= 912.44 kg/cm2
Bending Stress on Beam K= 8053426.59/12261.55
= 656.8 kg/cm2 < 912.44 kg/cm2 SAFE
Shear Stress on Beam K = 27685.8/368
= 75.23 kg/cm2 < 1146 kg/cm2 SAFE
Deflection of the Beam K
d= (1150^3/(2.1X10^6X674385.4))X(((5X322X11.5/384)+(4572/48)X(3X1800/11500-4X(1800/11500)^3)
+(15080.65/48)X(3X2825/11500-4X(2825/11500)^3)+(4982.08/48)X(3X3575/11500-4X(3575/11500)^3)
+(1199.61/48)X(3X5475/11500-4X(5475/11500)^3)+(1199.61/48)X(3X6025/11500-4X(6025/11500)^3)
+(4982.08/48)X(3X7925/11500-4X(7925/11500)^3)+(15080.65/48)X(3X8675/11500-4X(8675/11500)^3)
+(4571.95/48)X(3X9700/11500-4X(9700/11500)^3)
d= 0.75 cm
Permissible Deflection = L/800 = 1.440 cm SAFE
Load & Stress in beam K under BDT Condition
Reaction at K1= (7097X9700+21270.2X8675+6965.3X7925+1199.6X6025+1199.6X5475
+6965.31X3575+21270.22X2825+7097.02X1800+0.322X11500^2/2)/11500
= 38383.66 kg = 38.38 T
Reaction at K2 = 7097+22491.3+6965.3+1199.6+1199.6+6965.31+21270.22+7097.02+3703-38383.66
= 38383.67 kg = 38.38 T
Maximum bending moment = 38383.67X575-7097.02X395-21270.22X292.5-6965.31X217.5-
= 10965497.44 kgcm
Bending Stress on Beam K= 10965497.44/12261.55
= 894.3 kg/cm2 < 1213.55 kg/cm2 SAFE
Shear Stress on Beam K = 38383.67/168
= 228.47 kg/cm2 < 2038 kg/cm2 SAFE
Thermal Expansion of the beam = 0.000012XDTXL (As per IS:800 CL. No.-3.3.4)
DT = 25
L = 11500 mm
2
E = 2140672.78 kg/cm
Thermal Expansion of the beam = 3.45 mm
Welding :-
Max. shear force on the Beam= 38383.67 kg
Fillet size is 6 mm, Shear area = 40X0.6X0.707X2+105X0.6X0.707 = 78.48 cm2
Stress = 38383.67/78.48
= 489.09 kg/cm2 < 1146 kg/cm2 SAFE
19 of 22
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING STRUCTURE FOR
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-003
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
16. Design of Column W3 & W4
500
4Nos. @1500 =6000
7500
W1 & W2
1500
1000
W5 2600 W5
Normal Wind Load on Structure
Wind
Form Pressu
Components L B/H Nos. Wind Load Wind Load
Factor re
2
(kg/m )
20 of 22
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING STRUCTURE FOR
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-003
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
P2= Load on each pair of column applied at middle of column due to wind load on Column
= S2 = 675 kg
P3= Load on each pair of column applied at top of column due to wind load on horizontal beam
= S3/2
= 1138.5 kg
P4= Load on each pair of column applied at top of column due to wind load on Hoist Equipment
= S4/2
= 702 kg
P5= Reaction on the column due wind load
= ((8721+675)X3750+(1138.5+702)X7500)/2600
= 18861.06 kg
Max. Load on column ( with impact ) = 36494.00 kg
Max. Load on column ( with BDT ) = 55614.31 kg
Section of Column
2600
Iyy = 35318.67 cm
3
FLOW
Zxx = 1996.92 cm
3
Zyy = 2207.42 cm 250 X 10
210
rx = 11.64 cm 10 X 230
ry = 12.23 cm X
Ly = 150 cm Lx = 1500 cm
Ly/ry = 12.26 Lx/rx = 128.87
Refer Table 5.1 of IS 800 - 1984 sac = 57.00 Mpa
2
Permissible Compressive Stress= 581.4 kg/cm
Permissible Compressive Stress under BDT= 581.4X1.33 kg/cm2
= 773.262 kg/cm2
Load Cases
i) Gate Operating Under Normal Condition with Wind blowing across the gate
Maximum Load on end Column = 36494+7544.42
= 44038.42 kg
Axial Stress = 44038.42/(236)
= 186.6 kg/cm2 SAFE
ii) Gate Operating Under BDT Condt. with normal Wind
Maximum Load on end Column = 55614.31+7544.42 = 63158.73 kg
Axial Stress = 63158.73/(236)
2
= 267.62 kg/cm SAFE
iv) Considering Seismic Condition
Total load on hoist bridge = Dead weight of hoist+Dead weight of hoist
bridge+25% of live load
= 5000 + 11000 + 0.25 x 25000
= 22250 kg
Seismic Force= 0.38 X 22250 = 8455 kg
Assuming the seismic force acting at the top of the column
Reaction on column = 8455X7500/(2600X2) = 12194.71 kg
Maximum Load on Column = (5000+11000+6250)/4+12194.71
= 17757.21 kg
Axial Stress = 17757.21/(236)
2
= 75.24 kg/cm SAFE
21 of 22
DESIGN OF HOIST SUPPORTING STRUCTURE FOR
25T ROPE DRUM HOIST FOR BARRAGE GATE Doc. No.-
North Karanpura(660MWx3) 4410-301B-PVH-U-003
(JHARKHAND) Rev.:R0
v) Storm Wind with Dead Weight
Load on the column due to dead weight = (5000+11000)/4 = 4000 kg
Load on the column due to Storm Wind = 18861.06 kg
Total load on the column = 4000+18861.06 = 22861.06 kg
Uplift on column = 18861.06-4000
= 14861.06 kg
2
Axial Stress = 22861.06/(236) = 96.87 kg/cm SAFE
17. Design of Base Plate
FLOW
450
Bearing Pressure = 63158.73/(45X45)
= 31.19 kg/cm2
= 3.06 Mpa
Permissible bearing stress of concrete = 0.25 X fck
grade of concrete = M 20 fck = 20 Mpa
Permissible bearing stress of concrete = 5 Mpa
450
From IS:800 Cl. No.-5.4.3
3w 2 b
2
t a
bs 4
where=
w = the pressure on the underside of the base,in Mpa
sbs= the Permissible bending stress in slab bases ( for all steels,shall be assumed as 185
MPa)
a= the greater projection of the plate beyond column, in mm;
b= the lesser projection of the plate beyond the column, in mm
t= the slab thickness, in mm;
a= 110 mm
b= 100 mm
t= ((3X3.06/185)X(110^2-100^2/4))^0.5 = 21.83 mm
Provided thickness of the base plate 25 mm
18. Bolt
Number of Bolt Provided = 12
Maximum Uplift load = 18861.06 kg
Load on each bolt = 18861.06/12
= 1571.76 kg
Bolt Diameter= 20 mm
500
22 of 22