The 2008 VIX Trading Strategies Report
The 2008 VIX Trading Strategies Report
The 2008 VIX Trading Strategies Report
strategies; four of which have been profitable more than 80% of the time in
predicting the short-term direction of the S&P 500 since 1995. VIX Strategy
is so strong that it has achieved nearly 100% of the gains in the S&P while
only being in the market less than 16% of the time.
The following was transcribed and edited from TraderTalk, a free, live,
interactive workshop conducted for TradingMarkets members by Larry
Connors.
In my opinion, the VIX is the best market-timing indicator available for short-
term traders today. The VIX is, simply, a measurement of the implied
volatility of the at-the-money OEX Index Options. High VIX readings usually
occur after markets experience sharp sell-offs, when fear is rampant and
sharp reversals to the upside tend to occur. Low VIX readings (as we are
seeing now) usually occur when the market rises. This is a signal that there
is complacency in the market and a sell-off is near.
These four rules will help you understand why VIX signals work:
3. This is the one that gets most traders on Wall Street messed up (and if
you only learn one thing from this session, this is the most important): The
VIX is dynamic, not static. Simply saying that you buy the market when the
VIX goes above 30, and sell the market when it trades around 20, is sheer
B.S. The Press over the past couple of years has done a wonderful job of
engraining this into traders' heads, but nothing could be further from the
truth. Blindly entering the market because the VIX reaches some pre-
determined level will eventually get you killed.
4. As mentioned before, the VIX measures fear. High VIX means that fear is
high, low VIX readings mean that fear is low. History has proven (and the
CVR signals have statistically proven) that approximately two out of three
times, when these market expectations occur, a top or bottom is in place
and we're going to look to fade these expectations as we know we will be
right approximately 65% of the time.
CVR Signals
I will now teach you two of my 10 CVR strategies. Both of these strategies
can be found nightly on our Market Bias page. Also, all the strategies can be
found in my book Trading Connors' VIX Reversals and in my nightly service.
(Why do I feel like Landry right now, shamelessly plugging my stuff?)
The 10 CVR signals as a whole over the past nine years have correctly
predicted two- to three-day market direction for the S&Ps approximately
65% of the time. The CVR 3 and the CVR 7 have correctly predicted direction
nearly 70%. First, let's look at the CVR 1 signal, which is the most basic of
signals, and then we'll look at the CVR 3, which is one of my favorites.
CVR 1 Signal
The rules for the CVR 1 are simple: For market buys, we are looking for the
VIX to make a 5-day high and close under its open. For sells, we are looking
for the VIX to make a 5-day low and close above its open.
Let's talk conceptually about what is going on here. First, a 5-day high or low
for the VIX tells us that the market on a short-term basis may be reaching
some extreme. By waiting for it (for buy signals) to make a 5-day high and
then at the same time closing below its open (remember rule #2: Volatility
is auto-correlated), we are finding a market that may be experiencing a
sentiment extreme and has a higher-than-average probability of reversing
for the next two to three days.
Take a look at some of the CVR 1 buy signals that occurred during the month
of December and helped us open up this year. As you can see, it did a good
job of identifying swing lows throughout the month.
CVR 3 Signal
Now, let's move on to the CVR 3 signal and then we'll talk about entry and
exit. My CVR 3 signal was co-created with Dave Landry. What we found is
that when the VIX moved 10% away from its 10-day moving average, it
identified a market that had been "stretched too far" and was likely to
reverse. In fact, over the last nine years, it has correctly predicted a two- to
three-day reversal better than 68% of the time.
For Buys:
1. Today, the low of the VIX must be above its 10-day moving average.
2. Today, the VIX must close at least 10% above its 10-day moving average.
3. If rules 1 and 2 are met, buy the market on the close.
4. Exit (on the close) the day the VIX trades (intraday) below yesterday's 10-
day moving average (reversion to the man). Or exit within two to four days.
For Sells:
1. Today, the high of the VIX must be below its 10-day moving average.
2. Today, the VIX must close at least 10% below its 10-day moving average.
3. If rules 1 and 2 are met, sell on the close.
4. Exit (on the close) the day the VIX trades (intraday) above yesterday's 10-
day moving average (reversion to the mean). Or exit within two to four days.
Again, let's look at this conceptually. For the VIX to move 10% away from its
moving average, the market must have gone through some extreme one-
way move. As we all know, the short-term moves are nearly always
unsustainable, and the best reversals come from them. We have found that
the best way to measure these extremes is with the CVR 3. On average, a
CVR 3 signal occurs about once every two and a half weeks, and we look to
exit within a two- to four-day period of time.
Multiple Signals
Before talking about which markets to trade and entry and exit, I want to
cover one more thing. The CVR signals perform even better when you have
multiple signals all pointed in the same direction. If you take the signals
from our Market Bias page, you'll want to see at least two CVR signals
pointing in the same direction. If you take the signals from my trading
service, the ideal time is to wait for three or more signals pointing in the
same direction.
Many traders have their own market-timing methods, some which are quite
good. CVR signals combined with other internal signals will give further
confirmation that those signals have an edge, and increases the odds that
your trade will be successful.
Money Management
One caveat: No matter how sure you are that the market is going to move in
one direction, you need to use protective stops and proper position size to
manage the position. Even if you have a methodology that's right 70% of
the time, it's more important to remember that it's wrong 30% of the time.
The gains take care of themselves, it's how you manage that 30% wrong
that will ultimately decide how successful you are with your trading.
Now let's talk about which markets to trade and how to enter positions. The
majority of my testing (and real-world results) with the CVR signals have
been with the S&P futures. This means that the best way to replicate the
results is to trade S&P futures (E-minis) or SPDRs. For the S&P futures, had
you traded one contract for every CVR signal since 1993, you would have
earned approximately $1.8 million since this past summer. THERE IS NO
GUARANTEE THIS WILL HAPPEN AGAIN. But this should give you an idea of
the cumulative effects of the CVR signals from 1993 up until recently.
Alternative Markets
For those of you who don't want to trade SPDRs or trade S&P futures, you
should look at the Market Bias page and the CVR signals to guide you as to
what the likely market direction will be for the next couple of days for the
market. One of the things we have continuously preached on the site from
Day 1 (in spite of the fact that it wasn't in vogue in 1999) was that we need
to trade both sides of the market to fully take advantage of them. Too many
methodologies out there are "bull-market-only" methodologies (or "bear-
market-only") and all these guys got killed when the market turned on them.
If you're not trading both sides of the market, you should strongly consider
doing so. Dave Landry (there's that name again) wrote an excellent article
on how to short stocks. Also, one of the advantages of trading SPDRs is that
they do not require an up-tick so you can short them immediately, without
worrying about violating the up-tick rule.
Probably the biggest edge with the VIX signals occurs in the options market,
and I'll be the first to say after trading the CVR signals for nearly six years, I
haven't come anywhere close to taking advantage of this edge. With that
said, again let's talk about what's going on with the CVR signals,
conceptually. For example, when a CVR buy signal occurs, and it is correct, it
is correctly predicting price direction and volatility direction at the same
time. It really doesn't get much better than this for option traders. There are
multiple strategies to take advantage of such signals, ranging from selling
naked puts (not advised, but certainly gives you the biggest edge) to trading
verticals.
Let's take this one step further: By selling premium on a CVR buy signal, you
will have price exploding on the underlying (which means your short
premium is imploding in your favor), and you have volatility imploding which
is causing further good erosion on your short position. Plus, because these
signals are two to four days in nature, you also have theta (time) working in
your favor. Again, it doesn't get much better than this.
Let's go to a CVR sell signal. The correct strategy here is to be long put
premium. The reason is that when the signal is correct, price will move in
your favor, increasing the value of your put, plus volatility is also moving in
your favor, increasing the value of your put.
As with all these strategies, you want to be in the market approximately two
to four days, and you'll want to make sure you use the correct stops to
protect yourself when the signals are wrong. As far as the perfect strategy
to trade with this, that is 100% up to you, you're the only one who knows
what's best, based upon your trading style and risk tolerance.
Q&A
A: I have never really done extensive testing on the VXN. My initial testing
(and my instincts) say that the rules work the same, and there should be
some sort of edge there. I would prefer testing this for at least a five-year
period of time before committing to this any further, but there should be an
edge here.
A: Multiple signals occur more often than you think. On average, when our
Market Bias page has one signal pointing in one direction, about half the
time it will have another one pointing in the same direction. And to reiterate
what I said earlier, the multiple signals do increase the chances of success
with the trade.
Another example of this complacency was Monday night's action in the VIX.
Even though the S&Ps lost nearly 10 points for the day, the VIX barely
budged, and in fact, closed near a four-month low. Both VIX actions
combined were telling you loud and clear that the complacency out there is
at an extreme, and certainly today's rapid, sharp sell-off occurs over and
over again when these extremes get reached. This is not a 2002 event or a
recent market event; this type of behavior has been exhibited by the
marketplace for decades, and will continue to occur for decades to come.
A: For those of you who are TradersWire Interactive subscribers, Greg Che
comes on the Wire a few minutes before the close and gives you the signals
that look like they will likely trigger at the close. On the TradingMarkets site
and on my subscription service, the signals are updated nightly at
approximately 7:30 p.m. EST.
Q: What if the CVR signals conflict with the other Market Bias indicators?
A: If one CVR signal conflicts with another CVR signal, you'll want to pass on
the signal. Again, there is no edge. If a CVR signal conflicts with a TRIN
thrust signal, or the momentum index indicator, the CVR signals override
those signals, and the CVR signals should be taken.
1. You can anticipate the CVR signals occurring and enter the market
intraday. This would be especially true by placing stops at some level away
from the market which will only get triggered if the market strongly reverses
intraday. This will many times give you a head start to the signals (but is far
riskier than a mechanical market on close entry when you know the signals
will be there for sure).
2. Simply to wait for the signal to occur, and then enter either on the futures
at the close, or for stocks, on the market opening the next day.