Vibration and Air-Overpressure Handout - October 2013
Vibration and Air-Overpressure Handout - October 2013
Vibration and Air-Overpressure Handout - October 2013
AIR-OVERPRESSURE
INTRODUCTION
Informing a nearby
resident of
impending blast.
This property owner
complained that the
blasts were startling
her, but her
complaints stopped
after regular
notification visits.
From Vibration, Airblast, and Risk Management REVEY Associates, Inc. Page 1
Underground Blasting Technology and Risk Management_____________________________________________
INTRODUCTION
AC ME
GFR
BLAST EFFECTS
When explosive charges detonate in rock, they are designed so that most
of the energy is used in breaking and displacing the rock mass. However,
some of the energy can also be released in the form of transient stress
waves, which in turn cause temporary ground vibration. Detonating
charges also create rock movement and release of high-pressure gas,
which in turn induce air-overpressure (noise), airborne dust and audible
blast noise.
In the very-near zone, crushing usually occurs in the rock around the
charge. The extent of this compressive and shear failure zone is usually
limited to one or two charge radii (half the diameter of the charge).
Beyond the plastic crushing zone, the rock or ground is temporarily
deformed by elastic strain waves. For some distance, tangential strain
intensity exceeds the rocks strength and new fractures are created.
Radial cracks are created in rock around detonating charges as a result of
induced strain that exceeds the rocks tensile strength. These cracks
generally do not extend farther than 26 charge radii.
Ground Vibration:
In and beyond the ground cracking zone, stress waves spread through
the rock mass and along the ground surface. As shown in Figure 5.1,
some waves pass through the body of the rock mass. Primary
compression waves and shear waves are examples of body waves. Other
surface vibration waves travel along the ground surface similar to the way
waves travel along the surface of water. In an ideal isotropic and
homogenous rock mass, wave energy would travel evenly in all directions.
However, most rock masses are far from ideal, so wave energy is
reflected, refracted and attenuated by various geological and
topographical conditions. When seismic waves pass through the ground,
ground particles oscillate within three-dimensional space. Soon after
blasting has stopped, vibration energy dissipates and the ground particles
become still.
Abbreviations:
SH = Shear wave, horizontal
SV = Shear wave, vertical
R = Rayleigh wave
P = Compressional wave
nt
xte
ee P
W av SH
SV
Detonating R
Charge or other
Impulsive
Disturbance
Standard industry damage criteria and safe levels of ground motion are
generally based on particle velocity and frequency of motion. The
response of humans to ground motion is primarily influenced by ground
motion velocity and duration of the motion. Vibration intensity is expressed
as Peak Particle Velocity (PPV) or the maximum particle velocity of the
ground. Since ground-shaking speeds are generally quite low, it is
measured in inches per second (in/s).
Persons not familiar with vibration science often confuse particle velocity
values with ground displacement. For instance, if a measured peak or
maximum particle velocity is 2.0 inches, the ground has NOT moved 2.0
inches. Ground particle movement or displacement would be much less
because in one second of time ground particles disturbed by blast
vibration waves will oscillate back and forth many times in a second.
TIM E
Peak
Am plitude (+/-)
Event Duration
Idealized Vibration or Air-Overpressure TimeIntensity History Plot
2 5 4 (1 0 )
2 0 3 (8 )
50.8 mm/s
(2.0 in/s)
5 0 .8 (2 )
2 5 .4 (1 ) 19.0 mm/s
2 0 .3 (.8 )
(0.75 in/s)
Drywall 40
1 5 .2 (.6 )
Plaster & Lath
12.7 mm/s
1 0 .2 (.4 ) (0.50 in/s)
5 .1 (.2 )
12
2 .5 (.1 )
1 2 4 6 8 10 20 30 40 60 80 100
FREQUENCY, Hz
USBM Safe Level vibration curve from RI 85071
1
Siskind, D. E., Stagg, M. S., Kopp, J.W. and Dowding, C.H. (1980). Structure Response and Damage Produced
by Ground Vibration From Surface Mine Blasting. RI 8507, U. S. Bureau of Mines.
2
Siskind, David E., Stagg, Mark S., Wiegand, John E. and Schultz, David L. (1993). Surface Mine Blasting Near
Pressurized Transmission Pipelines, R.I. 9523, U.S. Bureau of Mines.
Much higher PPV limits than those evolving from RI 8507 can be applied
to protect dams and appurtenant structures. Too often, the cost of work is
increased immensely when widely-published limits intended to prevent
cosmetic cracking in drywall are inappropriately applied to protect heavy
civil and commercial structures, pipes and mass concrete.
Research has also shown that the human response to transient vibration--
like those caused by blasting--varies depending on exposure time and the
intensity of the motion. Response curves defining how humans respond to
transient vibration based on these variables are shown in the following
Figure.
10
Strongly
perceptible
1
(mm/sec)
10
Distinctly
0.1 perceptible
Barely
perceptible
0.01
0.1 1 10 100 1000
Exposure time (s)
Rock Damage:
As indicated in the following Table, minor rock-slabbing or failure
generally does not occur until peak particle velocity exceeds 2,540 mm/s
(10 in/s).
Peak Particle Velocity Effect
(in/s) (mm/s)
10 254 No fracturing of intact rock
10 to 25 254to635 Minor tensile slabbing will occur
25 to 100 635to2540 Strong tensile and some radial cracking
> 100 >2540 Complete breakup of the rock mass
3
Wiss, J.F. and Parmalee, R.A. (1974), Human Perception of Transient Vibrations, Journal of the Structural
Division, ASCE, Vol. 4, pp. 349-377.
4
Bauer, A., and Calder, P.N., (1971), The Influence and Evaluation of Blasting on Stability, Proceedings of the
First Conference on Stability in Open Pit Mining, Brawner, C.O., and Milligan, V., eds., SME-AIME, Littleton,
CO, pp. 83-94.
Vibration Prediction:
With square-root scaling, the scaled distance for the 1-kg charge at a
distance of 10 m is 10-m-kg-0.5 [10/1-0.5]. If the size of charge in hole at a
distance of 100 feet is increased to 100-kg, the scaled distance is also 10-
W 1 = 100 kg
D = 10 m
DsD1s 100 10
DsD2s 10
100 10
1
D = 100 m
As shown in the following Figure, vibration data and curves generally fall
within the bounds defined by Oriard (1970). For curves with a presumed
slope of -1.6, K values generally vary from 24 to 605 (171 to 4316 Metric)
Curve slopes (m) for both imperial and metric (S.I.) units generally vary
from -1.0 to -1.9.
K Imperial = 605
V = K [D/W1/2 ]-1.6 K Metric (S.I.) = 4316
HI
K Imperial = 242 G
H
K Metric (S.I.) = 1726 CO
TY NF
PI IN
CA EM
1.00 L
DA
EN
T,
(25.4) TA C O
K Imperial = 24 FR UP
K Metric (S.I.) = 171 O LI
M NG
DO ,A
W ND
N-
HO RO
LE CK
0.10 NOTES: BE ST
NC RE
(2.54) ATTENUATION SLOPE:
H
BL
NG
AS TH
-1.6 is typical but slope may vary TI
NG
depending on wave types
and other modifying factors.
Slopes usually vary between -1.0 and -1.9
0.01
(0.25)
1(0.45) 10 (4.52) 100 (45.2) 1000 (452)
S ca le d D istan ce - ft/lb 1 /2 (m /kg 1 /2 )
5
Oriard, L.L., (1970). Blasting Operations in the Urban Environment, Association of Engineering Geologists
Annual Meeting, Washington, DC, October 1970, published in Bulletin of AEG, Vol. IX. No. 1, October, 1972.
SRRQ PPV Curve (Yr 2005)
PPV (in/s)
10.000
1.28
95 % PPV 40 . 1 D
W
1.000
0.100 1.28
50 % PPV 18 . 8 D
W
0.010
1.0 10.0 100.0 1000.0
1/2
Scaled Distance (ft/lb )
Correlation Coefficient = 0.796
10000.000
1.82
1000.000 PPV 95 % 3041 .3 D
W
PPV (mm/s)
100.000
1.82
1.000
0.100
1.0 10.0 100.0 1000.0
CorrelationCoefficient= 0.976 Scaled Distance (m/kg1/2)
Ds PPV K
1
m
For example, if the desired PPV-limit for buried pipes is 5.00 in/s, with
cautious constants with K = 240 and m = -1.6, the limiting Scaled Distance
(Ds) is 11.2 ft-lb-0.5 [(5.00 / 240) (1 / -1.6)].
W D D s
2
All licensed and capable blasters are trained to understand and apply
scaled distance equations. For example, if a blast occurs 20m from a
buried pipe where a minimum scaled distance of 5.5-m/kg1/2 is mandated
to control vibration, the maximum charge-per-delay would 13.2 kg [(20 /
5.5)2]. If the distance increases to 40m, the allowable charge-per-delay
increases dramatically to 53 kg [(40 / 5.5)2].
Long Period (LP) detonators with timing delay intervals generally ranging
from zero to 8,000 milliseconds are generally used for blasting rock in
underground applications.
6
Matts, T., (2012). Blast Vibration Control - Long Delay Pyrotechnic Detonators & the 8ms Rule
AIR-OVERPRESSURE (AIRBLAST)
Overpressure, as its name implies, is the transient pressure change
caused in air, water or any other fluid medium affected by explosions.
Pressure changes are caused by acoustical waves travelling through the
medium at the speed of sound. The speed of sound is varies in different
materials, depending on the density of the medium. For instance,
pressure waves travel at the speed of 4,920 ft/s (1,500 m/s) in water,
whereas they travel at only 1,100 ft/s (335 m/s) in aira much less dense
medium. When educating the public about blasting effectsalways use
the term Air-overpressure instead of airblasta term with negative
connotations.
The regulatory limit defined by USBM for airblast measured with 2-Hz
response seismographs is 133 dB-L. Damage to old or poorly glazed
windows does not occur until air-overpressure reaches about 150 dBL.
More importantly, since the decibel scale is a logarithmic ratio, the actual
overpressure at 150 dBL is 0.092 psi, versus 0.013 psi at 133 dBL.
Therefore, the actual pressure at the 133-dB-L limit, is over seven times
(0.092/0.013) lower than the threshold damage level at 150-dB-L. The
relationships between actual overpressure expressed in psi and decibel
scale measurements are shown in the following Equations.
dB
dB 20 Log10 P or psi Po 10 20
Po
Where: dB = decibels, P = overpressure (psi), Po = Threshold of Human Hearing Pressure (2.9 x 10-9 psi).
7
Siskind, D.E., Stachura, V.J., Stagg, M.S., and Kopp, J.W.,1980, US Bureau of Mines Report of Investigations
8485.