ESL-HH-00-05-47

-ENERGY EFFICIENT RONDAVELS IN THE KRUGER NATIONAL

GAME RESERVE, SOUTH AFRICA

Dieter Holm Head Research & Postgraduate Study: School for the Built Environment University of Pretoria
Pretoria

ABSTRACT
Unique huts are being used as guest lodges in the Skukuza is the largest camp in the two million
South African National Kruger Game Park. These hectare game reserve which is about equal to the area
are inspired by the rondavels (indigenous round of Massachusetts. It is approximately 500km east of
thatched adobe building), but have been westernized Pretoria, sharing the eastern boundary with
by adding glazed window areas, higher cement block Mo~ambique.
walls and asbestos fiber cement roofs. Serious
overheating and overcooling occurs if the huts are not The annual rainfall of 680mm mostly occurs
air-conditioned. The summer design day indoor during summer (December, January) leading to hot-
temperature then remains above 27C (8 IoF),while in humid conditions. During the dry winters, animals
winter it remains below 18C (64F) for 20 hours per seek the water holes and are more easily visible
day. because of the then shorter gass. The mean daily dry
bulb temperature amplitude is 14K (25.2"F), with the
Tourist accommodation typically makes up 65% largest swing during June, July. Winter nights are
of the power consumption of camps. Where camps wonderfully clear, starry and still. The haunting
are not grid-connected this led to high costs. Various jackal's call and the ominous lion's roar make their
passive design alternatives have been simulated using presence felt. On the eastern horizon the Lebombo
the Quick program, developed by the University of range is penetrated by east bound rivers crossing the
Pretoria. A combination of envelope optimization, broad Sul do Save footvalley before discharging into
earth connected ventilation pipes and ceiling fans led the warm Agulhas current of the Indian ocean.
to thermal comfort while cost-effectively reducing
peak demand by 30% and consumption by 33% The northern tip of the reserve lies on 22'20'
without impairing the architecture. -
southern latitude well inside of the Ecliptic of
Capricorn (23"3O8S),and closer to the equator than
This paper shows that indigenous designs are a Rio de Janeiro. On the Southern boundary the
good starting point throughout the world (no matter if Crocodile River reaches 25'32' southern latitude,
it is Africa, Mexico,. ..). They are a "window" to which is about equidistant to the northern latitude of
designing low embodied energy to passive solar Brownsville. Skukuza lies on 25" S, and is only
design for their particular region! 700m above sea level.

INTRODUCTION INDIGENOUS RONDAVEL

Visiting the Kruger National Park to "hunt" the The word "Rondavel" is probably derived from
Big Five is an unforgettable experience. Part of this the Latin root "round" and is an apt description of the
is the climate and the unusual architecture of traditional climate-adapted 3,600 to 6,000mm
rondavels. These traditional buildings were diameter hut consisting of a circular 1,200 to
originally windowless round huts with low mud walls 1,500mm high mud construction wall supporting a
(adobe or wattle- and- daub) topped by conical conical grass thatched roof. This geometry closely
thatched roofs. approximates the hemispherical Zulu hut but has the
advantage that, the thatch does not touch the ground,
However, the progressive introduction of thereby reducing risks of rot, fire and termites. The
concrete block walls to increasing wall heights, conical roof with a slope of 36" to 45" has a thickness
glazed window-areas and the use of asbestos of 150mm and consists of reedy type grass, less than
reinforced cementitious roofing forfeited the benefits a pencil thick and 1,200 to 2,000mm long. It has
of low embodied energy and passive solar design. good insulation values. The thatch is stitched to
This led to the need for air-conditioning units, which circular laths supported by radial rafters, either
caused high consumption and high peak demands of resting on the wall or peripheral posts. The roof
expensive electricity. About two thirds of the overhang serves to shade the walls and also protects
Skukuza camp energy bill is attributed to guest them against erosion by rain. There are no gutters.
accommodation.

Proceedings of the Twelfth Symposium on Improving Building Systems in Hot and Humid Climates, San Antonio, TX, May 15-17, 2000
 ESL-HH-00-05-47

The traditional rondavel has no windows, light Design

being provided by the door opening during the day Most contemporary tourists would hardly be
and a wood fire at night. Fire was also useful against prepared to stoop at the entrance door, stay in a
mosquitoes and other insects entering through the windowless room with dark brown mud-plastered
ventilation slit normally left between the top of the walls and floors, or sleep on the floor on a thin
wall and the roof soffit. All building materials were woven g a s s mat in a smoke filled room without
harvested nearby in the veld. Hut building was a any ablutions.
community ritual. After the death of its inhabitant
the hut was left to decay, gradually returning to earth. The gradual introduction of standard
This tradition required very little embodied energy rectangular beds, closets, baths, showers, vanity
and had little environmental impact. cabinets etc brought so much conflict with the
circular shape that this was often abandoned in
Temperature measurements in traditional favor of a rectangle. This led to enlarged surface-
rondavels undertaken by the author in the Middelburg to-volume ratio, and it necessitated a revised roof
area yielded an amplitude ratio of 0.3 of the outdoor shape, often a replacement by standard hipped
dry bulb temperature swing, which is quite good a asbestos fiber reinforced sheets. Wall heights were
result. However, the delta T in summer is 1SK, increased to at least 2 100 and glazed windows
which is not so good. So the romantic appeal of with insect screened openable sections followed.
indigenous architecture has its limits. Walls were built of concrete blocks with cement
stucco and white wash.
MODERN RONDAVELS
South Africa's standard power is 220 Volt at
50Hz. A modern hut would typically have four
60W incandescent lights, a 200 W refrigerator, a
100 litre water heater with a 3.10kW element, a
120W ceiling fan and miscellaneous plugs for TV,
hair dryers etc. The resulting indoor temperature
in passive mode is outside the summer and winter
thermal comfort range. See figures 2 and 3.

Consequently a 3.5kW air-conditioning unit

has to be installed. This produces a peak demand
on the system because tourists act in a
synchronised manner. The arrive in air conditioned
automobiles and tend to have demanding comfort
Figure 1. Modem rondavel expectations.

TEMPERATURE SMUJATION MIR HOT DAY

PROJECT:
ZONE
SKUKUZR -
KRUILDTM
2NI
HUT "G" STANDRARD - -
" H - ) 1 ' DUTDOOR AIR TEHPERll URE
-1MDOOR l r I R TEHPERJURE
CPHFORT TEMP L I H I T z

Figure 2. Status quo for summer conditions

Proceedings of the Twelfth Symposium on Improving Building Systems in Hot and Humid Climates, San Antonio, TX, May 15-17, 2000
 ESL-HH-00-05-47

TEMPERATURE SIMULATION FDR MllD DAY

TEHP
(QC)

PROJECT : K R U I L D IN " X ' X ' OUTDIIUR A I R TEHPERATURE

ZONE ' Zlt f
SKUKUZA -
HUT STRNPARRD -
'-/-j-ItIDDOR A I R TEHPERATURE
COHFORT TEHP L I H I T S

Figure 3. Status quo for winter conditions

In addition to the electrical peak demand, construction, as well as the probability of runs of
consumption is also considerable in an area where successive hot or cold days (spells). The design day
electricity is expensive by South African standards. weather data assume the previous day to be of the
same conditions.
Use pattern
There is a seasonal shift in the use pattern as Hot and cold design day data have been
follows. produced for all representative stations in Southern
Use
- summer winter Africa at the lo%, 5% and 2.5% probability levels.
Arrival 12:OO- 16:OO 12:OO-16:OO The 10% probability level represents the mean of the
Game viewing 16:OO- l7:3O 16:OO- l7:OO 10% extreme hot and 10% extreme cold days. These
Bath, supper l7:30-2O:OO l7:OO- l9:OO are expected to be exceeded on 10 to 15 days per
Relax 2O:OO-22:OO 19:OO-22:OO year. Similarly the 5% and 2.5% levels have been
Sleep 22:OO-06:OO 22:OO-07:OO obtained representing design data of increasing
Breakfast 06:OO-07:OO 07:OO-7:30 stringency. While there are standards for commercial
Game viewing 07:OO-10:OO 07:30-9:00 buildings [2], there are no energy standards or codes
Relax 1O:OO-16:OO 09:OO-17:30 for housing in South Africa.

IMPROVED RONDAVELS THERMAL COMFORT

Design climate Following Szokolay [3] the summer and winter
In contrast with the convention of using the TMY or thermal comfort zones were calculated for a
degree-days, it is standard practice in South Africa to use population acclimatized to local conditions (figure 4).
the "design day" method. This is argued on the grounds It appears that the outdoor climate is overly hot-
of the probability levels of coincidence of weather humid from October to April. While the over-cooled
conditions [I]. For hot conditions this is the combined period represents a relatively minor problem from the
probability effect of solar radiation, low temperature passive solar design point of view, the hot-humid
radiation exchange, dry bulb temperature and wind problem is not so tractable.
speeds, whereas for cold conditions it is the daily
minimum temperatures and wind speed. This procedure
takes account of the characteristically large diurnal
variations in air temperature and radiation, abundance of
sunshine and the predominantly heavy weight

Proceedings of the Twelfth Symposium on Improving Building Systems in Hot and Humid Climates, San Antonio, TX, May 15-17, 2000
Council (or SdeMk Md I n d u W
ESL-HH-00-05-47

ALTITUDE 700 m
BarmeMc pressure 93,19 kPa

Figure 4. Skukuza

SIMULATION PROGRAM It has been validated for South African conditions, is

"Quick" was originally developed by the Center for user-friendly and sufficiently accurate for most
Experimental and Numerical Themoflow at the design evaluations.
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of
Pretoria, under leadership of Professor Eddie Mathews.

TEMPERATURE S I W T I O N FOR HOT DAY

TEHP
(OC)

.-X.XmUUTDOOR e I R TEHPERATURE
-
~ I N O O D R A I R T E n f ERRTURE
COHFORT TEHP LIHITS

Figure 5. Structural night air cooling with cavity wall for summer condition

Proceedings of the Twelfth Symposium on Improving Building Systems in Hot and Humid Climates, San Antonio, TX, May 15-17, 2000
 ESL-HH-00-05-47

ALTERNATIVES Elimination of west window

Twenty-one alternative designs were The summer maximum is reduced (fig. 7)
modeled, starting with the status-quo (figs. 2 & 3) while making little difference in winter (fig. 8).
until maximum indoor thermal comfort was
reached in both summer and winter. A selection is Cavity filled with 50mm polystyrene plus 80%
illustrated below. [4] direct evaporative cooling
Acceptable summer (fig. 9) and winter
Structural night air cooling with cavity wall (fig. 10) conditions are achieved, but at a cost.
This leads to a 50% thermal improvement in
summer (fig. 5) and almost acceptable conditions in
winter (fig. 6 ) .

TEMPERATURE SIEdlR,4TION FOR MIIl1 DAY

TEHP
(OC)

PROJECT : KRUILDTH T I H E IHOURS) .

A , Jd OUTDOOR A I R TEHPERATURE
I.,

ZONE :
SKUKUZA - 2H5
HUT STRUKTUURUERKOELING -' ~ I N D O I I R f l I R TEHPERATURE
CDHFORT TEHP L I H I T S

Figure 6 . Structural night air cooling with cavity wall for winter conditions

TEMPERATURE SW4TION FOR HOT DAY

PROJECT : KRU ILD I N l I H E [HPURS)

ZUNE : 2N9
SKUKUZA - HUT ''6" HINDER UEMSTER

Figure 7. Elimination of west window for summer conditions

Proceedings of the Twelfth Symposium on Improving Building Systems in Hot and Humid Climates, San Antonio, TX, May 15-17, 2000
 ESL-HH-00-05-47

TEMPERATURE S
W ON FOR GO1D DAY

PROJECT: KRUILDTN T I H E [HOURS)

20HE ' ZN9
SKUKUZII HUT IIGII HINDER UENSTER

Figure 8. Elimination of west window for winter conditions

TEHP
(QC)

PROJECT: KRUILDTN T I H E [HOURS) " S I ' X ' O U I D D O R A I R TEHPERATURE

-
ZONE : ZtiiB
SKUKUZA - HUT " G I GEKDHBINEERD ALT 5 -
V I N D D O R IIR TEHPERRTURE
C O H F U k l TEHP L I H I T S

Figure 9. Cavity filled with 50mm polystyrene plus 80% direct evaporative cooling for summer conditions

Proceedings of the Twelfth Symposium on Improving Building Systems in Hot and Humid Climates, San Antonio, TX, May 15-17, 2000
 ESL-HH-00-05-47

TEMPERATURE SIMULATION FOR DAY

PROJECT :
ZUtiE '
SKUKUZA -
KRU I L D TH
?Hi8
H U T 1 1 ~ 1 1 GEKOHBINEERD A L T 5
TIHE (HOURS)
-
~ ~ # s X ' O U I D P OARI R TEHPEKATURE
- i t ' I H DCUHFORT
U U R FlIRTEHPTEHPERnTURE
LIHITS

Figure 10. Cavity filled with 50mm polystyrene plus 80% direct evaporative cooling for winter conditions

TEMPERATURE SIWTJON FOR HOT DAY

OU TOOUR R TEHPERA TORE

- 'A.
TINDOER
tl I
hIR TEHPERhTUKE
CPHFURT TEnP L I ~TSI

Figure 1 1. Underground air pipe, ceiling fan for summer conditions

Proceedings of the Twelfth Symposium on Improving Building Systems in Hot and Humid Climates, San Antonio, TX, May 15-17, 2000
 ESL-HH-00-05-47

Underground air pipe, ceiling fan

Comfort is maintained (fig. I I) cost effectively.
The absorptivity of the exterior finish is reduced from
30% to 18.5% (ASTM E - 892 - 82) while the
emittance remains 90% (ASTM E - 408 -71). A
variable speed fan produces air speed from 0.5m/s to
1.5mIs (1 00 to 150 Wminute) through a 1Om, 250
0mm underground pipe.

RESULTS
After passive design changes to the envelope
(reduced wall height, elimination of west window,
reflective white exterior paint, weatherization,
perimeter insulation) and reduction of interior gains
(incandescents replaced by CFLs) and underground
air supply system provides comfort. The peak
demand is reduced by 30% and the consumption by
33%.

CONCLUSION, FURTHER WORK

The above design changes do not include
(improved) insulation to the electrical water heater,
insulation to the hot water pipes or - probably the
-
better option domestic solar water heaters. Passive
thermal design can achieve thermal comfort while
saving energy costs and retaining the architectural
appeal of the traditional rondavel.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The kind assistance of Prof. Mike Murphy is
gratefilly acknowledged. I thank Mr. Frans
Laubscher of the Kruger National Park for support
and information. Thanks to colleague Deon van
Aswegen of Holm Jordaan Architects and to the
University of Pretoria.

REFERENCES
[ l ] Van Deventer, E.N. 1971. Climate and other
design data for evaluating heating and cooling
requirements of buildings. CSIR Report 300.
National Building Research Institute: Pretoria.

[2] South African Bureau of Standards. 1999. South

African Energy and Demand Efficiency Standard
- SAEDES. 03 Department Minerals & Energy &
U S . Department of Energy: Pretoria.

[3] Szokolay, S.V. 1992. Archipak, Version 4.2 User

Manual. University of Queensland: Brisbane.

[4] Holm, Jordaan architects & Urban planners. 1991.

1
energiebesparing en behaaglikheid vir toeriste-
akkomodasie. Gedeeltelike verslag, deel I.
Pretoria.

Proceedings of the Twelfth Symposium on Improving Building Systems in Hot and Humid Climates, San Antonio, TX, May 15-17, 2000

The author has requested enhancement of the downloaded file. All in-text references underlined in blue are linked to publications on ResearchGate.