ADHD and Behavioral Disorders: Assessment, Management, and An Update From DSM-5
ADHD and Behavioral Disorders: Assessment, Management, and An Update From DSM-5
B
ehavioral disorders in pediatric patients Impairment before age 12 instead of age 6. As a neuro-
primarily attention deficit hyperactivity dis- developmental disorder, ADHD usually starts at a
order (ADHD)pose a clinical challenge young age; teenagers presenting with newly devel-
for health care providers to accurately assess, oped ADHD-type symptoms probably do not have
diagnose, and treat. In 2013, the criteria for several ADHD and efforts should be made to rule out other
disruptive behavioral disorders were updated in the illnesses or social dynamics. The DSM-5 raised the
fifth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual age limit for onset of qualifying symptoms to before
of Mental Disorders (DSM-5),1 their first major revi- 12 years (previously by age 6) primarily to capture
a cohort of pediatric patients, typically female, who
present solely with inattention symptoms and may
Dr. Austerman reported that he has no financial interests or relationships that
pose a potential conflict of interest with this article. not display overt functional impairment early on.
This article was developed from an audio transcript of Dr. Austermans presen- Symptoms required in at least two settings. Symptoms
tation at the Perspectives in Pediatrics: From Theory to Practice symposium must be present in at least two settings to qualify for a
held at the Global Center for Health Innovation, Cleveland, OH, May 810, diagnosis of ADHD. This ensures that the behaviors
2014. The transcript was formatted and edited by Cleveland Clinic Journal of
Medicine staff for clarity and conciseness, and was then reviewed, revised, and occur globally; they do not occur just at school or at
approved by Dr. Austerman. home but occur in both places.
doi:10.3949/ccjm.82.s1.01 Fewer symptoms required for diagnosis in adolescents.
S2 C L E V E L A N D C L INI C J OURNAL OF ME DI CI NE VOLUME 82 SUPPLEMENT 1 NOV EMBER 2015
AUSTERMAN
Although the diagnostic criteria retain the same are seen in children with intellectual disabilities or an
symptoms as those in DSM-IV for different age autism spectrum disorder.
groups, individuals aged 17 and older are now required
to display only five or more inattentive or hyperac- Disruptive mood dysregulation disorder
tive-impulsive symptoms. Previously, at least six were A new diagnostic category in DSM-5 is termed dis-
required. ruptive mood dysregulation disorder (DMDD). This
captures many children who previously would have
Partial remission criteria been diagnosed with pediatric bipolar disorder, even
The concept of partial remission was introduced in though most of them do not fulfill criteria for bipolar
DSM-5. This acknowledges that two-thirds of chil- disorder as adults. The presence of baseline irritabil-
dren diagnosed with ADHD do not have symptoms ity separates this disorder from IED, which requires
that functionally impact activities of daily living intermittent rapid and severe outbursts. The severe
beyond age 18. temper outbursts of DMDD must be recurrent, with
Oppositional defiant disorder an average of three occurrences per week, and have
In DSM-5, oppositional defiant disorder (ODD) background irritability. The symptoms must have a
is defined by emotional and behavioral symptoms duration of at least 12 months and be present in two
grouped into three categories: settings. A diagnosis of DMDD cannot be made ear-
Constant anger or irritability lier than age 6, with onset before age 10.
Argumentative or defiant behavior (arguing
with authority figures) ASSESSMENT OF ADHD
Vindictiveness. The clinical interview in conjunction with objective
Because defiant behavior may represent difficulty scales is the primary tool for diagnosing ADHD. The
with self-control, ODD is associated with execu- most frequent source of information is from the par-
tive functioning deficits that are present in ADHD. ents followed by the childs schoolteachers. Patient
Children with ODD tend to perform best in situa- interview, although unreliable in young children,
tions in which they can dominate or exert authority. should also be part of the assessment. Comparing the
To qualify as ODD, the pattern of behavior must be patients functional impairment against children of a
consistent for longer than 6 months. A severity rating similar age is necessary for an ADHD diagnosis.
was added based on pervasiveness of ODD symptoms. The medical history can help rule out children with
Otherwise the diagnosis did not change. asthma or allergy being treated with corticosteroids
Conduct disorder: Purposeful aggression and those with hypothyroidism and hyperthyroidism
The hallmarks of conduct disorder are purposeful whose symptoms often fulfill the diagnostic criteria
aggression (eg, bullying), destruction of property, for ADHD.2,3 Symptoms of ADHD also may appear
deceitfulness or theft, and serious violation of rules suddenly after a traumatic brain injury or other neuro-
(eg, running away from home, repeat truancy). Some logic event.4 Other psychiatric illnesses, especially
consider conduct disorder to be a separate illness learning disorders, mood disorders, anxiety, other
from ODD, whereas others consider it a continuum disruptive behavior disorders, or substance abuse, can
of the same disorder. Conduct disorder can manifest mimic ADHD.
as violence, as in initiating physical fights, or it can Ruling out other factors from a social history (eg,
manifest in behaviors such as truancy, stealing, lying, family conflict, bullying, sleep deprivation, being
and running away from home without the physical- overscheduled with activities) adds to the reliabil-
aggression aspect. ity of an ADHD diagnosis. For example, repetitive
uprooting and frequent changes in schools can cause
Intermittent explosive disorder academic problems that may be mistaken for ADHD,
Failure to control aggressive impulses defines inter- and use of stimulants may have failed to improve
mittent explosive disorder (IED). The aggressive symptoms in these children.
outbursts can be verbal or behavioral and tend to be
impulsive. A small subset of children display isolated Assessment scales
aggression out of proportion to provocation. The dis- Pediatric assessment scales that can be performed in
order tends to manifest at ages 3 or 4, and a diagnosis an office are more practical than standardized clinical
requires a stable environment with no significant assessments (Table 1). The Vanderbilt ADHD Diag-
early childhood trauma. Most often these symptoms nostic Teacher Rating Scale correlates highly with a
CL E VE L AND CL I NI C J OURNAL OF MED IC INE VOLUME 82 SUPPLEMENT 1 NOV EMBER 2015 S3
ADHD AND BEHAVIORAL DISORDERS
TABLE 1
Selected diagnostic tools for ADHD assessment
diagnosis of ADHD. We use the Vanderbilt ADHD delinquency and peer rejection are high. This may
Diagnostic Parent Rating Scale for children up to age result in secondary comorbidity such as emotional,
1 year. Other scales track symptoms and functional disruptive, or substance abuse problems.
impairment over time and can be administered before
the patients appointment. The Conners Third Edition MANAGEMENT STRATEGIES
scale can be used to establish a baseline before initiat-
ing therapy and to help monitor changes over time. Stimulants
Standardized tests to bolster the utility of the The first-line pharmacologic treatment of ADHD is
clinical interview include the Diagnostic Interview stimulants: methylphenidate, dexmethylphenidate,
Schedule for Children and Adolescents and the mixed amphetamine salts, dextroamphetamine, and
Schedule for Affective Disorders and Schizophrenia lisdexamfetamine. Head-to-head trials of medications
in School-Age ChildrenPresent and Lifetime Ver- versus behavioral management favor medication use,
sion. Free training is available regarding use of some even over the long term.1214
of these standardized tests. Methylphenidate and amphetamines are equally
effective and have similar adverse effect profiles.
Developmental course, risk factors Insomnia and anorexia are the most common side
The clinical course of ADHD is chronic. The onset of effects of stimulants. Cardiac effects include tachy-
hyperactivity usually occurs at age 3 or 4, with com- cardia, chest pain, and hypertension. Very rarely,
bined hyperactivity and inattention usually appear- stimulants have been associated with sudden cardiac
ing from ages 5 to 8.5,6 The evolution of symptoms death syndrome in patients with underlying cardiac
is progressive and constant. Between 50% and 80% problems. The consensus is that stimulants are safe
have symptoms that continue into adolescence, and in the general population. The need to obtain an
in about 40%, symptoms continue into adulthood.7,8 electrocardiogram before initiating a stimulant was
Some children with ADHD have a temperament- removed by the US Food and Drug Administration
neuropsychological profile characterized by aggres- (FDA) unless it is otherwise indicated.15
siveness, irritability, and mood lability. Deficits in The response rate to stimulants is in the range of
planning, delayed aversion, and temporal processing 70%. About one-third of patients have side effects,
are present. and approximately 15% have side effects severe
Risk factors include prematurity, prenatal com- enough to requiring changing or withdrawing the
plications, an anoxic event, nutritional deficits medication.16,17
(specifically iron and zinc), and lack of appropriate Stimulants are available in several delivery systems.
socialization.911 The disorder is heritable, which For the best effect, medications should be combined
is usually clear from the clinical interview. Rates of with behavioral management.
S4 C L E V E L A N D C L INI C J OURNAL OF ME DI CI NE VOLUME 82 SUPPLEMENT 1 NOV EMBER 2015
AUSTERMAN
TABLE 2 TABLE 3
ADHD comorbidities23,24 Summary of drug therapy options for ADHD
with comorbidities
Comorbidity Rates
Oppositional defiant disorder 54%67% ADHD + oppositional defiant disorder or conduct disorder
Conduct disorder 26% Stimulant or atomoxetine plus behavioral therapy
Mood disorders 20%30% Stimulants + behavioral therapy + alpha agonist
Substance abuse 12%24% Stimulants + behavioral therapy + second-generation antipsychotic
Anxiety disorders 10%40%
Tic disorders 18% ADHD + mood disorders
Bipolar disorder
Second-generation antipsychotic; then add stimulant
Atomoxetine, alpha agonist, or bupropion
Alternatives to stimulants Major depressive disorder
If stimulants are ineffective, atomoxetine can be used Bupropion; then add stimulant
to treat patients with inattention; however, its effect Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor + stimulant
on hyperactivity and impulsivity is less pronounced Cognitive behavior therapy + atomoxetine + alpha agonist
than that of stimulants. Bupropion is another option
for inattention. Both agents are well tolerated. Irrita- ADHD + substance abuse
bility and insomnia are side effects of atomoxetine,
Atomoxetine
and liver damage is possible, so liver function tests
Bupropion
must be ordered if the patient complains of upper-
right-quadrant pain. Alpha agonist
The evidence to support the use of modafinil is Stimulant difficult to abuse (eg, lisdexamfetamine)
equivocal.18,19 Unlike stimulants, modafinil is associ-
ated with a slight increase in motivation. ADHD + anxiety
Alpha-2 agonists are effective for treating aggres- Atomoxetine
sion in the setting of ADHD, especially in younger Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor + stimulant or alpha agonist
children, and are well tolerated.20 Extended-release + cognitive therapy
forms are available. Tricyclic antidepressants (for pediatric anxiety)
Combination therapy
ADHD + tics
Polypharmacy is sometimes indicated in the treat-
ment of ADHD. A stimulant used in combination Alpha-2 antagonists
with atomoxetine was shown to be superior to either Atomoxetine
treatment alone in improving symptoms of hyperac-
tivity and inattention.21 The combination, however,
markedly increased the incidence of appetite loss,
insomnia, and irritability. oping a treatment strategy. The following describes
A more promising combination is a stimulant with treatment options for the most common ADHD
an alpha agonist. Symptoms of hyperactivity and comorbidities (Table 3).
inattention were improved more with this combina- ODD or conduct disorder. The first-line therapy for
tion than with a stimulant plus placebo, with no dif- these patients is a stimulant plus behavioral therapy.
ference in side effects.22 Adding an alpha agonist to this combination may be
indicated if the comorbidity is severe. Second-gener-
ADHD with comorbidities ation antipsychotics also have been used as add-ons
Patients with ADHD, both adults and children, often to stimulants with behavioral therapy, but weight
have comorbid externalizing disorders and other gain and hormonal side effects are common.
emotional disorders, such as depression and anxiety, Behavioral interventions are effective in targeting
occurring in up to half of cases (Table 2).23,24 These disruptive behavioral disorders, specifically multi-
comorbidities are important to consider when devel- systemic therapy. Multisystemic therapy is intensive
CL E VE L AND CL I NI C J OURNAL OF MED IC INE VOLUME 82 SUPPLEMENT 1 NOV EMBER 2015 S5
ADHD AND BEHAVIORAL DISORDERS
therapy that involves working with the patients term reduction of core symptoms of ADHD.31,32 No
peer group or school, but most children must enter herbal remedy has demonstrated efficacy in improv-
the legal system to receive this intervention. Multi- ing ADHD symptoms. The use of omega-3 fatty acids
systemic therapy is the only intervention shown to as a complement to stimulants has demonstrated effi-
improve symptoms associated with comorbid ADHD cacy in reducing core symptoms in ADHD.33
and conduct disorder.25
Mood disorders. For these patients, the mood disor- Behavioral therapy
der is treated first. In doing so, symptoms of ADHD Several forms of behavioral therapy have shown
may disappear. For those with bipolar disease, a utility in improving symptoms in ADHD. Evidence
second-generation antipsychotic agent is superior to supports that ADHD responds to cognitive behav-
lithium in efficacy, maintenance of remission, and side ioral therapy.34 In-school neurofeedback training
effects in patients with a clear bipolar affective disor- for ADHD was shown to be better than cognitive
der, after which a stimulant can be added with less training in improving inattention and hyperactivity-
risk of developing manic symptoms. Using a stimulant impulsivity at 6 months of follow-up.35
first for this indication risks mood destabilization. Parental training has the most evidence to support
For patients with a major depressive disorder, its use in children with ADHD. The two most com-
bupropion can be used, although this indication is mon forms are Pathways Triple P (Positive Parenting
not FDA-approved, followed by the addition of a Program) and The Incredible Years. Triple P is an early
stimulant. One alternative is a selective serotonin intervention designed to promote positive parent-
reuptake inhibitor plus a stimulant; another is cog- child relationships to reduce behavior problems.36
nitive behavioral therapy plus atomoxetine and an The Incredible Years is a multicomponent program
alpha agonist. that emphasizes creating opportunities for active
Substance abuse. Patients with ADHD have high involvement, reinforcement of positive behavior,
rates of substance abuse.26,27 Whether treatment of teaching skills, and setting clear limits, all of which
ADHD with stimulants reduces the risk of substance are central to the social development strategy.37
abuse is controversial. Because abuse of stimulants is Many children with ADHD respond to in-school
common, start treatment with atomoxetine, bupro- interventions, at least an evaluation to rule out learn-
pion, an alpha agonist, or a stimulant that is difficult ing disorders, which typically have high morbidity.
to abuse (eg, lisdexamfetamine). Refer patients who Children may qualify for Individualized Education
are abusing substances to a specialist in substance Program (IEP) services, such as peer tutoring,38 com-
abuse for behavioral management. puter-assisted instruction,39,40 and task-modification
Anxiety. Atomoxetine is recommended for the instruction.41 All of these have evidence to support
treatment of anxiety that coexists with ADHD. A their use.
selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor in combina-
tion with a stimulant or alpha agonist, plus cognitive REFERENCES
behavioral therapy, is another option for treating 1. American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and Statistical
anxiety and ADHD. Tricyclic antidepressants have Manual of Mental Disorders. 5th ed. Arlington, VA: American
shown benefit in pediatric anxiety. Bupropion should Psychiatric Association; 2013.
2. Hak E, de Vries TW, Hoekstra PJ, Jick SS. Association of child-
not be used to target anxiety as it has been shown to hood attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder with atopic diseases
have a limited effect on anxiety. and skin infections? A matched case-control study using the Gen-
Tics. Stimulants may transiently exacerbate under- eral Practice Research Database. Ann Allergy Asthma Immunol
2013; 111:102106.
lying tic disorders, but no longstanding difference 3. Pretorius E. Corticosteroids, depression and the role of serotonin.
in the course of tics has been observed with stimu- Rev Neurosci 2004; 15:109116.
lant use.28 Alpha-2 antagonists target both tics and 4. Keenan HT, Hall GC, Marshall SW. Early head injury and atten-
tion deficit hyperactivity disorder: retrospective cohort study. BMJ
ADHD, so their use is preferred.29 Atomoxetine does 2008; 337:a1984.
not exacerbate tics but may reduce their frequency 5. Applegate B, Lahey BB, Hart EL, et al. Validity of the age-of-onset
and severity.30 criterion for ADHD: a report of the DSM-IV field trials. J Am Acad
Child Adolesc Psychiatry 1997; 36:12111221.
6. Loeber R, Green SM, Lahey BB, Christ MAG, Frick PJ. Devel-
Dietary factors opmental sequences in the age of onset of disruptive child behav-
Although challenging to accomplish, management iors. J Child Fam Studies 1992; 1:2141.
of diet, specifically removal of artificial food coloring 7. Barkley RA, Murphy KR, Fischer M. Adult ADHD: What the
Science Says. New York, NY: Guilford Publications; 2008.
and sodium benzoate preservatives, has been more 8. Rasmussen P, Gillberg C. Natural outcome of ADHD with
efficacious than behavioral management in the long- developmental coordination disorder at age 22 years: a controlled,