Bowman - Vicente Pazos and The Amelia Island Affair, 1817

Vicente Pazos and the Amelia Island Affair, 1817
Author(s): Charles H. Bowman Jr.

Source: The Florida Historical Quarterly, Vol. 53, No. 3 (Jan., 1975), pp. 273-295
Published by: Florida Historical Society
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/30145960 .
Accessed: 17/06/2014 22:28
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Florida Historical Society is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The Florida
Historical Quarterly.
http://www.jstor.org
This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
VICENTE PAZOS AND THE
AMELIA ISLAND AFFAIR, 1817
by CHARLES H. BOWMAN, JR.*
MAY 9, 1817, seven distinguished patriots from Buenos

ON Aires arrived at Savannah on board the English cutter Hero.
The number included Vicente Pazos, editor of La Crdnica Argen-
tina.' Their departure from the Rio de la Plata had helped rid
Supreme Director Juan Martin de Pueyrred6n of his most viru-
lent detractors. Born in the province of Larecaja in Upper Peru
in 1779, Pazos was descended from the Aymarai Indians who re-
sided around Lake Titicaca.2 After attending the Royal and
Pontifical University of San Antonio de Abad in Cuzco where he
received his doctorate in sacred theology in 1804, Pazos taught
the Quechua language for a time at this institution.3 He later
moved to Chuquisaca and Potosi. He was living in Buenos Aires
in 1810, where, with the help of Mariano Moreno, he launched
his career in journalism. An alert mind and a facile pen won for
Pazos a large following as the editor, in turn, of the Gazeta de
Buenos-Ayres, El Censor, and La Cr6nica Argentina. Although
Pazos stoutly committed himself to the independence cause in
Buenos Aires, he did not always approve of the methods and
objectives of the different revolutionary governments. It was his
editorial lambasting of Pueyrred6n that resulted in his exile in
1817.4
*Mr. Bowman is assistant professor of history, Fayetteville State Uni-

versity, Fayetteville, North Carolina.
1. The Hero's voyage from the Rio de la Plata had taken fifty-seven days.
Baltimore Patriot and Mercantile Advertiser, May 29, 1817; Savannah
Republican, May 10, 1817; [Buenos Aires] Museo Mitre, Documentos del
Archivo de Pueyrreddn, 4 vols. (Buenos Aires, 1912), III, 273-74, 277-78.
2. Arturo Costa de la Torre, Catdlogo de la Bibliografia Boliviana, Libros
y Folletos, 1900-1963 (La Paz, 1966 [1968]), 815; William Bollaert, "Ob-
servations on the History of the Incas of Peru, on the Indians of South
Peru, and on Some of the Indian Remains in the Province of Tarapaca,"
Journal of the Ethnological Society of London, III (1854), 143.
3. Costa de la Torre, Catdlogo de la Bibliografia Boliviana, 815; Pazos to
Joseph Tarn, July 27, 1829, "Foreign Correspondence Inwards, 1829,"
III, 23, Archives of the British and Foreign Bible Society, London.
4. Gabriel Ren6-Moreno, Biblioteca Boliviana; Catdlogo de la Seccidn de
Libros i Folletos (Santiago, 1879), 3-4; Baltimore Patriot and Mercantile
Advertiser, May 29, 1817; La Paz Presencia, November 4, 1973.
[273]

274 FLORIDA HISTORICAL QUARTERLY
Pazos and his compatriots did not remain long in Savannah

after their arrival. By May 29 they journeyed to Baltimore.,
There they found "a respectable merchant" and former traveler
in South America who put them in touch with others who were
"as sensible and generous as himself."8 These included John
Purviance, an attorney, John Stuart Skinner, the postmaster, and
Henry Didier and John Laborde, both merchants.7
The summer of 1817 was an unhealthy season in Baltimore.8
By the middle of July, Pazos had joined a contingent of Spanish
Americans in Philadelphia, which since 1796 had been the home
of Manuel Torres of New Granada, an influential patriot leader.9
He would become the first minister from Latin America received
in Washington, and he had important social, political, and busi-
ness connections.10 Pedro Gual, Jose Rafael Revenga, and Juan
Germin Roscio-all Venezuelans-were other patriot figures
in Philadelphia that summer.1' On July 8 William Thornton,
head of the Patent Office in Washington and a supporter of inde-
pendence for Spanish America, instructed Gual to convey his
best respects "to the brave patriots who are assembled with you
in Philad[elphi]a." Like Pazos's acquaintances in Baltimore,
Thornton wished to serve the Spanish Americans "collectively
5. Baltimore Patriot and Mercantile Advertiser, May 29, 1817.

6. Ibid., July 10, 1817.
7. Charles C. Griffin, "Privateering from Baltimore during the Spanish
American Wars of Independence," Maryland Historical Magazine, XXXV
(March 1940), 21; Miguel Varas ValAsquez, Don Josd Miguel Carrera en
Estados Unidos (Santiago, 1912), 42.
8. Heavy floods and much sickness compelled many people to leave the city
for as long as possible. Luis de Onis to Jos6 Pizarro, August 24, 1817,
Secci6n de Estado, Legajo 5642, Letter 132, pp. 525-27, Archivo Hist6rico
Nacional, Madrid, photocopies in Manuscript Division, Library of Con-
gress, Washington, D. C. Hereinafter cited as SE:AHN.
9. Onis to Pizarro, July 18, 1817, Letter 119, pp. 473-74, ibid.; Baltimore
Patriot and Mercantile Advertiser, July 10, 1817.
10. Newspaper editor William Duane, who was closer to Torres than per-
haps anyone else, summed up his friend's attainments: "Mr. Torres has
resided several years in this city [Philadelphia], retired and unassuming,
but by all who know him, as much admired for his uncommon acquire-
ments and knowledge, as esteemed for the purity of his principles, moral
and political." Philadelphia Aurora and General Advertiser, March 26,
April 17, 1818. See also, Charles H. Bowman, Jr., "Manuel Torres, A
Spanish American Patriot in Philadelphia, 1796-1822," Pennsylvania
Magazine of History and Biography, XCIV (January 1970), 26-53.
11. Jos6 Rafael Revenga to William Thornton, June 20, 1817, Papers of
William Thornton, V, 775-76, Manuscript Division, Library of Congress;
Thornton to Pedro Gual, July 8, 1817, ibid., V, 779-81, 785. Hereinafter
cited as WTP.

AMELIA ISLAND AFFAIR, 1817 275
and individually."12"Friends"with whom Pazoseventually came
in touch included CommodoreDavid Porter, Philadelphia fin-
ancier Stephen Girard, John Jacob Astor, and New York pol-
itician DeWitt Clinton.13
The main topic for discussionat the moment in Philadelphia
centeredon the filibusteringexpeditions againstSpanish territory
sailing, or about to sail, from American ports. In 1816 Louis
Aury founded his own governmentat Galveston and set up an
admiralty court to condemn captured vessels. Although this ac-
tion had been taken purportedlyin the name of Mexico, it was
obvious that the main purpose of the enterprisewas to capture
Spanish vessels and property.There was little desire to aid the
revolution in Mexico or in any other Spanish colony. In April
1817, Aury left Galveston for Matagorda,which he held for
about two months.14The principal backers of his undertaking
had also begun as early as the summerof 1816 to formulateplans
for an assault on the Floridas. Accordingto Pazos, even the lib-
eral FranciscoXavier Mina of Spain and Jose Alvarezde Toledo
of Cubawere cooperatingat one point in Baltimoreon a Florida
adventure.15The exasperatingcircumstancesin Venezuelaheight-
ened the urgency of such a move: "The horrors which the
sanguinarySpanishgeneralsBoves, Morales,and Morillo, caused
their regimentsof black slaves,to commit against the inhabitants
of Venezuela,in order to destroythem entirely, obliged many of
them to take refuge in Carthagena[sic], from whence famine and
sickness soon compelled the constituted authorities to depart,
with 3000 of its inhabitants, of all ages and sexes. Some sought
asylum in the West Indies and the United States. . . . These
fugitives, full of the love of liberty, and inspired with that
12. Thornton to Gual, July 8, 1817, V, 779-81, ibid.

13. Charles Carroll Griffin, Ensayos sobre historia de Amdrica (Caracas, 1969),
153-54.
14. Eugene R. Craine, The United States and the Independence of Buenos
Aires (Hays, Kansas, 1961), 98-99.
15. Thornton to Jos6 Alvarez de Toledo, July 24, 1816, WTP, IV, 732-33.
Not all scholars accept Pazos's account of the cooperation between Mina
and Toledo. See Joseph B. Lockey, "The Florida Intrigues of Jos6
Alvarez de Toledo," Florida Historical Quarterly, XII (April 1934), 163;
A. Curtis Wilgus, "Spanish American Patriot Activity Along the Gulf
Coast of the United States, 1811-1822," Louisiana Historical Quarterly,
VIII (April 1925), 205n; Harris Gaylord Warren, "The Origin of Gen-
eral Mina's Invasion of Mexico," Southwestern Historical Quarterly,
XLII (July 1938), 16-17.

intrepid resolution, so often the effect of adversity upon virtuous

minds, formed the project of wresting from the hands of their
enemies the provinces of the Floridas, which presented con-
siderable resources to sustain the cause of independence, and an
asylum to the unfortunate emigrants of Venezuela and New-
Grenada [sic], who were perishing with hunger in the West
Indies, during the month of August, 1816."16
Mina arrived in Port-au-Prince from Baltimore in September
1816 and met numerous refugees. He and Toledo were jointly to
command an expedition to Florida. The plan, however, was un-
done by man and nature. A hurricane badly damaged Mina's
fleet, and Toledo unexpectedly defected to the Spaniards. He
turned over to Luis de Onis, Spanish minister to the United
States, reports of the Florida scheme, which of course then had
to be abandoned.17 Mina, for his part, sailed away to meet Aury
at Galveston. Pazos was positive that Toledo's information had
prompted Onis to protest to Secretary of State John Quincy
Adams about the "mischiefs" stemming from the toleration of
the arming of privateers in the ports of the United States. Adams
informed the chairman of the house committee on foreign af-
fairs of the desirability of new and better neutrality legislation.
The law enacted by Congress on March 3, 1817, was proof
enough for Pazos "that the Spanish minister had been successful
in the use to which he had converted the revelations which
Toledo made." It was soon learned by Gual and his associates
that Onis's secretary was about to leave for Madrid carrying with
him the latest correspondence between the minister and Adams
on the subject of the Floridas. These developments, in Pazos's
opinion, boded no good: "The South American agents, residing
then in Philadelphia, must have been very indifferent to their
duty, if they did not perceive, that the law of the 3d of March,
and the representations of the Spanish minister to his court,
would, in reality, or in appearance, induce the consent of the
16. In December 1815, Aury broke the Spanish blockade of Cartagena and
rescued the three thousand persons, whom he carried away to safety.
Vicente Pazos Kanki, The Exposition, Remonstrance and Protest of Don
Vincente Pazos, Commissioner on Behalf of the Republican Agents Estab-
lished at Amelia Island, in Florida, under the Authority and in Behalf
of the Independent States of South America; with an Appendix (Phila-
delphia, 1818), 10-11.
17. Wilgus, "Spanish American Patriot Activity," 205n.

AMELIAISLANDAFFAIR, 1817 277
Spanish government to negociate [sic] for the sale or cession of
the Floridas. Anticipating the injury which such a negociation
[sic] would inflict on the cause of their independence, they were
obliged to precipitate their measures, and make the most of the
time left them."'8
On March 31 the Scottish adventurer Gregor MacGregor,
who had served with the patriots in Venezuela, received a com-
mission in Philadelphia from "The deputies of free America,
resident in the United States of the North." These deputies were
Lino de Clemente, who acted for Venezuela; Gual, for New
Granada and by proxy for Mexico; and Martin Thompson, for
the United Provinces of South America. MacGregor was to take
both East and West Florida in the name of the governments
granting him authority. He was first to occupy Amelia Island
and then move into the Floridas proper.'9 Pazos claimed that the
aim of the patriots was to conquer the territory and cede it to
the United States after it had served its purpose as a depot for
supplies for the Spanish Americans. MacGregor himself con-
firmed Pazos's contention of an intended transfer, but added that
there would be a price tag for the Floridas amounting to $1,500,-
000.20
MacGregor was raising his force just at the time Pazos reached
the United States. He recruited men and solicited funds in sev-
eral Atlantic ports-notably Baltimore, Charleston, and Savannah
-and purchased a schooner at Charleston. Following a hasty
capitulation by the Spaniards, MacGregor and his fifty-five men
took control of poorly defended Amelia Island and Fernandina
18. Pazos Kanki, Exposition, 12; Onis to the Secretary of State, January 2,
1817, American State Papers, Class I, Foreign Relations, 4: 184-85; Phila-
delphia Aurora and General Advertiser, January 5, 1818.
19. T. Frederick Davis, MacGregor's Invasion of Florida, 1817, Together with
An Account of His Successors, Irwin, Hubbard and Aury, on Amelia
Island, East Florida (Jacksonville, 1928), 7-8. Amelia Island was the
northeasternmost tip of Spanish East Florida. It is located near the
mouth of the St. Marys River, which forms the boundary at that point
between Florida and Georgia.
20. [Vicente Pazos Kanki], "Memorial of Vicente Pazos," Niles' Weekly Reg-
ister, April 11, 1818; J. Skinner to John Quincy Adams, July 30, 1817,
"Letters Relating to MacGregor's Attempted Conquest of East Florida,
1817," Florida Historical Quarterly, V (July 1926), 55-56; Charles Francis
Adams, ed., Memoirs of John Quincy Adams, Comprising Portions of
His Diary from 1795 to 1848, 12 vols. (Philadelphia, 1874-1877), IV, 53;
Thornton to Adams, February 9, 1818, WTP, V, 799.

on June 29.21 Disorder quickly ensued and prevailed there for

some time. Pazos blamed the confusion not on the men associated
with MacGregor, but on "the machinations and desperate views
of a few individuals, who, destitute alike of means and morals
. . . presented themselves at Amelia . . . after it had been cap-
tured." These troublemakers soon subverted the "military dis-
cipline and the public peace," as a consequence of which Mac-
Gregor departed from the island for the nearby Georgia town of
St. Marys on September 5. Ruggles Hubbard, former high sheriff
of New York City, and Jared Irwin, a former congressman from
Pennsylvania, then emerged as temporary leaders of the inde-
pendent government.22
Rumor had it that the fundamental reason for MacGregor's
withdrawal from the island was his disappointment in the prom-
ises of men, money, and munitions made to him by several in-
dividuals in the United States, particularly in New York City.23
On September 15 Aury appeared on the scene at the urging of
Gual in Philadelphia. The next day MacGregor sailed out to the
mouth of the St. Marys River to recount the story of his recent
failure on Amelia Island, but Aury was determined to move on
the place himself. MacGregor gave him complete authority to do
so. Conditions had certainly deteriorated there with Hubbard as
civil governor. Fernandina was, Pazos pointedly commented,
closely beseiged by a Spanish force from St. Augustine and on the
verge of surrender. Aury saved the day. The Spaniards were de-
feated and repulsed by the patriots, and the island was pacified.
Hubbard, who had taken refuge at St. Marys during the fighting,
returned to Fernandina to resume his post as civil governor,
while Aury took over as head of the land and naval forces. The
two men had what Gual termed a "mercantile arrangement."
Aury made a verbal promise to invest $60,000 in cash
brought with him "in the objects of possessing the Floridas;"
21. Pazos Kanki, Exposition, 13; Savannah Republican, June 5, July 10, 1817.
An anonymous friend of Pazos said that MacGregor's security given for
the financial aid advanced him was thirty thousand acres of Florida land.
Narrative of a Voyage to the Spanish Main, in the Ship "Two Friends;"
the occupation of Amelia Island, by M'Gregor, &c.-Sketches of the Prov-
ince of East Florida (London, 1819), 85-86.
22. Pazos Kanki, Exposition, 13-14; Davis, MacGregor's Invasion, 65; Daily
National Intelligencer, September 13, 26, 1817; Charleston Courier, Sep-
tember 30, 1817.
23. Philadelphia Aurora and General Advertiser, December 4, 1817.

Hubbard agreed to devote "the immense resources within his
reach" to the same end. Both men, it seems, expected to govern.
Aury first hoisted the Mexican flag over Amelia Island; it was his
original intention to annex the Floridas to Mexico. He also en-
deavored to provide an efficient administration, for which a
council of eight members had already been created. Hubbard,
not satisfied with his limited authority, contrived with others to
drive Aury off the island and to appropriate all his vessels and
prizes.24
In Philadelphia Gual, who had met Aury earlier in Cartagena,
had in mind to liberate Mexico preliminary to definitive patriot
victories in South America. On July 23 he related to Thornton
the significance of the Floridas to the patriot cause: "The estab-
lishment of a republic in [the] Floridas claims the attention and
support of all true friends of South America .... The influence
of the emancipation of [the] Floridas on that of Mexico, New-
Granada, Venezuela, Buenos Ayres, Chile, and Peru, is of more
magnitude than it is generaly [sic] imagined, even by the best
informed."
Pazos's correspondents in London were forwarding a compre-
hensive plan in accordance with English merchants interested in
the trade of the emerging Spanish American nations. There
was no strong squadron in the Caribbean to complete the plan,
yet Aury had such a force under his command. The Floridas
were certainly looked upon as "an integral part of the great
Empire, which is in a state of revolution." Such a concept was,
opined Thornton, "in perfect consonance with the ideas of the
most enlightened patriots, whose views are not bounded by the
narrow policy of individual regions."25
Gual and Pazos set out together for Amelia Island with their
intelligence, expecting to arrive before Aury. They failed in this,
however. In mid-August 1817, the two appeared in New York
City to await passage southward, and while there they had an
24. Ibid., October 28, 1817; Pazos Kanki, Exposition, 14-15; Daily National
Intelligencer, October 4, 1817; James Forbes to John Quincy Adams,
April 22, 1818, State Department, Miscellaneous Letters, pp. H-J, Na-
tional Archives, Washington, D.C. Hereinafter cited as NA.
25. Thornton to Adams, February 9, 1818, WTP, V, 799; Gual to Thornton,
July 23, 1817, ibid., V, 783-84; Stanley Faye, "Commodore Aury," Louisi-
ana Historical Quarterly, XXIV (July 1941), 646.

opportunity to talk with various merchants and with Baptis

Irvine, editor of the New-York Columbian, about their project.26
The ship on which Pazos and Gual were to sail was a Vene-
zuelan privateer, Amdrica Libre, whose captain was Bernardo
Ferrero. It reached New York from Norfolk on September 5 for
the purpose of taking on men and supplies "in order to commit
hostilities against the subjects and possessions of the king of
Spain." Irvine at once hailed "the appearance of the free (S.)
American flag in our waters." The better to enlist men, an offer
was made by the ship's officers of clothing and $8.00 a month,
together with an advance of $10.00 or $12.00. On reaching Amelia
Island, the men were to be allowed the alternative of serving
either in the army or in the patriot naval force.27
The crew aboard the America Libre proved to be a rowdy
lot. On September 7 a number of them landed on Staten Island,
and in a fracas with the inhabitants threatened to burn down a
house. Perhaps their rambunctiousness arose from the fact that
their ship had to lie at the quarantine ground for nearly two
weeks before it could sail. When the America Libre did sally
forth, it mounted three carriage guns and carried a crew of
seventy-four men and a supply of small arms. On board also were
a number of European officers-chiefly Augustin Codazzi, Augusto
Gustavo Villaret, and Maurice Persat-Pazos, Gual, and 130
other men bound for Amelia Island.28 The ship weighed anchor
on the morning of September 18, and twelve days later it reached
the Charleston Roads. "She sails again, first fair wind," the
Charleston Courier laconically announced.29
26. Juan Canter, "El Aflo XII, Las Asambleas Generales y la Revoluci6n del
8 de Octubre," in Ricardo Levene, ed., Historia de la Naci6n Argentina
(Desde los Origenes hasta la Organizacidn Definitiva en 1862), 10 vols.
(Buenos Aires, 1936-1942), V, Sec. 2, 750n.
27. Thomas Stoughton to Jonathan Fisk, September 16, 1817, Legajo 5642,
Letter 191, pp. 800-01, SE:AHN; New-York Evening Post, September 6,
1817; New-York Columbian, September 6, 1817. Ferrero had commanded
a schooner in Sim6n Bolivar's expedition of March 1816 from Aux Cayes.
Gustave Schlumberger, ed., Mdmoires du Commandant Persat, 1806 a
1844 (Paris, 1910), 22.
28. John Kerney to Samuel Evans, September 8, 1817, in Philadelphia Aurora
and General Advertiser, January 1, 1818; Deposition of John Reilley,
September 17, 1817, Legajo 5642, Letter 191, pp. 804-05, SE:AHN; Adams,
Memoirs, IV, 75; Herman Albert Shumacher, "Biograffa del General
Agustin Codazzi," Boletin de historia y antigiiedades, IX (June 1913), 8;
Schlumberger, Mdmoires, 26.
29. Gual to Thornton, September 17, 1817, WTP, V, 786; Charleston Courier,
October 1, 1817.

As the ship was riding out a storm, Pazos, Gual, Ferrero, Per-
sat, and several others went ashore and took lodgings at the
hotel of a French royalist named Picault. That night after dinner
the captain, his tongue loosened by wine, proposed a toast to the
health of Napoleon. All his listeners rose to their feet except
Picault, who exclaimed to the gathering: "I do not drink to the
health of tyrants!" The enraged Ferrero jumped at the throat of
the bold royalist and held it so tightly that the poor man lost
consciousness. Pazos and his companions were finally able to pull
Ferrero away and to restore a measure of harmony.80
While in Charleston the travelers learned that Aury had re-
placed MacGregor on Amelia Island. The day before their ship
sailed again, eight men and a boy who had boarded the America
Libre at New York had second thoughts about venturing farther
and had to be taken to land by the revenue schooner Gallatin.
On the morning of October 3, the A mdrica Libre sailed for Amelia
Island. As the voyage from Charleston to Fernandina took only
one day, the ship made port on October 4.31
The passengers landed to find Aury still military governor
and naval commander, while Hubbard held sway as civil gov-
ernor. But Hubbard and his "American party" had been busily
preparing for a showdown by bribing officers and sailors and
secretly shifting powder and munitions from the public magazine
to their own houses. After the arrival of the Amdrica Libre, Aury
replaced Hubbard with Gual as civil governor. The land force
on the island then stood at about 150 men. There were some 250
sailors in Fernandina belonging to five armed vessels, including
two government ships. There were also three large prize ships in
port loaded with sugar and coffee. They had already been con-
demned in Aury's admiralty court, and their cargoes were to be
sold shortly. The health conditions on the island, however, left
much to be desired; five or six men were dying daily of fever.32
To make matters worse, Hubbard and his men "took up arms
to commence a civil war, which must have cost much blood."
However Aury acted with his numerical superiority and "with his
30. Schlumberger, Mdmoires, 24-26.

31. Charleston Courier, October 4, 1817.
32. Ibid., October 31, 1817; Philadelphia Aurora and General Advertiser,
October 28, 1817; Harold Alfred Bierck, Jr., Vida pzblica de Don Pedro
Gual (Caracas, 1947), 149.

282 FLORIDAHISTORICALQUARTERLY
accustomedpresence of mind, and by dint of strong and well

conceived measures,arrested the sedition." His "French party"
led by Codazzisoon triumphed,martial law was temporarilypro-
claimed, and Hubbard stood accusedof treason, cowardice,and
conspiring with the Spaniards.Shortly after he "retired,"Hub-
bard succumbedto the ravaging fever from which he died on
October 19. Pazos describedhis end in almost poetic terms: "he
survivedhis shamebut a few days, and died of a broken heart in
the agonies producedby his guilt."
But all of Aury's troubles did not cease with the demise of
Hubbard.He had a new antagonistin the personof Jared Irwin,
and there was ominous quarrelingbetween their supporters.The
enforcement of new laws, however, finally enabled Aury "to
eradicate disorder, and afforded,by that means, leisure for the
establishmentof a provincialgovernment,which,"as far as Pazos
was concerned,"might be held up as a model to others of the
new states."33
In the making of this exemplary government, Pazos had a
considerable share of responsibility. Since Aury was quite il-
literate, his proclamationswere mainly composed by Pazos and
Gual. Pazos was given a seat on the "SupremeCouncil of the
Floridas,"a body which helped Aury in the administrationof
Amelia Island. One of its first taskswas the drafting on October
8 of a proclamationadvising the inhabitantsof the island of the
penalties for persuadingany slave to run away from the United
States "or any other place whatsoever."Every slave "taken up"
was to be held in jail until claimed by his owner, and any slave
going to Fernandinafor employmenthad to have a written per-
mit. The next day the council addresseditself to the question of
the designation of bounty lands for those men who might vol-
unteer for the conquestof St. Augustine.It was decided that time
of servicewould run from six to twelve months; the amount of
land to be grantedranged from 320 acres for a private who vol-
unteered for six months to 10,000 acres for a brigadier general
serving the same period. Each volunteer would automatically
receive a bonus of an additional 160 acres.On October 14 Aury
issued a proclamationhighlighting the weatheringof the recent
turmoil. It was so reminiscentof the style of Pazos'swriting that
33. Pazos Kanki, Exposition, 15-16; CharlestonCourier, October 27, Novem-
ber 7, 1817;Niles' WeeklyRegister, November1, 8, 1817.

only he could have been its author: "A horrid plot had threat-
ened to ruin in its infancy, our rising republic. Discord, ever
ready to spread its baneful alarms, had put us on the brink of
civil war; fortunately, we still preservedamong us, respect for
liberty and the cause we defend. We have discoveredthe secret
machination of a depotic [sic] government,and we have saved
ourselvesfrom ruin, into which Spanish perfidy was on the eve
of plunging us."'4
The population of Fernandinawas alwaysmotley, a situation
not conducive to the maintenanceof law and order.At the time
Aury was taking over there, a North American observer char-
acterizedthe patriotson Amelia Island as "a most heterogeneous
set, consisting of all countries and languages, except Spanish
Americans."Among the group were North Americans,French,
Irish, Scots, English, Dutch, Germans,Haitians, and of course
Pazos, an Indian from Upper Peru. All came ostensibly "to aid
the cause of the patriots of South America,but," alleged the ob-
server,"theirreal motive is, no doubt, to prey upon whom they
can." Privateeringhad become big business on the island, with
property taken from Spanish vessels in one instance amounting
to $100,000.Aury, who styled himself "Brigadierof the Mexican
Republic and Generalissimoof the Floridas,"freely granted com-
missionsto privateerswhich, in the opinion of the United States
SupremeCourt, did not exempt the granteesfrom the charge of
piracy.35
On November 1 a correspondentin St. Marysreported that a
host of English officers,attracted by the supreme council's gen-
erous offer of bounty lands, had arrived at Amelia Island and
that it was supposedthat "the greatestpart of Gen. Auray's[sic]
cavalcade will go away southwardly."36No movement against
34. Rufus Kay Wyllys, "The Filibusters of Amelia Island," Georgia His-
torical Quarterly, XII (December 1928), 312; Charleston Courier, October
24, November7, 1817.
35. The technicality used by the Supreme Court to justify its decision was
that Mexico did not figure among those Spanish provinces "in actual
revolt, nor was any such State de facto known to exist as the Mexican
republic," under the authority of which the commissions were issued.
James Brown Scott, ed., Prize Cases Decided in the United States Su-
preme Court, 1789-1918, 3 vols. (Oxford, 1923), II, 1080-81; Thomas
Wayne to Benjamin Homans, September17, 1817,in Philadelphia Aurora
and General Advertiser, January 2, 1818; American State Papers, Class I,
Foreign Relations, 4: 535-36.
36. Charleston Courier, November 28, 1817.

St. Augustine ever materialized for two reasons: Aury was too
preoccupied with firming up his position in Fernandina, and he
was distracted by disputes with American authorities over the
privateers and prizes entering and leaving his bailiwick.
Aury again declared martial law November 5, this time for
ten days. His proclamation to the people of Amelia Island once
more bore traces of Pazos's hand: "For days past you have
witnessed the scandalous transactions of a fraction, composed
of men, who existing and tolerated on this Island by our
generosity, have solely been engaged in subverting social order.
They are mercenaries, traitors or cowards, who abandoned the
cause of Republicanism in the hour of danger, and who either
hired by our enemies or misled by the intrigues of a few aspiring
individuals, have attempted to involve us in all the complicated
horrors of a civil war. Citizens, we are Republicans from
principle, our fortunes have been spent, and our lives oft ex-
posed for this most glorious cause. We have come here to plant
the tree of liberty, to foster free institutions, and to wage war
against the tyrant of Spain, the oppressor of America, and the
enemy of the rights of man. AWe are every ready to pay
obedience to the principles of Republicanism, but firmly deter-
mined never to adhere to the dictates of a faction." As soon as
"public peace and tranquilty" had been restored, Aury promised
the establishment of a provisional government "most suitable
to our common interest, and to the advancement of our glorious
cause.""37Difficulties with the United States navy began during
this time when martial law was imposed.
The slave schooner Tentativa, prize to the Mexican privateer
Brutus, was being brought into Fernandina on November 8 by
John Austin, prizemaster, when a boat from the American brig
Saranac came alongside and an officer asked to be allowed to
come aboard. Austin threatened to fire on the vessel if any at-
tempt was made to board the Tentativa. Muskets were discharged
under his stern, whereupon the schooner fired back and then
hastened into port.
John H. Elton was captain of the Saranac and the man re-
sponsible for patrolling the waters around St. Marys to keep out
contraband. On November 9 he wrote Aury a note demanding
37. Ibid., November 14, 1817.

that Austin be made to answer "for the insult according to the
laws of the United States." Meanwhile, all ships coming into and
going out of Fernandina would be stopped. Aury immediately
replied that an investigation of the conduct of the prizemaster
would be made and that if guilty he would be severely pun-
ished.38 Later, on November 9, a court of inquiry, of which Pazos
was a member, heard testimony from Austin, corroborated by two
other men from the Tentativa, to the effect that the ship was in
"Spanish waters" at the time the attempt to board her took place.
Indeed, the Tentativa was only 150 feet off the shore of Amelia
Island. The merit of his case aside, Aury realized that he had his
hands full retaining control of Fernandina without taking on the
United States navy. In an effort "to avoid all difficulties for the
present," he consented to give the vessel up to Elton, hoping that
the government of the United States "will do us the justice which
becomes a free and great people."39 Gual and Pazos were behind
Aury in this conciliatory gesture, but Elton was far from placated.
On November 15 he wrote for the secretary of the navy in Wash-
ington a summary of these latest developments: "The slave vessel
was brought over last night, but every thing but slaves, and a
small quantity of rice, was taken from her, and she appeared in a
filthy state. The prizemaster was not sent, neither [were] any of
the prize crew .... I shall send the slave vessel to Savannah for
adjudication, and if the slave master is found, shall send him
also."40The controversy dragged on until the admirality court in
Savannah months later "decided against the schooner Tentativa's
being a good prize to the Brutus privateer."41
38. John H. Elton to Benjamin W. Crowninshield, November 15, 1817, in

Philadelphia Aurora and General Advertiser, January 1, 1818; Elton to
Louis Aury, November 9, 1817, State Papers and Publick Documents of
the United States, from the Accession of George Washington to the
Presidency, Exhibiting a Complete View of Our Foreign Relations since
that Time, 3rd ed., 12 vols. (Boston, 1819), XII, 431; Aury to Elton,
November 9, 1817, ibid.
39. Depositions of John Austin, Charles Johnson, and John W. Johnson,
November 9, 1817, in Philadelphia Aurora and General Advertiser,
January 7, 1818; Aury to Elton, November 13, 1817, State Papers and
Publick Documents, XII, 432-33.
40. Elton to Crowninshield, November 15, 1817, in Philadelphia Aurora and
General Advertiser, January 1, 1818.
41. The Tentativa reached Savannah on November 19 with 128 slaves on
board. It was there libeled by "the proctor for the captors," and the
slaves, by order of the court, were delivered over to the proctor and the
customs collector "to be taken care of by them until demanded by the
competent authority." A. S. Bullock to William H. Crawford, November

Pazos'slegalisticflair also came in handy for Aury outside the

courtroom.Gual and Pazos appearedin Fernandinawith a plan
of governmentfor the Floridas.They arguedthat as the territory
had once been a dependencyof Mexico "and continuesthus until
this momentwith regardto taxes,"no other flagbut the Mexican
ought to be recognizedthere until it had been declaredan inde-
pendent state. Independencewould come when a majorityof the
inhabitants had been freed from Spanish authority.As an inde-
pendent state the Floridas would be recognizedas part of the
confederation of South America, but such recognition did not
preclude the right of the people to join the confederationof the
north, should the United Statesdesireto annex the territory.The
possessionof the Floridasby the patriotswould be advantageous
to their northern neighborsbecause they would try harder than
the Spaniards to curb the depredations of the Indians, "very
probably... incited by some foreign agent on the frontier."Care
ought to be taken to choose capable persons to run the govern-
ment. They should, however, consider their jobs only as pro-
visional until there had been established "an order of things."
Whoeverthe officialswere, they had the obligationof establishing
the basis for a republicanconstitution.Pazosand Gual made pro-
visions in their plan for executive, legislative, and judicial
branches of the government and for a military and fiscal ad-
ministration.42
In keeping with this plan and with the promisehe had made
on November 5, Aury took steps toward the organizationof a
provisional government, apparently foresaking his idea of an-
nexing Floridato Mexico. On November16, the day after martial
law ended, he called together at his house in Fernandinathe of-
ficersof "the republic of [the] Floridas."Tranquility, Aury told
the gathering,had been restored,and the time had come to al-
25, 1817, Correspondence of the Secretary of the Treasury with Collectors

of Customs, 1789-1833: Letters to and from the Collectors at St. Marks
and St. Johns, Florida; St. Marys, Brunswick, and Savannah, Georgia;
Ocracoke and Plymouth, North Carolina; Yorktown, Virginia, II, 179,
NA; Charleston Courier, November 22, 1817; Philadelphia Aurora and
General Advertiser, March 20, 1818.
42. "Plan para lanzar por fuerza armada al Gobierno espafiol de las Floridas,
puesto en ejecuci6n y principiado por la isla de Amelia en el afio de
1817," in Francisco Jose Urrutia, Los Estados Unidos de Amdrica y las
Reptipublicas Hispano-Americanas de 1810 a 1830; Pdginas de Historia
Diplomdtica (Madrid, 1918), 134, 136-38; Philadelphia Aurora and Gen-
eral Advertiser, December 9, 12, 15, 1817.

low "the citizenspeaceablyto elect their representatives."He sug-
gestedthat an assemblyof representativesbe called "to frameand
constitutea provisionalgovernmentadapted to the present situa-
tion of the state."
The men at the meeting, Pazosamong them, took the subject
under advisementand unanimouslyadopted six resolutions: (1)
on November 19-20, the inhabitants of Amelia Island were to
elect representatives"to frame and constitute a provisional gov-
ernment"until a constitution could be drafted; (2) every free
civilian inhabitant residing on the island since November 4
would be eligible to vote, provided he would take an oath sup-
porting the cause of the Republic; (3) no military person on
active duty would be entitled to vote, but he could be elected as
a representative;(4) nine representativeswere to be elected, and
each voter had to give in writing the names of the nine for whom
he voted to the officersto be appointed for that purpose; (5)
everyfree personwho intended to vote had to call before election
time at the treasuryofficeon WashingtonSquareto take and sub-
scribe the oath to be administeredby M. Walsh and Pazos; (6)
the polls would be open from twelve o'clock noon to sunset on
November19 and from sunriseto sunset the following day.43
Pazosand Walsh administeredthe oath to over 150 men who
selectedthe nine representativesfrom a field of twenty-twocandi-
dates. Gual, with 151 votes, and Pazos, with 150, led the race.
The other winners were J. Murden, a South Carolinian, 148;
Louis Comte, a native of Baltimore and son of an Smigrdfrom
Saint-Domingue,148; Jared Irwin, 113; one Lavignac,a French-
man and formerresidentof Baltimore,112;JamesForbes,brother
of the North Americanconsul in Copenhagen,111; one Mabrity,
a "SpanishSouth America,"107; and one Chapelle,an American
from Connecticut, 101. The "Frenchparty" of Gual and Pazos
counted a majorityof one over the "Americanparty"among the
representatives.On November 27 Aury confirmedthose elected
and set December 1 as the date for the first meeting of the as-
sembly. Representativeswere urged to fulfill the duties which
were "committedto their charge by the people of the free state
of Florida."44
43. Philadelphia Aurora and General Advertiser, December 8, 1817.
44. Ibid., December 17, 1817; Adams, Memoirs, IV, 74-76; American Monthly
Magazine and Critical Review, II (January 1818), 215.

The assembly appointed a three-man committee-Pazos, Mur-

den, and Gual, who was named chairman-to draft a plan of
provisional government for the Republic of the Floridas. Pazos
suddenly found himself a constitution-maker. On December 7 he
and his collaborators had their first meeting and agreed on
guidelines for their project. The provisional government was to
be divided into three branches-executive, legislative, and judicial
-with "the military subordinate and obedient in all cases to the
civil authority." There would be one chief magistrate, or gov-
ernor, rather than an executive council of three or five members.
A lieutenant governor had the duty of presiding over the legisla-
ture and would vote only in cases of a tie. There would be two
executive secretaries, one for the departments of state and treas-
ury, the other for the department of the army and navy. A
unicameral legislature was adopted "on account of our peculiar
situation." It would originally be composed of seven members,
although every district in the Floridas that adhered "to our
cause" would be entitled to send two representatives. The ju-
dicial authority was vested in a supreme court of four members
-including an attorney general-inferior courts, and justices of
the peace.
On December 9 the committee met to flesh out these "Funda-
mental Rules" for a democratic republican government. The
governor was granted wide appointive powers which he would
execute with the advice and consent of a council of state made
up of the governor, lieutenant governor, the two secretaries, and
the attorney general. The secretaries were to be appointed with
the consent of the assembly.
The committee saw the council as vital to the success of the
government. In it "all the parts of the public administration"
were concentrated: "The council, therefore, is chiefly intended
to maintain harmony and good understanding between the sev-
eral branches of the government, and by collecting from time to
time, in a single body, all kind of information from every one,
it must infuse life and activity in the whole. The council is also
calculated to supply the deficiency of a single House of Legisla-
ture .... In regard to the executive the council is finally a coun-
cil of appointment and advice."
While the governor was given veto power over acts of the as-

sembly, he could be overriden by two-thirds of the members
present. The assembly had the power to impeach, and its mem-
bers enjoyed immunity from prosecution for "opinions mani-
fested, or doctrine professed" in their capacity as legislators. The
functions, administration, and jurisdiction of the courts remained
to be determined by statute. However, the committee did insist
that all crimes deserving "corporeal or ignominious punishments
shall be tried by Judges and a Jury."
The four articles pertaining to the provisional government
were to remain in force "until a Constitution be adopted by a
Convention, legally called and composed of Delegates of the ma-
jority of the Districts of [the] Floridas." Two additional articles
guaranteed freedom of the press and freedom of conscience. The
committee submitted a report to their fellow representatives, as-
suring them that they had been governed in their proceedings
"by strict adherence to the principles of Free Governments."
Their debt to the form and content of the federal and state con-
stitutions of the United States was substantial; they cited, for
instance, Alexander Hamilton's Federalist No. 70 to justify a
single executive. Although there is no record of action on the
committee's report, it seems likely that it was ratified by the as-
sembly of representatives.45
Pazos, as chairman, and Murden also served on a three-man
committee appointed to obtain information relative to the trans-
actions between Elton and the Florida republic. The third mem-
ber was Comte, a follower of Aury scarcely twenty years old. On
December 9, a busy day for Pazos, the committee asked Aury
to turn over copies of all the correspondence between him and
Elton and also the proceedings of the court of inquiry appointed
a month earlier to investigate the conduct of Austin. The next
day Aury complied with the request. The committee reported
that, in its opinion, an attempt had been made to board the
Tentativa and that she had been fired upon "in the very waters
of Amelia." "Whatever may have been the motives of the com-
mander of the Saranac, in ordering or approving such a violation
of neutral rights, they can, in the judgment of your committee,
45. Douglas Crawford McMurtrie, ed., Republic of the Floridas: Constitution

and Frame of Government Drafted by a Committee Appointed by the
Assembly of Representatives, and Submitted at Fernandina, December 9.
1817 (Evanston, Illinois, 1942), [iv], 3-7.

290 FLORIDA
HISTORICAL
QUARTERLY
never be sanctioned, much less could they have been ordered, by
that enlightened government which has itself contended against
the right of search on board their own vessels, even when out of
their waters. How then could Captain Elton, certainly un-
authorized, take upon himself to board our vessels in our very
waters? What authority could he have had to detain those vessels,
to molest our commerce, and threaten us, if we should rescue
from him, or protect a vessel under our own flag ... ? What
authority? None other than that which he must have unjustifiably
assumed."
The committee then presented two resolutions, recommending
that they be put into swift execution. First they resolved that the
correspondence and other pertinent documents be printed, and
that the documents, with a statement of the transactions that had
taken place, be officially transmitted to the President of the
United States, thus exposing Elton's questionable conduct. Pazos
and his committee were satisfied that once the President knew
the facts of the case "complete justice will be done to us."46
The assembly complied with the committee's request. Pazos
supervised the printing, a business he had been in for some weeks.
In August a press and printing apparatus had reached Fernandina
from New York City, and a printing office, managed by R. Find-
ley, was established. MacGregor thus had a means of issuing
his proclamations and a paper currency. A correspondent in
Fernandina on August 23 related that the inhabitants daily ex-
pected the arrival of a printing press for the purpose of issuing
a newspaper.47 It remained for the assembly to take definite ac-
tion on that score. On December 1 a weekly newspaper in Span-
ish was authorized in order to give "publicity to the Acts of the
Provisional Legislature, and to such other information as may be
interesting and important to the welfare of the people." Pazos,
with his earlier experience as a journalist, was made editor of
El Telegrafo de las Floridas. Within the week the first number
was issued. It contained a write-up about the first meeting of the
46. Report of the Committee Appointed by the Honorable Assembly to Ob-

tain Information Relative to the Transactions between This Republic
and John H. Elton, Esq., Commander of the U.S. Brig Saranac, &c.
(Fernandina, 1817), State Department, Territorial Papers, Florida, pp.
66-70, NA. See also ibid., folio 94; Charleston Courier, December 27, 1817.
47. Savannah Republican, August 19, 1817; Daily National Intelligencer,
September 13, 1817.

"Representatives of the Floridas, under a discharge of artillery,"
at which time steps were taken for the organization of the new
government. Pazos announced that the object of the Telegrafo
was to furnish a record of events on Amelia Island and to provide
extracts from North American and other foreign newspapers.
His first issue, understandably, abounded in speculative editorial
remarks about the future destiny of the Republic of the Floridas.
Pazos's Telegrafo has the distinction of being the second news-
paper published in East Florida.48
Pazos named the printing office in Fernandina "America
Libre" in honor of the vessel that had brought him to Amelia
Island and of "the deputies of free America." Under his aegis at
least two pamphlets were published. One was the report of the
committee appointed to frame a plan for the provisional govern-
ment and the other the report of the committee to examine the
dispute over the Tentativa. The title page of the first pamphlet
carried a quotation in Latin from Cicero that summarized the un-
certainty of the patriots about their future: "What will happen
I certainly do not know, but nevertheless there is one hope that
some day the Roman people will be like our ancestors. I at least
shall not fail the Republic; but whatever happens I hope that I
shall be free from any blame in this matter, and I shall bear it
with a brave heart. Marcus Tullius Cicero sends hearty greetings
to Cornificius."49
In his last issue of La Crdnica Argentina on February 8, 1817,
Pazos had drawn a comparison between the situation in Rome
and the predicament in Buenos Aires in regard to conspirators
who spread false alarms in the city, "trying to bury the State with
them in order to escape a sure retribution.""0 The title page of
the second pamphlet was embellished with the single Roman
proverb: "Fiat justitia, ruat coelum."
48. There were probably no more than three issues of the Telegrafo pub-
lished, none of which is known to be extant. Charleston Courier, De-
cember 19, 1817; Daily National Intelligencer, January 2, 1818; T. Fred-
erick Davis, "MacGregor's Invasion of Florida, 1817," Florida Historical
Quarterly, VII (July 1928), 48; Douglas C. McMurtrie, "The Beginnings
of Printing in Florida," Florida Historical Quarterly, XXIII (October
1944), 68-69.
49. McMurtrie, Republic of the Floridas, [iv].
50. [Juan Canter?], "Inventario de documentos publicados," Boletin del In-
stituto de Investigaciones Hist6ricas, Supplement to V (January-March
1927), 94.

The need for an articulate press in Fernandina was real

enough, as the patriots there had many critics in the United
States. Thornton in Washington had done his best to convince
the public at the time Pazos and Gual embarked for Amelia Is-
land that they were "not the flinchers and the plunderers, but
brave, active, intelligent, honest men, captivated by the cause of
liberty." Other commentators were more inclined to view the
activities at Fernandina as "A Horrible Picture" or as a farce. A
resident of St. Marys on November 22, 1817, wrote a friend in
Charleston his jaundiced interpretation of the doings of the
patriots: "You at a distance, can form no idea of the emancipa-
tion of the Floridas, and the great advance of civilization, in this
young republic. In speaking of the government about to go into
operation, they express a wish to form a convention similar to
that of the early days of the French revolution. Numbers of the
Americans have been banished into the United States-this is a
terrible sentence! They have even taken upon themselves, it is
said, to proscribe some of their inhabitants to a residence north
of Charleston; and we expect daily to see a guillotine erected in
'Washington Square,' Fernandina, and some Mexican chief hold-
ing up the reeking head of an American citizen, exclaiming,
'behold the head of a traitor'."5'
The administration of President James Monroe tended to side
with the opponents of Aury and his "party-colored associates."
At a cabinet meeting on October 31, the secretary of state openly
advocated breaking up "the marauding parties" at both Amelia
Island and Galveston as soon as possible. His sentiments were
shared by other cabinet members and by the President, who
ordered the secretary of the navy to dispatch at once John D.
Henley of the U.S.S. John Adams and his squadron to St. Marys.
There he was to cooperate with James Bankhead, commanding
officer of the land force, in removing from Amelia Island "the
persons who have lately taken possession thereof, and, as it is
understood and believed, without authority from the Colonies, or
any organized Government, whatever, and to the great annoyance
of the United States." From Amelia Island Henley was to take
his squadron to Galveston to help break up the establishment
there. His naval force at St. Marys was to be augmented by ves-
51. Daily National Intelligencer, September 11, 1817, March 14, 1818; Savan-
nah Columbian Museum and Savannah Daily Gazette, December 1, 1817.

sels under the command of Elton. The secretary of the navy, in
his orders to Henley, expressed the hope that Aury and his men
would withdraw without bloodshed. In any case, Henley and
Bankhead were to take possession of the island "in the name, and
by the authority of the United States."52
On December 2 Monroe made known in his first annual mes-
sage to Congress his decision to move against Amelia Island. That
patriot center, said the President, had been converted into noth-
ing more than "a channel for the illicit introduction of slaves
from Africa into the United States, an asylum for fugitive slaves
from the neighbouring States, and a port for smuggling of every
kind." The rights and interests of the United States, he had con-
cluded, required that such goings-on be suppressed.53
As soon as Lino de Clemente, one of the signers of Mac-
Gregor's commission in Philadelphia, read Monroe's message, he
sent a letter by express to Fernandina advising the authorities
there of the imminent hostilities and ordering Aury to defend
the place to the last man-unless attacked by a superior force. If
such was the case, he should file a solemn protest in the name of
the Spanish American governments against the proceedings on
the part of the United States.54
When Clemente's letter and his enclosed copy of Monroe's
message reached Fernandina, the consternation of the patriots at
first ran high. It soon subsided as the more audacious spirits de-
cided to set sail for Nassau to join MacGregor in a projected ac-
tion in the Tampa Bay area. One patriot spoke for them all
when, on December 20, he wrote a friend in Philadelphia: "We
are of the opinion that the Spanish government is highly in-
debted to the government of the United States, for the
friendly
interference of the latter in our affairs. If we should have been
permitted to retain this island for six months longer, our naval
establishment would be such, I will venture to predict, that out
of one hundred vessels bound to or from Cuba, no more than ten
could have escaped our cruisers; as it is, we have
annoyed the
Spanish trade considerably."55
52. Adams, Memoirs, IV, 15; Crowninshield to Henley, November 14, 1817,
Navy Department, Private Letters, I, 245-46, NA; Crowninshield to
Henley, November 18, 1817, ibid., I, 247.
53. Stanislaus Murray Hamilton, ed., The Writings of James Monroe, 7
vols. (New York, 1898-1903), VI, 35-36.
54. Niles' Weekly Register, December 20, 1817.
55. Philadelphia Aurora and General Advertiser, January 13, 1818.

The rendezvous between Henley and Bankhead was accom-

plished by December 18. While off Amelia Island on December
22, they officially notified Aury that they had come with orders
"from our Government to take possession of Amelia Island, and
to occupy the port of Fernandina." The patriots were to evacuate
the island, leaving behind all public property surrendered by the
Spaniards earlier to MacGregor; all private property belonging
to the patriots would be respected.56 After receiving this letter,
Aury answered that he had submitted it "to the representatives
of the republic, and, as soon as I shall have obtained their opin-
ion, it shall be immediately sent to you."57Pazos, Gual, and other
representatives sent a reply in Aury's name to Henley and Bank-
head on December 22. They expressed surprise that the two of-
ficers were authorized by the government of a people who sympa-
thized with "their southern brethren in the struggle for liberty
and independence in which they are engaged, as were the United
States forty years ago." Furthermore, the United States could
claim no jurisdiction from the source of the St. Marys River to
the Atlantic Ocean, "on this side [of] the centre of the channel."
The only law Henley and Bankhead could adduce in their be-
half was that of force, and the same could be said about their
interference with the property of inhabitants of Amelia Island.
The demand to leave behind all public property surrendered by
the Spaniards was "contrary to the public rights, by which public
property captured from the enemy, is avowedly that of the cap-
tors, when not otherwise stipulated." Were Henley and Bank-
head, the representatives wanted to know, perhaps acting in the
name of the king of Spain or his allies? The patriots considered
the people of the United States to be "the only free people on
the surface of the globe," but the demand of the officers was "in-
admissible and unjustifiable in the ages of the world." Pazos and
his co-authors requested that their remarks be laid before Mon-
roe.58
Henley and Bankhead responded the next day, saying that
they were bound to obey their orders "without any discussion or
56. Henley and Bankhead to Aury, December 22, 1817, American State
Papers,ClassI, Foreign Relations, 4: 139-40.
57. Aury to Henley and Bankhead, December 22, 1817, ibid., 140.
58. Aury to Henley and Bankhead, December 22, 1817, in Narrative of a
Voyage, 321-23.

animadversion on our part as to the correctness of them." They
proposed to send a force ashore that very day. Henley's squadron
would sail into the harbor at Fernandina where Bankhead was
to wait for Aury to make the necessary arrangements for the land-
ing of the troops.59 Aury replied in a note that he was ready to
surrender Amelia Island. Consequently, 250 men landed and
marched into the fortifications of Fernandina. At twelve o'clock
noon, the Mexican flag was struck, and the United States flag
hoisted over the island.60 And so the abortive Republic of the
Floridas came to an abrupt, but a peaceful, end.
The United States troops held Amelia Island in protective
custody to the last of the Spanish period, offering to turn it over
to the Spaniards when they could police and govern it. Pazos's
contributions to the short-lived republic were largely in the realm
of ideology and publication. He also helped the patriot effort
with his legal expertise and served as a "working" legislator. His
faith in republicanism for the Floridas proved to be misplaced,
but at least he could claim the honor of being the editor of one
of its first newspapers. His exertions on behalf of the defunct re-
public did not, moreover, stop with the raising of the United
States flag on December 23. The papers that Aury had indicated
would be conveyed to Monroe were, in fact, to be delivered by
Pazos. For four months in 1818 he acted as agent in Washington
for Aury, vainly trying to secure reparations for the patriots.61
59. Henley and Bankhead to Aury, December 23, 1817, American State
Papers, Class I, Foreign Relations, 4:140-41.
60. Aury to Henley and Bankhead, December 23, 1817, ibid., 141; Charleston
Courier, December 31, 1817; Philadelphia Democratic Press, January 7,
1818.
61. Aury to James Monroe, December 23, 1817, State Department, Territorial
Papers, Florida, 71, NA.


Bowman - Vicente Pazos and The Amelia Island Affair, 1817

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Bowman - Vicente Pazos and The Amelia Island Affair, 1817

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Bowman - Vicente Pazos and The Amelia Island Affair, 1817

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Vicente Pazos and the Amelia Island Affair, 1817

Author(s): Charles H. Bowman Jr.

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

MAY 9, 1817, seven distinguished patriots from Buenos

*Mr. Bowman is assistant professor of history, Fayetteville State Uni-

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

Pazos and his compatriots did not remain long in Savannah

5. Baltimore Patriot and Mercantile Advertiser, May 29, 1817.

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

12. Thornton to Gual, July 8, 1817, V, 779-81, ibid.

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

intrepid resolution, so often the effect of adversity upon virtuous

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

on June 29.21 Disorder quickly ensued and prevailed there for

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

opportunity to talk with various merchants and with Baptis

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

30. Schlumberger, Mdmoires, 24-26.

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

accustomedpresence of mind, and by dint of strong and well

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

37. Ibid., November 14, 1817.

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

38. John H. Elton to Benjamin W. Crowninshield, November 15, 1817, in

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

Pazos'slegalisticflair also came in handy for Aury outside the

25, 1817, Correspondence of the Secretary of the Treasury with Collectors

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

The assembly appointed a three-man committee-Pazos, Mur-

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

45. Douglas Crawford McMurtrie, ed., Republic of the Floridas: Constitution

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

46. Report of the Committee Appointed by the Honorable Assembly to Ob-

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

The need for an articulate press in Fernandina was real

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

The rendezvous between Henley and Bankhead was accom-

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

This content downloaded from 195.78.108.60 on Tue, 17 Jun 2014 22:28:26 PM

You might also like

Pfad - The Proxy pFad of © 2024 Garber Painting. All rights reserved.