Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.

html



 
 

    !#"$"&% ')(*,+.-&/01- , ' ",+.2

3 5  47698
;:=<>8@? 40AB5C5DEF
;:HGJIKMLN:O540P :JNIRQ5L8CS8TVU @
WG=4X8Y>8@:OUSI
[Z\TL:OUSIWML>T]U^LNM4JU^LTZV_L`

L>_ML>8@:JNIRQ9G7_M4Xa:bQ54X@_:HML5UcL>Td:H8e69_fNgQ5569_ML>
W_ML9L`5_ML>T4X@`h
<>@IU @


iKjkilnm mJoXpqj

rKts@uwvBxKyauWsNuWyz[v|{~}Kyb@uWyaz[s@ yKdzvXxKyW[tyvXnsNzWszKyvyK[xzKs@ sM yNvBxKyVy[vXx b@uWyzK[ns@zK

xKFyWbs@zby0zyKduyR\};v~ v7=s@z zvXxyWN;vXuazWsKkvXxKv|{k}KyKb@uWyW@z[Nns@K[ 7@tyWsxKs
tyKv@tyvXxy@zKyt[zK9zvXxKyJvbyz[vX@{b@zWvyvXxKyWs@zKOy[vsu zKyKbyvsWvXxKyWKa{
uWy[vkN t7y@vXxKyWybyyK WNuWs@Kz[Fyz[vs@VsvXxKytqv~tyzKdu[xzys@5vBxKya}zKaNz
uWNz;sKvBxKyV@uzKvXxzK

N@zK{]ytya}KsvXxW[yK@yt=Kv|yKs@tyW y #Nynybs[ubs@z;yyzKbyR>@zK{yzKOsNz[vytyKdxu}[

[xK@zKOyazvXxKya}NVsvXxKyaxsKvyKcvy|}KsvXxWs@VbyKO[nsNzytyWsFyX@{7=[ vtvBzKa vBxJs@xzNyK@0ny>
y0yny[ xnsbs@xyV$xKsqvXKnyOsNzb[ns@K[zKybKhxnyW7yW7ytyv@zK@\@Nts[xKy@zKa
bs@z[ytbvXns@za}KyKNzRNvXxy;}J0yKJvs5$x ;xxNz[vuWyvsWvXx =

{~xFduanbby9@ v@$@zKvXxKyW[}KbyKMKyz;v~Nzy[vBxKv~@NzJs@xzaxK9}yKyzWs@zNzvBxKy[ zsF

n[yd0 Mx[vkW$xKytyvXxKy; dny[cvsKct$ vXxaNb@zKvXxv\vBxKyatvyWsuasKyuWyz;v]svyK[xzsNns
7=s@zKvsbbynytvyW@zKvXxKv7yWytyWs@zKvs}KyKbs@uWyats@}Ksv=s@5KbyW vBxts@}sKvs@Vbs@uWy[vXxz
yvXxKv0NzJs@xzWbs@z[vy0zKvXxKvVvXxn=bs@nz v~xNKyzR\}Kyb@KbyvXxyatsN}sv=bs@nz vk}KyWOsNzb[ns@KK

hxny{~xKdxKyNta[[xv@W}y[sNtyR5{kxKaNnKy vbyz[vXnyz;v~sN}sKvytyazvXxKyatyNus5O[nyzKby
nJvB s@zNM[vkzKs=@ts@ubs@uWyKs@zy{kty[KyKqvyK>5{7xKyK@0zKaJvBts@zKaNtMuWyz[vVvXxKvVvBxKy[7ytyW
zKyK@vy0uKsb[} vt>>{]Fv@yzW@}K[[yK;KyK[n@ M yzaN tsFyz@} vtWvs uWzKyW@zKa[tyKvy
vXxKy[vXyN@{@tyK KzyK*vXxKvkzKy*vyK;xzKs@nsFM yyWyzKy;vXnyzKzKyy0zKa@zKdzK@zKsvy[xzKs@ns7yty
 NzKdKvXxKyasFyvs tyuWNyvXxKyWsN @V}[v ty@nJvB =@zKduuazKyz[vbbyzK@0 ss@|z;vy yz[vkts@}Ksv
[00 OyKduWyN

{tv0nyJWvsy[v@yaN}sN;v];K[xa}tyNOvXxts@xKK yaxKyK@|zvXxyazKyK@uWsJvy[Fys5bs@uWy

KzKasvyK;xzKs@ns O@Ks@\b; yz[vX =NzbyNFNy[vVvXxn=7zKss@tzK@ tynJvXns@zN>{XzvBxKyaxKsvy}K@\@
FyauWyW K@vB @ty0z[vsxnvXxKyzs@vXxKOsNuazKd}Kss@@NW0qNH7$xn[x
s@[vXzKyKa ;vs@n xKysNtyb&s@zKyazxn[xaxuW@zK=@zyKdzKyK@|uauWs@v@ v }[ }KyKOs@uzKas@zKyW$ vXx
ts@}KsvXnvyK;xzKs@nsFR>zatyKzKd v0\ubyzKbyWszKybyWs@z z[vyzK; nyK|{Vy v];tyaxKyaxKvs }y
zKytJvKvBzvBxKyW@zKyt\zKytJvvXzKvXxKyats@}K@} vts5 }Fas@[vOs@uyW@ns@zKvXxnKvXxN

{\s@zKduFby uWsJvVvXts@} yd}[ KbOFyWy[vNzKavs@ @zWbOyzK@0nsV

THE NEW LUDDITE CHALLENGE

rKtJvkny[vkKKsJvBnKvyvXxKvVvXxKyWbs@ua[vyVb[nyz;vXnJv=[KObyKydzWy;Fy s@zKdz[vynyz;v~uW[xzKyvXxKv

1 of 18 1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html

b@zWs@[vXxzK}y[vtvyvXxK@zaxuW@z}yzK=b@zWsWvBxKyu @{BzvBxKv]OFOyatyK;uWN} @K7s@0$}y

s@zKya}[WFqv0\x Mx s@tNz yKaJJvyuWsuW[xzKy@zKdzKsxuW@zy;^s@v$}KyazKyKOyKbON

 vBxKyVs
v7sbbyuanx[vsb[X5xKyauW[xzKyKuanx[vk}KyaKy0ua vvyKvsu@yWNKsvXxy\szyK[n[ns@zK=$ vXxKs@[v
xuW@zWsKyt; Mx[v0>s@Vynbyaxu@zWbs@z[vXsNsKyvXxKyauW[xzKyunx[vk}Kyaty;v@zKyK

{tvXxKyauW[xzKy=Ntyay0ua vtvyvs uWNyW@;vXxKyVs$zWyK; ; s@zK>7yWONzR vkuWNyW@z[bs@zJ0yKJvBtyK=vs

vXxKyaty[ v\}Kyb@Kbya vk uaKsb[}nyvsMKyKbxKs)[[xau[xzyKunx;v~}yxKyNys@z Ks@z[vs@[v
vXxKvVvXxKyvyWsvXxKyaxu@zatbyW7s@nd}KyWvVvXxKyauWytqsKvBxKyauWF;xzKyK@{tvkua x;vk}KyWNKyKvXxv\vBxKy
xuW@zatFOyW7s@n9zy[y|}Kyss@ ;xyzKs@KxvsxK@zKasKyV@;vXxKyaKsyvsWvXxyau[xzyKKM[v7yW@ty
[KyKJvBz9zy vXxKy5vBxKv\vBxKyaxuW@zatFOyW7s@nFs@z[v@0 WvX0zaKs7y\syvsWvXxyau[xzyKzKs@5vBxKv
vXxKyauW[xzKys@n  by yaKs7yXhxKvyWs[yKqv~nvXxKvVvXxyaxuW@ztbyauanx[vyK;
Kyu vk vby vs0 ^vkz[vs Ks[ vXns@zWsK5;K[xWyKyzKyzKOyWsNzvXxyau[xzyKvXxKvk v]s@ dxKyazKs
tJvXnb@[xKs@nbya}[vVvsFOby;v]@KsvXxKyauW[xzKyKy[n[nsNzK5=bs[ny;vt@zKvXxKyats@}nyuWvXxKvVFOya v
}KyKOs@uyauWs@tyW@zKdus@tyWbs@uany[@zKduW[xzKyK}Kybs@uWyaus@tyW@zKduWs@tyaz[vy yz[v\KysN yWny[v
uWF;xzKyKuW@yauWsNysvBxKyVyK[n[ns@zKs@vXxKyu>[ua }KyKb@byau;xzyJuyWyK[n[ns@zK=$}0zK
}Ky[vvy|ty[ vvXxK@zauWNzRHuWyWs@zKyK
[yz[vBK@ qvyauWK }yatyK[xKyaKvx ;xvBxKyWy[n[ s@z
zKyKOyKbON Wvs yKyvXxyWJFqvyu 0zzzKa$}KyWbsbs@ua y;WvXxKvkxuW@za}KyzK}yzKON@} yWs
uWNzKvBxKyu z;vy yz[vB vVvXxKvJvFyvXxKyauW[xzKy}yzWy[cyJvX FyWOs@z[vXts@

[yKs@nyW7s@z vk}Ky
@}nyvs=JKJvVvXzvBxKyau[xzyK=s^\}Kyb@KbyvBxKy[}KyWOsyKyzKyz[vs@zvXxKyuwvXxKvVvXzzKvBxKyu sKc
7s@naNuWs@z[vVvs[n[ny@

7zvXxyWsKvBxKy|xK@zKd v~nKsb[}nyvXxKvkxu@zWbs@z[vBtsNsKyvXxKyauW[xzKyu }Kyaty;v@zKyK5>{XzvXxKvbby

vXxKyWytyauW@zuW xKFyWbs@z;vXts@KsFy\byv@za0 FvyauW[xzKyK=sxn=s$z[K[xWxnONVs@x
Kybs@zK@Kbs@ua[vy\}[vbs@z[vXts@Ksy| @tyWqFJvyuW=sKuW[xzKy=$}KyazvXxyaxK@zK=s5WvXz[y vy
HJvF vk vsK\};v] vBxv7sM cytyzbyK
|Kyvs uatsFyvyK[xznKy7vBxKyWy vyW$xKFyWMtyKvy
bs@z[vXts@sKyvXxKyauWbby[@zKd}KyKO@KbyaxuW@zW7s@0$$zKs ns@zKy}yazKyKOyKbb@WvBxKyauObyK=$}Ky
[yKs@>Kbynyb}tyzs@zvXxyqFJvyu @{tvBxKyWy vyan0;vXxnyKO7vBxKy[ uW[u yK[nyvs
y[vy0uazKvyvXxyaub=sxu@z vt@{tvBxKy[@tyaxuW@zKyvXxy[ uW byats@K@zKs@\svXxy
KJ[xKs@nsnb@Ks@}ns@ns O@[vy[xznKyvs tyKbyvBxKya}vXxatvyaz[vB;vXxKyauWb=sKxuWNz v }KyKOsNuWy
y[vXzKJv0VnyKNzKvXxKyWs@0 vsvXxKyWy vy@\ vXxKyWy vyWbs@zK[nJv=s5bscv0HxyK@vy9}Kyt@n@vXxKy; u
yK; yvs nWvXxKyats@nyWs5ss;xKyxKytvsWvXxKyatyJvsvXxKyaxu@zatbyNF5xKy[KOyKyvs vVvXxKv
y[ysNzy x;F[nb@zyKyK@tyWOKvB qnyK>NvXxKv@K[xntyzW@tyat@nbyKdzy|KJ[xKs@ns O@ x[nyzn
bs@zK vXns@zK@vXxKvy[ys@zKyaxK=$xKs@nyKOs@uyaxKs@}};Wvs yKyxu}KJ>@zKvXxKv@z[Fs@zKyWxKs uW
}KyKOs@uyWnbOKvBnJnyKdzytsFy vXtyvXuWyz[v vs[tyaxn
Jts@}nyu  5bs@tbyR\ yW$}KyWbs
0sFOynyKbvBxKv~yKs@nyW$xKFyvs}Kya}ns@ sM b@ s@KqF[xKs@nsnb@ yzKzKyytyKay vBxKyvs yuWsFy
vXxKy|zKyyKs@vXxKyaKsy|tsbyKO=sN|uWNyvXxKy u ;}uv

y vXxKy\0 ys@sFy|z[vsOs@uyaxK@0uanyKb
xKs@}}[5xKybyWyzKMzyKytyKdxuW@z}yzKuW }KyaxK@[ zW[K[xWOsF; y;vt\}[vVvBxKy[$uWsJvby v@z
zKsvk}KytyyNFMxy[$xKya}KyKyztyKOyKvsWvBxKyWJvvXs5sNuWyJvXn=NzuW@nK

{XzvXxKya}Kss@[@Fs@Ws@z vnbOsKy|z[vB;Fs@vX0zvXxKyaFyvXxKvVvXxKyW@[vXxs@\svXxnKbbyn#5xKyKss@ty
bONzK[vXx y \zN}sNua}KyX@{@uzKs@sNnsnJvVs@|bONzK[
n}Ks@u}nyKvXxtyKyaKys@nyW0zKa
 FyNvy0ts@\ONuaK@nzW@zKa7s@zKydu@z[svXxytK7zyWsKx }Ks@ua}K=tFy zJJty9uW0 yzK
\@ a|yny0z;vys@zKyWsvXxKyauWsJvk}0n@z[vNz@n[nsNzN Os@u;vyVb; yz[vXnJv=s5s@vXuy@
[yauW@z[
suOsNnyKyK{\y vVvXxKv|{]OsN ayF; xKy}yKyzvBxK y VzK@}Ks@u}y zKy;KvVv@ty;vH

bONzK[ =JvXns@zK=7ytyauatyts@K=@zK@VzauWNnyK >[0uazK@ zKb@zKy@
5yan=[nyK@0 

[K vyV}[v
[ua OK@zKvXxn=syKzKsvn[ua Ox =@tuWyz[vX= ^ ; v v~ns@|uyvs[zKs$nyKy5{b
bs@uWyauy0 v~zvXxKyatybs@zzKdzvXxn=[zKnyaKbOFyN@{Vy vbs@uy yvsbs@z;ts@z[vk vH

bONzK[ =Fqvs@n@z@ ; s@zWyb[0}Kyzz;vyzyKabs@zKOyKKyzKby>7yHzKs$zats@}nyu$ vXxvXxKy

yK; Mz@zKdKOyWsKvyK[xzKs@ s>@zKas@zKyvXxKvkn=[nyK@0 tynvyKvs=0x[ nF&z[KvBxzKvBxKvb@zs
$ts@zK>>$S 5JvXN @vXxn rzFM yR nF >$x ;xza vby 5;xKs7vXxKvkrKzKnyW70nx[vH 
sFy0KbyWs5@z[vX}nsvXnbxK yvs$xKvkuW }KyvXxKya} yKJv[[xats@}nyuOsW@b@vBxKyWyuWytyzKOyWsK
@z[vX}nsvXnHty[nJv@z[v@zKduaK[xauWs@tyW@zKysN}Fqvy0n@5ua @vXxzKxK@yzKyxKyzWvtvyua[vvs
yuzKvyauW@n@0 @uWsb vsFyK[zK M ONbyKvXxyuwvsbt y htyK[nJvNzbykuW@nN0n@K@t[ vy
yK$nbyWbMtyKdua vX0@Hty[nJv@z[vyzKyK 

5xKyWb@KbyWsuW@z[[K;x;00nbyOyKyuW=[nyK@b5xKyWJJvyuWz[s@ yKa@tyWbs@uany[Vz;Fs@ NzK

z[vyFqvXnsNzW@uWs@zKaNzyKy}K[W}Ky;v7yyzauW@z[ K@vKRz[[xK@zyKvs[K[xWqFJvyuKOFObyaz
7FvXxv]@tyW cn[ vVvs tyKnJvBVvXxn =y[KyK; @ WvX0KyWxKyzaxuW@zWFqvXns@zK=Ntyaz[s@ yK5

2 of 18 1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html

{]qv@vy;xKs$zK0nyzvXxKyabONzK;KKMKsvyts@uhNW0=J@
W{]7s@ dxK@zKvXxKyu

t7y }Kss@[Vny[vVvXxKyutyKvXxyMKsvy@zKvXxKyzKv[xvXxKy|tyFqvXnsNzWvXxKy;nbbsFytyKa$xs xK
$0 vtvyza vJv@ts@zKvXxKyWONuWyvXuWy{\s@zK 5@zK ~s@tyKn}sFs@\NV ;X=RqN
0b;N;N   ks@tFyn=s@zKyWsvXxKyanyKytzats@}KsvXnbtybyK@t[xR>@zKa7=WsNzKy\svXxy
7s@0n@ n@tyKqv~sN}sKvB OtybyN[xatst@uv
5@0zKyKM  y kyns@
z \z yt[ vtV @yauyauWs@ty
uWKvy0n@[vsvXs@[vs@zuW yzK7uWKvy0n@K[0n[zK [sNvB yWsFOb@zK[n=NtMuWyz[vJrs@
y[@uny

The Short Run (Early 2000s)

nsNnsnb@K[yK[nyK=@uWsFqv~zy[Fy\;N yWyzKbs@z[vy vBx;Ky0 s@Vbs@uaKy[vB vsNtNyzauans@zyK@t=s
s@[vXxW@zK5s@vXxuWy0nbytyWbyK@tvy9}[[zyz[@zK@unJvXxuaKK>Ns@[vXxuWy0nb\y
N
KJvBtNnWvsFK>FKs@ vyKd}[ uWN[n@uW@uuW@n\zK[KMzKdKs@K;xKyKay F@nyz[vstv
yKytNzvB ytKhxKyzvBxKya qvXxuaK=bs@zzKyJvXzK5s@vBx@zKNs@[vXxuWy0nbtsbyV vVvss@$s@z WyK
vXxKs@KONzyK@ts@vXxKyazsNvBxKy0zanbyz[v@K[yK[ny> vBx;nx[vB uWs@tyWy[cyJvX yuWy;v@}Ks@ [uW=@zK
tytsFMKJvX yWNz9zyFs@qFJvyuWNvsn[nbyW@zKayuazKvy@uWsJvN[vBxKyWbs@[vXxy0zauWN[n@nK

{XzWbs@uany[vy WtyyuW@0y[vXnbyR>[Ky0ns@sN}sKvs@n;ty ^yKqv~xu@z5s@vXxuWy0nb@z

nbyz[v@ =^yKqvyKNs@[vXxuWy0nb@zauWN[n@n @zKaFxu@zKxKyWKcyJvyOs@z[vXnyKO;KyK; y b
Ns@}KsvXnzKKJvB0nyK=7s@nabs@uy[vy@ s@tsN[ NuWs@zKvXxKyuWby Fys@|uvtvyyzKyt@zKa[KbyR
zK[nyz;v@ 0 @zKvBxKy0 Oya}Ky[s@zKdxuW@zty[xN

VzN} yvs^sNvBxKyazKyKOyKb; vB y=sK yR
}ns@ snb@xuWNzs@ d}KyWOKyyKyKas@[vsK5y;NnJvyzKby@

5xKytyants@}K@} bs@uWya}tyKvXxz9tss@u\}Kyb@KbyWyWs zKsvk yazbs@u y;vy WtyKyauW@0y;vXnbyN

sy0zuWyz[vbsytbyzKs@zuWNy[vk}KyxKNns@>y[Ky[n@ }[bs@nyKJvBzKvyKKR ; s@[ @ny@
sFy0zuWyz[v@Kbsyt; s@zWbs@na[sNvkxu@zaKs@nvXns@zKzxnxWJvNnyWs@zvBxKy0 vsts@}Ksvkn@}Ks@
KyxK@Ks@\nsNzx y@

9vy[KvB}Kss@$Fqvs@na@zK~s@tyK JKJvy;vtvXzKa7s@z9N
5yWsy=sNzvsnb[KOxsF)s@|uWNzs@}

zvBxKy5Jvbyz[vX$}Ky yzK[zKabs@z[vBzKyKabss@KytvXnsNzts@uwvXxKyats@}KsvkzKKqvX0nyK 7}; Kb[zK
nFyK[tyyzKvXxKvVvXxy[ }Ky Jznby   Nzvsyb[0}KyaxKs)by0 s@K; Nzyts@K=xuW@zONza}Ky 0s@zKby
vXt@zKJs@0uWyKdz;vs@zaz}sNzKyKa[Ky0z[vy yz[vkts@}KsvH ks@tFyK NnyK nvXxKvVvXxKyats@}Ksv
y[yz[vBK@ [bbyKydKvXxKvkxuW@zK=[nyK@0 WbyWy;KvXzKqvXnsNz@

{]yK[ny9 v7vXuWyvsWv@=vsuW0nyzK \@zz[ nK

V@zz[ }Kyb@uWy@uWs@KvXxyWbss@zKyVsK
5xzKzKkF;xzKyK
sN0sNKvB s@z$xn[xa} vWy Ks7yK@t@ yK[ytbs@ua[vyX \y[ vyau
[0tyz[v@s@}vX vXnyWs
xny;VN[nyz[vXnJvv|5 z = ;tsFqFJvyuW5{@uuWs@tyWbs@ua[vyVN[x vyKqv\vBxK@zW
b[nyz;vXnJv0Nz {kty[KyKqv V@zz[ KzsF yyWsvXxyaz[s@0uWKvB s@zW@zKdx[[nb@Kb[nyzKbyuWs@tyvXxK@zvXxKv
s5Nz;sKvBxKyV[zKnyaKytbs@z{~zKs
V@zz[ n=@ Os xnx ty@ty[vX qv]xKsWvBxznsNz@vy0u 
s@Fy@ts xKyWJvNvyKvXxK y bs@zK5s rsNzKvXns@z>xn[xa }nzKa[ns[$y[nzKyvs nJv
[yK@tVzW@zWvtvyu;v\vst)vtvyz[vXns@zvsWvBxKya vX  [xKs@vvtvyz[vXns@zW[K@zWsK5s@Vbs[ny;vt>
0Nyy  NyKqv]s@5uy $XK 5 VKy F5 
Nsa{VnyK*v s bszKyny7s@5vBxKyWy[@tyKO0KsbyWsxKNzKazzKy\ vX x \@zz[@zKdxn=$ yR [vX @{
7yz[vVvXxts@Kxau zKs=@uan@ts@;vXzKy@vXtsvtvXzKas@[vVvXxKyany@zKdKbOFyKvXxKv|{Vs@zKabs
nJvX0}zK5
V@zz[ =@zKb7yMtyJvya[KyK; nb@ vkt7y =bOyzK@0nssxuW@zKuWytzKa$ vXx
ts@}Ksvb@uWyWb$ ^vB >@zKa vyW;00nby9uWy@
5yWb@n@>;ua NvXxKvVvXxyW[xK@zKy=7s@nOsNuWy
tK@ >@zvBxKv]yW7s@nay[vkKbyvsWvBxKyu

[v|{]MKyKO${7[zR vVvsv@ ;00nby5@{kxKabyKyzKsvyts@u \@zz; zat7yn}sFs@WzW$xn[xaxKy

b@n@ B{0us@zKasu }Ks=Nz;Fs@zKyV}[vk V{]O@z}Ky$ vXxW }Kss5[ Os@z5{0;v@ya vHk{tv
byyuWyKvXxKvkxKyW7=vkKyKbyW vBxvBxntsbyKO@zKd v=vtvyzK@z[vk0n[>$xny{7zKsvH

hxnyv@zK@zvBxzKzKa@}Ks@[vkt7y\bONz[K>@z ks@tFy5{[Kyz tyuyua}KytyzKsFy

{~xFdty@uWsFqvyK@t=saN O=}[ rKt@z y0}Kyv|7zW$x ;xus@nyK;nN|}ns@ snJv
nM0 yzazKb@zKya}[WvBxKyWbyzbynyKOuatyVsxn7@u >FsbyKyWty[yzKyaxKyWbs@zKJvB0KJv=@zK
nbbyuzKvy= zKy)Nz9x x OsNz;vns@K MKyvXxKvkK = y }[vbynyJvX Fy >
 ytya[b
bONzK[K7= uWvXxKyuWKvB ; @zVzKsv uWs@ y[n@} s@nsnJvH k{7=NnbstyuazKysvXxyasNtasHV^
X| x FyWsK@vB }ns@nsnb@VK@vX ts@}KsvXn=[tyKvXtyK=$ vXxWqvXts@zKayKqvX0KqvX FyWJvXyK@FMsN@Hy
nbJvyt=NyJv@nyWs5b[nyzKby JvB s@zR>bs$x[ xKzR v|{~}KyyzauWs@tyWbs@zKby0zKyKa@}Ks@[v[K;xsN}sKvB 

3 of 18 1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html

Fqvs@ny@0ny
hx[7ytyzR vsvXxKyKys@nyuWs@tyWbs@zKOy0zKy@}sN;v\vBxKyKOyaz Mx[vXuW@0n[xWbbyz@0 s

[N v]svXxyWNzb7y\Oyv@z yzWs@VKvvX vXKyvsF@tvBxKyazKy 7zWs@} vs7@tdzKJvNz;v

@uan@0 vt@zKdzKyKJvB s@zzKabby[v@zKOyN5O[KJvs@uyvs @zKa$ vXxWNuWsJvkts@[vXzKyWb; yz[vX n
}tyNOvXxts@KMxK7yaxKFyy[vVvsbs@uyvsWvy0u= vBxvBxKyJvVvXxv\vBxKyausqv]OsNuaKyzK5qv0Oyz[vB
vy[xzKs@nsnyK7ts@}KsvXnbyzKy;vXn=yzKMzKyy0zK>>@zKdzK@zKsvy[xzKs@nsa7KsbyWM cytyz;v\vBxtyKvVvXxK@zvXxy
vy[xzKs@nsnyKvXxKvkxKFyWOsNuWya}Ky;s@ty@@5Ky[ nb@ \ts@}Ksv>yzKzKyKytyKas@t@zn[uWNz9zNzsN}sKv=[xK@ty
@zKyts@K=@ua cNzKJvsNOMxy[b@zWby Hty OKvyNR }Ks@ua}a }ns$zaWs@z sNzby7}[vs@zKya}Ksv
b@za}KyKOsNuWyauW@z[NzMn[K y;v]s@[vs5bs@z[vBts@S

=K[xWsusN syvXxKyaKqv  yK@txK}KyKyzs@zWbs@ua[vy|zKy[vs@0KzK@$xKytyvXxKyWOyzKzKa@zK

t yKOy NzKasuybby=[tyKvyvXxKyWs@Ks@vBz vtWs@Vs@[v00st0bs@z[vXts@ty OKvB s@z@[v$xnyatynbvXns@zaz
bs@ua[vyVs@\Os@u;vy|zKy;v7s@0$b@za}KyW znb@zKbyR>v7s@tJvk v]M O@} y= uW[xzKyWs@5vNyK=s$z
zKy;v7s@0$s@|zKy[v7s@0$byNnbyN VzKbs@z[vXsNnyKaby HtynbvXnsNzazvXxKybyazKyKyvy[xzKs@nsnyK0zK= uaK;x
tyKvy|0 ;N  ; s5;}KJvNz;vXnN@uyazvXxKyax[F[nb@Ks@0 

K[xWsvXxKybyvy[xzKs@nsnyK=@ Oss^ytz[vs@ dts@uanby55xKy@ ; s@zWszKyK@|uuWs@v@ vWvXxKvkt7y

byyKzaxnts@}KsvtyK@uW=0 Fy7s@t7@tyzKy[vB =yzKzKyKy0zKdubss@zatsNnyvBtyKvXuWyz;v\ zKsv
s@[vX0nx[v[tyK@s@|usqv]M OyKbyK;@zKdzK@zKsvyK;xzKs@nsFRNz9zNzsNuWyn[zKyWb@ztyKO7y[vkuWs@tyanK
NsFy[vXxyvXxKy;bs@n; z nb@z[vX y[vyzs@VFytya yW[K@zW@zKduatsyvBxKyWK@ vts5s@ FyK
Ny[v0$ vXxWyK[xWsvXxKybyvy[xzsNnsnyK>OyKKyzKbyWs5[uW@Vz NnK@ OyzK;} yWNzbyKnyKvs@z
b[uanvXns@zs5yKvkKs7yV@zK@bs@zKbs@ua v@z[vX tyKv@zKyX

hxKv7= ^ytyz[vkzvXxyKvXxWbyz[vX

5yv@z @vXxKyvy[xzKs@nsnyKzKy0 NzKvXxyyK@Ks@zK=suWb
yKqvX0KqvXnsN z    k7zK; y@\}ns@nsFM O@Nz;xKyuanb@  
k7ytyaKs7y@zKvBxKyW7y@Ks@zK=Nz
yzKs@0uWs@KvXxtyvH;v~} Mz9z[nyK@V7yK@Ks@zKtytyK>>vk yJvVs@VWvXuWy>ObyKbvs }KsvXxat@ty
zKyKy@>y;^yKqvX Fy zK@n@}ny7t uvy0nNn=@zKdxnx tsvyJvy9z[s@0uvB s@zk}ns@nsnb@K@zK
[xKyunb@KyK@Ks@zKtsNuW=@ OsWvyzKyvs tyKMtya @tyOb@ yWJvB @ vXnyKK

5xKy5JvOyz[vXWvyK;xzKs@ns yyzKy;vXnbVzK@zKsvy[xzKs@ns@zKdtsN}svXnb  
k@tyWbsKs7y [vBxKv

vXxKy;b@zW[K$zW$xKs@nyazKy)[ ObyK=s5b[nyz[v=@zKaN}KbyK
ksJv@zKyts@K[ @s@vXxKytqv\vBuWyR
vXxKybyWb[nyz[v=@zKa@}Kby@tyW y $ vXxzvXxKyaty[xWsKzK @ MK@ =s@V[uWNKMtsNKKFMxy[$zKsv
tyKMyn@ty[ vXnyK=s@|t@tyatF uWvy0 @nKMzKs$nyKyWNns@zKyW$KyzK@}nyvXxKyaKbyWsvXxyu

5xK=7yaxKyvXxKyaKsb;} vt zKsv@HKqvsK5yK@Ks@zK=suWFOyKJvB0KJvXns@za}[vsKzKs yyRyzK@}nyK

uWFOyKJvB0KJvXns@
z X

  XNvBxnyKJvB0KJvX yzKybxKy @ua nyKd}[WvXxyaKs7y\s5by Hty OvXnsNz@

{\vBxzW vknzKsy;FytvXns@zvsb7yW@tyWs@zvXxKyW[[WsKvBxKyvXxKyKyyJvXns@zWs5y[KvBtyuWyWy[@Nz
y @$xKsbyaKsO[} vt[tyK=7y}Ky[s@zKvXxKv$xn[xW7y@Ks@zK=sKuWb=yJvX0JvXns@z}yKKyvXxKyvs
[
vXxKyazKvB s@z0JvvyKsNzvs[00n[zKaNzvy00}nyWyuaKs7y0uWyz[vs5y[vXtyuyazK @ MK@ 

5svXxzKa@}Ks@[vVvXxKyW{svkz[Fs@ Fy vXxWbs@u[vyt;KyJvyvs uWyvXxKv|{]sNzKvs}Ky[zK

vXxKybyaKzKsnb[yKK

| yaxF}KyyzW0 Fyza}[yyazKyyKvs[$MKyKqvXnsNz@zKz@zKO7ythxKyz{]F {]

@ty tyKzK>>bsuWvXxKy5vss@WuWyvsWvBxKyWynyuWyz;v@b[xsFs@>xKyty{bvs@zvBxKya0zK[K@ nN
@zKdtyKdxuJvs@>@{JvNvyKab[xsFs@yK@0 \nvy\;KKyty@zKayKbONyKdz;vs }sFs@$k{7
zK[ty} uWsvX Fvyvs nyK@0z@@{];yKdnsv=s5KyKqvXns@zK>scvyz @z v7vsnJvBtFqvXns@zN

5=WvyyzKy{7Fy z[vyyKJvyKdzWb; yzKbyW@zKvy[xzKs@ns>>{]@z[vyvs }KyW xNu tnss@KytvsN

}[vnz vkxKFyvXxKyauWs@zKy;Wvs };WvXxKyWyKMuWyz[vJ
5@utns7vBxKy{Xz[vy0zKy;v]s vvXuWy5@Fy
nJvX FyR>@zKa vyWbs@ v@

ks@zKy[ nb[yK=[nyVu uWsvXxKy[vkxKyssvs$zk{7zKsv\vs }KyW
xK@ua|{]F=@z[vXnbs[n@KyzKs@KxW@yK>

{~uW zKsvkxKFyaxKduWNz;[nsFOy0nyz\}[v|{]F=7;xza yKKM x MxO[xKss@5{~xnbOsFyty

vXxKyWyKvb[nyzbynJvXns@zW$0 vytK@{ktyuWyu}yVyK[Ky[n@  5yz yz  b $0 ;@@zK
5[uWsK 
tVN~$ vXxa vk5xyKy b7=sNs@}KsvXnb@{7yzK[xNz;vyKd}[WvBxKyWyKO[0[vXns@zK=s5[Kby
vXtFy>@zKa7@z[vyvs xKyWWvy ybbs@Kyvs nssN$vVvXxKyWqv@t[[zKOy{kxKdzKs uWs@zKy;Wvs };sN|uW@y

4 of 18 1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html

s@zKy{];xKyK[yKd}Kss@=s@zvynybbs@KyRHuW@KzKas@[vsKvBxKya}N@zKdty@}Ks@[vkuW@KzKvXxKyuzKJvy5@{
bs@tyKdzu uWFMzKvB s@zN

5xtbK z Mx[vu K@tyz[vyz[vk}KszK@@zKa7yaKn=JvKyKdxKs@uWyW@ s@zKy@@{tv7vXxyz Mx[vsK5|yzKy

Nsyz}Ky0ns@0nzK@FV^X ~@zKvXxKyatsNu uyW}n9uatyb[ns@zs@zauWyN@{b@uWyvsbOy[v
vzKsvXnsNzvXxv~xu@zxFaW[vXtyazW[FOy yKJvy0z0Jvt@ny> vBx} dxKytsyK=@zKaFRFyz[vXtyK
Nsyz}Ky0n7@n[nsNzWsvXxyOyz[vB0nyKvsOs@uyWF=s@zKyW vBxqvXts@zKdus@t@[@yKyua}KsnyKdzOsFyK
yvXxK
y 0uy |tyKJvB y5@vs zKsvkz;vyyyzvXxKyWy[FynsNuyz[vs ybvy[xzKs@nsnb@ NzbyK
[ N vXns@zKKFMx xKa@zzK;tyK}nyW@KyN;vs uWyy;vXxnb@xuWNz\zsKvkts@}Ksv>s@uazKvyKvXx [vXtyR
@zK{\vss@WNsyz}y0 =tyK@u FK@vsusFzN

{]y;FOy ydzauWvXxKyuWvXnbzax MxO[xKss@>@zKa$xKyz{7yz[vVvsWvBxKyVz Fyt[ vts n[x NzW=@z

zKyttKvyWyzKzKyy0zKaJvBKyz;v{Vvss@=vXxKyW@zKby;00n[usvXxyauvXxyuWvXnbuO0s@tK
Ns@ @zK9uWvXxats@}nyu=7=@zWy[F; vBz;xK@nyzKyV}[v$xyz{]M ObsFytyKabs@ua[vyt{\sNzK
bs@uWy[vXxz9uaK[xauWs@tyaz;vytyJvXzK uWF;xzKyaz[vsxn[xFs@Wbs@n9[v tst@uwvBxKvKvvyua[vyKvs
bs@ FyW tsN} yu>^vyV$xn[xvXxKyauW[xzKyW ;K [xKy[yvXxKyWbs@[vXns@zN5xyOs@u;vy|xKa[nyN
zKsvXns@zs5OsN0tyJv@zKdzbs@0tyKqv0NvB0KyW@zK@nbyN ytyau nyK=bs@0tyJv k5xKyauW[xzKyWbs@ vyuy@
5xn7ybyKqvX FyN

{]K;byzsNxvsy;v=s@}atst@uauazy@0 ;Kytbs@u[vyt@zKanbOsKytyvXxKyW@uWFzK

Ks7y\sn@tyauWF;xzKyKvszuWy0nb@ [uanvyW@zKbyKay[nzKKhxKyz{7yz[vVvsMtKvyWb;xKssN
v 
y0y y; zvXxyaun@ 5{Jv@vyKaJvNzKdanvys^vyzWNz x;v0\z[yz[vBz9zyK)7s@0n
zK[nyvXxKyauW[xzKyK@Ns@ NzKdts@}nyuh0 vXzKvXxKyWOsFyvXxKvNKyKabsJvXts@zKM Wvs }KyW$ vvyzN



{XzNN^@ @BK^O{X@zKvs@zKyn} sNx O@zKsFyKs = ;xKyn@zKy svs@zKyWyKO[0}KyK
N Nn xKs = ;xKyn@zKy stynyKOyKvXxKyWJvvXKyKts@uwvXxKyWqvs@zKy H}yK@KzKvXxKyauW@0}nyW[Ky b@@z

ts@uwvBxKyauyzaxnuzK {Xzu uWsJvyKbqvvXnuWs@uWyz[vNvBxKyWbs^v7@tyazvBxKyWbs@ua[vy\yuyty
zvBxKyWb@uWy>zKOy{kxKduzKy9 vkzu uazK {Vy v\vBxKvk v7=@tyKWvXxytyazvXxKyauW[xzKy
7@ vXzKvs }yynyKby5@vK@zK9@znx;v]OyKyuy[uW@0nbyvs KWvsWyKya vvs FyvBxKya yK
bs@zK[ty;vysNu

^vyVWy*FyNvky0yny[a{JvNvyKvsbyzKas@[vbs@uWyWsvXxKyWbscv7@ty{kxK0 vtvyz@z

zKJvX0JvXns@zK@ [bb@KJJvyu Vz [vX vB y>@zKavy[v]y vs@Vb@ny@ xn[xa =JvBNvs u[00nbyR
$ny KOyKduWsNtyvBxK@zyK@tnvy kvssvXxKyt=$xKs xFa[ua @V[uW@  $@zK   
uaznbs@ua[vyt5xKyKOyWFRFyz[vXtyzWbscv7@tyWy[yz;vXK@ WvB0zKy9z[vsvXxKyay0y y;WFyt[ns@zsvXx y \z
s@KytvXzKaJJvyu>$x ;x}Kyb@uWyW Kytbs@zK@ 0[KbOyKb=nbJvy kbsu@z[ yKs@nyW7@z[vyd vVvXxKv|{
zKy[yzn[xyKdu x k@{XzJvy {sv=0sN}W7s@0zs@  V@0K [vtvXzKdy0yny; \z s@zvXxKy{Xz;vy0zy[v
@zK NzKd v\vs }Kyatyn@}nyW@zKvs 0zn@tyatybyK@t[xW@nbvXns@zK=7y 5xn=7=@tyKvVz@z
Fy tyKNtMz5zK>Nt@zK {]OF zKsts@}KsvxKyy>s@V@z[FxKytyazyK@X

vXV}[WvXxKyWy@0 h@F{]MtsFzzK5FMxy\z tynyKbyK=ytyFy[KObyKOJ@zKdu vtvXny

tsOyJvs5s@zKyWbss@zxFduWs@zKy[@zKabs@uWyWJvctV}[vVvXxKyatsN} yuvky0yny[F=@n7F=s^nbyW[Kby
tvXxKy5vBxK@zuWs@zKy;vBxKytyW[z vktss@uwsNvXxyaxKyvXxKyatsO0yKJvkzKyyKyK@bsxKyzvXxKyWsvXxys@zKyt
sV5 z n[tsJJvyuW;xKs7y9{@HuaKyaKvVvBxKyW[xK@zKbyvs=0sNzvXxKyu Rv|5z@vXxKyans@zK9xs@t
bs@z[vXzyKdz;vsWvBxKyWyK@0 F=s57s@0JvvXns@zK=@zKdKytbs@zNbs@u[vyt>@zK{kxKFyWyzJsyK
K@vXn[KvXzKdzvBxKyW[tyKvB s@zWs5F@zKOyKdun[sNtsbyKbOs@5vy[xzsNnsnyK=@zK{Xz[vy0zKy;v\vyK[xzKs@ sny
[K;xH@zKz

rKts@u@[vXx 5{VvX0KJvk vk =; yNvXxKv|{@uzKsv [K vyN>{~xKyWNn7\tvBxKyVxKaJvXts@z9}Ky y;z

vXxKy@KyWsvBxKyWb[nyz;vX n=byK@t[xsNvX0;vXxWNz9zvXxKyW@} vts5tyKvyzzKyKy0zvs }0zKduWvy0n@
tstybKFMxy{XzKKqvX0nNNy;Fs@[vXns@zxFuauy[t@} usKyKay[ys@zKyn yWsyvXxKyanJvbs@ny
xzKMtyKFy@t>@zK{@ K=y[@KyKJvyKdub@tyKy5vsz[Fs@ FyvXxya} Mzs5sNvBxK$xnyWbs@[vXns@zKvs
tyK@tsN} yuW>s@zKyasN} yuvWvXuWyN

{~xKyazKsvk}KyKyzM O@Ks@z;vyK
|7s@0WxKxKdus@tyauaKJvVvXxK@z{~xFay;Fy|xKs@Kys@\@zKdxK
}KyKyzaus@tyW y KbyvBxK@z{bs@ndxKFyatyFOsNz@} y;NyKJvy5>{~xKyW[Kyz;v\vBxKyanFqv|yK@t=JvB
vX@zvsWntyWsN;v~xsF*vs uW@yWbs@ua[vyt=ty @}nyW{]7@z;v\vBxKyu vs }K y vXxKy;NyazKsv~zyK@0
vXxKytyFy;v @zKdxKs*vs uW@yvXxyu;uanyvsKb y s@[vXxKvkxKuWy[v$ vXxWy[yzanyKbty vX y
[KObyKb q \y[ vyWbs@uWyatstyb@vXxKyats@}nyuvXxKvktyu@zWbyKyuy[yzauWs@tyW@z[vXzK

5 of 18 1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html

[v$xny{]NtyWsvBxKyaus@t@KMnyuauW;0ts@zKMzvyK[xzs@ s =bs@zKbyKyzKbyznyny

7yNsNzyKby@t[x5{ndzKsvy[NyKJvVvXxKv|{7s@nabs@z[tsNz;v];K[xanb[KyzausFznyn@sNVvk yJvkzKsv
bsOsFs@z@

[y0xK@K vk =@n7FxK@tvsbyKyvBxKya}ny|uaKJv$xnyFs@WNtyazvXxKys@vy[s5;xK@zKy@rNzvs

zKytJvNzvBxKyWbs@zKbyKyzKbys5s@|z;Fyz[vXns@zK=$xnyW7yW@tyazvXxyat@[vXtyWs5nbOsKy@zK
zzKsFvXns@zWbyKyuvs }KyWOsNuauWs@z@ vsK5O[nyz[vB qv=NzvyK[xzKs@ snJv[7yaxKya s@zKd}KyyzW0 Fyza}[
vXxKyWsyt@t[xzKay[tyvs zKs*vXxKvkn7vBxKyazKvXtyWs5b; yzKbyR =KyJv0VzKsvJvs@zKvszKsvXnbyvXxKvVvXxy
tstybvs zyK7y\@zKduWs@tyaKs7y;vyK;xzKs@nsFM y=b@zvNyWs@z yWsK v=s$z@

{~xKyansNz9ty@nyKvXxKvVvXxy} aNzbyKzaz;s@0uWKvB s@zvy[xzKs@nsbs@uWyazKsvVts@uwvBxKyW7s@0$s

b s@ua[vy\O[nyz[vB qv>Os@u[vyV@t[x vyJv>s@\ynyKJvB0 ONyzKMzyKyt\};v\ts@uwvXxKvsx[[nb@Kb; yz[vXnJvK
5xKyax[[n[nJvvyxKyz s@ Nu Nz9ts; 5b[n[xKyz[vBtsFMKby9uWyVzvBxKyWyK@0 h@Nvs[xKs
vXxKys@Nz9zsNzzKy@\JJvyuWK@{XzvXxy9@F5{k y@0zKyKa@}Ks@[vbs@uany[JJvyuts@ubs@z[ytbvXns@zK
$ vX x \@zz[ nNvBxKya}ns@ snJv|vX@v~@[cuW@z@vXxKy 5s@}KyJnNtyKvyax[F[n[nJv =0t|y k@zz>@zK
svXxKytK

ksJvktyKOyz[vB  5O[ ;xKyV@zKvXxKyWynyJvX0nb@KyzKzKyyVNzy[Nnbyax[F[n[nJ v k@0WNyyKdxKFy
}KyKyzW NzKduyazK; x;v~z[vsWvXxyzK;tyK}nyaKsb;} vXnyK=sus@nyK;nNVynyJvXts@znb

{Xzaus$zWsN0;>=bsy[nzKyVsvXxtyyaua ;tsNtsbyKObs@\@t[x vyKJvBtyKk 

]\nbsJK>@zK |

@zKaFvXxyWyK; zyVs5by[yt@uanyuWyz[vvXnsNz7vBxKytyst{0 Fya}yKyzWcs@tyyKy@zKJvXxK@zK
bK@z[v@zKOyW$ vX x ksFs@tyR rsNVybyK kssNtyR n xF=bs@0tyJvX tynJvyvBxKyWy[@Ks@zKyz[vXn@
tvyWsuasKyuWyz;v]s5byua OsNzKJvsNvy[xzsNns
Vz[vXnJvVFyN{k}Kyny[yKvXxKvVvXxKyatvys
F@zKOyKty qvyKd}[ kss@tynn unx;v]Os@z[vXzKyWs@z z[vBtsNx a5[>$xyzWbs@uWyax[F; ON
ua v=7s@nd}KyKzvs}KyatyK[xyK5>{tv]zsKvs@}[@ s@7vs uWyvXxKv zKy*vyK;xzKs@nsFR7s@n@00 yz
vXuWyvs yKyaKys@0uW@zKbyW@zK[zKa[uWssKvBx >

[vk}KyKO@KbyWsvXxKyatybyz;vktN a@zKdtnb@tstybzuWs@nyK[ @VynyKJvBts@znb$xKytyaz NnK@

vs@u=@zKduWs@ y[nyKtynFOya vXxsFMtNxnb@ tzvBt@zK[nJvs@t@zKdtynvyKdzK@zKsOb@ y

vy[xzKs@nsnyK7yW[xKs@nd}KyW@}nyvs uWyy[vs@\y;FbyyKvXxKykss@tynn tvyWststybs@VNzsKvBxKy 
Fy@tKa >yW@tyay Wvs }KyW@}nyvs}n9uW[xzKy\zWK@z[vB v>ua s@zvXuWyK=s7y
7vBxKyaKytbs@zK@Kbs@ua[vyt=svsa[[cn[nyz;v\vs u yuyz[vVvXxKyWMtyK@uWsyK@zK ~s@tyKK

5vXxn=yzKs@0uWs@K=bs@u[vXzKdKs7yn=bs@ua}zKyKa$ vXxvXxyuW@znvX FyW@zKbysvXxyax[F; O@

b[nyzbyK=@zKvXxKyazyK=yKyazKytJv@zKMzzWyzKy[vB O>yzKs@0uWsN7vBt@zKJs@0uWvX FyasFy| }KyzK
znyK[xyK5F5xKyKOyOs@u}zKvB s@zK=s@KyzvBxKyWs@Ks@vXz vWvsbs@uany[vy tyKy[nzvXxKyWsN @@s@|}Ky[vvy
s@\sNtOy55xKyaty OKvBz@zKay;Fs@ NzKdtsbyKObyKvXxv~xKya}KyKyzWbs@z[zKyvsWvXxyazKvXt@KsN a@ty
@}Ks@[vVvs }yKbs@uWyatyK@uWsxu@zWyzKyKFs@X

{XzWyK; zzOsKcvNy@zKduan[ts@tsbybbs@t{~xKyazKy[y|xKvXxKyyKyzKvXxKv|{7yK[nzz@z

z[vynyz;v~uW[xzKy@5xKyWbscv7@tyW@zKdxK@t@tya =bstnyWNzvBxKyWb@K@} vB y=sKvBxKyauWF;xzKyvs
vBxz bs[nyK@0 @}Kbyz;v\vBxKv0>y;FyzWF= sFO[} vtNvBx xK=@n7F=byyuWyKFyW@|zvBxKy[vBtyN
[vkzKs=$ vXxvXxKyasF;KyKqv]sxu@zJny[FyKbs@ua[vBz9sFy|zW@}Ks@[v WFy@t>zKyK ny[KyKqv
vby J@vXxKv|{~uW }KyW7s@0zKvs[tyvyvss@nxn[xW$yzK@}nyvXxyOs@zKJvX0JvXns@zsvBxKyvyK;xzKs@nsWvXxKv
uWK tynbyWs@\;KyK; yK

sF)s {\yKyK@}Ks@[vVvXxn 
5y zKOs@us@v@}nyN 5NzKaJvX0nyKduyz[vXty
b@tyKy5vs }ndtynN} yWOsKcvNtyWqFJvyuW\ vbyyuWvs uWyauWsNtyvBxK@zay vBxKvVvXxn[vBtyW$zKsv
7s@0$s@[vyK=bs@uWyaKyKs@nyauWK uWzKyN  ytbs@zK@Ky;Ny0nyzKOyW[KyKJvyvyzvs
sFytyKJvBuWvyWs@VyK; Mz@} vB yK

7 yzvXxKyazK[ty}nyaKs7y\svXxKybyazKy*vyK;xzKs@nsFM y>;xKs@nz vya}KyW[KzKdxKs)7yWb@za}KyJv

bsy[@ qv$ vXxvXxKyu 7z9 5s@Vs$zWy[vXzKJvXns@za = y >s@Vy[yzaKsb[}nys@[vbs@uWyWs5s@
vy[xzKs@nsnb@Ky;Fyns@uWyz;v0>[xs@ Mz v7yatsFOyKy vBxMtyKvb@[vXns@z

5xKyWtyNu sKsN}sKvB On@tJvNvXxKvkz[vynyz[vku[xzyK=b@zWss@V7s@0=sN|K@ns$zKdK yK=s

nyn[tyR\tyJvs@0zKdKvsyzNFNy[vkzx xnJvs@s5[[xa yK
  cNqNH7ysNty
5bs@zW7@0zK B{XzvXxKyW@uWyWs yWNzy;Fs@[vXns@zvBxKyy@tyvBxtyKyanFyt=v\vBxKyv@}ny5Vxu@za}Kyz

6 of 18 1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html

zKvXtyR>@zKduW[xzKyK@{@uw0ua s@zvXxy; yWsKzKvBtyNM[vkzKvXy5{[K;KyKqv0\n=s@zvBxKyW[nyWsvXxKy

uWF;xzKyKK 5=7yaxKyWbyyz ~s@tyK=tyKy\}y y;NzKa7yauW7yzKsv];N yvBxKyWyzbs@z[vy\ vXx
vXxKyW;Ky0ns@|ts@}Ksv];KyK; yK

5s)bss@zOsN a[[xWNzaz[vynyz[vktsN}sv~}ya} v k5xKyWbs@uaz@zKbyzWbs@ua[vXzKdKs7y\OyKyu

vs uW@ya vkKsb[}nya}[a >zs@zKOyW@zz[vynyz[vkts@}Ksv]y;NnJv\ vkns@z ;u@KJvyvsts@}Ksv
[Ky[nyKvs@zaz[vynyz[vktsN}sKvVvBxKv]O@zuW@yWy;Fs@ FyKabs@nys vby

gOyKbs@zKaty@usts@}KsvXnb vXxKvyW$tK@ tynbyWs@tby yK=$ vXxWs@|ts@}KsvXn7vyK[xzKs@ s

[xny[@z9zyK@uauWsN v@ vt };s$znsFMzs@Vbs@zKO[nsN[zKyKObyK;k vknvXxntsbyKO7vBxK
v \@zz[

vXxzyW$KtK@ y[vkKbyvs@zKvXxKvk@K tyKyny@z[vX y;v@nz]NWKM0 
=RqN   y@tya}yKzzzKvsbyKyaz[vXuWvXns@zK=sKvBxnzvXxKyauan@z[vvXns@zs5bs@ua[vyVy[@nbyKz[vs
vXxKyaxu@za}Ks>KJvBtvyKas@zvXxKy bsFy s $Xa > 

[vk 57yW@tyWs$znsyKdz[vssN5vyK[xzKs@ s>xKv]@tyvBxKyW[xK@zKbyvXxKv7yW$[vXxytyKcvy}Ky

s@tby yK=s@\y;FyzxuWNz ${tvbyKyuW7vs uWy@uWs@tyay WvXxKv sN}sKvB =y;NnJvyzKbyWsN dzKsvk}KyayW
xuW@zWsNzyazW@z[byzKbyvXxKvyazKytJv@zK>NvXxKvVvXxysN}sKvs@n9zazKsOyzKOy}yWsN\;xntyz@vXxKv
s@zvBxnKvBxs@|xuW@z vt uW7y}ya sJvJ

yzKy[vB =yzKzKyy0zKdts@ua OyKvs ty;Fs@[vXns@znyW ; vBtya}[ zK[ty[zKa[ts@@nyn=$xnyatyK[zK

vXxKyaKOyWsKyKJvB ; yK[Vvs[tyvyvyzsvBxKs@Kb@zK=szKsFyK[yK[nyK=s}KJvy0n\n@z[vNN0KOyK@zK
@zu@n[VvstynbyatytsKqvXnsNzR>s@\;nyuWyz[vk v>$ vXxW[ns@zzKVvs[tyvyW[tys@uW@z[nbybyK
zK[tyF;zs@| yW[K@zW@zKasN\N vts y@zKduaK[xR\uaK[xauWsNyN yazsF zKs)$ vXxWby v@z;vt
vXxKvVvXxKybyatss@zKa[xK@zKyzvXxya} s@nsnb@Kb; yzKby@tyauauzKyz[v@zKa$[xK@ yzKyW@Ks@
zKsvXns@zK=s5$xKvk ya 

NyK[xzKs@ sny;K[xWxuWNzW[ns@zzKdxKFyazaK@vXn[n@t@nbys@V7@tyzKyKb=svXxyatss@zKay;vXxnb@
@zKdus@t@nb[yK=7ybyN>{tt@s@Vy[F@uany7yW7ytyvs yKyzzKyKy\s@tOy Fyz[vsby;FytNbyNKvy
@zKdzKyKMK@K[Ky[nyKK;zKvXxyaKs7yVs5yzKy[vB =yzzKyKy0z@NvBxKyzW7yWsN vXxtyKvyzvBxKyazKsvXns@zWsK
yK@ vtWvXxv~nvXxKyybs@0zytJvsNzyWsK5s@Vyus;tFq>

7 yzvXxKyazK[ty}nyaKs7y\s5yzKy[vB =yzzKyKy0zK@\ v0nzs[0nbyvXxKvVvXxKytyW@tyW[nz nb@z[vby[vt

nb[Kyza vKby@
|W0nyzuWs@ bsNzKtyKOyz[vB OsFtsvy@ s@zKa$ vBx z[vy  bsNzK>@zWyK vs@0n@
vXxKvkts@ y=NzWybs@ snb@;NnyK)s5bs@uWyWsKvBxKyKOyW@zKyKuWs@zKvXxKyVbs@zKOy0zKNvBxK v vXxyazKyK
}Ksv@z[@ MzKvXxKyWy;Fy s@uWyz[vsK @z[v vBxvXxKyVyKbs@zsNuan\zsKvy;Fs@[vXns@zK@[KbOyKb 0NyKy  

NNnyWs@N7s svNz y 7Ky > us@ nsNzONtyy|xK}KyKyzs[KOyKas@zyzKytRNz9tybs@tOy
y[cn[nyzJ }[Wv@zKa$xKs@ny0JFJvyuw@nyK)sxuW@zHuWyWJJvyuW[[K;x$xKs@ny0JFqvyu NnyK)s^vyz
zK=[uany[uW@v]OsN[vB s@zKvssvXxKyt$nbyWbyyuazK  ^ ; v~tsN} yuW>@zKdnby[ @ny9xyty
y


^vy|tyKzKvXxKybs@zKyK vs@0n@{]O @zWs@yd}[7tyKJvy0}tss@WzVN |  [   
 5syua}Ky7> @}Ks@[vyzy[vXnb@ yzKzKyyty;ts@K\zKy5vXxyaxKyKzKy5 Jrs ss@vXxKyarK;vXty
Ns@uyV0 OyW$xKFya} v0Jz@ vNuaz
VznyKbvBxK
y [K vy=$zN 

tyuWsN@zK z[vybsNzK [K vyK

5yv@z zsKvJ@{k}Kyny[yW7yW@7s@nMtyKyvXxKvs@nyz0nbyR
$ vXxa v} v0HzN v@uazVV ts@}K@} ssFvXxz@\ 5y;Fyns@Ky vBxts@KyVb@tyW@zKdtyK[yKJvVsN
vXxKyay @zKytzuWsNzKayzKyK=[tsb=[yK[nyK}Ks@zK@0nyKK

57@tyzKyKb=svXxy@zKytzxKytyz;v~zWyzy[vXn=yzzKyKy0z9n}KyKMzzzKvsts >ty[ yJvydzvXxKy

bsNzKKy vs@0 @ 5xKyWyzKyt@}n =7@tyWs>@zKdzKyFqN}sN;v0>yzKy;vXnb@ uWs nyKsFs>@zK
byyuW7vs }KyatyqyJvXzKvXxKyazsKvB s@zvXxKv[[xss=[xKs@nd}KyaKyu vtvyKvs }yazn@}KynyK

[vyzy[vXn=yzzKyKy0zvyK[xzKs@ s n=@tyWFyW@VNns@zK5R5vXxKybsNzKzKsvyRNvBxKy 5 xK

@ty@tsFyaN}s@[v yzKy;vXnb@ yzKzKyytyKa[sN7s@zua vyKdty ybykuWs@tyvXxK@zaxK@ 5sKvBxKy
7s@0n@ =bs@}KyK@zK=@zKaWvXxs v=bs@0zazKs)bs@z[v@zWyzKy=[nbyKdzts@usvXxKy5s@0u=s yN

hxnyvXxKyy@tyauW@z[ us@v@z[vk O[KyxytyR\usFzauO0sNVbs@zKOy0zW$ vXxWyzKy[vB =yzzKyKy0z9n

zK@0ts7yb@vXxKvk v]M yKvXxKyasFy$xKy;vXxKyua v@0 FO[nyz;v@ >s@zWy}ytvyvy0ts@0nJvFqv|
vs;tyKvyWhx v y  yN

7 of 18 1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html

5xKyauWNz;7s@zKytszK@zsKvyK[xzKs@ sytytqv~uWzKyKd}[WvBxKy 5s@}KyJ @tyvyax[[n[nJvk5n[xK@t

ry;NzuW@zazW;KyKy[xaxKyWFyazd K>>[}KbyKMKyz;vX }n[xKyKdzyvXxKyvB vB y 5xKytyR  yz[vts
Nss@uvVvXxKyasvtvsNu  V5xKya}Kss@=vXxKvkuWyW }nduatyb[ns@zWsNzauWyVzvXxyaun@B @>F 0n


ty;Nny N

@X[@^K=zxn[xaxKyWyKO[0}KyKd}Ky@[vX  xKs uWNznKvB s@zWsuWKvvyVvVvXxKy
vs@unny[yKbs@ a[tyvyW [vsN @z;vXtyWs5@}z@zKby$xKytyHJv@}Ks@[vy[FyKvBxzKabs@n9}yauy
[xKy@ >@zKa@usJv@z[ uWz@} yWM OyKbyWs@x[F; ONts@}nyuOsN d}KyWOsN FydK[zK
zK@zKsvy[xzKs@ns@zKaN vX n[n@z[vynyzbyKK

g;}KbyKyz[vk}KssN;> NN cNF@X kN F@KJN \ @^K=xn[xty;NnyVbs$tsvy
uzKyOs@uyWsvXxy;xK@zKy7vBxKvkunx[vVvNyanbyazWs@0 axKytyWyaxK9uWs@nyK[n@J y;Fy
bOyua}nytK 5Obyua}nyt=OsN duW@yaKsb[}nyazK[ty} s bsJvbs@n@sFy[ty7s@\ONzbyV@zK
vXxKyWOsNuauWs@zOsNnd}[@KuWyz;vvXns@zsvBxKyaxuW@zuauazKyWJJvyuyKbOyz[vB @ bs@u y;vyW[nyK@zs
vXxKyWyz[Nts@zuWyz;v0\zK[yK} zKy[@KyzK; yaKs[y[v[ytbs@ua[vyt7zJv0Nz; tsKJvsN d}Ky
uWNz[JvBt@}nya}[bbyu} yt=KvbsJvkzKsyKvy5vXxNzvXxKvs57ss[Kby;nx[vkuWs@tyWFObyKO[}ny
vXxK@zvXt@zKOsFOyK@znvXtFy[vs@zKdtyKJvs@tKvB s@zWs5y[vXzKJv[Ky[nyK

{~tyuWyua}KyyKyzKass@}Ks@[vkzNzsKvyK[xzKs@ scvy|tyFMzK N
@X[@^K 5=Wvy[xzKs@nsnJv0
v]KyauyWbyzbyWs5b@u vXxKvkn\zK@zKsvyK[xzKs@ s;xKs7yKdKvXxKvkzK[ty}nyatstyb=7
Ksb[}ny@zKdzyKy9y0xK@KzKy;N v@}nyN>{tzK@zKsvy[xzKs@ns7=s@5[vXtyNvBxKyz{nz vVyKytybby
vsOs@ yWbs uW@z[ ts@}nyuWzvBxKyatybyz[vJ@{7s@nay[vVv s ty;Nnyn;vs@n@z[vXtyazWKyvBuWy|{
ua x;v]=7yKyzJ0s yaus@tyazvXxKyaxKytyW@zKdzKs@{tvnzR vku@yWbyzby FyzaxnNn[ns@zNvsJvK 
@znx[v0N[vBxKyvXuWyN

ty;Nny Nn[ns@z@nbs nyvs nsvsK5ssFzN@{7s@nasbb[ns@zK@ y;vVvsyKb;0}yvBxKyW7s@zKyt=s

zK@zKsvy[xzKs@nsWvssvBxKyt=$xs xKdzKsvkxKyK@tas vJcvyvy[zKvBxKyu $ vXxW@;vXxKyvXxzK |  ty;Nny
yKO[0}KyK{7s@na FyW xKs@uWyKs@0$FO[nzuWyz;v]sus$z5    byazK@zKsvy[xzKs@nsWvs;tyKvyW
F@uatyVs@\y;KvXt[tyKM v[yKvyW@zWNz;vXnsvyN

h vXxvXxKybyW7s@zKyt=b@uWy; y@\Nzyt>s5$xn[x{7=F;[vy 7@ty@5{b@ av

zK@zKsvy[xzKs@nsbs@z[ytyzKbyaz9@  yWONzR v[u ss@\O[nyzKOyWNz9zsKvsN0 @}sN;v\vBxKyKOy
y[vBx O@ O[KyK   ;v~u[}byKMKyz[vOsNz;FybvXnsNz vXxax[F; ; qv=bs@z[NzKOyKduWyvBxKv
zK@zKsvy[xzKs@ns ua Mx[vkzKsv]y;Fyzs@0sN>vk yJv0\ v7s@nzR v7s@0$@z[KvBuWyWbss@zN>5xKs@vX
vXxKytyKcvy{~uWsFyvs
sNns@tsNvs;Kz$s@0{~xOy[vkNzvBxKys[su7s@0$[x cvyvs
bs^v7@tys@vXxKy{Xz;vy0zy[v0[Ky[ nb@ s@zanyKvXxKvk}Kyb@uyJF@zKzS

5xKyzR\nFqv[uauy\ts; 5b[n[xKy5vsNnduWyvXxKvkzK@zKsbb@nyauWsNnyK;n@\y yJvXts@znb=7zKs

tJvXnb@ 5xn=7ON )zKy7v~nyFqv\vs uWyNz {VvXxz=vs uW@z[ KyKs@ny@zKd v~tnb@ [xK@zKy


us@zns@zW@}Ks@[vkzK@zKsvyK;xzKs@ns>>{tv]Oyz[vkuWya}K[=vs @
NX;Nc |@ytyFMz |ty[@ny =sN0
^vyuWs@tyvXxNzd[WFy@t5{7=n[uWFyvs tyK@nyaxsF vtvXny{kxK9tyuWyua}KytyasK vnyzvXx[
byJvXns@zONnyK  V@zKyt=Nz sNyK 7zK[KMzKa O[Kb; s@zWsxKs zK@zKsvy[xzKs@nsnyK=b@za}KyKOsNuWy
yzKzKys5yJvX0JvXns@zN k{XzKyyK@Vzu tyyKzKasvXxn=b@[vXns@zK@ uvy0n@[vs{]@uqvX0K;W}[
xKs zK@ yWbs@uWyWsK |ty;NnynOKyKMK@t9ts@Ksb@ =byyu>@zKdxKs uaK[xWtyvy{NJKyvXxKyW@zKyt
vs }yazKs*vXxK@zWy[FyzaxKyWbyKyuWyKvsWvBxKyz@
 K@zKaNz;vXn[KvyKa@zKayb[0}Ky9uW@z[Wvy[xznb@K@zK
Ks@ vB ONts@}nyuW=$ vXxazK@zKsvy[xzKs@ns ty;NnyVJv@vyKvXxKyars@tyK[nx[v|{XzJvX vX[vyazvXxynvyd@F vs
xKyatyK@tyWbs[ny[vtWs@\@z[vB ;KvyKaF@zKOyKvy[xzKs@nsnyK k7uWsJvkuKs@v@z[v0\zNzsvyK;xzKs@ sR> 

5xKyWyzK@}zKd}tyNOvXxts@xvsbbyua}nyt=byyuWM vyay $ vXxzvXxKyazKy;Kv|WyK@tK ~s@nyK; @

ynyKqvXts@znbvXxKyazKy)[}[nynasKzNzsKvyK[xzKs@ sRxKyyazKM @nK@uWs@ y[nyK=@tyW[t[ vynyuyz[v
[xKs@nduWKvBtyWn[ @zKd}Kybs@uWyWyzKs@0uWs@K[ K[tvX FyW vBxzvBxnyKbyR>b@K;z @ty
zK[tyuyz[v@z[yKJvBuyz[vkzW@zK@zKsvy[xzsNnsnyK

Vz[s@vBzKvy >=$ vXxazK[nyNvy[xzKs@nsV v~n@VyK[nyvs[tyKvyyKJvB0KJvB yaKby7s@

zK@zKsvy[xzKs@nsWvXxK@zWbs@zKqvX0KJvB yWs@zKyKK 5@zKsvy[xzKs@ns xK=[nyK@|u v@Nzvy0ts@0nJvkKby>@zK
Fs@azKyKydzKsv~}yW[n[n@[vstynyKbyWuO[ y yJvX0JvX FyazK@zKsvyK[xzs@ snb@Ky[Nnby;K[xWy[@nbyK
b@za}Kya} v\vs }KyWbynyKJvB y yJvX0KqvX FyR>^yKJvBz@Ns@\y;F@uany>s@z OyvNzWyKsNxnb@K@tyKsN
ts@WsKys@ yWxKs@tyWyzKy[vBnb@ nJvXzKqvH

zauauWyKnvyWbs@zKOyKyzKOysvBxKyar@KJvB @za}K@t@zazWs@}[v@zzKvXxKyWMtyKvkKs7y\szK@zKsvy[xzKs@ns

n7vBxKv]ya0zWtya0 ;vXxKya0n[=vXxKv7yauanx[vyJvXtsWvXxya}nsF;xKytyWsNzW$x ;x@ yWyKyzK

8 of 18 1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html

 ty;NnyVy[@nNzKy
5

 n@z[v  vBx JnyKFy 7zKsus@tyWy;^ ; yz[vVvXxK@zvsn=bs@ @Vbyn=bs@ns@[vbs@uaKy;vyatyK@ @z[v

[ts7MzKvBxKya}nsF;xKytyW$ vXxW@zzKy}nys@ny@Ns@KxWs@uz s@ts@KH}KJvy0n bs@ns@[vbs@uaKy;vy
tyK@}Fqvy0nV5xKy[Os@ a[tyKdya} sz9sNnyzVtynbvyWO$ ^vX >@zKdtyKMKbyvXxKya} s[xKytyvs
Kqv~zW uWvtvy\s5K
V@zKysNtynbvs@t=bs@ny[ }KyvssWvs@KxR>[uW@@zK9N M
[tyzKvsJvs@vknyKJvk 57yauWNyazKs tyK@tvXns@zN yaxKFyvXts@} yWyzKs@KxWbs@z[vBtsNzKN0Kby
@zK0 vVnyK

uWsNzvBxKyWbszKsbOyz[vBKszK@zKsvyK;xzKs@ns@vXxnvXxtyKvkxK}Kybs@uWyzKs$zWvXxKy 0tss

ts@}nyu  V5xKs@KxauWbbyK=szKOs@z[vXts@ ydtynbvs@tzKyKydzKsv~}yWts@\ssy[NvBxKyvyu K
ss yuaxK[nyKvXxKvkty bvsNt=@}nyvssN} vytvya yaua x;v~}ya ybzK[0zKvXxK@zW[zKM yW[yK[ny
s5[t@}Ktb5xKy; uanx[vk}KyW;Ky s@|zW@zWy[sN[vB s@zK@byzKbyR\};v\vBxnzyKy9zKsvkuW@yvXxyu
F@K@}nyN

5xKyWtssWvBxtyKvkuWNyK=s@zKyvXxz9KyyJvX [nyNbyO@zzKsvKcs@tabyv@zzK=s5FO[nyz;v

$ vXxatynbvXzKabbyua}nytK

7tss7s@n;ty }KyWyyKb;zKayzKzKvss@|xuW@zWFyz[vXtyWs@zK@vXxRN@V7s@tbyvBxK@z

uWytytyWs@| Oy>@zKas@zKyvBxKv]OsN aJvyuwts@u;uanyanN}sNKvsN O[nyz[vJ |s@KK

{tvk uWsJvs5N[vBxKyaKs7y\s5yJvX0JvX FyWby tJtynbvXns@zzWyzKy[vXnb\zK@zKsvyK[xzsNns>@zKdts@}KsvXnb

 
vBxKv[xKs@na yaKK@Kby@@Ny Hty OvXnsNzanvXxKyauWsK=s@Kyt@zKMKs5yzy[vXn=yzKMzyKyz@
$xn[xaKOyKvXxKyauW[xzKysKvBxKyWby;vs ty OKvya vyK[nz>@zKvXxKya0uWyW@zKy|zKy0 @zKat
ss zazK@zKsvyK;xzKs@ns>>vs@0nyK=s0z0NuWs@Wts@}KsvyvXxKyas@t@VtynbvXzKas@ua[vKvBzvsyKOb@Ky
ts@uwvBxKyWy[vBxnb@Kbs@zKJvBt@z;vuaKsbyasNzvXxyu}[WvBxKyV[tyKvsNt>@tyW7yyKJv@}n[xyKdzs@Vb[nyzKby
nJvB s@za}Kss@=@zKdus@ yK>{tv~n=y[yzaKsb[}nyvXxKvby tJtynbvXns@zuW }KyauWs@tyz@uyz[v@[vBxK@zy
vXxKs@KMx[v0Nz9xyzKbyaxNtys@\y;FyzauaKsb[}nyvsOsNz;vXts@  yKbyz[v@vXn[nya}[avXK@vk@[^uW@z
z @RXvX vXnyK
XNy H@ynbvXns@z5 [y
z [y[vB y \s {tv nb[bby7vBxKyWnbbsFyWvXxKv @uazKs[n
Ky;vXnyWb@z @[vsOKv@ bya v=sFzWJNz[vBxKyK;   yWs@z vkKzsF xsF) yK[yKvXxn=N} vt n\}[v
@[^uWNzazKsvyvXxKvk v~uW xz[v v 0 ts@[vyvsby tJtyts[zKdus@nyK; @VJJvyu=s@zW }K[n@
$ny5vXxNzW vOs@z
0 ;W}KbyJK@0z5 

{XzvX0[vXxR>7yaxKyaxKdzaxK@zKsNFy@t=[ y@\@0zzK=svXxKyW@zKytzxKytyz[vkz yK[tyK

KzKs yyWs5 avyK;xzKs@ns ysKvBxKyaKsb[} vtsKzKs$nyyW@nsNzyWyzK@}zKdub=yJvX0JvXns@zN
[vVvXxKybyW7@0zzKxKyzR vk}KyKyzny }n[nyKVvBxKya}n= O[Kb; s@zKxKya}KyKyzW[ y@0
zKyKvyNFMxytyanzKs ts v~za}n[nKzKvXxyW@zKytK

5xKyazK[nyN\}ns@ snb@>@zKa[xyuanb@  
vy[xzKs@nsnyKKby9zKvBxOyz[vB7yNsNzsuWb
yKqvX0KqvXnsNzW7ytyW@zKa@tya @ty u v@>y[ynsNyKdzsKy0zuyz[vk @}Ks@tvsN0nyK@{XzW[xN0Wbs@z[vBtJv0
vXxKy5Jv00byz;vX avy[xzKs@nsnyKxKFyW[nyNVbs@uauWyt[n@KOyK=@zKaNtya}yzKay[yns@KyKa@usqv
y[[K[ Fy };bs@0Ks@tvyWyz;vy00 OyKK>{XzvXxn=FysvB0uxK@z[vbs@uuWyt[n@n[uNvyK[xzKs@ sa vBx
b[nyzbyW vxK@zu@nyz7n=y Fy0zKaby0 y=sK5@uWsJvkunb@z[yz[vB s@zKvBxKv]@tyvXxyausJv
xKyzKs@uyzK@ K;tKvB yWy[yVbyKyzNyWNtyWMtyKb; y t;zKvXxKyats@uanbyK=svXxKybyazKy
vy[xzKs@nsnyK=$ vXxzvXxKyazKs Hz[xK@ yzKyqFJvyus5ns@}K@Kb@ v@n[u@zKd vu@z s@ zK@z[ @
zKbyz;vX Fy@zKabs@uaKy;vX vX Fyatyb[tyK

5xnnvXxKyJvkus@uWyz;v~zvXxKyaxnJvs@sK5s@|n@zKy[vxKyzW@z[[Ky[nyK\}[ v=s$zFs@z[vNJvB s@z

xK}KyKOsNuWyWNzyvs vby VyKvsWJvkzua}Kyts5svXxytK

{tvkunx;v~}yWW@uan@tstyKO[nsNzRNvXt@zK;0zs@zauWNz;7s@0n n@zKy[v\zKy$ Ws@0uWyK>\n[n

ty[s@ yK=@ts@zKd v=Jv@0k yW[ns$ Ws@0uW[ @ ynsbbs@ntsbyKO[ns@zs5[tyvXtyy;Fs@ Fy[
z[vynyzbyWyuWytyK=$xn[xR>vk yJvkvsKs@z;v0>bs@z;yyzKs@0uWsN;N N;F@Ky@zKvXxKyz
vy[xzKs@ns z[yz[vyK5>{tv$zK=s@zvBxKyu vXxKvVvXxKytyW@tyW[K[xvXxzKn7=s5vXtyRNvXxKvVvXxyKby
nFO@z}yy[Fy@ yd}[y[@Ky0uWyz[v>@zKvXxKvkKzs$nyKyWsvBxKyKbyan7=b@za}KyauWya}KsvXxvsOFy
@zKvsWv@ya yKV}KsvXxWs@zztyKOyKyz[vyOb@nyKK>N[nyzKOyNvBxKy[ tybsznyt@z[vuuWyzKbyaKs7ytK
{XzWWn[x@vXxKy;[tyKvyW7s@0n@@ vy0zOsNz;vX0 F@zKbyK>NsNuWyan@zKy[v@[ NnvXnsNzOyKyvXxy\
vXxts@KMx\ byau v=s@zW$xKvkuW@zKaxKv~uaKqv~zsKvk}KyWsNzyNzOKy KbvXxtsNxvXxKyvXuWyWs

9 of 18 1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html

KynKvBxKytVzKsvbs K;bs@\Os 0Kyz[v\Ky0 ;xN



5xKv~n
5@0NNzR>$0 vXzKdzd @Vz 
~}Kss@ yKb;0}z9x Nn[ns@zWsvXxKyaxuW@z
;vXtyazW[Kby@@{]@u sNz zKs ty@nz9xKs)yyaxnz[nx[v7@zK9xs OsNy a{~uanbNz
ua O\xnFs@nby@rs@V@ vy sMKyzKOy5@FNzR =bs@z[vX0};vXnsNzW7zKsvknyKJvVvXxKvs5[uanyOs@uuWs@z
byzKby@zvvX0}[vyvBxKv0>@ns@zKa$ vXxaxua vt\uW@z[svXxKyanyKzKasFOvyK=svXxKy5Jv00byz;vX
vy[xzKs@nsnyK=byKyuwvs ;F

{~tyuWyua}KytsNu u;x xssFvXxKvkut@zKuWsvXxyV7qvXts@zK @zKJvVvXxKyWsy0KOyWsK

@z[vX}nsvXnbK>5xKyaxKa7s@0y;zbya}Ky[s@tyvXxKyJv s@0 a @VF= ztbyW@zKdxKabs@uauWsNzbyzby
vtvX vXKyvXxKvVv@KzKa@z[vX}nsvXnbVznyKO7vBxKy[ytyW@}Kbs@[vy zyKbybb@>7}Ks@Fs@N

{tvk zKsvVvXxKv[xyW7=NzWyzKyuststybK@5xyWb u[xtstyKOzW@z@uWsFq v yK@|zt[zK

b@tyKy0kut@zKKvBxKyn@}Ky;vXn\}yzKy; vyMtyKvX Wts@uwvBxKyautsKyKvXtyvXuWyz[v7vBxKvk}KyKb@uWy
F@ @}nyazx y;vXuy@[v[xy\yauW@z[ ny[yxKyKydKyKs@ny7s@ndts@}K@} WvXxzW vtyKvB
@0ts@z[vVs@|K\zs=Nvs }KyWy[nzzKa ts@}KsvXn  HtynbyuWyz;v];KyK; y $xyzW7yWs@}[Nns@K; xKyWbs
uaK[xvXts@}nyauW@KzKdtynvX Fy ;uanyvXxzKsN[>@zKabsu[xvXts@}nyauW@zKzK s@Vy[yz
zKytJvNzzK s@by FyK

{~ty@nyazKs*vXxKv[xKyaxKa@zWF@tyzKyb=svXxKyazKvXtyWsKvBxKyWs@tyVs y@zKsvBxKyazKyKOyKb; vsK

@z vBx@zKdty[KyJvXzKvXxKvs@tyXh vXxvXxntyK;KyKqv]OsNuWyzKyKOyKbON xua vtWvXxKv7yR> vBxs@
yK@0 B5Jvbyz[vX[x[vKNxR\n[$v]s@|Ky0 FMxyWbs@uuWs@zKbyzKby@ y=ts@zKydzvXx tyK;KyKqv0\n
s^vyza0 Mx[v0VzWF@zbyWsvXxKyWb[nyz[vX n=y[@ yzKOyN5xKyW; y@5t vt@zKdzKy[cn[nyzK[nyK=svXxKy
xuW@zHuWyWJJvyuWyaxKFya} v[xKs@na FyaK=@K@KbyVvXxKyt vtsvXxyWJFJvyuW{~xKy
7s@0yKas@zbyv@z xua}nyKuWyN

yW[xKs@ndxKFyanyK@0zyKa nyKbOs@zts@uwvXxKyauW@KzKasvXxKytJvKvs@un}Ks@ua}@zKvXxyatyK[ vBzKa@0uW

tbyN yWnz v]s7y;vXxKyz>@zKvXxy@tNnynvss@V[tyz[v[ vXKvB s@zW@tyvXts@}zK5

5xKyWy[cs@vVvs} vXxytJvvs@ua }Ks@ua}W7 y9};WvXxKya}0 @z[vkx;F[n[nJvVMNs@}Kyv7yzxKyuyX

7KyzxyuWyV7zKsv~zKvBt@ z[vytyKqvyKdzaKs@ vXnb};v~}yKb@uWyaK@z[ 7@tyWs5$xKvkxKy
Kyby FyaFvXxyWtFyvXxtyKvVvs yJvy0zW[ N vXns@zts@uwvXxKy5xtdNyn[x>vXxtyv];ty ty
}KyKO@KbyWsvXxKyaKsO[} vtWvXxK v  vXnyuanx[vs@}[v@zazK[nyK@V7yNsNzK
zKytM yKd}[WvXx =bs@zKOy0zVxKy
}ts@Kx;v~x =JvBts@zK9z[vynyKJv\Kb; s@zs@|x[[nb>@z;xK@0 ;uvXnnyKyt[xW[K v
s bs7n@uWs@zK
nyKa t@naNz;KbbybJKy;^s@v~};NzazK[ty}nyWbs@nyJvXns@zs5yKvkuzKvsn[ z[yz[vVvBxKy
}Ks@ua}N

hxKvk =qvX0KzKd xKs*vXx =y;^sNvbs@z;vXzKyKabszKvXt@ Kcvy5vBxKyaz vB @uaKy[vBK=7tyuWsFy5@{XzW


uWyKy[vBz;xKs@vX ^vy V \$ vXxWbs@uWyax[[n[nJv=$xKsy vVvBxKv~y0xK@KvXxyWy[cs@v[xKs@naJvs@
7KyzxyuWyVNKyKvsbs@z[vXzyN
 =JvKvyKdtyKbs@zWbyyuW= } vJvXt@zKy5VzKsvk}KyKO@KbyWsvXxKyyK@VsK
nNtyWb[K@ vXnyKts@u Nzaz[F; s@zWsH@K@zV}[vk}Kyb@KbyvXxy Vz vyK5vXns@zK>xn[xW7=bss@zvs }Ky
s@0uWyK>>[xKs@ dxKFys@tyzKs$nyKyWsK5vsNuan=7yK@Ks@zK us@tyay tybs@zvBxKyatsOyJvbs@z[vBzyK
n7vBxKyaus@uWyz;vXuwvBxKvkxK9} vkvXxKytJvvs@unvyJv0M0z vt>FzKy@0 vkxK@zK

yaKzsF*vBxKv~zatyK@0zvBxn7tJvKvs@unvyJvVvXxKyax[[n[nJvtsOyKyKyKayK; vyW n@tyazua}Ky\s

Ksb[}nyW@zKytKFMxy[7ytyaz vXnN 7s@00nyK@V}Kbys@zWb@n[ vXns@za}[ KNtNyny@vXxKv@z
vs@un=y[@ns[nsNzauanx[vby;v\tyvsWvXxyWKvBus;xKyty@ ty[@nbyKab@n[nvXns@ztyKOyKvXxKyW@zKyVsK
yKqvXtsNzKvXxys@0 vsWvXxtyKyRHzJua s@zW[xK@zKOyN NynyVbFxKyWFnvyV@}nyvsM ;unbvXxKy
ts[KyJvs5vXuWsF;xKy0 nz vXns@zWyz[vXty  7KyzxyuWyNvBxKs@Kx7=[[cn[nyz;vX bs@zKby0zKyKa@}Ks@[v
vXxKyaty[ vs@Mz vtWvBxKvkxKyW@0tNzyKsNV sFO[}nyWy[F[vXnsNzWsvXxKyWOsN;vXxKyKJvkK@vsvXxKyWqvvyWs
5yK ky[@nbszK>>s5bs@tbyRNvBxKytyWFvBxKyW[nyK@\@zKyVs5Jv@vBzzK[nyK@V@0utby@

h vXxzW uWsNz;vXxWsvXxKvVtJv>[KObyKOJ[vyJv0@v7svsNuan}Ks@u}yKJvBtsFyK ts[xuW@zK5b@S

Ns@uyWO[nyz[vXnJvxK;KyJvyvBxKv\vBxKya}Ks@ua};ua }KyWyuWsNzJvXtvy@\tvBxKyvXxK@zWts@KyasNz
H@K@zKybyW[ vXnyKb@zvBxKv\vBxns@nMtyKvX utsKyvXxKyW[x@zKbyKs@\@0uW=bs@z[vXts@KcvyvXxKyW@
}[vVvszKsF@ h vXxvXxyvBtyKRs [yN0 5@0}Ks@\qvX;ty[xazuWy0nb@zKRuazK\ v]s@n9xKya}KyKyz
Fy ^ ; v\s@  ty[nyz[v50uW@zvss@ty\yuWs@zKJvBtvXnsNzWsvXxyyK@Ks@zKtvXxyvXxK@zaKbyvXxyu
xKyWnvXxKyWy[tyvsM ;K yzKvBxKyW7@\@zbyvXxKya FyKvXxv]s@ dxKya}KyKyznsJvkz@z;
z[F[ns@zWsKJ@K@z7yqvXts@zK5Fy;vVvXxKyWsFy00nzKvX0[vXxWFts@}K@} Wy[uany5@5vXxKy
x[[n[nJvkrKtyyuW@z FOsNzanvyVb@n@ 5xKyatyKOsNzvXxKvk v7=ts@KyJKJvVvXxKvkzKs@}sFR xKvBxKy

10 of 18 1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html

bs@tyWs@vXxKysNty[nx[vVvsb zKs

{tv0nuaKs@v@z[vVvstyK@ yaxKs)[xKs[yKvXxyx[F; ; qv=7ytyazvXxKyWcvy0uWvXxWsvXxKya}sNua}zKas


ts[xuWs@zKJv | @5xKy[yKb;0}yWby0 y=sK5FyK=s5yuWsvXns@z5@tqv0>byzbyWs
 uWyz[vVvXxKvVvBxKya}Ks@u}WsN0yK>NvXxKyzaxKs@0ts@\v@;vXxKyaKys@ yvBxKvkxK9}yKyzanyK@@zKvXxKyz
bs@z[@zK;zyKyzKvXxv]s@zazKsbOs@z[v[xKs@na@zKsvXxKy}Ks@ua}a}KyWts@Ky5Ny;vsK5OsNtbyW@zKsvXxKy}sNua}
7=ts@Ky@>s@z 5b@sNz WvBxtyKyWK=Kcvy5vBxKya}Ks@u}zs ts[xuW


{Xz 5sFyua}Ky7 @vXxtyyaus@z[vBxK=^vy5vBxKyWvs@ua }Ks@ua}zK7KyzxKyuWyVJvss0ua }KyxzKvXxKy
b[nyz;vX n=vtvX vXKy>OK@zK@ B{tvknzsKvkKsb;} yvs }KyWO[nyz[vB qv~znyKbFs@a}Kyny[yvXxKvVvXxyzKs$nyKy
svXxKyW7s@0n@@zKvBxKyaKs7y\xn[xvXxn= FyK\n=WvXxzKa$x ;xn=sz;vX0zK[nF@Kyvs xuWNz vNz
vXxKvVFs@W@tyaK[zKd v\vs xKyazvXxKyW[tyKasKzKs$nyKyW@zKaNyzKvsWvNyvXxKyWbs@zbyKyzKOyKK 

7KyzxyuWyV7yz;v]s@zvs7s@0[$ vXxWsvXxKyt>s@zvXxKy5;xKyKOsNzR [ yz[vXxK@yKs@v0$xn[xR>5n[xK@t

5xKsy=bFzx tybyz;v~}sFs@
nJ@KK[ s@z7Wvs ty[yz[v; @zKyKJvBzKyazK[nyK@
@0utbyW vBxKs@[vktyKOsNvBzvs@0uWyKa7s@0nasFyzuyz[v JVvXxKy\[yKqvXns@zF=s@0us
tyzKn[xuyz[vszK[nyK@V7y@Ks@zK=7s@0W}[ zKvXns@z0Jvvy7vs@zaz[vy0zKvB s@zK@KyzKJ

5xntsNsb@nyKvsWvBxKya@0K[x @z$xn[xWF=[}ua vvyKvsvXxKyVz vy 5vB s@zKzzKyd }[v 

zKy[yVs@[vy BKy0xK@K}KyKONbyxKsyK=[yJvVy0zNtd@0K;xxKJzK; qvyKas@za}tyzzK
vXxKyan@zW$ vXxWbs@z[yz[vB s@zK@KONzJvXns@zK vXxyty}[ zy[@ vN} ss@uazKd v>y[yzvXxKs@x v7s@n @uWsFqv
byv@z xKya}KyKyzatyJ0yKJvyKd}[av@z qv~Kb; Nz;F7  bvXxKy\y;^sN vvs ts@uWsvyWbyzK[}nyWJvyK
vs7@tdz[vy0zKvXns@zK@nz9zK[nyK@|Ks7yvsty[yz;v]@zW@0utbyat@zWs@y vXxKy\s gsN vXnb=@zK
z[vyzK@KnJvX0Jv0sNVnJvXKJvk}[WvXxKyNs@ y;vKF5xKyWs@Ks@vXz vWvssNnvXxKyW@0uWtbyW7 sJv>@zK
Fyn[ 


N7sWyK@tnKvyVzd @>KyzxKyuWy\byyuWyKvsxKFyaty[xKyKa@zKsvXxyVJvyazaxn7vBxzKzK@
bNzK@ X{XzWbs@uWyWbs@vs5[0KyWOyzKOyW$xn[xazKsW@n@0 vtVzKs xus@VzKssytJvKvyuWyz;v]ONzW vy
y[vXzKn[xRNvXxKyax[F; ; JvxKFyaKzsFzW[z@zKvBxnn= zKs$nyKyvXxKy;b@zzKsvk sOyN 


{Xzd @@vXxKyNs@ y;v=y[@nsFyKa@zvsNu }Ks@u}@h \}KsvBxvBxKy @zKvXxKyNs@ y;v Vz s@zaxKvyKqvyK
x[FMtsyza}Ks@ua}K=[ v@}nys@Vy Fy }[@t[t^vJzKabsvXxKyazK; y@\@0uWtbya}KyKNz@

 FOsNzW[uuW@0nyvXxKy
5yK@0 aWFy@tsVzvXxyWs[uWyz;v@N
$t[=0 rKtyyuW@z 
b[nyz;vX n=vtvX vXKyKvXxKvk}ts@Kx;v~7vsWvXxyazK[nyK@|ty[ Oy5

X{kxKFyy vk vkuFOy F5xKyW vvyVszK; yNV7y@Ks@zKK>{tv~n0tyK; qvX} ya sNWbs@uWyvsWvBxKyu F=

b[nyz;vXnJvHFsyy v0nvXxKyyzFs@|xK@zKNvstynyKOyvBxnyzKytWvXxKvVynvXxKyWJvNtNvs y;vk vsFs@
}nzK5FNs Kys@0uwvBxKyKbyauat[nyK@vs ^vuns@zvs@zK=sts[Wz;vsWvBxKyW[b@{tvkn=bs@uy;vXxzKvXxKv
 FyyKs@nyW@z[nsNzWsua vN} yasFy@zK9 vkn\zWbs@uWyW7FVtyK;Ks@zK[}nys@VNKs@vXts@} y
vXxn$xKvVFs@aua Mx[vb@;vyK;xznb@K@0ts@zKbyRNvXxv]sytbs@uWyKKys@nyxKyzvBxKy[byyW$xKvVvXxKy;b@z
s vBxvBxKy|uzKK 

5s=FvXxyz7yW@tyW[tyvs@tszyK*vy[xzKs@nsnyK=@zKaJv@t=svXxKyauMzKy[vBty0 FyzvBxn

vXuWy};tyKvVzK@zK; @tyK7@t@zKans@}K@Kbs@uaKy;vX vXnsNzy[ vyvXxyW[nyK@\@zKyt\xK@t
y[@KvBzxKv~ vkuW }yayvsWvXWvs yaz7s@0nvBxKv~nvXxKyaty@nJvB =s@[vOs@uyWs5$xKvyWNty
[tyKvBz@zKduWFMzz5



{Xzd @ 5R^ V^@k 75q;^n }KyKNza;vtvXzKaVssNuWbK
 s;$sNza v=bsFyXrs@uWs@ty
vXxK@z WFy@t\ vkxK=[xKs$zW@zWyKJvBuWvyWsvXxKyatynKvB yazK[nyNV@zKyV7yaxKFybyK@Vty[nyKJvBzvBxKy
[xK@zKMzKdz[vy0zKvXns@zK@Kbs@zKM vB s@zK5xKyaxK@zKs@zvXxKyW; s[WxKyausyK vXuWyK=@zKvsJv@zKzK
v~zzyauz[vyKvsunznx;v0\ty;nyKqv]Os@z[vXzzKa@zKdtyK@K@zyts@uzK[nyK@V7yK@sNzK5xKyatybyz;v
 vXns@zsV{XzKM @zK @ qv@zvsWvXxyanJvszK; y@KsytxKz[tyKbyvXxKyvXxtyKvsKM@yWsKvBxKy
zKs@zts@ ytKvB s@zWs@>@zKvXxn=@zKy\ty;nyKqvyKd}[ uWsNzKvXxKyaxNz=[nsFOyvs uanznx[vkz


{XzWsN5vBuWyVxKs u [xW@zKy\s7yFOy\zsvNJKJvVtsNu zK[nyNV7y@Ks@zKV}[vVts@u@KsvXxyKby

vy[xzKs@nsnyK sF x xW@tyvXxyy;KvBzJvXns@z0n[

11 of 18 1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html

5xKyaxnsbs@xKyJsNxz by[ yaxF=JvBKnyKvXx =yKJvB s@zW@zKabs@zK[KyvBxKvVvXxKya0n[$sxuW@z

y[vXzKJvXns@za =vknyKJv  Kybyz[v $xnyaN y}Kyny[yK=7yaxKy }Ky[vvyvXxK@zWy[yzW[xK@zbyWs
uWNzK9 vVvXxsNx $ vXxvXxyOFyKvVvXxKvkxKyaxF0NnK}KyKyzb;Kbys}KyzKaNzWs@[vXuanJvH 5sv
s@z NtyvBxKyKOyWyKJvXuWvyKzKsvyzKbs@tzK@V}[vVvXxKy;s zsKvkzK[KyvXxKyats@}K@} vtsu@z[ xsN0
s@[vbs@uWyKvXxKvknyW[xKs@vs5y[vXzKJvXns@zN

rby vXxW[K[xWbbyb[uWyz[vbs@uyWOy0ns@KKyKs@nyW@tyW@yK[KyKqvXzKvXxKv7yW[ua usy

}Ky[s@zK K@vXxWMn[K Ksb[}nyN yW7s@nOs@ s@znyvXxKyW@nK K;zKsNz 5yuW@zzats@}KyK
$xn[xaxKs@ts@u Jv@\qFJvyuwvsJvNVJJvyuVtynbvXzKavXxKy[s>F5xnqvyW$K@usqv]Oyv@z }Ky
zKyKOyKbON } s@zFy@t7ts@uzKs s@Vbss@zKy| 5s@\OsNn@VJFqvyun=nbJvBtsN[ uaKJvyKd}[WvXxKy
uKyzKzKabs@ ; s@zWs5sN\@nK vBxvBxKyzKts@uWyK@nK$ vXxzvXxKyazy[Kv  }ns@zFyK@t X\}[vk
7yv@yat7yK@zK ks@tFyK=vVvXxKyV7s@td vkunx[vk}KyazyKbybb@ }[WvBxKyaunM yWsvXx =byz[vX>

hxKv@tyvXxKyauWs@t@uanbvXns@zKxKyty ${t5yuaKqv~uWsFya}y[Fs@z K@vBxvBxnMn[K zs@ty5s@5vBxKy

[Ky[nyKvs[@ y>xKsOby[v7vBxKyatyK;Ks@zK[} vWs@5vBxKyvysvBxKsbyXuWsJvsKKcvy\@ $xKs@ty
ny[^vk}KyxzK
7zy;Fyz 5yObvtvy5vsWvXxyqv@tV ;z vk v~y WvBxKv7yauWKWvNyWs@ts@}nyuW vXxaK
k5xKyvyWs5sN\;KyK[nys@
s@5z@\nvyNvXxKvVvXxy[ xKys@ s7ydK z K@vXxW@zKas@5vyazvBxKyW@nK
byyuzKy;KvX0nb@} zy5

zKsvXxKyny nvsytyKJvby0nyK=s5[x y 7vsy;yzKaFNzKqv]y[xWsKMvXxKyW@zKyts@KvyK;xzKs@nsnyKKFMxy

vXtvyn Vy[yzby{Xz vXnvX FyR\ts@Ksbyd}[WvXxKya@yK@zWFMuznJvBtKvB s@zR>7=@zvvyua[vVvsyK; Mz[[x
[x y a@zKJvVvXxyvXxtyKvs5 zK[nyK@VKvv[=tsNu vXxKyNsNny;v Vzns@zNM[vFvBx

 @0y$xKs
70 KWvsnb[KO[ns@zK@}sN;v\vBxKyatsOyJv0s@}KbyFy t5xKs@KMx vkunx;v~}yaKsb[}nyKvVJvy[NyzKOy
vsOs@zKJvX0Jvk sb@Ky[yzKOyWJFJvyuWvXxKv7s@n s@z ny[vVvXxsNxWWy KytOyz[vs}K@nJvB uanb[nyK
vXxKyauaK[xvs@;vyKdnyKs5 zKvXns@zK@ua}tynzsNzbyzbyN [n7 NyK;\Ky0xK@KvXxKyWyKvyJv
y[@Ky0uWyz;v@x[[n[nJvsvXxn=byz[vBVtyuW@0yvs uWyvXxKvVvXxyWFRFsbvys5[[xWb[xKyuWyK=7yty
y }0nx[v;F=$ vXxazKsbs@uuWs@zWbyzbyN 

n@0yWbs@z;vXzKyK  bss@KzKdz[vs us^vyzW[ns@K[Jv@}N5{[K;KyKqv\vBxKv]vsv@Ky;yzKbyauanx[v
zKyKyd}KyaKsb[}nyazbyz;vXs@Vbs[vVvXxyvyK[xzKs@ sR z[s@ yKa7s@ndtsKOy>= };JtsKJv
7yNsNzOsWvy00}nyvXxKvkzKss@zKyWsN d}KsvXxyV$ vXxW@z[KvBxz0ua vB yW}NnJvXnunb;nyK [

{Xz N
@X[@^K 0n ty;Nny|ts@KsbyvXxKv7ya}naNzWJvB yazK@zKsvyK;xzKs@ns O@K[xnyn
s@0usuauzKyWJJvyuws@vXxKya}ns[xytyvsy[yzKa@zKJv@zKyts@Ktynbvs@t=s5@KzKvXxKv
ua x;v]ybb@Kyts@un@}Ks@tvs@0 y=s@\svXxKyt$nbya}KyauW@ ; s@K; ;tyKvy5[vVvBxKyW[xnyndxKyats@Ksby
7s@nd vby }KyWy;KvXtyuWy @zKyts@K7zKsvXxzKabs@ndty[yz[vk vVts@uy[FynsNz@[vsNuauazKy
ts@}nyuW=@zKaKvv[zKvXxya}nsF;xKytya vby 

5un@\ cn[ vXnyK=@ WvsvXxKyWbs@zKqvX0KqvXnsNzWs5[xny @zKJvkts@}KsvXnb=@zKayzKy[vB =yzzKyKy0zK5

5xKyKOyvyK[xzKs@ sM y@tyvsFsKs7y;vs }KyW;xnynyKa@zKJvkzvBxKyvXuWyt@uWyWsKz[vytyJvXy;Fyza  v
7ytyaKsb[}nyvs uanyuWyz;v]y[yzK[ yW[xnyn@vXxKyW; yWy;^yKqv=sKvBxKyVy[yns@uWyz[v7s@ d}KyWvk yJv
Nzyts@K=vXxKyvyK[xzs@ snyK=y@tyvBNzKvs tsvyKqv]@zKJvJ

5xKyKOysb[} vXny@tyW@[vXxy vXxKyzyK[t@}nyWs@zK[xny[@}nys@|}KsvXxNF5xKyWs@z tyK@ qvXn

@ vy0zKvX y{]byyantyzKMn[xuWyz[v@vs ua vy;Fy s@uWyz;vsKvBxKyvy[xzKs@nsnyKvXxKv@tyvss@zKyts@K
}[ ua vXzKas@t[ vs5by v@zazKszKs$nyKyN

NyK{~zKs=VKzKs$nyyansFs>> vXxyOyK@t[xsN|zKyvB0[vXxK yaxKya}KyKyzWbyKyKzKdKzKs yy

[zKbyW@zK; yz[vVvXuyKR0 qvsvXnyWsNyzKy9x ky[v@x[F; O vBxvBxKyW[uanyWJvvyuyz[v uyza}[ zKvXty
yK;yvs zKs  yaxKFyR>= }Kyts[=NKyazWs@\OsF; y;vt\nsNzyKyKas@zvXxKyNKyWs5s@Kyz
bbybvs z[sNuvXns@zNz9tybsznyvXxKyats@} yuvXxKv@0nbyW$ vXxWvtvyua[vvstyKJvB0nJvFObyKO7vs@zK
y[yns@uWyz[vszKs$nyKyN@{Xzatybyz;v\vBuWy>yaxKFyWbs@uWyvs ty;FytyWb[nyz;vX nKzKs$nyy@

[vyK; vyvXxKyWqvXts@zKdxnJvs@0nb@tybyyz[v\ 5s@KyzbOyKbvs@zKdzua vyy[FynsNuyz[vs

KzKs yyaxKyzKby;s@vXxa;vK=NzW[nyK@V@zKy\s5y[vXzKJvB s@z@vXxKyzWbs@uuWs@zWbyzbyWyuW@zKvXxKvy
tyKy;F@uazyWy[FyzvXxKybya}K[n\ns@zK@JxKy d}Kyny;K

{tv7ny[vb[xyW$xKs7@0zKyKdK>vVvXxKyWyzKasKvBxKydvBxOyz[vXVzKsv]s@z WvXxKv|s9n=yFd};v\vBxKv

@ vBxzWb[nyzby$xn[xW^vyV@Ky;NnJvzKyz @} >b@zzsKvs7ya v=s@0nzvsONn[s[vB vt@~ v
uaKJvkxKFyWs@0nzKvyaJ 5vXxKyFqvVvXxKvVvXxKyWn[;vX vt@zKa@zKyts@K[zyKb=svXxKyn$;vsWvB0[vXxKs

12 of 18 1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html

vX[vXxWv]@z[ 0 OyntsKyKvs vbs@zJv@z[vX  k{v~nvXxnvXxKy\@zKyvXxKv7yazKs* WFOyvXxKy

bs@zKbyKyzKbys5s@vX0[vBxOyKyKzK5FMxyvX0[vXxvXxKvO[ yzKbyWOyKy=b@zOyvNz }KyWbs@zK; yty
@zKyts@K=[}KqvX vX[vys@\|s9  vk y Wvs yvss@Vy[vXzKJvXns@zN

{t57yWbs@ atyy>=;KyK[ny>xKv]yW7@z[vy@$xKytyW7yW7ytyaxKyKy@>@zx[@vXxKyzyW7s@n
uWNyWs@5[vXtyau[xa yb=@zKyts@KvXxKyzWyuanx[vkzytqv@zKa$xKv7yWb@zW@zKa[xKs@n
tyzKn[x@vXxKyt$nby7yWb@zWyK[ uzKyW@zW@0utbyWy;Fy s@zKasFy\ avy[xzsNnsnyK> v
n vXxvXxKy 
dvy[xzsNnsnyKzvXxKyKvBxOyz[vB>F5xnnKy0x@KvXxKyWtyvyKqv~0n[;Ns@\s@zKbyW;K[xW
tbya}KyzK\ v0n7y xNtvsyzKd vHFMx vXuWy7zyW0zvBxK
y ~@zxKvtv@
z tsb0yKqvyW@tyz v~zW
7@N[zKa@zuanb@}nyyzKyuWvBxKv~nvXxtyvyzzs@V[ N vXns@z7yW@tyW0 yzVzJvyF>\}[s@
xK@} vs@\yK[ty>s@VyKOsNzsNuan=JFqvyu>@zKas@Vbs@uaKy[vB vB yazKyKyvs zKs

{~}y y;FyvBxKv]yW@$n[xWsN\bs@tbyWbs@nd}KyWy[vy0uazKyKd}[s@Vbs@ yJvX Fy@yKy[vXx O>@zK

uWsNt@nK>{t57yaxKa@zKyKduWs@tyWbs@nyKqvX FyW$nbs@usFyvXxyJvVyvBxKs@Kb@zKFy@tNvBxKyzWM @nsKy
vsWvBxnyzKa7s@nd}KyauWsNtyatJvXnb@>@zKvXxKyazK[ty}nyaKs7ytyW@tyWN}sN;v\vs z y[xW7s@n9zsKv
}KyazKyN bsvXts@}zK5

7zyW7s@nvBxz$7yauanx[vk}KyW0 Fyzvs[[xWn@ sMKya}[s@zKqvXzKJvVs@Vby HyKbyFvXns@zN

{XzK NnNn=[nyK@0 xKFyvBxnyK[ty@Fy;vF=;KyK; y=sN}KyxKNns@\OyKyuvs}KyazKsvkzWs@sNX>{Xz
yK@zKa$ vXxvXxKyaz[nyK@5vBxtyKv>7yWscvyzW[sNyWn[xKs@zKyJvX WvssNtby yK=@zKvsyF;xsvXxy@vXxKyty}[
tyKvB zK;tyK[zKvXxKya0n[Khxy[vXxyvXxn=7Ks@ vXnb@ usvX KvyK@s@}Kyb@KbyWyW[xKsbyazKsvVvsvXxz
@xKyK@s@}Kyb@KbyWxKyzFOyKa$ vXxW[K;xMtFyvXxtyv=7yWJvyd0tvB s@zK@ sN;v]syK@{]szKsv
KzKs \};v~ vsyKzKsvk}KsyW7yS

5xKyazKyK [@zKs@t }KsyK=s5yzy[vXnb\zK@zKsvy[xzsNns>@zKdts@}KsvXnb=@tyWNuWsJvs@Kyz@Fy;v]yWbyKyu

xK@t Wvs xKyazKsvXnby5@{yK=b@z vk}Kya;v~}F;WzW }sK@kzyat@zu sN|[vsNzu@vXxKy;s@z v
zKyKyvs }KyauazKy@zKdty;zKyK>>@zKvXxKy;b@za}Kytyy bs@nyK57zbyvXxKy;@tyWsN;v0NvBxKy[@tyWs@[vH

xt[xtyuW@0y@VzWW@us@Kny[cv0JxK@zKyKabs@uauyz[v0@vXxKvVvXxKyuWy0 ONzaKys@ny@zvBxKy| yFyt
Hz[N @} svXxKya0nx[vVvXxzK>>^vyvXxKy; xKFyWy[@uzKyay[FysvXxKy\@ vy0zKvX Fy@ k{XzvXx =bOy
xKs7y;Fy>7yauaKqv]JvkuWs@tyatyKO[nyz[vB >vssWvXxy x;v\vBxzKasNz vknJvku }Kyvs nsFOyvXxKy
[xK@zKOyvss vv@

5#MxsNyK@Wb@ > ys zKsvk0nyWs@zvBxKyat@tsk vk0 yKKs@zaK J@zKvXxn =$xKvyauKqvVnx[v0

zs@vXuWyN5xyMKyKqvXnsNzanVzKyKy@>hx [xanvs }yuWJvy
hK7yW;N FyWs@vy[xzKs@nsnyK

yW@tya}KyzKdts@Ky y9z[vsWvXxnzKy Oyz[vB$ vXxazKsnNzR\zKsbs@z[vXts@\zKs}t@yK
KyW7yW@tyK

s@zKyvssW@\sFzvXxKyaKvXxvsN vyVbs@tby ${]sNzR vk}Kyny[yWbs\};v]yWNyz v\vBNzKFy;v0>@zKvXxya Jv
[xK@zKOyvsbbyvbs@z[vXts@RvXxKy@byaKs@z;v|#nt@n @ts[xzK5 yaxKFyWs@tJvkKy;vkts@}Ksv
yK=bs@uauyt[n@ F@ @} yWyzKy;vXnyzKzKyy0zKvyK;xznKy>@zKas@|zK@zKsbb@nyvy[xznKy=@ty
F@zK;z9t@n >hxnyvXxKyWy;Fy s@uWyz[vsKvBxKyKOyvyK[xzKs@ sM ytsbyKyvXxts@KMxzua}KyVs
JvyKV vkn[z v~zyKbybb@0 WvXxKyWbbyxK@KyzKy9zvXxK y k@zxKvtvN
z tsOyJv@zKvXxKy50z vtWvyJv|vXxKv
vXxKyanJvJvyazats@zvyK;xzKs@nsFR n@tyW@zKdxK@t55xKya}tyK@bvBxts@Kxvs$ aby HynbvXns@zz
ts@}KsvXnbyzy[vXn=yzKMzyKyzK>>s@|zK@zKsvyK;xzKs@nsFRbs@nOsNuWyW[yz \ty0n[zKvXxKyW[00nbyW7yy v
$xKyzW7yanyK@0zKysvXxyW[nsNzzs5 uW@uau@

zKFy;v{k}Kyny;FyW7yWsxKFyWJvXts@zKa@zKabs@ d}K[ns@|xKs@KyN7\vtvyua[vvsyK@K vBxyK@Ks@zK

sub=yJvX0JvXns@zazvXxKyanJvbyz[vX tsNnyW;xzzy;F@uanyWsKyzn[xuWyz;v\s@7vs
bs@zK[nyb@vXxKyaznvyt@  @}K@zKs@zuWyz[v0$ vXxKs@[vktybs@zK vXns@zKsvXxKyWy;Fy s@uWyz;v]s} s@nsnb@
7yNsNzK5xntyzK [xuyz[vJvyuauyts@uwvXxyatyK@ vXns@zvBxKv$xny v7s@nv@yW@zWyzsN0uWs@K
y[cs@vVvs[tyKvyvBxKyKOyvy00}nyW7y@Ks@zK@vXxKy;Os@ ts@uwvXxKyzWsNzWyF; }KyW OKvyKa@zK@z[vsWvBxKy
xK@zK=stsKyazKvB s@zK=s@5vy0ts@0nJvts@K

5xKyW[nyK@Vbs@zK[K[ns@zW7vXxKv7yW7s@na[tyvyW vXns@zK@[vXxtyvvss@tOy Fy}[ t[zvBxKyKOy

7yNsNz>@zKvXxKvyW7s@n9}yaus@tyWby[tya 57yWM dzKsvkt;KyvXxKyu  yaxKFyWyua}KsnyKas@
tyzKn[xuyz[vs}nsNnsnb@K@zKa[xKyua ON7yK@Ks@zzvXxKyd   s@nsnb@K yK@sNz
s@z[Fyz[vXns@z
X
@zKvXxKyd 
xKyuanb@K y@Ks@zK
5s@z[yz[vXns@ z 

b [

5s@5vBxKyWbs@z[vBzz; @}nyvXxtyv\ts@uzK; y@\yK@Ks@zK$xn[xW7yaxKya yKa$ vXxazKs*s@|uWsNty

13 of 18 1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html

vXxK@z WFy@tNvBxKy9Nyzvyntybyz[vktyJ0yKJvB s@zWsvXxKy

5s@uatyxKyz[ FyNyKqv~@z5tyKvt uW@y v[nyK@
tyzKn[xz9zK[nyK@V7yK@Ks@zK=zKsvk}KyaKs@ vXnb@ yFq>M[v7yaxKFyWznKyWs@Ks@vBz vt>$ vXx
vXxKyWyzKasKvBxKy
5s@na @NvsKyvu vBKs@n@\@0uWtbyNM Mzs@zvXxKya
h@zK


tyzKn[xuyz[v>[KObyKOJK@}Ks@ vXns@zWszK[nyK@V7yNsNzOs@ dxKy}nvs7@ta xN} vs

tyzKn[xzNzyts@Kvy[xzsNnsnyK
t5qvXK@ \};y[vtvBz90nas5@}[v=[ zK; y@\yK@Ks@zK
7s@0n$ny7ts@KMx vBxKyvsv@KyKJvB0KJvX yaKs7yVs5 s@0n @{0{]@zKabs@zK[nyN} y[nyv[7y
bs@nayuazKvyvXx =y;KvXzKqvXnsNzvXxtyKvH  

5y0 cNzKdtyzKn[xuWyz[v$}KyW cn[ vkts@}nyu\}[vkzKsvNzazbs@ @}nys@zyN yW@tys@vXzKvyvs

xKFyW@tyKsNzynsKvsty y;F@z[v7s@0WzvXxKyWbs@z[vy[v]svXxya
hNzsvBxKyvXtyKvB yK7|uWb0s@
v [$$}Kyvs@ WvXxnvsWvyK[xzKs@ sny7vBxKvNtyazKvBt@ uaK[xauWs@tyWbs@uauyt[n@[vXxK@zaua v@>
5xKyW[}Kqv@z[vXn@zKyyKdxKytya sNvXt@zK;K@tyzKqF= cn[ vtsy0 nbvXns@za =tyJvX ts@Ks@vXns@zK@[vs
vXxKyW cn[ vts5nJvBzn[xzKdtyzK ;xKyKts@u y vXuvyWJvB N vXnyKK


{\t@zK }Kyny;FyvXxKvVvXxyW[ vXKvXns@zzd ;uanyvXxK@zvXxys@zKyWyazKs*byMxyazK[nyN
vy[xzKs@nsnyK=7ytyatyKbs@zK@} byK@t@}nyz[vsbs@uauWyt[n@K@zKdua v@ Kby>@zKduWs@z vs@0zKa7
@ yKd}[WvXxKyazKvBtyWs5vs@unvyJv=@zKvXxKyWyFOyW$ vXxW$xn[xatnsJvX N vtbs@nd}KyauWyK[tyK5
NybyK@t[xWs@zaua v@@nbvXnsNzOsN d}KyaysN0uWyvkzKvXns@zK@n@}Ks@tvs@0nyK=[K[xW bs7n@uWs
$ vXxvXxKyaty[ vy[vby[ty[vnsNzKsb[}ny@

5xKyW vyK[xzKs@ snys zKsv NnyW[nyK@0 z[vsbs@uuWyt[nNNz9ua vN byK; FyzvXxysKvyz[vB @

zvBxKyau@0y[v0V v0 xK@tvs uWzKyat;zKvXxKyu s@z zazKvXns@zK@n@}Ks@tKvs@0 yKh vBxvBxKy
$ny[tyFabs@uauWyt[n@t[ v0yz[s@t[zKdtyzKn[xuWyz[v$tyKtyWFy OvXnsNzatyuyW;ua @vs
vXxKvVs@|}ns@ snb@KyK@Ks@zK\}[vs@zW@zztybyKyz[vyabb@nyN5xnVzKy[@ vN} >t@nbyvyzK[ns@zK
}Ky[v7yyzWs@zKM @ MK@0 FJ@zKay[tys@|ts@0ny[vN z[s@0uvB s@z@zKvXxKyazKyyKs@Fy0 nbvXns@z
vs tsvyKqv~@  yW$zs@}[vy yzKOsNz[vy\JvBts@zKdtyK[nJvNzbyvsWvBxnnsb=s0 FJ@zK
tyyKs@u sK5JvB s@z@

5y0 cNzKvXxKyatyzK ;xuWyz[vs5byv@z avy[xzKs@nsnyK=$xKFyvssb[zWJN}Kyt[KOy=7yK

v~x[F; ON;[ vB yK5xKyW;0 vB O@nb[KyW}Kyvs uW@yvXxKyazyKbybb@WvXt@zK;K@tyzJbby[v@}nyazW
7s@0nasKtsN0ny[v@ z[sN0uWvXns@z\tyK[u@} }[ sK@nz9zyK*s@0uW=stsvyJvXns@zs@z[vy yJvXN
ts@Kyvt>

5y0 cNzKabs@un@zKbyWK@nbstyKtyvBxKv]O[nyz[vB qv=NzyzKzKyyt=s@[vJvBts@zKOsyWs5y[vXx b@

bs@zKJv0VtyKbyu}zKvXxy Ks[tvXn=sFvBx>@zKvXxKvVvXxy[ xKFyvBxKyWbs@tyvs$xnJvB y}ns 
zKyKOyKbON >y;FyzvkxnxaKytbs@zK@KbsJvJ5xn=7s@n@zb7y5vXxyWb@RWFyK@t=^vy ts[xu 7}[
vXxKy 5s@}Kyn@tyKvy @zKy[vXxKyR>s@zKyWsvXxyausJvbyzns@\svXxy;N @z9uWyua}Kyt=svXxK y k@zxKvtv@z
tsOyKqv0NvBxKvNKO[nyz[vB Jv
bybyW@zKyK[nJvVts@u7s@0$[tyvXzK@>y[yns@z@\uatsNzK>>@zK

uWNz[JvB0zKdzK[nyNV7y@Ks@zK=NzsvXxyV7yNsNzsKsvyz[vXn@uWb=yKqvX0KqvXnsNz@  {XzvXxKyJv
byz[vXNvXx tytyK@ n@zKbyW@zKdKytbs@zK@ty[Ks@zK[} v }[WvXxKsbyWxKssN a7s@0$s@za}KsvXx 

@zKa avyK[xzs@ snyKvsFs@n9uanyuWyz;vXzKa7yK@Ks@zK=suWb=yKJvB0KJvB s@zW@zKdKzKs yyRyz@} y

uWFOyKJvB0KJvXns@zN

5xKs@tyK@W@ Osb@nvBxKv7yW$}Ky J0 ;xzats@Ks@vXns@zvsWvXxyazua}KyVsvXxzKxn[xW7yWb@zW^sNtvs

ny[v@ s@zKy@  yWyK[xWbyy=vs}KyaxK@[\};v~ v7s@nabyKyu7s@vBxK$xnyvsMKyKqvXnsNzWxKy[vXxyV7yazKyyKvs
v@yW;K[xW xnxa0n[$svsv@KyJvXKJvXns@zvs@zFy;v~uWs@tyaKzsFnyKyW@zKy[vkus@tyvBxzK[OsNuauWs@z
byzKbyWbFvXxv\vBxKytyan= u vVvss@|uWvy0n@zKyyK@zKvXxKvbyv@zzKs$nyKyan7vsFs@zKyts@K
@zKd }KyJvVs@ts@zKy@

5y vXxyV[xKs@na7yat;KyazKyN|uuWs@v@ vt$ vXxKs@[vOsNz[ny0zKvXxKyWOsFqv$ vXxKs@[vbs@zK; y0zKvXxKy

bs@uauyzK[Kvyaz[tyKbyazvXxKya0n[$s5y;KvXzKJvB s@zN>{Xuaus@vN vt>$xnyaKy0xK@KvXxKyWs@0nzK@\nOyv@z
zKsvVvXxKyWs@z Ksb[}nya[vs@ @zWtyNu

{~tybyz[vX xKvXxKyWsss@vXzKyvs uWyKy;vVvXxKyWnJvBzn[xKy@[vBxKs@\@zKab;xKs@ @HbMKyKvtvN>xKsby

}Kss@
[N N0  =[ WzvBxK y zKn[xvXt@zK; vXns@z 7xKyKyKdzK[tyvXxyHFNzz
@ts[xvsWvBxKyWbs@uazyWsKyF[ yWbs@u[vXzK@Fy[Nns@K[ yb[0}Ky9zvXxnuWFFzKyN>{Xz
xnzKyK }Kss@ 0@[0 HvtvNKyb[}KyxKs)sN\yK@u=s[vsN xKFyW[xNzyKasFy5vBuWy5

14 of 18 1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html

vVvXxyW$zWs5bs[ny[vXnyK\uWyzWb*vXxKyKObyWs@z NvBxzKsvXxz9uWs@tyvXxK@zW n@}[Nz[vBxsNz

v\vBxKyWyzs5$x ;xqvssss@nyKzK@@NnWvBxKyVyKvXxRNvsvXxKyWbs@uaK@z[s5s=@zKvs M[0 
h vXxvXxK y 5y}tyK=NzvBxKyzvXxytyy>bs@uWyauWyzW@tyKtyKyvXxyuWby yKts@uwvBxKyKs@nsnb@Kyu@zK
@zKatyK@us5@za yK@
 v$xKyty [ N;J a7s@ ns@0n[x@vXxKy\zKsvBzKvXxyWy[sN[vB s@zWsvXxKyauW@0y;v
bs[ny[v\zKytJvssvXxKvVvXxKya}KyvsK5OsNuWyW7s@ ayz;v@;vXxKyW@ yzKvXns@zs5svXxyt@zKvXxKy;


bs@Kx;v

  

HbMKyKxKyyKduyazKytJv@zKdxKs*vXxKybyvXxtyKyW ^ytyz[vk[vs@n@zWs@ =y[@nJvkzvyzK[ns@zazWs@Vbs[ny[vt

vs> 5yWsyK=s@zvsyKb;0}ys@vBx;vs@n KN[0 ~xKsbys@zvXns@zn=@ vB0n[u rKKvy0z vt
@ s@zKyWbOs[ vyKzK NnK@xNzKyKb= vBxvBxKyaxK@zKyb=sK5svBxKyt>^s@tzKvXxKyats@uanbyWs
by [Jv@zuWyz[vJ

5xn;FJvNnys@uWyau ts@}nyu vXxaty =tyNu dvy[xzKs@nsnb@K@ts[xvs[vy0z vta

zKyK@|uuWs@v@ vtWvXxts@KMxts@}KsvB O$7uW zKsvk}KyvXxKyauWsJvyK;N} ya[vs@n@zKd vt[ vk}0zK
[nyK@V@zKytK
kN}yyW[xKs@ndty[vBxz$sN;vs@nNzW[xsNnbyK

hxKytyWb@zya ss@=sNV zyK)y[vBx O@}K[nvsby;vs@\OsNtby {~xKys@zKvXxynyzvXxKya}sFs@

^B$^N
 =; W };vBxK y VNn@ b@uWNvs}KyFy xKy[ 5ny0xK@K=7yKzKsz}[v
vvXnyxyKyyK@@vXxKy V@ @ ONuW@tMKyKvXxKvVvXxyausJvkuaKs@v@z[vVvXxzKdns@7vsbs@zKMKJvs@ Fy=$ vXx
nsKyW@zKabs@uFO[nsNzsNVsvXxKytNzvBxKv]s@\bs[ny;vXnyKzKyKyvsy;FynsNWqvXts@zKyzsKvB s@zWs
z Fytb@ty[Ks@zK;} vt@zKasK5s@z[vytyyzKyzKqNkxKyats@KsOyK=JvNz@tssF; vB yWy[vXx ON
bs@zKJvVs@|zKM @nK@n@zKabs[ny;vXnyKvXxKvbyyuW=bs@zKbs@zK@z[v$ vXxvtv@ rKKvy0z vt ;vs@n>

5xKy\@n@ b@uWWvXxKy\@tyKvXxKv7yauaKJvkzytqv@zKa$xKvk v~nvXxKvkuW@yKKys@nyaxK@[>@zK

[KzsF yyvBxKyWJvXts@zKay;NnyzbyvXxKvkzKy vBxKy|uWKvy0n@tstybzKs@5vBxKyat; v]svBxKyaKs7y\s
KzKs yyanvXxKyay[avXxKvVvXxytyW@tyaua vvsxKvb[nyzbyW@zKvBxKyWb[nyz[vX nt; v]@ns@zKyWb@zWs

7\ yJvy0zazKsvXnsNzWsxK@zKyb=byyuW7vsbs@uWyts@uwvBxKyWtyKy$xKsy[zyKd vvBxKyWy[yt[nbyWs

N v@sFyt=@nsNz9zKyK=s5y[bynyzbyaz yWKcs@tzKvXxyuObs@KyN 

nyK@0 7yazKyyKvszKduy@zzKK[xNnyzKyK=@zKa[[cn[nyz[vObs@Kyazs@| yK 57yW@tyvs }yaxK@[
zxKvy[y|n7vsbs@uWyNM[v|{~}Ky y;FyW7yauaKqv\zKaN vy0zKvX FyWs@[vB y;vs@Vs@\;tyKvX Fys@tby\}Ky;Fs@zK
vXxKyW; vBtyWsKyKy[vBK@KyKbs@zsNuan=tskvXxVvXxn=tskvXxaxKnNty }KyKyzW }nyKO[zKs@\Oy[yt@
xzKMtyKFy@t\}[vk vkxKzKsvk}ts@Kx;v~zK@nsFy9x@zKyKO>@zKa7yauaKqv~zsF);xKssFOya}Ky[v7yKyz
vXxKyat[ vsztyJvX0nJvyaNz9zKtyKqvyKatskvBxvXxts@KxWb; yzKbyW@zKvy[xzKs@ns@zKvXxKyW[nyN
bbs@uaK@z[NzKa@zKytK

{tvk zKs uWs@tyvXxK@zWWFy@\;zbyauWtJvyzKOsNz[vy\ vBx@ MtyK@zKHs@xzNyN y@@{byKyW@ts@z

uWyO@Kbys@|xKs@KyazvXxKyFs@nby7s@\ON;vXnsNzW@zKdtyzK ;xuWyz[v@zKdzvXxsbyaKyKs@ny{kxKFy
nbbsytyKaxKs@tyW=bs@zKby0zKyKa{]@u@}Ks@[vs@V[0tyz[vktynb@uyz[vH>{\yKy@vss>yKyKyzKy
byzKbyWsKytOs@zK@tyK;Ks@zK[} v7zsKvVs@5vXxyW7s@0{~xKyW@tys@zKyR\}[vVs@5vXxyW7s@0=vXxKv|{kunx[v
Fy;v]s>vVvXxKyWbs@z[KyzKOyWsKvBxKyWb[nyzKbyK

[vkuWNz;sKvBxKy|KysN yWxKs zKs)N}sN;v\vBxKyW@zKyt=JvXKbyyuJvBt@zKy [nyz;vHhxyzatyKObyK>NvXxy[

Xv tsvs@[vVvXxKy vXxn zKsvXxz9zKy 70KsJvyF 57@tyzyKb=s5$xKvbs@ndxK@Kyza ty[Ks@zKbyWyzKs@KxN
5xKy[WvyuWy5xytyW@tyaz Fyt[ vXnyKnyKa$ vXxa}nsy[vBx ; qv=$xKsJvXKRWvXxn=JvX[c5@ s@zK5xKy[
b@;vXxnxK}yKyz0 vvyzW@}Ks@[vk}Ky;s@tyR>@zKd}[y[@Ky vK5xy[bs@uanNzNsN\sN0 y=Nzs@
@tuWyz;v=NtyW@tyKRs@ndxKvH

{]sNzR vkKzKs)xKytyvXxyKbyayKs@nyaxnyvXxKyyK@X5=@zWN[x vyKqv]s5OsNuany;qFJvyuW{]yz[vy5vXx

@tyzKyzyt@ qvH[v;xKs@ vBx =uazn[xaubs@zKOy0zK ${]@u F@tyWsKxsF uaK;xxK}Kyyz
$0 vtvyzW@}Ks@[v0@v@yKa@}Ks@[v0@zKd yJvXyKaN}s@[vbs@[vXxs@0 vKvB y >M[vsyKvXx uWyK@za v~xF
tyK[xyKdKyKs@ny \sy7vBxnuWyNzW7yWO@znbOs@z[vVvXxKyW@zKyt}Ky;s@tyaK

zKs$zKdnzsKvtKvB s@zNnysN|zKsvJvXzK5

5@zW7yWs@}[vVvBxKv~zKs$nyKyaxK}KyKOsNuWyWyK@Ks@zW7y
$nyna@zJvsNtby yK

5xKyWy[@Ky0nyzKbyK=svXxyWKvsNuan=b[nyz;vXnJv=[nyK@0 [xKs*vXxyzyKyvsWv@yaytbs@zK@tyK[Ks@z[} vtNvXxy

15 of 18 1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html

@zKy5vBxKv\vBxzK=$uWsKyvssWJv0NzvBxKyW7 zxn[xW tsbyb=b@zv@yWs@zW yWs v=sFzN

yWb@zFvXxy[n@[tyKvyzK;0uWsNz[v@}nyats@}nyuWz@uWsFqvkzKsWvXuWynvHyauKqvs uWs@ty
vXxzz9ts@z[vk 5yW@tyazKsv\vs }KyW[ua @0 [00nbyKa@zKa[xKs[yKd}[WvXxyOs@zKbyKMKyzbyK=s5s@
z[Fyz[vXns@zKK

|bs@z[vXzzKdtsyKb; s@zK@Ks@0W =s@zauats@zvBxKyatynN} vts5bscv7@ty@@Ns^v7@tya =vss@Nz

vss@}ny{kuKqvJvX0Kny vXxvXxKyaKbyvsxn[xvXxKyvss@n${kuW@yW@tya[vJ@{kxKFyW@n7F}Kyny[yK
W
vXxKvkuWNzKabs^v@tyaus@tyatyn@}ny Fyz vuW@z[ Kby>uW@yvBxKyW7s@0naby\@z9}Ky;vtvy
nbyk V{7ytyvsbs@uWyvs }y y;FyvBxKyWs@Ks[ vyRNvXxKyz{]sN d}KyauWs@t@ s@}nvyKvsJvs@vXxn=7s@0F
{]ONzazKs uWFMzy;K[xWK uWbs@uWyN

yzby[s@vXx@s@|uyR\tsyKb=$}Ky
5xn@nyKyKuyazsKv@zKM }[vv~nyFqv]} v~uWy @zK;xKs@nK 5
bs@uWyK$xKvk} vtvytO7yKy;vH

\sFs@atyuWyua}Ky5vBxKya}KyK@;vX yz vBuWvyWbOyzKyaz~@zxKvv@zW$xKytyW ssFRWnyzan @zKasNzaxn

bs@K[xW@zKv@KzKdz[vsv@KyatyKOs@ty
5ya =0 vBz[xKs@vJvs@@}Ks@[vkKys@ yWxKs@tyW[yKvXzK
zzKybybb@VzKytsvXnts@} yuW7s@5vBxKyuWby yK\}Kyb@Kbya vkyKyKvXxKyuwtsNu yK@zKa$ vXxaus@ty
zKOsN F@} yRNvy00 ^@z9tsN} yuW@}Ks@[vVvXxyaz FytbyN

5yanyKxuWby vsvXxKyWyKJvXns@z hx[ n yW7s@vXxa @zK @zKvsbs@zK; yV$xKvkuWNyK v

7s@vXx$xnys@xuhts@K[xKs~@>hnykF@vXxKyWbybs@zKduWsKyuWyz[vsKvBxKy vyNuaxKs@z[
bs@n70uWJvBts@zK@ tybs@tzKas  [svv
s yKdyK kN7yn[xauWsK@nyKVrKn@}Kyv0 Nyz;vXuyz[v@
KKOvXnsNzR k@0 s@zat@zKsVrKt@z5zKvXtNvBxKyW@nyK=@zKdKyK@t}[

K@zzKyRNvXxKyW;t@}K=Kv|N@u s
@zK@NzK@ NvXxy;xKs7Jvs@KybVx nsFy5tJ by@

K[xWsKxKs@ty[ns@KvXxzK>@zKayWb@tys@vXxKyu7yansbvyvXxKyWybbyzKbyWs5s@|xuW@z vt>

X{ zvXxKyWyz@\ vkn}yKb@KOys5s@Vtyv]ONF; vWs@Vb@0zvBxKv|{~tyu@zWsN;vXunJvB =yKOs@z[ts@z[vVvBxKy
@zKyts@K O[KyzKs }Ky;s@tyaK

| uauWyKnvyaxKs@Kyanvs N vXn[Kvyazu[xa @ty\M O[Kb; s@zWsvXxKyanb[yKt@ OyKdxKyy> vBx

KyKs@ yts@uuWNz; cytyz;v~}F;ts@zKVzWby;vtvXzKzKsvktyn[KsbyvsWyK@\s@sNvy[xzKs@nsWsN
v=sFzO@yN

5=Jv@v5{kxKFyv Oyat@ OyKdu@z[svBxKyKbyanb;KyK=vy[yz[v=[s@zKbs@tyKd}[WvBxKy5[Kyz{XzJvX vX[vyWNz

xKFyWbyK@tvy sNsFOyKvXxKvVvXxyuWy0 ONz5byusK v=Nz N; yzKby7v@yvXxKyuW=@z
y[vyz[nsNzWs v=7s@0$$ vXxvXx y F7[x
5s@z[ytyzKbyK

 5xKyKOyaxKFya}KyyzaxKy a[zKbyd  WvsM O[Kb
@0u=bs@z;vXts@yK;KyK[n@ sz[nyK@\yK@Ks@zK>@zKvsWs@0ua vyW7s@0@}nyaKs@ ; yK

{tv0nz;s@vXzKvyvXxKvVvXxy 7[xauWyKy;vXzK=Jv@vyasNz yK^vyvXxKyaz[nyK@\yznyW7=s@[vsvXxKy

}KsvtvXny7ts@Kx h yK@tvss nvy@ yW@tyW@ Osy;vtvXzKa }KynKvyKaJv@vs@zWby0ns@K[ tyb[zKvXxy
nb[Ky@ts@z Jv00byz[vXWvyK[xzs@ snyKvXxyaty[yz[vB s@zWsKzsF yyRyzK@}nyKduWFOyKJvB0KJvXns@z
@zKvBxKyVy byyuWzKbby[v@}ny@

Nsa{0uJvXKby@t[xzKVvXxytyW@tyauW@z[ us@tyvBxzKvs nyK@0z@hxKy;vXxKy\yWNyvs[bbyyKas@5NNvs

[@ FyWs@5@;NnJvXuwvsWvXxKybyvy[xzKs@nsnyKVnzsKvVy[vyK; yK5>{0unvyW@z7 v0n@uWsJv @u
{0uwvBNzKvsuWzKyWbs@uWya}Ky[vvyV@zKbyt@vs }tyK@=vXxKyW;KyK@zKyKyvXxKyuwtsNu vXxKyWJvs@zKyN


  
 !" # %$&'()*+), .- / 102,3'
3465%, $7 !89)1 *.: 1 3;  .<#="4 ,>!? +)9@,<A<)  .9
3+B>C4DFE6D4GIHHpJ8KLBHlNMODP,<QB>C4DSR#T>PUClNVW4Xcp>VZYp.PX2!"[>!&!"4'Z >!A!"
38 ,L *4'Z  ,$!88@!"[,[,<]\]^A)F1 !_
`ab) <
c64 8,>!"4894#[ 4 <
3!2!? a<*. . 4,d
e ^7!Af fF!"* U$7@!?
, .   >\[ +[+;
 <L3[) b) ,Q ,:!8F!"48g48 .'
94,<h$i4a U!_+L-,jFf # + ,
,>++\)k
,:!_[>!_6,<94!8[ >+[+; 1'
 >!6 !"4 :!?
-    ,]\F 4 [[*.,*F!?>!6 4'4,Ff; <L<[!_
!?*l!6,<Z>!6
;,*.434!A!_4!_?mA,<[!?>!n f>o;*!? +[1>!p  4,<]\@[ . . *!?/ #3;>!_6<L !?9,<L !p,

34 N\
e ^@ <L>b;F!"4 <h!?'(,>!A!8
;3  .4\]^8/ 'q) <[!_>+Z<) <,;/ !6 .-['[)\]^a  >\ e

16 of 18 1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html


J8T)GNlNVWBliD
J Xl XlNVWOX7C)DVT[p>M)D>J> .9@d ]\
"!"# $

% c68>!&!?9
&" )\7B>C)D('Kp>MlNV;W
YbmNTW;D@E6DGNmnj()MODJ"WlNVW
l PD>T>PD.PlNVZT |
R p>Jm+*,-;Xp"Ki]TbmNTV.D/4, ,9 d
01 1243654! 9
]9 )9 4\
1781 17 125!

9 g^ *:a . '>bZ< *.8 3<[1>!n3* 'F!_

'[ !A$7'4
b) >I>$@>!_; *8  %$7 3>!p3>b)   ,
; #34-;<>=p?pX  ,
)9@ ,Z n@;&>f $A@443!? * d \B: 3>!n'>+L,>!p ,l=_[
;',
34 ,94894!_;4Z ,*!? ,94  >I
;'[,
05#
34 ,[!8[*'F!8
48'O\2!4\B: 3>!n'Z !63>+[!?[< f) b;,
 !n3+L;'[,Z3 , .9>o;*  !21[ .*.<
 <
*,>$  *!A1 !?F!? >  -! &>:2\ C)B\ : 3>!p'Z !p >!8*!p !" f>#,>o) !8,* 9 # ,Z  *.
;>!8*!_ ,[<; #,!6*,>$&  *!A1 !?
!?  >  !647D]*,E < &>:\
F 5 *. 4, F1>!8[[ ,,>!2!?>!p3 , d
ENp>V
C;TkmG0pXXlNMpFTJ?Xl P>X7T[Tbm+.HVI.0pVJ.DXXcp
')AC GHVZMZTJ8 M p#HP pJmp|lNV[LP KF[V p>E V .lNJ .0p>VLP .Jl UT
'KpJmL
P p#HP p DJ .C lpMD#HP pqmpF T N4JD mnmpFTJ8J l UT
UT[M
TI V .C)( D B4l+*bl LP .DFOT mnmOGlNV4X&JD mnm DcX p
)!8,F!?, . !"
!_; f d
D

BC)DP)D.PXp?]TJ?Xl P>X P1C;TX7C

Vp[XgCpBWC4X2X^p#PUC[pG
G6C l+.COXgC4DFtJ pWC[PcX p>V) D lN
V l X PfLP QDRJ m+pPP.C4DJmnm
*pX7C
V pRX lNJV .m+*D M^X pPJ?D>TKZXgC4DFM
TSJ m D#TP Q@JD mnm
l P1bT mnm4XgC4DFCT V *ZXgC;TX]PD>J DP#XgC)P D ;J8bT lNEV .TI V *p
D)!8,[<; *.8 3
!?
;*  d  e U F #,>!A48- ,[$&'( f<>1 ,; fA*. +L'< >m@!?>+L<Z4 34,Z !6>+]\ U 
 f*4ib ,[$&' !_
 ' # ,Z #'Z ,<]\ U  +; f,<L,<; #-,> #4[>b;7+L  ,9*.7b;9@' 1'
 ! '9,<
>!A#!6<;4 !_Z ,:!_
7!6$!_[ !8,F!"[*.!"F!?
 >j  >$8\ e
B>C4D/V2W[p>Vj[TVJ*
X7C)DP)J._P>X7T>PXj `A;3 <;+)9 )d 9
0W
 XW @\
H11 $

  -! U . ! [],>$i4,* [,\4,>!8*., +L ,kp*!83 ]49F!"4 -1!_ !_ < e @
YZ  >>!?[>$[]'Z >!">!_ 4,4\ e ;3  .<
 ,([@,<  9
^\[A\),<(_' `&>1 .9< !8 >\iEATV[pXDB.C;V[pJmp>WjX
=@D.PD>TJ.CZTV*[Y;DJ&PTQDB.X l DPLn5f^ a  .9 0!@d
!W4]\D
  
%F\N$i4 . >! \ 4gb0[],>$i4,* Sb>5/\)X#6b?\@,2\ >!_'Z \
c ^",
; ( 0WCZ,>b; 'T;TX G Pd')J8T4*Om DH<fi!7ea,,!p ') ,<Z[g+3"3_  -[**. <,!21[F$i48'q>$A *[*  <L *J3?, ,9
1 *.
3*'  4  <Z>! 
'Z*.Z 4!8'Z >!_g49)$
!?[*4, >\
f 4>$ $'[,9D!?7!\ e D $g3?   *>!_ ,@d
h>b;,> >!? <; 1`A
^7! \ e \@>!?9
C]!9:6) ! ]9 0WAd1W\
D 
%:\ ,!8>$7)\ <)H
 bU $& b"  H b>-4$ $&'H, bU 4- 3?  >!? <; >\ !_'Z \
i h; 
9 _ ,)\iB>C)D
OT jjV7XD>J
B>JlNVl X j2[o02=Fp"4D>J?X,
Q4Q@D>VC4DqlNMOD>J TV*LB>C4D/V X^p>Ml+.5ip>M >b;4  3 [>!
%
:\ >+)'Z <<) *!\ *' $\
k  f !_ '[>!8
 #  , &l   / #3-)BC)P D );V *7p"XgC4DS| R p>J m+*2 BC)P
D .l DJV .DFTJV *l)4XgC l+._
P p?2m MZT V )Ln]X lNV.X lp>V?< #4g

,>!"
!?>!A!_
;33   !&+Z>$@>o!_ ,*!? ,Z f .;3 !8,>!?   +L 46 $f[** >!-^4,<,o[]7!88/ #`A' <;>+P: )'4,!_9)1 *.
 .9
3;8 >$& +94!_>! e f[)>!A!8
>b[ '
 *!",*F!8
3  b;F!?>!2[Fb;4i+Zo;* >!? ,  +Z4" +)9)$7  , !"4,*
 ,:!_
8   ! #p\ #4#
F *,>!?9'[,Z ;'[, %#F#  >b6>b
  b;<]\
f <L3[ '[
 ,F$i4!_; ,- ,[!_>!
;'4,;- ,<[#  ,!6 .7b) bF$i '4,+L'[[*,>!?8  .9 >!64 ,[* , F!_ >o+]J\ []7!88/ f<' <;>+Z4)',>!
<; .,/ !6,>!8[,>+L8 .-: !_ '[>!8 =? !p3>+L !8  $"\]^7!p f,4g',>!A$7 J?D Xl XP lNVW
!_[ !? '>!8
1 *:[,>!8F1,
[*, . <;4b;48  #   . 3 [<;, >\ -e @)>!? <;9 4W2d >
9 C9 H125)\ $
qZ[@ 48-9:67!_;A[A\ e  . <,>!" .9
h>o) 7!" .9,<P:A !"4 < >\ e
.l D>V.DH<r_,59 4]\2@) 8 ,>!"<
 e D]*. ,*[,<D]*. >!+ e
 , s2J?DDX lNV;WTP <-')TSJ [p>2V t^i]T>PD *#iKl Q@D *>P u
'KpJmnm D . XD *l)PPUOT j>TP <-vw?xyXtSvwwz4D! \]5%7!? ,;/ {   .9 42
d 54!W]\
@o:6,<)9 #`A>b) <EU8 !6 ; !" # ,Z #  4 e @4 >!_ ,E\@,!"*;, +O`A>b 4 ;'[,!_9 e >b  3 
>! %
:\N$7 . )>!\ 0 b"\,@)>0b b?U8 l|! 4]]\ !_'Z 9 e ^7$
 <
!?8 *!p  3   !+Z f,[ !88,>!? b;F!8
) >!? ,
 !Af <L3
 '
  . 3 F$7A,>+Z<;b;  !8
 ,>!88,4  F!?[* !6$!_
8 .- < !?8*!_ ,[>$!_Z3  . J $?9 F!?!? *  +[!?
*!_ b) !+Z$<>b;   ,L,,>!8*.,4 +Z . <L,>b63
,<7!8-,)\ e U8 !_/ f, +; . 1 >b #
# !_, +Z>b;48,;'[,!
; >!_ ,F!"
>!"*!p` 3p,>!6[*4':$77!? ,[!?!\
 % 5n  4,;9@5%>!&!?>F\ e 3 4'q>$A^] 4  *L}L , >\ e  ,!8>!_ ,F!"F!_~9]
0]!_oD)!8>!8<L5%>!_ ,
>$!_
:6'[8 *4` , :a*<;4':+Z>$:67!" f, < D]*. 4,* .9 _ ,47+ "C9 04]\ 'Z ,7b;)\ 4'*<]\  bU4g*. b;H b>3  >!_ ?, 1\ >!_' $
 9 `a>!&+)9
N\ e U>!!8,Z5%,*ad
\A*. 47}L4 , /D)!8*.-    /D)!_  @)  ,>!A!?^ ; !@>!2!"
[@ b)   >!? ,)\ e EAT;g X J?8D <>1#!;9@`A*'
3A 9 042
d 5]C)\
BFD[  U , {^4!?/ (
 >!&!"4!8 . <;4,! a[   ,>!",9>! %%F\N$7 >\ b>3>!?*.?\ >!_' \

17 of 18 1/19/2004 4:24 PM
Wired 8.04: Why the future doesn't need us. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy_pr.html

Y U 'Z  !8,9

h< !_)\7BC)D(s2J?DD>K R#Tbj4A} \} \2\47!",
a[])\ 9 d )\
0B12!
C5

[;ON[|F@ @;5J;^ K5K5R=qX;bK H bJkV^N=B[c

b   bK d^N@XW
b$X[XqKNnb@^@Kk5xKyHb@zKKy5yK[ OKvB s@zN 
 n
 d^N [5; b Wb W5@c KJN $;NXK>htyK
    

Valentine Robotics, Inc. Robots and Robot Kits 3d Robotics Simulator New Book on Searle's Work
Automation Training and Huge Selection of Projects and Realtime, physics simulation Conversations with John
Support Services Kits Cool Robots and Kits, Great of robots and microcontrollers. Searle A discussion of his life
www.valentinerobotics.com Prices! www.eyewyre.com and ideas
www.robotbooks.com/hobby-robots.htm www.librosenred.com/conv.htm

 >+)8 )>!

[ 4C3!"##C1@([],<\ !-3  *>!? , #^8,*>\B:  8 )>!" # 47b;<]\
 >+)8 )>!

[ 4B123!"##Co}  <L`6  !8 9@^8,*>\B:6 8 >!" # 7b<\

18 of 18 1/19/2004 4:24 PM