Indianyes Bank Report
Indianyes Bank Report
Indianyes Bank Report
Organic
Sector
Vision 2025
A White Paper
No part of this publication may be reproduced in any form by photo, photoprint, microfilm or any
COPYRIGHT
other means without the written permission of YES BANK Ltd., APEDA, AIOI and Ingenus
This report is the publication of YES BANK Limited ("YES BANK"), APEDA, AIOI and Ingenus so YES BANK, APEDA,
AIOI and Ingenus have editorial control over the content, including opinions, advice, statements, services,
offers etc. that is represented in this report. However, YES BANK, APEDA, AIOI and Ingenus will not be liable for
any loss or damage caused by the reader's reliance on information obtained through this report. This report
may contain third party contents and third-party resources. YES BANK and APEDA take no responsibility for
third party content, advertisements or third party applications that are printed on or through this report, nor
does it take any responsibility for the goods or services provided by its advertisers or for any error, omission,
deletion, defect, theft or destruction or unauthorized access to, or alteration of, any user communication.
Further, YES BANK, APEDA, AIOI and Ingenus do not assume any responsibility or liability for any loss or
damage, including personal injury or death, resulting from use of this report or from any content for
communications or materials available on this report. The contents are provided for your reference only.
The reader/ buyer understands that except for the information, products and services clearly identified as
being supplied by YES BANK, APEDA, AIOI and Ingenus, it does not operate, control or endorse any information,
DISCLAIMER products, or services appearing in the report in any way. All other information, products and services offered
through the report are offered by third parties, which are not affiliated in any manner to YES BANK, APEDA, AIOI
and Ingenus.
The reader/ buyer hereby disclaims and waives any right and/ or claim, they may have against YES BANK, APEDA,
AIOI and Ingenus with respect to third party products and services.
All materials provided in the report is provided on "As is" basis and YES BANK, APEDA, AIOI and Ingenus make
no representation or warranty, express or implied, including, but not limited to, warranties of merchantability,
fitness for a particular purpose, title or non infringement. As to documents, content, graphics published in
the report,YES BANK, APEDA, AIOI and Ingenus make no representation or warranty that the contents of such
documents, articles are free from error or suitable for any purpose; nor that the implementation of such
contents will not infringe any third party patents, copyrights, trademarks or other rights.
In no event shall YES BANK, APEDA, AIOI and Ingenus or its content providers be liable for any damages
whatsoever, whether direct, indirect, special, consequential and/or incidental, including without limitation,
damages arising from loss of data or information, loss of profits, business interruption, or arising from the
access and/or use or inability to access and/or use content and/or any service available in this report, even if
YES BANK, APEDA, AIOI and Ingenus are advised of the possibility of such loss.
This study has been done basis a pre decided scope of work between YES BANK, APEDA, AIOI and Ingenus with
the objective of achieving specified outcome and does not cover all aspects/all opportunities pertaining to the
cold chain sector in India.
Organic farming is based on production standards which are environmentally supportive and are socially,
economically and ecologically sustainable. It is believed to play a pertinent role in safeguarding biodiversity,
improving the soil health, and inclusive & sustainable development of the farming community.
Government is now focused on sustainable interventions and is promoting organic farming in a big way
through its different schemes and programs. We now require to formulate a robust integrated policy to
benefit all the stakeholders and primarily the farmers who need to be integrated with the organic value
chain.
APEDA in association with AIOI, YES BANK and Ingenus have undertaken an extensive study which shall be a
foundation to India's Vision for Organic Sector-2025. The contents of this report have put forth an extensive
industry perspective which will definitely guide our way to the global organic market and help us formulate
strategies to explore the opportunities. This shall be a stepping stone to position the Indian Organic brand in
the global organic market.
I hope that this white paper proves to be functionally handy and shapes the way forward to more useful
interventions by policy makers and Indian organic industry.
Currently, the Indian organic food market is largely driven by exports to developed nations with exports having
doubled from INR 1,155 Crores in 2012-13 to INR 2,100 Crores in 2014-15; however the vast domestic organic
market remains largely untapped. It is critical to strengthen the organic agriculture supply-chain as well as
promote awareness and consumption in the country. Additionally, a market-driven approach, led by the industry
and supported by policy makers, with backward linkages to ensure appropriate interventions at the farm end, will
enable a quantum shift in India's organic sector.
To address key challenges of growth of chemical residues in the food chain and exploitation of agro-chemicals, it is
critical for the organic fraternity to focus on a holistic approach which includes reviving soils with organic content,
capacity building of farmers, supply of organic inputs, bulletproof certification standards, consumer marketing
initiatives and most importantly integrating farmers into market-led value chains, amongst others. Additionally,
to leverage the full potential of the sector and achieve sustainable farming and commercial prosperity for the
Indian farmer, fast-tracking regulatory, procedural, infrastructure, promotional, skilling and product specific
interventions will be highly significant.
On the occasion of National Conference on Sustainable Agriculture & Farmers Welfare, we are pleased to release
the YES BANK-Ingenus-APEDA-AIOI Knowledge Report 'India Organic Sector: Vision 2025' which provides
strategic recommendations to promote integrated development in the organic sector.
I would like to acknowledge the support of APEDA, AIOI and Department of Agriculture, Cooperation and Farmers
Welfare for their valuable guidance towards drafting this report. I strongly believe that together, we can achieve
the goal of over USD 7 billion exports by 2025 and put India firmly on the global organic map.
Thank you.
Sincerely,
Rana Kapoor
Managing Director and CEO
Chairman
Message from the Industry
It is a historic moment for all of us in the Organic movement. The industry against heavy odds has been at the
forefront of organic movement promoting organic farming and processing as well as promoting organic food
and fiber in the domestic and international markets. Today India is a leader Internationally in a few segments
like Organic Tea, Basmati Rice and Cotton. The market share in the global organic market is only 0.6%. But
given the huge soil & agro-climatic diversity, large areas with low fertilizers and pesticides usage the
potential for organic farming and industry is immense. This can transform lives of millions of farmers in
rainfed, tribal and other low input agricultural areas.
By 2025 the Indian Organic food business is likely to be a Rs 75,000 crores, a manyfold growth from the
current level. Both export & domestic markets are crucial for this to happen. This will mean an additional
12,500 Crore income per annum for farmers, impacting about 5 million farming families on about 6 million
ha. Another one million jobs can get created in rural and semi urban areas. India can also earn valuable
foreign exchange of Rs 50,000 crores per annum. With proper policy support the figures could be much larger.
Without demand for organic products from customers, farmers will not be encouraged to take up organic
farming. Markets therefore will be the incentive to grow more organic food & fiber.
This study provides a road map for the industry and also the policy framework required to realize this
potential. The study has been done meticulously for the past four months with inputs from various
stakeholders across the country and analyzing the trends both in the domestic and export markets.
We would like to thank Shri Santosh Sarangi, Joint secretary, Ministry of Commerce and former APEDA
chairman, Shri Krishan Kumar, Chairman APEDA and other APEDA officials for their encouragement and
support in making this happen. I would also like to thank my colleagues in the industry for their active
support and participation for the successful completion of the study. Thanks to Nitin Puri, Gopinath Koneti,
their colleagues at YES BANK and Kishore Rao of Ingenus Strategy for their dedication and commitment in
bringing out a high quality and actionable report.
The genesis of this report is a long felt need and outcome of a special meeting convened by
Mr. Santosh Sarangi, the then chairman of APEDA with representatives of the Industry -
Association of Indian Organic Industry (AIOI) to find aggressive ways of growing the Indian
Organic sector. After much brainstorming and deliberations it was concluded that if India
has to make headway in the Organic sector, it needs to have a proper direction, focus and
plan to take advantage of the reasonably sound foundations in place. AIOI represents the
Indian Organic Industry and is focused on building Indian Organic sector.
Mr. Krishan Kumar, who took over as Chairman APEDA, initiated this project and has been
instrumental in flagging off, setting the actual objectives and finalizing the mandate. He
has been guiding, motivating the team continuously and setting new demanding standards
of excellence and vision. AIOI was tasked with using the services of professional
consultants for the complex task of making a road map for the sector for the next decade,
2015 to 2025.
YES BANK & Ingenus Strategy and Creative Research have been jointly mandated for coming
up with recommendations on strategy for boosting certified organic exports from India and
charting a roadmap of the sector.
YES BANK, India's fifth largest private sector bank, has created 'Food and Agribusiness
Strategic Advisory and Research' (FASAR) Group to actualize its focus and commitment for
the holistic development of the Food and Agribusiness sector.
YES BANK has created a differentiated approach in the food and agri space in the country
through various significant knowledge initiatives across sectors like dairy, horticulture,
cold chain, food processing, high value agriculture, commodities, amongst others and
supplemented the Government's efforts in promoting Co-operative Federalism through
02
multiple State reports, specific food maps etc. Further, to supplement various domestic initiatives, YES
BANK has successfully entered into several strategic international alliances with important nodal
agencies, like AUSTRADE, NAFTC, amongst others.
Mr. Kishore Rao & Raj Supe of Ingenus Strategy are niche Global & Indian Agri-Business Strategy
Specialists and intricately involved with Organic business strategy for over a decade. They have had the
privilege of conducting India's first nationwide study on organic foods The Market For Organic Foods In
India Consumer Perceptions & Potential for ICCOA-FIBL- SOLIDARIDAD as well as many other seminal
works in the sector, including being appointed FAO's India marketing consultant to study the acceptance
Indian Organic Sector: Vision 2025
of certification/labels/PGS concept from a market perspective and advice the way forward. They have
pioneered many national studies in Agriculture and worked on global projects with a number of leading
Indian and Multinational firms.
This report is an outcome of deep study of available knowledge as well as detailed consultations with a
wide body of stakeholders across the country as well as a few international ones. Leading Organic
companies/Exporters across product categories, certifying bodies, regulators, organic experts, NGO's,
Government bodies, farmers and others stakeholders participating in the supply chain of organic food
were consulted. The study owes much to their frank opinion and diverse pieces of advice.
We are specially thankful to Mr. Rajashekar Reddy Seelam, Sresta Natural Bioproducts & Chairman AIOI,
Mr. Ajay Katyal, President- Amira Foods, Mr. Shakti Singh, Ambootia Tea, Mr. Sameer Mehra, Suminter
India and Mr. Tapan Ray, LT Foods, all of them Organic veterans and members of AIOI for their contribution
to this study. Many of the ideas and perspectives given have origin to their deep understanding of the
Industry and insights into the issues involved. But for their initiative and individual financial
sponsorship, this study would not have been possible. While APEDA committed financial support, it is to
be noted that the industry came forward and invested in the study upfront.
Today India is on the cusp of change, it is one of the few countries with a positive growth rate in the world
and has an young and increasingly growing population with purchasing power. Many things are rapidly
changing and Agriculture revival is inevitable. It can bring in additional prosperity to the Nation and
organic agriculture can be a strong stream heading this revival.
The Organic agriculture stream is a sunrise sector that will show the direction to where Indian Agriculture
should head with its strong sustainability and market linkages along with traceability and premium
prices. Reviving soil health, making agriculture holistic, involving skill upgradation and emphasising on
allied activities like dairy & poultry as a part of farm family activities all point it to a great future.
This report aims at providing policy makers a strategic focus to the Indian Organic sector to set correct
goals and point out the hurdles and bottlenecks that impede progress. India can reach Rs. 75,000 crores
mark by 2025 from the current 2700 crores in the near future if there is a strategic impetus given correct
planning is actioned and a right environment is created.
Removing obstacles, providing a right environment and setting correct targets and goals is the first step
to success, and this study provides insights and inputs for this. We are optimistic that the Organic
Industry, APEDA and the GOI will individually and collectively find much wisdom here for preparing India's
Organic Sector Road Map for 2025.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to acknowledge the following members for their contribution: (in no particular
order)
APEDA- Mr. Krishan Kumar, Chairman, Dr. Tarun Bajaj, Dr. A.K. Yadav, Advisor, Dr. P.V.S.M. Gouri,
Ministry of Agriculture - Shri Siraj Hussain, Secretary, Dept of Agriculture, Cooperation & Farmers'
Welfare and Mrs. Rani Kumudini, Joint Secretary, Dept of Agriculture, Cooperation & Farmers' Welfare
AIOI- Mr. Rajashekar Reddy Seelam, MD, Sresta Natural Bioproducts, Mr. Ajay Katyal, Amira Foods, Mr.
Shakti Singh, Ambootia Tea, Mr. Sameer Mehra, Suminter India and Mr. Tapan Ray, LT Foods
Thailand - Mr. Sam (Peerachote Charanwong), TOTA President and MD, Merito Products, Mr. Theerasit
Amornsaensuk from Green Net and other TOTA members and representatives from - Merit Food Products
Co., Ltd., Green Net SE Co., Ltd., TPI Polene Bio Organic Co., Ltd., Top Organic Products and Supplies
Co., Ltd., and Siam Organic Food Products Co., Ltd
ICCOA & Biofach India - Mr. Manoj Menon, Exec.Director , Dr. Tej Partap Singh, Former Vice Chancellor,
Sher-e-Kashmir University of Agriculture Sciences and Technology
PJTSAU, Department of Agribusiness Management, Hyderabad - Prof & Head Dr. Seema Nath
IIM, Kashipur - Mr. Gautam Sinha, Director and Mr. Sanjeev Jha, Learning Resource Center
YES BANK team - Abhijeet Banerjee, Amit Saluja, Anshul Sah, Hemendra Tiwari, Kaushik Basu, Kumar
Gaurav, Manish Sachdeva, Neerja Rawat, Pradeep Shrivastava, Prasad and Shikha Bhatt
Ingenus Strategy team - Mr. Raj Supe, Ashish Bhandarwar, Harpreet Thukral, Kirti Reddy, Atifa
Tamkeen, Varsha Surve
04
Abbreviations
ACT- Organic Agriculture Certification Thailand MIDH- Mission for Integrated Development of Horticulture
AGMARK- a certification mark employed on MOFPI Ministry of Food Processing Industries
agricultural products in India
AIOI- Association of Indian Organic Industry MRLs- Maximum Residue Limits
APEDA Agriculture & Processed Foods Export NCOF National Centre For Organic Farming
Indian Organic Sector: Vision 2025
Development Authority
APMC- Agricultural Produce Market Committee NECC- National Egg Coordination Committee
CAGR- Compound Annual Growth Rate NFSM- National Food Security Mission
CB- Certification Body NGO Non-Government Organisation
CIB & RC- Central Insecticides Board and NHM-National Horticulture Mission
Registration Committee
CSR- Corporate social responsibility NOP- National Organic Program
DGFT- Directorate General of Foreign Trade NPK- Chemical elements Nitrogen (N), Phosphorus (P), and
Potassium (K)
DRDO- Defence Research and NPOF- National Project on Organic Farming
Development Organization
F&V - Fruits and Vegetables NPOP National Programme on Organic Production
FAO Food & Agriculture Organisation OTA- Organic Trade Association, USA
FIBL- Forschungsinstitut OVRCT- Organic Value Chain Round Table
fr biologischen Landbau- Research Institute
of Organic Agriculture
FMCG Fast Moving Consumer Goods PGS Participatory Guarantee System
FPC- Farmers Producers Companies PKVY- Paramparagat Krishi Vikas Yojana
FTDR- Foreign Trade Development Regulations QSR- Quick Service Restaurant
FTL- Food Testing Laboratories RKVY- Rashtriya Krishi Vikas Yojna
GAIN- Global Agriculture Information Network TC- Transaction Certificate
GMO- Genetically Modified Organisms TNAU- Tamil Nadu Agricultural University
GoI- Govt of India TOTA- Thailand Organic Trader Association
HDPE- High-density polyethylene USDA- U.S. Department of Agriculture
HFCS- High-Fructose Corn Syrup USOCA- Uttarakhand State Organic Certification Agency
ICAR- Indian Council of Agricultural Research VAT- Value-Added Tax
ICCOA International Competence Centre For WHO- World Health Organization
Organic Agriculture
ICDs- Inland Container Depots YBL- YES BANK Limited
ICS- Internal Control Systems
IFOAM- International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements
IGNOU- Indira Gandhi National Open University
IICT- Indian Institute of Chemical Technology
IPM- Integrated Pest Management
Part 1
Scenario Analysis
06
Indian Organic Sector: Vision 2025
Scenario Analysis
1. Background, Objectives & Methodology
01. Indias organic food sector is estimated at Rs. 2700 crores (approximately
USD 415 million) which stands at lesser than even one percent of the
global organic food market estimated at about USD 90 Billion in 2015.
1
APEDA estimates for 2014
2
Industry estimates.
07
02. Indias organic sector is poised for growth if the right interventions are implemented as all the
elements and ecosystem needed for making the sector significant have evolved over the past two
decades. These include a National standard as well as a National
program, a basic accreditation system, certifying bodies, a
relatively large base of organic farmers, basic supply chains and Exports drive India Organic
a number of small but robust organic companies managing Story. All elements in place for
these supply-value chains and participating in the global rapid growth. Domestic market
organic markets. Organic players have also been developing too holds potential for future
03. This study was undertaken to identify the bottlenecks that impede the
growth of the sector and find out the strategic focus and requirements to Study to identify
take Indias exports as well as the sector as a whole from current levels to bottlenecks and
Rs. 10,000 crores by 2025 or even Rs. 50,000 crores. Also, the study provide Strategic
aimed at providing foundation for setting India Organic 2025 Vision and
Focus & 2025
form the basis for a detailed road map using shortlisted - identified
India Organic
focus product categories. Analysis of gaps & providing initial
recommendations for immediate implementation in areas of policy, Vision.
infrastructure, regulation, support, skilling & HR and branding are a
part of the study.
04. Individual Indian Organic firms/programs are very small and only a Collective effort
collective effort under a national plan and platform can provide focus required for national
and impetus to place India Organic in the premium global supermarket
success.
shelves currently dominated by financially stronger and better
organized firms in the developed world.
05. The primary goal of the study was to Identify Indias Top Ten Focus Identifying TOP TEN
Product Categories for concentrating efforts both in the value & supply
product categories
chains, and the next five categories to be developed for future. To
for focusing national
categorize and map the top organic global market and opportunity
analysis was other important goal. To understand gaps and bottlenecks effort.
and provide initial way forward as discussed previously was the other
major objective.
06. The methodology was a combination of primary research comprising exhaustive consultation and
interview process of members in the export value chain and comprehensive scan-access and study
of available knowledge on the sector from specialist Industry sources. Leading organic exporters
selected from the major product categories were interviewed face to face by experienced and
qualified staff from YES BANK across the nation using a mix of discussions and detailed
questionnaires. About fifty high quality interviews were achieved out of nearly hundred contacts
08
a. Credibility of Indian certification in top markets of Europe and USA was opined as not
universally acceptable or partly suspect unlike in minor markets (e.g UAE & other Asian
countries) where it was not an issue. Exporters feel that the perception about quality of
Organic foods exported from India is a concern in top international markets; many opine that
3
spurious exports from India as certified is a challenge to be overcome and impacting overall
credibility.
b. The Indian third party certification system is felt to be generally good but overall credibility
needs to be built up and made more acceptable widely. Exporters are nervous about dilution
of Indian Organic Certification by a few fly-by-nights being allowed to operate within the
system.
c. The potential inclusion of untested systems like Participatory Guarantee Systems (PGS)4
where self-declared and self-attested products entering the Organic Certified category or
rather being labeled as Organic is felt to be counterproductive. It is opined that Organic
categorization should be in line with internationally accepted practices5 or it will negatively
impact the fledgling Indian organic sector which will continue to be dependent on the
international markets and also inhibit the development of the domestic market by
undermining consumer confidence.
d. Unambiguous labeling laws that define organic foods in lines of USDA & EU need to be framed
and implemented. Alternative systems can have different labeling as is the international
practice.
3
Soya and Cotton were pointed out by most eminent companies with established farmer and value chains as areas needing special
attention as a number of traders without any farmer network have mastered dubious practices bringing bad name to overall
industry. A weak accreditation system allowing dubious certifying bodies to operate was another weak link pointed out.
4
PGS is a system for local and direct markets where farmers and consumers can directly interact and not suitable for distant
markets where quality labels are demanded by consumers.
5
Only Certified products can be labeled as 'Organic' in Major International Markets like USA & EU. They need to follow 'laid down
standards' and 'be verified' by 'an accredited agency' before they can use the seal or label organic to ensure consumer
confidence as well as follow the required practices.
09
30%
identified as the primary
25% 22%
issue impacting the growth 20% 20%
and efficiency of the sector. 15%
Excessive controls, and 10%
g. The huge outlays, efforts and plans of Ministry of Agriculture with the farmers are seen to be
directed to diffuse farmers and not linked to either domestic market or exports requirements
which will pay organic premiums. It was felt that the farmers and the organic value chain will
benefit only if they are directly linked to the market requirements. Investments may be
wasteful and farmer sustainability will be a question mark if not aligned to the
buyers/consumers needs and priorities.
h. Large bases of Organic farmers need to be pooled and farmer incentives linked to and
channelized through established value chains-businesses who are primarily linked to the
markets and organic consumers.
i. It is felt that if Organic Organic Food Exports will thrive if farmers benefits are channelized through
hubs/ Organic Food Parks established businesses, profiting all concerned
with sufficient critical 60%
mass are developed it can 51%
50%
enable establishment of 40%
shared/common third 30% 27%
party logistics- 20%
infrastructure and supply 10% 5% 7% 7%
2%
chain and can give a boost 0%
Cant Say Strongly Agree Maybe Disagree Strongly
to Indian exports as also Agree Disagree
domestic markets and
benefit farmers too.
6
Also felt to be expensive.
10
j. Indian exporters were more inclined to supply commodities as against value added/
processed products given the current confidence levels. This could be a reflection of current
Indian exporters being small, not so seasoned, ill-equipped or less-supported or diffident of
7
the challenges on the global stage.
k. Development of the domestic market is extremely critical for the overall sustainability of the
Organic sector. Government support is highly required as the sector is very small. Consumer
education & organic category promotion is felt to be the basis for this which cannot be done
Indian Organic Sector: Vision 2025
m. GMOs entering the food chain legally and illegally8 is a strong concern. The need for strong
and continuous monitoring mechanism and the organic community to also have a say here
was expressed.
7
It was opined to be 'pragmatic' for today's Indian exporters to be raw material- ingredient supply chain partner with
International brands as a practical export strategy in the next five years. However it was felt that with niche marketing and greater
and more effective work on gaining credibility and support of the government the situation of can significantly be improved
towards selling value added foods..
8
BT Brinjal illegally coming in through the porous Bangladesh border is a concern and new technologies getting approval other
than BT Cotton is the legal concern
11
9
43.1 mil ha in 2013-14 . The wild collection classified area comprises another 35 mil ha totally
amounting 78 mil ha. The organic component is about 1% of total global agriculture land. However
about 11 countries in the world have more than 10% under organic farm lands10. Of the total farm
land from available data nearly 27 mil ha is grazing land, about 3.7 mil ha is permanent crops (
11
orchards etc), and 7.7 mil ha arable crops . There are around 2 million organic cultivators; Asia
leads the list with 36 % of organic producers followed by Africa (29%) and Europe (17%).
12
02. The global organic food market which is estimated at USD 90 billion in 2015 has been growing at a
04. The organic packaged food and beverage Australia 1250 1,600
products category occupies around 40-50% of Denmark 1192 1,300
the total global organic food market with an Netherlands 1093 1,200
estimated market size of around USD 38-40 bn Brazil 910 1,300
in 2015. Of this, organic packaged food Finland 280 300
category accounts for USD 32-34 bn while
organic packaged beverages account for USD 4-6 bn. Dairy and dairy products,
bakery/confectionery products, ready meals and baby food are the largest categories in the
organic packaged food market globally accounting for around 50% of the total organic packaged
food market. Dairy sector accounts for close to 25% of the packaged food products followed by
bakery confectionery products (18%), ready meals (8%), baby food (6%), chilled processed
9
Organic World 2015. Fibl & IFOAM
10
Falkland islands, Liechtenstien, Austria, Sweden, Estonia, Switzerland, French Guyana, Czech Republic, Latvia, Italy
11
India, Brazil and Australia have not reported land use. In 7.7m.ha arable- Cereals 3.3, green fodder 2.4, oilseeds 0.8,veg &
protein crops 0.3 each.
12
USD 72 Billion is the last commonly accepted published figure and 90 billion is also the latest available estimation for 2015.
This is inclusive of all categories; packaged foods and beverages, F&V, meat & milk etc.
12
meat/seafood (5%), processed/frozen food (4%). Considering the beverage segment, the major
categories include those of fruits and vegetables juices, coffee and tea together accounting for
over 70% of the total non alcoholic beverage segment.
05. USA, Germany, France, UK and Italy are the global leaders in consumption of packaged organic
products. USA tops the chart with a consumption of around USD 15 bn, followed by Germany and
France with USD 4.2 bn and USD 3.5 bn respectively. There are other growing organic retail markets
in the lesser prominent countries like Argentina, China, Turkey, Colombia, India and Brazil. It is
estimated that in the coming years countries like China, India, Argentina, Morocco shall grow at
significant growth rates of upto 20-30% in the packaged/processed food segments. The larger
markets like USA, France and Italy shall continue to grow at 5-10%.
06. Global trade in organic products is growing. Data is not universally tracked but a snapshot of latest -
trends indicate a positive outlook for exports from India:
a) USA imported organic food amounting to nearly USD 1.3 bn in 2014. The major commodities
include coffee, soybean, olive oil, bananas, wine and honey. Commodities like coffee,
bananas, wine and mangoes have seen a significant downfall in the import value, while the
import values of soybean, ginger, almonds and apples have significantly increased since
2011. India has been a major supplier to USA for tea, rice, ginger and soybean.
c) U.S. alone exported USD 12.3 million to EU in 2014, an increase of 77% from 2011 to 2014.
Fresh grapes singly reached USD 4.7 million in 2014.
a n y da ay
and nmar
k urg stein str i de an US na rw
erl m bo e n Au S we e rm Ca No
wit
z De xe ch
t G
S Lu Lie
14
USA has the largest organic food market in the world with retail sales reaching USD 39 billion with a share
of 43% of global market. The organic food segment is growing at a rate of 11 % and expected to grow at 12-
14% CAGR during 2015-20. US consumers tend to perceive organic, especially USDA certified Organic as a
premium product category and have a favorable opinion about the organic food. Thus, there is a growing
Indian Organic Sector: Vision 2025
preference for healthy, natural and safe food among the US consumer. Fresh fruits & vegetables is the
major category with 38% of organic food sales. There is high dependency on imports to meet the local
demand for organic food such as soybeans, coffee, fresh fruits & vegetables. US continues to be a major
export market for Indian organic food processors and traders.
Market Overview: US
Market Size USD 39 billion
Growth rate 11 %
Expected Growth Rate 12-14% (CAGR 2015-20)
Distribution Channel Hypermarket / Supermarket 66% Organic specialty stores 24%
Growth Rates Processed Categories Baby Food (8-10%) Dairy & Dairy Products (5-6%)
Fruits & Vegetable Juices (7-8%) Bakery Products (5-6%)
Product Categories-All % contribution Fruits & Vegetables 38% Dairy & Dairy Products 21% Meat, Poultry &
Eggs 7% Packaged food & Bread 26%
02. Germany:
Germany is the largest organic food market among European Union nations with retail sales of USD 11.2
billion. The organic food segment is growing at a rate of 5-7% and is expected to grow 9% CAGR during
2015-20. Organic food has gained popularity among German consumers as awareness level is high on
the impact of chemicals. Germany has one of the strictest laws for cultivation of GMOs, which also lead
to increase in organic food consumption. Milk and milk products is the major category with 24% of
organic food sales followed by fruits and vegetables at 21%. Organic food has become a mass market
product; Germany has to rely on imports to meet the local demand for organic food.
03. France:
The French organic food market is valued at USD 6.7 billion growing at a rate of 10% and expected to grow
8-10% CAGR during 2015-20. French consumers have developed a strong understanding and acceptance
for health & wellness food segment. Consumers are becoming increasingly proactive and looking for
organic food. Milk & milk products is the major category with 21% of organic food sales followed by fruits &
vegetables at 17%. There is a preference for organic food with label Made in France. This can also be seen
as organic imports have declined from 36% (2011) to 24% (2014).
04. Italy:
The overall organic food market is USD 2.9 billion growing at a rate of 7% and is expected to grow 11%
CAGR during 2015-20. Greener & healthy segment is catching up fast in Italian market. There is a
growing concern of overweight and obesity among age group of 15 and above. Fresh fruits & vegetables is
the major category with 25% of organic food sales followed by milk & milk products at 18%.
05. Denmark:
Denmark is one of the well developed organic food market with 8% of all food sold being organic. The
market size is USD 1.3 billion with growth rate of 6% and expected to grow at CAGR 5-6% (2015-20).
Danish consumers are more concerned about food sourcing and its impact on environment. Danish
government has launched organic plan to double the organic cultivated area in order to meet rising
demand for organic food by 2020. There is growing demand for sophisticated products such as
Indian Organic Sector: Vision 2025
convenience food, tropical fruits, ethnic food etc. Dairy & dairy products are the major categories with
38% of organic food sales.
06. Spain:
Spain organic food market is experiencing a growth rate of 8% with market size of USD 1.5 billion and is
expected to grow 10% CAGR during 2015-20. Organic food and beverages as of now is popular among
niche segments. With increase in awareness level among consumers, organic food is gaining acceptance
level across all consumer segments. Fresh fruits & vegetables is the major category with 35% of organic
food sales.
Recovering after a decade of recession, the Organic food market is at USD 2.9 billion with a growth rate of
3% and expected to grow at a low CAGR. The major challenge for UK market is to return to solid growth. The
awareness campaigns by government and companies helped UK in last 2 years to regain the market. Dairy
products were among few categories with high growth rate. Fresh fruits & vegetables is the other major
category with 32% of organic food sales followed by dairy segment at 28%.
17
Market Overview: UK
Market Size USD 2.9 billion
Growth rate 3%
Expected Growth Rate NA
Distribution Channel Hypermarket / Supermarket 70% Organic specialized stores 15%
Growth Rates Processed Categories Baby Food (6-7%) Confectionary (8%) Snack Bars (8%)
Product Categories-All % contribution Fruits & Vegetables 32% Dairy & Dairy Products 28% Baby Food 11%
08. Switzerland:
Switzerland with USD 273, has the highest per capita consumption of organic food globally. Organic food
market size is USD 2.6 billion with a growth rate of 6%. Swiss consumers are the most health conscious
people in Europe as Switzerland is considered to be a global leader in organic farming and organic
products. As Swiss consumers purchase more and more food products for their perceived health benefits,
the value they place on such products continues to grow. Egg is the major category with 21% of organic
food sales followed by bread at 20% and fruits & vegetables at 19%.
09. Canada:
Canada organic food market size is USD 3.6 billion growing at 9% and expected to grow at CAGR 5-6%
(2015-20). There is growing trend for fresh fruits & vegetables such as Banana, Apple, Citrus fruits etc for
gluten free baby food and organic coffee with a growth rate of 9%. Fresh fruits & vegetables is the major
category with 42% of organic food sales followed by organic beverages at 17%.
10. Japan:
Japan is one of the most promising markets in Asia with market size USD 1.45 billion growing at a rate of
5% and expected to grow 9% CAGR during 2015-20. Japanese consumers are willing to pay a premium for
organic products with JAS logo. There is growing trend for organic beverages such as tea and coffee. With
the aging population, organic convenience food has picked up. Fresh fruits & vegetables is the major
category with 72% of organic food sales followed by cereals at 20%. There is high dependency on imports
(60% ) to meet the local demand for organic food. Earth quake/ tsunamis are regular features of the
Indian Organic Sector: Vision 2025
nation so most of the consumer relies on imported food to meet the conventional and organic food
consumption.
11. Australia:
Australia is one of the fastest growing countries in organic food market with market size of USD 1.6 bn
which is growing at a rate of 15-18%. The organic food market is expected to grow 15% CAGR during 2015-
20. Australia is one of the fastest growing organic markets with the largest organic land under cultivation
i.e. 40% of the global organic land. Australian consumers believe in ethical food habits and have
environmental concern. There is a growing demand for organic food in supermarkets and modern trade.
Dairy is the major category with 27% of organic food sales followed by meat & poultry at 25%.
South Korea is predominantly dependent on imported organic products. Korean organic food market
size is USD 578 million which is growing at a rate of 8%. The Korean consumer is health conscious, with
high disposable income and is ready to pay a premium for organic food. Korean population is rapidly
aging and considers healthy eating as a top priority. As per a study approximately 40% of the
population buys organic food on regular basis. Milk & milk products is the major category with 45% of
19
organic food sales followed by rice at 32%. There is high dependency on imports to meet the demand
for organic food. South Korea can be a major potential market for Indian organic food processors and
traders for rice, cereals, dairy products and processed fruits & vegetables.
02. The estimated organic production for the year 2014-15 was 1.1 million MT which is slightly lower
than the previous year production (2013-14) i.e. 1.24 million MT. Statewise breakup of wild vs farm
production and contribution to total production is as below:
State Farm (MT) Wild (MT) Total (MT) Share
Madhya Pradesh 321586 377 321964 29%
Karnataka 254664 96 254761 23%
Maharashtra 217112 210 217323 20%
Gujarat 60621 5 60626 5%
Rajasthan 59449 667 60117 5%
Uttar Pradesh 50165 133 50299 5%
Odisha 28678 293 28972 3%
20
The top three states in the wild production are Chhattisgarh, Jammu & Kashmir, and Jharkhand,
having a combined share of 81% of the total wild production for the year 2014-15.
The combined share of top 10 categories is around 99%. The top four categories (with a share of
around 85%) include sugar crops, oil seed crops, fiber crops and cereals & millets.
03. Indian Exports of organic foods were estimated at INR 2100 crores in 2014-15 with total volume of
2.86 lakh ton and which is about 26 % of the total produced volume of around 11 lakh ton. It is
assumed that most of the balance quantity is sold in local markets or sold uncategorized. The
exports in the previous year were about Rs. 1328 crores.
04. The organized domestic certified organic market is estimated to be between Rs. 250 to Rs. 300
crores. Guesstimates put the other part of the irregular unregulated domestic 'unorganized-
uncertified-unmonitored' organic market size range between Rs. 300 to Rs. 500 crores. Total
domestic market13 estimates range widely from Rs. 500 crores to Rs. 1000 crores as no reliable
estimation exercise was ever undertaken.
05. The major share of exports were oil seeds , cereals and millets, and processed foods with a combined
share of around 87%. In the Oil seeds category, Soybean with exports of 1.46 lakh MT during
2014-15 had a share of around 91% . In cereal and millets category, rice, maize, wheat and millets
are being exported. In the rice category the quantity of basmati rice exported was around
10300 MT.
13
International Competence Centre for Organic Agriculture (ICCOA) estimated that the domestic market for organic products in the
year 2012 at Rs. 300 crore which grew to Rs. 600 crore in 2013 i.e. a growth rate of 100%. This was a very small study and involved
wide projections/ assumptions.
21
06. The major Indian export destinations were USA, European Union, Canada, Switzerland and Israel
with a combined share of around 99% in volume terms (lakh MT). In terms of export value USA,
European Union, Canada, Switzerland, and Japan have a combined share of 97%. Around 3000 MT of
organic produce worth value around INR 55 Cr was exported to different Asian markets in 2014-15.
The major Asian markets volume wise were Israel, Japan, Turkey, UAE, Singapore and Thailand.
Japan with Rs. 26.5 crore tops the chart in value terms followed by Israel, Turkey and China .
a) Organic seed varieties are not available in India- Proper research and development on organic
seeds suitable for various agro-climatic zones is still lacking in India. State seed corporations
do not have certified organic seed. This is leading to erratic supply of various organic crop
seeds.
22
b) Plant protection is a big challenge in organic industry- Due to lack of research and availability of
organic plant protection, organic farmers are susceptible to utilize conventional products
(weedicides, herbicides and fungicides).
c) State-of-the-art residue testing labs are not available in India and most of the exporters are
sending samples to Europe for testing leading to higher costs as well as time for export
shipments increases, due to clearance from external labs.
Indian Organic Sector: Vision 2025
d) Dedicated warehousing and transportation facilities are absent in India for organic produce
limiting the growth of the sector. Moreover contamination of organic commodities in
conventional warehouses is also an issue.
e) The North Eastern region is having abundant produce like large cardamom, pineapple, ginger,
citrus fruits etc. but due to lack of post harvest, storage and logistics infrastructure, inherent
strength of the region has not been realized.
f) Commodity specific infrastructure for organic produce is missing from farm gate to processing
centers. Ex: Silos for grains, Cold chain for perishables etc
g) For Organic F&V, sufficient dedicated cold chain and logistics facilities are not available, thus
hampering export of organic F&V, especially mango, grapes, pomegranate etc. Lack of
dedicated logistics for organic sector increases cross contamination issues.
i) Organic produce is highly prone to pest infestation during storage as no chemicals are used for
fumigation. Conventional chemical based fumigation cannot be utilized for organic produce,
and hence new technologies like Co2 fumigation needs to be promoted and supported by grants.
a) Lack of awareness on organic agriculture as a concept among farmers: This knowledge deficit
leading to a gap between what is required by the consumer/ buyer and what is produced by the
farmer leading to trust issues.
b) Lack of technical know-how leading to yield drops, contaminated output etc- divulging the
farmers from organic agriculture.
c) Inadequate extension activities and non availability of trained trainers. No significant impact is
being seen in up gradation of skills despite efforts from the government.
23
d) Inadequate budgetary allocation for capacity building in organic farming is limiting the
outreach and quality of capacity building.
e) Limited research in organic sector remains unfruitful until it reaches the farms. A revolution in
organic farming is possible only if the transfer is made efficient and its outreach is extended
significantly
f) Both the above areas reflects on most part a result on scattered nature of the sector, so efforts
When adding health and wellness claims to products, sellers must first understand how consumers
perceive their products. If the product is perceived as healthy, any claims regarding the health benefits
of a product are likely to resonate with consumers. For semi-healthy and indulgent categories, however,
manufacturers must be more selective and choose claims that address a particular product attribute.
For example, while consumers may be skeptical of heart-health claims for potato chips, they may be
more open to claims about low or reduced sodium because this is compatible with their view of chips as a
salty indulgence.
1. The New Age Organic is Actually Organic Plus: Branding Organic products is no longer simple.
Organic certification faces competition from other green movements, like sustainability which
many manufacturers are turning to. (PGS has an opportunity to go this route for domestic
markets). Research indicates, the brand Organic is saturating and overlapping with other
categories internationally. As the lines blur, it is important for Organic to conjoin with other/
kindred categories such as Fortified, Naturally Healthy, Vegetarian, Kosher etc. Fair Trade
Certification for instance is practiced by Soap maker Dr. Bronner's etc. and the French beauty
brand Nomino retains the basic Organic value while propagating other claims such as Local
Product/ Less Carbon Footprints etc. A new holistic approach is desirable in Organic branding.
3. Whole Foods Move: Organic foods now face the challenge of being seen as prized food as against
prized for Organic alone. The point is best illustrated by the case of Whole Foods Market in USA.
By the early 2000's, Whole Foods had pretty much maxed out market share in the organic and
natural customer segment, but were pursuing growth. Research indicated that 80% of first-
time Whole Foods shoppers became loyal customers, and Foodies represented a highly prized
customer segment with the most untapped growth potential.
Indian Organic Sector: Vision 2025
Their challenge was how to appeal to this segment more effectively and inspire Foodies to try
shopping at Whole Foods for the first time?
The answer was a shift in brand strategy. The strategy involved de-emphasizing the
Organic/natural messaging, and developing a new brand strategy targeting Foodies (without
alienating the earthy-crunchies) captured in the tagline Passionately Picky. The strategy
was expressed in an ad campaign focused on getting Foodies excited about a specific food item.
4. Dietary Claims: Today the scientific evidence questions the efficacy of conventional dietary
supplements, therefore Organic products branded with scientific dietary claims have potential
to see strong growth. Whereas in food and drink, organics can be associated with health
benefits, for many other industries, such as beauty and personal care, apparel and tissue and
hygiene, the purchase has strong ethical connotations.
5. Emotional claims a key: Most successful Organic branding is leaning on developing a lasting
emotional attachment with customers. This is the key ingredient in long-term customer loyalty
and establishing a sense of authenticity among followers. Fostering emotional attachment
helps build trust and gives customers a sense that 'we're in this together'. This can be a
powerful tool. (- Dan Ratner, Foodmagazine July 15)
6. Indian-ness in positioning: India evokes powerful and deep emotions in the western psyche,
but how do we leverage it? How do we develop a unique positioning which harnesses that?
Where does brand India Organic go now on? There is tremendous scope to incorporate the
Ayurveda and yoga platforms in Indian Organic branding. This is being used successfully in
the developed markets, Pukka Health Ltd for instance has significant sales for
herbal/traditional medicinal teas. It produces a wide range of organic bio supplements. The
company ensures the brand follows its beliefs in ayurveda, and targets those consumers trying
to achieve overall wellbeing, physically and mentally.
7. Brand values On Organic Pack: Packaging can be used to highlight brand values and features.
Brands can consider this desire for naturally healthy food through the use of thoughtful
packaging that reflects the brand's core values and key features. Many health food companies
are generally opting for images that reflect this desire, such as nature, families and fresh
produce. (Whole Kids, for example, uses this strategy)
25
8. Messaging for Organic: Message Strategies in branding need to take into account a few things.
It's best to avoid consumer's skepticism and be more transparent about the contents and
source of foods, providing stronger scientific support for health claims to build consumer trust.
It helps if the health/wellness claims are clear and upfront. Transparency is key for health food
brands looking to reinforce and communicate authentic healthy foods. Consumers want to
know more about the products they're buying and it makes good business sense to oblige them.
10. Packaging material: In Organic products packaging material too has important message to
lend itself. Often, the design comprises fresh, pure images, where the environmental benefits,
in particular, are easily recognized. The use of greener packaging is true not only for food, but
increasingly for other organic products, including pet in the developed markets, Pukka Health
Ltd for instance has significant sales for herbal/traditional medicinal teas. It produces a wide
range of organic bio supplements. The company ensures the brand follows its beliefs in
Ayurveda, and targets those consumers trying to achieve overall wellbeing, physically and
mentally.
11. Information on Organic packaging: Packaging labels are a key source of information for
Organic consumers. Globally the respondents say they read packaging labels carefully.
Manufacturers and retailers need to provide easy-to-understand and clear nutritional
information to help respondents take control of their health.
12. Packaging Organic to aid informed decision: It's also important to make it easy for consumers
to cut through the clutter (nutritional content of foods as well as the environmental and social
impact, production source and health benefits) and make informed decisions by helping them
understand the benefits of particular ingredients and foods using out-of-store
communications, in-store signage/displays and package claims.
Packaging for Organic should suggest an openness about the origins of the food and invites
people to find out more about the brand.
NOTE: Data sources for part 1are Industry Reports from- Fibl/ IFOAM/ Organic data network/ USDA/ OTA/ Global Organic
Trade/Individual Country Trade Data/ Organic World / Trade Publications/Report by Govt. of Canada (www5.agr.ca)/Austro Organic
Report/The Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Environment (MAGRAMA)/Italian Ministry for Agriculture (MiPAAF)/International
Society of Organic Agricultural research/Intracen.org/ APEDA/GOI/ Others
Part 2
Recommendations
28
Indian Organic Sector: Vision 2025
Recommendations
1. Identification of India Stars or Focus Products:
Top 10+5
01. India today exports about 300- 400 products, mostly non value
added commodities at the bottom of the value chain. Of these the
major share are low value bulk commodities - oil seeds , cereals and
millets with a share of over 55% of the volume, soybean alone
having lions share. Indian exports are basically a cheap low-cost
source for organic companies that value value add or process and
sell it further to companies that brand and market them to
consumers.
02. Most of the value is thus lost and the country is unable to do
anything about it given that the sector as well as individual
companies have very low bargaining power and are also small. They
do not have resources to do what is required to go up the value chain
or break-into the markets at a higher level of value or price point.
Small exceptions of course do exist but once again they are mere
blips in the aggressive competitive global market place and are
struggling with firms from other countries that are larger, more
specialized and can also produce at lower costs having efficiencies
of scale.
03. The sourcing, collection and other logistics and supply chain
activities are scattered geographically and no industry
concentration exists even at a micro level. Organic farming is
spread across the nation and farm concentration in individual crops
or clusters are difficult to come by. Farmers, thus do not have
supply to authentic organic farm services, inputs and guidance on
crop management. They face similar problems of poor productivity,
inefficiency and inability to get the best market price possible
though they produce a premium product.
29
04. Overall, across the value chain from the farmer to exporter, there is no specialization and
inefficiency is common. Professionalism and efficiency can be brought in only if there is
concentration and scale.
05. Organic is a niche business worldwide. Niche businesses strategy has differentiation at its
core and has two well established cardinal principles:
b. Closeness to customer: be as close as possible to the customer so that the player can react
quickly to his needs and changing preferences. So sell as much higher up the value chain
as possible.
This is the competitive strategy India needs to adopt and get the best price from the market which
can thus go down the value chain up to the farmer.
06. Unless there is a concerted effort in a few focused selected areas, India cannot go up the value
chain, have specialization and build an efficient supply chain. India can succeed in the
organic business if it specializes and gives the best deal to the farmer, earn valuable foreign
exchange and build a thriving export business for the country as a whole. Product focus is 50
% of the strategic battle.
07. The study team went through a comprehensive exercise to identify areas where Indias
organic business should focus on:
a. Develop specialization
b. Develop concentrated pockets of organic farm clusters
c. Build common primary farm processing and storage in those organic farm clusters
d. Develop superior technology in selected focus areas in processing and handling
e. R& D in product development
f. Industry /consolidation for efficiency
g. Common India thrust under which firms can operate for marketing in these selected
product groups.
h. Developing new export markets and access for sustainable global trade Ex: Russia,
Australia, Korea etc
08. Focus products were selected through a comprehensive exercise. Five parameters were used
to arrive at the final scores for selecting top prospects for 2025:
promotion. These categories and their derivative products should form the basis of Indias organic
food product export growth till 2025.
03. Other Markets for Development: The markets listed above are most likely untapped by the Indian
exporters, therefore showing up low current confidence in dealing with them. But it is to be noted
that some of them have very high growth rates and maybe an early entrant advantage is possible here
since no established trade relationship need to be overcome. these markets will be looking for new
suppliers.
04. There is a need for a country wise sales plan for the focus products as well as promotional plan for the
focus product categories identified earlier.
05. Detailed country wise survey may be required in the next stage to make the above plan.
A comprehensive Brand Personality/ Identity/ Communication plan needs to be charted out. Goals
must be set for the brand & budget allotted in order to achieve awareness targets in different
audiences and the same implemented through professional agencies.
03. India organic is likely to grow its products and markets and become a flagship of Indian organic
produce internationally, thus an umbrella branding needs to be created for India organic brand, and
after that a strategy to establish linkages between Umbrella and Individual Indian Organic Company
brands developed.
Indian Organic Sector: Vision 2025
04. It may be prudent for the national brand India Organic to use shared communication platforms and
undertake joint promotion of India Organic and individual brands so that individual brand can be
supported as vehicle to take India Organic brand values as against non targeted- non carrier generic
promotion.
Different brands of different exporter companies could be used via joint promotion to communicate
core values of India organic brand.
05. The sensibilities of international markets are inclined towards testimonies and referrals. Once there
is a foothold, penetration of the brand is relatively easier. It may therefore be useful to create
avenues for business of India Organic brand with leading and reputed global retail houses and
organizations globally and ride on these testimonies for further growth.
06. Aggressive promotion strategy using a strong branding theme in all vehicles including trade fairs etc
should be linked branding strategy and sales plan. It is necessary to allocate communication budget/
expenses with clear sales targets in each focus product and focus country. Promotion plan must have
all elements. Other initiatives must include: Trade missions and business meetings, Assistance in
fairs, congresses and other events abroad, Market studies for TM, changes in trends and allied Market
access problem identification, studies and execution of possible solutions.
07. A domestic branding and promotion strategy should be done hand in hand which dovetails into the
international positioning. Urban customers buying premium products especially organic products
may be similar to international. The Domestic Market for Organic products is still in nascent stages
and the government could expedite the process through Consumer education on organic foods, this
is of critical importance. Promoting organic category locally and creating awareness of organic foods
among all stakeholders, especially consumers is a must. (Healthy foods, natural foods, pesticide free
foods, organic foods, zero residue foods are few categories that occupy super market shelves.) AIOI
could facilitate this promotion for a pan India consumer campaign/ education program on the lines
of Milk/ Egg Promotion initiatives. The same could be overseen by APEDA/ GOI. The government could
sponsor the consumer awareness campaign in the media and fund the same. The domestic campaign
will have cascading effect on the supply chain- farmers as it will enable pride in being an organic
farmer as well.
08. A medium and long-term marketing strategy including recommendations for branding is required
and the financial and technical resources required need to be identified to implement the strategy.
The overall marketing strategy will include a detailed short-term marketing and promotional
program for the first five years, outlining activities, targets and cost estimates on a yearly basis.
33
A study needs to be commissioned immediately to evaluate this critical area of branding with
following objectives:
a) Map consumer needs and concerns in both domestic and top international markets to find out
relevant positioning platforms.
b) Test most relevant platforms and identify the best position that India Organic should adopt
c) Fix communication goals for each segment
02. There is also a feeling that PGS may be allowed to use the established Organic label to accede to
demands of NGO's leading the PGS movement. This is a matter of grave concern because PGS being
less stringent and self-certifying claim is an untested label and can dilute the authenticity of entire
Organic category both domestically and internationally. This could derail all the work of building
credentials of Indian Organic products so far. This is also against International norms in the largest
global organic markets like USA & EU.
03. The PGS system is recognized by IFOAM as most suitable for 'local' markets which are described as
markets where the farmer and consumer interact directly or know of each other. Local does not mean
domestic distant markets in cities far away from the farms. The word 'local' is being confused in
India to connote domestic market (as against international market). Consumers in city markets in
India are very concerned about non-adulteration, authenticity and genuineness of claims and
require certification in no uncertain terms. So it's recommended that Organic label and PGS label be
kept apart and not get mixed up.
04. Certification costs more money and is very stringent. The certification processes are stringent and
cost money, but they offer the consumer the watertight assurance he seeks. Higher incentive should
be given for farmers going in for organic certification in comparison to PGS, so that the two are
clearly set apart as deserved. Both the domestic customer who is willing to pay more and the farmer
who works harder both deserve protection from lower quality checks.
05. PGS should be used to educate & encourage farmers to take up sustainable farming. The farmers
could then migrate to certified organic. As such calling it as "Organic" would be misleading.
34
06. Today in the market place it is not enough to have just an Organic premise, it's necessary to make an
Organic +, branding with other certifications. Other certifications needed and sought by the
consumers in the international market include Fair-trade, Gluten free, Vegetarian, Halal, Kosher,
Humane etc.
07. To streamline the current certification process the following needs to be done immediately:
a) Three month study to be commissioned for understanding and receiving suggestions on in
Indian Organic Sector: Vision 2025
08 Other recommendations:
a) APEDA to Institutionalize Annual Participative Dialogue (APD) with Cbs & industry for more
effective ownership and role clarity. ii) APEDA and FSSAI to institutionalize annual National
Pesticide Residue Testing (NPRT) to build trust in consumers and help genuine organic
operators. iii) Review of CBs role and independent monitoring of their functioning. iv) Propose
a new organic trade regulatory body similar to TRAI to protect interests of stakeholders. APEDA
can continue to function in policy making and licensing etc. v) study required to investigate
certification costs./ processes in other countries, to put quality control mechanism in place so
as to avoid penalty measures/ bans, analysis costs which are highly prohibitive needs to be
drastically reduced. The certifying agencies are just scared of regulatory system which is viewed
as business unfriendly. TC costs need to be regularized and made reasonable. vi) Dairy and
Livestock Certification: As on date no CB has been accredited for livestock and dairy
certification, this is the need of the hour and urgent steps for accreditation of the CBs to be
taken up.
5. Policy
01. Domestic Organic policy especially certification and standards should be made subsidiary to
international market development and export requirements. This ensures Indian export credibility
is not impacted in any way (till such a time organised sector domestic market sales near exports-
correctly domestic to exports is 200-2100 cr), additionally Indian customer also gets the global
quality product.
35
02. NPOP- should be the only standard for both domestic and international market and enforced strictly.
Only one body should oversee one quality and one national standard. Clear-cut organic labelling
laws like USDA & EU as international practice need to be implemented for India for both domestic and
international markets.
03. Two separate bodies are suggested for the development of Indian organic sector, one for uniform
regulation and other for promotion and awareness of organic (for promotion, Domestic and Exports
should be handled separately).
07. No Bans or restrictions in exports. Commodity stocking limits also should be lifted.
08. Others: Stakeholder Support System (3S) platform for the industry covering the following aspects to
be available : incentives for exports, incentives for new product and market development,
infrastructure set up under private ownership, trade facilitation in new export destinations,
incentives for sustainable eco-packaging and packaging innovations, brand building for new
product categories and new export destinations
36
chemical and toxicity analysis. This would encourage genuine operators of the sector.
Setting up of world class food testing laboratories in a three tier system at farm level,
processing and consumer market level and port levels for unbiased food testing and
transparency. Low cost food testing innovations to be encouraged through global
tendering.
Organic Food Parks (OFPs) to be set up in key organic food production clusters with
assistance from MoFPI for common infra. Tenders should be invited with active
participation of Indian exporters, global buyers and FTLs as partners.
Supply chain control by operators: Entire farm-gate handling to processor supply chain
should be under the ambit of organic processors and exporters. This will ensure proper
focus by the farmers on quality production on the farm.
8. Skilling & HR
01 Organic farming to be included in the National Skill Development Mission. AIOI can be made the
nodal agency for this.
02 Credit course on organic agriculture to be developed and implemented in all agricultural
universities.
03 Recommendations from private sector (from Indian and global stakeholders) for the curriculum
design
04 Active NGOs, grass root level institutions and Certification Bodies can also become partners for
education. Corporate CSR funds should be made available under alleviation of rural poverty
theme.
05 Training the trainers- Training modules to be prepared after consultation with industry players as
well. Impact assessment to be done periodically for the organic extension activities
06 Seeing is Believing- Demonstration farms to be set up for organic farming- Support private sector to
set up organic demo plots. Use existing organic farms as success stories. Farmers, who are already
practicing organic agriculture can also be selected as demonstrators.
07 Extension activities should take place in a PPP mode, wherein the service provider identifies a cluster
for his work and proposes his work methodology
08 Increasing Budget Allocation: Allocations for promotion of organic farming be scaled up
substantially to meet the intended objective of sustainable agriculture
09 Formation of Self Help Groups and Farmer Producer Companies: Better planning and management of
resources, value addition and marketing is possible through formations of of SHGs/ICS groups/FPCs
37
9. Product Specific
Category (key products) Sector specific recommendations
All Products 1. MEIS scheme
2. Organic farmer development- PKVY to be given via all operators,
especially market linked supply chains. Extension fund for ICS
managers based on number of farmers to be provided for providing
Tea and herbal beverages 1. Subsidy on the tea packaging machinery, brand promotion and market
(Conventional and herbal teas development of tea (Ex: Organic Darjeeling, organic Assam teas etc)
and beverages) 2. Special fund for development of organic market in domestic and export
markets
Nuts and dry fruits (Cashew, 1. Value added cashew processing machinery subsidy
walnuts, value added products)
Soybean and products (Soymeal, 1. Merchandise Export Incentive Scheme (MEIS) to be reintroduced for
soybean, lecithin) certified organic products.
Processed, packaged products 1. Testing subsidy for GMOs, Pesticides etc to be provided for processed
and ingredients (Ethnic / foods till globally equivalent Food Testing Laboratory is set up in India.
specialty foods Gourmet meals)
38
Vision 2025
1. Way Forward
The global organic food market-currently at USD 90 bn shall reach close to
USD 230-280 bn by 2025 at the current growth levels. The Indian organic sector
at USD 415 million (Rs.2700 Cr) is not even 0.5 % of it, constituting both
negligible domestic component and exports.
For planning growth, scaling up and for the overall economic development of a
business sector, it is necessary to have a threshold size and critical mass. This
should be the basis for all future visioning, plans, investment & establishing
infrastructure. Unfortunately the Indian Organic sector lacks this critical mass.
While a straight line vision and growth plan may seem logical and way to go
about, in actuality it will neither make any difference nor enable sustainable
success. Only a radical vision can bring the Indian Organic sector to achieve this
threshold, and also make it forward-looking.
The choices and decisions made on these scenarios will determine the way
forward.
41
01. In this Conventional Assisted Growth approach the projections are based
on aiding the natural growth rate trend and boosting it a few points to CAG- CONVENTIONAL
about 15 to 20% per annum with a consideration that incentives and ASSISTED GROWTH
schemes are provided and identified issues, problems and policy (Straight Line Normal)
bottlenecks are smoothened. This is a highly conservative model and (8,840 Cr by 2025)
neither farmers nor exporters will stand to benefit appreciably through
this approach.
14
Initial provisional Scenarios: Each category would need detailed study to arrive at ratified figures. At present no official study
nor data available, this is the first such attempt.
42
The Indian organic exports can reach the Rs. 8,840 mark if all policy hurdles are removed and current
incentives asked for are provided. However, no distinctive change in global market share is visible
here. It shall remain below 1%.
India remains static in the world market even though there is four times jump in revenue.
02. Under the Focused Sectoral Growth strategy the growth is strategically
FSG-
Indian Organic Sector: Vision 2025
The effort required is very different from the first approach. Here the export has to focus on including
new value-added product options, ingredients and processed products as against exporting primary
processed products or commodities. The products and markets related to the chosen categories need
to be developed and special schemes formulated to ensure growth in each. Selling value- added
products involves overseas marketing activity as against exporting commodities, it is quite different
from the mechanics of a low-level supplier. Overseas importers are reluctant to buy ready-processed
foods or even semi- processed value-added foods even if it is to another brand, unless some
conditions are met. Some of these conditions pertain to quality assurance and some with liability in
their own domestic markets. The right policies need to be framed and requisite support provided on
all these counts. Needless to state R & D and technology development is an integral part of this
approach.
This approach is in line with the current thinking of the government and the global market share
achievable thorugh this approach is only 1% of the world market. The strategic advantage derived for
India Organic through this approach remains small on the whole in spite of focused efforts as the market
share obtained is small .
15
5% of Conventional Exports in 2025. Projections done using CAGR of last few years.
43
Here, after studying the international market, we determine a share we wish to aggressively
accomplish for the chosen products and go about putting in place plans to achieve these numbers.
This requires serious unrelenting commitment of business strategy, professionalism and global-
level swift policy making.
In this RTG plan, the target is estimated at Rs. 45, 000 crores . This figure was computed by adding
up projections of individual products at 4- 5% of the Indian conventional exports. Most exporters
RTG's figure of Rs.45,000 crores is about 3% share of the world market. At this level the Indian
organic sector will now have a critical mass.
This critical mass will make India Organic sustainable and competent to take a 'competitive
position' as a serious player in the international market. But it would require very high level of
commitment of putting in whatever effort and resources required to achieve a set target .
An integral part of this strategy is to develop the domestic market for organic foods through
lucrative incentives for farmers to go Organic and all the necessary technical assistance in addition
to increase awareness and usage, making India among the top Organic using nations.
The sector a whole has to be grown generically at a primary level. The thinking has to transcend to a
new pace and plane. India needs a critical threshold if it has to operate sustainably and with
"strategic competitive advantage" in the long term.
The way to go about in this approach is to work backwards from the figure determined for each
category and find out how to achieve it. This process can be outlined in steps as under:
a) Determine volume targets for products to be exported by individual category as well as for
domestic consumption
b) From the volumes above, determine sales/share targets for individual/country markets
c) From the Volumes in 1 above , determine India's own supply and farm production plans
d) Determine the number of farm acreage by crops and even the varieties (thus planning farm
clusters and processing hubs)
e) Roll out plan for the next 5-10 years by components.
Some of the preliminary projections given in the table above may appear to be high. In a few
individual categories e.g. Darjeeling tea, it is quite likely the target may have to be stepped up to
10% of conventional.
For a large country like India taking a 3% global share is a right beginning, and the RTG approach shall
enable this. This is the most recommended approach.
44
2. Impact on Farmers
Farmer will be the ultimate beneficiary in the process of the govt.
Five million farmers
integrating the farmer with these market-led growth plans. Historically the
and six million ha
farm sector has prospered only when the farmers have become an integral
can benefit from
part of the market-linked value chains. This vision can ensure that there is
Organic farming
Indian Organic Sector: Vision 2025
We have examples from the past, wherein product such as tobacco, tea, coffee, seeds, sugar, PDS procured
Grains etc., which have ushered in farm stability and prosperity. An integrated value chain from farmer to
the consumer which enabled commitment of purchase and price stability was a distinctive characteristic
in the marketing of these products. This kind of integration has not been available to other commodities
and led to uncertainty and chaos in the farm economy due to vagaries of the APMCs (market yards).
Unless the market targets are significant , impact at the farm level can not be felt in a large country like
India. Similarly, if the farmers are encouraged to produce large quantities without them being made a
part of a market-led supply plan and a value chain, they are unlikely to find buyers who will buy their
produce at the right price.
Considering both export and domestic market projections, the following is likely to be the impact at
farmer level:
About 6.3 million ha with 5.3 Million Ha rain-fed & 1 million ha irrigated land will be included
in the organic value chain under these projections. (current organic cultivation is around
100,000 ha)
Approximately 5 million farmers will be benefited. Increased incomes, food security and farm
prosperity will ensue
Given the fact cattle are integral to organic farming, bringing "the cow" back into the farm
household will broad base their enterprise
Taking the example of Rice, to illustrate farm level impact, the number projected here of Rs.8000 crores
translates to only about 500,000 ha - a miniscule fraction of national rice area 44 m.ha. If India is serious
about organic farming, RTG target is also quite small.
While this plan is focused on providing a larger vision to achieving a value target, eventually the same
growth platform must be used to convert at least 2% to 3% of national acreage into organic farming.
It is however important to note that creating market demand precedes expanding farm supply which is
being spoken of.
We can draw a lesson from parallel models like Hy. Rice penetration in understanding the dynamics of
diffusion of organic farm technology. While it took about 10 years to reach 3 % of total rice acres in India,
in the case of China, hybrid rice reached over 30 % to 40% in a similar time frame.
China used RTG model and converted over 70% of all rice to hybrid whereas in India it is still 5% using the
CAG model though nearly 20 yrs have passed.
45
3. Domestic Market
Domestic Market can
India Domestic Organic Market Projections
reach Rs.25,000
( In Rs. Crore)
crores
45000
25000 mark by 2025.
40000
Research shows there is high demand for the Organic product, but
Need For National
unfortunately very low awareness. Organic category as a whole needs to
Organic Category
be promoted and consumers made to see Organic products in association
Promotion Budget
with their sorely felt requirements for healthy foods. The individual
brands operating locally are and will be unable to grow, in absence of
Make Organic
promotional budgets, unless they find themselves in an 'Organic-aware
Aware Nation
nation'. The brands will grow at a steady pace, but the impact would be
radically enhanced if the Government invests in promotion.
This is the task the government should undertake since Organic-awareness will lead to Organic-
readiness for business, thereby promoting its own national India Organic brand and also subsidize the
other brands thus operating symbiotically. National-level awareness on Organic will also motivate the
farmers and give them a sense of pride in growing Organic products. They will feel they are a part of the
premium consumer movement in the urban India as against being left out in rural anonymity.
The campaign promoting "India Organic" may be managed by the Industry association- AIOI overseen
by GOI. National Brand promotion requires an annual budget. Successful brands spend 12% of projected
sales in first year to develop a new category in a five year plan. We are projecting Indian market will
reach between Rs. 20,000 to Rs. 25,000 crores, this is a necessary investment that the Nation will
benefit from. The entire supply chain from farmer to consumer will continue to reap the benefit from the
India Organic Promotion campaign for years to come.
4. Game Changers for India Organic
01. Make in India: Landmark change can be brought about and Organic revolution in India expedited
by encouraging Global Organic companies to set up India processing base for which Indian
companies and farmers can become suppliers initially, making it a win-win for all. This can
increase. Indian Organic farm area manyfolds. The basis for setting up these would be (1) Strong
regulation & clear quality environment (2) Providing an international Organic ecosystem via a food
park or similar system (3) Giving access to Indian domestic market to incentivize.
46
02. India Soil Carbon mandate: Indian Organic soil content is dismal, the green revolution and cheap
fertilizer chemical availability being the prime reasons. Fertilizer companies enjoying subsidy need
to be made partners in reviving soil health. Therefore, India needs to adopt India Soil Carbon
mandate, like the E2/ E5 and B10 biofuel mandates to the gigantic fertilizer companies, to make
available Organic manures/inputs as a percentage of their turnover/ subsidy and convert a given
acreage to organic in a year. Fertilizer companies have the logistic infrastructure available to handle
the huge quantities of organic matter required and make it available to the farmers.
Organic inputs are scarce and more of a cottage industry in India, making such mandate will enable
Indian Organic Sector: Vision 2025
aggressive and structured availability of inputs. Mandates need to be ramped up every three years
(say starting from 0.5%). The same will take a century if left to the cottage industry. Rs.3400 crores
annual effort by organized agriculture companies can happen by a stroke of the pen/single policy if
5% of the fertilizer subsidy bill of 68,000 crores is mandated to making organic acres.
03. Developing Organic Hubs: Organic hubs of minimum sizes will help integrate the dissipated and
dispersed Organic acreages into manageable concentrated pockets. All needed support
infrastructure can easily be provided both at farmer as well as output/processing ends, to achieve
economies of scale and efficiency needed to compete on global standards. States governments and
organic companies can work in these hubs primarily.
Develop a Comprehensive National Organic Strategy and Implementation Plan for each category on
the lines of typical business plan of a multinational, adapted to a country, outlining:
a) Markets by Product Groups
b) Market Targets in each
c) Share and Volume Objectives & Profitability Goals
d) Strategies to achieve the above
e) Processing Infrastructure required
f) Value added products and technologies to be developed
g) Farm Supply, Acreages and location
h) Incentives, training, extension, inputs, support and farm plans
5. Other Elements required for Organic Vision 2025
01. Promote one certification standard which is simple and credible. Customers whether in India or
abroad expect Organic products to be free of pesticides, harmful chemicals and GMO's, follow high
food safety standards are produced in a sustainable manner and are fair to the farmers. Having
multiple standards can cause confusion, ultimately affecting the farmers and wasting of valuable
financial and human resources.
02. Skill India: Training of rural youth in Organic farming under skill India mission. AIOI is willing to take
up the responsibility of implementing this.
03. Financial support to farmers: Organic farmers receive limited subsidy and support or support.
Amount equivalent to fertilizer subsidy should be given to organic farmers to generate on farm
organic inputs, purchase bio fertilizers, bio pesticides, certification and other cultivation tools. This
could be done through JAM mechanism.
04. Technology Mission for Organic Agriculture: The current efforts of research through the wide
network of Institutions are weak and ineffective. ICAR should create a separate division headed by
47
Deputy Director General to develop appropriate technology including varieties, agronomy, plant
protection and post harvest technologies. The funds to go into actual research and not R&D infra
which is more than required. R& D should be monitored by user bodies.
05. Organic Food Parks: Organic requires specialized storage and processing infrastructure so that the
produce is not contaminated. Given that the industry is at a nascent stage, having decentralized
primary storage & processing parks at district level and a few central Organic Food processing
parks will help in achieving the goals. Liberal grants will help in this regard. The Association
through its members will be willing to form Special Purpose Vehicles (SPVs) for this. To start with
Annexure 1
1. During the survey the following individual products were listed as having good potential/
opportunity areas for exports from India. The focus products mentioned above were shortlisted from
these.
Annexure 2
Snapshot of key products
Category: Rice Top Ten- 1
Key production states Uttar Pradesh, Uttarakhand, Jammu & Kashmir, Andhra Pradesh, Haryana
Key production areas/ clusters Northern Belt, Andhra Pradesh
Export statistics (2014-15) 19,965 MT
Present export categories Basmati Rice: Brown traditional, Organic white Traditional, Brown, white pusa, Brown Pusa etc
(as per HS codes) Non basmati: Brown fast cooking, Broken, parboiled, Tarai, Red rice etc
Top sub categories (from survey) Basmati, Sona-masuri
1. EU,
Top Destination countries
(by volume) 2. USA
3. Japan
4. Australia
5. China
Top sub categories (from survey) Herbal tea, green tea, black tea, Darjeeling tea, flavor tea
1. EU
Top Destination countries
(by volume) 2. USA
3. Canada
4. Switzerland
5. New Zealand
Indian Organic Sector: Vision 2025
Present export categories Flour ( Rice, Wheat, Maize, Soybean, Bajra, Bengal gram, Black gram, Buckwheat, White rice),
(as per HS codes) Pulp & Puree ( Alphonso, Totapuri, Kesar, Papaya, Rajapari), Soybean (meal, roasted, lecithin),
Wheat bran, rice syrup, Extract (Annatto, Guava, Pomogranate), Sauce (Chili, Tomato),
Dehydrated Manhgo and Frozen mango, Ginger (Granules & candy), Pea powder, ready to eat
rice, flattened rice, roasted chicory, Onion granules
Top sub categories RTE, Frozen food, Indian frozen cuisine, snacks
1. EU
Top Destination countries
(by volume) 2. USA
3. Canada
4. Switzerland
5. New Zealand
Present export categories Ajwain, Turmeric, Amla Powder, Cumin Powder, Cumin, Ginger TBC, Black Pepper, Fenugreek,
(as per HS codes) Nutmeg, clove etc
Top sub categories (from survey) Black Pepper, Turmeric, Chili Powder, Cumin
Present export categories Sugar, Cane Sugar, Palmyra Sugar, Sugar White Cane
(as per HS codes)
Present export categories Arhar dal, Split pigeon Pea, Toor dal, Black gram, Urad dhuli, Green gram, Red Kidney bean,
(as per HS codes) Chick pea, Lentil, Cow pea red
Present export categories Flaxseed, linseed, Hulled Sesame, Natural Sesame, Mustard Oil (Crude & Refined), Safflower
(as per HS codes)
Top sub categories (from survey Q) Flax seed, Mustard, Safflower, Sunflower, Sesame,
Present export categories Totapuri Mangoes, Guavas Fresh, Mango Kernel, pomegranate arils
(as per HS codes)
Present export categories Almond: Shelled , Kernel ; Cashew Kernels: Shell Broken, Shell Whole, W240, W320, LWP, NW,
(as per HS codes) split, whole, Roasted , salted; Walnut: Kernels & Shelled
Top sub categories (from survey) Cashew, Almond, raisins, walnut