Solution Focused Therapy
Solution Focused Therapy
Solution Focused Therapy
Solution-focused therapy
Counseling model for busy family physicians
Gail Greenberg, MSW Keren Ganshorn, BPT, MD, CCFP Alanna Danilkewich, MD, CCFP, FCFP
ABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE To provide family doctors in busy office practices with a model for counseling compatible with
patient-centred medicine, including the techniques, strategies, and questions necessary for implementation.
QUALITY OF EVIDENCE The MEDLINE database was searched from 1984 to 1999 using the terms
psychotherapy in family practice, brief therapy in family practice, solution-focused therapy, and brief
psychotherapy. A total of 170 relevant articles were identified; 75 abstracts were retrieved and a similar
number of articles read. Additional resources included seminal books on solution-focused therapy (SFT),
bibliographies of salient articles, participation in workshops on SFT, and observation of SFT counseling
sessions taped by leaders in the field.
MAIN MESSAGE Solution-focused therapy’s concentration on collaborative identification and amplification
of patient strengths is the foundation upon which solutions to an array of problems are built. Solution-focused
therapy offers simplicity, practicality, and relative ease of application. From the perspective of a new learner,
MECSTAT provides a framework that facilitates development of skills.
CONCLUSION Solution-focused therapy recognizes that, even in the bleakest of circumstances, an emphasis
on individual strength is empowering. In recognizing patients as experts in self-care, family physicians
support and accentuate patient-driven change, and in so doing, are freed from the hopelessness and burnout
that can accompany misplaced feelings of responsibility.
RÉSUMÉ
OBJECTIF Offrir aux médecins de famille dont la pratique en cabinet privé est surchargée un modèle de
counseling compatible à la médecine centrée sur le patient, notamment des techniques, des stratégies et des
questions nécessaires à sa mise en œuvre.
QUALITÉ DES DONNÉES Une recension a été effectuée dans la base de données MEDLINE de 1984 à 1999 à
l’aide des mots clés « psychothérapie en pratique familiale, thérapie brève en pratique familiale, thérapie axée
sur la recherche de solutions et psychothérapie brève ». On a identifié 170 articles pertinents; 75 résumés
ont été cernés et un nombre à peu près égal d’articles ont été lus. Au nombre des sources d’information
additionnelles figuraient des ouvrages fondamentaux sur la thérapie axée sur la recherche de solutions
(TARS), les bibliographies des articles importants, la participation à des ateliers sur la TARS ainsi que
l’observation de séances de ce genre de counseling enregistrées par des experts dans ce domaine.
PRINCIPAL MESSAGE La concentration des thérapies axées sur la recherche de solutions portent sur
l’identification et l’amplification conjointes des forces du patient constitue le fondement sur lequel repose la
détermination de solutions à un éventail de problèmes. La thérapie axée sur la recherche de solutions est
simple, pratique et relativement facile à administrer. Du point de vue d’un néophyte, le MECSTAT offre les
paramètres qui facilitent le perfectionnement des compétences à cet égard.
CONCLUSION La thérapie axée sur la recherche de solutions reconnaît que, même dans les circonstances
les plus noires, l’insistance sur les forces du sujet se révèle habilitante. En reconnaissant les patients
comme des experts pour prendre soin d’eux-mêmes, les médecins de famille soutiennent et accentuent les
changements réalisés par le patient et, ce faisant, se libèrent de l’impuissance et de la fatigue professionnelle
qui accompagnent parfois des sentiments mal placés de responsabilité.
VOL 47: NOVEMBER • NOVEMBRE 2001 Canadian Family Physician • Le Médecin de famille canadien 2289
cme
Solution-focused therapy
ounseling has been the subject of numer- Schilling state that the approach allows the medical
2290 Canadian Family Physician • Le Médecin de famille canadien VOL 47: NOVEMBER • NOVEMBRE 2001
cme
Solution-focused therapy
VOL 47: NOVEMBER • NOVEMBRE 2001 Canadian Family Physician • Le Médecin de famille canadien 2291
cme
Solution-focused therapy
2292 Canadian Family Physician • Le Médecin de famille canadien VOL 47: NOVEMBER • NOVEMBRE 2001
cme
Solution-focused therapy
If a patient scales a problem at 1 or 2, you might take the form of cheerleading, they encourage patients
ask, “How will you know when you reach 2.5?” This to think aloud about personal accomplishments. “How
question requires the patient to identify the next step did you decide to do that?” or “How do you explain
and to begin solving the problem. If confidence is that?” reinforces and accentuates exception behaviour.
scaled at 1, asking, “How did you manage to come in In reality, once you get your head around the power
today?” encourages a patient to recognize that action behind the use of accolades, it becomes, for some
is possible even with low confidence. If confidence of us, the easiest and most supportive first step in
is scaled at 3, a question like, “What do you need solution talk. When we focus on small things patients
to do in order for your confidence to move to 3.5?” do to overcome adversity, we quickly begin to notice
will encourage thinking in concrete terms of strate- strengths and accomplishments. These become the
gies needed to sustain and increase confidence. When subject of compliments.
patients have trouble thinking in terms of forward
movement, a question like, “What do you need to do Task
to maintain the progress at 3?” frees up both patients Assessing patients’ change readiness in terms of the
and physicians to recognize that sometimes, treading cycle of change by Prochaska et al34 influences the
water is an accomplishment in and of itself. negotiated task. Webster summarizes it quite nicely:
Time-out Clients who are very unsure about what they want from
Because SFT is a counseling model used by a variety therapy are usually not given assignments. Those who have
of health care professionals, using time-out is prac- a defined complaint are given the task to observe when
tical for some and not for others. Time-out allows exceptions occur. Clients who are willing to change are
both clients and counselors to reflect on conversa- given “doing” tasks, which amplify existing exceptions and
tions they have just concluded. When a session has construct different kinds of interactions in their real life.35
been observed by colleagues behind a one-way mir-
ror, counselors use the time-out for consultation. At The homework task is discussed at the end of the
the onset of each session, counselors inform clients session, after the time-out. As physicians begin to
that a time-out will occur toward the end of their time learn to use this model, we suggest the following
together that day. This time-out prepares clients to as possible generic assignments to negotiate with
receive the accolades and task assignment that follow. patients: think about the times when an exception
Family physicians should limit time-outs to a min- occurs and note differences; obser ve for positive
ute or two, during which time physicians leave the changes; do more of the exceptions and pay attention
examining room to mentally list the accolades to to the consequences; pretend to do a small piece of
deliver moments later. Although time-outs are not the miracle picture; pretend you know what to do to
always feasible, the rationale for using them warrants start solving the problem and try it out; and finally,
reinforcement: the accolades we offer patients are think about what you are doing to prevent the situa-
part of solution talk, and taking a minute or two to tion from worsening.36
identify praise statements is important.
Benefits and caveats
Accolades Shifting from one’s favourite counseling approach to
Using accolades is a simple strategy that packs a pow- one that is new and unfamiliar is not without peril. We
erful punch. Integral to solution-building conversa- have experienced first-hand the dissonance from such
tions, its effect is multiple: it validates any progress an endeavour. The benefits of using this approach,
that patients make; it encourages patients by remind- however, far outweigh the discomfort of a counseling
ing them of personal power over their well-being; it situation when we are barely one step ahead of patients
emphasizes strengths and abilities; it sets up the expec- in our own knowledge and experience.
tation that past success is an excellent indicator of Solution-focused therapy is easily integrated into
future possibilities; it fosters confidence; and it facili- patient-centred clinical care. Its language is both hope-
tates relationship building and maintains rapport.29 ful and optimistic. Appreciating that change occurs
Accolades take many forms, including compliments in small increments means that goal behaviour is
and cheerleading. Simple statements are intended to readily accessible and attainable, thus creating a posi-
reflect back to patients positive observations about tive climate for both patients and physicians. Solution-
something they have said or done. When accolades focused therapy puts ownership of their health back
VOL 47: NOVEMBER • NOVEMBRE 2001 Canadian Family Physician • Le Médecin de famille canadien 2293
cme
Solution-focused therapy
2294 Canadian Family Physician • Le Médecin de famille canadien VOL 47: NOVEMBER • NOVEMBRE 2001
cme
Solution-focused therapy
4. Blattel RA. Adverse effects of psychotherapy in family practice [case report]. Can 23. Hillyer D. Solution-oriented questions: an analysis of a key intervention in solu-
Fam Physician 1992;38:663-4,734. tion-focused therapy. J Am Psychiatr Nurs Assoc 1996;2(1):3-10.
5. Christie-Seely J. Counseling tips, techniques, and caveats. Can Fam Physician 24. Walter J, Peller J. Rethinking our assumptions: assuming anew in a postmodern
1995;41:817-25.
world. In: Miller S, Hubble M, Duncan B, editors. Handbook of solution-focused brief
6. Peterkin AD, Dworkind M. Comparing psychotherapies for primary care. Can Fam
Physician 1991;37:719-25. therapy. San Francisco, Calif: Jossey-Bass Publishers; 1996. p. 9–26.
7. Rosser WW, Borins M, Audet́ D. Anxiety disorders in family practice. Diagnosis 25. Furman B, Ahola T. Solution talk: the solution-oriented way of talking about
and management. Can Fam Physician 1994;40:81-8. problems. In: Hoyt M, editor. Constructive therapies. New York, NY: The Guilford
8. Rockman P, Moran B. An introduction to brief therapy for family physicians. Toronto, Press; 1994. p. 41-66.
Ont: Rockman and Moran; 1997. 26. Miller SD. Some questions (not answers) for the brief treatment of people with
9. Links PS, Balchand K, Dawe I, Watson WJ. Preventing recurrent suicidal drug and alcohol problems. In: Hoyt M, editor. Constructive therapies. New York,
behaviour. Can Fam Physician 1999;45:2656-60.
NY: The Guilford Press; 1994. p. 92-110.
10. Barker P. Solution-focused therapies. Nurs Times 1998;94:53-6.
11. Chandler M, Mason W. Solution-focused therapy: an alternative approach to 27. DeJong P, Miller S. How to interview for client strengths. Soc Work
additions nursing. Perspect Psychiatr Care 1995;31(1):8-13. 1995;40(6):729-36.
12. Giorlando M, Schilling R. On becoming a solution-focused physician: the MED- 28. DeJong P, Kim Berg I. Interviewing for solutions. Pacific Grove, Calif: Brooks/Cole
STAT acronym. Fam Systems Health 1997;4:361-72. Publishing Company; 1998.
13. Poon VHK. Short counseling techniques for busy family doctors. Can Fam 29. Walter J, Peller J. Becoming solution-focused in brief therapy. New York, NY:
Physician 1997;43:705-13.
Brunner/Mazel, Inc; 1992.
14. McNeilly R. Solution oriented counseling: a 20-minute format for medical practice.
Aust Fam Physician 1994;23:228-30. 30. Hopwood L, Taylor M. Solution-focused brief therapy for chronic problems. In:
15. Park E. An application of brief therapy to family medicine. Contemp Fam Ther Vandecreek L, Knapp S, Jackson T, editors. Innovations in clinical practice: a source
1997;19:81-8. book. Vol 12. Sarasota, Fla: Professional Resource Press, 1993. p. 85-97.
16. Franklin C, Corcoran J, Nowicki J, Streeter C. Using client self-anchored scales to 31. Butler W, Powers K. Solution-focused grief therapy. In: Miller S, Hubble M,
measure outcomes in solution–focused therapy. J Systemic Ther 1997;16:246-65. Duncan B, editors. Handbook of solution-focused brief therapy. San Francisco, Calif:
17. Macdonald A. Brief therapy in adult psychiatry—further outcomes. Assoc Fam Jossey-Bass Publishers; 1996. p. 228-47.
Ther Systemic Pract 1997;19:213-22.
32. Duvall J, Rockman P. Living a wonderful life: a conversation with Yvonne Dolan.
18. Jordan K, Quinn WH. Session two outcome of the formula first session task in
problem- and solution-focused approaches. Am J Fam Ther 1994;2(1):3-16. J Systemic Ther 1996;15:82-93.
19. Zimmerman T, Layne A, Wetzel B. Solution-focused couple therapy groups: an 33. Ahlers C. Solution-oriented therapy for professionals working with physically
empirical study. Assoc Fam Ther Systemic Pract 1997;19:124-44. impaired clients. J Strategic Systemic Ther 1992;11(3):53-68.
20. Steenbarger B. Toward science-practice integration in brief counseling and ther- 34.Prochaska JO, DiClemente CC, Norcross JC. In search of how people change:
apy. Counseling Psychol 1992;20(3):403-50. applications to addictive behaviors. Am Psychol 1992;47(9):1102-14.
21. De Shazer S, Kim Berg I. ‘What works?’ Remarks on research aspects of solution-
35. Webster D. Solution-focused approaches in psychiatric/mental health nursing.
focused brief therapy. Assoc Fam Ther Systemic Pract 1997;9:121-4.
Perspect Psychiatr Care 1990;26(4):17-21.
22. McKeel AJ. A clinician’s guide to research on solution-focused brief therapy. In:
Miller S, Hubble M, Duncan B, editors. Handbook of solution-focused therapy. San 36. Cade B, O’Hanlon WH. A brief guide to brief therapy. New York, NY: W.W. Norton
Francisco, Calif: Jossey-Bass Publishers; 1996. p. 251-71. & Co; 1993.
VOL 47: NOVEMBER • NOVEMBRE 2001 Canadian Family Physician • Le Médecin de famille canadien 2295