A Thesis (Proposal) Presented To The Faculty of The College of Nursing Adamson University
A Thesis (Proposal) Presented To The Faculty of The College of Nursing Adamson University
A Thesis (Proposal) Presented To The Faculty of The College of Nursing Adamson University
In Partial Fulfilment
of the Requirement for the Degree
BACHELOR OF SCIENCE IN NURSING
Researchers:
(NAMES)
(NAMES)
(NAMES)
(NAMES)
Research Adviser
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
Critical care nursing is a speciality that is responsible for providing high quality care
Care Unit (ICU) nurse includes continuous monitoring of patients, coordinating care by the
health care team and discharge planning (Despins, Scott-Cawiezell & Rouder, 2010). With
the stressful environment and the physical structure of the ICU, nurses face challenges such
as high level of stress, high rate of errors and complications and high complexity care needed
by the patient. Aside from that, they should acquire knowledge, skills and experience to be
able to determine and arrange priorities of patient care needs and to maintain patient’s care,
hygiene and nutrition (Norris, Currie & Lecko, 2012). These aforementioned challenges
could compromise patient’s safety. This phenomenon has received an increasing attention
worldwide as managers and healthcare organizations spend great deal of efforts to enhance
quality and patient care safety by having non-punitive culture, supportive climate and
decisional involvement. Emphasis is placed on the system of care delivery that prevents
errors, learns from the errors that do occur, and is built on a culture of safety that involves
In the past, we have often viewed nurses’ responsibility in patient safety through the
narrow aspects of patient care such as avoiding medication errors and preventing patient falls.
In the Philippines, statistics show that about 18 percent of all reported hospital care-related
injuries is due to medication administration errors made by nurses and it can reach as high as
1.9 per patient per day (Dumo, 2012). While these dimensions of safety remain important
within the nursing purview, the breadth and depth of patient safety and quality improvement
are far greater. Among these unexplored factors is decisional involvement. Martin (2010)
noted that the quality of patient care is more affected by the degree to which they have an
active and central role in organizational decision making and by the degree to which the
hospital nurses are active and are empowered by the participants in making decisions about
their patient’s plan of care (Miller, Goddard & Laschinger, 2010). This integrative function is
said to promote professional nursing practice and uphold a powerful nursing executive thus
leading to superior patient care. In spite of this, recent studies revealed that nurses’ decisional
involvement is still restricted to the area of the nurse practice environment besides; nurses’
(Shariff, 2015). Also, the level of nurses’ desire to and the scope of their participation in
decision making were not revealed yet (Liu, 2015; Warshawsky & Havens, 2010).
This could be the most critical contribution of nursing to patient safety especially
when nursing is continuously being redefined which would deliberately require a greater
autonomy and participation from nurses. But with its limited researches against the topic, the
involvement and safety attitudes of intensive care unit nurses in selected hospitals in Manila.
The said combination of variables is deemed to produce more detailed information regarding
the said topic of concern, thereby contributing to the structure of long- term strategy to
The study aims to describe the relationship between the decisional involvement and
REAEARCH OBJECTIVES
Decisional involvement and patient safety issues pose a great burden worldwide.
However, there is still inadequate data on the burden of these in the Philippines to specifically
address institutional and national concerns through directed programs, policies, and
interventions. This current study aims to describe the decisional involvement and safety
The researchers used the Donabedian health care quality model as their guide in the
study. According to Moore, et al. (2015), improvement in structure of a health care should
lead to an improvement in clinical process, hence, a better patient outcome. They classified
three categories that describe information from which inferences can be drawn about the
quality of care namely: Structure, Process and Outcome. Structure of a health care
organization consists of the platform in which care occurs. This includes the attributes of
material resources such as equipment, facilities and personnel. Process indicates what the
health care worker is giving and what the patient is receiving. It includes the patient’s
activities in seeking care and carrying it out as well as the practitioner’s activities in making a
diagnosis and recommending or implementing treatment. Outcome is the effects and changes
which we can see on the patient health status after receiving care. Improvement in the
patient’s knowledge and salutary changes in the patient’s behavior are included under a
broader definition of health status, and is so the degree of the patient’s satisfaction with care
(Carayon, 2010).
Also, the researchers utilized Kanter’s structure power theory. It consists of six
dimensions: the structure of opportunity, the structure of support, the structure of resources,
the structure of information, formal power and informal power. According to Poudel, et al.
(2014), employees who have access to opportunity, information, support and resources are
empowered and have control over the conditions resulting in increased worker autonomy and
In the context of the study, the variables are decisional involvement and safety
attitudes which are represented by two boxes. It is shown that a solid arrow correlates the
The study will focus on the decisional involvement of Intensive Care Unit nurses
using the Decisional Involvement Scale by Havens & Vasey (2003) and safety attitudes using
the Safety Attitude Questionnaire (2006) by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality
(AHRQ). The study will be conducted in selected tertiary hospitals in Manila using simple
random sampling technique. The nurses who will be chosen are those who are currently
employed as an Intensive Care Unit nurse. The study will delimit the nurses who has not
signed the informed consent and whose questionnaires are not properly filled and completed.
SIGNIFICANCE OF THE STUDY
Patients. The respondents through this study will be able to benefit from the better
safety attitude from their nurses. Also, with a great decisional involvement from the health
For the staff nurses. This study may help to guide proactive strategies to decrease
errors and incidents in the patient care and the staff‟s environment. Empowerment from their
part may also be achieved. This may lead to encouragement of employees to put more effort
into completing their assigned work tasks and engage to a greater extent in discretionary
Nursing Management. Through this study, government and private sectors will
acquire information about the accommodation they can provide for their employees, also this
will give them information and idea on the specific or modified needs of their employees.
Moreover, the organization will gain idea about their employees’ insights about decisional
Nursing Management. They will gain ideas on how to improve their healthcare plans
and benefits to cater the needs of their ill employees. Results may be used as a basis for
healthcare plans design for improved medication adherence and status which may help on
Future researchers. Practitioners in the field and in other fields of research would be
able to know the additional knowledge that the study could add. They can also use our study
In this part, the terms used in the study are discussed for better understanding and clarity
the activities that manage nursing practice policy and the practice environment.
Profile. It refers to the nurse’s age, gender and length of service in the Intensive Care
Unit.
Safety Attitudes. This refers to the six factors namely a) safety climate, b)teamwork
Decisional Involvement
leadership (Poudel, et al, 2014). Partnerships where nurses and management meet each other
half way are essential for decisional involvement to be successfully actualized. Warshawsky
& Havens (2010) recognize that a strong indicator of nursing excellence and positive
outcome is staff driven decision making. It is indicated that involvement in decision making
has been positively linked to improved job satisfaction, positive clinical patient outcomes,
(Scherb, et al., 2010; Shariff, 2014). The inability to be involved in decision making and thus
and initiatives as one of the elements necessary to achieve improved working conditions. In
2003, the Institute of Medicine (IOM) published a report discussing the link between practice
environments and patient safety where it revealed that unsafe work and workplace design
the work environment of nurses including the involvement of “direct care nurses in
operational decision making and the design of work processes and work flow” and the
hierarchical decision making and in the design of work processes and work flow” (IOM
2003).
Literatures suggest that nurses must be empowered in order to achieve patient safety
and quality of care required in the current health environment and this can be achieved
through nurse decisional involvement. In summary, the effects of decisional involvement are
viewed overall as positive for the patient, nurses and the professional practice and work
environments.
The related studies regarding decisional involvement are very limited. One of these is
Laschinger, et al.’s (2009) quantitative study that identified that the nurses perceived that
they had low levels of actual decisional involvement and that there was a statistically
significant difference between the actual and preferred level of decisional involvement of the
nurses. Nurses were shown to prefer to have more decisional involvement than they actually
had. Another study by Scherb et al. (2010), using a descriptive correlational design, identified
that the level of actual decisional involvement for nurses was low and their level of preferred
decisional involvement remained low, not reaching the level of the mid-range score of shared
decision making. Managers in this study agreed that they preferred not having shared levels
Another quantitative descriptive study conducted in Iran identified that the nurses
perceived themselves to have only somewhat actual decisional involvement but to have high
levels of preferred involvement (Al-Dweik, et al., 2015). Meanwhile, Wong, et al. (2010)
showed that senior nurse leaders in Canada are able to influence decisions throughout the
organization. In review, the empirical studies indicate that nurses generally perceive that they
have low actual decisional involvement and would prefer to have more decisional
involvement.
In summary, it has been identified that nurses who are empowered to have the
freedom to initiate and participate in the decision making processes, resulting in change
which ultimately impacts positively on themselves, their patients and the work environment,
Safety Attitudes
Intensive care nursing is described as a specialized nursing care for acute and
critically ill patients with manifest or potential failures of vital functions (Bondevik, et al,
2014). Intensive care and the speciality of intensive care nursing are considered as the result
of advances in medicine, medical technology and nursing over the last century. Experience
showed that the mortality reduced by gathering patients in different specialized units such as
with regard to respiratory and cardiovascular support throughout the 24-hour-period, where a
sufficient number of bedside nurses were observing, recognizing and compensating for a
failure of the patients’ vital functions (Mota, 2015). Intensive care nurses need the highest
level of professional knowledge and skills to ensure the quality and safety of patient care and
that “there should be congruence between the needs of the patient, and the skills, knowledge
and attributes of the nurse caring for the patient” (Martin, 2010).
With regard to patient safety in the ICU, research shows that incidents involving
critically ill patients regularly take place (Douma, 2015). Errors related to medication and
procedures in connection with lines, catheters, drains, artificial airways and medical
equipment are common (Flotta, et al, 2012; Parmelli, et al, 2011) White (2012) found that
most serious errors occurred during the ordering or execution of treatment, and that the main
causes were slips and lapses rather than rule- or knowledge-based mistakes. In addition to
breakdowns in team processes, stress and workload are associated with a greater risk of
In this thesis, the use of “patient safety culture” is based on The European Network for
Patient Safety, which defines the culture of safety as: “an integrated pattern of individual and
organizational behavior, based upon shared beliefs and values that continuously seeks to
minimize patient harm which may result from the process of care delivery” (EUNetPaS,
2010, p. 4). This definition differs from more neutral definitions, as it reflects a culture of
safety in which actions are taken to reduce risk or harm to the patients (EUNetPaS, 2010).
Sammer et al. (2010) identified the properties of a patient safety culture as: leadership,
actions, and lastly, patient-centred care. According to Ginsburg, et al. (2014), teamwork,
communication and how to handle incidents are particularly important for patient safety in
the ICU.
Although there are limited published studies about safety culture in Philippine
hospitals and in terms of the impact of healthcare-related harm in the country, several efforts
to promote patient safety have been initiated since 2008. One such initiative is the National
Policy on Patient Safety (Department of Health, 2011) that mandates Continuous Quality
Improvement (CQI) patient safety programs in all healthcare facilities. These programs are
organizations dedicate this event to safe patient care activities. Most initiatives are done at
institutional levels during various local fora. However, these events were not documented
Healthcare provider attitudes about organizational factors such as safety climate and
morale, work environment factors such as staffing levels and managerial support, team
factors such as teamwork and supervision, and staff factors such as overconfidence and being
overly self-assured are components of an organization's safety culture (Sexton et al., 2006).
One most commonly used instruments by researchers is the Safety Attitudes Questionnaire
(SAQ), used by some authors to measure patient safety culture (Devriendt et al., 2012) and
(Sammer et al., 2010). Teamwork climate may be described as perceptions about the quality
of collaboration. Job satisfaction reflects the positive feelings towards work. Perceptions of
management involve issues such as the approval of managerial action. Safety climate reflects
conditions offers perceptions about the qualitative and supportive dimensions of the work
environment, and stress recognition gives confirmation of how the daily activity of workers is
among professions, both within ICUs in different hospitals (Hor, et al, 2013) and across ICUs
in a single institution (Khater, et al., 2015). In some studies, a more negative perception of
patient safety culture was identified among intensive care nurses compared to physicians
(Sexton et al., 2006), while another study found no differences between the professions (Reid
& Bromiley, 2012). The perception of a positive patient safety culture has been reported to be
associated with fewer patient safety incidents Nonetheless, incident reporting has been
than half of all nurses attained positive stress recognition scores (positive scores indicate a
greater acknowledgement of the effects of stress). Nearly half of nurses (45%) in the study
had significantly higher stress recognition scores (20%) and only 45% nurses were satisfied
with their jobs. Also, nurses had low perceptions of their working conditions but favourable
In the contrary, some studies have demonstrated that ICU nurses have positive
perceptions of teamwork within the unit (Baid & Hargreaves, 2015; Baartman & de Bruijn,
2011). However, while the ICU nurses generally have a positive perception of teamwork, a
paradox is that failures are found in ongoing team performance, with coordination, leadership
and communication all being contributory factors to patient safety incidents in the ICU (El-
On the other hand, Li (2013) found that safety attitudes of nurses were positive,
although some safety attitude areas were self-evaluated as lower such as Job satisfaction,
Attitudes have been found to be more positive after training, and similar to the improvements
of knowledge reported by Ahmed et al., (2013), the same study showed that after a day
training course on patient safety, nurses’ safety attitudes had significantly improved post
A study by Paguio (2016) was conducted to identify the safety attitudes among
Filipino nurses. Nurses from the National University Hospital displayed both positive Safety
Culture and Safety Attitudes based on AHRQ-HSOPS and SAQ. Dimensions that garnered
the highest positive perceptions in Safety Culture were Organizational Learning and
Teamwork while the lowest were Hospital Handoffs and Non-Punitive Response to Error. On
the other hand, dimensions on Safety Awareness that received the highest positive
perceptions were Teamwork and Safety Climate while the lowest was Stress Recognition.
Perceptions of nurses also varied significantly across ranks in position titles and work
settings. This implicates that there are identifiable dimensions that can be improved in both
Safety Culture and Safety Attitude that can have a positive impact on nurses and potentially
programs.
essential for the implementation of appropriate strategies to manage nursing care. In this
sense, registered nurses’ beliefs and values as part of the organizational culture are important
Synthesis
Intensive care with its complexity represents potential patient safety challenges for
critically ill patients. Human errors are stated as the most common cause of patient safety
Most of the studies are international studies and very limited are done in the
Philippines. This leads us to conclude that a lack of research studies was done concerning the
subject in the country. One also sees that the previous studies applied to various medical
departments and are mainly concerned with patient safety culture alone or safety attitudes.
This differs from this study because the researchers are going to correlate it with decisional
involvement and the target group is the Intensive Care Unit nurses.
Based on the literature review, it can be concluded that it is a big challenge for health
care professionals to ensure patient safety in complex health care systems. Therefore, this
research is an endeavour to identify the relationship between safety attitude and decisional
HYPOTHESES
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
RESEARCH DESIGN
descriptive and correlational designs will discuss extensively the nurses’ decisional
involvement and safety attitude. The descriptive approach will be used to determine the
profile of the nurses, their decisional involvement and safety attitudes. Descriptive design
simply will be to describe the variables of the study. Lastly, correlational design will be used
to correlate the two factors: decisional involvement and safety attitudes. This type of design
will ascertain whether an increase or decrease in one variable corresponds in the increase or
decrease of the other variable, however, this did not imply the causation of the correlates to
The respondents of the study are the employed Intensive Care Unit nurses of the
tertiary hospitals in Manila. The respondents will be chosen regardless of their position at the
this study. The researchers will present their letter of permission to the chief nurses of the
selected hospitals and will be asked if the charge nurse can distribute it among the nurses.
The researchers will acquire the total number of nurses who meets the criteria from the chief
The researchers will conduct the study at the selected tertiary hospitals in Manila. A
list of the tertiary hospitals will be acquired from the Department of Health and from the list,
RESEARCH INSTRUMENTS
There were three (3) kinds of instruments used in this research. It includes:
The researchers included the identification of age, gender and length of service in the
questionnaire.
The researchers also used Decisional Involvement Scale by Havens & Vasey (2003).
This scale, consisting of 21 items, measures actual and/or preferred decisional involvement
for staff nurses and managers on a nursing unit. Sample items include determining the unit
schedule, selecting unit leadership, and selecting staff for hire. The DIS uses a five-point
scale to indicate the degree to which decisions are the responsibility of staff nurses and
analyses (contact corresponding author for information) showed that the DIS measures nurse
involvement in decisions and activities related to six constructs: unit staffing, quality of
support staff practice, and collaboration/liaison activities. Reliability of the DIS has been
assessed through determination of Cronbach’s alpha following numerous administrations to
staff RNs and nurse managers. Consistently, the instrument has demonstrated total scale
alphas ranging from .91 to .95, which indicates a highly reliable measure.
For each of the 21 items, respondents indicate which nursing group (staff nurses or
administration/management) that they perceive has the primary responsibility for the decision
or activity (actual decisional involvement) or that they would prefer have the responsibility
for the decision or activity (preferred decisional involvement) on the unit on which they
work. Response choices are as follows: (1) administration/ management only, (2) primarily
administration/ management with some staff nurse input, (3) equally shared by
administration/management and staff nurses, (4) primarily staff nurses with some
administration/ management input and (5) staff nurses only. Items can be considered
individually, by the six subscales, or by total DIS scale. A high score suggests a high degree
of staff RN involvement, a low score suggests a low degree of staff RN involvement, and a
The researchers used a survey tool named “Safety Attitudes Questionnaire” (SAQ), a
systematically eliciting input from the respondents. It is a refinement of the Intensive care
Unit Management Attitudes Questionnaire, which was derived from a questionnaire widely
used in commercial aviation, the Flight Management Attitude Questionnaire (FMAQ). It was
developed by Bryan Sexton, Eric Thomas, and Bob Helmreich with funding from the Robert
Wood Johnson Foundation and Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. The “Safety
information (length of service). Each of the 36 items is answered using a Five-point Likert or
Agree Slightly, E as Agree Strongly). Some items are negatively worded. It has a scale
reliability of 0.9 in the Raykov’s coefficient while it scored .89 for the Cronbach alpha. A six
factor model of provider attitudes fit to the data at both the clinical area and respondent
nested within clinical area levels. The factors were: Teamwork Climate, Safety Climate,
The SAQ can be used to meet the increasing demand for safety climate (often called safety
culture) assessment at the clinical area level. It is also used in other studies in order to have a
baseline data about the existing culture of the health care providers. Responses to each item
in a scale is summed and divided by the number of items in that scale to create that range
from 0 to 100. The scores obtained will represent individual perceptions with higher scores
Essential data needed for the study will be gathered through the setting of guiding
principles which will allow the researchers to acquire them. The following steps will be
The initial step that the researchers will do is to get permissions from the chosen
hospital from which the targeted participants will come from. This will be done through the
dissemination of communication letters. Letters of consent that will include the purpose of
conducting the study, the steps in data gathering, and the criteria of the respondents will be
accomplished by the researchers. The thesis adviser, level coordinator, and the dean will also
The researchers asked the permission of the respective authors and/or developers of
the questionnaires Decisional Involvement Scale and Safety Attitude Questionnair. Their
scoring system for proper presentation of results was also inquired. As soon as permission
will be granted from the targeted institutions, the researchers will begin their actual data
gathering. The respondent should have read and signed the informed consent attached to the
questionnaire. Once they have completed the questionnaires, they will be collected and
encoded for tabulation and analysis of data. After the researchers arranged, tabulated and
tallied the data, analysis and interpretation will be done. Appropriate statistics will be used
along with the software for proper calculations to either accept or reject the null hypothesis
presented.
STATISTICAL DATA
Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS) will be used for proper calculations
The descriptive statistics will be used for the numerical descriptions of the variables
of the study. It consists of a table containing the categories and their frequency of occurrence.
The percentage will be used to identify the weight of frequency in reference to the total
number of responses. In the study, it will be applied to describe the demographic profile of
the nurses (age, gender and length of service), their decisional involvement and safety
attitudes.
INFERENTIAL STATISTICS
Pearson R Correlation
Pearson R will be used to measure the correlation between two interval/ratio variables
(decisional involvement and safety attitudes.). A p-value of less than 0.05 level of
significance rejects the null hypothesis, then the results would be significant because it is
more stringent than 0.05 while, a p-value of more than 0.05 accepts the null hypothesis, it
ETHICAL CONSIDERATIONS
which will verify their permission and assure them that their identity would be held in utmost
confidentiality.