Slavica Nikolovska Biljana Asprovska Sanja Dragićević Oliver Iliev
Slavica Nikolovska Biljana Asprovska Sanja Dragićević Oliver Iliev
Slavica Nikolovska Biljana Asprovska Sanja Dragićević Oliver Iliev
This paper presents the current status in the development of the Integrated In
formation System which is set up for the needs of the Archives of Macedonia. Your-
don 's Object Oriented Approach - OOA and the client-server methodology are used
in developing the model. The preliminary exploitation results comply in full with the
demands set up in the design project. The implementation of the system enabled a
modernization in archive work, application of current mass storage media and effi
cient multi-criteria methods for data searches. The computerized link of the central
unit with the local departments and their connection with the creators and holders of
archive materials will enable an integration of an archives data base, while the inte
gral approach to the protection of archive materials will be implemented through
the structural integration of this system with the security system and the automatic
climate control system for the repositories.
67
S. Nikolovska, B. Asprovska, S. Dragićević, 0 . Iliev, The integrated information system of the
Archives of Macedonia, Arh. vjesn., god. 41 (1998), str. 67-86
1. INTRODUCTION
2. PRELIMINARY RESEARCH
68
S, Nikolovska, B. Asprovska, S. Dragićević, O. Iliev, The integrated information system of the
Archives of Macedonia, Arh. vjesn., god. 41 (1998), str. 67-86
tic approach draws its experience form smaller organizations and through a scientif
ically supported generalization, it sets up the basics of modern archive work. This
direction was later supported by numerous research work in this field (Roper - 72,
Evans - 83, Posner - 76). They raise the level of archive work from mere preservati
on of documents and their use, mainly for historical research, towards a public servi
ce for current administration and citizens. In this way an integral approach was made
possible towards the research of historical and current archive materials.
The development of computers at the end of the sixties, and of the media for
mass data storage and processing, gives the stimulus for the development of new
conceptual models for efficient archive administration (Shellenberg - 75, Benedon
- 79). Still, the implementation of computer systems becomes attractive in this field
at the beginning of the nineties, as a result of: the sudden fall in prices of mass data
storage media, of the new user-based operational systems, development of applicati
on programmes for multi-media data processing (processing of text, picture, sound,
etc.).
As one of the currently most relevant problems in the implementation of com
puter systems for archive work is the problem of data search. The problem arises
from the impossibility to set up archive materials in an efficient structural frame
work (categorization) which would meet the needs of various kinds of historical re
search (Cook - 85), (Dojcinovski et al. - 96), the lack of precision in the presented
data, overlapping, non-existence of a uniform terminology and search procedures.
This problem is known as interdisciplinary searches (Weisberger - 93). The imple
mentation of the concept of fuzzy sets (Chang - 92) and the cognitive sciences (Ku-
hlthau - 93) give a solid base for the development of efficient algorithms for inter
disciplinary searches. At present, there are three different methods for solving this
problem:
69
S. Nikolovska, B . Asprovska, S. Dragićević, O. Iliev, The integrated information system of the
Archives of Macedonia, Arh. vjesn., god. 41 (1998), str. 67-86
It must be stressed that the application of these methods is connected with pre
vious theoretical and applicative research in order to get the optimal solution for the
structural set up of archive materials.
70
S. Nikolovska, B. Asprovska, S. Dragićević, 0 . Iliev, The integrated information system o f the
Archives of Macedonia, Arh. vjesn., god. 41 (1998), str. 67-86
71
S. Nikolovska, B . Asprovska, S. Dragićević, 0 . Iliev, The integrated information system of the
Archives of Macedonia, Arh. vjesn., god. 41 (1998), str. 67-86
At present, the first three have been implemented, and the preparation of the
main design/implementation project for the realization of the third subsystem is now
in progress. The computer link between the creators and holders of archive materials
and the Archives of Macedonia should enable an automatic taking over of plans and
lists of archive marks, inventory and description of archive materials with lasting
value, and inventory of documentary materials that are proposed for rejection. A di
rect intervention will be made possible for on-site work by the archive services at the
holders and providing appropriate solutions, approvals, etc., conform to the legal re
gulations. In this way, the efficiency will be increased in the operation of the service
for working with users, as well as in the degree of primary processing of archive ma
terials. This on the other hand will influence a larger efficiency in the compiling and
processing subsystem.
In the process of modeling the information system three subsystem units have
been set apart: protection of archive materials at the site of the holders, compiling
and processing archive materials and protection of archive materials at the Archives
(repository) with expressed subsystem interactions. A l l data and material flows in
the system have been resolved by using the object methodology in the process of
system modeling. The application of multi-attribute indexing in the relational tables
made automatic generation and updating possible for a whole set of reviews, files
and reports, which facilitates the manual part of work to a large extent.
Conform to Yourdon's approach for object oriented analysis (OOA) and object
oriented modeling (OOM), an object model of the Archives of Macedonia was cre-
72
S. Nikolovska, B. Asprovska, S. Dragićević, O. Iliev, The integrated information system of the
Archives of Macedonia, Arh. vjesn., god. 41 (1998), str. 67-86
ated (see Figure 2). Four classes of objects have been defined: users, archive materi
al, equipment and premises.
10, 11, 12
- Class of users - System users are all persons who use the archive materials.
Notwithstanding good wishes, the system must be organized to protect against ille
gal user activities. Illegal user activities here means all activities in the system which
73
S. Nikolovska, B. Asprovska, S. Dragićević, O. Iliev, The integrated information system of the
Archives of Macedonia, Arh. vjesn., god. 41 (1998), str. 67-86
fall outside the approved level of physical access to the premises or in the informati
on access to the databases.
- Class of archive materials - This class includes all original documents that
are kept permanently in the repositories, photocopies, microfilms, microfiches, doc
uments that are appropriately memorized in the computer system, and all other
forms of preserving data of interest to archive work. The proper categorization of the
level of access to the archive materials is of essential importance for efficient opera
tion of the system, and its abuse may have unforeseen consequences.
The user gets information about the existence of a document if and only if his
access category is higher than the one of the document.
- Class of equipment - This class includes all valuable equipment in the premi
ses of the Archives. The accent is upon computer equipment, printers, scanners, etc.
Since this concerns equipment that works within a network, the problem of protecti
on is reduced to holding equipment within specific premises. Just like with the archi
ve materials, a tagging system will be used (C.J. Revell - 95), enabling that equip
ment can be used in one room while its unauthorized removal will automatically ac
tivate the alarm.
- Class ofpremises - This class includes all premises of the Archives of Mace
donia which are of interest for the system. The protection of these premises
supposes:
- protection against fire;
- protection against flooding;
- protection against burglary;
- movement detection.
74
S. Nikolovska, B . Asprovska, S. Dragićević, O. Iliev, The integrated information system of the
Archives of Macedonia, Arh. vjesn., god. 41 (1998), str. 67-86
- The operating system includes support to a large number of different clients, start
ing with its Windows N T Client, through Windows 3.x, Windows for Workgro
ups 3.11, Windows 95, U N I X OS/s, Apple Mackintosh, and all up to MS-DOS
clients.
- Windows N T comes with support for almost ail modern networks: AppleTalk,
Novell NetWare, SunNFS-PCNFS, D E C P A T H W O R K S , I B M L A N Server, M i
crosoft L A N Manager, Microsoft Windows for Workgroups, R A S (Remote
Access Service), through ISDN, X.25 and standard telephone lines, etc.
- In compliance with the above, Windows N T has support for the following proto
cols: NetBEUI, IPX/SPX, TCP/IP, AFP, D L C .
- Windows NT contains drivers for all kinds of Ethernet, for FDDI, and it also has a
whole range of drivers for all possible kinds of peripheral devices: printers, mo
dems, C D R O M , etc.
- Windows NT is produced also for platforms that are not based on Intel processors,
i.e. for platforms based on Alpha and MIPS processors, and it is also designed for
operation with multiprocessor platforms.
- Windows NT contains the following built-in protection: RAID 5, C2, disk mirror
ing, support to uninterrupted power supplies (UPS), and support for recording va
rious tape formats(streamer, D A T , etc.).
It is natural that the Microsoft SQL Server becomes the database for the Win
dows N T operating system. The SQL server is a relatively new database developed
by Microsoft in cooperation with Sybase. It is specially designed for working with
Windows N T and it uses all its characteristics, which gives it an advantage over ot
her databases which have their own versions of Windows NT. The development of
client applications in a graphics environment may be implemented with any Micro
soft development tool: Access, Visual Basic, Visual C++ or Visual FoxPro.
Visual FoxPro was used for developing applications.
75
S. Nikolovska, B. Asprovska, S. Dragićević, 0 . Hiev, The integrated information system o f the
Archives of Macedonia, Arh. vjesn., god. 41 (1998), str. 67-86
Decisions on working with holders - For every employee in the Sector for in
spection supervision and protection of archive material at the holder's site, two deci
sions are prepared: 1. Decision on appointing a holder, and 2. Decision on annual vi
sits to the holders. Based upon these decisions, the employee attains an absolute
access to the holders who are allocated to him with the decision (No. 1).
Submitted by-laws from holders - For every holder, normative by-laws of
the holder and submitted decisions on the establishing of committees at the holder
are entered, forming an integral part of the holder's file.
Visits - The visits are divided into 3 categories: regular, control and advisory.
Regardless of the category of the visit, the responsible officer makes a protocol abo
ut the visit in all cases. After entering the notification for the visit to the specific hol
der, the responsible officer prepares a protocol from the visit with the determined si
tuation and the deadlines that were given. These inspections enable a monitoring of
the given deadlines for correction of the determined defects.
Destruction - By entering received requests for destruction of documentary
materials with expired storage deadlines from the specific holder, the responsible
officer has an overview of all received requests for approval for the destruction of
documentary material, and after the documentary material is reviewed, an approval
is prepared for its destruction. The reviews make it possible to prepare a summary of
destroyed documentary material per holder for every year. Furthermore, the review
of the specific holder provides data about how much and when worthless documen
tary material was destroyed, according to the issued approvals.
Plans for archival marks and lists - The received plans and lists are entered
automatically for each holder in the general part. Changes and supplements to the
plans and lists (especially in the separate part) are entered depending upon the orga
nization. By issuing an approval for their implementation, reviews can be made of
received plans and lists for the specific year, and a review of received plans and lists
for a specific holder.
Descriptions and inventories of archive materials - The descriptions and in
ventories of archive materials for every holder must be entered by the direct opera
tors. This facilitates to a large extent the admittance of archive materials and compa
rison of descriptions and inventories per specific holder, year and admitted archive
materials. The reviews make it possible to get insight into the received inventories
for every year, while the review per holder enables insight into all received invento
ries.
Admittance of archive materials to the Archives - Committee admittance of
archive materials from a specific holder, after the final protocol is made, means au
tomatic transfer of all entered data into a specific fond at the repository or its docu
mentation as a new fond. Thus, this system is connected to the DEPO subsystem.
76
S. Nikolovska, B. Asprovska, S. Dragićević, O. Hiev, The integrated information system of the
Archives of Macedonia, Arh. vjesn., god. 41 (1998), str. 67-86
Inspection control - Two types of inspection control are defined: regular and
control inspection. The application is intended exclusively for inspectors, where
after the notification and the visit to the specific holder, a protocol is prepared by the
inspection control with the determined situation and the deadlines that were given,
with precisely defined date of execution. Inspection control visits and the written an
nouncements after the inspection report refer to the already entered data at the hol
der. These reviews enable monitoring of given deadlines.
The subsystem contains a log file for access control to the application, in order
to avoid abuse. Within the log file for each user, a unique set of applications is allo
cated to which he has access.
Based upon the specific decision for work with the holder, the officer receives
all previously entered data about the holder. From the moment he receives the deci
sion, the officer has absolute access priority for that holder. The holder is closed for
access for the other officers, except for the head of the Department and the deputy
director of the Sector.
After the operation of the holder terminates, in order to cancel him and to take
over the archive materials, and after the admittance committee finishes its review
and makes a decision on the admittance, the admittance protocol is activated, the
reby transferring all entered data to the repository. After the fond is admitted to the
repository, the officer can no longer make corrections to the entered data.
77
S. Nikolovska, B . Asprovska, S. Dragićević, O. Iliev, The integrated information system of the
Archives of Macedonia, Arh. vjesn., god. 41 (1998), str. 67-86
tion is prepared of the archive books, a summary inventory, i.e. technical processing
of microfilmed materials. Within the framework of the fond, numbers are generated
for the archive books and boxes. Thereby a short description is prepared of the con
tents of the fond and of the creator of the fond.
Fond processing - For processing the fond/collection, the decision also speci
fies the information means which needs to be prepared: an analytic inventory or e re
gest. The serial number of the archive unit from the archive box is generated auto
matically.
Compilation and processing reports - The application is intended for the he
ads of the Compilation and Processing Sector, for facilitating the monitoring of de
cisions for compiling, respectively processing, of the fond, of the deadlines for com
pleting work based on the norms and standards for working with a fond, and the di
rect performing of the appointed tasks.
Receipts - In compliance with present practice, two types of receipts are defi
ned: for taking over and returning archive materials. After receiving the decision,
the officer fills in a receipt for taking over archive materials, with an inventory of
work operations, quantity and border years. The receipt is transferred to the manager
for confirmation, and after this to the repository for execution.
Worthless documentary materials - The selected documentary material is
inventoried and destruction is suggested. Upon the proposal from the committee for
issuing approvals for destruction, the data is transferred to the repository to be taken
over and destroyed.
Protocol on admitting a compiled/processed fond - After the planned work
on the material is finished, it is admitted to the repository by a committee. As part of
this application there is a men with an inventory (with signatures) of damaged archi
ve materials which are proposed for treatment.
When the fond is admitted to the repository, the archive officer loses all his pri
vileges, and all entered data are taken over automatically. After the fond is admitted
to the repository, the officer can no longer make any corrections to the entered data
until the moment a new decision is made for higher stages of work or for supplemen
ting with newly arrived materials.
Fond and inter-fond searches in archive materials - Within the application
a set of key words (sentences) is defined, with logical A N D and OR search functi
ons. The possibility exists to search per specific fond and within the framework of
the complete database.
78
S. Nikolovska, B. Asprovska, S. Dragićević, O. Iliev, The integrated information system of the
Archives of Macedonia, Arh. vjesn., god. 41 (1998), str. 67-86
Printing is done as an individual summary inventory for each archive box, and
collectively for the whole fond, if the fonds ends with stage V , i.e. the printing of the
covers of the analytical inventories and regests separately (covers) for each descri
bed unit, and collectively for the whole box, if the fond is being processed. Also after
the compilation stage and the processing stage, when a short contents at the level of
the whole fond and a short history of the creator of the fond are prepared, collective
data are generated automatically (number of books, number of archive boxes, archi
ve units and pages).
Register of fonds: Besides the registration of fonds, transfer protocols are pre
pared on all grounds for admittance of the archive materials: regular admittance,
purchase, gift or research. Within this composition is also the admittance of archive
materials from compilation and processing. The fonds are classified according acti
vity (applied in the Guide for Archive Fonds and Collections). Then follows locati-
79
S. Nikolovska, B. Asprovska, S, Dragićević, O. Iliev, The integrated information system o f the
Archives of Macedonia, Arh. vjesn., god. 41 (1998), str. 67-86
on of the archive materials. A l l previously entered data about the fond are taken over
(border years of the creator of the fond, border years of the materials, and quantity
expressed in the form of archive books and boxes, respectively microfilms).
Deposit - This concerns the admittance, documentation and location of the de
posited archive materials. It covers the time of deposit and the depositor. The re
views are prepared in this sense.
80
S. Nikolovska, B. Asprovska, S. Dragićević, O. Iliev, The integrated information system o f the
Archives of Macedonia, Arh. vjesn., god. 41 (1998), str. 67-86
Laboratories - After the archive materials are admitted to the laboratories for
conservation and restoration and for microfilming, the applied methodology and
procedure is described, as well as the deadlines that are planned for revision of the
performed activities.
Requests for documentation (certificates) - Citizens that apply to the Archi
ves with a request to receive a certificate for various needs (regulation of prop
erty-legal relations, of years of work experience, etc.) are documented, as well as the
responses to the submitted requests. The reviews enable a search according to name
and family name of the person submitting the request, and the date when this was
submitted.
Visits to the repository-Registration of daily entry to and exit from the repos
itory by visitors from the Archives or by external persons, with a description of the
performed work, the approval for this and the time of entry and exit.
Bilateral cooperation - Signed agreements, protocols and programmes for bi
lateral cooperation are documented according to the time of signature and the durati
on of the signed agreement, as well as the obligations which arise from them.
Research in foreign institutions - Sending researchers to foreign institutions
is based on signed agreements, and it covers notification and approval for the rese
arch, announced topic and approved time of stay. After the research is completed, el
ements from the report are entered: stay at the institution, research fonds and orders
for copying archive materials. The reviews are aimed at getting insight in which co
untries, cities and institutions research was made, and in which fonds, as well as for
which fonds orders for copying were made.
Registration and announcements of visits by foreign users to the Archives
- Announced and approved user visits to the Archive and announced research topics
are covered based upon the agreements for bilateral cooperation. The reviews offer
insight into the announced visits according to the submitted applications, date of su
bmittal and name and family name of the user.
Using the materials - Covers the documentation on users and archive materi
als: application for use, source data about the user, requested and approved archive
materials for use, and copying and daily registration of users.
Publications file - This is divided into the basic kind of publications: editions,
monographs and journals that are published by the Archives of Macedonia. A publi
cation is documented from when it is planned, a contract for preparing it is signed,
advance payments, providing funding, translations, reviews, printing, promotion,
and all up to the documentation about responses in the daily and other press.
81
S. Nikolovska, B. Asprovska, S. Dragićević, O. Iliev, The integrated information system of the
Archives of Macedonia, Arh. vjesn., god. 41 (1998), str. 67-86
This paper presents the current results from the development of the integrated
information system for the Archives of Macedonia. The implementation and the
preliminary results are a promising base for further development of this system.
Future development of the system will be in two directions:
1. In the theoretical field:
- Research in the application of various search algorithms by using fuzzy logic and
neuron based networks. It is expected that this approach should enable a faster
and more flexible data search, as well as a possibility for case-sensitive searches;
- Research in the field of multimedia systems, enabling mass processing, storage
and searching of archive materials;
- Theoretical preconditions for developing an application for genealogical trees,
based upon the oldest censuses of the population and source registers (of newly
born, married and deceased).
2. In the application field:
- Upgrading the system with a microfilm computer port;
- Development of a computer system for scanning and searching through the espe
cially important archive fonds and collections;
- Completion of the application of office and archive, testing, distribution to users
and connection with the subsystem for external service.
- Development of an application for chronology of contemporary events.
- Preparation of a study for connection of the existing computer network with Inter
net and possibilities for searching and receiving documents through Internet.
- Preparation of a study on C D - R O M for the Archives of Macedonia.
82
S. Nikolovska, B. Asprovska, S. Dragićević, O. Iliev, The integrated information system of the
Archives of Macedonia, Arh. vjesn., god. 41 (1998), str. 67-86
REFERENCES:
83
S. Nikolovska, B. Asprovska, S. Dragićević, O. Iliev, The integrated information system of the
Archives of Macedonia, Arh. vjesn., god. 41 (1998), str. 67-86
(Hiev, 95)
Iliev, 0. (1995), "Izveštaj za poseta i izvršeni istražuvanja na Public Record Office" Ar
hiv na Makedonija, Skopje, Republika Makedonija, Septemvri
(Nikolovska, 92)
Nikolovska, S. (1992), "Sistemska analiza na elementite za izrabotka na programska
poddrška na AOP", Arhiv na Makedonija, Skopje, Republika Makedonija,
Oktomvri
(Nikolovska, 94)
Razvoj arhivske službe u Makedoniji, magistarski rad, Zagreb, April
(Nikolovska, Iliev i Asprovska, 94)
Nikolovska, S., Iliev, O., Asprovska, B. (1994) "Predlog studija za realizacija na integri
ran informaciski, upravuvački i zaštiten avtomatiziran sistem za arhivska građa i
objektite na Arhivot na Makedonija" Arhiv na Makedonija, Skopje, Republika
Makedonija, Noemvri
(Nikolovska, Iliev i Asprovska, 96)
Nikolovska, S., Iliev, O., Asprovska, B. (1996) Realizacija na integriraniot informaciski,
upravuvački i zaštiten avtomatiziran sistem za arhivska građa i objektite na Arhi
vot na Makedonija, Arhiv na Makedonija, Ohrid, Republika Makedonija, Juni
(Nikolovska, 96)
Nikolovska, S. (1996) Razvoj na integriraniot informacionen sistem na Arhivot na Ma
kedonija, Infosamit, InForma br. 23, Skopje, Republika Makedonija, Dekemvri
(Salton, 83)
Salton, G. (1983), "Introduction to modern Information retrieval" McGraw-Hill
(Salton, 70)
Salton, G. (1970), "Automatic Text Analysis" Proc. Of Information Retrieval Systems
and Management Information Systems
(Stulli, 77)
Stulli, B. (1977), Priručnik iz arhivistike, Zagreb 1977
(Weisgerber, 93)
Weisgerber, D. (1993), "Interdisciplinary Searching: Problems and Suggested Remedies
- A report from The ICSTI Group on Interdisciplinary Seraching" The Journal of
Documentation, Vol.49, No.3, pp. 231-253, September
(Vickery & Vickery, 93)
Vickery, B. and Vickery, A. (1993), "Online Search Interface Design", The Journal of
Documentation, Vol.49, No.2, pp. 103-165, June
(Wong & Yao, 90)
Wong, S.K.K and Yao, Y . Y . (1990), "A generalized binary Probabilistic Independence
Model", Journal of the American Society for Information Science, 4(15),
324-329
84
S. Nikolovska, B. Asprovska, S. Dragićević, O. lliev, The integrated information system of the
Archives of Macedónia, Arh. vjesn., god. 41 (1998), str. 67-86
Sažetak
85
S. Nikolovska, B. Asprovska, S. Dragićević, O. lliev, The integrated information system of the
Archives of Macedónia, Arh. vjesn., god. 41 (1998), str. 67-86
86