Chapter 1 - 2
Chapter 1 - 2
Chapter 1 - 2
Research
Qualitative Marketing
Research
Understanding How Behavioral
Complexities Drive Marketing
Strategies
Rajagopal
Qualitative Marketing Research: Understanding How Behavioral
Complexities Drive Marketing Strategies
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Keywords
action research; ethnography; evidence-based research; information man-
agement; mixed-method research; narrative analytics; qualitative research
design; qualitative research
Contents
Preface��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������xi
Acknowledgments��������������������������������������������������������������������������������� xix
• Consumer analytics
• Consumer centric business models
• Co-creation
Current business • Market competitiveness Qualitative
environment • Sustainable strategies research design
• Best practices
• Consumer behavior • Attributes
• Market competition • Theoretical perspectives
Platform for discussion • Design development
• Business performance
critical analysis and arguments • Data collection
• Ethnographic research, • Information exploration
• Employee engagement research, • Data collection methods
• Qualitative loop • Participatory research appraisal
• Research, case research, • Interview techniques
• Phenomenology, • Information analysis
• Anthropomorphic analysis • Coding
• Evidenced based research
• Software applications
• Data analysis and reporting
• Mixed methods
Interactive applications of qualitative research
Preface
issues. A firm may assume that the current products reflect customer pref-
erences, and such assumption is likely to hold only in mature markets
with no entry barriers. However, in markets, where customers have been
deprived of products because of trade barriers, consumers might display
a preference for something different. Such latent preferences cannot be
uncovered through observation. On the other hand, the causal marketing
research is sometimes combined with experimental methods of research
and causal models. This book serves as a managerial guide to work with
the new perspectives of qualitative marketing research.
Understanding the need for qualitative research, business houses today
realize that it is essential to support a set of key decisions that collectively
determine how companies can develop marketing decisions, perform in
the competitive marketplace, and mitigate consumer-led risks. This book
argues new dimensions associated with the implications of qualitative
research to measure the changing perspectives of consumer preferences,
knowledge, values, and organizational decision-making abilities, and
addresses several pertinent questions that include the following:
Introduction to Qualitative
Research
Overview
Qualitative research is an art of learning from people by analyzing their
perceptions, emotions, and neurophysical dynamics concerning social,
cultural and personal values, and lifestyle. This is an explorative research
tool used through interpersonal discussions and continuous observations
of subjects in a given field of study. Qualitative research method has
evolved epistemologically across positivism, empiricism, and interpre-
tive schools of thought, which has influenced symbolic interactionism,
phenomenology, and ethnographic research streams. Human interactiv-
ity, freedom of expressions, emotional manifestation, logic, and rational-
ity in information provide insights into the research problem, and help
to interlink ideas through semantic mapping for potential quantitative
research. This chapter discusses salient features of qualitative research as a
tool and emphasizes the attributes of a good researcher to conduct qual-
itative research. The core discussions in this chapter are the ecosystem of
qualitative research, research planning, and developing research design. In
addition, the chapter discusses the evolution of schools of thought in the
context of qualitative research.
Introduction
Market research in the growing competitive business environment is a
complex phenomenon. There is no single method, which can suffice the
dynamic strategy development for companies in the rapidly changing
markets. Market research organizations emphasize on data-based quan-
titative analysis to help companies in making probabilistic decision using
2 Qualitative Marketing Research
• Informal scenario
• Nonprobability-based sampling
• Nongeneralizable sampling
• Circular reasoning
• Formative, earlier phases
• Rich information and time-consuming
• Flexible study design
4 Qualitative Marketing Research
Attributes of a Researcher
• Experience
• Rationale
• Empathy
• Judgmental behavior
• Minimizing biases
• Peer influence
• Interception and mediation
• Developing thematic conversation pathway, streamlining,
interpreting emotions
• Exploring concealed sense in conversation
4
5
No repetitions
Factual and validated
Research Designs
Sampling Techniques
Data Collection
Research Design
Setting qualitative research scenario is a challenging task for researchers,
in which research questions, propositions, and constructs of the study
need to be developed upon reviewing the previous studies. The field
research operations of the study can be managed by defining samples for
the qualitative study, locating the data collection region, developing pro-
files of respondents, and scheduling meetings with the identified samples
to acquire information. Some researchers begin data collection process
by organizing focus groups to identify variables of the study for devel-
oping research instrument. Data collections process then begins by con-
ducting survey or interviews, using the research instrument. Information
acquired for the study then needs to be validated to ensure that there is no
redundancy and biasness in the data. However, developing scale and the
instrument, and data collection should be done in contextual reference
to the predetermined objectives of research. Some critical aspects in data
collection and management of information include resource use based
on cost and time, quality of information, and use of appropriate filters
to prepare the data for analysis. The information analysis in qualitative
research demands a robust content analysis. Some researchers also use
descriptive statistics, if possible, while quantifying the small qualitative
samples. Graphic and pictorial illustrations are also extensively used in
analysis and reporting of findings of the qualitative information. How-
ever, it is very essential for researchers to check the consistency of findings
with the predetermined propositions of the study.
Any qualitative research design has the following components, each
of which addresses a different set of issues essential to the coherence of a
study, as discussed as follows:
they arise, and to avert risk (Rajagopal 2017; Langer and Beard 2014).
Over the years, empiricism has been associated with the qualitative
research, which has emerged from the experimental sciences in manage-
ment. The theory of empiricism explains that all knowledge is derived
from cognitive science and converges management and action. Research-
ers experience empiricism in qualitative research in which enlightenment
of thought process drives complex and contemplating minds to the new
challenges, and induces radicalism in the epistemological development
in management research over the conventional thoughts of schools
(Rajagopal 2017).
Theoretical concepts that support qualitative research have evolved
over a range of factors connecting ontology and epistemology. Ontol-
ogy is a set of concepts and categories in a subject area or domain such
as sociology, that shows attributes like beliefs and ethnology, and their
codependency. The qualitative research has grown over the social ontolog-
ical concepts and the ways to study them with the support of the logical
and philosophical phenomena (epistemology). The purpose and goal of
the research, the characteristics of research participants, the audience for
the research, the sponsors, and the positions and environments of the
researchers themselves have become the elements of qualitative research
evolving out of classical, neoclassical, and modern schools of thought
(Ritchie et al. 2013). Differences in the mix of these factors have led to
numerous variations in approaches to qualitative research. Therefore, it is
argued that a better quality work is produced if flexible approaches and
methods are considered, and choices are made according to the objectives
and context of the qualitative research (Seale et al. 2007).
Most epistemological philosophies have common attributes as exhib-
ited in Table 1.3, which would reveal the path of epistemological evolu-
tion from traditional to modernist and later toward critical theory.
Critical theory has made a docile stance in management research,
while its philosophy has been well established in social research and liter-
ature studies. Formalism, which stemmed out of the critical theory, exam-
ines the relationships between a texted idea and its form between what a
text says and the way it says it. However, critical theory aims at diagnos-
ing the problems of the modern society and prescribing necessary social
changes toward reducing the socioeconomic inequality. Philosophically,
Introduction to Qualitative Research 27
• Symbolic interactionism
• Phenomenology
• Ethnography
Symbolic Interactionism
Phenomenology
Ethnography
and subjects are integrally engaged to share their views on the prede-
termined topic. Data in the ethnographic tradition, therefore, contrib-
ute to continuous learning from the respondents. It can be subjective
or objective, and may be intensely personal such as sharing reflexivity or
distantly epiphenomenal. Epiphenomenalism is a philosophical state of
mind in which cognitive process is affected by the changes in the physical
states (Denzin 2011). The epiphenomenal research studies the conver-
gence of mental life that affects physical dynamics or body reflexes within
the social and personal surrounding. Accordingly, epiphenomenalism is a
part of ethnographic research, and can be described as neurophysiological
changes in the brain caused by events, retrieval of memory, or induced
state of mind. Researchers acquiring qualitative information can be ben-
efitted by the epiphenomenal observations of subjects during the study
(Birnbacher 2006).
There are two types of ethnographic approaches: visual and docu-
mentary. Visual ethnography is about the collection of visual artifacts to
the ethnographic record such as photographs, videos, maps, and clips,
which are often complementary to auditory or documentary forms of
data (Schwartz 1989). In the era of advanced information technology, the
ethnographic research has evolved from face-to-face research to the use of
digital platforms. It is widely accepted that respondents make little dis-
tinction between their online and offline personality, and people regularly
share personal content and experiences via branded digital platforms like
Facebook, Twitter, and Pinterest. The virtual platforms such as blogs and
vlogs have also become the major resources of ethnographic text mining
and virtual interactions. Digital platforms have become the new field for
qualitative inquiry and have emerged as rich assets for carrying out par-
ticipatory behaviors that unveil information about interesting lifestyle of
people, and deliver information about emerging subcultural in contem-
porary society.
Growing new technologies have driven customers to become cocre-
ators in developing customized products and services. New technologies
have also allowed customers to disseminate personalized messages they
receive, and authorize companies to customize the messages they would
like to deliver in the society. Such services were once offered only to the
elite for a very high cost, but application of technology by the companies
32 Qualitative Marketing Research
for penetrating the mass market makes such customization much cheaper
and easier. From jeans to coffee, to bicycles, to eyewear, to cosmetics, to
vitamins, to breakfast cereals, companies have used this technology to
create customized offerings. Managers have realized over time that if cus-
tomers could get exactly what they want, they would not settle for some
less-than-perfect standardized offering or message; and if companies could
manufacture to order, the inventory reduction would go directly to the
bottom line. Many firms focus on convergence of technology with cus-
tomer value in promoting products and services in the mass markets. Real-
izing that firms, technology, and society had to coexist, companies, social
networks, and social organizations look for ways to influence each other
through joint social responsibility projects. This paves the way for the
get-into-business stage, in which social networks and companies seek to
serve the customers at bottom of the pyramid market segment by setting
up successful businesses. In this process, customer learn through peers,
while corporations gain an appreciation for the local knowledge, low-cost
business models, and community-based marketing techniques. Increased
success on both sides has laid the foundation for the co-created business
in which companies and social networks become key parts of each other’s
capacity to deliver value (Burgmann and Prahalad 2007; Rajagopal 2013).
Social media has increasingly drawn more attention of consumers and
companies over the traditional media. Accordingly, most companies have
redefined the key factors of their marketing mix by reviewing the shifts in
the consumer behavior, and online word of mouth competing for innova-
tions in the products, operations, and services strategies. Many companies
consider staying active in social media as a viable alternative to traditional
advertising and communication. However, managers should understand
that both traditional and online social media should serve as complemen-
tary to each other rather than relying on either one of them. A compar-
ison of advertising and word of mouth shows that social media follow
rules that are very different from traditional advertising. Social media can
start conversations or build brand recognition, but the results are much
more difficult to predict or measure (Armelini and Villanueva 2011).
While working with social media, some companies have realized that
the problem-solving process begins with the identification of exchange
Introduction to Qualitative Research 33
content and goals such as what does the customer need, and how does
the company deliver solutions to meet those needs. The company’s high
degree of specialization may not be often ready to meet the shifts in the
consumer behavior, as online interactive media drive the perceptions
and attitudes of consumers faster than the traditional communications
(Tuli et al. 2007).
Ethnographic research involves a prolonged, intensive, and direct
involvement of the researcher in the lives and activities of people in the
society. It is often used in conjunction with other terms such as partic-
ipants’ observation, qualitative methodology, a narrative case study, or
social research. This methodology uses documents, observation, and
interviewing people within a wide range of situations and contexts.
Ethnography focuses on both the micro and macro aspects of society. The
broad attributes of ethnographic research are as listed as follows:
A researcher should stay with the subject, interact with them, and
observe the psychosocial, cultural, and emotional attributes of the subjects
to conduct the ethnographic research successfully. Most ethnographic
researchers and journalists have spent months with lesser known tribes,
villagers deprived of basic needs, and with the people at postdisaster reha-
bilitation camps to document their living conditions, expressions, and
emotions. Under such conditions, a researcher must be both a member of
the group and a stranger. During the research process, a level of cultural
strangeness must be established and maintained. Most researchers begin
as participant observers and end as informal interviewers.
34 Qualitative Marketing Research
Impact of Culture
Summary
Qualitative research is an effective tool to measure human values, emo-
tions, and logical narratives through symbolic interactions, and eth-
nographic and phenomenological expedition. It offers an exciting
experience to interact with the subjects, understand their perceptions,
and draw relevant observations. Qualitative research needs an informal
setting comfortable to the respondents and researcher that could cre-
ate both privacy and confidence. It involves an interpretive, naturalistic
approach to explore the research themes. Qualitative research is a flexible
process, which allows researcher to modify the existing research proposi-
tions and formulate new dimensions of the study based on interpersonal
information and observations. A good researcher develops semantics map
on the interconnecting words outgrowing from the responses during
the in-depth interviews in the qualitative research process. Qualitative
researchers develop grounded theory and establish research propositions
through meta-synthesis of the study by integrating relevant qualitative
analytics. Interception and mediation in qualitative inquiries are consid-
ered as good attributes and are used on need basis. The ecosystem of
qualitative research embeds grounded theory, and sociocultural and polit-
ical environment at the background, while the research setting, devel-
opment of research instrument, quality of information, arguments and
validations, audiovisual aides, and the observation of researcher form the
foreground of research. The qualitative research encourages explorative
instead of experimental design of study, unlike quantitative research that
36 Qualitative Marketing Research
uses random sampling within the specified criteria for the subjects like
age, gender, education, income, and occupation. Fundamentally, a good
qualitative research design includes objectives of the research, conceptual
framework, research questions, data collection tools, and validation and
interpretations of the contents Collecting information through in-depth
interviews is followed as the principal technique to explore various per-
spectives from the subjects on a given theme or topic of research. The
qualitative research has been evolved around school of thoughts led by
positivism, empiricism, and interpretivism. The major methodologies in
the qualitative research include symbolic interactions, ethnography, and
phenomenology.
References
Aksan, N., B. Kisac, M. Aydin, and S. Demirbuken. 2009. “Symbolic Interaction
Theory.” Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences 1, no. 1, pp. 902–04.
Armelini, G., and J. Villanueva. 2011. “Adding Social Media to the Marketing
Mix.” IESE Insight 9, pp. 29–36.
Berg, B.L., and H. Lune. 2004. Qualitative Research Methods for the Social
Sciences, vols. 5, Boston: Pearson.
Brennan, L., M.L. Fry, and J. Previte. 2015. “Strengthening Social Marketing
Research: Harnessing “Insight” Through Ethnography.” Australasian
Marketing Journal 23, no. 4, pp. 286–93.
Birnbacher, D. 2006. “Causal Interpretations of Correlations Between Neural and
Conscious Events.” Journal of Consciousness Studies 13, nos. 1–2, pp. 115–28.
Burgmann, J., and C.K. Prahalad. 2007. “Co-creating Business’s New Social
Compact.” Harvard Business Review 85, no. 2, pp. 80–90.
Cibangu, S.K., and N. Hepworth. 2016. “The Uses of Phenomenology and
Phenomenography: A Critical Review.” Library & Information Science
Research 38, no. 2, pp. 148–60.
Chalmers A.G. 1982. What is this Thing Called Science? Queensland, Australia:
University of Queensland Press.
Charmaz, K. 1995. “Grounded Theory.” In Rethinking Methods in Psychology, eds.
J. A. Smith, R. Harré, and L.V. Langenhove, 27–49. London: Sage.
Chaix, E., L. Deléger, R. Bossy, and C. Nédellec. 2018. “Text Mining Tools
for Extracting Information About Microbial Biodiversity in Food.” Food
Microbiology, in press doi.org/10.1016/j.fm.2018.04.011
Chater, N., and M. Oaksford. 2000. “The Rational Analysis of Mind and
Behavior.” Synthese 122, nos. 1–2, pp. 93–131.
Introduction to Qualitative Research 37
Toplak, M.E., R.F. West, and K.E. Stanovich. 2014. “Rational Thinking and
Cognitive Sophistication: Development, Cognitive Abilities, and Thinking
Dispositions.” Development Psychology 50, no. 4, pp. 1037–48.
Tuli, K.R., A.K. Kohli, and S.G. Bharadwaj. 2007. “Rethinking Customer
Solutions: From Product Bundles to Relational Processes.” Journal of
Marketing 71, no. 3, pp. 1–17.
Zahavi, D. 2008. “Phenomenology.” In Routledge Companion to Twentieth-
Century Philosophy, ed. D. Moran. Philadelphia, PA: Routledge.
Index
Note: page numbers followed by f and t indicates figures and tables respectively.