Stability Studies of Lysine Acetylsalicylate (Aspirin Derivative) : Mechanisms of Hydrolysis
Stability Studies of Lysine Acetylsalicylate (Aspirin Derivative) : Mechanisms of Hydrolysis
Stability Studies of Lysine Acetylsalicylate (Aspirin Derivative) : Mechanisms of Hydrolysis
net/publication/272878506
CITATIONS READS
0 318
1 author:
Oussama Kamal
Université Hassan II de Casablanca
22 PUBLICATIONS 55 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Oussama Kamal on 24 April 2015.
Received December 20, 2011; revised February 6, 2012; accepted March 9, 2012
ABSTRACT
To control the stability of the lysine acetylsalicylate compound (LAS) in aqueous solution, some studies of the hy-
dronium ion-catalyzed, hydroxide ion-catalyzed, and spontaneous reactions of this active ingredient in water solutions
have been carried out. The pH-rate profile (log kobs = f(pH)), shows that the hydrolysis reaction of the LAS, is con-
ducted by a catalysis acid-base mechanism, with multiple reaction pathways. The rate constants, kH, kOH and k0 to the
reaction pathways catalyzed by H3O+, HO– ions and to the spontaneous reaction, for the hydrolysis reaction of the re-
agent LAS, were determined. The results show that the studied compound LAS is unstable in basic medium and the
hydrolysis reaction catalyzed by HO– ions is predominant.For a known acidity (pH 10), studies conducted for differ-
ent temperatures of the medium, clearly indicate, that the experimental rate constant kobs ,depends on the temperature
according to the Arrhenius equation. The activation parameters: activation energy (Ea), enthalpy (ΔH≠) and entropy
(ΔS≠), for the transition state were determined, The very negative value obtained for the activation parameter ΔS*, first
indicates that in the transition state there is gain in order, then this late state, resembles the products and that probably
for the mechanism of the LAS hydrolysis reaction catalyzed by HO– ions, the rate-determining step is a bimolecular
reaction. Finally from all these results, the mechanism for the reaction pathway catalyzed by HO– ions has been eluci-
dated.
Keywords: Lysine Acetylsalicylate; Hydronium Ions Hydroxide Catalyzed; Catalysis Acid-Base Mechanism; Multiple
Reaction Pathways; Activation Parameters
O O
2. Experimental Section
O O
slow Inorganic salts were of analytical grade, and were used
O O without further purification, as well used normadoses
O
1 2 solutions of HCl and NaOH were analytical grade. Water
O was further glass distilled before use. The LAS was ob-
tained commercially. Aqueous solutions of reagent LAS
of known concentrations 5 × 10–4 M and 10–3 M were
prepared, the desired pH values are determined by adding
O O the quantities: HCl (0.5 M) or NaOH (1 M), respectively
CO2 for acidic or basic mediums and these pH values are
- H2O O
measured with a Hanna 210 microprocessor pH-meter,
+
H + CH3CO2 +
OH O equipped with a combined glass electrode and calibrated
3 with commercial buffers (pH 4.00 and 7.00). These solu-
tions are maintained at fixed temperature 298 K, and
Scheme 1. Hydrolysis reaction of the LAS reagent.
small aliquots were withdrawn at known time intervals.
seriously questioned this mechanism. He found that the These samples were analyzed by standard Helios UV-
addition of ethanol to the solvent increases the rate of visible spectrometer, using quartz cells of optical path
solvolysis, and that ethyl acetate is then a product [3-6]. length l = 1 cm. The absorption measurements have been
He ruled out the possibility that the rate increase is a performed at wavelength max = 300 nm. Indeed, the UV-
generalized solvent effect by showing that the addition of visible spectra of Figure 1, clearly show that the salicy-
dioxane has very little effect on the rate of hydrolysis of late ion formed by hydrolysis of the LAS, has a maxi-
aspirin. Garrett tried to explain his results by proposing a mum band of absorption at max = 300 nm, and at this
mechanism involving nucleophilic attack by ethanol on maximum wavelength, the reagent LAS has a negligible
the tetrahedral carbon atom of the intermediate (2) absorption.
(Scheme 1), but this explanation has not been generally The initial concentration denoted “a” of the reagent
accepted [9]. Nevertheless, the demonstration that the has always been very low (5, 10–4 M), so that all the
addition of ethanol increases the rate of solvolysis does spectrophotometric measurements were carried out under
suggest strongly that the question of the involvement of a conditions of pseudo-first-order, with higher concentra-
molecule of solvent in the transition state ought to be tions of reacting species (H3O+, H2O and HO–), com-
reopened. The work of Jencks and Gilchrist [11] shows pared to this initial concentration a. All experimental
clearly that ethanol and ethoxide ion are stronger nucleo- values of optical densities were measured by reference to
philes than water and hydroxide ion in reactions at the pure water.
carbonyl group, and a rate-determining step involving
attack by either species would explain Garrett’s results. 3. Results and Discussion
It has been recognized for many years that over a suf- 3.1. Identification of the Catalysis Type for the
ficiently wide pH range, three kinetically-distinguishable Hydrolysis Reaction
mechanisms for the hydrolysis of some compounds, such
as epoxides and derivatives of acetylsalicylic acid [12-15]. The hydrolysis reaction of this reagent derivative of aspirin,
The experimental rate expression for their hydrolysis is
given by the following equation:
kobs kH H k0 kOH OH (1)
has been studied at 298 K in the pH range of 0.50 to 13 on the reaction of hydrolysis reagent LAS, is given by
and the kinetics of this hydrolysis phenomenon have the expression:
proved sensitive to the medium acidity, therefore, there is
possibility of the existence of a catalysis phenomenon by
kobs kH H k0 kOH OH (4)
ionic species of water (H3O+ and HO–). Generally, the It is obvious to note that the kinetic law of pseudo
mechanism of hydrolysis may be conducted according to first-order Equation (3) can be easily connected to changes
the following Scheme 2. in optical densities as a function of time, especially, only
The rate constants of second-order kH and kOH, are as- the hydrolyzed product absorbs at the measurement
sociated with catalytic decomposition process, respec- wavelength (max = 300 nm). Indeed, if D0, Dt and D∞ are
tively, in acidic and basic environments. While the rate respectively the values of optical density at t = 0, at time
constant of first-order k0, is involved in the process of t and at the end of the reaction and if sal is the molar
hydrolysis under the effect of solvent molecules, how- extinction coefficient of salicylate ion, we can write the
ever, it must be noted that this constant k0 result of the following relations:
operation kH2 O 55.55 (water concentration), with kH2 O D 0 0 ; Dt sal lx ; D sal la (5)
is the rate constant of second-order corresponding to the where l is the optical path, a and x are the respective
process of hydrolysis by an elementary molecule of the concentrations of LAS reagent and hydrolyzed product.
water. From the kinetic law of Equation (3) and the preceding
If a is the initial concentration of the reagent LAS, and relations Equation (5), we can establish relationships that
x the concentration of salicylate ions, formed at time t, express the evolution of the optical density versus time t.
and for a fixed acidity of the medium, the rate equation a D
on the hydrolysis reaction is given by the following ex- ln ln kobs t (6)
ax D Dt
pression:
and we see immediately that the value of the apparent
dx
dt
kH H k0 kOH OH a x (1) rate constant kobs is obtained from the slope of the straight
lines
After separation of variables, we have the relation:
D
dx
kH H k0 kOH OH dt (2) ln f t (7)
d a x D Dt
The integration of this relationship allows obtaining The graphic in Figure 2 illustrates the good linearity
the following kinetic equation: of the observed experimental lines.
Several experiments on the hydrolysis reaction of the
a
ln
ax
kH H k0 kOH OH t kobs t (3) reagent LAS, were performed for pH values from 0.50 to
13, with HCl and NaOH as agents, respectively to deter-
The apparent rate constant of pseudo first-order kobs, mine the pH of the studied solutions. For these experi-
ments, the kinetic experimental lines Equation (6) were
O
plotted and the apparent rate constants kobs were calcu-
O NH2 lated for all studied solutions, from the slopes of obtained
OH
O NH3+
LAS O
O
kH[H+] kOH[OH-]
k0
Scheme 2. Different reaction pathways proposed for the Figure 2. Kinetics for the hydrolysis reaction of LAS re-
hydrolysis reaction of LAS. agent, in different basic solutions at 298 K.
lines. Table 1 includes all results related to the pheno- Therefore, the apparent rate constant kobs, expression is
menon of hydrolysis of the LAS compound. composed of three terms and is identified with the Equa-
These results show, firstly that the rate of hydrolysis tion (4). The shape of this curve on the pH-rate profile
reaction of this compound depends on the acidity of the clearly indicates that the hydrolysis reaction of the re-
medium and the reaction pathway catalyzed by the HO– agent LAS, is using three different reaction pathways, for
ions on the hydrolysis reaction is predominant, on the three different pH ranges and therefore, this reaction
other hand, values of these apparent rate constants (kobs) presents a phenomenon of acid-base catalysis. For pH
change in different ways, according to three pH ranges. values below 2, the curve has a negative slope (–1) and
From these values, the pH-rate profile graph (log kobs = in kobs expression Equation (4), the term kH is dominant,
f(pH)), was established (Figure 3), and the obtained ex- and this hydrolysis reaction proceeds according to the
perimental curve shows three different slopes (p = –1, 0 reaction pathway catalyzed by H3O+ ions. The zero slope
and +1). of this curve, presented for pH values between 2 and 8,
clearly indicates that in this pH range, the k0 term is pre-
Table 1. Evolution of the apparent rate constants (kobs) on dominant Equation (4), the apparent rate constant kobs
the medium acidity. depends on the concentration of HO– ions, and the hy-
pH Log (kobs)
drolysis process of LAS, results from the intervention of
these ions, according to the reaction pathway catalyzed
0.5 –3.222 by these ionic species HO–. From the curve in Figure 3,
0.7 –3.523 we determined the values of three rate constants kH, k0,
and kOH, for different reaction pathways that constitute
1.30 –3.886
the global mechanism for the hydrolysis process of the
3.00 –3.980 LAS reagent. Table 2 shows the values for these constants
4.00 –3.990 and the definitive expression of the apparent rate con-
5.30 –4.000 stant kobs at 298 K, is given by the following equation:
6.10 –4.097 kobs 1.73 103 H 3O 9.09 10 5 1.58 OH (8)
7.04 –4.097
These results indicate that the hydrolysis reaction of
8.20 –4.000 the LAS reagent, is achieved using an acid-base catalysis
11.33 –2.602 mechanism, the reaction pathway catalyzed by HO– ions
11.95 –1.921
is dominant, and the degradation of this compound is
important in basic medium. This value of the rate con-
12.18 –1.726
stant kOH on the hydrolysis reaction of LAS in basic me-
12.37 –1.404 dium is the same order of magnitude as the values of the
12.50 –1.390 constants kOH determined for the picryl chloride and
trinitro-anisole hydrolysis reactions [16-18]. It is consid-
12.70 –1.211
erably less than the value calculated for the hydrolysis of
pH values determined by adding concentrated solutions of HCl and NaOH,
kobs in mn–1, [LAS] = 5 × 10–4 M. 7-chloro-4,6-dinitrobenzofurazan [19], while this value is
much higher than the values announced for the hydroly-
sis reactions of styrene oxides [20].
tion pathway in the hydrolysis process of studied reagent lar products and indicates that probably, for this reaction
(LAS). We followed the kinetics of the studied hydroly- pathway catalyzed by HO– ions, the intervention of the
sis reaction in basic medium of constant pH (10.12), by water molecule is in the rate-determining step, after the
varying the temperature between 298 and 323 K. The fast attack of the LAS reagent by very active HO– ion,
experimental values of the apparent rate constant kobs and that in the transition state there is a transfer of hy-
were calculated in the same way as the previous section, drogen atoms from one site to another. Indeed, some ki-
and Table 3 summarizes all results. netic studies [21,22] on hydrolysis reactions of some
The linear relationship between Ln kobs and the inverse organic compounds, have suggested mechanisms which
of absolute temperature (1/T) represented by the graph in involve a water molecule in the rate-determining step,
Figure 4, indicated firstly, that a consistent solvolysis and for this reaction pathway we propose the following
mechanism operated for this hydrolysis reaction pathway mechanism:
catalyzed by HO– ions, on the other hand, the Arrhenius
Table 3. The apparent rate constant kobs evolution vs. the
law is well verified for the studied temperatures and the
temperature.
activation parameters for this process were calculated
from the slope and intercept on the experimental right. 105.kobs (s–1 ) ln (kobs ) T (K) 103.1/T (K–1)
Ln kobs = f(1/T), plotted for the interval of studied
temperatures, with the following values for the activation 0.667 –11.917 298 3.36
energy Ea = (65.60 0.05) kJ.mol–1 and the preexponen- 1.160 –11.364 308 3.25
tial factor in the Arrhenius relationship A = (1.803
2.830 –10.472 318 3.15
0.005) 106 s–1.
From these activation parameters, we determined at tem- 5.330 –9.840 323 3.09
perature T = 298 K, the magnitude of activation enthalpy pH = 10.12, [LAS] = 5 × 10–4 M, kobs in s–1.
ΔH≠ and entropy ΔS≠, according to the following expres-
sions derived from the theory of the transition state:
H Ea RT and S R ln A 30.46 (9)
O O
O O O O
R a p id p re -e q u ilib riu m
H
O
#
O O
O Ly+ + H 2O O Ly+
O O O O
S lo w s te p
H H H O
O O H
T ra n s itio n s ta te
O O
O O
O Ly+ - O Ly+
+ OH + OH O + H 2O
+
OH OH
Figure 5. Mechanism for hydroxide ion catalyzed hydrolysis of the LAS reagent.
This mechanism for the reaction pathway catalyzed by Society, Vol. 79, No. 13, 1957, pp. 3401-3408.
HO– ions, composed of three steps, indicating that Step 2 doi:10.1021/ja01570a024
on the association of a water molecule with the carbanion [4] E. R. Garrett, “Evidence for General Base Catalysis in an
produced by Step 1, is rate-determining step, with a Ester Hydrolysis. I. Hydrolysis of an Alkyl Aminoacetyl-
highly ordered transition state whose structure resembles salicylate,” Journal of the American Chemical Society,
Vol. 79, No. 19, 1957, pp. 5206-5209.
the products of the reaction. The passage through this doi:10.1021/ja01576a036
highly ordered transition state with cyclic and internal
[5] E. R. Garrett, “The Solvolysis of Aspirin Anhydride,” J
transfer of hydrogen atoms from one site to another, well
Journal of the American Chemical Society, Vol. 82, No. 3,
justifies the activation energy required for the formation 1960, pp. 711-718. doi:10.1021/ja01488a052
of this transition state, and the very negative value of the
[6] E. R. Garrett, “The Neutral Solvolysis of the Aspirin An-
activation entropy (ΔS≠ = –133.42 J.K–1.mol–1). More- ion in Aqueous and Mixed Solvents,” The Journal of Or-
over, this very negative value is in favor of a bimolecular ganic Chemistry, Vol. 26, No. 10, 1961, pp. 3660-3663.
process involving two species, to imagine that highly doi:10.1021/jo01068a010
ordered transition state. Indeed, the value of this parame- [7] J. D. Chanley, E. M. Gindler and H. Sobotka, “The Me-
ter (ΔS≠) is very useful for identifying the rate-determining chanism of the Hydrolysis of Salicyl Phosphate. I,” Jour-
step molecularity. Recent studies on the degradation ki- nal of the American Chemical Society, Vol. 74, No. 17,
netics of some compounds [23,24], indicate clearly that 1952, pp. 4347-4352. doi:10.1021/ja01137a030
for the unimolecular process, the values of the activation [8] D. Davidson and L. Auerbach, “The Acid Anhydride Char-
entropy ΔS≠ are positive. acter of Aspirin,” Journal of the American Chemical So-
ciety, Vol. 75, No. 23, 1953, pp. 5984-5986.
doi:10.1021/ja01119a062
4. Conclusion
[9] M. L. Bender, “Mechanisms of Catalysis of Nucleophilic
Studies in this work have identified the stability of the Reactions of Carboxylic Acid Derivatives,” Chemical Re-
active reagent LAS as a function of the medium acidity, views, Vol. 60, No. 1, 1960, pp. 53-113.
to determine the different rate constants for the three re- doi:10.1021/cr60203a005
action pathways involved in the hydrolysis process of [10] M. L. Bender, F. Chloupek and M. C. Neveu, “Intramo-
this compound. Finally a study of the temperature influ- lecular Catalysis of Hydrolytic Reactions. III. Intramo-
lecular Catalysis by Carboxylate Ion in the Hydrolysis of
ence has been achieved for the hydrolysis reaction in
Methyl Hydrogen Phthalate,” Journal of the American
basic medium, and the activation parameters for transi- Chemical Society, Vol. 80, No. 20, 1958, pp. 5384-5387.
tion complex were determined. The analysis of these doi:10.1021/ja01553a016
results has identified an acid-base catalysis type for the [11] W. P. Jencks and M. Gilchrist, “The Nucleophilic Reac-
hydrolysis process of this studied compound, with a clear tivity of Alcoholate Anions toward p-Nitrophenyl Ace-
predominance for the reaction pathway catalyzed by HO– tate,” Journal of the American Chemical Society, Vol. 84,
ions in basic medium, and for this reaction pathway, the No. 15, 1962, pp. 2910-2913. doi:10.1021/ja00874a013
activation parameters on the transition complex was de- [12] J. N. Brönsted, M. Kilpatrick and M. Kilpatrick, “Kinetic
termined based on expressions derived from the transi- Studies on Ethylene Oxides,” Journal of the American
tion state theory. On the one hand, the values of these pa- Chemical Society, Vol. 51, No. 2, 1929, pp. 428-461.
rameters allowed us to propose a reaction mechanism doi:10.1021/ja01377a012
consisting of three steps for the hydrolysis phenomenon [13] F. A. Long and J. G. Pritchard, “Hydrolysis of Substituted
of reagent LAS in basic medium, and secondly, to clearly Ethylene Oxides in H2O18 Solutions,” Journal of the Ame-
rican Chemical Society, Vol. 78, No. 12, 1956, pp. 2663-
specify the rate-determining step for this proposed mecha- 2667. doi:10.1021/ja01593a001
nism.
[14] J. G. Pritchard and F. A. Long, “Hydrolysis of Ethylene
Oxide Derivatives in Deuterium Oxide-Water Mixtures,”
Journal of the American Chemical Society, Vol. 78, No.
REFERENCES 23, 1956, pp. 6008-6013. doi:10.1021/a01604a014
[1] L. J. Edwards, “The Hdrolysis of Aspirin. A Determina- [15] A. R. Fersht and A. J. Kirby, “Hydrolysis of Aspirin. In-
tion of the Thermodynamic Dissociation Constant and a tramolecular General Base Catalysis of Ester Hydrolysis,”
Study of the Reaction Kinetics by Ultra-Violet Spectro- Journal of the American Chemical Society, Vol. 89, No.
photometry,” Transactions of the Faraday Society, Vol. 46, 19, 1967, pp. 4857-4863. doi:10.1021/ja00995a007
1950, pp. 723-735. doi:10.1039/TF9504600723 [16] R. H. De Rossi and E B. De Vargas, “Buffer Catalysis in
[2] L. J. Edwards, “The Hydrolysis of Aspirin: Part 2,” Trans- the Hydrolysis of Picryl Chloride,” The Journal of Or-
actions of the Faraday Society, Vol. 48, 1952, pp. 696-699. ganic Chemistry, Vol. 44, No. 23, 1979, pp. 4100-4104.
doi:10.1039/TF9524800696 doi:10.1021/jo01337a017
[3] E. R. Garrett, “The Kinetics of Solvolysis of Acyl Esters [17] J. Murto, A. Bovallius, G. Bergson, L. Ehrenberg, J.
of Salicyclic Acid,” Journal of the American Chemical Brunvoll, E. Bunnenberg, C. Djerassi and R. Records,
“Nucleophilic Reactivity, Part 9: Kinetics of the Reac- Organic Chemistry, Vol. 58, No. 4, 1993, pp. 924-932.
tions of Hydroxide Ion and Water with Picrylic Com- doi:10.1021/jo00056a027
pounds,” Acta Chemica Scandinavica, Vol. 20, 1966, pp. [21] J.-P. Lee and T.-S. Uhm, “Kinetics and Mechanism of the
310-322. doi:10.3891/acta.chem.scand.20-0310 Hydrolysis Reaction of N-Furoyl-2-Phenylimidazole,”
[18] B. Gibson and M. R. Crampton, “The Stabilities of Meis- Bull of the Korean Chemical Society, Vol. 21, No. 1, 2000,
enheimer Complexes. Part 17. The Reactions of 1-X-2,4, pp. 29-30.
6-Trinitrobenzenes with Hydroxide Ions in Water,” Jour- [22] J.-P. Lee and S.-S. Lee, “Kinetics and Mechanism for
nal of the Chemical Society, Perkin Transactions 2, No. 5, Hydrolysis Reaction of N-Benzoyl-2-Phenylimidazole,”
1979, pp. 648-652. doi:10.1039/P29790000648 Bull of the Korean Chemical Society, Vol. 23, No. 1,
[19] F. Terrier, L. Xiao, M. Hlaibi and J. C. Halle, “Highly 2002, pp. 151-153. doi:10.5012/bkcs.2002.23.1.151
Eletro-Philic Heteroaromatics: The Hydrolysis of 7-Chloro- [23] F. Boujelbane and N. B. Hamida, “Étude Cinetiaue de la
4, 6-Dinitrobenzofurane and 7-Chloro-4, 6-Dinitrobenzo- Dégradation Hydrolytique d’un Insecticide: Le Bendio-
Furoxan in Aqueous Solution,” Journal of the Chemical carb,” Journal de la Société Chimique de Tunisie, Vol. 9,
Society, Perkin Transactions 2, No. 3, 1993, pp. 337-341. No. 2, 2007, pp. 121-132.
doi:10.1039/P29930000337 [24] F. Boujelbane and N. B. Hamida “Étude par HPLC et
[20] J. J. Blumenstein, V. C. Ukachukwu, R. S. Mohan and D. Spectrophotométrie UV de la Dégradation Hydrolytique
L. Whalen, “Effects of Para-Substituents on the Mecha- d’un Insecticide, le Zectran,” Journal de la Société Chi-
nisms of Solvolysis of Styrene Oxides,” The Journal of mique de Tunisie, Vol. 10, No. 1, 2008, pp. 39-51.