2006 Davidarnold PDF
2006 Davidarnold PDF
To cite this article: REUBENDRAN CHELLAN , JONATHAN POCOCK & DAVID ARNOLD
(2004) DIRECT REDUCTION OF MIXED MAGNETITE AND COAL PELLETS USING
INDUCTION HEATING, Mineral Processing and Extractive Metallurgy Review, 26:1, 63-76, DOI:
10.1080/08827500490477612
REUBENDRAN CHELLAN
JONATHAN POCOCK
DAVID ARNOLD
School of Chemical Engineering, University of KwaZulu-Natal,
Durban, South Africa
The production of pig iron in the blast furnace ranks foremost among all
the iron-making processes, constituting 59% of the world iron production
in 2001 (Moore 2001). Coke is used in large quantities in iron blast fur-
naces to promote a combination of direct and indirect reduction within
the furnace. Direct reduction involves the carbon reacting directly with the
We would like the thank Lignotech South Africa for sponsorship, the Geology Depart-
ments of the Westville and Howard College campuses, University of KwaZulu-Natal, for
respective X-Ray diffraction analysis and the SEM unit of Howard College campus for
analysis performed.
Address correspondence to Jonathan Pocock, School of Chemical Engineering,
Howard College Campus, University of KwaZulu-Natal, King George V Avenue, Durban
4041, South Africa. E-mail: Pocockj@nu.ac.za
63
64 R. CHELLAN ET AL.
iron oxide to form iron, while indirect reduction involves the carbon
monoxide, which is a product of direct reduction, becoming the reducing
agent to form metallic iron. The product is a liquid ‘‘pig iron,’’ containing
up to 5% carbon and 1% silicon (Peacey and Davenport 1979).
The blast furnace process faces many problems, such as low flex-
ibility in production capacity (Sasaki 1998), emission of air pollutants
(Lungen 2001), and high investment cost (Gielen 2002).
The current major problem, however, is the decrease in supplies of
coking coal. The coal required for coke production must have specific
properties and production of coke is not environmentally friendly, as
volatiles have to be burnt off. In the world, there are limited reserves of
coking coals (Yusfin and Pashkov 2002). Research conducted by the
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Cape Town, South
Africa (Anon 2001) confirms that only approximately 2% of the large coal
reserves in South Africa, i.e., 55 billion tons, are suitable for coke making.
Due to the lack of good coking coal within South Africa and
dwindling supplies worldwide, new iron-making processes are being
developed to use cheaper coal supplies. Processes that produce iron by
reduction of iron oxide below the melting point of the metal produced are
generally classified as direct reduction processes and the products are
referred to as direct reduced iron (DRI) (Feinman 1999). DRI is the
product that has a high metallization degree, i.e., >90% (Els 2001),
obtained by reducing iron bearing materials with natural gas or non-
coking coal in a reducing unit. The product, which is porous, is also
known as sponge iron. In 2001, the worldwide production of DRI
amounted to 39 Mt, which constituted 4% of the world iron production
(Moore 2001). Yusfin and Pashkov (2002) have projected that the pro-
duction of DRI will reach 53 Mt in 2005.
Presently, most direct reduction processes employ an excess of coal,
which is much higher than the required stoichiometric addition. These
processes are also run at temperatures in excess of 1000 C, which is
higher than necessary for direct reduction to proceed, with the minimum
being around 850 C (Gilchrist 1980).
Although iron ore is the primary source of iron oxide, the existing
reserves need not be utilized at the current rate. Replacing part of the iron
concentrates with recycled steel scrap, iron-containing dust, and metal
machining scrap can reduce the use of natural resources (Heino et al.
2000). In South Africa, Phalaborwa Mining Limited as well as
Foskor Limited produces magnetite as a by-product. The magnetite is
DIRECT REDUCTION OF MIXED MAGNETITE AND COAL PELLETS 65
The coarser coal will be referred to as coal <100 mm, while the finer
coal will be referred to as coal <20 mm. The particle sizes of the feed
material are comparable with the material used for pellets in the Fastmet
Process, which are around 40 mm (Fowkes 1997).
The lignobond pellet binder used was obtained from Lignotech SA
and referenced as Lignobond DP001. Carbon present in the binder
amounted to 43.88% (SEM Experimental Analysis). Commercially used
binders, e.g., bentonite, are normally added in the range of 0.51% by
mass. A maximum of 1% lignobond binder was therefore added to bind
the pellets. An advantage of lignobond is that it is hydrophilic, thereby
rendering the material to be pelletized wettable. This is advantageous as
coal is naturally hydrophobic.
The pellets required for reduction testing were pelletized mixtures of
magnetite and floated coal fines, including a 1% solid lignobond binder.
The production of pellets was conducted batch-wise in a disc pelletizer,
with 500 g of feed material. The disc pelletizer was operated at 20 revo-
lutions per minute (rpm) at an angle of 60 to the horizontal. The disc
diameter was 61 cm and the lip extended 15 cm from the disc. Pellets were
allowed to dry in an oven at 100 C, but were not heat treated in any way
prior to processing.
It is required that the pellets should not fail under furnace conditions;
therefore, the pellets were subjected to temperatures ranging from
500900 C and subsequent compression strength tests were performed
using a strength tester. The breaking strengths of both sets of pellets, i.e.,
pellets comprising coal <20 mm and coal <100 mm were found to be greater
than the industrially acceptable limit of 22 N for pellets between 11.2 and
12.7 mm in diameter (Ripke and Kawatra 2000). At temperatures up to
800 C, the pellets made with coarser coal exhibited slightly higher
strength. Pellets showed signs of sintering at temperatures above 800 C
with a significant increase of strength for both types of pellets but a
strength increase of the fine coal pellets to above that for coarse coal
pellets.
DIRECT REDUCTION OF MIXED MAGNETITE AND COAL PELLETS 67
Figure 1. XRD analysis: mixed ore=floated coal pellets (1:1 by mass), 1% lignobond,
N2 atmosphere, with gas stream.
Coal=mag ¼ 1:6 Coal=mag ¼ 1:6 Coal=mag ¼ 1:2 Coal=mag ¼ 1:6 Coal=mag ¼ 1:6
by mass by mass by mass by mass by mass
coal < 100 mm coal < 100 mm coal < 100 mm coal < 20 mm coal < 20 mm
time ¼ 15 min time ¼ 45 min time ¼ 15 min time ¼ 30 min time ¼ 15 min
N2 atmosphere N2 atmosphere N2 atmosphere N2 atmosphere Air atmosphere
Increasing the coal=magnetite feed ratio, in this case from 1:6 to 1:2 by
mass, i.e., increasing coal addition from 1 to 3 times the stoichiometric
requirement, increases the degree of reduction.
Reduction in an air atmosphere induces indirect reduction, which is
favorable, but also unfavorably enhances the re-oxidation of reduced
iron.
Although reduction in an N2 atmosphere nullified re-oxidation of the
product iron, the time taken for a substantial percentage of carbon to
reduce the magnetite was in excess of 45 min.
XRD and SEM elemental analyses were carried out to identify the degree
of iron formation and the remaining oxide types in the pellets.
The optimized run of duration 1 h showed significant improvement
to the reduction process. The XRD analysis of samples taken at different
sampling points, i.e., top, middle, and bottom (Figure 3), shows traces of
wustite present and no magnetite present. Due to a solid product being
formed, containing large amounts of reduced metallic iron, the product
will now be referred to as DRI.
Using the elemental analysis (Table 3), an approximate mass balance
could be performed to calculate the mass percent of DRI produced.
Assuming that all the oxygen was in the slag phase, the percentage
conversion of magnetite to DRI was calculated to be 100%. This is,
however, improbable, as the XRD analysis show traces of wustite pre-
sent. Assuming that all the oxygen is in the wustite (FeO) phase, mag-
netite is converted to approximately 85% DRI and 15% wustite. This is
also improbable due to oxygen certainly being present in the slag phase.
A single pellet, therefore, comprised approximately 7580% metallic
iron, 515% wustite, 510% slag, and 4% carbon. This compares well
72 R. CHELLAN ET AL.
C 3.95
O 3.50
Mg 0.00
Al 2.69
Si 3.31
P 0.00
S 0.33
K 0.00
Ca 1.36
Ti 1.11
Cr 0.00
Mn 0.23
Fe 83.53
DIRECT REDUCTION OF MIXED MAGNETITE AND COAL PELLETS 73
CONCLUSIONS
A new DRI process using induction heating was investigated and the
following conclusions were made.
REFERENCES
Anon, 2001, ‘‘Preliminary energy outlook for South Africa,’’ Energy Research
Institute, Dept. of Mechanical Engineering, University of Cape Town, South
Africa, Rondebosch, www.dme.gov.za=energy=iep.pdf
Anon, 2003, ‘‘Induction heating,’’ Lepel, http:==inductionheating.com
Els, J., 2001, Next Generation Developments in the Ferrous Industry:
Pyrometallurgy: Current Issues and Future Trends, Mintek, Randburg, The
South African Institute of Mining and Metallugy.
Feinman, J., 1999, Direct Reduction and Smelting Process, ch. 11, Pittsburgh, PA,
AISE Steel Foundation, J. Feinman and Associates, Inc., www.aise.org=
newpubs=ironchap%2011.pdf
Fowkes, N., 1997, ‘‘The reduction of iron ore pellets in the Fastmet process,’’
Research Report 1994=31. Mathematics Department, University of Western
Australia, Australia.
Gielen, D., 2002, CO2 Removal in the Iron and Steel Industry, Ibarahi, Japan,
National Institute for Environmental Studies.
Gilchrist, J. D., 1980, Extraction Metallurgy, 2nd ed., London, U.K., Pergamon.
Haque, R. and Ray, H. S., 1995, ‘‘Role of ore=carbon contact and direct
reduction in the reduction of iron oxide by carbon,’’ Mettallurg. Materials
Trans. B, 26B, pp. 400 401.
Heino, J., Makkonen, H., Laitila, L., Hatkki, J., and Poylio, E., 2000, Recycling
or utilisation of dust, scales and sludge from steel industry, www.cc.jyu.fi=
helsie=pdf=heino.pdf
Jones, R. T., 2001, Iron and Steel, Murdoch University, Perth, Western Australia,
Australia, www.science.murdoch.edu.au
Khan, S., Ahamed, M., Khan, M. A., and ul-Haq, A., 2000, ‘‘Innovative appli-
cations of induction heating for selective heat treatment,’’ Sci. Vision Quar-
terly, 5(4), pp. 14 19.
Lignin Institute, 1991, What is Lignin? www.lignin.info
Lungen, H. B., 2001, ‘‘State of the art and future of the blast furnace,’’ Paper
presented at the 35th Meeting of the IPIS, Berlin, Germany, www.pig-iron.
com=Informationen=images=Luengen.pdf
Minerals Bureau, 2001, Producers of Iron Ore, Directory D8=2001, www.dme.gov.za=
publications=pdf=project_research=minerals=d8_2001=d8_2001 02.pdf
76 R. CHELLAN ET AL.
Moore, C., 2001, ‘‘120 years in pig iron,’’ Proc. 60th Electric Furnace Conf., Int.
Pig Iron Secretariat, Dusseldorf, Germany.
Nascimento, R. C., Mourao, M. B., and Capocchi, J. D. T., 1998, ‘‘Reduction-
swelling behaviour of pellets bearing iron ore and charcoal,’’ Canadian
Metallurg. Quarterly,. 37(5), pp. 441 448.
Negri, E. D., Alfano, O. M., and Chiovetta, M. G., 1987, ‘‘Direct reduction of
hematite in a moving bed. Comparison between one- and three-interface
pellet models,’’ Chem. Eng. Sci., 42(10), pp. 2472 2475.
Peacey, J. G. and Davenport, W. G., 1979, The Iron Blast Furnace — Theory and
Practice, London, U.K., Pergamon.
Ripke, S. J. and Kawatra, S. K., 2000, ‘‘Can fly-ash extend bentonite binder for
iron ore agglomeration?,’’ Int. J. Miner. Process., 60, pp. 181 198.
Sasaki, N., 1998, Direct Iron-Making Process Using Fusion Reduction (DIOS),
ICETT, Japan, www.icett.or.jp=techinfo.nsf
Sharma, T., 1997, ‘‘Reduction of double layered iron ore pellets,’’ Int. J. Miner.
Process., 49, pp. 201 206.
Tanaka, H., Sugiyama, T., Harada, T., and Sugitatsu, H., 2002, FASTMET Dust
Pellet Reduction, Operations report on the First Fastmet Waste Recovery
Plant, Kobe Steel, Ltd. Japan.
Yusfin, Y. and Pashkov, N., 2002, ‘‘Non-blast furnace steel: Alternative or
supplement?,’’ Eurasian Metals, National Review, en.eurasmet.ru=online=
2002=1=science&tech.html