Jurnal Poligami Aan
Jurnal Poligami Aan
Jurnal Poligami Aan
January 2007
The International Journal of Legal Information is produced by The International Association of Law
Libraries.
Abdullah, Raihana (2007) "A Study of Islamic Family Law in Malaysia: A Select Bibliography," International Journal of Legal
Information: Vol. 35: Iss. 3, Article 8.
Available at: http://scholarship.law.cornell.edu/ijli/vol35/iss3/8
This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at Scholarship@Cornell Law: A Digital Repository. It has been accepted for
inclusion in International Journal of Legal Information by an authorized administrator of Scholarship@Cornell Law: A Digital Repository. For more
information, please contact jmp8@cornell.edu.
A Study of Islamic Family Law in Malaysia: A Select
Bibliography
RAIHANA ABDULLAH∗
Abstract
Introduction
∗
The author is Associate Professor in the Department of Syariah and Law within
the Academy of Islamic Studies at the University of Malaya, Kuala Lumpur.
514
2007] RAIHANA ABDULLAH 515
of family affairs. It is clear that this aspect of life is always given great
attention and draws the interest of researchers who seek answers to the many
questions that arise from the implementation and practice of Islamic Family
Law. Hence, this field is constantly evolving, and many issues are still being
debated by researchers today. This is because matters pertaining to Islamic
family law are practiced fully and executed in the daily life of the Muslim
community in Malaysia since the 12th century when Islam was introduced to
Malaysia.
There exists evidence showing that the British colonial authorities had
codified several pieces of legislation related to family matters. This legislation
focused mostly on administration, and also on marriage and divorce
registration. This can be seen for example in the first family law being
enforced in the Straits Settlement namely the 1880 Muhammadan Marriage
Ordinanace. According to M.B. Hooker, this Law had many shortfalls, and as
such, several amendments were introduced to streamline its provisions.
Perhaps because these had limited scope, the Muslim community did not
encounter any difficulties in complying with Islamic family rules. This is
because there were many books in old Jawi written by regional Islamic
scholars on the subject of Islamic family law and based on the Shafie school
of thought.
516 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF LEGAL INFORMATION [Vol. 35.3
Preference of Study
From these three periods we are able to discern the differences of the
writers and researchers who are critical of Islamic family laws. On the whole,
writings and studies pertaining to the Islamic Family Laws in Malaysia not
only discuss the state of marriage, divorce and matters in relation thereto from
the perspective of the classical Islamic Law, but it also covers matters
pertaining to the history of Islamic Family Laws, the implementation and
administration of the Islamic Family Laws and current issues that arise from
the implementation of the Islamic Family Laws.
the question of custom and the Malay community. This question is related to
the question of the Malay familial system pursuant to the Customary Laws
(Undang-Undang Adat).
1
Meanwhile, many of these researchers write and study the system of
Malay Customs, in particular those pertaining to:
the differences between the Adat Temenggung and the Adat Pepateh,2 the
status of women in the Perpateh Custom,3 the conflict and the relationship
between custom (adat) and Islamic Law,4 and also those regarding property,
land and estates.5
Writings and studies that examine family aspects from the legislative
perspective began around the year 1960 with the writings of Ahmad Ibrahim
and Mehrun Siraj. Their writings refer to the implementation of family laws
that were in turn provided through the Islamic Administrative Law. One
example is the late Professor Ahmad Ibrahim’s book, The Status of Muslim
Women in Family law in Malaysia, Singapore and Brunei (1965). In this
book, the writer discusses the question of the status of women in family law
according to the Islamic Administration Enactment, which was in force at that
time. The Enactment advocated that several aspects of family law needed to
be rectified. The author concludes that the provisions related to the family in
this Administration Enactment were too brief. Hence, he suggests the
inclusion of provisions such as the minimum age for marriage, rules in respect
of polygamy, registration of marriages and divorces, reasons for fasakh
(judicial dissolution) that should be expanded, and most important, the
creation of a law that is uniform for the entire country in Malaysia. Even
though this book discusses the status of women in the legislative perspective,
it is apparent that there are many shortfalls from its family provisions in
guaranteeing the position of women in terms of legislation.
1
Ahmad Ibrahim 1964, 48.
2
Nurhalim Ibrahim (1993).
3
Azizah Kassim 1992, 28.
4
Durrishah Idrus 1990, 43.
5
Maxwell 1884, 75.
6
Mehrun Siraj 1963, 148-159.
2007] RAIHANA ABDULLAH 519
Ahmad first book was entitled Islamic Law in Malaya (1965). It not
only discusses Islamic family law, but also other aspects of Islamic law,
namely criminal law, evidence, and property. In his discussion of family law,
there is not much difference with his earlier text, The Status of Muslim
Women in Family Law in Malaysia, Singapore and Brunei. Other than Ibrihim
and Siraj, there are few writings at that time that address the law of marriage
and divorce.
The Islamic Family Law Enactment in its new form is distinct from
the Administration of Islamic Law Enactment; thus, there have been many
writings and studies that discuss the newer Islamic family law. The scholarly
literature still maintains the legislative analysis form, whether on the
development of law or even specific aspects in the Islamic Family law.
Several writings have analyzed the latest developments and refer to the
legislation of the Islamic Family Enactment in every state. In his writings,
Mehrun Siraj asserts that legislation around the 1980s represented a big step
towards strengthening the administration of the Islamic family law. Several
other writers were of the same view.7 They welcomed legislation related to
Islamic family law and concluded that it would remedy the administration and
in some way the position of women, in Islamic family law. This writing
touched on the provisions available in the enactment of the Islamic family
law.
7
See, e.g., Mehrun Siraj Marriage and Divotce – the Law Applicable to Muslims
in Selangor and the Federal Territory, MALAYAN L.J. lxxiv-lxxx (1988).
8
Abdul Kadir Muhammad, Poligami Dan Pengamalannya Di Malaysia
[Polygamy and its Practice in Malaysia], In UNDANG-UNDANG ISLAM DI
MAHKAMAH-MAHKAMAH SYARIAH DI MALAYSIA [Islamic Law in Sharia Courts in
Malaysia] 84-92, (Ahmad Hidayat Buang ed., 1998).
9
Ahmad Ibrahim 1980.
10
Abdul Kadir Muhammad 1996, 85.
520 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF LEGAL INFORMATION [Vol. 35.3
book was due to the request for a course offered by the Law Faculty,
University Malaya. Its contents do not differ much greatly from the Malay
and English versions except that it updates the reported cases, as there have
been no later developments in the amendments of both family laws for
Muslims or non-Muslims.
The scholarship on Islamic family law can be divided into two forms:
1. themes and aspects;
2. approach and analysis.
In most instances, Islamic Family laws are not limited to matters such as
marriage, divorce, polygamy, history, or custom. In examining these matters
almost all writings and studies use the legalistic approach.20 The earliest
writing using this approach is entitled The Status of Muslim Women in Family
law in Malaysia, Singapore and Brunei (1965) written by the late Prof.
Ahmad Ibrahim. This volume covers most aspects of Islamic Law in
Malaysia, and to a lesser extent, touches on the Islamic Administrative Law
Enactment.
19
Mahmood Zuhdi Abdul Majid & Raihanah Azahari, 1989.
20
Ahmad Ibrahim, 1997.
21
Sharifah Zaleha Syed Hassan, 1986.
522 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF LEGAL INFORMATION [Vol. 35.3
development of the law enforced. There is a relation between the law and
social changes.22 From this perspective, the law is one agent of social change
or social engineering. For example, the study by Jones found that the divorce
and marriage rate appeared to decline, especially compared with the years
prior to the implementation of the Islamic Family Law Enactments.
Towards the end of the 1990s and in the early 2000s, the literature is
more inclined to the settlement of several problems that arose from the
implementation of the Islamic Family Law in the Shariah court. Issues related
to the delay in resolving family cases23 most certainly have been deemed as
discriminatory against women.24 Additionally, family cases as well as female
judges hearing these cases have all drawn the attention of researchers.25 The
approach used by them is in the form of socio-legal perspective, which not
only discusses on the implementation of the law but also discussed its social
implications. The prevailing theme in newer research indicates that Shariah
court administration continues to contribute heavily to discriminatory
decisions against women. Hence, amendments to several provisions of the
Islamic Family Law need to be made forthwith, and the effort to unify the
Islamic Family Law should also be realized.26
22
G.W. Jones, 1994.
23
Zaleha Kamaruddin, 1999, 95.
24
Maznah Mohamad, 1999, 237-262.
25
Rozi Bainun, 1999.
26
Maznah Mohamad, 1999, 60-76.
27
Ghazali Abdul Rahmn, 1999, 151.
2007] RAIHANA ABDULLAH 523
Conclusion
28
Ahmad Hidayat Buang, 1997, 35.
29
Nik Noriani Nik Badli Shah, 2000.
30
Zuryati Muhamed Yusoff, 2004, 17-31.
31
Raihanah Abdullah and Sharifah Zahrah Syed Mohamd, 1998, 93.
524 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF LEGAL INFORMATION [Vol. 35.3
The Islamic Family Law today not only touches on the requirements
of marriage and divorce in the classical Islamic law, but also involves matters
pertaining to administration. It also encompasses the protections and the
rights of wives and children. Based on current developments, studies and
writings focus more on current issues pertaining to the familial environment
and phenomena that occurs in the Islamic family law itself. This may be seen
for example in issues pertaining to the delay of cases in the Shariah Court and
its effect on women and children, discrimination against women and children,
issues pertaining to procedures and evidence and also pertaining to family
properties – all which begin from matters in relation to Islamic family law.
Other issues ranging from divorce through text messages, proof and
enforcement of maintenance, triple divorce, polygamous marriages, and
custody of children from parents of different religions, and bio-medicine
issues continue to be important topics of scholarship and discussion.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Ali, Mohd Din. “Malay Customary Law and the Family” dalam
David Buxbaum, Family Law and Customary Law in Asia: A Contemporary
Legal Perspective, 179. The Hague, 1964.
Diah, Mohd Shahrizad Mohd. The Legal and Social Issues of Wife
Battering and Marital Rape in Malaysia. Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka: Kuala
Lumpur, 1996.
Ikhsan, Abu Naim bin Haji. “Kaedah Perceraian Khul’ atau Tebus
Talak.” (Procedure of Khulu`) Jurnal Hukum XXII, no. II (2006).
---. (ed). Islamic Family Law: New Challenges in the 21st Century.
Kuala Lumpur: Research Centre, International Islamic University, Malaysia,
2004.
Maxwell, W.E. “The Law and Customs of the Malay with Reference
to the Tenure of Land”. JSBRS (1884): 75.
Shah, Nik Noriani Nik Badli. Marriage and Divorce: Law Reform
Within Islamic Framework. International Law Book Services: Kuala Lumpur,
2000.
---. “The Shariah Courts and Its Control of the Divorce Rate”. Malaya
Law Review 5, no.1 (1963):148-159.
---. Malay Peasant Society in Jelebu. The Anthlone Press: New York,
1960.
Zin, Najibah Mohd, “For the Best Interest of the Child: The Impact
on the New Approach of Custody Order in Malaysian Legislation”, IIUM
Law Journal, 11, no.1 (2003): 63-81.
---, “How the Best Interests of the Child is Best Served in Islamic
Law with Special Reference to Its Application in the Malaysian Shariah
Court”, Jurnal Undang-undang IKIM 9, no.1 (2005): 323-347.