NAME - Definition of Death: Mistakes Are Made!!
NAME - Definition of Death: Mistakes Are Made!!
NAME - Definition of Death: Mistakes Are Made!!
DEFINITION OF DEATH
LECTURE OUTLINE
II. People are thought to be ALIVE but are really DEAD !!!
This can happen anywhere but primarily in New York State. Due
to:
Ignorance- NO , Seldom
Carelessness- NO , Highly Unlikely
1
Possible Motives:
==============================================
=========
2
OVERVIEW
DEATH
BRAIN DEATH (avoid this phrase)
COMA
IRREVERSIBLE COMA
PERSISTENT VEGETATIVE STATE (PVS)
==============================================
===================
CENTRAL CONFLICT
-----------------------------------------------------------------
A. Lung / Heart Functioning vs Brain
Lower Brain cerebellum
Upper Brain cerebrum
Whole Brain -including brain stem
Neo-Cortex
Consciousness
==============================================
===================
B. Use of Upper Brain Only
anencephalic neonates - Are they dead or alive?
Advocates for treating them as dead; e.g., Loma Linda Medical Center
(CA)
==============================================
===================
C. Use of Heart Only
3
What is death? When is death?
When there is agreement about item (1) then society leaves the rest to physicians to determine.
When there is little or no agreement about (1) then society leaves only items 3-5 to physicians.
COMA
Is coma=DEATH
4
Definition of COMA
Longest coma
Types of coma
Reversible
Irreversible
Definitions of death
a. Social
b. Psychological
c. Economic
d. Theological
e. Philosophical
f. Biological
g. LEGAL
LEGAL Definition
Black’s Legal Dictionary
Old Definition
New Definition
Medical Definition
5
Old way to settle the issue: run a contest!
The contemporary way to address the problem: set up a committee to study it.
No motion
No Responses
No spontaneous breathing
Flat or Isoelectric EEG Reading
2 exceptions
Central Nervous system depressants
Hypothermia
Revision (1977) repeat check for signs after 12 hours
Philosophical Considerations
Robert Veatch-
7
LEGISLATIVE OPTIONS
Determination of death
The law generally supports customary medical practice and provides the medical profession with a
great deal of autonomy. A dramatic example is the determination of death and the issuance of a
death certificate. In almost every country of the world a physician declares a person dead and
issues a death certificate after a determination of death is made in accordance with accepted
medical standards. A question that recently appeared was whether physicians should continue to
be given the authority to declare a person dead if the medical profession were to adopt whole
brain death as an acceptable definition of death (instead of the past definition of irreversible
cessation of respiration and heartbeat). A mechanical respirator can artificially maintain the
respiration and circulation of a person whose functions would cease without such mechanical
support. In the late 1960s the potentials of organ transplantation from such persons were
becoming realized, and the seeming futility of devoting limited medical resources to maintaining
circulation under such circumstances was of growing concern. Physicians began proposing that
irreversible cessation of brain activity be used as an alternative definition of death.
Since that time, most Western countries have adopted a revised definition, by either continuing to
permit physicians to declare death, passing a specific statute endorsing this brain oriented
definition, or issuing court opinions giving approval to physicians' declarations of death in such
circumstances. The law, in short, has continued to defer to medical practice in the definition of
death itself.
NEW YORK is the only State NOT to specifically recognize Irreversible COMA .Several groups
are advocating a change in the law to move from brain criteria back to the heart and lung criteria.
The countries that have not adopted brain oriented death criteria have not done so primarily for
cultural and religious reasons. For example, Japan has refused to adopt a brain-based definition of
death in part because it would conflict with religious tenets that require the death of all major
organs prior to a pronouncement of death. Accordingly, such medical techniques as heart
transplantation cannot be performed in Japan (or in any country that does not accept a brain-
death definition).
Harvesting a beating heart from a person is considered in such countries to be homicide, even
though brain activity has ceased and respiration is being maintained artificially.
In the meantime be cautious of medical personnel using the terms "coma" and "brain
death". Ask for clarification and critical testing.