Finding a Place: Nigerian Artists in the Contemporary Art World

Author(s): Olu Oguibe

Source: Art Journal, Vol. 58, No. 2 (Summer, 1999), pp. 30-41
Published by: CAA
Stable URL: https://www.jstor.org/stable/777946
Accessed: 23-07-2019 11:35 UTC

JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.

Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms

CAA is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Art Journal

This content downloaded from 86.12.163.50 on Tue, 23 Jul 2019 11:35:33 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
 IN

H P IN oB

0 LAN Ih03

Aw M mS

This content downloaded from 86.12.163.50 on Tue, 23 Jul 2019 11:35:33 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
 In the late 198os a new generation of Nigerian artists began to register their
presence in the art world, especially in the metropolises of the West. They
include Sokari Douglas Camp and the late Rotimi Fani-Kayode, both of whom
had immigrated from Nigeria to the United Kingdom. In the 199os others
have come to prominence, also. These include Osi Audu, Oladeile Bamgboy6,
Mary Evans, Donald Odita, Chris Ofili, Folake Shoga, Yinka Shonibare, Ike
Ude, and myself. Works by these
Olu Oguibe artists have found their way into
international biennials, group exhi-
bitions, and other forums. Likewise,
Finding a Place: scholars, critics, and other writers

Nigerian Artists in the Contemporary in Africa, Europe, and the Americas

have begun to write about the work
Art World of these artists with increasing fre-
quency. Conversant with the tech-
niques and discourses of new forms,
and versatile in the requisite politics of the international mainstream, these
artists envision themselves and their practice alongside their contemporaries
from other parts of the world.
Although most of these artists were born and raised in Nigeria, all live
in expatriation as part of the culture of itineracy which marks the end of the
twentieth century.' Some were taken abroad at a young age by their parents.
Others left in their late teens for higher education. Still others left the country
either as children or adults, to avoid civil strife or political persecution, espe
cially in the late i960s, during the bitter civil war of 1967-70, which displace
hundreds of thousands of Nigerians, and in the i98os, when military dictator
ships came to power. In all instances, however, the artists have maintained
close ties with Nigeria, most of them visiting regularly, or returning at some
stage in their lives to visit or study.
Whatever the circumstances of their relocation to the West, expatriation
has accorded these artists greater opportunities to penetrate and navigate the
insular world of the international contemporary mainstream. The fact that
some of them have studied in the dominant centers of contemporary art,
especially New York and London, for example, has accorded them access to
specific conventions, spaces, curators, and critics. They also understand and
have increasingly mastered strategies of alignment and positioning without
which their presence in the West would have no significant positive effect
on their careers. In addition, they exhibit the patience and dedication require
to forge the alliances that have enhanced their professional opportunities. Las
but not least is their determination to achieve visibility-to forge a career in
4. Ike Ude. Cond6 Nast
the center rather than to accept the limitations of the periphery.
Traveler, 1994. From
the series Cover Girl. If location, access, familiarity with prevailing discourses and preoccupa-
Cibachrome. 8X x II X tions, and strategic alignments are crucial factors in the efforts of these artists
(22 x 29.2) Courtesy
the artist. to find a place within the contemporary mainstream, the emergence of an
equally new generation of forward-looking curators and critics has also made
a significant difference. In the past decade such power brokers have caused a
I. For a detailed discussion of this condition, see
Olu Oguibe, Cross/ing: Time.Space.Movement, exh. growing fault in what for long remained a stolid, almost impregnable wall of
cat. (Santa Monica: Smart Art Press, 1998). exclusion. With the subsidence of the museum as an all-powerful institution,

3 I art journal

This content downloaded from 86.12.163.50 on Tue, 23 Jul 2019 11:35:33 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
 there has been a shift in favor of the independent curator, whose allegiances
are more ambivalent and flexible. Such curators, working under less institu-
tional pressure, have proved more willing to experiment and to initiate cross-
cultural collaborations. In the 198os and 199os, also, segregationist positions in
the centers of contemporary cultural practice came under increasing scrutiny,
for which an entire contingent of non-Western scholars, artists, and critics
must be partly credited.2
Consequently, a more international awareness has begun to emerge
among certain curators, critics, and administrators, with the result that plat-
forms that for long remained bastions of Western exclusivity are beginning
to open up, albeit ever so cautiously, to artists from the non-Western world.
In the 199os, particularly, independent curators and critics such as Octavio
and Antonio Zaya from Spain; Rasheed Araeen, Jean Fisher, and Sean Cubitt
from England; Adelina von Furstenberg from Switzerland; Peter Weibel from
Austria; Guillermo Santamarina from Mexico; and others have in different
ways expanded opportunities for non-Western artists to get a foot in the
door of the international mainstream. By offering such artists opportunities
to exhibit their work alongside their Western contemporaries or by bringing
critical attention to them and their work, this generation of curators con-
tributes to an environment in which contemporary artists from around the
world may aspire for visibility.
Perhaps even more decisive is the emergence of Nigerian and other
African practitioners within this cadre. In an era that some have described as
the Curator's Moment, the progress of a number of Nigerian artists on the
international contemporary art scene owes significantly to the increasing influ-
ence of individuals such as the Nigerian-born, New York-based curator
Okwui Enwezor. In 1994 Enwezor founded Nka: Journal of Contemporary African
Art, which is now published by the Africana Studies and Research Center at
Cornell University. This journal has not only brought relative visibility to a
number of African artists and initiated serious discourse on contemporary
African art, it has also attracted many important critics, thus creating a forum
for dialogue. Enwezor was also artistic director of the Second Johannesburg
Biennale in 1997-the first black African to serve as artistic director of a
major international biennial; in 1998 he was appointed the artistic director
of Documenta XI. Through his curatorial work and his writing, he has show-
cased the work of artists such as Bamgboy6, Fani-Kayode, Odita, Shonibare,
and Udi, among others, placing them alongside their contemporaries from
other parts of the world. He and others have questioned how the condition
of diasporicity has remapped the global terrain of contemporary culture by
questioning hegemonic concepts of ethnicity, nationality, and authenticity,
of center and periphery.

2. It was with the intention to provide a shared Sokari Douglas Camp made her mark on the British art scene in the 198os
platform for such scrutiny that the Tate Gallery in with her large-scale, motorized sculptures. Born in Buguma on the Niger Delta
London, in collaboration with the Institute of
International Visual Arts (inlVA) hosted a sympo- in 1958, she moved to England as a teenager, where she was raised by her
sium on internationalism in 1994. For debates that brother-in-law, the anthropologist Robin Horton. In the 197os, she moved to
emerged from the symposium, see Global Visions:
Toward a New Internationalism in the Visual Arts, ed.
San Francisco, where she studied briefly at the California College of Arts and
Jean Fisher (London: Kala Press/inlVA, 1994). Crafts, before returning to England to enroll at the prestigious Central School

32 SUMMER 1999

This content downloaded from 86.12.163.50 on Tue, 23 Jul 2019 11:35:33 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
 at St. Martins in London, from
which she graduated in 1984. In
between her travels abroad, Douglas
Camp spent periods in Nigeria,
during which she studied with the
Yoruba master sculptor Lamidi
Fakeye. In Nigeria, she also came
under the mentorship of the choreo-
grapher and dance scholar Peggy
Harper. Through Harper she made
the acquaintance of the Austrian
sculptor Suzanne Wenger, matron of
the Oshogbo school, which thrived
in Nigeria in the i96os.
Alali Aru, one of Douglas Camp's
earliest works, is a sculptural inter-
pretation of a pageant float or festival
boat inspired by the annual marine
festivities of the Kalagbari group of
the Niger Delta. Although her boat is
stationary and the occupants are not
represented, Douglas Camp motor-
izes the oars, creating the illusion of
rowing. She also surrounds the boat
with an audience of stylized figures.
These she animates with a time-

based mechanism that intermittently

enables them to clap in applause.
I. Sokari Douglas Camp. This performative element, she informs us, was inspired by an encounter wit
Church Ede, 1984. Steel,
cloth, motors. 93! x I 17 x
a Yoruba priestess named Amonia Hosfall. It was Hosfall, and her experiences
104 (237.5 x 298.5 x 264.2). with Kalagbari performance arts, that encouraged her to "make things about
National Museum of African
movement and space."3 To accompany another early work, a funerary bed
Art,Washington, D.C.
Museum purchase, 96-55- I. titled Church Ede (1984) (fig. i), she created an orchestra of mechanized drum-
Photo Franko Khoury.
mers that recall examples from her culture. Among the Kalagbari, a deathbed
would be decorated with buntings and flowers for the deceased's wake. The
funeral itself would also feature drummers and dancers, among the mourners
Inspired by the death of her father, Church Ede re-creates the wake scene in
steel, without the body of the deceased, its uniqueness residing not only in
its performative kinetics, but also in its power to evoke through a stringent
poetry of absence.
Douglas Camp gave British sculpture a jerk by bringing an element of
vitality, originality, and boldness to it. Given the British taste for the lifeless
and funereal-which has triumphed in Rachel Whiteread's casts of turned-out
ghost houses and Damian Hirst's dead animals preserved in formaldehyde-
Douglas Camp's work symbolizes life, movement, elegance, inventiveness, and
technical skill. Even so, her relative visibility on the British art scene has had
3. Sokari Douglas Camp, in interview with Patricia
Ainslie, Nka: Journal of Contemporary African Art,
as much to do with the privilege of graduating from Central School and the
no. 3 (Fall-Winter 1995): 38. Royal College of Art, where she won the Henry Moore Scholarship, as with

33 art journal

This content downloaded from 86.12.163.50 on Tue, 23 Jul 2019 11:35:33 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
 .??i

4ol

Yivi

'44

b,:

NAi?

2. Sokari Douglas
the formal and Camp
iconographical attributes of her work. Also, at the beginnin
Installation view of Spiri
of her career she was keen to avoid marginalization by dissociating herself
in Steel: The Art of the
from so-called
Kalabari black exhibitions and spaces. This led to a mild controversy
Masquerade,
American Museum of
when, on the advice of her dealers, she declined to participate in the definit
Natural History, New
York, April 25, black British exhibition of the decade, The Other Story: Afro-Asian Artists in Post-
1998-january 31, 1999.? Britain, at London's Hayward Gallery in 1989.
American Museum of
Natural History. Photo J. The above notwithstanding, Douglas Camp was all but abandoned in the
Beckett.
early 199os by London's commercially driven art dealers and galleries, som
of whom apparently found her themes difficult to market. Subsequently, he
foothold on the international scene rested increasingly on the growing inte
of ethnographic and natural history museums in her work. As her sculpture
shifted away from the initial exploration of form and its possibilities, these
museums came to see her animated dancers and masqueraders as a useful
means to illustrate a make-believe, natural context for their ethnographic c
lections of African art. This was the basis for her exhibition Spirits in Steel: Th
Art of the Kalabari Masquerade at New York's American Museum of Natural Hist
in 1998 (fig. 2). This symbiosis has provided a market for Douglas Camp an
has ensured that she continues to enjoy visibility.

34 SUMMER 1999

This content downloaded from 86.12.163.50 on Tue, 23 Jul 2019 11:35:33 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
 Rotimi Fani-Kayode, certainly the most celebrated Nigerian artist of his
generation, had established himself as one of the most significant photo-based
artists in England by the time of his death in 1989 at age thirty-four. Having
left Nigeria with his family when he was eleven to escape a civil war, Fani-
Kayode grew up in England. He moved to the United States to study at
Georgetown University in Washington, D.C., and at the Pratt Institute in New
York. After he finished his studies, he returned to England. His choice of art
as a career earned the disfavor of his aristocratic father as much as did his

sexual orientation as a gay man. In an essay published in the journal Ten-8

in 1988, he aptly described himself as an outsider "on three counts": a failure
to his family, a gay man in an intolerant, black community, and a black artist
in a largely racist society.4
As the founding chair of the black photographers group, Autograph, Fani-
Kayode helped shape the discourses of race and sexuality in the visual arts in
England in the late I98os. During this period, black artists and curators chal-
lenged conventions within the British art world that denied them access and
representation. They used their work to address difficult political and historical
issues such as colonialism, British involvement in foreign countries, and lin-
3. Rotimi Fani-Kayode.
White Bouquet, 1987. gering racial intolerance in British society. Under such racially charged cir-
Gelatin silver photograph. cumstances, it was pertinent for black artists to partake in this challenge to the
Courtesy the estate of
Rotimi Fani-Kayode and establishment, but it was difficult for them to raise certain questions within
Autograph, London. their own community, especially regarding sexuality. Fani-Kayode was able to
engage both arenas, working closely
with other black artists to confront

the establishment, while addressing

black discomfort with gay sexuality.
He did not reject the mainstream
even as he critiqued it. He recog-
nized that the cracks that emerged
within it in his time were best taken

advantage of to open it up further.

In his work, Fani-Kayode com-
bined a sophisticated understanding
of the aesthetics of religious eroti-
cism with an activist devotion to the

politics of race and sexuality, which

the critic Kobena Mercer has dubbed

"eros and diaspora.)"5 In Black Male,

White Male, his portfolio from the
early and mid-i 98os, Fani-Kayode
moved between images of Yoruba
gods and devotees, such as Sonpono:
The Smallpox God (1987); seemingly profane, homoerotic images, such as Bronze
Head (1987); and direct engagements with race and homosexuality, such as the
4. Rotimi Fani-Kayode, "Traces of Ecstasy," Ten-8,
no. 28 (1988): 36. complex and partially autobiographical White Bouquet (1987) (fig. 3). In this
5. Kobena Mercer, "Eros and Diaspora," in Rotimi black-and-white photograph a white man presents a bouquet of flowers to a
Fani-Kayode and Alex Hirst, ed. Mark Sealy and
black lover. Both men are nude with their backs to the viewer. The black man
Jean Loup Pivin (Paris: Editions Revue Noire,
1997). lies on a white sofa with his face turned away in a gesture of either wrathful

35 art journal

This content downloaded from 86.12.163.50 on Tue, 23 Jul 2019 11:35:33 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
 rejection, shame, or playful coyness. While offering his present, the white
man bends his head in either penitence or a lover's romantic entreaty. Noth-
ing else is revealed, no opinion betrayed, and the viewer is left to battle with
the challenge of interpretation. As Fani-Kayode crosses the slippery terrains
of race and sexuality in White Bouquet, we find a defining element also evident
in his other works: a rhetoric of ambiguity that reminds us not only of the
highly charged nature of the discourses that he engaged and of his own loca-
tion within them, but also of his adopted guardian principle, the Yoruba deity
Esu, messenger and interpreter to the gods. In The Signifying Monkey, Henry Louis
Gates provides a long list of Esu's qualities, significant among which are "in-
dividuality, irony, indeterminacy, open-endedness, ambiguity, sexuality, dis-
ruption and reconciliation, betrayal and loyalty, encasement and rupture."6
At once the guardian of meaning and the embodiment of indeterminacy,
Esu is the divinity of the crossroads, an apropos location for a gay, black, ex-
patriate Nigerian artist living under the subtle racism of Thatcherite England.
Even Esu's sexuality, encoded in myth in the story of a maternal curse that left
him with an eternally erect penis,7 resonated with Fani-Kayode. In a number
of works he inscribed his own penis as a locus of self-definition and penance,
a trope of salvation and a curse, the ultimate crucifix. Like Esu, he proved
himself a master of the crossroads, a shrewd navigator able to create work
that takes on uncomfortable questions of race and sexuality in a manner that
implicates both his host society and the viewer-work that is nevertheless
powerful, beautiful, and engaging enough to earn the attention and respect
of his contemporaries. Although Fani-Kayode's career spanned only six years,
from 1983 to 1989, his work belongs in the canon of late twentieth-century
British art.8

Ik6 Ude, who lives and works in New York, belongs to a younger generation
of Nigerian artists who have emerged in the 199os. Born in Makurdi, Nigeria,
in the early i96os, he moved to New York in his late teens to study art. After
graduating from college in the late i98os, he began his career as a painter, but
later changed to photo-based work and installation. His installation Cover Girl
at the nonprofit gallery Exit Art/The First World in New York in i994 estab-
lished his place on the contemporary scene. In this space, he constructed a
news agent's kiosk in which he displayed mock-ups of popular magazines,
from Conde Nast Traveler to Vogue, which he designed and produced himself. On
each magazine cover, he combined images and texts that address issues rang-
ing from the absence of black faces in the mass media, to stereotyping and
the misrepresentation of people of color. Each cover addresses and challenges
a theme directly relevant to the magazine's readership. On the cover of Conde
Nast Traveler (fig. 4), for instance, he presented a popular diagrammatic image
of slaves in the body of a slave ship, buried in a background of red as if in
a sea of blood. Through this image, he displaced the magazine's association
6. Henry Louis Gates, Jr., The Signifying Monkey: A with leisure travel and pleasurable adventure with a historical reference to
Theory of African-American Literary Criticism (New
York: Oxford University Press, 1988), 6. forced relocation and cruelty.
7. See Melville J. Herskovits, Dahomey, An Ancient On his cover of Parents he presented a black nanny wheeling a white
West African Kingdom, vol. 2 (Evanston: North-
western University Press, 1967), 205-6.
child in a pram. However, rather than using the stereotype of an old and full-
8. Mercer, "Eros," 109. bodied Aunt Jemima for the nanny, he uses a young black woman in jeans

36 SUMMER 1999

This content downloaded from 86.12.163.50 on Tue, 23 Jul 2019 11:35:33 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
 and T-shirt in a modern U.S. suburb. The image of the young maid threads a
path of ambiguity, at once referencing the prevalence of cheap, Third World
5. Ik6 Ude. Uli, 1998.
C-print. 16 x 14 (40.6 x domestic labor in the contemporary United States, as well as engaging the
35.6). Courtesy the artist. complex issue of race and trust in U.S. society. Such themes have previously
been perceived as the preserve of certain sections
of the U.S. ethnic map. Though an outsider, Ude
nevertheless ventures into them, working squarely
in the terrain of the postmodern, where issues
of race, sexuality, glamour, popular culture, and
representation are broached in one fell swoop. Al-
though his use of magazine covers is not entirely
novel, what is unique is the relentlessness with
which he has used the medium to address these

themes together rather than in isolation.

In subsequent work Udd has broadened his
techniques and media to include monoprints,
photography, and body art. While his gradual
emergence in the international contemporary art
arena might be partly explained by the quality
of his work, institutional factors have also playe
a role. At different moments in his career, for
example, he has been a close acquaintance of or
collaborator with prominent artists such as Carri
Mae Weems, who once roomed with him and
in some of whose works he appears as a model,
and Lyle Ashton Harris, with whom he has colla
orated.9 He has also worked with critics such as

bell hooks and Greg Tate and entertainers such

as RuPaul and Quentin Crisp, among many other
Udd further consolidated his place on the New
York cultural scene in 1995 when he founded
the culture magazine aRude, which draws contribu
tions from established and emerging artists, crit-
ics, and literary figures. The launch of aRude was
a glamorous affair that attracted the most visible
elements of the younger generation of New York
cultural elite, with entertainment provided by
Greg Tate's jazz band, Women in Love.
Looking further toward his Nigerian heritage
in the late 199os Udd began to experiment with
uli, the ephemeral body- and mural-painting trad
tion of the Igbo people of southeastern Nigeria,
one of the country's three largest cultural groups. These impermanent, ly
designs, traditionally painted by female artists on the bodies of their clien
family members, or on houses and compound walls, were used during m
riages, memorial services, and other ritual occasions. In his works Udd pai
9. An example of their many collaborations is the
well-known work Sisterhood (1994), in which Uds
the body of a model with uli motifs and then produces a photograph of t
and Harris pose as gender-benders. decorated model (fig. 5). His motifs are loosely based on classical uli but

37 art journal

This content downloaded from 86.12.163.50 on Tue, 23 Jul 2019 11:35:33 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
 include his own innovations.

Through painting, he fully

shares the experience and
process with his sitters and
leaves them with ephemera
in the tradition of his sources,
while in the photographs he
introduces both new media

and permanence to this

experience. While the tran-
sience of uli is uncompro-
mised, its vulnerability is
nevertheless mediated.'o

Although Yinka Shonibare

was born in London of

Nigerian parents in 1962, he

grew up in Nigeria before
returning to England, where
he studied at the Byam Shaw
School of Art and then at

Goldsmiths College of the

University of London, Eng-
land's fountain of conceptual
art. Shonibare began to
exhibit his work in 1988. By
1993, when he had his first
one-person exhibition at
London's Centre 181 Gallery,
he had already participated
in several key group exhibi-
tions, including Interrogating
Identity, which traveled
through the United States
in i991. In 1992 Shonibare
was one of the artists in the
6.Yinka Shonibare. Victorian Barclays Young Artist Award exhibition at the Serpentine Gallery in London.
Couple, 1999. Wax printed
In 1994 he was one of five artists in Seen/Unseen, an exhibition of leading
cotton textile. Approx. 60 x
36 x 36 (153 x 92 x 92) and African artists in Britain that I curated for the Bluecoat Gallery in Liverpool.
60 x 24 x 24 (153 x 61 x 61).
He also participated in 2 out of 4 Dimensions at Centre i81.
Courtesy Stephen
Friedman Gallery, London. Shonibare's contribution to the Centre 181 exhibition was a work entitled

Double Dutch, composed of small "paintings." Some consisted of bright acrylic

on fabric; others consisted of just the fabric-Dutch wax, a popular printed
10. Other modern artists who have worked with
fabric used by millions of people across sub-Saharan Africa and increasingly
uli include Uche Okeke, Obiora Udechukwu,
Tayo Adenaike, and myself. For more information in the West among people of African descent. This fabric became a symbol
on these artists and the tradition, see Simon of nationalist revival in the wake of political independence in Africa, a sign of
Ottenberg, New Traditions from Nigeria: Seven
Artists of the Nsukka Group, exh. cat. (Washing-
the new continent, of pride and difference. Politicians discarded their Western
ton, D.C.: Smithsonian Institution Press, 1997). business suits in favor of Dutch wax jumpers and embroidered gowns. In the

38 SUMMER 1999

This content downloaded from 86.12.163.50 on Tue, 23 Jul 2019 11:35:33 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
 e~?7~

L-

bS

I-
11~

7.Yinka Shonibare. Diary of a 1970s the material made its transition into the iconography of the Black P
Victorian Dandy: 19:00 Hours, movement in the United States and Britain, and its residues are still to be
1996. Photograph. 72 x 90
(183 x 228.6). Courtesy found in such neighborhoods as Harlem in New York and Brixton in Lon
Stephen Friedman Gallery, In time tourists and exotica hunters bought into the myth of this "African
London.
fabric," with its bright, decorative patterns and flowing, open-ended form
But just how African is this fabric, this mark of African identity and b
authenticity, this cipher of uniqueness and difference? As Shonibare obser
in an essay for Seen/Unseen, the irony of this African fabric is that it is in fa
only "a colonial construction, as its origins can be traced from Indonesia
to Holland (hence Dutch Wax), to Manchester (from where it is) then sold
to Africa where indigenous variations on the fabric have been appropriated
for local use."" While for Westerners, including diaspora Africans, the ob-
vious appeal of the fabric lay in its "authenticity," Shonibare observed tha
this was only a fictive authenticity, whose functional principle was seduct
(fig. 6). By appropriating this fabric, Africans were concerned with establi
a sophisticated mark of identity that derives from the multiple, global hist
and trade routes that have given rise to Africa's modernity. The matter of
authenticity was not at all at issue, and would only arise as a figment of t
Otherizing imagination and desires of the West in search of difference.
I I.Yinka Shonibare, "Purloined Seduction," in
Olu Oguibe, Seen/Unseen, exh. cat. (Liverpool:
Shonibare was fascinated by the processes of seduction, the power of
Bluecoat Gallery, 1994), 15. fiction, and the vulnerability of desire. Double Dutch takes its title from thre

39 art journal

This content downloaded from 86.12.163.50 on Tue, 23 Jul 2019 11:35:33 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
 sources, including the British colloquialism for babble or incomprehensible
talk and the fabric's Dutch origins. In the installation, Shonibare successfully
seduced those who were attracted to the fabric because of its supposed
"African" origin. However, his formal concerns were about the meaning and
possibilities of painting at the end of the century. In the process, he drew
attention to questions of perception, the ineluctable nature of identity, and the
dangers of interpretation and mediated knowledge. He also brought ideologies
of origin and purity under crisis. If fabric produced in Indonesia, printed in
Holland, and marketed through Manchester could take on an African identity
in the minds of adept seekers of authenticity, then notions and ideologies of
authentic origin are nothing but nonsensical babble, after all.
The conceptual sophistication of Shonibare's game of seduction has
made some uncomfortable. As Mercer observes, "English critics have come
away from Shonibare's work feeling that it is not quite African enough."''
This notwithstanding, he has continued to explore seduction and inauthen-
ticity as central themes in his work. In recent installations he has created
lush, make-believe Victorian parlors into which he inserts himself as a lone,
black gentleman among white aristocrats, a character navigating the corridors
of wealth and power in an era of intolerance (fig. 7). Shonibare's new
tableaux are as fictional as they are historically grounded. His aristocratic
settings belong as much to Victorian England as to Victorian Lagos, which,
as records confirm, were not at all distinguishable one from the other.
Shonibare digs as deep into his Nigerian heritage among the nobility of
Lagos as he does into British history and eccentricities. In addition to these
sources, his work is very much informed by his own experiences as a child
in England in the i96os and as a youth growing up in the funk-culture of
urban Nigeria in the 1970s.
Shonibare is savvy and confident as he engages the spaces of the British
mainstream, counting as much on his familiarity with it as on his sound
grounding in contemporary Nigerian culture. At Goldsmiths College he
became proficient in visual languages and discourses in the traditions of
Conceptual and postmodern art, the core of his installations and projects,
which in turn has made his work viable on the international scene. As

a young artist brought up in the center, he ridicules demands for ethnic

authenticity on his part, being no less British or Nigerian by fact of his
ancestry or location. Nonetheless, he navigates that center with a strong
awareness of the disadvantages that accrue from the fact of that ancestry,
and the strength that it brings to his work.
It is tempting for those unfamiliar with the work of these artists to imag-
ine that because they operate within the space of the international mainstream,
their art must be different and distanced from their heritage. Likewise, some
12. Kobena Mercer, "Art That Is Ethnic in Inverted
are inclined to imagine that insularity and protection from that mainstream
Commas," Frieze, no. 25 (1995).
13. Jennifer Higgie, "Chris Ofili," Frieze, no. 42 guarantee faithfulness to tradition and claim to some form of authenticity.
(September-October 1998): 86-87. Nothing could be farther from the truth. As may be gleaned from this brief
14. I have addressed the obstacles that contem-
porary artists of African origin encounter on the
discussion, rather than distance themselves from their Nigerian heritage,
international scene in my earlier essay, "Art, these artists apply their knowledge of that heritage to their work, but on
Identity, Boundaries: The Rome Lecture," Nka:
their own terms and not as a condition or imperative. It is not entirely fortu-
Journal of Contemporary African Art, no. 3
(Fall-Winter 1995): 27-33. itous that two of the artists I have mentioned, Ud& and Bamgboyi, both use

40 SUMMER 1999

This content downloaded from 86.12.163.50 on Tue, 23 Jul 2019 11:35:33 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
 orthographic signs in their names. It is a deliberate act of insistence on speci-
ficity and clear identity in the mire of a globalized world.
Even so, these artists do not perceive themselves as cultural ambassadors
any more than do their Western contemporaries. They reject the burden of
ancestry and ethnicity as a matter of fact. Having come through multiple cul-
tural circumstances, they lay claim to the entirety of their experiences and
consider themselves as much part of their societies of relocation as any others.
Among their contemporaries, they suffer the peculiar affliction of never being
discussed without some reference, no matter how benign, to their "stranger"
status. Even the most sympathetic critics seem unable to avoid references to
ethnicity when discussing their work. In an otherwise sympathetic review
in Frieze in 1998, for instance, Jennifer Higgie is compelled to remind us that,
though "of Nigerian descent, Chris Ofili is English [sic], and feels no more
affinity with an African aesthetic than he does with the tradition of American
or European painting."'3 Such defensiveness, which the artists themselves are
often driven to, also, is situated in the context of the inherently treacherous
and demanding nature of the terrain in which they find themselves.'4 To con-
tend with such circumstances, these artists carry with them a pronounced
sense of self-awareness and clarity, and determination to ensure that they are
at home in the world.

Olu Oguibe has taught at the University of London and as Stuart S. Golding Endowed Chair in African Art
at the University of South Florida. His books include Uzo Egonu: An African Artist in the West.

4 I art journal

This content downloaded from 86.12.163.50 on Tue, 23 Jul 2019 11:35:33 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms