Bu3 Final Case Study
Bu3 Final Case Study
BUILDING UTILITIES 3
FINAL CASE STUDY
“A REFERENCE OF ACOUSTIC DESIGN IN
ARCHITECTURAL SPACES”
1|Page
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION………………………………………………………………………………..3
SCHOOLS……………………………………………………………………………………..5-8
AUDITORIUMS, THEATRE……………………….......…………………………………10-20
CINEMA/MOVIE HOUSES……………………………….............................................20-21
SCHOOLS ………………………………………………………………………………....23-28
CONCLUSION ………………………………………………………………........................40
CONCLUSION-GENERAL…………………………………………………………………….43
REFERENCES …………………………………………………………………………………43
2|Page
INTRODUCTION
The modern science of acoustics over the last 100 years has broadly treated the spatial
aspect of sound in two contexts: propagation in a free field, and the behavior of sound
fields in enclosed spaces, the latter being the basis of what is known as architectural
acoustics. This work has resulted in a significant body of theoretical and applied
literature, including many approaches to the complex problem of modeling the
acoustical properties of actual and proposed spaces.
Although the acoustic complexity of real spaces may exhibit subtleties that require furth
er research, the general principles involved seem well established. However, the
perception of acoustic space – how we interpret sound as creating a sense of space – is
not well understood. Perhaps the greatest impediment is our reliance on visual models of
space which are relatively stable and detailed, giving us the impression that space is a
fixed entity through which we can move. The practice of architectural design is similarly
characterized by an emphasis on the visual aspects of space, with few schools until
recently giving any thought to the acoustic aspects of design. How does the auditory
perception of space differ from its visual counterpart? And how are the two related? The
most fundamental difference is that the auditory perception of space depends entirely on
time, meaning that it is in a constant state of flux. I will argue in this paper that the time
domain is central to two related aspects of auditory space – the space or “volume” within
a sound and the sense of space created by all of the sounds within a soundscape. Clearly
I am putting the emphasis on the human perception of auditory space as to how we
interpret acoustic cues, which therefore is the domain of psychoacoustics. However, my
goal is broader than that, because I will argue that the perception of acoustic space, and
our perceived orientation within it, is a central concern of acoustic ecology, an emerging
field of study whose main concern is the relation of the individual to an environment as
created by sound, and by extension, the relationship between a community and
its soundscapes.
3|Page
II. CHARACTERISTICS AND TYPE OF
ARCHITECTURE:
4|Page
INTERIOR PLANNING:
Constructing schemes of the period
styles of historic art and architecture was
a major concern of 19th century scholars
in the new and initially mostly German-
speaking field of art history. Important
writers on the broad theory of style
including Carl Friedrich von
Rumohr, Gottfried Semper, and Alois
Riegl in his Stilfragen of 1893,
with Heinrich Wölfflin and Paul
Frankl continued the debate into the 20th
century. Paul Jacobsthal and Josef Strzygowski are among the art historians who
followed Riegl in proposing grand schemes tracing the transmission of elements
of styles across great ranges in time and space. This type of art history is also
known as formalism, or the study of forms or shapes in art.
Semper, Wölfflin, and Frankl, and later Ackerman, had backgrounds in the history
of architecture, and like many other terms for period styles, "Romanesque" and
"Gothic" were initially coined to describe architectural styles, where major changes
between styles can be clearer and more easy to define, not least because style in
architecture is easier to replicate by following a set of rules than style in figurative
art such as painting. Terms originated to describe architectural periods were often
subsequently applied to other areas of the visual arts, and then more widely still to
music, literature and the general culture. In architecture stylistic change often
follows, and is made possible by, the discovery of new techniques or materials,
from the Gothic rib vault to modern metal and reinforced concrete construction. A
major area of debate in both art history and archaeology has been the extent to
which stylistic change in other fields like painting or pottery is also a response to
new technical possibilities, or has its own impetus to develop (the kunstwollen of
Riegl), or changes in response to social and economic factors affecting patronage
and the conditions of the artist, as current thinking tends to emphasize, using less
rigid versions of Marxistart history.
Although style was well-established as a central component of art historical
analysis, seeing it as the over-riding factor in art history had fallen out of fashion
by World War II, as other ways of looking at art were developing, and a reaction
against the emphasis on style developing; for Svetlana Alpers, "the normal
invocation of style in art history is a depressing affair indeed". According to James
Elkins "In the later 20th century criticisms of style were aimed at further reducing
the Hegelian elements of the concept while retaining it in a form that could be more
easily controlled".
5|Page
“A REFERENCE OF ACOUSTIC DESIGN ARCHITECTURAL SPACES”
1. Schools:
These requirements apply to the design of brand new classrooms or learning spaces of
small-to-moderate size, and to renovated spaces.
When we look at the numbers, though, you’ll see that most classrooms have noise levels
that more than exceed the recommended maximum level. Average noise levels in most
classrooms can range between 66 decibels (dB) and 94dB, and one 2001 study found
6|Page
that average classroom noise levels were 72dB
— similar to standing next to a busy intersection.
(Source)
The ANSI standard is voluntary, unless otherwise
specified by a school system or other
regulations. Several schools across the US now
voluntarily comply with the ANSI standards for
noise in classroom settings. Connecticut and
Minnesota, as well as New York City public
schools have adopted the ANSI standards
across the board. Additionally, the New
Hampshire Department of Education, the Ohio School Facility Commission, and the New
Jersey School Construction Board have accepted the ANSI rule as their standard for
acoustic design in classrooms.
Many school districts, including those in New York, Los Angeles, and Washington D.C.
have developed their own directives for acoustic design standards.
Although these standards are currently voluntary, if you’re in the process of developing a
design for educational spaces, we recommend you consider these as the minimum
standard. How your project performs once it’s inhabited by students is just as important
as the end visual result.
Architects and Acoustics: Improving Classrooms
at the Design Phase
The State of Texas is pushing to improve
acoustics in classrooms, starting at the
architectural design phase.
In Texas, 64 architects focused on school design
participated in a research study via the ASHA to
explore how architects employ acoustic design in
schools. The goal of the study was to find a way
to include acoustic performance criteria for
classrooms, which is omitted from the
Architectural Barriers Act and is currently voluntary. From the survey of these architects,
several key elements of design were highlighted to help create the perfect learning
environment, including:
knowledge of acoustical performance criteria for learning environments
practices they, as architects, employed to address acoustics in their design
attitudes around the earlier published version of the ANSI standard
The survey found, however, that only one-third of the architects were actually aware of
the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) standard for hearing, despite the
negative effects they perceived in learning environments where acoustics didn’t meet
standards.
By educating architects and designers about these acoustic design standards, any
architect would be better prepared to design a better, more acoustically sound learning
environment.
Green Street Academy: Sustainably Built and Acoustically Sound
7|Page
Architects looking for ways to improve acoustic
design might also look to Baltimore, Maryland
for an excellent case study of creating proper
acoustic design in a historical building .
The Green Street Academy (GSA) is public
charter school in Baltimore, Maryland providing
an education for middle and high school
students. The GSA has been certified as a
LEED BD+C school since 2009, achieving
LEED Platinum status in 2016. This is the
highest possible ranking under the LEED
stature, and the school has plenty to show for it.
2. Offices/Conference Room:
8|Page
and wood. In the minds of a manufacturer like
Hunter Douglas, the architect should think
about the different tonalities that might
permeate throughout their proposed design
before beginning each project.
“The needs of the users must be integrated
into the design,” they said. “We ask whether
the objective is to reduce sound reverberation
within the space or to reduce transmitted noise
from room to room.”
Ecoustic Veneer by Unika Vaev
Once the design team answers this question,
it’s easier to determine which acoustic solution will best fit a particular project.
The Ceilings & Interior Systems Construction Association (CISCA) suggests that
addressing several different work modes within a singular design is the key to creating
comfortable sound within a massive space.
These three plans can help you decide which
work zones need to stay silent and which ones
should sound busy.
Open Plan: Designing for Focus
In areas where employees will be completing
assignments solo, noise distraction must be
nearly null. Architects should consider a ceiling
or wall solution with a high NRC (Noise
Reduction Coefficient) rating and a moderate
CAC (Ceiling Attenuation Class).
SoftGrid by Arktura
9|Page
loud noises sound even louder. If this type of
look is integral to a project’s overall design,
then the architect should consider using even
higher quality products on the ceilings and
walls — ones that don’t take away from the
edgy design but rather enhance it — to
mitigate the noise.
Soft Sound by Arktura
According to a 2014 study conducted by
Steelcase and Ipsos, workers lose an
average of 86 minutes per day due to noise
distractions. With major tech
companies like Facebook going all-in on the open office plan in their most recent
company constructions, it’s unlikely that this workplace design trend is going away
anytime soon. For now, architects have to figure out how
to ideally configure a large space to suit different types of work styles.
After all, in a way, work is synonymous with focusing, whether that’s in a group setting
or not. It’s the architect’s job to design for focus so that the client can get the most out of
both their work-space and their employees. It all starts with acoustics.
3. Auditoriums Theatre
Performance Type
The Essential Question: What is the
primary type of performance that
audiences will see here?
Every performance type has specific
geometries that support not only the
staged performance, but also the
audience’s experience. The first step to
designing an auditorium is to become
clear about what kinds of performances
will happen, and what the audience’s
experience of those performances should
be.
Theatre and Dance performances, for
example, are usually most successful in a
room that provides a sense of intimacy
and immediacy. With these performance
types, the audience is close and tight to
the stage so they can experience the immediacy of the performance. The overall physical
volume and acoustics of a drama room are controlled so that the room supports the
performance with little or no direct amplification. A dance theatre can use amplified or live
acoustic music, and may require more variable control of the acoustical environment.
10 | P a g e
Conversely, live acoustical music performances are most successful in a room that has
volume and some reverberance, allowing music to reflect, bounce, and fill the room.
Audiences enjoy being close to this type of performance as well, but it is less important
to be close to the stage than it is to have a high-quality aural experience from anywhere
in the room.
For musical theatre, staged concerts, and opera, a combination of theatre and live music
performance criteria are considered with the balance between immediacy and acoustic
envelopment varying based on the art form.
An auditorium often supports more than one type of performance or might need to serve
an entirely new set of criteria as our definitions of performance evolve. Indeed, as we look
to contemporary practice, new definitions of performance like “immersive” and
“experiential” theatre are being developed with greater frequency and for larger
audiences. With this in mind a multi-use venue that possesses the flexibility to support a
variety of performance types can be ideal. Solutions for a multi-use venue might include
flexible seating arrangements and stage configurations, variable acoustics, or room
divisions that alter the volume of the room for different performance types.
11 | P a g e
direct-view orientation allows for the audience to be “in conversation” with the
performance, making it easier to achieve suspension of disbelief and invest themselves
in the performance.
The size and location of sections or groups of seats will have a subtler but equally
impactful influence on the audience experience. Generally, the greater the physical
distance from the stage, the greater potential for psychological distance from a
performance. However, the shape of aisles among seated sections and the delineation
of “lower” (closer to stage) and “upper” (further from stage) areas with cross-aisles and
egress paths can help a room feel inclusive, intimate, and connected not only to the
performance, but also to other audience members within a section of seats. With this goal
in mind an actual physical and perceived psychological distance from the stage can be
mitigated by enhancing the perceived collective experience of a particular section of
seating.
When it comes to auditorium design, there are an infinite number of ways to develop the
shape of an auditorium. It’s important to keep these ideas about seat distribution and
room shaping in mind to help guide design decisions as the nuts and bolts requirements
like row depth, aisle widths, sightlines, and acoustic shapes and materials become clear.
12 | P a g e
feel dangerous, exposed, and unsettling to patrons. The addition of railings within rows
can solve the security and safety issue, but it can also psychologically distance patrons
from the performance.
It’s important to note that the sightline and room-shaping process is about balancing the
complex symbiotic relationships among the many variables that influence the room. It is
both a quantitative and a qualitative study to meet all the requirements of code and ensure
the best live experience for the audience.
Auditorium Lighting
Expert contributor: Jason Osterman of Altman Lighting
Aesthetics
Architectural Coordination
When considering auditorium design, good lighting design is always in step with a venue’s
interior design. They are symbiotic. New build venues have the luxury of developing these
designs in synchrony. However, that doesn’t mean that retrofits and refurbishments are
at a disadvantage; necessity breeds creativity. There is usually a good surface or detail
13 | P a g e
that is worth highlighting. Fundamental
concepts in architectural accent lighting
like shadow gaps, bounce lighting and
grazing are great tools to consider.
These can almost always be enhanced
by using color changing fixtures.
Opportunities for these lighting tools
can be limited in refurbishment projects
due to wiring considerations, but new
technology such as LED line voltage
dimming is helping solve these
problems. A good lighting consultant or
contractor will always understand the
architectural goal of a venue and work
to complement it using the latest tools
available.
Requirements
Code compliance
14 | P a g e
Integrating minimum illumination
standards and an emergency
lighting scheme is necessary and
should be an integrated
component of the design. It’s
possible to have a single fixture
provide all these requirements if
good coordination exists between
the architectural lighting designer
and the rest of the team.
Standards vary between locales so
getting a consultant or contractor
who understands these
requirements is crucial. It is worth
noting though that sometimes a totally separate system is more preferable. This can often
be the case with refurbishments and retro-fits as the emergency lighting may be adequate
and not intrusive to the design.
Maintenance
The selection of lighting fixtures should be chosen with a realistic maintenance schedule
in mind. Access to the fixtures can be difficult if they are placed in hard to reach areas.
As safety standards increase, some venues are finding that older lighting schemes are
no longer safe to maintain. Reasonable placement and access should be integrated into
the design process along with the selection of long-life sources.
The Components
Accent Lighting
Getting a quality, even illumination in the main areas of a venue is a priority, but so too is
accent lighting. Depending on the goal and resources available, this component of a
lighting scheme can vary greatly. And even on a shoe-string budget, a few nice touches
can go a long way to make an auditorium more inviting. For example, flood uplighters in
a venue with an architecturally interesting ceiling will make the venue infinitely more
inviting, and dimmable units can be used during performances.
Control and Systems Integration
15 | P a g e
Flexibility is the key when designing the control system. Normally, a venue will have a
programmable lighting control console to operate the performance lighting, and then a
separate architectural control system. Typically, it is best for the performance lighting
system to control the auditorium lighting as it needs to be controlled in a comparable way
to ensure the smooth transition from “pre-show” to performance. This system needs to be
both powerful (to operate performance lighting in an effective way) and flexible (to enable
a “lights on” state for a janitor or director to operate).
Complications can arise when the venue lighting is expected to be controlled from both
systems. The integration of the two systems can be complex, both in terms of programing
and physical wiring. However, a competent lighting consultant or contractor should be
able to help with simplifying the design and instructing the build process.
In Conclusion
The old adage, “you get what you pay for” is true for auditorium lighting, but equally
important is the preparation and design work that goes into a great lighting design.
Choosing the right fixtures and enlisting the help of professionals will always pay for itself
many times over, and with the right planning and equipment, an auditorium lighting
scheme can last for decades.
Stage Design
Expert contributor: Staging Concepts
16 | P a g e
products since they are designed with safety in mind first and foremost, but are often used
in tight or confined spaces. This can make setup and tear down physically demanding.
The project coordinator can help these procedures and the end-user, by changing the
system based on his or her understanding of the entire environment the system is setup
in.
The finishes of the platforms and guardrail must meet the aesthetics of the space.
Think through the details of the design of guardrails, the platform surfaces and
closure panel materials.
The acoustics of the space should be considered. Platforms can be designed with
acoustical damping materials to minimize footfall noise.
Storage of the space should be considered. A full service staging equipment
company can help determine the proper storage options for your space, such as
carts to facilitate easy portability, doorway widths in your space and amount of
space needed for portable platforms when they are not in use.
Equipment set up instructions and training for staff on how the risers are assembled
should be incorporated into your plan.
If you are mounting fixed seating onto platforms, you should coordinate this between the
seating provider and the platform provider to ensure that fixed seating attachments are
incorporated into the platform design. Portable chairs are easier to manage, but you may
want to consider chair stops into the seating riser system.
Aisle lighting and power sources are important to consider into the design of the seating
riser system. Seating risers that are flexible and can be used in multiple configurations
can make your space more usable, but also require extra planning up front, so staging
platforms and equipment can be reused for various set ups and efficiently deployed.
Fixed Seating
Expert contributor: Theatre Solutions Inc.
17 | P a g e
fixed seating basics. Here, we’re going to give you just a summary of that information, so
read on.
Seating Basics
There’s two basic types of seating arrangements you can consider for your
auditorium: “multiple-aisle” or “continental.” Generally speaking, a continental agreement
will allow more seating in your space. Click here to view more details and to see images.
For early stage planning, you can use an average of 7.5 sq ft. per person.
When it comes to seating widths, the most common chair widths are 20 inches, 21 inches,
and 22 inches. That being said, available seat widths can range anywhere from 18 inches
to 24 inches. You’ll also want to consider the row spacing. An average minimum
dimension might be 30″, but if you space the rows at 36″ (for example) the audience’s
comfort level will increase dramatically.
We would definitely advise you to take a look at various safety and building codes such
as:
Finally, you’ll want to make sure you perform a sightline analysis to ensure that the
audience members can see everything they want to (and are supposed to) see.
Acoustics
Expert contributor: Aercoustics
18 | P a g e
space are effected by design choices that an architect would make. We will start off with
a brief description of how our ear works in the context of listening.
19 | P a g e
Shoebox-shaped rooms provide for strong early lateral reflections (even more
important for music, but quite helpful for speech as well)
Reflections down from a ceiling can often provide early reflections, and therefore
should be made acoustically hard (reflective)
The back walls of an auditorium have a risk of providing late reflections – both to
the audience and to the stage: Providing acoustic absorption at such locations is
usually helpful. This could be in the form of fabric panels, slatted wood finish,
acoustic plaster or even acoustic drywall.
The audience seats and the audience themselves are usually the biggest acoustic
absorption in the room. The use of the right amount of acoustic absorption in the
seats can serve as a great way to achieve the acoustic goals of the space.
There are, however, many other aspects of the auditorium acoustics that would require
analysis, and any space where the acoustics are critical should be analysed in more detail
for things like: the overall Reverberation time (RT60), the Distinctness (D50), the Acoustic
Strength (G) of the space, and the background noise from building services or exterior
activities. Getting an acoustic consultant to evaluate these aspects and provide suitable
solutions that fit within the architectural expression is key to arriving at a cohesive design
outcome. The best spaces are the ones where the acoustic elements fit seamlessly into
the design and the space doesn’t scream out “Acoustician was here”.
4. Cinema/Movie Houses:
Many people have had the experience of sitting in the back of a large auditorium and
being able to hear what is spoken on stage even when there is little, if any, sound
amplification. Others have been in much smaller spaces, seated much closer to a
speaker or performer, and yet have been unable to hear what is going on up front.
Why this difference? The answer lies in the acoustics of each space.
Acoustics is a science that has to do with measuring the transmission of sound waves.
Although the discipline covers waves in solids, liquids, and gases, most people are
likely familiar with acoustics through the application of the science to architecture. A
theater or other building with good acoustics allows sound to travel naturally for long
distances, enabling people to hear music, a play, or something else even if they are
sitting far away from the stage. On the other hand, buildings with poor acoustics do
not allow the sound to travel very well from one side of the space to another. No matter
how loud a performance or other event happens to be, people who are attending it will
have trouble hearing it if the acoustics are bad. A theater or other building with good
acoustics allows sound to travel naturally for long distances, enabling people to hear
music, a play, or something else even if they are sitting far away from the stage. On
the other hand, buildings with poor acoustics do not allow the sound to travel very well
from one side of the space to another. No matter how loud a performance or other
event happens to be, people who are attending it will have trouble hearing it if the
acoustics are bad.
The field of acoustics is actually one subset of the larger discipline of physics. Whether
people are enjoying a performance from the comfort of a well-designed and enclosed
20 | P a g e
auditorium or they are sitting in an outdoor theater, their ability to hear what is going
on will only be as good as the quality of the architectural acoustics and the ability to
transmit sound waves in the building or structure. Acoustics takes into account the
generation, propagation, reception, and effects of sound waves in a particular space,
and architects and builders rely on acousticians to either reduce the distance that
sound will travel or increase it. In a library, for example, an acoustician’s goal is to
minimize the transmission of sound waves so that people can study in comfort and
not get distracted. The goal is exactly the opposite in rooms that must accommodate
large crowds that are viewing a performance or lecture.
Perhaps the best way to understand acoustics in action is to consider the theaters of
ancient Greece. Thousands of years ago, there was no such thing as electronic sound
amplification, so builders had to figure out a way to build theater structures that would
allow the sound from a performance to extend all the way to the back of the Greek
amphitheaters where it was conducted. They did this by employing stepped seating
arrangements like those that are still used today for stadium seating at movie theaters
and other venues. The first row of seats was on the same level as the stage, the
second row a little higher, the third row a little higher than the second row, and so on,
all the way to the back of the theater.
Why was such stepped seating so good for theater acoustics in ancient Greece? The
answer lies in the way that sound waves bounce off of stepped or corrugated surfaces.
In such structures, low-frequency sounds are minimized.
Thus, background noise such as the breeze blowing was minimized and the sound
waves coming from the front of the theater during a performance could be heard from
the comfort of all of the rows of the theater’s seating.
Sound waves are either absorbed by the material that they strike or are reflected out,
bouncing off of a material. The key to sound acoustics is striking a balance between
construction material and layout that will allow sound waves to be absorbed or
reflected in an optimum way for the purposes of the building that is being designed.
The key is to select materials and designs that screen out the wave frequencies that
are not desired in a space while amplifying those that the space is designed for.
21 | P a g e
5. Entertainment Rooms:
Sound Movement Architectural acoustics is the process of managing how both airborne
and impact sound is transmitted – and controlled – within a building design. While virtually
every material within a room – from furniture to floor coverings to computer screens –
affects sound levels to one degree or another, wall partitions, ceiling systems and
floor/ceiling assemblies are the primary elements that designers use to control sound.
Sound moves through building spaces in a variety of ways.
Most commonly, it is transmitted through air. But wall partitions, ceilings and floor/ceiling
assemblies can also transmit both airborne sound, such as human voices and ringing
telephones, and impact sound, such as footsteps on a floor. Sound waves actually travel
through many physical objects faster and with less loss of energy than they travel through
air. Sound waves travel at a rate of 1,128 feet per second through air (at 70 degrees F);
11,700 feet per second through wood; and 18,000 feet per second through steel. Sound
reflection occurs when sound waves bounce off smooth, hard wall, ceiling and floor
surfaces.
Concave surfaces tend to concentrate or focus reflected sound in one area.
22 | P a g e
Convex surfaces do just the opposite; they tend to disperse sound in multiple directions.
Sound reverberation is the persistence of sound reflection after the source of the sound
has ceased.
Reverberation can have both a positive and negative effect in architectural design. For
example, specifying highly reflective ceiling panels directly above the stage area in an
auditorium will help direct sound toward specific seating areas, thus enhancing the room’s
acoustical performance. However, that same reflective performance will become a
negative factor if highly reflective wall and ceiling materials are installed in the rear of the
auditorium. That’s because the sound reflections from the rear of the room take too long
to reach the audience, resulting in a distracting echo effect.
Sound can also diffract, or bend and flow around an object or through a small space or
opening. This gives sound waves the ability to “squeeze” through very small openings
with little loss of energy. The small openings under and around doors, floor tracks,
electrical boxes and conduit and HVAC ducting are typical sources of sound diffraction.
These are commonly referred to as “flanking” or “leaking” paths. They can be controlled
by the proper application of acoustical sealant.
SCHOOL
CHARACTERISTICS
PARAMETERS
BUILDING FUNCTION/SPACE:
Schools get built for many reasons.
Accepting on face value that we build
schools to provide buildings for schooling
quickly becomes circular and banal. One
way we can break that circle is to look at the
reasons governments give for building
schools. That helps because it makes
explicit something of what schools are
expected to do.
It isn’t perfect – governments claim many things – but it usefully illustrates the great range
of motivations for buildings schools. As will become clear, it also shows how enmeshed
schools are in our lives – their role in the economy, in shaping urban planning, as means
of gaining political support, in reforming education, in attempting improvements to social
justice and so forth.
23 | P a g e
Education Reform
Rome, Italy: A competition held over 2004/5 for three new schools in Rome was prefaced
by the (then) Mayor, Walter Veltroni, arguing for schools as a means to bring ‘great
architecture’ (cited in Capanna, 2005:73) to the neglected suburbs in order ‘overturn
hierarchies that might correspond to our idea of a more balanced, cohesive, open and
calm city’ (ibid:77).
Australia: The Building the Education Revolution programme launched quickly in 2009
during the global financial crisis as part of the government’s $AUS42 billion Nation
Building and Jobs Plan, where the ‘overriding goal … was to stimulate aggregate demand
by employing workers in the sagging construction sector’ (Parker and Cahill, 2017:261).
(The Parker and Cahill paper is excellent by the way, exemplary political analysis of public
policy and financing.)
England: One of the aims of BSF was to ‘reposition schools at the heart of communities’
(Department for Children, Schools and Families et al., 2008:5).
Cambridgeshire, England / Istres, France: I mention these two just to provide a little
historical context. The Cambridgeshire Village Colleges built in the 1930s are definitely
worth looking at – in part they were a way to re-value rural areas (with respect to urban
ones) and took the community rather than a particular age group of young people to be
the social/demographic/educational focus and the village college as the means to house
and celebrate that. This article in the Guardian provides a good and quick overview on
their educational and architectural visions. Forty years later, the Centre Éducatif et
Culturel “Les Heures Claires” near Marseille recalled many of the core concepts of the
village colleges e.g. a broad education in the heart of the community, for all ages – an
educational village. Note also how the design prefigured what are commonly cited as
uniquely 21st century concerns: in the words of the architects, this would be “an open
school”, “necessary in a society affected by rapid change” which was “the result of great
complexity” cited in Blain and Borruey, 2007:104.
24 | P a g e
The above list is just a beginning and I will add to it over time. However, even these few
statements raise some points that are worth a little more discussion. (The following are
notes but I will try at a later date to write these up more formally.)
– How the purposes of schools and schooling are studied is complex and necessarily
spills over into many disciplines: planning; social policy; economics; art; and of course,
architecture and education. It also changes over time in that the purpose(s) of building a
school is likely to be different from the purpose(s) of a school once built. However, see
De Carlo, below – they are clearly related.
– The question “Why do schools get built?” is important in and of itself. However, it is
often eclipsed by “Why do schools get built in the way that they do?” which is also
interesting but a different question that perhaps helps us to forget what schooling is for.
Schooling just is: naturalised and so taken for granted. This is why I keep returning to the
architect Giancarlo De Carlo’s provocative line of thinking: “We cannot deal with problems
of ‘how to’ [build] without first posing the problems of ‘why’. If we were to begin discussing
immediately the best way to build school buildings for contemporary society without first
clarifying the reasons for which contemporary society needs school buildings, we would
run the risk of taking for granted definitions and judgements which may not make sense
anymore and our speculations would turn out to be sandcastles” (1969:12).
– Some purposes for building schools will be claimed explicitly but might be more for
public show than the existential core of school-building. Conversely, some reasons for
building schools may never be claimed since they are unpalatable – for example, schools
keep young people busy and safe in the hands of professionals allowing their parents and
carers to be active in the economy: one function of schooling is publicly-funded “baby-
sitting”. If that seems far-fetched, take a look at this article illustrating Swiss debate on
the issue.
– One way to dig into this is to make a distinction between the explicit purposes of building
schools and the functions that school buildings serve, regardless of the intentions
advertised. Purposes illustrate intent and are more likely to belong to and be articulated
explicitly by a group of (usually powerful) people [for Ackerman and other architects’ take
on this relation to schools, see this post]; functions are often less visible, less owned and
more embedded in existing histories. Purposes can be more readily ahistorical as when
people seek self-consciously innovative solutions that reject bodies of experience;
functions can’t ignore history so easily because they’re embedded, they become
sedimented over time, meshed with and adapted to other functions and the daily life of
school. Purposes are an aspirational, directing, yet-to-be-realised sub-category of
function. Purposes are a target ideally reached in a future time; functions are the current
direction of travel often regardless of destination. Purposes are always normative;
functions can be descriptive, just what happens. I suggest that the more innovative school
architecture attempts to be, the more it is likely to focus on a school’s explicit, aspirational
purpose and play down the less visible, more taken for granted functions which the school
will nevertheless have to carry out. This is potentially dangerous since if consideration of
functions is bypassed, the building will not be able to provide for those needs. This brings
25 | P a g e
us back to the necessity of understanding clearly why we are building schools and that
can only be done thoroughly and fairly through “intense and continual public dialogue
about the ends and means of schooling” as Tyack and Tobin advocate (see below). Daniel
Little writes interestingly in a post about functions, purposes and institutional change:
“Purposes have to do with the intentions of the creators or reformers of a thing; and
functions have to do with the relationship between the thing’s effects and the broader
needs of the system within which it sits”. I think this is a helpful adaptation* to Robert K.
Merton’s now old but so helpful writing on “Manifest and Latent Functions” in his 1968
book. This podcast with Meira Levinson about the Aims of Education on the Philosophy
Bites site is very good, pointing up the need to clarify ‘for whom?’ when we discuss what
schools are for. All of this takes us back to De Carlo’s Why we’re building schools and so
also who that “We” is i.e. which dimension of school buildings serves who, and how might
we be able to talk about building schools with purposes of serving more than lots of
constituencies of interests (which may be important) and of articulating, building, a
common cause.
– As a useful counterpoint to what I’ve written so far, Judith Suissa draws on anarchist
theory to offer a convincing argument against the tendency of many working in the
philosophy of education philosophy to elaborate the aims and so desirable outcomes of
an educational project. For Suissa, a useful and important view of social change is
achieved not “by working out in advance which human qualities are necessary to bring
about and … nurturing them through education but by imagining and enacting this social
world here and now in our social relationships” (2014:149). Her chapter in the edited
collection on the philosophy of education is well-worth reading, giving both a powerful
critique of the positions we normally hear about and many constructive proposals for
thinking and acting differently.
– And yet, I suggest the purpose-function distinction may also be useful to think about the
evaluation of schools – whether educationally or architecturally through exercises such
as Post Occupancy Evaluation. If neither the functions nor the purposes of schools can
be reduced to learning, then which and whose values/purposes/functions should
evaluation seek to produce information about?
– Bearing in mind what Giancarlo De Carlo, cited above, argues (the need to ask –
preferably via public discussion – what schools are for and what, in building new ones,
we are seeking to achieve) we are not doing particularly well at making explicit the implicit
work of schooling. There is, perhaps, too much work on the explicit – the aspirational
school / school design of the 21st century and so forth when we need to think more
anthropologically about schooling and school architecture. In fact, the anthropologist
might be useful here. In writing about institutions, Mary Douglas makes a number of
helpful points, all from 1986, page 92:
26 | P a g e
2. Institutions systematically direct individual memory and channel our perceptions into
forms compatible with the relations they authorize. They fix processes that are
essentially dynamic, they hide their influence…
3. …they [institutions] endow themselves with rightness…
4. For us, the hope of intellectual independence is to resist, and the necessary first step
in resistance is to discover how the institutional grip is laid upon our mind.
For similar reasons, buildings and their architecture cannot have purposes either. Rather,
groups of people may have individual and collective purposes, and architecture is simply
another tool available to help them achieve those purposes. This gets us past the “space
is an agent of change” and restores agency to people – always limited and to some extent
enabled, of course, by “how the institutional grip is laid upon our mind”.
It also brings us closer to seeing how stability and change are made possible and why,
therefore, “innovation” is so interesting and so problematic: “Humans build organizations
and can change them. Cultural constructions of schooling have changed over time and
can change again. To do this deliberately would require intense and continual public
dialogue about the ends and means of schooling, including re-examination of cultural
assumptions about what a “real school” is and what sort of improved schooling could
realize new aspirations.
LOCATION:
The geography of where schools are located and the impact of so-called
education deserts on students is the topic. “If higher education is to better serve
students and expand educational opportunities,” the paper asserts, “then
stakeholders must prioritize the importance of place and understand how it
shapes college options.”
Windows should be placed at about three and a half to four feet from the floor of
the room. The total area covered by windows should be one-sixth to one-quarter
of the area of the floor. Lighting in a room is said to be appropriate if a student
can read ordinary type at a distance of one foot from the eye in every part of the
room.
Light (room the right side casts some shadow, light from behind throws shadow
on the whole work while light coming from front side is dazzling. Dazzling and
glare-light should be avoided. The desks should be arranged in such a way that
full advantage of light coming from the left side can be reaped.
28 | P a g e
OFFICES/CONFERENCE ROOM
CHARACTERISTICS
PARAMETERS
BUILDING FUNCTION/SPACE:
A clear understanding of the functional and
physical requirements of a project is essential to
ensuring its success. A client's / owner's intent to
develop a project is derived from a need, a
purpose or mission, and a desired result. When
the design of a facility satisfies the emotional, cognitive, and cultural needs of the people
who use it and the technical requisites of the programs it houses, the project is functionally
successful. Program and functionality are also characterized by building type. A building
that functions as it is intended is the underpinning of a quality "whole" building. The
qualities of such a building may not even be noticed or recognized, but a poorly
functioning building can be costly to correct, if the opportunity to correct ever becomes
available. When designs fall short of this goal, the cost can be modest to extreme, but the
failures are generally noted more significantly than the expected successes.
Information in these Functional pages must be considered together with other design
objectives and within a total project context in order to achieve quality, high-performance
buildings.
29 | P a g e
2. Functional Quality: decisions to incorporate the use of hard walls for offices and
workspaces vs. flexible 'furniture' systems have a significant impact on functionality
of a building.
The perfect office doesn’t mean the most expensive or state-of-the-art. It simply
means the space is within your budget and is equipped with the facilities you
need to operate efficiently.
30 | P a g e
appliances will facilitate a speedy performance of office work. In this way, office
organization is based on the organized routine and procedures and continuous
flow of work.
EQUIPMENTS:
Office equipment are the asset purchased by the organization, which are used
for while working for the company. The equipment here means, tables , chairs ,
computers, etc.
Office supplies are the kind of things which are utilized on a regular basis like
stationary, simple office accessories, etc.
31 | P a g e
AUDITORIUMS, THEATRE
CHARACTERISTICS
PARAMETERS
BUILDING FUNCTION/SPACE:
The audience in a modern theatre are
usually separated from the performers by
the proscenium arch, although other types of
stageare common.
The price charged for seats in each part of
the auditorium (known in the industry as
the house) usually varies according to the
quality of the view of the stage. The seating
areas can include some or all of the following:
Balconies or galleries: one or more raised seating platforms towards the rear of the
auditorium. In larger theatres, multiple levels are stacked vertically above or behind the
stalls. The first level is usually called the dress circle or grand circle. The highest platform,
or upper circle is sometimes known as the gods, especially in large opera houses, where
the seats can be very high and a long distance from the stage.
Boxes: generally placed immediately to the front, side and above the level of the stage.
They are often separate rooms with an open viewing area which generally seat only a
handful of people. These seats are generally considered the most prestigious of the
house. A state box or royal box is sometimes provided for dignitaries.
32 | P a g e
OCCUPANTS ACTIVITY: Auditorium space types are areas for large meetings,
presentations, and performances. Auditorium space type facilities may include
assembly halls, exhibit halls, auditoriums, and theaters. Auditorium space types do
not include such features as sound reinforcement systems, audiovisual systems and
projection screens, food service facilities, proscenium stages with heights greater
than 50'– 0" or fly gallery, orchestra pits, revolving or hydraulic stage platforms, flying
balconies, movable seating, or billboard systems.
STYLE: Seating arrangement in which chairs (and tables) are arranged in rows
facing a dais or platform.
33 | P a g e
arranged to give a clear view of the stage. The walls and ceiling usually contain
concealed light and sound equipment and air extracts or inlets and may be highly
decorated.
34 | P a g e
CINEMA, MOVIE HOUSES
CHARACTERISTICS
PARAMETERS
BUILDING FUNCTION/SPACE:
A building that contains an auditorium for
viewing films (also called movies) for
entertainment. Most, but not all, theaters are
commercial operations catering to the
general public, who attend by purchasing a
ticket. Some movie theaters, however, are
operated by non-profit organizations or
societies that charge members a
membership fee to view films.
The film is projected with a movie
projector onto a large projection screen at
the front of the auditorium while the dialogue, sounds and music are played through a
number of wall-mounted speakers. Since the 1970s, subwoofers have been used for low-
pitched sounds. In the 2010s, most movie theaters are equipped for digital cinema
projection, removing the need to create and transport a physical film print on a heavy reel.
A great variety of films are shown at cinemas, ranging from animated films
to blockbusters to documentaries. The smallest movie theaters have a single viewing
room with a single screen. In the 2010s, most movie theaters have multiple screens. The
largest theater complexes, which are called multiplexes—a design developed in the US
in the 1960s—have up to thirty screens. The audience members often sit on padded
seats, which in most theaters are set on a sloped floor, with the highest part at the rear of
the theater. Movie theaters often sell soft drinks, popcorn, and candy, and some theaters
sell hot fast food. In some jurisdictions, movie theaters can be licensed to sell alcoholic
drinks.
OCCUPANTS ACTIVITY:
35 | P a g e
Group A‐2 occupancy includes assembly uses intended for food and/or drink
consumption including, but not limited to: Banquet halls; Casinos (gaming
areas); Nightclubs; Restaurants, cafeterias and similar dining facilities (including
associated commercial kitchens); Taverns and bars.
Group A‐3 occupancy includes assembly uses intended for worship, recreation
or amusement and other assembly uses not classified elsewhere in Group A
including, but not limited to: Amusement arcades; Art galleries; Bowling alleys;
Community halls; Courtrooms; Dance halls (not including food or drink
consumption); Exhibition halls; Funeral parlors; Gymnasiums (without spectator
seating); Indoor swimming pools (without spectator seating); Indoor tennis courts
(without spectator seating); Lecture halls; Libraries; Museums; Places of religious
worship; Pool and billiard parlors; Waiting areas in transportation terminals.
Group A‐4 occupancy includes assembly uses intended for viewing of indoor
sporting events and activities with spectator seating including, but not limited
to: Arenas; Skating rinks; Swimming pools; Tennis courts.
Group A‐5 occupancy includes assembly uses intended for participation in or
viewing outdoor activities including, but not limited to: Amusement park
structures; Bleachers; Grandstands; Stadiums.
LOCATION: MALLS
STYLE: An Art Deco-style bar cart in the corner is an easy yet playful touch that
will make your cinema experience feel more luxurious.
36 | P a g e
BUILDING APPEARANCE: Building appearance is of ever increasing importance
to attract and retain tenants. In an increasingly competitive leasing market, 3M
Window Films are an excellent and cost effective way to protect windows and
enhance the overall appearance of your building.
EQUIPMENTS: For design and equipment for audio, Video and 3D since 2009.
We are now catering to more than 3500 screens in and around the country for
different range of products. With all the right exposure and expertise our team
also provide customized and turnkey solutions for theatres, cinema equipment,
cinema design, and personal and commercial home theatres. Our mission and
key to our success is providing best movie going experience to end customer
(We being amongst them as well).
37 | P a g e
ENTERTAINMENT ROOMS
CHARACTERISTICS
PARAMETERS
BUILDING FUNCTION/SPACE:
OCCUPANTS ACTIVITY:
38 | P a g e
occupancies, accessory to a dwelling unit, having more than five roomers or
lodgers shall be classified as Group R‐2 or I‐1, as appropriate).
Group R‐4 occupancy shall include buildings, structures or portions thereof for
more than five but not more than 16 persons, excluding staff, who reside on a 24‐
hour basis in a supervised residential environment, receive custodial care and are
capable of slow evacuation. Buildings of Group R‐4 shall be classified as one of
the occupancy conditions specified in Section 310.6.1 or 310.6.2. This group shall
include, but not be limited to, the following: Alcohol and drug treatment centers;
Boarding houses; Group homes; Halfway houses; Residential board and care
facilities; Social rehabilitation facilities.
Group R‐5 occupancies shall include all detached one‐ and two‐family dwellings
not more than three stories in height with a separate means of egress and multiple
single‐family townhouses not more than three stories in height with a separate
means of egress designed and constructed in accordance with the International
Residential Code. This Group shall also include: Care facilities that provide
accommodations for five or fewer persons receiving care; Single residential
occupancies, accessory to a dwelling unit, having no more than five roomers or
lodgers (Single occupancies, accessory to a dwelling unit, having more than five
roomers or lodgers shall be classified as Group R‐2 or I‐1, as appropriate); Group
Homes with 5 or fewer occupants in accordance with Section 308.3.4; Rooming
houses with five or fewer residents. 2015 International Building Code [Use] Group
Occupancy Classifications.
STYLE: An Art Deco-style bar cart in the corner is an easy yet playful touch that
will make your cinema experience feel more luxurious.
CHARACTERISTICS: A game room has to have a flexible design. It’s why you
should try to include a variety of functions in one design. For example, there can
be a foosball table in the center, a table for board games, a seating area for those
that need to take a k and a variety of other features.
39 | P a g e
VENTILATION & LIGHTING: Normally very tightly sealed rooms. Although
windows are required in all rooms in a new home, in most cases mechanical
ventilation is a more suitable option than natural ventilation.
EQUIPMENTS: For design and equipment for audio, Video and 3D since 2009.
We are now catering to more than 3500 screens in and around the country for
different range of products. With all the right exposure and expertise our team
also provide customized and turnkey solutions for theatres, cinema equipment,
cinema design, and personal and commercial home theatres. Our mission and
key to our success is providing best movie going experience to end customer
(We being amongst them as well).
CONCLUSION (GENERAL)
A good acoustic design will provide a better and comfortable environment in the
mosque in term of sound audibility and speech intelligibility. Unfortunately, architects
nowadays often focus more on designing a building based on its looks or form, and the
main function of space most often neglected. The research has taken place at Masjid
Al-Hussain Kuala Perlis. The research approach includes interviews and observations
guided by the theory of affordance employed. Although the acoustic design was not that
perfect, the acoustic design is still acceptable. There is a correlation between the
acoustic designs of the mosque and the worshipers’ comfort.
Architectural acoustics is the art of achieving a good sound within a building. Based on
Wikipedia the first application of modern scientific methods to architectural acoustics
was carried out by Wallace Sabine in the Fogg. Museum lecture room. He then applied
his new found knowledge to the design of Symphony Hall in Boston. Architectural
acoustics is about achieving a good quality of speech in a theatre, improvise quality of
music in a concert hall or recording studio, or suppressing noise to make offices and
homes more comfortable and peaceful places to work and live. Nowadays, architects
have often focused on the design a beautiful mosque. Acoustic design is an important
characteristic of a mosque. A high level of quality of sound is needed for all worship
activities. Poor acoustic design in a mosque will disturb the concentration of the
worshipers. According to Khabiri et al. (2013), to ensure good listening conditions,
acoustical needs must be considered in the design phase. High-quality sound also is
vital, especially for pure tones that must be both wide and effective.
40 | P a g e
GENERAL CONCEPTS APPLIED
The study of acoustics is intrinsically architectural: sound behaves as it does
because ofthe environment in which it is heard. Much can be gained by first
understanding the basic principles of room acoustics and then being a critical
listener. In order to fully experience architecture, one must begin to view it from the
perspective of the senses. This document will address the principles of
architectural acoustics applied to community theatres as a resource for nonprofit
groups to improve their theatrical environments. Acoustics is the science of sound:
the qualities in a room that make it easy or difficult for a person in it to hear
distinctly. Leo Beranek, intemational authority on acoustics, says that: Musical
acoustics still calls upon art as well as science. The science lies in applying to the
design of new halls the known acoustical attributes derived from measures on
existing halls; and the art lies in judging and applying those acoustical attributes
that are still unmeasurable. The art of music and the science of sound must fuse if
criteria are to be established for the design of halls in which music is to be played,
since the experience of music can never be divorced from the acoustics of the
space in which it is performed.
ACOUSTICAL TREATMENTS/MATERIALS
Acoustical materials are used to control sound, whether for industrial, architectural
or studio applications. Sound control possibilities include elimination,
enhancement, diffusion and absorption, as well as a wide variety of custom
solutions. Among the materials used for these functions are polyurethane and
melamine foams, fiberglass, wood, plastic and synthetic tiles.
Noise control materials are also used in a variety of vehicles, including aircrafts,
boats and automobiles, to reduce the level of sound experienced by passengers.
Barriers, tiles, screens, baffles, blankets and sheets are all used in acoustical
control applications, often incorporating pyramids and other specialized shapes to
assist in sound reduction and dispersion. Acoustical materials can be directly
applied to facility walls and ceilings, suspended from various fixtures, or erected
around a sound source. Typically, especially in architectural and studio
applications, a complete acoustical solution involves a variety of materials and
shapes.
41 | P a g e
Proper installation is equally important to proper selection of materials, and various
consultation and installation services are also available. Materials are rated with
various noise reduction capability ratings. However, these materials tend to be
exceptionally absorptive, and may retain fumes, particulate and other pollutants,
lowering their sound reduction capabilities.
There are times when designers are lured by the process of creating a solution
without giving much preliminary thought to whether the solution is really and
critically needed. This is equivalent to spending a lot of time and effort following
the wrong path, which leads to design solutions with little benefit or positive impact.
Thus, it is imperative to really delve into the core problem of your project. By finding
and solving for this core problem, you will be designing at the point of
most leverage because when you solve for a root problem, the entire building
system will strengthen. Conversely, if you only solve for a peripheral problem, then
the building system will suffer because the root problem (which is the weakest
point) will remain and prevent the rest of the building system from having its
positive benefits realized.
One solution to this bank acoustical problem is to create a separate but adjoining
room where bankers and customers could go to have discussions. However, this
is a solution to one of the bank’s “symptoms” of the root problem. This solution is
not addressing the root problem where all of the bank’s occupants must function
within an uncomfortable space. As you can see, designing a separate and
adjoining room is not the right design path. Instead, if one designs for the root
problem, the bank will be able to function at dramatically improved employee and
customer levels.
For the first part of this study, the finite element method (FEM) and the boundary
element method (BEM) are both used to predict the interior acoustic field of a
rectangular closed cavity, due to the vibration of one wall. The direct (i.e. inversion
of the dynamic stiffness matrix) and modal superposition solution techniques are
compared for the FEM, and the collocation and variational techniques are
compared for the BEM. It is found that there are no significant differences between
the collocation and variational results. Identical results are also obtained from both
the direct and modal superposition techniques, provided that sufficient modes are
included in the latter case.In order to investigate the influence of the boot (luggage)
compartment on the acoustic response of the passenger compartment of a car, a
second (smaller) rectangular cavity is joined to the one described above. The
acoustic response of the combination is computed by the FEM when the two
cavities are separated by different types of partition. It is found that addition of the
42 | P a g e
boot cavity, as well as the characteristics of the partition, have a very marked effect
on the main cavity response.
CONCLUSION-GENERAL
The importance of acoustics is not limited to classrooms. Noise in corridors and public
spaces can soar if they are too reverberant (too much echo), with voices raised louder
and louder to overcome the background echo, just like shouting conversations at a
noisy cocktail party or restaurant. In addition, sound is an important navigational tool for
people who are blind or low vision, and either end of the reverberation scale (too "live"
or reverberant, or too "dead" or absorptive) can prevent them from finding their way.
REFERENCE:
https://kireiusa.com/blog/acoustic-design-education
https://architizer.com/blog/practice/details/acoustics-open-office-plan/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Architectural_style
https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=258814361677080&set=pcb.621236371670478&type=3&t
heater&ifg=1
https://www.lencore.com/Portals/5/Lencore_Docs/Article_UnderstandingAcoustics.pdf
https://www.lencore.com/Portals/5/Lencore_Docs/Article_UnderstandingAcoustics.pdf
https://architectureandeducation.org/2017/11/07/the-purposes-and-functions-of-schooling-some-
reasons-governments-give-for-building-schools/
http://www.wbdg.org/design-objectives/functional-operational
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Auditorium
https://webspm.com/Articles/2014/05/01/Auditorium-Acoustics.aspx
43 | P a g e